14 ms·
California moves to silence Stanford researchers who got data to study education
- sproketboy 3y agoLeftists always do that. SCUMS.
- michaelmrose 3y agoWhy do you keep posting this malarky here? Your account has been active for over a decade but most of your stuff ends up dead because you post crap like this for basically nobody to read.
- mcpackieh 3y agoThe truth does not fear investigation.
- nemo44x 3y agoYes, but narratives do.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- asdajksah2123 3y agoThere's a long history of nearly every major freedom supporter or civil rights supporter being investigated and wrongly imprisoned and even killed across the world. And that's just the famous ones we've heard of. There are an order of magnitude more who were done with well before they became historically famous and no one even knows about them. This bumper sticker quote doesn't really track in the real world.
- mcpackieh 3y agoSo are you meaning to say that California is afraid these Stanford researchers are going to imprison people, wrongly or otherwise? Come on. This isn't the police, these are academic researchers.
- LexiMax 3y agoI think the point is that reality is a complex and messy place, and shallow platitudes don't really add much to the conversation.
- pseg134 3y agoYou are right. The world is way too messy for morality and honesty.
- IX-103 3y agoThe world is too messy for naive morality and honesty. People are too easily swayed by anecdotes or irrelevant facts. In your "moral" world of brutal honesty: the children of serial killers would never find work, people who were caught cheating on a test in kindergarten would never be allowed in positions of power, and people with non-mainstream interests would be sidelined in favor of those that people more closely identify with. Is it right to hide things from people who would use that information incorrectly and to society's detriment? I think so, and that's why I believe people should have a right to privacy.
- mcpackieh 3y agoThe "shallow platitudes" cut through the BS. The government is trying to gag researchers because they want to hide their own failure. The narrative that the government is afraid of PII being revealed during a trial is straight horse shit. The courts themselves will decide what is or isn't appropriate information for a witness to share on the stand. Furthermore, am I to believe these researchers are trusted not to share student PII when doing their normal academic research, but at soon as they become witnesses against the state that trust is no longer warranted? Bullshit. If protecting PII were the motivation they would not allow researchers to access that PII and publish their findings. What they're actually doing is preventing those researchers from testifying against the state. They're not protecting students, they're protecting the state's interests.
- hex4def6 3y ago"The truth does not fear investigation." I don't think you'd feel the same if you were the defendant in a lawsuit, even if you had a rock solid case. You might be completely vindicated, but bankrupted. Or, perhaps your lawyer is a dud, and fumbled the ball. Or perhaps the jury were idiots. Or perhaps the law has some unknown (to you) technicality that you end up hanging for. Or perhaps during the investigation you honestly misremember something or misspeak and the police / investigators become convinced you're guilty and spend all their time and resources trying to pin it on you. Or maybe they're just lazy, and you end up being an easy target. Don't worry, if you plead guilty you'll avoid a lengthy court battle that you can ill afford, and potential prison time if found guilty (are you that confident in your lawyer, your finances, the jury, and the legal system?). If you plead no-contest, you avoid jail, weeks or months of time off work defending yourself, and just do probation. But wait, I thought you had the Truth on your side?
- throwaway290 3y agoTell that to Alan Turing
- downWidOutaFite 3y agoDesantis was doing the same thing in Florida, preventing proffesors from testifying in a voting rights case against the state. https://apnews.com/article/lawsuits-florida-ron-desantis-voting-rights-university-of-florida-f3b88f128a3175586fdc21b56a0a7132 https://apnews.com/article/lawsuits-florida-ron-desantis-vot...
- justrealist 3y agoThat's also questionable, but it's not the same thing.
- PartiallyTyped 3y agoIs that not a first amendment violation?
- mcpackieh 3y agoYes, both are and one does not justify the other.
- PartiallyTyped 3y agoI am glad you stated that because it’s good to have it in writing.. we can’t take anything for granted these days.
- appplication 3y agoIf I could wear a tin foil hat for a minute: it could be plausible that CA could fight this to allow it to escalate to the Supreme Court and establish a judicial standard for these types of cases. I don’t really understand why, of all the CA government institutions, the CDE finds this to be appropriate stance though. An educational office should absolutely be held to a much higher standard than this, and should at its core value openness of information and freedom of speech. The fact that this lawsuit exists at all is an indication of deeply problematic internal values within CDE that are completely misaligned with its mission and governmental function.
- spamizbad 3y ago> At issue is a restriction that CDE requires researchers to sign as a condition for their gaining access to nonpublic K-12 data. The clause, which CDE is interpreting broadly, prohibits the researcher from participating in any litigation against the department, even in cases unrelated to the research they were doing through CDE. That's an unreasonable restriction and I expect the ACLU to win this.
- ww520 3y agoWhy are the K-12 data non-public? Aren't they from publicly funded institutes?
- kayodelycaon 3y agoThere’s a law protecting individual student records: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Family_Educational_Rights_and_Privacy_Act https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Family_Educational_Rights_an... It also goes beyond K-12. Quite a few parents try to get their children’s college grades and run smack into this law.
- spamizbad 3y agoI'm guessing detailed information on individual students, anonymized - that's not something that any edu department will make public.
- edgyquant 3y agoThings involving minors tend to have stricter regulations.
- jimhefferon 3y agoMight it bump against privacy? If you do a search on third graders receiving speech services in towns of pop less than 3000 in county... at some point you have private information.
- tmpX7dMeXU 3y agoHow would you feel if data pertaining to your interactions with government were made public just because the government is taxpayer-funded? How about data pertaining to your kids? Any Joe Taxpayer doesn’t have a right to walk in and demand any data they want from a government department. That’s entirely entirely reasonable. Anonymising data isn’t nearly as easy as a passer-by with “faker.fake_name()” may think it is.
- remote_phone 3y agoHow can data collected by the government be private? That should all be available to the public since it was gathered with public funds. Has no one issued a freedom of information request?
- IronWolve 3y agoIMHO,Making the public pay for records, at high expense in a digital age is how the government limit information. Police arrest\crime data, Court data, Zoning Data, Meeting transcripts, Budget Data, etc, and yes, Education data. Society shouldnt accept this data should be behind paywalls or accept high costs to access it. Or paper only releases to stop release restrictions for costs and size.
- codyb 3y agoZoning data and meeting transcripts generally are public? At least in NY that's been my experience. A lot of the rest I'd rather was private. Although it'd be nice to get aggregated data for certain crimes which currently are tracked at each individual department level and not in any sort of national manner.
- civilitty 3y ago> How can data collected by the government be private? That should all be available to the public since it was gathered with public funds. Has no one issued a freedom of information request? Agreed. What gives the government the right to reject my FOIA requests for the exact specification and design files for gaseous centrifuges, implosion devices, and nerve gas? Extreme natsec examples aside, there are a thousand reasons to keep government data private, not the least of which is constituent privacy. Deanonymizing data is far easier than preparing it for release and the data schools keep on students is particularly sensitive (I'm not claiming that that's the case with this data, just making a general observation).
- kayodelycaon 3y agoStudent records are protected by federal law. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Family_Educational_Rights_and_Privacy_Act https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Family_Educational_Rights_an... Personally, I think an individual’s privacy should take precedence here.
- verteu 3y agoRequiring more education/outcome data to be public would help prevent this. If education researchers are forced to get data from California's Department of Education, there's tacit pressure to find results that make DoE look good.
- troupe 3y agoIt doesn't seem entirely unreasonable that if a school system gives a researcher access to data that isn't shared with the public, the researcher agrees not to use that information to sue the school system. Such agreements would allow the school system to be more free to share information. The issue here seems to be that the school system is saying that the researchers aren't allowed to be a witness in any lawsuit against the school system regardless of whether it has to do with the data that was shared with the researchers. I think a bigger issue is whether the school system should be allowed to keep any information private in the first place. If the information can safely be shared with a particular researcher then it seems like there is minimal benefit to society in letting the school system pick and choose who gets access and who doesn't.
- heliodor 3y agoWhat information does a school system possibly need to keep away from the public? This smells.
- amalcon 3y agoMost obviously, personal information about students.
- troupe 3y agoThere might be some information that could be combined with other data in ways that would violate the privacy of students and their families. Obviously discipline records with student names shouldn't be public, but what about records without names where the students name could be found by linking it with other data. AOL released a bunch of search queries in 2006 with they idea that they were anonymous, but it turned out you could get quite a bit of personal information from them by linking searches together.
- nend 3y agoIf you're curious, read up on FERPA.
- nonameiguess 3y agoPresumably all data about student educational outcomes, which are protected by FERPA. The school system doesn't have the option to just ignore the law and make this information public.
- gnicholas 3y agoProfessor Dee was one of the authors of some excellent research regarding SFUSD’s math detracting experiment: https://www.edweek.org/teaching-learning/san-francisco-insisted-on-algebra-in-9th-grade-did-it-improve-equity/2023/03 https://www.edweek.org/teaching-learning/san-francisco-insis...
- TheMagicHorsey 3y agoOne of the weird things about America is that we all know Asian kids are better at math than other kids on average. Its pretty obvious to anyone that's been in a class with Asians or taught Asians. I've done both. But nobody can actually say this. Instead we have to pretend like this isn't the case. Just look at math Olympiad teams. I coached one years ago. My entire team was Asian except for two alternates. One who was Russian, and the other Indian. Yes, environment can change outcomes ... but maybe it can't change outcomes to a point where everyone is going to perform the same. Are we going to try to get everyone's 100M sprint into the same range too? People are different. We should give every individual the same shot at opportunities but I don't think we are ever going to make Asian kids perform at the level of other kids in math or vice versa. Its not environment. Every one of us that has taught an engineering or math course knows this. Even if we don't talk about it.
- dragonwriter 3y ago> One of the weird things about America is that we all know Asian kids are better at math than other kids on average. Its pretty obvious to anyone that's been in a class with Asians or taught Asians. I've done both. > But nobody can actually say this. “Asian kids in the US are, on average, better at math and, furthermore, this effect is stronger the fewer generations removed from immigration they are, and is in large part due to well-established general familial impacts on performance and the selective filter of immigration.”
- moosey 3y agoTo sum up another comment: it's cultural, not biological. Race is not a useful scientific guideline for any kind of scientific study. For example: there is as much biological diversity in sub Saharan Africa as the rest of the world, but racially, the best we can do is "Black", or "African". It's a useless, dated concept that we, as species, find it difficult to work past because our brains are categorical engines. I'm as politically "leftist" as anyone you'll ever meet, but we have to be able to do better than "Asians are good at math" to make effective decisions about education, amongst other problems. This is of course impossible with the current world and thinking. Even though I know race isn't real, I still see it. It still has an impact on my day to day actions, because my stupid brain is all too happy to categorize people on how they appear. Taking another route: to say that Asians are good at math is categorical error. The word "Asians" represents something abstract, and abstract things cannot take action. Categorical error is basically the starting point for the various "isms" like misogyny, misandry, racism, etc.
- say_it_as_it_is 3y agoThis has everything to do with demographics and science that presents findings contrary to ideology/politics. The same kinds of people pressure police to omit demographics data in police reports.
- anon84873628 3y agoInterestingly, the article states that the data sharing agreements do not limit what the researchers can publish. They can share results/conclusions critical of the state, which could then serve as a basis for litigation. What's weird is that they are being prevented from voluntary testimony on cases unrelated to the specific shared data, thus unnecessarily removing many experts from the pool.
- yttribium 3y agoThere's a distinction between a fact witness and an "expert witness". A private agreement can't prevent a court from subpoenaing a fact witness to testify. "Expert witnesses" are overwhelmingly hired guns paid to come in and voluntarily spin a narrative, and I'm not sure why they shouldn't be able to make that a provision of a contract just like any other commercial arrangement.
- mcpackieh 3y ago> I'm not sure why they shouldn't be able to make that a provision of a contract just like any other commercial arrangement. Because we're talking about part of the government.
- phpisthebest 3y agoMainly because it is a government agency, and government agency do and should have lots of restrictions on them that are not like "any other commercial arrangement" One of the biggest things I disagree with republican on is that "government should be run like a business" no... it should not
- themitigating 3y agoSeems pretty obvious because the main/sole purpose of business is to make money. Why would you want a government to act like that?
- phpisthebest 3y agoTo steel man it, it is because running a for profit business also requires efficient use of limited resources and driving out waste from the processes So "running government like a business" is a way to ensure tax money is being spent effectively and efficiently to be clear I dont think that is the best way to accomplish that goal, thus why I disagree with it, but it is not "profit" that drives that statement It came about because far far far far far too often government programs and spending are judged by their intentions, not their actual results.
- GCA10 3y agoThere's a lot more going on here than the initial story reports. For more than a few academics, making big $$$ as an expert witness is a magnificent source of side income. (Fees of $1,000/hour, including lots of open-ended prep time, can be found.) That begs the question: Did the research lead to the desire to be an expert witness? Or did the desire to be an expert witness define the nature of the research project? We'd need to know a lot more about the origins of this project before being able to referee this one. But if the state of California is worried about litigants using "researchers" to find and filter data that ordinarily would be available only through legal discovery processes, that's not a crazy worry.
- AlbertCory 3y agoI went to the Apple v. Samsung trial in 2016 or so, and the highest paid expert witness that day was $850. The other two were $450 and $350. Where are you getting this number? The prep time is included in your hours. The $850 guy said he'd put in 900 hours. (btw, it IS excruciatingly boring work. But of course, the money.)
- angrais 3y agoSo the $850 guy got $850×900? So $765k? How many months were the 900 hours split over? This sounds absolutely ridiculous
- onionisafruit 3y agoIt's great pay if you can get it, and I'm sure it wasn't enough to be noticed in the legal costs of that case.
- nonethewiser 3y agoJust for frame of reference, there are 2080 work hours in a year assuming 40hrs/week. So imagine making 765k for like 5 months of work.
- viscanti 3y ago
- timcavel 3y agoCalifornia has the strictest Science Denial laws on Earth, so HN must censor everyone reading this for 180 days.
- kmeisthax 3y agoA huge part of the civil litigation metagame is just finding ways to legally exempt yourself from being sued. It used to be the case that only sovereign states could declare themselves immune from litigation, but now that power has been delegated to anyone who can convince someone else to sign a binding contract. Which is literally everyone because almost every business relationship requires contracts. And now we're going to "you can't testify against us because you had an NDA" which seems even more abusable. By $NEAR_FUTURE_YEAR the only people who wind up in civil court will be victims of extortion.
- onionisafruit 3y agoHas anybody found a link to the contract in question or a quote from the relevant part of it? I'm curious how it seemed ok for the researchers to sign a contract with this provision.
- anon84873628 3y agoProbably because they didn't have any other choice if they wanted to do the research. Redlining won't get you anywhere, so need to wait for a situation like this to argue the unconstitutionality.
- themitigating 3y agoSo they did have a choice. I don't like the notion that if you want something then you don't have a choice on the actions you take to aquire it
- jdkee 3y ago"Sunlight is said to be the best of disinfectants; . . . " -Louis Brandeis
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- themitigating 3y agoThat's an oversimplification of the real world as a metaphor and if taken literally, also not true
- s1artibartfast 3y agoIf we're being literal and pedantic, Sunshine probably does more disinfection then every man-made method put together.
- adamnaga 3y ago[dead]
- 1024core 3y agoYears ago, there was a site which had photos of people, and asked you to guess: murderer or software engineer? (I'm going from memory here, so let's not get sidetracked by the details). In a similar vein, we need a site that lists actions taken by a state government and asks: was this in Ron DeSantis' Florida or California?
- jjtheblunt 3y agoor chicago, in general (where i'm originally from)
- zeroCalories 3y agoWhich one is the swe, and which one is the murderer?
- rufus_foreman 3y agoProgramming language inventor or serial killer? https://vole.wtf/coder-serial-killer-quiz/ https://vole.wtf/coder-serial-killer-quiz/
- ilikehurdles 3y agoOr similarly, one listing low-rank in performance and quality of social programs and asking: was this Oregon or Mississippi?
- pocketsand 3y agoJust for context. I'm a PhD trained in education research who has met Sean Reardon a handful of times, had a meal with him, gone through methods training with him. He sits at the top of the field and has the unconditional respect of nearly everyone for his methodological rigor. This is not a guy who shoots from the hip.
- stainablesteel 3y agothese schools are horrendously insidious, nothing should be kept secret, and all this [tax-payer funded] data should be public to begin with
- tomohawk 3y agoCalifornia has over 900 school districts. That's over 900 highly paid executive staffs plus associated bureaucracies. That's a lot to protect. By way of comparison, Florida has 69 school districts, and does measurably better across the board in providing education.
- roody15 3y agoI am a bit confused by the case that is wanting to use the researchers data. So there was measurable learning loss from remote learning and during the pandemic. Ok this is known in education. The state has only relied on individual districts to make up the learning loss. Ok so that makes sense. There is no magic bullet on fixing the learning loss issue. The state relying on individual districts taking a multi approach to learning loss .. seems reasonable. I don’t understand the merits of the lawsuit. The state of California is already aware of learning loss and is looking at ways to address. To be sued because the state of California didn’t do x,y,z by the paintings seems incredible short sided and unrealistic. We are still learning how to best address learning loss from 2020. Just my two cents
- s1artibartfast 3y agoThis article doesn't talk about the case itself, so we would have to find a different source discuss that. I don't find it implausible that the state could have been negligent or knowingly inequitable in its learning deficit response. A simple example would be if it suppressed internal reports about the impacts and needs, or ignored them when structuring its response.
- AlbertCory 3y agoThere are a lot of comments on my answer about expert witnesses, so I'll collect it all here: Martin Rinard is a star. They pay him $850/hour because he testifies well, and he's done it before. He's got the credentials from MIT so juries tend to listen to him. I remember this exchange: Apple lawyer: So that was a lot of money! Martin: It was a lot of work. People seem to be doing some object inheritance from an ancestor post's "one month" but I didn't say that. His work would have gone over many months. They interview him, and he writes something. Then the lawyers rewrite it. Then they all go over it, line by line. It's excruciatingly boring. I sat in on two days of the review of a different expert witness' 300-page declaration, and they had another day planned after me! They probably have a mock trial, where he practices his testimony (I'm not sure how prevalent that is). I didn't work on Apple v. Samsung; I was just a spectator. I don't know what an expert witness would get in this Stanford thing, but it doesn't seem to me like the spending would quite so wild.
- bhk 3y ago"Ah, it looks like you have a nice academic career going here. It'd be a shame if something were to happen to it..."
- PsychoOil 3y ago[dead]
- summonerlf 3y agoIt's heartening to see efforts being made to address the isolation that incarcerated individuals often face and promote better communication with their loved ones. Improving access to communication could have significant positive effects on inmates' mental health, family relationships, and potential for rehabilitation. It's essential to continue exploring ways to support and uplift those within the prison system to create a more humane and effective approach to criminal justice.