7 ms·
Malignant melanoma deploys elegant molecular mechanism to evade immune responses
- ourmandave 3y agoSee also the Kurzgesagt video The Reason Why Cancer is so Hard to Beat https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uoJwt9l-XhQ https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uoJwt9l-XhQ
- MichaelZuo 3y agoIt does seem extremely elegant relative to the very tiny amount of resources a single cancer cell has to work with. I'm not sure why there was so much talk about 'nanomachines' some years ago when there are literally millions of pre-existing examples that are so vastly more sophisticated.
- Terr_ 3y agoTo recycle a comment: > Oh, I agree, imagine a "grey goo" apocalypse, where uncontrolled and hyper-aggressive nanotechnology spreads everywhere in a unceasing orgy of consumption and replication. Mutating according to its own unknowable logic, it eventually it covers the land in an inhospitable blanket of massive crawling megastructures and inscrutable malign hive-minds! > ... Oh, wait, that happened -- It's us. :P
- noduerme 3y agoThis line of thinking about humans is exceptionally noxious when it gives a pass to AI or nanobots or anything other than human that might exhibit the real behavior that humans are hyperbolically accused of. That being said, the same logic applies: Evolutionary advantages lead to outcomes that don't get a fuck about what you or I want. So far, we have no examples of monocultural life gaining a permanent advantage over whatever evolves next, at least not on a geological scale. But my response to this is always some variation of: If you hate people so much, why do you have kids?
- FooBarWidget 3y agoHow do you know these "humanity is a virus" type of people have kids?
- noduerme 3y agoI never know that for sure, but it's a safe guess. It's become a bit of a hilarious trope here in Portland. The people who are always complaining about the rest of society's wanton disregard for the environment are the ones who aren't riding the bus. Their kids are the reason they're so worried about climate change, which is caused by overpopulation, you see. Nothing racist or Malthusian. They're shuttling their kids to soccer practice in a Subaru, how much more eco-conscious could they get? And when dad puts the kids down, he gets online and complains about how everyone else's consumption is ruining the world. When you talk to other people who don't have kids, they always make sure to let you know they don't.
- vibrio 3y agoIMO, “Single cancer cell” isn’t really a the unit. Solid tumors act more like a mini organ with different types of cells having roles: driving blood supply, immune suppression, or enabling and executing metastasis are examples. Cancer isn’t sentient, but life finds a way. Fu*k cancer.
- zer8k 3y agoI am not an oncologist but I thought that metastasis was more related to a tumor growing too close to a major blood highway. If some of those cells that like to grow out of control get into that system they end up getting lodged all over the place. It seems less like "enabling and executing" and more like it just grows and grows until it leaks out. The ability for tumor cells to suppress the immune system however is fascinating. It's almost like an alien.
- vibrio 3y agoCancers actually drive blood vessel growth into the tumors to feed themselves. I’m sure they leverage that as part of dissemination. Different primary tumors (eg Prostate, breast, lung) have preferred sets of metastasis sites that are not always explained by where they get stuck due to getting into the blood supply. Even getting into the blood supply requires functions of degrading extra cellular matrix, evading immune surveillance, getting out of blood vessels and “setting up camp” at the news destination, and those requirements can be cancer and/or met site preferential. Much of the immune suppression mechanisms are actually regulated systems normal cells use to prevent runaway inflammation. Cancer finds that function and highjacks it to “hide”. Conversely (to further illustrate complexity), some cancers use aspects inflammation as ”fuel” to drive tumor growth especially early in the cancer. I do agree- it is all truly fascinating.with that said: Fu*k cancer.
- matthewdgreen 3y agoWhat I’ve never understood is how all this complex cooperative behavior emerges out of a relatively small number of mutations. I get that these are all repurposing of existing mechanisms, but still the overall coordination seems so much more purposeful than something that would happen with a few initial mutations and then some further selection. Particularly things like metastasis, which sounds like a many-stage process that would be hard to spontaneously evolve.
- wrycoder 3y agoThis work appears to be closely related: "Anti-PD-1 and Novel Combinations in the Treatment of Melanoma—An Update" https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC7019511/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC7019511/
- mcbain 3y agoThere are many papers - development of immunotherapy for melanoma has been a big topic for the last few years, with some fantastic improvements but more to do. As it happens I can spot that the linked paper is already out of date as I know at least one is the trials has been cancelled, because I was on it.
- tuxguy 3y agothe paper by ben izar et al : https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S1535610823001812 https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S15356...
- adrian_b 3y agoIts free version: https://www.biorxiv.org/content/10.1101/2022.03.21.485049v1 https://www.biorxiv.org/content/10.1101/2022.03.21.485049v1
- PaulDavisThe1st 3y agoSo close and yet so far ... "Malignant melanoma manipulates marvellous molecular mechanism, managing masked malevolence" Sorry, it's been a rough day.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- bglazer 3y agoImmune evasion in cancer is really interesting and particularly important because immune therapy has really emerged as a groundbreaking therapy. But, while immunotherapy excels in blood cancers, it still struggles in solid tumors. Part of the reason for this is that a solid group of cancer cells can much more easily change their microenvironment to exclude immune cells. So this paper explores one of the ways they do that. Cancer cells turn off a protein that sits on the surface of normal human cells that immune cells regularly bind to. Binding to this protein, CD58, causes changes in the immune cell. What these changes are critically depends on the other signals that the immune cell senses on the surface of the cell. If it senses another (somewhat famous) protein, PD-L1, the immune cell self destructs, as PD-L1’s presence typically means that a cell is normal and healthy. But, cancer cells frequently evolve to over generate PD-L1, thereby creating an micro-environment filled with self destruct signals. Further, the other protein CD58 actually increases the physical force of immune cell binding, so when cancer cells turn off CD58 they actually get more slippery. This paper explores an interesting connection between the two proteins. There’s a third protein which binds to both of them and increases the amount of time they're active on the cell’s surface. Honestly I haven’t had time to fully digest this bit, but it seems like the regulatory protein preferentially binds to CD58, which is good because it promotes immune cell adhesion and recognition of the tumor cell. But! When CD58 is lost, it then binds to PDL1 and promotes immune cell evasion. Why nature chose this as a regulatory mechanism is kind of baffling, but exactly the kind of thing that makes cell biology interesting
- xupybd 3y agoOutstanding summary. Thank you very much.
- ccakes 3y agoWarning: no background in science, dumb question inc It seems like the cancer cells are pretty good at evolving to get around our immune system. Is there a reason our immune system doesn’t evolve to outcompete the thing that is killing it?
- pnpnp 3y ago
- jawns 3y agoI'm hung up on the title's use of the word elegant, which ordinarily has a positive connotation, to describe a very sad and deadly process. When something is elegant, it means we recognize something beautiful in its form, such as an elegant gown or an elegant solution to a vexing problem. I would rather see a word such as grotesque or monstrous used, or a phrase such as brutally efficient. That indicates a similar type of imposing magnitude, but also a lack or distortion of beauty.
- rho138 3y agoElegance is less of a positive descriptor and more of a way to describe precision of craft in this connotation. Where the evolutionary pattern of malignant melanoma is very deft at adapting to its situation.
- airstrike 3y agoAgreed. "Efficient" would have been a much better word. "Elegant" just feels like ragesadbait
- greyface- 3y ago"Elegant" is an aesthetic judgment, not a moral one. Ugly things can be good, and beautiful things can be bad.
- MichaelZuo 3y ago> Ugly things can be good, and beautiful things can be bad. This is indeed very common in the real world, and often talked about in one way or another on HN. So much so that the parent almost certainly has seen multiple examples after nearly 15000 comments and 13 years on HN.
- folli 3y agoAs any molecular biologist will attest, the mechanism is indeed very elegant. The outcome not so much.
- adolph 3y agoI wonder if this would have application to treat autoimmune diseases
- smadge 3y agoHow do cancers have sophisticated mechanisms for evading immune responses when they don’t have any adaptive pressure? The cancer dies with the victim. It seems like the equivalent of mashing on the keyboard and getting a valid program.
- notamy 3y ago> when they don’t have any adaptive pressure The adaptive pressure is your body constantly detecting and killing pre-cancerous cells. Eventually some will get a lucky mutation and slip through.
- mromanuk 3y agoI’m just another guy throwing ideas, maybe the cancer should be compared to a virus or bacteria, where their life cycle is much shorter than humans, the objective is maximum growth, then it dies as any other organism
- smadge 3y agoTrue, but by that analogy it's an extinction event, not a death. Any mutations the cancer cells acquired will not be propagated.
- mrosett 3y agoThey have immense adaptive pressure at the cellular level. The evolutionary process plays out within each patient. Aberrant cells that don’t have some sort of evasion mechanism will be identified and destroyed by the immune system.
- geysersam 3y agoI've heard a hypothesis that cancer behavior is not primarily evolved in the patient, but instead it is an ancient mechanism from the time of transition from single cell to multi cell organism. A human cell can never survive on its own. But there might have been a time when cells could have benefited from "pulling the escape hatch" and taking their chances instead of continuing cooperation within a damaged early multicellular organism.
- _madmax_ 3y agoInteresting choice of word for the title.
- rherhd 3y ago[flagged]
- seaal 3y ago67
- kazinator 3y agoThings don't look so clever when the host dies, and the tumor with them.
- CatWChainsaw 3y agoGreater level of irony is that we say things like that while steadfastly refusing to look in the mirror. Civilization as it stands isn't the most sustainable either.