13 ms·
Silicon Valley’s business model is a scam
- theGnuMe 3y agoThis was true back in the pets.com day as well. Yahoo itself was fueled by ads bought by startups fueled with venture capital. The goal was to IPO as fast as possible, and that is a game of musical chairs in some sense.
- stemlord 3y ago>subsidizing the price of their products until users couldn't live without them A good, more succinct way to describe the bait and switch scheme uber, airbnb etc have performed in their respective markets
- DragonStrength 3y agoClassic monopoly behavior w/o the monopoly: run competitors out of business with cheaper, better service then provide more expensive, worse service once the existing players are bankrupt. Calling them "start ups" and ignoring the major money backing them shouldn't change the equation.
- ChadNauseam 3y agoWithout the monopoly, it’s not really problematic though. Ironically, this accusation. is almost always levied against Uber, which is not a monopoly, better than the competition, and competing with a monopoly! The taxicab monopoly was part of the reason prices were high and service was bad
- hgsgm 3y agoTaxicabs only had a monopoly (not exact the right word, but a constrained market) in a few cities.
- danaris 3y agoIt's problematic because it is explicitly intended to make them a monopoly. When you run competitors out of business, you...don't have competition. Competition is what keeps a market healthy.
- Sohcahtoa82 3y ago> then provide more expensive, worse service I like how the term "enshittification" got coined to describe this.
- eropple 3y agoThat they got away with the term "blitzscaling" still offends me. We had a plenty-adequate term for it before: dumping. When your business model is "profit margins are for after we've killed or neutered all competitors", you don't have a business and that fundamentally shouldn't be permitted for a healthy economy.
- pydry 3y agoPredatory pricing is the the general term. Dumping is predatory pricing done in the context of international trade. IIRC theres a page on the FTC website which condescendingly explains that while predatory pricing can theoretically exist in practice it's vanishingly rare and you can basically just assume it doesnt happen. So there you go. Hear no evil see no evil.
- eropple 3y agoI used the term dumping specifically, because (to my understanding, and hectored at by an econ professor once who made it stick) it refers to trade out-of-your-home-market rather than purely "international trade"--and what 'home market' is is, itself, a thing for debate. If you parachute in with enormous sacks with dollar signs on them from Silicon Valley and engage in deep predatory pricing in other cities and states both within your country and without, I'm comfortable calling it dumping. Your other point wrt the FTC is, well...womp womp.
- pydry 3y agoEvery definition ive ever seen including the wikipedia page is pretty clear about it being specific to international trade and thats how Ive always understood it.
- hgsgm 3y agoYour memory is hyperbolic. https://www.ftc.gov/advice-guidance/competition-guidance/guide-antitrust-laws/single-firm-conduct/predatory-or-below-cost-pricing https://www.ftc.gov/advice-guidance/competition-guidance/gui...
- steveBK123 3y agoYeah it's funny how for example, Uber kind of followed a curve. It started out, in NYC at least, as a luxury "black car" replacement. Then it got flooded with the cheaper tiers, and it was hard to understand how anyone was making money - the drivers, the company etc. And they weren't! Now its more expensive than ever and generally far cheaper to get a yellow cab again.
- ChadNauseam 3y agoThe drivers were obviously making money, or they wouldn’t be driving
- spaceman_2020 3y ago“The slaves must obviously be happy, or they wouldn’t be singing songs”
- treis 3y agoThere's no masters with whips forcing Uber drivers to drive.
- asadotzler 3y agoActually, yes, there are. They're called landlords and health insurance companies. When your literal life is in someone else's hands, you do what you need to satisfy them.
- treis 3y agoThat's not the same as being owned as literal property. Don't be ridiculous.
- fullshark 3y agoPotentially they were/are trading long term depreciation on their vehicle, as well as the opportunity cost of working for a traditional employer for short term cash infusions and not really making any money.
- Spivak 3y agoI don't get this, none of Uber, Lyft, AirBnb, Vrbo, Hellofresh, Blueapron DoorDash, Postmates, Casper, Instacart, Carvana have driven their competition out of business and people are still choosing them. It costs nothing all all to not use them and you at all times could have switched back to whatever you did before.
- Dowwie 3y agoThe paper: https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=4437360 https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=4437360
- ttul 3y agoThank you. The journal article is a whole lot less sensational. “ In this Article, we argue that venture predation can harm consumers, distort market incentives, and misallocate capital away from genuine innovations. We consider reforms to antitrust law and securities regulation to deter it.”
- asah 3y ago"genuine innovations" reveals their prejudice: Uber and Lyft had to drive 100s (perhaps 1000s) of inventions, from mobile and database platform changes to user experience. Legacy taxi companies weren't going to attract the kinds of engineers who could drive them, let alone the product leadership commitment to see them through. 10 years later, the knockoff ridehailing apps *still* lack key features found in Uber and Lyft. p.s. I'm no fan of predatory pricing using VC, but this particular accusation is unprofessional BS.
- JeremyNT 3y agoDiscussed previously: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36003096 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36003096
- version_five 3y agoI didn't quite buy the connection they were making between the predatory pricing and the offloading shares onto public markets. Both are present, but I don't see the two together as a smoking gun that would make this kind of predatory pricing special. Otherwise, the article just covers pretty well explored ground. Companies take VCs money and buy revenue, and early investors have been able to offload money losing companies on public markets. This had a lot to do with interest rates imo, there was too much free money chasing returns. It's largely going to take care of itself.
- sharemywin 3y agoMoral hazard is a situation in which one party engages in risky behavior or fails to act in good faith because it knows the other party bears the economic consequences of their behavior.
- HillRat 3y agoI think the most effective argument against Wansley and Weinstein is that the markets may reset after the companies involved collapse, so you essentially get a transfer of value from shareholders to VCs and from shareholders and VCs to consumers at the cost of disrupting (in a very negative way, certainly) existing competitors. In other words, given a long enough time horizon, it's not really a monopoly problem, it's a fraud problem, and the losers are retail investors who were gulled by VCs funding impossible and unsustainable business models in pursuit of IPO-happy greater fools. (And, if the bloom comes off the SV VC rose, as it well should, then those con games are less likely to work, and we'll see a rapid collapse in valuations, junk IPOs, investments, and, relatedly, these same attempts to corner monopolies in markets -- like software -- where there is no natural barrier to competition.)
- mydriasis 3y agoAll eyes are now on the companies that don't have any real offering, or couldn't be competitive in the current market without loss-leading. Which, I mean, good. If you have a company that drives real value with its product, that's a good thing -- that's what we should be striving for. Otherwise you just want to have a big VC booze and coke party.
- JoshTko 3y agoFunding follows founders that consistently execute in scaling a solution. The big bet is that these same founders will be able to figure out profitability along the way. The challenge is that there are many "business" that can scale but are fundamentally not profitable, i.e. Groupon. This used to be fine as IPO process used to filter these bad models out. SPACs however made this IPO filter much less effective and should not be allowed.
- JumpinJack_Cash 3y agoEven without SPACs, California is where narratives are made and stories are written (think Hollywood's music and movie industry). If profitability is not found along the way (spoiler alert: almost never happens) then California fires up the afterburners as it pertains to narrative and storytelling and the company IPOs selling into those who buy the narrative , which is mostly the East Coast Asset Management Industry. Those at the helm of the East Coast Asset Management Industry will never buy the IPO with their own money, they'd do their due diligence and look under the hood and beyond the narrative, but for pensioneers and insurance policies holders the narrative more than suffices. If anything happens they can turn around and point at the narrative and say "we were told a story".
- renegade-otter 3y agoSPACs are just a legalized instrument for fraud, let's just say that. How else can you describe a system specifically designed to bypass the S1 vetting process? https://www.justice.gov/usao-sdny/pr/former-chief-financial-officer-two-spacs-pleads-guilty-fraud-scheme https://www.justice.gov/usao-sdny/pr/former-chief-financial-... And, I believe what you are saying is that in the current "business model" the scale is the product - not the product itself.
- MAGZine 3y agoSPACs are done. SEC is finalizing rules on the topic and have been for more than a year now. there's a reason you don't hear about them anymore.
- renegade-otter 3y ago
- gkoberger 3y agoI'm no fan of most business models and the way SV money works, but some of this was suspect. For example, the first fours paragraphs are based on an offhanded comment from an unnamed exec 7 years ago. It doesn't even bother to talk about how Lyft shut down its self-driving efforts in 2021 (as did Uber in 2020), which renders the whole point moot. Why start with such a bad-faith argument?
- delecti 3y agoIf you thought the whole point had anything to do with Lyft's self-driving efforts, I think you missed the point, or maybe stopped reading before it got to the point (it did bury the lede a bit). The argument being made is that the predatory pricing is a means to inflate the an eventual IPO so VCs can cash out. It's framing predatory pricing as being half of the strategy combined with a pump and dump, to work within the bounds of a dumb SCOTUS ruling.
- fullshark 3y agoIt's meant to be an illustrative anecdote, I do think there's some validity to the idea that the industry is based on taking on heavy losses for many years to own market share while simultaneously building out tech infrastructure and capabilities to shrink operational costs once you own that market...do you not?
- gumby 3y agoWhat a terrible article. First, this is hardly a new insight, having been discussed extensively even on HN for many years, much less in the press, blogosphere et al. Isn’t it in Thiel’s book? Second, it only applied to a few businesses. (And those few were mostly in SF, not SV anyway :-).
- sonicshadow 3y agoThird, if all this is true it means all the fake wunderkinds on HN won’t be able to startup the next grift that withdraws value from the consumers’ pockets and places it into theirs! Oh no!
- olalonde 3y agoMeta: the misuse of the term "scam" appears to be on the rise, often serving as a catch-all phrase for anything that one disapproves of.
- taeric 3y agoAgreed, this use of scam can quickly reduce to "most business models are scams." And that is less than useful. I do think there is something there. At large, tech's chasing of "scale" robs so many ideas of the ability to grow and be acceptable in the small. Frustrating, as nothing works at scale. Pretty much period. And "in the small" can still be quite large and manageable for many successful people. But so much of this argument seems to be on a redefinition of predatory pricing. Non sustainable pricing is not the same, all told. Especially when what makes it non-sustainable is the growth in the company. Either in market share, capabilities, or general offerings. I'm wary of turning a lot of this into whataboutism argumentation. But it would be very helpful if there was a callout to what is pushed forward as an alternative model. I'm not seeing it in this article. :(
- jonathankoren 3y agoYour argument about “predatory” versus “unsustainable” pricing is a distinction without a difference. All predatory pricing is unsustainable. You’re literally selling at a substantial loss to take customers away from your competitors and drive them out of business. It is an unsustainable price. That’s the whole point. Usually, you don’t do that in every market simultaneously, and are actually turning a profit overall, thus. Or taking yourself down along with the competition. Uber and Lyft got away with it so long because VCs believed in growth above all else, and that at sometime in the unspecified future, the ride share companies would transition to a sustainable business model after they established a near monopoly.
- taeric 3y agoPredatory is selling at below cost of manufacture. You do it in a way that is unsustainable with regard to making and offering of the product. Much of tech's unsustainable pricing is that they cannot maintain the growth of the company at that pricing forever. Which, tracks, as they also cannot sustain that growth forever.
- blueyes 3y ago"Silicon Valley" is not a monolithic actor, and certainly not a scam on some general level. There are scams within Silicon Valley, just like there are Madoff on Wall Street, and car dealerships charging too much for repairs in most small towns. Re: Uber - Why anyone would complain about Softbank and the Saudis subsidizing urban transport for years is beyond me. Take it while it's cheap...
- troupo 3y ago> Why anyone would complain about Softbank and the Saudis subsidizing urban transport They are not subsidizing urban trasport. They are subsidizing a monopoly built out of gig workers.
- sonicshadow 3y agoDeal with the consequences later is what I like to say.
- JohnFen 3y ago> "Silicon Valley" is not a monolithic actor, and certainly not a scam on some general level True to a degree, but there is absolutely a Silicon Valley mindset and ethos that is very common. And that mindset is largely accepting of scammy behavior and often even celebrates it.
- blueyes 3y agoThere are multiple cultural streams within Silicon Valley. Anyone who lives there could tell you that. Again, not a monolith. One of those currents easily tips into scams, and they are the least respectable. Other currents are focused on deep tech and life sciences. The first powers everything you do online, and the second will probably save your life at some point. Any society that equates technical innovation with "scams" will stagnate. It is in all of our interests to remember that and not lapse into easy pessimism. Silicon Valley is much more than scams.
- JumpinJack_Cash 3y ago> > SV not a scam on some general level Except it kinda is. The big improvement in quality of life for people in the last 3 years have been mRNA vaccines, they brought normality back in the world. Developed in Boston and Germany. In the 2010s the real revolution which made everybody in the world safer was fracking. Forget social media and all that crap, fracking has saved trillions to the US economy given how costly the Middle East military campaigns proved to be. And yet in the press (tech, financial and otherwise) there is just the Silicon Valley, because it's a 2 way street, people in Silicon Valley go out of their way to get press space to explain to mere mortals how they are saving the world when there is vivid action attacking the problems in all kind of places, sometimes world saving kind of action (as per the case of mRNA)
- mjr00 3y ago> Take Uber, one of their key examples. It'd be one thing if the company had simply outcompeted taxicabs on the merits. Cabs, after all, were themselves a fat and complacent monopoly. Uber/Lyft did outcompete taxis on merit, and to suggest otherwise is revisionist history! Before ride-sharing apps, the process for getting a taxi was: 1. Stand on a street corner (if you're in a busy area) or make a call if you're not. If you have to make a call, there's a ~20% chance a taxi actually shows up. 2. Get in the taxi, tell your driver where to go and how to get there since they could otherwise take a more expensive and profitable route. 3. When you're at you destination, pay the driver. 80% chance they will say "the machine is not working," offering to take you to an ATM to get cash if needed. Note that the machine magically works when you shrug and tell them you're not obligated to pay if the reader is broken. Ride-sharing apps completely changed the game. Suddenly you know exactly how much you had to pay, in advance. You knew exactly where your ride was so you had an estimated arrival time. You knew exactly what route they were taking. People talk about how Uber/Lyft dodged taxi regulation, which is true, but the reason there was so much regulation around taxis in the first place was because the old system was so ripe for abuse. Imagine being a tourist landing at an airport and taking a taxi to your hotel; what if you got into a cab and they charged a hidden $20 "airport pickup fee," or took the scenic route, or simply charged a higher rate than the car in front of them? That's exactly why the industry was so tightly regulated, and you have things like standardized rates, requirements for rates to be displayed on the interior and exterior of every cab, the meter being visible to the rider, etc. All this to say, any sort of competition on pricing is totally orthogonal to competition on product. Uber and Lyft handily won the product battle against cabs.
- cratermoon 3y ago> Uber/Lyft did outcompete taxis on merit, and to suggest otherwise is revisionist history! Uber's predatory and illegal practices are pretty well documented. It's not revisionist to say that without deliberately putting their thumb on the scale, Uber would not have even been able to get into the market.
- rib3ye 3y ago1a. The cab shows up but then picks up another person who flagged them down 1b. You have an emergency and need to cancel or the cab can't find you and the company blacklists your phone number.
- wunderland 3y agoA corollary to this is that many of these venture-backed businesses that use predatory pricing also exert strong downward pressure on wages of the “contractors” they employ who would otherwise be able to find full time jobs in the incumbent industry.
- foul 3y agoIt will happen again.
- louzell 3y ago> The point is that the entire model deployed by VCs is to profit by disrupting the marketplace with predatory pricing, and leave the losses to the suckers who buy into the IPO. That certainly rings true. But, I also think it's true that all the information you need to assess a business is right there in the public filing. So, at least in theory, enough information is out there to let the VCs keep holding the bag. Right?
- ImPostingOnHN 3y agothere seems to be enough information out there to address it via regulation. Right?
- AndrewKemendo 3y ago“Competition is for losers” has been the driving mantra of SV for a decade, led by Peter Thiel. This isn’t hidden or a secret, it’s literally the open known, repeated plan and has been written about for decades. [1] https://www.wsj.com/articles/peter-thiel-competition-is-for-losers-1410535536 https://www.wsj.com/articles/peter-thiel-competition-is-for-...
- lumost 3y agoThis isn't an uncommon attitude, tech has just had the unique ability to re:invent itself and build defensive moats faster than competition can catch up.
- dgellow 3y agoI believe the point of OP was that it is perceived as a common attitude as a result of Thiel’s influence.
- gretch 3y agoThiel's quote from the article "You create a monopoly when you invent something new". What he means is that when you compete in an existing competition with known competitors, you only have a chance of winning. Example - if I started an airline tomorrow I have to win customers over from United, AA, Southwest etc. Instead, if you start a business that no one has ever done before, you get to be a monopoly by default. E.g. Wright brothers once had a monopoly on manned flight. Competition is for losers means that you should not war with entrenched incumbents - even if they are terrible businesses that are not innovative, you can't win (as they say the winner of a knife fight dies in the ambulance).
- maxlamb 3y agoI don't see that quote anywhere. Did Thiel actually say that? I thought the main gist of his book Zero to One is you want to create a monopoly but inventing something new doesn't necessarily lead to monopoly. You need the other moats he talks about: network effects, brand recognition, etc.
- vxNsr 3y agoThis is a whole bunch of revisionist history dressed up in political us vs them, conservatives vs progressives arguments.
- nemo44x 3y agoThe story: - VCs get to invest into startups early - Companies use this money to grow their customer base often by subsidizing customers - This rapidly increases the valuation of the company - VCs look to make an exit by selling their equity while the company is aggressively scaling I don't see what the problem is. Don't buy the shares from the VCs then. These are adults doing adult things and they can make their own choices on if a company is worth buying into or not because all the financial information is public information, or available if its a private deal. I'm not sure if the article is saying that growing a business rapidly should be banned or that VCs shouldn't be allowed to sell their shares until some criteria has been met?
- ImPostingOnHN 3y agothe article is saying that the business models exhibited by some companies are unsustainable, and exist only to diminish competition in the market (which is a net loss for consumers) in other words, it's descriptivism, not prescriptivism. Do you agree with that description presented by the article?
- nemo44x 3y agoIt's sort of prescriptive though in that the lawyers say they want to chip away at this. I agree that VCs fund companies at high valuations with the idea that the company will use those funds to hit aggressive growth targets which in turn grows the potentiality of the company. This is often done by subsidizing customers to encourage rapid growth. Selling at a loss during the landgrab phase to capture market. But it's not sustainable (as the article mentions) and eventually companies have to pivot to profitability. So I have no problem with it. It has never been the case in tech that a company did this long enough to put everyone out of business and then used its acquired monopoly power to gauge customers. "Your margin is my opportunity" comes to mind and the second a margin is too big then someone will come along and take their piece.
- ImPostingOnHN 3y agoindeed, it's not sustainable, and with both the aim and effect being the destruction of competition in the market, it's a loss for consumers. I do have a problem with such societal losses.
- dataflow 3y ago> The Supreme Court bought the argument. Well that certainly explains the question I'd had for years. When I first heard about predatory pricing I kept wondering why it's not being prosecuted on a daily basis, given it seems to be everywhere. It's amazing how much laws are reshaped by the Supreme Court.
- costanzaDynasty 3y agoI would be very bearish on California right now. All the tailwinds that its had for the last 30 years are slowly unwinding. Nevermind the fact that China's economic growth 6% is equal to the percentage of US-China flights as compared to pre pandemic levels.
- kozikow 3y ago> "Of course we're committed to automated driving," the exec told him. "The numbers don't pencil out any other way." If I was doing this strategizing at Lyft - "technologies like models advance at tremendous pace, invest just enough so we are not severly behind competition if something trans-formative comes up". In X years you will be able to build your own self driving from open source components, the question is whether X is 5 or 25 years.
- 26fingies 3y ago> Under the rules of capitalism, you aren't allowed to use your size to bully competitors out of the market. That’s not a “rule of capitalism”. What rules? That _was_ a rule of the United States, but if it is still it’s not enforced anymore.
- cortesoft 3y agoLots of strange logic, but first: > Under the rules of capitalism, you aren't allowed to use your size to bully competitors out of the market. That is certainly not a rule of capitalism; it might be an interpretation of antitrust, but that is not a rule of capitalism. Also, it isn’t how the US courts and regulators view antitrust at all. You can certainly use your size to bully competitors, you just can’t use your size in SPECIFIC ways (buying too many competitors, dumping, etc) The article is correct in courts expecting to be shown harm to consumers in order to take antitrust enforcement action, but their argument as to how the companies are doing that makes no sense. They say these startups subsidize their business at a loss, offering consumers cheaper goods than they normally could, then they sell the company to unsuspecting rubes who don’t realize they will never be able to raise prices and make money. If this is true… there is no crime. As they pointed out, antitrust has been interpreted to be about harm to consumers, and as described, consumers are not harmed. They get cheap goods for a while, and the company never is able to force price hikes with monopoly power, so consumers are never harmed. The article argues the harm is actually to investors, but investors are not the ones protected by antitrust laws. As long as the companies are not committing fraud or lying in their statements to the market, investors are on their own to decide if the company is worth investing in or not.
- JohnFen 3y ago> and as described, consumers are not harmed. Hard disagree here. The government has chosen to interpret "harm" in a very, very specific way. The reasoning is that if it causes prices to go down, then there is a benefit, not harm. But harm comes in all sorts of forms, and a lot of harm is done by companies even if their actions cause prices to fall. > The article argues the harm is actually to investors Investors do get harmed, but I think the larger harm is actually to ordinary people.
- cortesoft 3y agoYou left out the first part of my sentence: > As they pointed out, antitrust has been interpreted to be about harm to consumers, and as described, consumers are not harmed. I wasn’t trying to argue whether the court and government interpretation of harm is right or wrong, just that it IS the way it has been interpreted and is the current law of the land.
- Joel_Mckay 3y agoMoney excuses any behavior for some folks, but I think the thesis falls apart when assuming a salable product/service has real associated monetary value. While “Pig in a poke (cat in a bag)” scams fall across many markets, a far more popular “Noorseekee (нурсики)” scam seems particularly prevalent in global technology and property assets. i.e. people convincing other people something is valuable before reality shatters the illusion. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_confidence_tricks https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_confidence_tricks This isn’t new, and fighting dirty to gain dominant market share for an artificial monopolistic position hijacks critical thinking. The stock markets main function is to wash away accountability, and leverage information asymmetry to siphon equity out of the losers. And yes, by definition poor people are often irrationally competitive, and lack impulse control. Those who foolishly take credit for scams often suffer rather unsurprising consequences. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9b7P2z0-cuQ https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9b7P2z0-cuQ Actual successful companies bring real value to the customers, and foster goodwill with their brands. Have a wonderful day, =)
- Robotbeat 3y agoSurprise! East Coast publication engaging in anti-tech culture war with the West Coast.
- swalling 3y agoEven more ironic here is reading criticism about economic model and ethics on Business Insider, a hive of scum and villany that regularly publishes sponsored content and outright lies from anonymous sources.
- khwhahn 3y agoThe article is leaving out a key fact. You have to build something people want. You can throw as much VC money onto a bad product (and business model) and it still won't work. Figuring out a new product and viable business model is hard. That is the reason why so many startups fail. What the article is basically saying is that "monopolies are bad". I think everyone agrees on that and there are many examples in the tech industry, but then again monopolies are easier to achieve today with digital products. What the article should have written was: Be more active in breaking up tech monopolies.
- beej71 3y agoI'm not sure that's the main thrust of the article. The idea here is that VCs can profit regardless of whether or not the product is viable. The rationality or irrationality of the company itself is not relevant. You can have a completely non-viable company disrupt an industry where ultimately everyone loses except the VCs, and the VCs' incentives are not necessarily aligned with what consumers would consider to be success.
- deckar01 3y agoNot only might consumers favor an inferior product that simply undercuts market pricing, even a higher quality product that has been subsidized to grow market share may be degraded for profitability. I believe this paper is saying that the momentum of market share provides a window for VC to extract profit and exit regardless of the quality of the product.
- emgeee 3y ago> The transfer of lousy tech equity to late-stage investors who have been led to believe it's valuable sure looks like a good blow-off to me. Uber did $8.8b in revenue last quarter is apparently on track to post operating income profitability by the end of the year. Seems like the company still has plenty of value. Also, this article makes no mention of ZIRP -- which in hindsight is starting to seem like a very large enabler of the subsidization strategies we've seen over the last decade.
- dboreham 3y agoHmm. This seems to miss the point. Consider that when you invest in exchange traded stocks: your goal is not to predict which company will make more profit. Your goal is to predict which company other people will end up thinking is worth more. These things are somewhat connected obviously, eventually, but they're not the same. Similarly, your VC is thinking about how much they can offload a portfolio company to investors in the public markets. If those investors believe stupid stuff like self-driving cars are a real thing, then why should we feel mad at the poor VC? They're just doing their job well.
- Timber-6539 3y agoThis article feels 2-3 years late.
- djoldman 3y ago> Where Wansley and Weinstein break important new ground is on the other legal standard set by the Supreme Court: recoupment of losses. If Uber and WeWork and the rest of the unicorns are perpetual money losers, it sounds like the standard isn't met. But Wansley and Weinstein point out that it can be — even if the companies never earn a dime and even if everyone who invests in the companies, post-IPO, loses their bets. That's because the venture capitalists who seeded the company do profit from the predatory pricing. They get in, get a hefty return on their investment, and get out before the whole scheme collapses. That makes sense except that in the case of Uber, the "whole scheme" never collapsed. Uber stock is about where it was when it IPO'd, it has been between ~20 and ~60 since. It seems awkward at the least to say that Uber's lack of profitability is an ongoing scheme that's going to eventually defraud current owners of Uber stock.
- timcavel 3y ago[dead]
- Night_Thastus 3y agoI knew UberEats/DoorDash were losing money at an astronomical rate (~1.3 billion in 2022) but I didn't realize that was nothing compared to what Uber is losing (9.1 billion). Man, the people backing all of these companies are going to have one cold wake-up when this finally collapses. It feels like a pump-and-dump, reminiscent of crypto. Endless hype to try to convince others to invest, only to get out as soon as possible.
- archo 3y agohttps://archive.is/Rwrms https://archive.is/Rwrms
- sharts 3y agoSo is Ukraine and yet we go along.
- ymolodtsov 3y agoI really "enjoy" when academics try to judge tech companies they don't really understand. Look, Uber's finances still aren't great. Doesn't apply to all of its peers across the world. If they burn through all their money and can't raise more, something will happen. As a user, I will say that I will continue using ridesharing apps even if conventional taxis end up cheaper. Barcelona regulated the hell out of ridesharing. Uber is prohibited, I think. When you open Bolt there for the first time, you can't order a car for 15 mins. It's an arbitrary limit they instituted so you go to a road and catch a taxi. Well, those are OK and always have card payments. But you have to be on a busy road to catch them in the first place.
- achenet 3y ago§