6 ms·
>Even a lot of the anti-cycling stance comes down to, “What am I, poor?” I agree with the overall point that people don't want to cycle because the experience
by gruez 3y ago
>Even a lot of the anti-cycling stance comes down to, “What am I, poor?”
I agree with the overall point that people don't want to cycle because the experience sucks, but your description feels like an unnecessarily inflammatory way to say "people are willing to pay for a more pleasant experience". Nobody says "a lot of the anti-cheap laptop stance comes down to, "what am I, poor?".
- Guvante 3y agoNothing about the post you responded to says "people are willing to pay for a more pleasant experience". The closest is "people aren't willing to pay to improve an unpleasant experience" which isn't related to purchasing a laptop in anyway.
- gruez 3y ago> Nothing about the post you responded to says "people are willing to pay for a more pleasant experience". Are we reading the same post here? The one I'm seeing lists out all the reasons why cycling/public transport sucks, all of which can be avoided if you pay several hundred dollars per month for a car.
- dahfizz 3y agoOP's whole point is that paying for a car is a much more dignified and enjoyable way to travel. And then the tax base doesn't want to pay to improve public transit, because they already have a car.
- goda90 3y agoI have literally seen people scoff at biking or riding the bus as something for poor people. It is a common sentiment.
- adra 3y agoThis is a hyper regional statement. Where I live, you'd be considered a weirdo for carrying that sentiment. Drive an hour away, and the statement could be considered a lot of credence. All we can do is make the right choices for ourselves and help influence those in our spheres to encourage the behaviour we want to see.
- xtracto 3y agoAnecdote time. Ten years ago I (Mexican, living in Mexico, a bit "white-er" than the average Mexican skin color) worked for a Silicon Valley startup with HQs in Mountain View. One time I was visiting said HQ, I met several people, I got to talk with one of them (Chinese/Asiatic looking woman) about how I was moving while I was there, and where was I staying (she didn't know where I was from). At some point I told her that I hadn't rented a car, so I was basically walking. And because I wanted to go to some outlet, I was thinking on taking the bus. Her comment was: "Don't take the bus, that's for Mexicans!", I had to swallow my surprise and keep a poker face, just answering something along the lines of "ooh yeah? thanks for the advice". I guess the stigma that only poor people (And we Mexicans are poor you know haha) take the bus is pretty alive in some parts of the US.
- thereare5lights 3y agoWhat a weird thing for her to say given that Asian Americans use public transit in great numbers. Then again, I've noticed that the ones with money are utterly alien to those of us that don't have it or grew up without it.
- robertlagrant 3y agoIf you take the ethnicity out of this and stick to economics does it have the same outcome?
- throwawaywu 3y agoYou can't do that! Without keeping differing ethnicities at war with each other, how can we maintain power?
- bobthepanda 3y agoAsian Americans lump together homeland countries of over half the world’s population. The waves of immigration also look different demographically; the people who came over to build the railroads and staff laundromats, restaurants and nail salons are very different from the tech worker on H1B. (And the latter often look down on the former.)
- PaulHoule 3y agoThere is this story that nobody takes the bus in L.A. but when I go there and ride the bus the bus is always full. It is not bad at all to ride the bus from Beverly Hills to Hollywood but the bus does not stop at Rodeo Drive, you have to pick it up on the next street over.
- OfSanguineFire 3y agoSurprised to hear the bus is always full. I took the Metrolink train from Union Station to San Bernardino recently, during an hour when people ought to be going home from work, and it was spookily empty. The one single other passenger in sight told me it was usually so empty. I thought of how crazy it was to offer this huge rail infrastructure - which really did seem cheap and convenient - for so few people to use.
- pbhjpbhj 3y agoYou have to provide public transport infrastructure _first_ if you want people to use it. You can't get rid of your car in the hope that 8 months down the line you can get a train; unless your boss is happy for you not physically attending work for 8 months, at least.
- joshuahaglund 3y agoThat line had over 10k daily riders in 2019, before people stopped commuting to office jobs and it dropped to about 1500. https://metrolinktrains.com/globalassets/about/agency/facts-and-numbers/quarterly-fact-sheet-q4-fact-sheet-2019-2020.pdf https://metrolinktrains.com/globalassets/about/agency/facts-... It's still less than half its previous average at 4700 daily riders now. https://metrolinktrains.com/globalassets/about/agency/facts-and-numbers/fact_sheet_q4_fy22-23.pdf https://metrolinktrains.com/globalassets/about/agency/facts-...
- MarceColl 3y agothat is honestly very little, barcelona is a lot less populated (1.5M) and even during non-tourist season we get 2 million riders per day (not deduped and people coming from nearby areas). I dont have stats of any particular line, but dividing that between the approx number of routes gives you about 50k riders per line. Some routes will have less, some routes will have way more (particularly subway lines)
- Silhouette 3y agoLooking down on cyclists is a common sentiment in some parts of the world. Meanwhile here in Cambridge (the UK one) there are numerous people who cycle around the city simply because it's a better way to get around for lots of reasons. Those people range from students at the universities who in many cases will have very little disposable income to professionals with some of the most highly paid jobs in the country. The idea that cycling is "for poor people" seems quite bizarre after living somewhere like this. Indeed it is one of the few things - in a city among the worst in the UK for inequality - that truly spans almost all financial and social classes. The idea that a lot more money and resources need to be invested in improving facilities to make cycling and walking more attractive does resonate though. The arguments made in the article look on point here.
- plagiarist 3y agoThe sentiment that having money makes one "above" a form of transit is a bit despicable, but it absolutely is the case. I think particularly with public transit. "Hey, would you like to take a multi-leg two hour journey with at least ten minutes of waiting between each leg, or drive fifteen minutes?"
- fragmede 3y agoTwo hours with a transfer to fifteen minutes is a bit much (not that I doubt such poor public transportation options exist), but the mental toll of driving, even just fifteen minutes is not to be ignored.
- barney54 3y agoOne problem in the United States is that transportation planners apparently think that buses are for the poor and people won’t ride them. Instead they want to build expensive light rail or subway when a good bus system would be much better, flexible, and affordable.
- city41 3y agoCurious what would be a good bus system? I've only ever lived in the US and can honestly say I've never seen one.
- jghn 3y agoI use the busses in Boston all the time, and have been for over 20 years. Way back when it was a pain but ever since bus tracking apps showed up on the scene about 15 years ago it's been a smooth experience.
- fnimick 3y agoI live in Boston and would still use the T buses as an example of bus service as an afterthought. The buses are loud, uncomfortable, bus stops frequently have no shelter and are on busy roads with no buffer from 2-3 lanes of traffic, and there are almost no dedicated bus lanes so the bus gets stuck in the same traffic as all the cars.
- inferiorhuman 3y agoIn San Francisco Muni shelters are largely all the same whether for street level bus or tram. They're all equally awful because they were designed to be inhospitable in an attempt to prevent people from sleeping at them. https://www.sfmta.com/sites/default/files/styles/teaser-col-4/public/feature-image/2017/170525_shelter_06.jpg https://www.sfmta.com/sites/default/files/styles/teaser-col-...
- coldtea 3y agoPlenty of bus stops, special bus lanes, modern buses, air-conditioning, clean environment, frequent on-time schedules, and plenty of routes to take you to/from all major city areas and suburbs. No crazies and violent crime either. Of course the city also needs to support walking the final 300-2000 ft to your destination after the bus stop. If most of your stops are some BS office or industrial zone, with roads build for cars, no shade, no shops, and nothing to do around, it's pointless.
- UtopiaPunk 3y agoThere's an ad in rotation right now on a popular local radio station where the whole bit is that character A's car isn't working, and character B talks about the great deals at a specific car dealership. "Don't walk," he exclaims and he shares the gospel of car ownership. Literally, the whole framing is that walking sucks and is embarrassing :(
- closeparen 3y agoIn the vast majority of American postwar development, walking does suck and is embarrassing. That’s why the article’s framing about dignity for pedestrians in street design is interesting.
- pbhjpbhj 3y agoIt's like idiocracy where they say something like "you drink water? like water, that you use to flush the toilet?". People are easily manipulated because they want to signal that they're valuable and/or rich; "walking is for poor people" ... well yes, also people who want to stay fit, or who care about the environment, or want to be closer to their community, or ...
- ta1243 3y agoIf you're walking there are fewer opportunities to advertise to you
- OfSanguineFire 3y ago> If you're walking there are fewer opportunities to advertise to you How so? I’m reminded of that sequence of shots in Zabriskie Point where Mark Frechette walks around Los Angeles and is assailed by billboards everywhere around him.
- pxeger1 3y agoPerhaps GP meant that you can't fruitfully have cars advertised to you if you don't want to buy one
- ClumsyPilot 3y ago> inflammatory way to say "people are willing to pay for a more pleasant experience" You got it all wrong! It does noy matter how the expience feels physically. The problem is social stigma attached to cycling. Like tell you mates you spent 3 weeks fixing your car, or built your own house, and it was super u pleasant and you broke your hand in the process - you are cool. But tell them you cycled to work to improvr fitness, and you are a weirdo.
- zdragnar 3y agoFew companies have showers on site, and "fitness" is frequently associated with sweating. The last thing I would want to do is show up at an office for an 8 hour shift soaked in sweat. Where I live, it is humid enough during the summer that there's really only at most 4 months of the year where "pleasant" can be described to use the weather for biking. In fact, the weather forecast for today is 85% humidity, and is going to hit 93% twice this week.