7 ms·
Please don't say just hello in chat
- mooreds 3y agoPreviously: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30642052 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30642052
- ano-ther 3y agoI don’t like just hi either, but people tell me they do it because they don’t want to disturb me and don’t know if I may be sharing my screen - so it is well-intentioned. I once was on a WebEx when the presenter was notified by her manager about the company car she would get for her promotion in a thread with many details. Very insightful.
- andrewmunsell 3y agoYour notifications aren’t automatically silenced when presenting your screen?
- naikrovek 3y agothey can be in every tool I've used, and are also on by default, so I think this is a lot of people shooting themselves in the foot. when I am on support, if you ping me with only "hi" or "hello" or some other simple greeting, I will simply not respond to you until you give me something actionable for me to look at. if you don't say your problem and provide some info about what you need, then I have neither the time nor the desire to pull it out of you. tell me what you need or I will not respond.
- fsflover 3y agoNo, on Qubes OS, different apps work in indepenent VMs and don't know about each other.
- asdkjkasjd 3y agolol, I can't do anything in any of these meeting softwares unless I'm using some specific OS+Browser combination that nobody actually uses.
- ano-ther 3y agoOh, they are. It’s part of my routine when I get a new setup. But the people pinging me cannot know and want to be considerate.
- caseyohara 3y agoFor Mac users, the Muzzle app is great for this. It automatically turns on Do Not Disturb while screen sharing. The website is hilarious too https://muzzleapp.com https://muzzleapp.com
- ndlan 3y agoThe website is incredible. I spent a few minutes and I could not get to the end of it. I wonder how many copies of the software did that website sell - I'm thinking of buying one and I don't even own a Mac.
- rodgerd 3y agoI do not for the life of me understand why people have not got into the habit of sharing windows, not screens.
- adrr 3y agoI could also have people at my desk looking at my screen as we go over some code or a project plan. Messaging services are for urgent matters which usually have some privileged info. If it’s just a non urgent question or request, send an email so you don’t interrupt people. Biggest issue with messaging services is that they easily abused for things that can done via asynchronous communication. They become big distractions.
- tayo42 3y agoDepends on what you want to share. Sometimes it's helpful to have like maybe code and a browser or terminal up to present to someone
- bluefishinit 3y agoPlease don't complain about how people use chat, it's super annoying. Just say "hi" back, it's not going to kill you.
- jonny_eh 3y agohi
- throwbadubadu 3y ago[flagged]
- lcnPylGDnU4H9OF 3y agoI'll be saying "hi" back the next hundred times they bother me with literally nothing. No thanks, I'll ignore it until they ask me something.
- outworlder 3y agoThat wastes everyone's time. 'hi' is fine at a personal setting. At work, you waste time for a reply, then the reply to the reply, and only then the person will state their request. This can take hours if done across timezones. Just say "Hi. <Request>"
- bluepizza 3y agoHow is typing "hi" a waste of time?
- ChrisArchitect 3y ago(2013)
- ChrisArchitect 3y agoSome discussion a year ago: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30642052 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30642052
- debo_ 3y ago[flagged]
- unglaublich 3y agoThis all assumes the person doesn't have a reason to verify your presence before doing a brain dump. Maybe they do. Maybe they want to make sure you're there; maybe their issue is dependent on the time; maybe they want to send/receive a TOTP; maybe the whole point of the conversation is to check whether the medium is functional; maybe they want to send you something sensitive...
- Lt_Riza_Hawkeye 3y agoHey, are you there? I need a 2fa code for the netflix account
- Volundr 3y agoThis message I will reply to if/when I'm around. I know exactly what I'm getting into. "Hi" could be I have a quick two second thing, or I'm about to dump 6 pages on you and expect a reply in a few minutes. I'll reply when I'm prepared to deal with the latter. Maybe.
- mastazi 3y ago> This message I will reply to if/when I'm around. which is perfect because the precondition is that the other person wanted to know if/when you're around > "Hi" could be I have a quick two second thing, or I'm about to dump 6 pages on you so you agree that "Hi" carries zero information and should be avoided?
- Volundr 3y agoYes exactly. I'm agreeing that this is the right alternative and will get a response from me much faster than the empty "Hi". "Hi" <brief description of why I'm reaching out> is always superior.
- twodave 3y agoThat’s the point—it’s ambiguous. It’s better to use more words to indicate what you’re saying hi for than to try and force me to acknowledge you by hiding your reasons up front. That is a form of manipulation.
- Dudester230602 3y agoJust ignore the 'hi'-sayers. Either they will go away or they will state the matter. Make sure their message is marked as read, so that they would understand.
- xur17 3y agoThis feels like the sort of thing that could be easily solved with technology. Something like: if I receive a message on slack with the message hi, how are you, hello, or something similar, wait 15 minutes to notify me about it. For all other messages, notify me as normal.
- bluefishinit 3y agoIt's a social issue, not a technological one. People just need to be ok communicating with people who have different styles. Most people do not care to optimize their communication like this and will have a more natural way of speaking, including starting a conversation with "hi".
- comfypotato 3y agoIf the people at the receiving end are annoyed by the interruption, they have every right to implement a solution. Your remark implies the “hello” folks are correct, and that is purely opinion.
- gAI 3y agoNone of that is how communication works. It requires (basically equal) effort on the part of the sender and the receiver. Gatekeeping communication styles is just a symptom of not having control in other areas.
- bluefishinit 3y agoIf people are annoyed by someone saying "hi" then yes, I think they are in the wrong and creating a hostile work environment. I've worked on a lot of different teams, and people who complain about stuff like this are always the single biggest drag on morale. Teams should practice tolerance, trust and flexibility, especially remote teams.
- mrdude42 3y agoYES. I completely 100% agree. Try to minimize the number of messages you're going to send. Just saying "Hi" and then also saying what you want to ask just makes my phone ring twice instead of once and that just gets more annoying with each subsequent message you send before I have a chance to respond.
- caconym_ 3y agoI think "no hello" evangelists should emphasize that you can say hello if you want, as long as you follow up with your actual question/request in the same message. The point isn't that the "hello" itself is a critical waste of some human resource, but rather that interrupting somebody with "hello" and then making them wait for something actionable is disruptive and frustrating. This may seem obvious to many, but I don't think it's universally understood.
- SteeCee 3y agoSaying hello and then your inquiry is what every example in the website says is the right thing to do. Who is saying you shouldn't say hello at all?
- burnished 3y agoI think the tone being kind of sassy and put apon over a small inconvenience shifts the focus from the more constructive parts of the message and in that sense I agree with the person you are responding to - the etiquette evangelists might be more effective if they did less spleen venting.
- em3rgent0rdr 3y agoThe marketing of "no hello" (nohello.net) is contrary to what those examples say. So maybe there is a better way to market it instead of "no hello". Like maybe "just ask the question", or "start with a query", or "Don't just hello".
- FireInsight 3y agoI feel like this almost falls under dont ask to ask https://dontasktoask.com/ https://dontasktoask.com/ which is a clearer ask.
- sanarothe 3y agoMy boss always sends a hello first, usually 1 to 5 minutes before I get the thing I'm actually supposed to respond to. If she just sent the whole thing at once, I could determine if it's something I need to break focus for immediately, or get to in a few minutes.
- booleandilemma 3y agoI don't mind an innocent "hello" or "good morning", etc. If you're antisocial then maybe working in a company isn't for you. Hello everybody!
- version_five 3y agoThat has nothing to do with the message here. This is about saying hello and then waiting for a reply as a prelude to a longer discussion.
- simion314 3y agoI would love if people would send just 1 big message instead of splitting it in multi lines and send them one of a time. I prefer to get 1 notifications not 3+ and having to check and then see the "X is typing " message
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- Blackthorn 3y agoWhere I work people indicate their preference by saying "no hello" or "yes hello" (or rather the corp equivalent of it here). Works pretty well. This problem is entirely solvable!
- sentientslug 3y agoWhere is this preference recorded for each employee? A status message?
- Ntrails 3y agoI am super guilty of sending 4 messages instead of 1. Hey Did you see that thread in #hn_feed? I remember you asking about the right way to sand the wood before painting - some great ideas. Also - cake on the 4th floor kitchen fyi Since nobody in my entire office answers messages in the time it takes me to write those four, I struggle to feel guilty.
- Volundr 3y agoHonestly as long as they second message comes promptly after the first this doesn't bother me at all. It's when the "Hey" is just left out there by itself that annoys me.
- burnished 3y agoI don't think the problem described is staccatto bursts (at least I hope, I do the same thing), but adding a synchronous element to the communication that doesn't add thing. I think what you do is pretty in line with this ethos - the other person is pretty free to prioritize your messages as they see fit
- eagleseye 3y agoI suppose, as long as these 4 messages arrive in quick succession you're fine. If you wait a minute between sending each, that's where you should feel guilty :P
- slyall 3y agoThe real crime is that you left the line about cake till last
- plorkyeran 3y agoIt's very mildly annoying when it leads to me staring at slack waiting for you to finish typing, but if that's the most annoying thing that happens on slack that day then it's a really good day.
- benhurmarcel 3y agoThe multiple notifications often bother me, but I think it's a problem with the messaging app, not with the sender. It shouldn't send a new notification for each message if it just sent one a few seconds ago.
- Stratoscope 3y agoThis is something every pilot learns early in their training. You don't do this: Pilot: "San Jose tower, Cessna 54321" Tower: "Cessna 321, San Jose tower, state your position and request" Pilot: "Tower, Cessna 321 is five miles to the southeast" Tower (starting to sound annoyed) "Cessna 321, and your request please?" Pilot: "I'd like a straight-in landing on runway 30 right" Tower (if pilot is lucky) "321 cleared for straight-in approach and landing 30 right" Instead, you do this: Pilot: "San Jose tower, Cessna 54321 five miles southeast, request straight-in landing 30 right" Tower: "Cessna 321, San Jose tower, cleared for straight-in approach and landing 30 right"
- johnchristopher 3y agoI am OK, the bull is dead: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=779723 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=779723
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- paulddraper 3y agoMan do I love pilots. Succinct, intelligent, calm.
- Freedom2 3y agohttps://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36590806 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36590806
- wintorez 3y agoUnbind Enter key from Send. You will thank me later.
- commandlinefan 3y agoOr, alternatively, you could: deal with me saying hello.
- meghan_rain 3y ago[flagged]
- another_story 3y agoYou have the choice to ignore the hi. Seems like a non-issue.
- ThinkingGuy 3y agoEven worse than just “hello”: Following it up with just “how are you?” (Yes, I’ve had coworkers who would actually do this)
- dekhn 3y agoThese days, I start wiht a hello, and inline with that, a call to not respond if the person is OOO or it's outside of work hours, a bit of context on the problem, several links to the relevant code/pipeline failure, a specific request for what I need to know, another request to actually answer my question and not solve another unrelated problem, an unrelated sportsball comment, and then finally, what I actually needed. Then when they're online I can just re-paste that.
- hamasho 3y agoI'm pretty sure this is what my chatgpt thinks whenever I say hi. I know it's annoying, but you respond so quickly and gladly, so I can't stop starting the chat with hi. I should stop this, or I would begin to do the same to real humans on Slack.
- palata 3y agoOh come on, it's a chat. I don't get those who get pissed because someone tries to be polite, or because they think every conversation should go in a thread (maybe you need a forum then?), or because they get too many notifications (just disable them?). The solution to this is not technology, but rather anger control.
- irrational 3y agoI can’t think of a single time that someone has done this. Is it a generational thing? I’m Gen X and probably the majority of people I chat with are also Gen X (other than my kids who are Gen Z).
- brocha 3y agoThere is also a cultural component to saying hello/hi before stating your request. Almost every Asian/Indian person I have worked with starts a conversation this way. I asked a friend one time and they just said it is polite so I stopped caring
- xela79 3y agothe point is not to "not" say hello. But to have your message include the actual reason for contacting them. so instead of 8:14 "hello" 9:15 "actual question" sent 8:14 "Hello, actual question"
- temp84858696945 3y agoSaying just "Hi" or "Hello" is asking for a synchronous chat, whether by text or by voice. Lots of people prefer talking to people rather then writing each other letters. Yes it's arguably less efficient, but lots of things that people do are inefficient, and if they prefer that means of communication it doesn't really hurt and in my mind is just polite to oblige them.
- ilyagr 3y agoThen you can say "hi, do you have a moment for a quick chat? I'm free until 4". Be aware that this can cause a heart attack or panic if you are in a position of power over the recipient. Saying something like that to your manager can work wonders, though.
- temikus 3y agoI view this not as a “you’re making me wait” thing but rather being kind to those of us who have anxiety. “Hi.” without any follow up can really derail a struggling person. Statistically speaking 2/10 have an ongoing mental struggle so I try not to make the “hi” transactional and immediately follow up with the point in the same message.
- senectus1 3y agoThis site is my permanent status in MS Teams... and I ignore any time someone doesn't pay attention to it.
- redler 3y agoIt could be even worse — you could have a “good morning, sunshine”er among you. Yes, just that, followed by three or four minutes of a few crawling ellipses, on and off. Then, at last: “Got a minute?”
- technion 3y agoI think the "don't do this" examples are actually some of the least egregious examples of this problem. I've got an infamous chat I here where a guy opened with "hey".. followed by a "how are you".. and like seven messages and 20 minutes later he gets to "we have a Sev1 incident, all systems down, can you look at it"?.
- TacticalCoder 3y ago> please don't say just hello in chat In a great many chat (as in one-to-many group chat as in, say, IRC -- where the 'C' stands for "chat" btw) it's perfectly okay when people join and start with just "hello". I think TFA meant to write: "please don't say just hello in PMs to coworkers". Not all chats revolves around leveraging synergies to maximize shareholders value while at work.
- farazzz 3y agoYeah, also this: > Imagine calling someone on the phone, going hello! then putting them on hold. I literally start every call with “hello” and then I pause to see if they're there…
- insickness 3y agoI do it all the time in chat. I'll say, Good Morning [name], and wait for them to respond. It seems rude to me to just blurt out what I want. If I walked up to someone in an office whom I don't normally speak with, I would first say, "Hi. How are you?" and wait for them to respond. At the very minimum, I would say hi and wait for them to say, hi back before I tell them what I'm looking for. Same thing over chat.
- JadoJodo 3y agoThe issue is that in-person, you can see the individual and whether they’re going to immediately respond (since, socially, it would be odd to delay in response to someone who is speaking to you in-person); in chat, you have no idea if I’m going to answer in 5 seconds or 5 hours. And the same for me as I wait for your response to my “Good morning to you, as well.”
- lamontcg 3y agowhat is worse are people who are just clearly trolling for someone to come help them via vaguebugging. "hey team, [although not actually on your team] is anyone seeing bugs in the latest release?" this sounds like i'm about to get sucked into a game of 20-questions, and when you've got an issue tracker with 400+ open issues there's definitely still bugs in the latest release. just spit the question out: "i'm with <client> and we're trying to do <thing> and we're getting this error message <paste error message or point at a gist/pastebin if it is long>, is this a bug or are we doing something wrong?"
- oytis 3y agoFrankly to me it's not the productivity loss, which might be minimal, but just that people who do that automatically look dumber.
- nokya 3y agoThis could be specific to French speaking culture but I am often contacted by individuals who start online conversations with either: "hi, I hope you're well." "hi, what's up?" These introductions clearly tend to trigger me as I interpret them as someone who wants to ask for something but isn't brave enough to simply ask for it so she/he keeps walking around you desperately looking for a sign of welcome. When this happens, I usually just reply with: "Hi." Then I pull out my popcorn and watch the "X is typing a reply" prompt come up then disappear, repeatedly for the next minute or two.
- palata 3y agoI often start a conversation with a colleague with "Hello, how are you?", to which they may answer "Good, thanks... just coming back from holiday, was nice". Then I can ask about their holidays, and have an actual social interaction with them. They can also say "I'm good, how about you?", to which I can answer "I'm okay, it is a bit stressful these days", and maybe we get another social interaction from that. You know... just like if I meet a colleague at the coffee machine. I don't come, say "Please review PR 1342 when you have time" and leave. Of course, if I just had coffee with that colleague, then on the chat I may just say "oh btw, did you have a chance to look into PR 1342?". I would assume those are the basics of social interactions.
- orwin 3y agoI assume it depends on the person. I would rather have a single message.
- palata 3y agoSure, I have no problem with that. I guess I just don't create a website called "pleasebepolite.net" where I explain how I like it better when people behave politely (for my definition of politeness).
- argulane 3y agoSounds a lot like cultural thing. In Scandinavian countries everyone will be much happier if you just get straight to the point. If you you want to have your PR reviewed, just ask `Hi, can you review PR 1342.` and the other person will answer `Sure, no problem`. There really is no point of fluffing up your request with random chitchat.
- thisisit 3y agoI find people routinely ignore this and still just say Hello. It’s a habit hard to get rid of. So just ignore the person saying Hello. Later I found some people complaining about how I am never available for “quick” chat.