8 ms·
Kangaroo tendons could rebuild human knees better, stronger
- jaggederest 3y agoInteresting related article I think I saw here a while ago: Healing of acute anterior cruciate ligament rupture on MRI and outcomes following non-surgical management with the Cross Bracing Protocol https://bjsm.bmj.com/content/early/2023/06/13/bjsports-2023-106931 https://bjsm.bmj.com/content/early/2023/06/13/bjsports-2023-... TL;DR they braced the knee at 90 degrees flexed and saw evidence of some healing in 90% of enrolled patients after 3 months
- pr0zac 3y agoIsn't this common treatment already? Don't actually know, just remember my stepmom and everyone else I've known that had knee surgery getting a cool knee scooter thing to roll around on for the months long recovery period.
- jaggederest 3y agoNo, this is instead of surgery, as far as I can tell just splinting it bent at 90 degrees to allow it to heal.
- swader999 3y agoMy wife healed her fully severed mcl without surgery. It's difficult but possible. You have to be really disciplined and follow the protocol.
- jaggederest 3y agoFrom what I gathered from the article abstract I posted above, this is unique because it's a protocol for healing a fully severed ACL, where the MCL heals much more readily than the ACL apparently for reasons of blood supply and positioning. I love it when doctors can use conservative treatment to avoid the need for surgery though, very exciting when a natural process can do the work. If you have any anecdotal discussion from your wife's experience I'd be interested to hear more about it - I haven't banged up my knees yet but it's just a matter of time, already down some functionality in an ankle.
- swader999 3y agoYes, although if you have a few million and access to a daily MRI you can even heal a PCL this way. See the Connor McDavid documentary "Whatever it Takes". For my wife, it was strict bracing at specified angles with forced stretching to retear the tendon at periodic intervals as it healed. She was on advil and a cryo cuff immediately after injury which really helped. I'd recommend having a cryo cuff on hand or a plan to quickly get one if knee injuries are likely in your future. Look into red light therapy for ankle, for example: https://a.co/d/7CPLFkl https://a.co/d/7CPLFkl
- steve76 3y ago[dead]
- 5555624 3y agoDiscussed at the time: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36594634 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36594634
- taneq 3y agoThis seems to be saying that a completely torn ACL will actually reconnect if the knee is kept immobilized? I did my ACL and in the MRI it was just gone aside from a fuzzy puddle on top of my tibia, it'd be incredible if that could regrow. > knee immobilisation at 90° flexion in brace for 4 weeks, followed by progressive increases in range-of-motion until brace removal at 12 weeks Compared with an ACL reconstruction with Gracilis tendon graft (the procedure I had), I wonder if complete immobilization for four weeks might do more damage than just having the surgery. I was limping but still loading up the leg as much as possible for four weeks after the accident and then off it for a week after surgery, and the muscle loss and general degredation was severe. It took months of physio and most of a year of exercise to rebuild back to ~95%. Taking 2-3 months to get weight back on it sounds light it could be worse overall.
- throw1234651234 3y agoIf it grows back "correctly", that's still way better than surgery, since who knows if they "get it right".
- taneq 3y agoThat's no more convincing than "If the surgery 'goes well,' that's still way better than just leaving it, since who knows if it grew back 'correctly'."
- throw1234651234 3y agoIs "rupture" a full tear? The "common knowledge" is that "ligament full tears can't heal". In fact, 10 years ago, people were told that partial tears can't heal either, and you might as well not bother.
- trogdor 3y ago>Is “rupture” a full year? Yes. Complete discontinuity of ACL fibers on MRI.
- light_hue_1 3y agoThey claim they can prevent them from being rejected with their "special sauce" which they won't reveal. What else can this be other than washing away all of the cells and leaving behind only the scaffolding? Decellularization is already a thing for tendon xenografts. Maybe they have a unique way of doing it but that's pretty doubtful. In general this field is getting close to large scale use in humans as it is. Oddly, there's already a different Australian startup from another university doing extremely this. https://www.imcrc.org/blt-allegra/ https://www.imcrc.org/blt-allegra/
- twic 3y agoLo and behold, the patent [1] says: > [0038] In preparing the xenograft for use, the tendon is surgically dissected and removed from the paratenon (tendon sheath). The tendon is composed mostly of an extra-cellular collagen matrix, which is non-immunogenic. The tendon may therefore require no denaturing (decellularisation) prior to implantation into a mammal. In some embodiments, the tendon may be subjected to a decellularisation process prior to implantation. In removing the cells from the tendon, the immunogenic antibodies within the cells are also removed, thus rendering the tendon non- immunogenic. Methods of decellularisation of tendon tissue are known in the art. Such methods include physical, chemical and enzymatic treatments, wherein the cells within the tendon are lysed, leaving an undamaged extracellular matrix having the same physical and biochemical properties as the natural tissue. So it is decellularisation, they aren't claiming any particular decellularisation method, but it's quite possible they have some particular recipe for decellularisation which works well, and which they are keeping secret. [1] https://patents.google.com/patent/WO2019014698A1/en?oq=2017902800 https://patents.google.com/patent/WO2019014698A1/en?oq=20179...
- twic 3y ago> They have also developed a way of ensuring the kangaroo xenografts are not rejected after transplant. The key to this is what he describes as “the special sauce”, and it is a closely guarded secret that has already been patented. PATENTS DO NOT WORK THAT WAY! Anyway this appears to be it: https://patents.google.com/patent/WO2019014698A1/en?oq=2017902800 https://patents.google.com/patent/WO2019014698A1/en?oq=20179...
- jaggederest 3y agoI love it when people do this "patented secret" thing. Patents are public for very good reason - society protects ideas that are documented publicly so that the public knowledge is improved after the patent expires.
- twic 3y agoAlthough there are secret patents: https://slate.com/technology/2018/05/the-thousands-of-secret-patents-that-the-u-s-government-refuses-to-make-public.html https://slate.com/technology/2018/05/the-thousands-of-secret...
- taneq 3y agoLike most (all?) governments the U.S. government has a strict set of rules that it must follow unless it decides it doesn't want to.
- deaddodo 3y agoWell sure. Because if the US govt's patent on hypersonic rocket propulsion (as a conjectural example) were public knowledge, it would be trivially simple for their rivals to use that information in their own programs or countermeasures. Surely it's evident that most nations would find an imperative in keeping that knowledge guarded? The govt doesn't have to patent these techniques at all. They do so for the benefit of public enterprises (so contractors and military industry can benefit) and so that the knowledge does eventually enter the public commercial sphere. That article itself mentions multiple patents that eventually had the veil lifted and/or expired.
- a_shovel 3y ago<joke>I wonder, does this also make knees harder and faster?</joke>
- pluijzer 3y agoAs someone with trouble giving up on meat this is a highly hypocritical comment but news like this always gives me an unsettling feeling in my stomach. We are sacrificing the life of an intelligent entity to fix the knee of another. Like I said it is hypocritical and I probably found a way to explain it away if I needed itvmyself and am happy for the people it will help but still, we as a species do have the tendency to put ourselves above others. I feel very conflicited by it.
- ceejayoz 3y agoI'd draw a pretty big distinction between this and regular meat eating; you're not getting a new tendon several times a week. In this case, it's not even extra animal deaths: > It was important to Dr Hartnell that no kangaroos were killed expressly for his research, and this has remained his practice throughout his investigations: all of the work has been done only using kangaroos that have either been culled for reasons of population control or harvested for meat.
- danw1979 3y agoIf they’re using decellularization to prevent rejection, does the tissue have to be … freshly harvested (i.e. in a medical setting) ? Or would the offcuts from abattoir-killed roos be of sufficient quality ?
- orwin 3y agoIt seems tu be sufficient. Although maybe the abattoir have to really follow sanitary rules for once, that'll cut into the profits.
- dylan604 3y agoJust in time for the WWC where there's recent news articles about why the women's game has so many ACL type injuries.
- reocha 3y agoThis is very cyberpunk.
- omnicognate 3y agoKangaroo knees? Where do I sign up? And if you could replace my spine too while you're at it, that'd be great.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- TOMDM 3y agoOne assumption this skips over is that it's okay to put athletes on the field with ligaments 6 times stronger than human baseline. Of course this is a phenomenal treatment assuming it works as planned, but isn't there a performance enhancement angle that needs to be considered for it's inclusion in professional sports?
- swarnie 3y agoThe Enhanced Games will be stoked for this.
- chongli 3y agoLike the old SNL sketch: The All-Drug Olympics!
- williamdclt 3y agoI'm okay with dealing with this problem when it comes, I definitely do not consider it a good reason to slow down medical progress. I'd rather sport adapts to medical progress, not the other way around!
- midoridensha 3y agoThe inverse of your position would mean that athletes would be forbidden from ever having surgery, including for sports injuries. Taken to an extreme, athletes should be forbidden from having any kind of medicine: vaccines, bandages, antibiotic ointments for cuts, etc.
- hef19898 3y agoI don't think so, the tendons make the knee potentially more stable, the performance so comes from the muscles. And it requires surgery, usually that kind of surgery is hard on the body, and requires extensive physio therapy and training afterwards. So, the kangaroo tendons are potentially better than traditional implants, the question you pose so is whether or not they are better than the original, human ones. And I somehow doubt that, but I am just a semi-engineer with a ruptured, but still working, knee and not a physician.
- at_a_remove 3y agoI gather that kangaroo "leather" is also quite resilient.
- rco8786 3y agoWhat if the "bionic man" from SciFi is not robots and nanomaterials but actually just us borrowing things from nature that happen to work better than the human version
- bryanmgreen 3y agoA menagerie of animal-part patchwork humans sounds like a great time!
- no_wizard 3y agoIs it possible to farm Kangaroos for this purpose? Perhaps its brutal to suggest, but I imagine hunting wild Kangaroos is not what we want here, as their numbers are already in decline, IIRC. Can the rest of a Kangaroo be used in some productive way? I'd honestly feel ethically bad that we are killing Kangaroos just for their muscle tendon in certain areas
- senectus1 3y agoThe bloody things breed like rabbits... you dont need to farm them.
- mrits 3y agoI was under the impression that Kangaroos were an overpopulated nuisance.
- ceejayoz 3y ago> Can the rest of a Kangaroo be used in some productive way? I'd honestly feel ethically bad that we are killing Kangaroos just for their muscle tendon in certain areas From the article: > It was important to Dr Hartnell that no kangaroos were killed expressly for his research, and this has remained his practice throughout his investigations: all of the work has been done only using kangaroos that have either been culled for reasons of population control or harvested for meat. Kangaroo populations are fine; culling is done to keep them from overpopulating. Similar to deer in the US. https://www.theguardian.com/environment/2019/jul/12/koala-kangaroo-culling-considered-as-numbers-become-overabundant https://www.theguardian.com/environment/2019/jul/12/koala-ka...
- stubish 3y agoTotal numbers are anything but in decline. Unfortunately though, we seem incapable of correctly managing the required culling and puts pressure on the more endangered species rather than the intended ones. And there are disagreements about the methodology used to count the population numbers and thus the number that need culling. The meat is available for human consumption, but often isn't stocked due to consumer boycotts. So most of the meat from culling ends up as dogfood or wasted. Maybe this will change with Australians embracing traditional culture more, but for now 'eating the national animal' horrifies many who will stick to their non-native farm animals. The leather is great, used for top-tier foot ware and sporting equipment like footballs. But this is being replaced with synthetic materials, driven by consumer ethical concerns again. Most of those concerns seem driven by problems in the culling industry, and the horrific news articles it generates fairly regularly. Bone as usual goes to fertilizer.
- FpUser 3y ago>"undisclosed" materials for compatibility" Should not it invalidate the patent?
- pfannkuchen 3y agoShould genetic engineering on humans ever become feasible to the point where you can make large changes to the body plan, I wonder if reverting bipedalism would be easier than fixing all of the problems it causes (such as, I assume, knees, due to taking all of the load on half of the limb joints, but, also, back problems, etc). With human computer interaction technology advancements, we may eventually move beyond needing hands at all, anyway.
- adrian_b 3y agoWhen predictable genetic engineering of animals will become possible, there will be no difficulty in growing both two hands and four legs, like in the mythical Centaurs.
- pfannkuchen 3y agoNot necessarily. That is like saying “when predictable engineering of bridges becomes possible, there will be no difficulty in creating a floating-in-air bridge”. Engineering challenges still exist. My point is whether going to a more standard body plan is an easier engineering problem than fixing the design flaws in the nonstandard human one.
- adrian_b 3y agoYour counterexample is not valid. There are reasons why a "floating bridge" would not be easy to make, but the fact that all the vertebrates with jaws that exist today have no more than four paired limbs is just a historical accident and only small changes in their body plan would be necessary to make one with six paired limbs or even with much more. In some vertebrates, i.e. amphibians, it is very easy to generate supernumerary limbs without any genetic engineering, but just by manipulating the embryos. Due to defects in the development of the embryo, birds or mammals and even humans are sometimes born with polymelia, i.e. with extra legs, and some of them succeed to have a relatively normal life. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Polymelia https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Polymelia The purpose of predictable genetic engineering would be to ensure the development of a body precisely into a form optimized for a certain purpose. Obtaining random monstrous forms is easy even today, by using various mutagen agents and/or embryo manipulations.
- xwdv 3y agoDon’t know why people have objections to this, we already use bovine and pig valves in hearts, saves lives, improves health. I am comforted by the fact that if I ever need to rebuild a knee someday in the future, kangaroo tendons may be an option, so I can stay off the bench and stay on the basketball court.
- Zigurd 3y ago[flagged]
- cmrdporcupine 3y agoBold of you to assume someone hasn't already created that thread/meme.
- noirhg 3y ago[flagged]
- dvh 3y agoDoesn't this increase the chance of novel diseases when they cross from kangaroo to human?
- cududa 3y agoThe ligament is denatured/ all cells removed which just leaves a scaffolding for the natural tendon to populate
- makeitrain 3y agoQuestion: Would my new kangaroo enhanced legs disqualify me from the Tour de France?
- mrweasel 3y agoOne has to be rather careful about the wordings of such announcement. I keep thinking "Dr. Nick want's to replace bits of my mom body with kangaroo parts.... I wonder how my dad feels about that?".
- merth 3y agojumpy?
- mensetmanusman 3y agoHow would this not result in kangaroo harvesting farms/extinction?
- jb12 3y agohahaha if you can figure out how to farm Kangaroos, let us Aussies know please!
- moomoo11 3y agoCool but I’d rather have fully automated robotic legs that can let me jump like 30ft and sustain falls from 100+ ft.
- absqueued 3y agoI need one, I just ruptured my ACL.
- pmatos 3y agoI just happened to suffer an ACL tear 5 weeks ago. A week later I had ligamys implanted to great success. Four weeks post-op not only can I walk, I can also cycle. I am surprised this is not mentioned in the article. It is true ligamys only works if done soon after the tear but it would seem to my naive few that it would cover most cases.
- grammers 3y agoThat sounds very promising. Too late in my case I would have needed it 15 years ago.