5 ms·
https://archive.is/rznQr https://archive.is/rznQr We've plainly seen over the past several decades that the War on Drugs is an abject failure. All it's done i
by kelnos 3y ago
https://archive.is/rznQr https://archive.is/rznQr
We've plainly seen over the past several decades that the War on Drugs is an abject failure. All it's done is increase incarceration rates (without solving the problems of drug use and addiction), and many people caught in the system are just drug users, not distributors/traffickers. This really doesn't help much of anything.
> State leaders have acknowledged faults with the policy’s implementation and enforcement measures.
And there you go, right there in the second paragraph.
> As Morse put it, “If you take away the criminal-justice system as a pathway that gets people into treatment, you need to think about what is going to replace it.”
And clearly they didn't do that well enough, or at least didn't follow through well enough on what needed to be done.
It's good to see reporting on this, because clearly "just decriminalizing" doesn't help, and can make things worse on some dimensions. And some measures to replace prison sentences likely work better than others, and it's good to see the ones that don't work so we can refine policies like this.
But let's not take this as failure of the idea of decriminalization.
- j_walter 3y agoClearly they had the best of intentions, but Oregon's politicians are terrible at implementing anything properly. Open drug markets, increased property and retail thefts and a homeless population explosion are what happened...when <1% of people actually seek the treatment if they can even find it it causes problems. They always claimed to follow other successful implementations like Portugal, but the law was no where near what they implemented as far as requiring treatment. Whats funny is the Governor is telling the Portland mayor to fix the drug issues...like it didn't stem from measure 110. https://www.wweek.com/news/2023/07/19/kotek-and-blumenauer-tell-local-officials-fix-rampant-drug-use-on-portland-streets-now/ https://www.wweek.com/news/2023/07/19/kotek-and-blumenauer-t...
- kelnos 3y agoThat's fair, and certainly a problem, but I don't think the solution is "let's just go back to throwing everyone in jail". We know from long experience that isn't working.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- schnable 3y agoI don't know the specifics in Oregon, but in many places (especially bigger cities) that stopped prosecuting drugs and prostitution, "throwing everyone in jail" was not the previous scenario. People were arrested then put into diversionary programs that were enforced by the courts. It worked much better than just letting people stay on the streets as the process acted as a wake up call for many (of course, not all).
- EricDeb 3y agoYea not jail but supervised programs makes sense.
- j_walter 3y agoOregon basically made it a $100 fine or you could get treatment...<5% of the people arrested chose treatment. Portugal had more rules requiring treatment which is what made it effective...Oregon did not choose that route. https://www.wweek.com/news/state/2023/04/22/economist-magazine-a-longtime-proponent-of-drug-decriminalization-says-measure-110-is-struggling/ https://www.wweek.com/news/state/2023/04/22/economist-magazi...
- chimeracoder 3y ago> Portugal had more rules requiring treatment which is what made it effective...Oregon did not choose that route. As I explained in a sibling comment, requiring treatment is not the difference. Very few people who use drugs in Portugal are subject to mandatory drug treatment. The key difference is that Portugal has a radically different housing policy than Oregon. As of 2019, housing is a formal legal right (and even before 2019, it was much closer to a de facto right than it was to Oregon's current model, which is "if you can't pay for a roof, pitch your tent over there, and hope we don't arrest you for vagrancy"). Most people who use drugs do not meet clinical criteria for addiction, so drug treatment programs are irrelevant and a waste of money for them. For those who do, drug treatment programs are still a waste of money unless they have stable housing, because it is essentially impossible to achieve and maintain sobriety without stable housing.
- orangepurple 3y agoI disagree that the implementation is terrible. Having seen several interviews on the matter I think its implemented exactly as the people of Portland wanted it. The major outstanding problem is a lot of the homeless people on drugs need someone to genuinely be there for them and care about them. That's the primary message you will hear from them if you care to listen to their stories on The Soft White Underbelly. It seems that you can't possibly spend enough money to make that happen at a policy level. There were horrible abuses in the institutions where it was tried here historically.
- j_walter 3y agoThey didn't spend any money on it...they didn't fund or push treatment programs at all. The implementation was 100% awful...just like every Oregon program that means well. https://www.wweek.com/news/state/2023/05/13/survey-shows-oregonians-have-dim-outlook-on-efficacy-of-measure-110/ https://www.wweek.com/news/state/2023/05/13/survey-shows-ore... https://www.wweek.com/news/city/2023/03/20/wheeler-slams-measure-110-for-slow-rollout-of-addiction-treatment-funds/ https://www.wweek.com/news/city/2023/03/20/wheeler-slams-mea...
- orangepurple 3y agoWhy do legislatures keep passing half-baked drug-related measures? It's not like this was the first one.
- lotsofpulp 3y agoMeasure 110 was not introduced or passed by legislators, it was passed by the public via ballot measure.
- j_walter 3y agoYep, and it took effect 13 weeks after voting it through. No possible way to get things in order in only 13 weeks...especially at the state level.
- rubyn00bie 3y agoTed Wheeler is a piece of shit, pushing policies that are completely ineffective. He's more interested in illegally gassing non-violent protestors than fixing issues. The police here are well-funded and by-and-large don't do anything, bringing up the real question "why are we funding them?" A family member of mine had someone ARMED and going through a very obviously psychotic episode enter their house and it was over week before the police showed up to remove them. The damage to the house was outstanding, and my family member obviously couldn't stay there during it, but the Portland Police couldn't fucking be bothered. For a fucking week. It's absolutely insane we pay for police in my opinion. The biggest issue in Portland that's been ignored since COVID started is that downtown Portland never recovered after the shutdown. It has nothing to do with safety, I know I live there, and it has everything to do with prices. The city is too expensive for what you get and what opportunities are here. I'm no fan of Kotek, but truly Ted Wheeler is among the most shit mayors the city has ever known.
- lotsofpulp 3y agoIs it possible the probability of success of treating the use of certain brain altering chemicals is untenably low, even if treatment was "properly" funded?
- kelnos 3y agoI don't think so. Portugal was famously very successful at drug decriminalization, at least until they slashed funding to rehabilitation programs. If you have data that suggests some drugs just make rehabilitation impossible or unlikely, I'd be interested to see it, though.
- lotsofpulp 3y agoI do not have data, but did Portugal deal with fentanyl? And why did Portugal slash funding for treatment?
- seanmcdirmid 3y ago> Portugal was famously very successful at drug decriminalization It isn't that famously successful at all, at least in Portugal. https://www.washingtonpost.com/world/2023/07/07/portugal-drugs-decriminalization-heroin-crack/ https://www.washingtonpost.com/world/2023/07/07/portugal-dru...
- chefandy 3y agoExcerpt from that article: "Experts argue that drug policy focused on jail time is still more harmful to society than decriminalization. While the slipping results here suggest the fragility of decriminalization’s benefits, they point to how funding and encouragement into rehabilitation programs have ebbed. The number of users being funneled into drug treatment in Portugal, for instance, has sharply fallen, going from a peak of 1,150 in 2015 to 352 in 2021, the most recent year available." It did work well. It doesn't now. What changed in between then and now is funding and commitment to getting addicts into treatment-- the founding principle of the program to begin with.
- gremlinsinc 3y agoYeah, I see it as a failure in implementing a better road to recidivism for drug users that doesn't involve prison. It's a mental health issue after all. I think perhaps maybe even separate "mental" health from normal healthcare and make it free / universal might go a long way. Maybe insentivize it, like giving plasma. Go to therapy 4 weeks in a row get $100 cash. That way it's not "forcing" people into something which is still a sort of "prison" mindset, but it's more like "encouraging" them to be there, and drug users will do almost anything for money, right? So why not have them do therapy?
- lotsofpulp 3y agoWhy would mental health be separated from "normal" healthcare? Mental health involves chemical signals in the brain. Once a chemical dependency has been established, how possible is it to "talk" someone out of it in therapy?
- monknomo 3y agowell, the thing with mental healthcare compared with regular healthcare is that the first bit of it is often kind of coercive? Like folks with chest pain want it fixed. But folks who hear voices/are addicted to something/suffer from crippling anxiety often don't want to fix it for a variety of reasons, some of which are even pretty good (such as nasty medication side effects). Crossing that hurdle is tough And you can talk someone out of a chemical dependency. Or rather, you can talk them into suffering through it, much the same way as you can talk someone into suffering through climbing a mountain or similar.
- anon291 3y ago> We've plainly seen over the past several decades that the War on Drugs is an abject failure. All it's done is increase incarceration rates (without solving the problems of drug use and addiction), and many people caught in the system are just drug users, not distributors/traffickers. This really doesn't help much of anything. Given that Oregon stopped its war on drugs and has had a terrible experience, I don't see how anyone can honestly believe that the war on drugs did not reduce the rates of drug use and addiction. This is not a political issue. Come to Portland and see. It's not like any other city. People engage in drugs freely and with impugnity. Correspondingly, people overdose continuously. It seems obvious to me the war on drugs kept addiction rates and usage rates at a much more acceptable level. At least, it ensured the dangers of drug use didn't spill onto the streets (needles in public parks; drug users in public restrooms... places kids go). Thus, it correspondingly seems obvious to me that the higher incarceration rate is worth it.
- agentofoblivion 3y agoa.k.a., "that's not real communism".
- AbrahamParangi 3y agoIs the war on drugs a failure in Singapore too? I mean, it is self-evidently obvious that at some level of enforcement, you can actually control the problem. The question then is whether we are willing to tolerate the level of enforcement necessary. Is the cure worse than the disease? That is a real question and a worthy one, but pretending that no tradeoff exists is just silly.
- oatmeal1 3y ago> The question then is whether we are willing to tolerate the level of enforcement necessary. I think the question is how do we make prisons less cruel and dangerous, and lower recidivism. Of course there is a backlash against enforcement when the solution is locking people in cages.
- pas 3y agoobviously by spending money on it. but the US in general is vehemently against doing that.
- pravus 3y agoAfter the outrage I saw when a US citizen was caned in Singapore for a vandalism violation, I'd say no, the people here probably don't look to Singapore as a guide for enforcement.
- spamuel 3y agoMinds have been changed on a lot of things that are pretty wild lately, in a short span of time. If this stuff continues, there might be further pretty wild changes of mind.
- chimeracoder 3y ago> Is the war on drugs a failure in Singapore too? Considering that thousands of people are arrested for drug possession every year in Singapore, to say nothing of the number of people who use drugs in Singapore and avoid legal action, then yes. > The question then is whether we are willing to tolerate the level of enforcement necessary. Drug use is rampant even inside prisons, which are literally the most surveilled and draconian environments on the planet. If a carceral approach to preventing drug use doesn't work even within prisons, what makes anyone think it can work in society at large, even if people were willing to turn all of society into a police state?
- cyberax 3y ago> We've plainly seen I have not seen that. > over the past several decades that the War on Drugs is an abject failure. It was not. WoD helped to _control_ the amount of drugs. It certainly had not eradicated them, but it helped to reduce their prevalence.