12 ms·
The Anti-Ownership eBook Economy
- connorgutman 3y ago[flagged]
- marcus_holmes 3y agoI pirate all my books now, except for the ones sold with no DRM as epub. I would like to reward the authors, but I refuse to allow the publishing industry to get away with this bullshit. If the authors choose to publish their books DRM-free as epubs, I will (and do) happily buy them.
- nicbou 3y agoAfter losing most of my books because I moved abroad, I am not paying for books again.
- redeeman 3y agowas this ebooks?
- nicbou 3y agoYes. One account removed my purchases after changing countries. The other is stuck in the old country, but won't let me purchase most books unless they're available in both countries. Libgen works instantly, every time.
- redeeman 3y agothey really should not be allowed to get away with this. Im happy I only buy books where I get a DRM free copy
- pierat 3y agoWho's going to "enforce" this? The UN? (HAH) The only way to force this issue is to "pirate before you buy-it" and save your money. Hard to get screwed by fake purchase buttons if you dont buy, and hit libgen, torrents, and usenet.
- redeeman 3y agoof course not the UN, but things that are sold are presumably sold, so... the country you bought it in? but I agree, do not buy shit you dont own
- marcus_holmes 3y agoThis. I move country a lot, and Amazon/Kindle just wasn't happy with that. Books kept being unavailable despite the fact I'd bought them. Spotify does the same, but at least Spotify doesn't pretend that I've bought the music.
- asynchronous 3y agoGood example is most stuff sold on Humble Bundle.
- kQq9oHeAz6wLLS 3y agoBaen sells thier ebooks DRM free if you get them direct from baen.com. They used to distribute CDs full of DRM free ebooks, back when Jim Baen was still alive. Handed 'em out at cons with instructions to copy and share. You can still find ISOs of them online.
- marcus_holmes 3y agoYeah, I've bought a few bundles :) They're doing good work :)
- TekMol 3y agoThe problem even with DRM-free epubs is that: A) I don't see a reason why some mega-cooperations should know about every book I buy. B) You don't know if they have been watermarked. I don't want every book I own to be watermarked with god-knows-what metadata about me. Let me pay with Bitcoin, and I'll buy books again.
- timidger 3y agoYour solution to a privacy problem vis-a-vis mega corporations involves moving your transaction to a public block chain?
- TekMol 3y agoFrom the outside, the blockchain is just a giant bunch of transactions. No company like a Amazon or Visa has a clear picture of what those transactions are about. Now in the times of lightning, there is not even a transaction for the payment of a book. Payments are bundled into channels. Individual lightning payments do not leave any trace on the blockchain.
- moffkalast 3y ago> No company like a Amazon or Visa has a clear picture of what those transactions are about. That's where you're probably wrong. If the NSA can listen to anyone on the planet through their phone, they surely have the data that exchanges are legally obligated to collect in terms of validating all users by their government documents, aka the place 99% of bitcoin users probably get their coin. The rest is just mapping it all together and correlating the remaining blank accounts with the piles of other data they've got on each person, which I'm sure they're easily capable of. A bitcoin transaction and a book download coming from a the same IP at roughly the same time are surely mappable to a physical person.
- brutusborn 3y agoNot a bad solution if you consider systems like Monero where transaction info isn’t easily obtained from the ledger.
- safety1st 3y agoRight now we are seeing video games disappear after only a few decades. When the business model is for the copyright owner to issue restrictive licenses, most information will eventually disappear. DRM further exacerbates the situation. Moreover this is inherent in the nature of a capitalist system itself - it's Schumpeter's creative destruction at work. It is normal, regular, and otherwise healthy for all businesses to eventually end. But if that business was the only entity with the right and ability to copy, distribute etc. - then the creative work they produced is highly likely to disappear, lost to us forever. It's tragic enough that the early history of video games may simply disappear. That future generations will have no idea how it all got started. With copying and distribution cheaper and easier than ever before, we're somehow still at risk of losing this era of history. It's far, far, FAR scarier to think of this happening to the repository of human knowledge contained in BOOKS. The future which is now unfolding is a sort of permanent, rolling version of the burning of the Library of Alexandria, where the collective wisdom of the human race just sort of fades away over time. Where we lose the ability to learn from our past, because we've lost the ability to make an enduring recording of it. Ironically, with technology, we have unlocked infinite, practically free distribution of copying and information. It can be done with a keystroke. The problem lies in our legal, political and economic systems - the iron boot has become so heavy it's crushing the larynx of the past and future alike, in a way never before seen in human history.
- hilbert42 3y ago"-the iron boot has become so heavy it's crushing the larynx of the past and future alike, in a way never before seen in human history." Exactly, as I said in my post we need a new political movement to fight the problem.
- jmiskovic 3y agoDRM is bad, most of us agree on this. Also, copyright laws were written for bygone era where things didn't move so fast. I think it's the case of the "lawful" not being aligned with "ethical". But the tragedy of games disappearing? There's more than 30 games released on Steam _each day_, let that sink in. Writing and publishing books has never in history been so easy. A vast majority of these are archived and easily available to anyone, in many more magnitudes of scale than our capacity to consume them. In fact, I'm seeing the opposite of your claims, with Meta and OpenAI publicly admitting of breaking copyright laws while training their LLMs, and also the widespread movement for self-proclaimed librarians hoarding books, ROMs and other software in terabyte scales. I'm not passing judgements about any of this, just saying that copyright law is not always strictly applied and the iron boot is more like a fluffy slipper when it comes to availability of historical content. There was a recent article about 87% of "classic" games no longer being commercially available - well that's still above the Sturgeon's law ("ninety percent of everything is crap"). Why would anyone expect publishers to offer content that is only interesting for historical reasons? For games that are still relevant, there is an added effort to run them on modern systems and to offer customer support.
- umvi 3y agoPay for a physical copy and only then pirate the ebook. Otherwise this attitude is incredibly entitled.
- marcus_holmes 3y agoNo, because then: - I'm sending a message to publishers that physical books are in demand (not the case) - I have to deal with the physical book (giving it away to a charity shop is probably the solution, but it's still hassle) - It doesn't solve the problem - publishers still think everything is good. Only by depriving the publishers of revenue until they start respecting their customers can we solve this. And I think my attitude is a lot less entitled than the publisher's. If I pay for something, I should own it, not have it subject to the publisher's whims. The attitude that they can disrespect their customers and keep control of the book even after it has been purchased is more than entitled. It should be illegal.
- nec4b 3y ago>> If I pay for something, I should own Do you believe then same thing when renting a car?
- vonnieda 3y agoWhen you "buy" a Kindle book, for instance, you click "Buy It Now" not "Rent It Now". The implication is that you are buying it to own, not renting it. Not a good comparison to renting a car.
- marcus_holmes 3y agoAlso when renting a car, I pay a fraction of its retail cost. Charging me the whole cost as a clearly marked "sale" and then renting the item to me is what's going on here, and it has to stop.
- nec4b 3y agoDo you buy or rent a subscription? I think it's pretty clear you are buying a license to view Kindle books and not buying the the book itself.
- NoMoreNicksLeft 3y agoI wouldn't even buy those. Who wants a bunch of shitty ebooks that they don't even bother to include cover art for? Sure, lately, the way they do contracts for the cover artists must include ebooks, but any title prior to about 2018 still has the shitty generic cover for whichever Random House imprint it is. And as juvenile as it sounds, I'd actually like my copies of The Dark Tower to include the interior art too. Completely absent. We finally got to a point in the future where theoretically they could siphon tens of thousands of dollars out of me (because I wouldn't first have to spend x20 that amount buying a home with a large enough library proper), and their authorized, authentic ebooks look no better than some half-assed scan downloaded from a #bookz DCC bot.
- Daz1 3y agoReally? I pirate e-books because why would I spend money if I don't have to?
- throw__away7391 3y agoThis is the same reason I shoplift all my clothes.
- cinntaile 3y agoMaybe you would it it was just as easy and without consequences.
- duckmysick 3y agoIt sort of is. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27241085 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27241085 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30315992 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30315992
- concordDance 3y agoNote that shoplifting deprives the seller of the ability to sell those clothes while copyright infringement does not.
- esafak 3y agoAnd both deprive the creators of income.
- Brometheus 3y agoIncorrect.
- Fricken 3y agoGood point
- jxramos 3y agosame here, I actually love it when publishers publish epubs, it encourages me to purchase more stuff from them. Same with bandcamp stuff with music files. A lot of times publishers are very ambiguous about the nature of their ebooks and I have to email their sales team or customer service to get a square answer about what exactly I would be buying from them. If it's some complicated morass of third party obscure e-readers and other clunky interference I just end the conversation there and move on.
- tene80i 3y ago[flagged]
- randunel 3y agoHe pays them when they don't DRM their content. Pirates would get a much better experience, otherwise, by not having to put up with the DRM crap. I'm doing the same as OP in other domains. Whether the message is understood or not depends on how many of us do it. It's called activism.
- innocenat 3y ago[flagged]
- hurutparittya 3y ago[flagged]
- Brometheus 3y agoMaking a copy is not theft. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IeTybKL1pM4 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IeTybKL1pM4
- marcus_holmes 3y agoThis. It's low-key activism, for sure, but it is activism.
- unmole 3y agoNot only do you get to take stuff for free, you also get to feel smug about being an activist. Amazing.
- tene80i 3y agoThis is, respectfully, bullshit. Are you having an impact? Do you have publishers quaking in their boots? Do you even have a plan to extract your demands? Or are you just pirating shit you want to read and dressing it up as meaningful? Which achieves what? Activism would mean you are out there convincing people who don’t already agree with you, and making hard choices about your own consumption, such as with a boycott. You’re just enjoying the fruits of people’s labour without compensating them. Cheap, cheap, cheap.
- unmole 3y agoInteresting how your grand principled stand doesn't inconvenience you in any way. Now, you could choose to not read books that don't meet your high moral bar for distribution. But screw that, you can have your cake and eat it too!
- marcus_holmes 3y agoYes, I agree. But I don't see any other way around it that works. Publishers need to stop doing this, or we end up in a world where everything is rented. They will only pay attention to what affects their revenue. I repeat: I'm happy to pay for books if they're DRM-free. It's not like I'm pirating everything because it's free; I'm happy to pay for it if I can actually own it.
- nicbou 3y agoDo you block ads on your computer, or avoid the internet altogether?
- unmole 3y agoI pay to skip ads wherever that's an option. I do use an ad-blocker because ads are annoying. What I don't so is pretend my ad-blocking is a grand crusade for privacy.
- izacus 3y agoOh no, poor inconvenience exploiters and profiteers, why won't anyone think of the rich people?!
- unmole 3y agoYeah, screw the author who actually wrote the book and the publisher who financed it. Only the freeloaders and parasites matter.
- Qwertious 3y agoI've taken a principled stand against Crunchyroll and Kindle - the result has been basically dropping reading nonfiction books and watching anime as a hobby for over a decade. Who does this benefit? Self-flagellation is not a moral imperative.
- fluxem 3y ago[flagged]
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- jrflowers 3y agoI like your point that the person you’re responding to is lying. It’s cheaper and easier to pirate everything, including books published DRM-free, so in order for your point to be true they must not actually buy any books at all. Why not just say “You are lying” rather than asking them to stop bringing up morals?
- _v7gu 3y agoHe has to show he is one step above him on the great ladder of moral upstanding.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- qwerty456127 3y agoThe same. I only buy DRM-free epubs (e.g. on Gumroad, Humble Bundle and directly), also pirate some which are not available this way. If I really were to buy something I would unDRM it. If I found out I can't unDRM it I wouldn't buy. Needless to say I only buy games at GOG.com.
- acomjean 3y agoManning is another publisher without DRM. I used to buy Oreilly books without DRM, but they’re subscription only but some books do show up on humble bundle from time to time. Manning does put a “licensed to my_email” on the pages of the digital copies but it’s not onerous.
- qwerty456127 3y agoAwesome to know! Thank you!
- tlow 3y agoWhat about local library?
- marcus_holmes 3y agoI was living in Germany, but don't speak/read German, so that was tricky. Moving country a lot doesn't help with this - a lot of the time you have to be a citizen or permanent resident to join the library and rent ebooks.
- Qwertious 3y agoThe arguments for pirating ebooks are very similar to the arguments in Uniquenameosaurus's "you should pirate anime" video (originally uploaded in, IIRC, 2018?). This: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zmi3akNnqis https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zmi3akNnqis - You Should Pirate Anime (Reupload) https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fXiQJWT442I https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fXiQJWT442I - You Should Pirate Anime 2 (Reupload)
- deelly 3y agoJust 5 cents, thats why I always trying to buy any games on GOG. No "install necessary launcher" bullshit and 100% confidence that backup of any purchased game will work in next decades, or even in next next decades without internet.
- Narishma 3y agoMaybe I'm being pessimistic but I feel it's only a matter of time before they too make their launcher mandatory.
- jocoda 3y agoLast time I looked Gog had a launcher as well.
- mrguyorama 3y agoIt's entirely optional. Every game you buy from them has a link on the store page to raw executables or even disk images.
- deely3 3y agoGOG launched like 15y ago and mostly owned by CD Projekt - creators of Witcher and Cyberpunk games, so I am cautiously optimistic.
- marcus_holmes 3y agoGoG for books would be awesome
- dageshi 3y agoI on the other hand am absolutely happy to buy ebooks via kindle. In fact most of the time I just borrow them via Kindle Unlimited, read them and effectively return them. Don't need to own a book I'm going to read once and never read again.
- T3RMINATED 3y ago[dead]
- psychoslave 3y agoJust reading the first few words remained me https://www.gnu.org/philosophy/right-to-read.en.html https://www.gnu.org/philosophy/right-to-read.en.html
- deutschepost 3y agoIn Germany, Austria and Switzerland all local Book store chains got together to create Tolino, a competitor to kindle. It got the same nice features like apps and sync. And the devices themselves are very good too. But the one thing that sets them apart is that they give you the opportunity to download the EPUB files for e-books and MP3s for audiobooks. Also you can just upload EPUB Files via the web interface. Sure you sometimes pay more, but at least you own what you buy.
- llui85 3y agoInterestingly, Kobo and Tolino use (mostly) the same hardware.
- Semaphor 3y ago> Also you can just upload EPUB Files via the web interface. That works for Kindles via E-Mail.
- deutschepost 3y agoWhen you first convert your books to MOBI. EPUBs don’t work directly.
- Semaphor 3y agoThat hasn't been true for a while, epub are supported and their own format is now based on them.
- e0 3y agoThings have changed. EPUB works now, and MOBI is no longer supported. https://www.amazon.com/gp/help/customer/display.html?nodeId=G5WYD9SAF7PGXRNA
- _v7gu 3y agoI get encoding issues when sending books directly as epub, so I have to use a epub->mobi conversion service (sendepubtokindle). Is there any way to fix encoding issues directly on kindle? I would really like to skip a step of conversion.
- degun 3y agoWell, it’s not that big of a mistery actually, even less a psychological manipulation to increase revenues. If I completely own an e-book, I can duplicate it, quadruplicate it, post it online for 10000 people to have it for free. And this would bring the company just the 3$ that I gave to them. If you want to live in the olden days, buy the hard copy, share it with a friend, donate it to a library. Nothing has changed there.
- caconym_ 3y agoIs the prevalence of DRM actually preventing ebooks from being pirated? I don't pirate books myself but I get the impression that the answer is very much 'no'.
- nerdponx 3y agoIt doesn't have to prevent all piracy, it has to prevent enough piracy to be cost-effective.
- Gigachad 3y agoThese days companies have been able tie in DRM with convenience value add. Rather than fiddle around with epub files, just log in with your amazon account and have everything right there. It's crap from a freedom perspective, but I can see how it actually seems better to the average user.
- caconym_ 3y agoWell, I'm not really convinced it presents a significant obstacle to piracy at all. See my other reply here: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36705716 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36705716 In terms of how DRM is cost-effective for platforms and publishers (i.e. why they bother with it at all), it seems much more likely to me that it's primarily meant to prevent fully legitimate post-first-sale transfers of books, e.g. library lending, second-hand sales, and so on. Publishers couldn't do anything to stop post-first-sale transfer of physical copies, but DRM-enabled ebook platforms give them a new lever.
- 3y ago
- caconym_ 3y agoI stopped buying ebooks with DRM, which essentially means I stopped buying them altogether. It's a real shame, because ebooks are vastly more convenient than print books, but I got to a breaking point with the hassle of cracking modern DRM. Anybody have success with DIY book scanning and conversion to epub?
- rebeccaskinner 3y agoI’ve been looking into it. Google published the design and software for the book scanners they used for Google books and it seems plausible to DIY them for a reasonable price. You can also buy book scanners for a couple of hundred dollars if you don’t mind turning pages manually. The main thing that’s kept me for pursuing this is that I don’t really want to own all the physical books in the first place. I prefer physical copies of technical and math books, but for random fiction I am interested in ebooks to save space. Buying the books and scanning them gets me into the same position with books that I’m already in with movies, shows, and music: lots of physical media taking up space so that I could put a bunch of extra effort into getting a digital copy that I could have downloaded for free with far less effort if I were willing to pirate.
- caconym_ 3y agoMaybe one could buy physical copies, rip them to epub, then sell or donate them. :)
- dannersy 3y agoCalibre has allowed me to essentially own all of my ebooks. I try to buy from wherever the author will get the largest percentage (so, not Amazon, essentially) and then use Calibre to strip the DRM. It's an amazing software and will basically do everything for you automatically, I can't recommend it enough. The only reason I need to do this is because I use an off brand e-reader and DRM can prevent me from using it. I use these words quite deliberately: it's fucking ridiculous. I don't distribute these purchases, I just store and back them up myself. Every so often I will "lend" one to my partner or a friend like any other paperback on my shelf. The difference being, I suppose they now "own" it, too.
- Ballas 3y agoOne of the biggest downsides to eBooks and streaming in my opinion is the availability of out of print books/music. I have had a hard time getting hold of a number of books and CDs. Some music seems to have just been lost, where the only place to get them is ebay - but that I suspect that avenue is dying rapidly with the adoption of streaming.
- comprev 3y agoTry Discogs.com for music
- toastal 3y ago“Piracy can’t be stealing if paying for it isn’t owning”
- unmole 3y ago[flagged]
- DharmaPolice 3y agoWhy do you think you can't own electricity? And taking credit for something you didn't do may or may not be some form of misrepresentation/fraud, but I doubt many jurisdictions would consider it literal theft.
- unmole 3y agoThere are no jurisdictions that consider copyright infringement literal theft either. But here we are.
- concordDance 3y agoI trust you'll be able to figure out how those situations are different with a minutes thought.
- unmole 3y agoI trust if you spend a few more minutes, you will be able to figure out the idiocy of the original argument.
- hsbauauvhabzb 3y agoYou wouldn’t download a car.
- nebula8804 3y agoWith todays prices, everyone would if they could.
- isykt 3y agoI agree with everything in this article, but I also gave up. I accept that when I buy an ebook, it’s not mine, I’m just renting cloud storage for it until the company decides I can’t have it anymore. This is mostly because the value I extract from it (the format) is the convenience and formatting. I want it now, everywhere, and well formatted for my device, and I want to do as little work as possible to make that happen. I have money and not much time. Is this short sighted? Probably. But I have come to accept that media is ephemeral, like most things. I just don’t have the time or inclination to be an archivist, much as I wish I did.
- IIsi50MHz 3y ago> I want it now, everywhere Fine if "everywhere" you go is somewhere the DRM allows. For people who cross region borders, it can remove the right you thought you paid for, with no justification. If you want it 'now', read it 'now', then you're also somewhat the DRMed item being 'revised' against your will (happens) or removed by actions of or failure of the publisher (also happens).
- michaelmrose 3y agoCalibre trivializes removing DRM on import, collects your ebooks in a simple directory structure, sharing them on the web to yourself or others, moving books to your device plugged in or wirelessly on your iphone or android with an easy to use app. It's been around for about 17 years and will probably hang around until the author dies. https://calibre-ebook.com/about https://calibre-ebook.com/about https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=com.multipie.calibreandroid https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=com.multipie.c... https://apps.apple.com/us/app/calibre-companion/id1171161691 https://apps.apple.com/us/app/calibre-companion/id1171161691
- isykt 3y agoCalibre is great! I’ve donated a few times. Alas, I simply don’t have the time or patience to maintain a library like this. It just isn’t worth it to me. I am grateful that the option exists.
- QuantumG 3y agoI have a Kindle and a bookshelf. Most books, I don't /want/ to own.
- IshKebab 3y agoThis is a silly argument. "Owning" something doesn't mean you have unlimited rights to do what you want with it. Do you not "own" physical books because you can't (legally) photocopy them? Do you not own a gun because you can't (legally, at least where I live) lend it to a friend? I'm not saying the way e-books work is good - it clearly isn't - but not because there's a fundamental law that owning an e-book should be identical to owning a physical book.
- derstander 3y ago> "Owning" something doesn't mean you have unlimited rights to do what you want with it. Do you not "own" physical books because you can't (legally) photocopy them? Do you not own a gun because you can't (legally, at least where I live) lend it to a friend? In your examples, you own the book and the gun because the publisher of the book and the manufacturer of the gun (or anyone else, excepting the state, I suppose) can’t unilaterally take them back from you or modify them without some sort of penalty. This can — and has [0] — happened with eBooks. The “unlimited rights to do what you want with [them]” are not guaranteed by ownership in my opinion. [0] https://www.nytimes.com/2009/07/18/technology/companies/18amazon.html https://www.nytimes.com/2009/07/18/technology/companies/18am...
- Lio 3y agoWhen the copyright expires on the books you own you will be able to legally photocopy them. Not so for a DRM’d ebook.
- IshKebab 3y agoAgain, "owning" does not mean that something cannot be unilaterally taken from you. Eminent domain is a very obvious example of that. Ownership does not have a single neat list of requirements, which is why it makes no sense to say "this is bad because we don't own it".
- derstander 3y ago> Again, "owning" does not mean that something cannot be unilaterally taken from you. Eminent domain is a very obvious example of that. Eminent domain is the state taking from you. I already mentioned this in my comment. In fact, the state pays a penalty for doing so in the US as enshrined in the 5th amendment: “… nor shall private property be taken for public use, without just compensation.“ > Ownership does not have a single neat list of requirements No, it does not have a comprehensive list for all use cases, but I would say that the one I mentioned in my first comment is a necessary one: fundamentally that it cannot be taken from you without penalty.
- keiferski 3y agoI hope that the subscription/Patreon/Substack model for publishing wins out in the end, because it seems obvious that piracy is not really a sustainable solution if you want new books to continue to be published. For all of its downsides, the subscription model has two big benefits: more of the money goes to writers, not publishers, as in the current system; and it shifts publishing to an economic situation similar to open source, where writers are compensated for their opinions/services and not for an easily copyable (and DRM'able) product.
- jmspring 3y agoThat's a long study. I look at ebooks like I look at movies, CDs, etc. Unless I can my own CDs or rip my own movies, I don't have a digital "file" copy of those items. Honestly, it has been difficult keeping up on that, improvements in displays (4K OLED TV, for instance), etc. It sucks and there should be a way of proving ownership such that you get access to the online digital versions. I have an extensive book collection and first several first editions in the areas I am interested in. I read the physical books from time to time, but for me the Kindle is a must have device that I use for hours every day - reading in bed, etc. Do I like it being a closed system? No. Do I have the energy to pirate things and keep on top of managing those collections - books are somewhat easier, but media is much harder - no.
- ckemere 3y agoCould we make a small machine that would live scan a book so someone could read it remotely? Would that be consistent with first sale?
- BigRedDog1669 3y agoThis isn't a device, but there is a mail-in service for that: https://1dollarscan.com/ https://1dollarscan.com/
- politelemon 3y agoIn all of this, I am surprised that the authors managed to miss out (or did they leave it out?) the damaging role that Apple played in this ecosystem by colluding with publishers. It got away with a light tap on the wrist but we still feel its effects today.
- high_5 3y agoAs long as there will be FOSS and open hardware, there will be a chance for piracy to exist. As long as piracy will exist, there will be a chance to save the many artifacts of our modern culture. But, if these artifacts were just to distract us from preserving them in the first place, they were probably not worth to be preserved. And ho boy, how there is much distraction to be found today!
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- aamoscodes 3y agoI love getting ebooks from my library. I can even request new books within my system that aren't out yet, then when they're released and purchased by the library, they are automatically put on hold and added to my account.
- outside1234 3y agoI get my ebooks on Anna’s Archive and then buy one copy physically and put it in my little book house when I’m finished. Solved.
- MattHeard 3y agosome consumers will pay the premium of ownership over the licence and some won't. if either market has demand fall below a particular threshold, the market will collapse. this isn't a moral issue, this is simply an effect of a new market for a service substituting effectively for an old market for a good. it's clear that a lot of previous book-owners really just wanted to be able to access a text if there is really a mass misunderstanding by ebook consumers that they don't have rights as part of their licence that they believe they have, the market demand will start shifting back towards ownership
- HlessClaudesman 3y agoOne often missed negative about digital goods, books and audio books especially, is that publishers have no incentives to lower their prices ever. With physical books the invisible hand of capitalism alters prices to match books to buyers, creating a long tail of demand decades after publication. As a young person I used to love picking up gems at book fairs and remainder sales, exposing me to so many more ideas than I could afford at full price. If publishers were smart, seeing fostering reading as a good thing for society and their bottom line, they would recreate this effect by gradually lowering the price on older titles.
- drpixie 3y agoThe author touches on revocation - to me this is a MAJOR problem with "licenced" media. Publishers have shown, again and again, that they will not continue to "sell" (distribute) their product. Despite storage and transmission being very cheap, it is almost impossable to find many classic films, music, and books. Aparently it is legitimate can claim a "loss" if they cease to sell an item (presumably having destroyed the master copy). It might make perfect commercial sense to drop low selling items and claim large tax losses, it may be legal, but how is this moral? For classic items, this is nothing less than destroying cultural artifacts. (This is yet another case where modern copyright is out of step with modern morals and expectations. Personally, I'm for short copyright terms, perhaps requiring explicit registration, and requiring licence holders to maintain a copy for historical purposes - perhaps in some kind of escrow at the internet archive.)
- aftoprokrustes 3y agoI use my e-reader a lot, as I only have limited shelf space at home, and like to be able to take my whole library with me in the train. For most books, I am fine with having them only available on my device. Bit once in a while, I wish there was some way to get the physical copy of the book for free or at a discount when one purchased the electronic version. Not being able to have the physical book to display on my bookshelf and lend to friends and family, although I essentially paid the same price, frustrates me again and again.
- guy98238710 3y agoJust pirate the books. You are only attracting attention of sharks when you pay.
- dannersy 3y agoI think what really chaps my ass about DRM and by extension, piracy, is that convenience is what really what people want. Gabe Newell of Valve said on stage, way before it was cool and way before everything was being served to you from the cloud, that piracy is not a pricing issue, it's a service one. Steam single-handedly made pirating games just not worth the time, so much so that people were re-buying old games, even ones that they had previously pirated, so that their library could be in one place. Unfortunately, ownership of what your purchase is still very much a heated topic and is more a game-to-game topic for now (ie, I can download and play certain games outside of Steam but other games need external and third-party launchers to be online in order to play). Amazon almost got it right by doing similar, and subsequently dominates the ereader market by making it easy and convenient to buy and download an ebook and have it be in a comfortable and familiar format for all your books. They lost me as a customer the moment I wanted a more capable device and to use that library demanded that I use their Kindle software. Frankly, it's sort of a pain to be a third party ebook reader and even though I have given someone an ebook to read in the past, I had to set it up for them. I would be surprised if ebook piracy was a large portion of ebook consumers since it's more hands-on, though it would not surprise me if it was a growing market share. Although the models are different, there have been similar effects with Spotify and video streaming services. You definitely own nothing in these examples, which I feel is worse but it's also pretty clear that you don't own something where ebooks and video games are arguably lying to you in terms of ownership. You essentially pay to get to play/read without owning anything. Before I move on, Spotify gets a special note here as I almost cancelled my subscription after being tired of their constant UI shifts to be more like a social media platform. Since it's the only place I consume music at the moment, I'm at the mercy of their bad decisions. It's all wrapped up into the same topic because if I drop Spotify, then I'm left with a music accessibility problem. This is the same thing Newell said, I now have a service problem, AGAIN. Thankfully they reverted those changes, but ultimately I feel like my problem has only been postponed. I lament that bandcamp is not more popular. Perhaps this is all anecdotal, but from my perspective, it's very clear to me that piracy is (or will be) making a comeback to all of these industries. DRM is ultimately a losing strategy and can alienate consumers. Platform exclusivity, invasive DRM, juggling apps and subscriptions, companies trying to change their music app into a social media one, etc are all user and consumer hostile. The only shame is that the creators ultimately suffer when consumers get tired of the distributors, particularly musicians and authors.
- marzipanWhale 3y agoWhen I buy ebooks on Amazon I always download them and put them in Calibre. I have also sent copies to my brother. The article states that this is impossible, but Amazon literally has a "download" button. (Although they hide it well)
- Timshel 3y agoDo you have a reliable way to strip DRM ? I used to strip and convert to epub but since the start of the year I can't anymore. Without it means for most book you will not be able load the book on a non kindle reader.
- marzipanWhale 3y agoI haven't needed to do it. I think it's because I download the file for my old Kindle Keyboard 3G, so I probably get a file without DRM. Not sure. Calibre "just works".
- Timshel 3y agoO yeah it's listed in (https://www.mobileread.com/forums/showthread.php?t=283371 https://www.mobileread.com/forums/showthread.php?t=283371, probably : "In addition, the owners of older e-ink Kindles running firmware prior to 5.6.5 (August 2015) can access books in non-KFX formats directly from the device via USB." Don't lose it, might try to buy on old kindle :D
- marzipanWhale 3y agoOh, that's neat. Thanks for finding this. Edit: I don't really care if I lose it, though. I just won't tell Amazon if I do.
- hilbert42 3y agoCorporations extorting the public has really gotten out of control. Also today on HN I viewed a video showing how free-to-air TV is being encrypted and being pushed into a subscription model. This is outrageous. The problem is everywhere, Redhat circumventing open source software licenses, Microsoft turning its Windows O/S into a data collection operation, Facebook privacy violations, rampant selling of personal information without owner's permission, and so on. It's now so bad it's causing significant damaging to our societies. Why aren't our politicians and political systems stopping this? Perhaps, a better question to ask is why aren't they capable of stopping it. It's not only happening in the US, it's everywhere, these greedy corporations have influenced US trade deals and just about every country is now beholdened to unreasonable US patent and copyright laws. What we're witnessing is governance by corporations, democracy is essentially dead. If politicians don't take charge and start rolling back the power of corporations it'll soon be too late. When the populous finally wakes up about how it's been screwed, things could turn very ugly and we could end up with another Marxist-like revolution, and that's the last thing we need. Revolutions rarely solve anything and cause much pain. What's truly worrying is the complacency of the population in that it's letting itself be manipulated by these corporations without a fight. What we do about it is the big question. It seems to me we need a new political movement that brings together all the disparate groups who are struggling with each part of the problem. There's nothing like strength of numbers to bring about change. History has shown that many times.
- SomeRndName11 3y agoFirst world problems.
- jdbernard 3y agoComing soon to a third world near you! Except the power imbalance is even greater, so it's likely to be even more restrictive.
- SomeRndName11 3y agoI live in third world. No one gives a slightest damn about copyright here and download books for free, from some strange places all over internet.
- IIsi50MHz 3y agoSeems like you're saying that DRM, region locks, and such _are_ problems in the third world; defeating them remains necessary, but is done pervasively, and often trivially, without criticism or other penalty. The fact that DRM on these downloads might have been defeated by somebody else does not change the fact that removing it was necessary.
- rob74 3y agoHow about the more general anti-ownership digital economy? When (legal) digital distribution of music was new, I remember how Apple's decision to distribute DRM-free MP3s in the iTunes store was hailed as a great success. Fast forward to today, where most music listeners are using (and paying for) platforms like Spotify, where they don't own the music they listen to. So it looks like the majority of people don't really care for owning the media they pay money for, or have gotten used to the "rent model" and will gladly trade convenience for ownership.
- dsign 3y agoHey, this is easy to fix: buy self-published books. Most authors don't really care about DRM, giving most of their revenue to Amazon or the man in the middle, or having to accept that an illustration they commissioned and paid $$$ for now looks like crap because Amazon eats their revenue on proportion to the book's size in bytes[^1] and their publisher really wants to pocket that 70%. And if you find a small number typos in a self-published book, just send them to the author. [^1]: https://kdp.amazon.com/en_US/help/topic/G200634500 https://kdp.amazon.com/en_US/help/topic/G200634500 . Search the part about delivery costs.
- Santosh83 3y agoThe problem is promotion and payments. Amazon et al will deal with payments from around the world, will print & ship hard copies, will deal with refunds, and will promote your book across their properties. You get none of this with self-publishing.
- lakomen 3y agoYeah. Paying a subscription to read a book? Not me. Looking at you O'Reilley
- LinAGKar 3y agoThat's why I make sure to always strip the DRM off with DeDRM whenever I buy an e-book.
- Timshel 3y agoUsed to do it but it's getting trickier and trickier for Amazon :(.
- grahamlee 3y agoRichard Stallman predicted this in 1997’s “The Right to Read”. Predictably rather than listen to him, software specialists discredited him. https://www.gnu.org/philosophy/right-to-read.en.html https://www.gnu.org/philosophy/right-to-read.en.html
- redeeman 3y agostallman has been very very good at seeing what others would collectively do in the face of technological development. People shunned him, yet he was absolutely right
- expertentipp 3y agoCopyright predators turn all sides of the conflict into extremists. There is no compromise in sight.
- ThinkBeat 3y agoA good solution to this is buying paper books. Lots of cheap used books out there as well. Then you can: Keep it on your bookshelf. Read it over and over again. Make notes all over it. Photocopy it. Share it with a friend. Donate it to a tiny community library. Give it away Sell it. Burn it. Toilet paper. I really wish that real paper books would become the new trendy thing (like with vinyl.[1]) You can even get together with some friends with similar tastes then each person can different good books and let everyone read them. Saves a lot of money. [1] I read somewhere that a significant percentage of people who buy and collect vinyl LPs do not own a turntable. Quite odd
- Engineering-MD 3y agoI think paper books are a trendy. Reading a paper book is a different experience much more so than vinyl is, and while bookshops and libraries went through a dip they seem to be coming up again
- antigonemerlin 3y agoYes, but I miss ctrl-f in real life.
- nathell 3y agoEvery time I buy an e-book in Poland, I’m grateful that DRM here ended up being just a fad, and no publisher uses it anymore. The gold standard here is watermarking, but I can easily copy books from my Kindle to my wife’s. That said, I’m still not very happy about the status quo. I wondered how the book economy would look like in my ideal world, and came up with this: https://blog.danieljanus.pl/2022/09/24/paying-for-books/ https://blog.danieljanus.pl/2022/09/24/paying-for-books/
- iamkd 3y agoI got both my AWS and Amazon accounts banned a few months ago, because I was living in Eastern Ukraine and ordered some books there in 2014 (before the postal services stopped working). Apparently, that address was saved somewhere and now it is under sanctions, even though I left that place in 2014. My Kindle library is gone because Amazon's support can't do anything about it. I was mostly ignoring the fact DRM exists, because what could go wrong? Well, it was a refreshing reminder that our "R" in "DRM" are much more fragile than we got used to think when nothing bad happens for years. At least until we forget about it once again. That's it folks, gotta go buy a few limited use licenses on Steam while they're on sale!
- flexie 3y agoThe HN crowd largely consists of people who make a living creating or working for businesses that create material which is protected as intellectual property rights. Source code to computer programs is protected under copyright law (and in America often also patent law). Databases such as the core of social networks are protected under a version of copyright law. Algorithms and procedures are often protected through confidentiality agreements and laws requiring confidentiality from employees and business partners. Names of companies, websites, URLs, games, characters, URLs (google.com) etc. are protected under trademark law. I can't just register "google.con" and make a search engine and sell ads from that domain. Google will come after me. And those on HN that don't work yet, often study at expensive universities that awarding fancy degrees. Not everyone is free to say they graduated as a Ph.D. in engineering from Harvard. Yes, many developers on HN open source part of or all of their work. But then the get paid creating some other intellectual property right. Very, very few people just give away all their work. Yet, that's literally what most commenters here seem to ask that publishing houses and authors do. Publishing houses make little money compared to many other businesses and especially compared to big tech. Authors typically make next to nothing. If publishing houses don't try to protect their digital works, they will not be paid enough to cover costs, yet alone turn a profit. Simple as that. An e-book can be copied and spread much easier than a print book. Without publishing houses, there will be less screening of published works, and less marketing of authors and new books.
- antigonemerlin 3y agoLet's address the root of your argument: At the end of the day, people have to eat. We're going to have to pay people somehow, either by buying a product, buying merchandise, paying taxes / donating to fund grants, or through patreon or github sponsors. The topic is fairly broad, and so it's less one system than a bunch of different industries with their own funding models, so this is going to be speaking fairly generally. A lot of our present funding models are a hybrid of these systems. Some combination of ads, small dollar donations, institutional sponsorship, and public grants broadly help pay for anything from a new software library to webcomics. Sometimes it's enough, and sometimes it's not, but there are alternative funding models to the present winner-take-all model of big publishing houses. It's good to recognize that a lot of open source can only exist because a lot of us work in high paying tech jobs, and that model will not work for traditional books, but that doesn't mean we should give up trying to find a better solution than the patchwork system we have today. So, why don't we just subsidize authors? Arguably, access to more information drives more technological growth, which benefits us all. How many discoveries have been delayed because journal articles are behind a paywall? How many wasted manhours were spent on that? Grad students make even less money and arguably spend even more time creating intellectual property. It's frankly ludicrous to gate scholarly articles behind a $20 paywall, because for one, the burden of payment in those cases tends to fall upon those least able to pay for it, who are students and researchers, while the publishers make all the money by extorting institutions who can pay, all while profiting off of publicly funded research. This is the least morally objectionable point, and probably why newer fields (especially in compsci) post all their articles for free on arXiv, or else host somewhere else, since the price of hosting is extremely cheap compared to the actual work. Less arguably, art itself is the same kind of public good; We have PBS, for programs that one can broadly say is "enriching" because a bunch of people a hundred years ago said so; we surely recognize that Shakespeare ought to be publicly funded. Why not modern forms of entertainment? Failing that, let's look at this purely from a cost perspective. We'll assume if we're paying 100% of a writer's salary, their work is in the public domain, and that counts as savings to consumers. Let's suppose we wanted to fund every single writer in America to do writing full time. Let's do some back of the envelope calculations here. Supposing I spent $40 on books per year, for the sake of argument. There are 330m people in the US, median income for writers is around $20k USD [1] (but those are poverty wages) to $50k USD [3] (I think those include industry), and there are anywhere from 50k to 200k active writers right now [2][3], depending on how you count. So, that's anywhere from $3.3 (probably add an extra few cents for admin costs) to $33 per person per year in additional taxes, if we literally subsidized every single writer in the US. I'm certain I spent more than $33 on books this year, though one could probably quibble on that. 'course, that's probably overkill, and it doesn't account for support staff, admin, editors, marketing etc, but evenly naively taken, it doesn't seem out of the realm of economic possibility. Of course, we probably won't pursue such an extreme solution. So let's look at another one. Consider the question of the library. Surely every author would be against an institution distributing their work for free (even having paid the publisher for one copy). For sake of money, should Stephen King be removed from circulation of libraries? But that fails to recognize that physical libraries target a market segment that cannot afford to buy a book; when it is more convenient, people tend to want to buy books for themselves. Digital removes these inconvenient constraints and will require a renegotiation in this space as it shifts to much in the other direction; the internet archive's unilateral action is at best, controversial. Streaming services like spotify initially gave a lot of consumer surplus at the expense of the artists (and is now, like every platform, trying to claw that surplus to themselves). The library model may not work for digital. Consumers or publishers can capture all the surplus in this new shakeup, but some balance is probably the most acceptable/optimal solution to most people. And like it or not, with AI, artists will be devalued, even if that work isn't done. Amazon is already killing traditional publishing houses with its own platform. While we're having a debate on copyright, the market is going to shift even more in favor of consumers and less in favor of authors. We're going to have to address these issues anyways, like it or not, because we're already on this path, so we might as well figure out a more robust solution now. Failing everything, why not have a national system of grants for writers to produce public domain works? (And yes, I know this naive solution probably has many holes in it. I'd be delighted to be corrected, even more so with another solution. But at the very least, shouldn't we at least try something else than the endless morass of DRM and copyright?) 1. https://www.nytimes.com/2019/01/05/books/authors-pay-writer.html https://www.nytimes.com/2019/01/05/books/authors-pay-writer.... 2. https://www.statista.com/statistics/572476/number-writers-authors-usa/ https://www.statista.com/statistics/572476/number-writers-au... 3. https://datausa.io/profile/soc/writers-authors https://datausa.io/profile/soc/writers-authors
- indymike 3y agoI just had an old account closed by Amazon and lost 15 or so books a couple movies, some purchased music and a bunch of old mobile apps from the Amazon app store. The total value was probably $500. After an hour of going circles with contact center people, I was told there was no way to transfer my content to another account, and there was no recourse to restore access to the account and the supervisor couldn't help either. This experience was a customer service horror show, and really soured me on buying any electronic content from Amazon, ever again. I really don't care about how piracy affects Amazon and mega-industries. I care a lot more about having $500 worth of content taken away on the whim of a call center agent. In fact, it might just be time to start working on getting legislation in place that forces companies to at a minimum, refund they buyer (with interest) if they cut off access to DRM protected content.
- amelius 3y agoThis is how you make your government aware of issues like this: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ombudsman https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ombudsman
- midoridensha 3y agoIt's time for you to hoist the Jolly Roger and set sail on the high seas to reclaim your stolen property.
- wwfzyn 3y agoIs it bad if the book is pirated and never read? I would bet a huge number of people pirate a book to have it and never read it.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- rchaud 3y agoI must still be living in the 2000s because I still treat big-publisher eBooks like MP3s....I'll buy the physical copy if I like it. At least MP3s on Bandcamp etc are fairly priced, $10/album is less than the $18.99 that was common at stores 20 years ago. Ebooks on the other hand cost almost as much as a paperback $9.99 seems to be the lowest price I've seen on Amazon. I'm not paying that!
- pierat 3y agoIf "buying" a thing doesnt mean I own the thing and control and ownership is retained from who I "bought" it from, is it really buying? And is it really "piracy" when the only sale option is a fraudulent "sale"?
- jamesgill 3y agoRemember when you could buy and own a copy of a software program? And how today you just ‘license’ or ‘rent’ or ‘subscribe’? Ebooks aren’t unique—the model is part of a larger, longer-term trend, and we’ve been willing participants and creators of it.
- renegat0x0 3y agoI keep my data on my NAS. If the thing I buy cannot be downloaded and stored, I think if my investment is worth it. My ereader, onyx boox uses WIFI to download books from NAS.
- tmaly 3y agoI prefer physical books when they are available and then used copies before new ones. If my library has a copy, I will often borrow it first before deciding to buy the book. Digital books are always last choice for me.
- beej71 3y agoMy googling is coming up empty, but it would be great if there were a list of links to author tip jars. A lot of us don't like giving money to publishers who rent DRM books, but do like giving money to the authors.