8 ms·
EurKEY: The European Keyboard Layout – For Europeans, Coders and Translators
- TRiG_Ireland 3y agoAny reason why the € symbol is on the 5, instead of the 4 (which is its standard location on Irish keyboards)?
- dadoum 3y agoI still don’t like when number keys are taking ten keys on the unmodified keyboard. In AZERTY you would need shift to enter them, and that’s fine because anyway numbers are usually by group. While a lot of keys requiring caps are braces that you will enter twice.
- lproven 3y agoI am dismayed that there is so little mention of the Compose key. It is one of the biggest keyboard-related boons of using any xNix OS, and it's trivially easy to add to Windows as well. It's one of the only things I dislike about macOS: no Compose key. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Compose_key https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Compose_key https://help.ubuntu.com/community/ComposeKey https://help.ubuntu.com/community/ComposeKey
- KomoD 3y agoNo thanks, that layout is terrible and looks impossible to type on If I want to type åäö or ÅÄÖ they're right there on my keyboard, with this it's hidden behind AltGr/Shift+AltGr Enter key is too small and a bunch of other complaints, like everything is much further away or requires both hands compared to my current layout
- loa_in_ 3y agoUseless for Polish, but thankfully we already use US layout
- RedShift1 3y agoUpvote if you're in the Azerty gang
- skerit 3y agoBelgian Azerty represent!
- lbourdages 3y agoCanadian Multilingual layout > Azerty. You can actually type uppercase accented letters with it!
- Hackbraten 3y agoYou’re going to pry my ISO Enter key and QWERTZ from my cold, dead hands.
- mschuster91 3y agoFound the fellow German here :D
- column 3y agoCH layout for the win
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- Svip 3y agoI definitely prefer the ANSI left shift key, but I am keeping my ISO enter key, thank you. Indeed, I have a keyboard with an ANSI left shift and an ISO enter key. But honestly, why not just use US Intl AltGr dead keys?
- nom 3y agoThere are dozens of us! Dozens! Seriously, ANSI/ISO hybrid layout should be way more popular than it is.
- logronoide 3y agoNo way. “Ñ” is not in the natural place for Spanish speaking people.
- kaapipo 3y agoNo way this is going to work for Finnish use. The person who has made this clearly has no idea that in Finnish ä, ö are completely separate letters from a, o
- skipnup 3y agoAs the guy is German and most certainly uses ä/ö/ü/ß, he probably has an idea.
- oktoberpaard 3y agoYou mean that it's cumbersome to have it hidden behind a key combo instead of it being its own physical key, correct? I get that, because it would slow you down tremendously. At the same time, if those letters would be physical keys, it would not be a European keyboard anymore, but a Finnish keyboard. So maybe the conclusion is that this project is nice for some languages, but not for all. In my language this keyboard would work, but letters like ö, ï and é are relatively rare and I'm actually content with the solution that I already have: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Compose_key https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Compose_key. So for me it doesn't actually solve anything.
- asmala 3y agoIf I’m mostly writing Finnish text, then the native Finnish layout (with separate keys for Å, Ä, and Ö) seems better. And if I’m coding, I personally prefer the US English layout where [, {, ;, etc. are more easily accessible. But I could see this layout being a better fit if I’d need to frequently swap between multiple different languages and still have convenient access to the most common symbols used in coding.
- Cloudef 3y agoThis is the reason why just using local layout (or modification of it) makes the most sense. The keys are where they are for good reason. That said do you ever really need å or Å in finnish layout?
- Hamuko 3y agoIf you're a Swedish-speaking Finn (like Linus Torvalds), yes.
- keiferski 3y agoNot seeing the Polish letters ą, ę, or ł anywhere on the keyboard. Poland is in Europe, too.
- tga 3y agoNot seeing the Romanian letters ș, ț, ă, â, î anywhere on the keyboard. Romania is in Europe, too. (â and î are even needed in French, what am I missing here?) I'm sure there must be many other letters missing. Not to mention Bulgaria and Greece. No qualms with the layout, it's probably impossible to cram all European letters and common programming symbols on only ~four layers -- it's just the name that's somewhat provocative. Interesting reference: https://jakubmarian.com/special-characters-diacritics-used-in-european-languages/ https://jakubmarian.com/special-characters-diacritics-used-i...
- keiferski 3y agoThe obvious solution would be to have all variants of a "base" character like a or e be accessible via the same key + shift/TAB/option, etc. So s would include ś, ș, etc. Obviously this doesn't line up exactly with how the letters are used in their respective languages, but it's a visually-optimized solution.
- nerdbert 3y agoThere are too many combinations though. à á â ã ā ă ȧ ä ả å ǎ ȁ ȃ ą ạ ḁ ẚ ầ ấ ẫ ẩ ằ ắ ẵ ẳ ǡ ǟ ǻ ậ ặ You'd need to hold down combinations of 5 different modifier keys, and shift can't be one of them because that's used to capitalize all this. Nobody's going to do that.
- DeathArrow 3y agoI am not seeing Romanian, Bulgarian and Czech characters. Last time I've checked, those countries were in Europe.
- Rygian 3y agoThe Spanish layout (as used in Spain) is the best compromise I've yet found to write code, Spanish, French, German, Italian, Portuguese, Catalan, and would probably work fine for most other European languages with a couple more dead keys.
- the_gipsy 3y agoIt's missing at least "ß" for German, has annoying dead key, but above all it's extremely awkward for coding because most symbols have been shuffled around for no good reason. Try out altgr-intl[1] (but no dead keys, where you just press e.g. AltrGr+E for "é", might not be installed on windows/mac). It's much better than Spanish for Spanish, can be used for the mentioned languages and probably some Scandinavian, and doesn't make writing code awkward. [1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_QWERTY_keyboard_language_variants#US-International https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_QWERTY_keyboard_langua...
- Rygian 3y agoA keyboard without dead keys for accents is a non starter for me. Thanks!
- the_gipsy 3y agowithout? Why would you want to require more key-presses?
- Rygian 3y agoBecause a keyboard has a fixed number of keys. If you want to have a bunch of letters of the alphabet with any the diacritics on top, you run out of keys very very quickly. Dead keys are the sane solution to that question. Also, regarding ß, I've got it in two ways: "AltGr + s," or the sequence "Compose, s, s." By the way, Compose is the ultimate dead key.
- teabee89 3y agoNo ő, or ű for Hungarian. I personally use US International on Mac and I never looked back. It uses a system where you press Alt + a key for an accent, and then the letter to put the accent on.
- happymellon 3y agoThis looks manic. I'll stick to UK ISO, thanks.
- slau 3y agoUK ISO is indeed the best for me as well, as a software developer. Having @ and " swapped makes so much sense for me, I don't know why. I also much prefer having \ and | located next to the left shift key. It's a single hand input, and the large enter key is so much nicer.
- happymellon 3y agoProbably just preference from experience, but whenever I see people trying to force ANSI layout with other char sets, or adding missing keys such as £ it just looks awful. Though not as bad as UK Mac.
- calini 3y agoFor my mixed English/Romanian/coding use, I use Romanian (Programmers), never found anything better.
- vladms 3y agoI think the name "European" is badly chosen - there are many languages not represented there if you consider the whole Europe. This might be "western Europe" although I am not an expert to confirm nothing is missing there either ...
- hecatia 3y agoLike, where are my macrons, tildes and hačky? I get it that not all characters from european language alphabets can be crammed into one keyboard but next time this should be correctly named for what it really is. Someday i might learn western eurpean language if i can challenge my willpower..
- gog 3y agoI see ČĆŠŽ missing from the layout, only Đ is here from the letters used in a Croatian alphabet, Slovenian as well, although they don't use Ć.
- cornholio 3y agoFor Romanians and Moldavian I don't see: ă â ș ț î This is an impossible task, just use the standard "Programmers" layout for your language which maps to US and allows access to accented characters via modifiers. The entire notion of a "local" keyboard layout sounds like a nationalistic throwback to the days where the world was much smaller. Some languages really need it, but most using the Latin alphabet simply don't, just stick to US.
- arlort 3y agoI think you're supposed to use the composition key for those. Don't know how frequent they are in croatian though, so it might be impairing the speed at which you can type if they are very common
- hiichbindermax 3y agoYou can get these with the composition keys. Shift+AltGr = ˇ and then hit the letter to compose them
- 3y ago
- LoganDark 3y agoWhy did you bother to reserve space but then add an application key (context menu key) instead of an Fn key? Most desktop layouts already commit the crime of omitting the left Fn key, the least you can do is leave alone the one on the right. You're just begging for people to flash QMK and repurpose Caps Lock...
- Nullabillity 3y agoThere's no such thing as a standard Fn key, that's handled by the keyboard itself. Standard layouts don't have a Fn at all.
- LoganDark 3y agoI don't know if I ever mentioned "standard" layouts? Anyway, I just looked it up, and apparently keyboard designers tend to replace right meta (the right windows key in this diagram) with Fn, and this layout still has one, so it's actually not missing a spot like I thought...
- __forward__ 3y agoI just use this for the German "Umlaute" it's the easiest way to get them while not putting special characters in hard to reach places (backslash anyone?). Easy to install and set up and as a bonus I can type greek letters for math stuff now!
- SushiHippie 3y agoSame, just use this as an US layout + umlauts. Because sometimes you need them, but otherwise the US layout is just way better than QWERTZ (IMO, i'm programming 90% of the time and life in zsh and sway).
- worldsavior 3y agoWhat's wrong with just a US layout?
- the_gipsy 3y ago¿Qué?
- Kichererbsen 3y agoIt's really hard to type out (e.g.) German text with the US layout.
- Cloudef 3y agoHow do I type ä or ö?
- enriquto 3y ago> How do I type ä <COMPOSE> " a where COMPOSE is typically ALTGR, but you can map it anywhere you want, like CAPSLOCK I write daily in three european languages with many accented characters, and this is enough for all of them. I have even mapped composing a to α, b to β and so on, which is useful for the (occasional) greek word. EDIT: (thanks to gpvos comment below), on linux with xorg you can achieve this by the following configuration: # setup base keyboard layoud and model setxkbmap us setxkbmap -model evdev # set compose to right alt setxkbmap -option compose:ralt # disable capslock sticky effect, set it as modifier setxkbmap -option caps:ctrl_modifier xkbset nullify lock # enable dead greek letters xmodmap -e "keycode 148 = dead_greek dead_greek dead_greek dead_greek" xmodmap -e "keycode 66 = dead_greek dead_greek dead_greek dead_greek" # swap brackets with parens (useful for programming) xmodmap -e "keycode 18 = 9 bracketleft" xmodmap -e "keycode 19 = 0 bracketright" xmodmap -e "keycode 34 = parenleft braceleft" xmodmap -e "keycode 35 = parenright braceright" # enable ridiculously fast repeat xset r rate 250 120 This nearly works on openbsd (you have to install the xkbset package, maybe there is another way). I guess that on macos and windows you can do similar things.
- Cloudef 3y ago
- sgt 3y agoI use a few European characters but I've found the best keyboard layout by far is the US key layout on a Mac. By using option you have access to all the special characters and modifiers you need. ü ö ø å æ ê é ... Very simple to find and you'll actually remember their positions because they are (somewhat) logically placed. At the same time, the US layout also has a very convenient setup for coding, and not any extra keys taking up space.
- dkga 3y agoI use the Swiss layout for the exact same reasons. Plus, it’s easy to find here in Switzerland. The only extra keys are the ones one uses a lot when typing German and French.
- bartvk 3y agoI'm sticking to US layout as well. What I find annoying, is that none of the Apple dealers in my country (The Netherlands) have stocked laptops with the US key layout. You need to order it online and wait a couple of weeks.
- mvdwoord 3y agoThis has prevented me from quite a few impulse purchases of way too expensive laptops.. :)
- the_mitsuhiko 3y agoIn Austria delivery of US keyboard laptops from Apple dropped from weeks to two days on the pro models so I think they are changing something.
- aequitas 3y agoI prefer the US international layout (with the standing return key) and it happens to be that the Dutch layout is just US international with a '€' sign printed on the '2' key as well. So I think I'm lucky in that regard.
- maratc 3y agoYou don't even need to use Option — by long-pressing a letter, you have a menu opened with all the different options conveniently numbered. As an example for the letter "a": a1 is à, a2 is á ... a8 is ā.
- fodkodrasz 3y agoSome European languages with missing letters: Hungarian, Romanian, Slovakian, Czech... they could possibly just as well go with US layout instead...
- jillesvangurp 3y agoHaving moved around Europe, I stick to US international. As a programmer, all these weird keyboard layouts that put their locally preferred characters in places where a US keyboard layout has all the things that programmers use all the time, is just really inconvenient. I've met more than a few Germans, Finns, and Swedish that map their local keyboards to US English for this reason. Keeping the local layout is just begging for repetitive strain injuries. Having to use 3 fingers to produce a { or a [ is just not acceptable or workable. And mostly the working language in a lot of companies is English anyway.
- qubex 3y agoThis is me, an Italian: US keyboard or death.
- tincholio 3y agoI routinely write in English, Spanish, French, and Finnish, and I code several hours a day. For me, the best layout (other than my Dactyl Manuform's, which is layered) is the standard ANSI US, with a compose key. The compose key gives me easy access to all diacriticals and accents, and I don't need to switch contexts at all.
- msoad 3y agoReallz well said ;)
- finnjohnsen2 3y agoDeveloper from Norway here and I've used 'US Intl, with dead keys' for about 10+ years. Our ÆØÅæøå are slightly inconvenient (using AltGR on Linux, and Option on Mac), but you quickly adapt and I find it to be worth it to have all the programming relevant characters like '"{(\| in the super convenient location of the US keyboard. My extremely made up assumption is that the Norwegian keyboard design was designed for typewriters, and the US is an older design made by and for developers.
- landgenoot 3y ago> US is an older design made by and for developers I think it is the other way around. Programming languages adopted the characters that are available on US Intl.
- pluijzer 3y agoFun to see they have included the dutch IJ ligature. I think nobody ever uses this and just types out I and J. I previous employer told now and again made a search for the word 'vrij' (free) on Slack to see if people were honest with there holidays. So when sending a message that I took a day free I would use 'vrij', just to troll.
- pluijzer 3y agoI always feel like a computer illerate when googling something like 'u umlaut' to copy it from wikipedia.
- Etheryte 3y agoThis looks like a case of design by committee, e.g. due to the compromises none of the target audiences are actually happy.
- dzik 3y agoEuropean language - there is no such thing so there is no need for such keyboard layout.
- blae 3y agoAgreed. You can't have normal usage letters behind AltGr when writing your own language, that'll get annoying fast.
- qxfys 3y agoThere was a day when I had to switch between Japanese-Swedish-US physical keyboard due to differences between my laptop, office's machine, and some other machines I had to take care of. The problem with switching keyboard like this is not the placement of alphabet, but the different location of symbols. Like, "/" and "-" have the same location between US and swedish keyboard, respectively. And this cost me a lot of context switching. Decided to screw it, by bringing my US keyboard everywhere, and (virtually) switch to another keyboard just if I need to, i.e., to write particular characters like "ö,ä,å".
- barrotes 3y agoThat's basically a US layout with some tweaks. Nice try muricans... Jokes aside, honestly I feel confident with US (or ISO/UK) keyboard and I think that I share this sensation with the vast majority of european developers and sysadmins. Also in general the ANSI format is more aestetically pleasing than ISO one, and, above of all, if you like mechanical keyboards ANSI plates are more widespread and consequentially cheaper, so I don't oppose this proposal
- gpvos 3y agoOn Windows, I'm fairly happy with the "Pseudo VT320" layout from https://keyboards.jargon-file.org/ https://keyboards.jargon-file.org/ . All added characters and accents are via AltGr dead keys, so it's not in the way of normal programming. It would be nice to have a few more dead key combinations for northern and eastern European accents though.
- alexdeloy 3y agoAlso ã/Ã seems missing? While it's a nice idea and usually I am a sucker for all things starting with European*, it seems to fall short and the practical use seems limited - who is writing more than 3-4 languages at a time? I'll stick to my AutoHotkey macros to put portuguese ã/ç/õ via AltGr on my german keyboard: <^>!a::Send {ASC 0227} +<^>!A::Send {ASC 0195} <^>!c::Send {ASC 0231} +<^>!C::Send {ASC =199} <^>!o::Send {ASC 0245} +<^>!O::Send {ASC 0213} (+1 for my fellow ISO Return key users in the thread)
- Hamuko 3y ago"European" keyboard layout that's ANSI and not ISO? Is this a joke?
- lproven 3y agoExactly so.
- noname120 3y agoShameless plug: I maintain a keyboard layout that allows you to effortlessly type 15+ European languages with it. It's entirely compatible with QWERTY, so anyone can switch to it without relearning anything. Contrary to EurKey and QWERTY international, it's a breeze to learn and use. The placement of every key is logical, you just need to learn a few simple rules and then everything makes sense! See the project on GitHub: https://github.com/qwerty-fr/qwerty-fr https://github.com/qwerty-fr/qwerty-fr Previous thread on HN: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29229583 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29229583
- the_gipsy 3y agoYou should mention that it is heavily french biased.
- throw_a_grenade 3y agoPlain Polish layout is much better and much more „European” than this thing. You can input all the accented letters from all over the Europe (not only letters from Polish alphabet) using combining strokes. For example, ä is "Alt+[ a". In addition to that there's assortment of math/greek characters, many punctuation characters (incl. full set of all the various quotes and arrows, which is handy) and even some Latin ligatures. The single exception is T-comma (used in Romanian), LATIN {CAPITAL,SMALL} LETTER T WITH COMMA BELOW, which AFAIK is impossible to input.
- otikik 3y agoI use something similar to this. Although as a Spanish, the acute accent is prioritized on the main vowels: aeiou -> áéíóú, with alt-gr, and the dieresis (¨) is only used with the u (ü) so I leave it at a chord (alt-gr ', u) https://github.com/kikito/us-4-es.keylayout https://github.com/kikito/us-4-es.keylayout
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- fxtentacle 3y agoGreat idea! Most programmers use the US layout anyway because then stuff like [ and { are easy to reach. This project extends the US layout by adding all the usual German+French+Italian+Spanish special characters onto the regular character keys, similar to how Alt+E is the Euro sign on standard German keyboards. Alt+A is Ä, Alt+O is Ö, Alt+U is Ü and Alt+S is ß so for German, that choice seems quite intuitive.
- missjellyfish 3y agoProposing a layout based on US-ANSI is the definition of madness. We can discuss what's on the keys, but my ISO layout stays.
- p-e-w 3y agoThis seems to suffer from the "Swiss Army Knife Syndrome": It does many things, but not one thing well. Any individual "European" (that is, a speaker of a language which uses those Latin-extended characters) is going to want a layout where the symbols they use daily are accessible either as separate keys, or with Shift. Requiring AltGr to type é and è isn't going to fly with users who need them. And I'm certainly not going to press Shift+AltGr+A/O/U to get Ä/Ö/Ü, which I have to type many times per day. Some parts of the layout also seem to ignore which letters are actually in use. The capital Eszett (ẞ, Shift+AltGr+S in this layout) simply isn't a thing in the real world. It has zero usage in practice. Surely that spot could be utilized for something better?
- hruzgar 3y agoI think generally this layout is more for programmers. If you're programming more than writing a text in your language, eurkey is certainly the way to go. I for myself switched to it and will never look back.
- sschueller 3y agoI'm sticking to my Swiss layout where äöü are directly accessible and I finally got used to it. Not switching back and Apple can suck it for having a different Swiss layout.
- briffid 3y agoHaving the name wrong, because the author forgot that Eastern Europe has been part of Europe for around 1000 years now, is acceptable. But the decision to support 5.5 speakers of Danish instead of 40 million speakers of Polish for example, is much worse, it's stupid engineering.
- r0ckarong 3y agoWas using this for years until openSUSE Leap somehow dropped this with 15.4 and now I'm flip/flopping US/German QWERTY on all machines again.
- me_bx 3y agoThis looks pretty similar to UK extended [0]. I prefer UK extended for the position of back-slash and point keys, and a few other details. This said, EurKEY seems to provide more, like a way to type ś or ć ... [0]: http://kbdlayout.info/kbdukx/ http://kbdlayout.info/kbdukx/
- kybernetikos 3y agoNow that I have a (zmk) programmable keyboard, one of the more frustrating things is getting it to produce characters that are not in the OS keyboard map. I think the best option might be to have a keymap that included more or less all characters so that they could be produced.
- the_gipsy 3y agoI stopped messing with the keyboard firmware / unicode, and just use altgr-intl. Except for some macros like typing out my email :)
- kybernetikos 3y agoThis is the exact sort of thing I was hoping someone would suggest. Thanks!
- the_gipsy 3y agoI forgot to add: the big upside is that you can then use the builtin laptop keyboard the same way. If you're on linux you can even kind of translate firmware mappings to xkb mappings for xorg and sway at least.
- erkkonet 3y agoI use US layout with Caps Lock mapped to toggle to my "native" layout. This way I can easily code without RSI-inducing combinations to get the frequently used {}[]\, and just tap caps when I'm writing emails without needing to retrain my muscle memory of where åäö are located. On Windows there's also a setting to get each app to remember the selected keyboard layout (Set-WinLanguageBarOption -UseLegacySwitchMode) so I don't even need to switch most times.
- konfektersatz 3y ago[dead]
- no_sunshine 3y agoI installed "Bookworm" (12.1.0) and i can not find this layout to add. But i also can not find the information that it was included in Bookworm. Only the info on the website that it is currently in Debian unstable. Were you able to add it via gnome-control-center?
- tacker2000 3y agoGreat idea! Beats having to switch to the german keyboard all the time just to input umlauts. The german layout is so suboptimal for actual work, its funny. Z and are Y switched, so to UNDO you have to almost break your wrist. Then they just randomly rearranged all the punctuation and symbols. Why did the parentheses open-close move by one? Who knows…
- nullpilot 3y agoI happen to be using this (present by default on Ubuntu 18 iirc). I'm surprised this makes me a bit of an outlier judging by the comments. EurKEY on a Dell XPS, with the Home/PgUP and End/PgDn flipped to get start/end of line in my editor right next to the arrow keys, right CTRL mapped to DEL. I am quite happy with that setup.
- WhereIsTheTruth 3y agoIt always saddens me when i see microsoft windows logo for the Super key on such proposals.. easily avoidable mistake.. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Super_key_(keyboard_button) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Super_key_(keyboard_button)