4 ms·
I wish companies would just opensource really old engines for educational purposes. Maybe take game assets resize everything to 1/10th so that it looks like sh
by Havoc 3y ago
I wish companies would just opensource really old engines for educational purposes.
Maybe take game assets resize everything to 1/10th so that it looks like sht but can still be used as placeholder.
Would boost the pipeline of talent for the entire industry
- viktorcode 3y agoYou can take a look at Amazon Lumberyard which is free. It's based on CryEngine, which is behind Far Cry.
- nrjames 3y agoCrytek and Crysis, not Far Cry. Edit: I stand corrected, it was Crytek and the CryEngine https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Far_Cry https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Far_Cry
- rzzzt 3y agoFar Cry 2 starts to diverge from CryEngine roots with the introduction of Dunia: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ubisoft#Dunia_Engine https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ubisoft#Dunia_Engine
- badsectoracula 3y agoNote that Lumberyard became "Open 3D Engine" (yes, very inspired name) which is Apache 2 licensed: https://o3de.org/ https://o3de.org/ https://github.com/o3de/o3de/ https://github.com/o3de/o3de/ AFAIK all development in Lumberyard has ceased and moved to O3DE.
- AHTERIX5000 3y agoAnd O3DE is mostly a rewrite. It's really interesting to compare the last public CryEngine releases and O3DE for example how the rendering architecture is laid out.
- kelsolaar 3y agoJohn Carmack did a stellar job in that respect. Doom and Quake are still very much alive thanks to his decision.
- suddenclarity 3y agoEven he had some challenges with releasing Doom: > The bad news: this code only compiles and runs on linux. We couldn't release the dos code because of a copyrighted sound library we used (wow, was that a mistake -- I write my own sound code now), and I honestly don't even know what happened to the port that microsoft did to windows. I would assume it's a lot more complicated today. Even the most simple programming projects tend to have a ton of dependencies nowadays. And it doesn't even account for the fact that you might be killing future projects by handing out the blueprint of old games. Would Assassin's Creed Valhalla exist if we had 100 clones of Assassin's Creed III?
- techwiz137 3y agoStill waiting for them to release RAGE 1 source code.
- dj_mc_merlin 3y ago> Would Assassin's Creed Valhalla exist if we had 100 clones of Assassin's Creed III? Probably, unless they all had the budget to create a shit ton of new assets and replace the old ones. And the code was released with a license that allowed commercial use.
- suddenclarity 3y ago> Probably, unless they all had the budget to create a shit ton of new assets and replace the old ones. Isn't that what we're getting from AI generated content? Note, I'm not saying that a random person will create something better. I'm just saying there might be a risk of saturating the market if you can play 100 versions of the same game for free.
- 3y ago
- awestroke 3y agoOld engines are very far from the current way is doing things. You might learn a lot, but you won't learn what you need to program modern games
- danhau 3y agoIt‘s still interesting to see how certain challenges have been solved back in the day. Or as a case study in what _not_ to do today. For example, Quake‘s ingame console commands were stored in a linked list. I believe looking up a command was a linear search through that list. You wouldn‘t do it like that today.
- zelphirkalt 3y agoThe example sounds like a quite basic insight into algorithmic complexity or complexity of lookup operation of data structures. A linked list is fine, if you need or want to go through the entries sequentially anyway, but if you need random access, then you probably want something different. I can tell that without ever having looked at something like Quake's console commands implementation. However, it might have been the case, that there were not that many commands anyway, so that the linked list did not noticably slow things down.
- codetrotter 3y ago> it might have been the case, that there were not that many commands anyway, so that the linked list did not noticably slow things down. Also, unlike the game code itself which has to finish running its work in time for every frame, it probably doesn’t matter if running a command from the Quake terminal takes a little bit extra time. Would anyone notice or care about a difference in the amount of time it takes to run the /noclip command for example, in a O(n) vs O(1) lookup of the command in the probably short list of available commands? I don’t think so. Speaking for myself, if I bring up the terminal in a game like quake to run a command, I’m probably standing stationary somewhere out of danger at the moment. And the amount of time I spend to tab open the terminal and type /noclip would be much greater than the amount that the game then takes to look for that command in its list of commands.
- esperent 3y agoI guess this is legally unfeasible. Take a look at the splash screens next time you're loading a game - especially AAA but also smaller ones too. There will beone page with a bunch of logos. Havok physics is the one that comes to mind but there's loads more. Each of these is a plugin with proprietary code. They would need to be stripped out before the code could be released, which would probably be a lot of work. And then the code wouldn't run anyway. This isn't a recent thing - as another comment points out, even the original Doom ran into this problem and only the Linux source was released.
- masklinn 3y agoIt's often legally feasible but the result is difficult to get value out of (and obviously worthless for the company). For instance Frictional open-sourced their HPL engine, Penumbra: Overture, Amnesia: The Dark Descent and Amnesia: A Machine For Pigs. However the Amnesia games are built with Autodesk's FBX SDK, and I don't think they include any assets, they're not necessarily uninteresting artefacts but there's not much you can do with them either.
- torginus 3y agoI'd be fine if they put up their code with the proprietary parts removed. They can just include a FIXME stating that the physics engine/video player etc. is missing. If the community picks up the code, they can just replace the missing parts.
- ironSkillet 3y agoRemoving these proprietary parts can actually be a lot of work or potentially impossible without a major refractor, especially if they're foundational to gameplay, like a physics engine.
- skrebbel 3y agoIt can just “ERROR file physicslib.h not found”. Nobody says open source code must compile or work.
- gonzo41 3y agoAs an aside, have you played red alert lately. Holy crap. I tried a while back and it's like people have just been studying that game non stop since I was a kid. I got owned. But year totally agree. I sort of think that with a smart OS license for game IP you could put a lot of stuff into the public domain and it would flourish in really interesting ways like fan fiction.
- bombcar 3y agoSame thing with Heroes III - they talk about “breaks” and chains and things on multiplayer and it just blows me away.
- BiteCode_dev 3y agoI though I was good at starcraft before going to Battlenet, and I though I learned I wasn't. But last year I went to play HOMM3 online, and I imagined I could at least teach the kids a trick or two. I was so wrong.
- bombcar 3y agoIt's literally a completely different game from "normal" HOMM3 now, really. It's interesting watching playthroughs, and seeing the tricks used, but it's not quite the game I played 20 years ago. I did pick up some positioning tricks and tips.
- masklinn 3y ago> Maybe take game assets resize everything to 1/10th so that it looks like sht but can still be used as placeholder. The assets are commonly licensed, so you can't include them at all, or in large parts. Commonly the game data is not part of the release either.
- concordDance 3y agoWhat should really happen is a law that video games get declared public domain and have their source code released after 10 years. All assets and dependencies would get automatically released under a license allowing for their use in that game and derivatives of it. As it is, the source is mostly just lost to time, making humanity poorer.
- flohofwoe 3y agoThere's a lot of games that have a shelf life of more than a decade. Maybe make that "10 years after the game is no longer sold".
- arlcode 3y agoThat (maybe) would have worked in the olden days of physical disks or catridges. Today it is trivial to keep the game on steam with zero sales (or almost zero). If lawmakers wanted to pass a law that actually made this happen they needed to stipulate a cut off date (and potential compensation) as well as rigid rules about what one can do with the released code.
- account42 3y ago> and potential compensation Why would there be a need for compensation. Copyright is only granted in the first place so that more things will (eventually) enter the commons. Rolling back the perversion that is the current copyright terms doesn't need anything to balance it out since the current sitation is already so unbalanced in the other direction.
- concordDance 3y agoVery few and they still make 90+% of sales before then. A price worth paying
- flohofwoe 3y agoThat dynamic has changed a lot with multiplayer games which are in continuous development. For instance DayZ just hit record player numbers after nearly a decade: https://www.reddit.com/r/dayz/comments/11nlu70/recently_dayz_has_been_reaching_record_highs_in/ https://www.reddit.com/r/dayz/comments/11nlu70/recently_dayz... But even if that's an outlier, online games can have a surprisingly long tail where the game remains profitable even if the player count doesn't grow anymore (as long as the developer supports the game at least).
- grishka 3y agoIn general, open-source all abandonware. Here's a few examples of non-game old software that would benefit the society if open-sourced: Windows 9x and classic Mac OS. No one has sold these OSes for 20+ years and they turned out to be evolutionary dead ends. It would make sense to release their sources so people could learn from them and run them on new hardware more easily. Flash Player. Adobe has stated in no uncertain terms that Flash is dead. Is there any good reason why the sources need to stay closed if they aren't going to make any further gains, financial or otherwise, from this product and its ecosystem? I mean the Flash Player plugin and standalone app specifically, not the Flash authoring software — that's still alive under a new name, Adobe Animate. Trident, the Internet Explorer engine. Again, it's dead for good as far as Microsoft is concerned, so why not release its sources for people to learn and hack on? Presto, the Opera engine. This was leaked and of course I hoarded it, but it would be nice to see an official release. Winamp. The company behind it pivoted to some kind of streaming social donation thing. It does not seem interested in maintaining the old Winamp app. Path, the social media thing for "close friends", their mobile apps. The apps were insanely cool, especially at the time of Path's peak around 2013, but the service was shut down a few years ago. Unless they're going to somehow resurrect the service, there's no good reason for the sources for the apps to remain closed. I'd love to take a look at their implementation of real-time photo filters. Thinking of it, it makes more sense for non-game apps than for games to release sources. Old games do sometimes come out as "remasters" for modern platforms. These usually reuse the engine and sometimes some of the assets. Non-game software, on the other hand, when it's dead, it's usually dead for good.
- geek_at 3y agoman I wish they had open sourced OS/2. It could have a linux sized community at this point. Sadly microsoft had put so much of their code in it, that they didn't allow the release (according to my dad who worked for IBM and was even called "Mr. OS/2" because he had sold it so good to companies)
- ttfkam 3y agoOS/2 is still in use and under active development, just under a different name. https://hackaday.com/2023/02/16/arcaos-os-2-updated-for-the-modern-world/ https://hackaday.com/2023/02/16/arcaos-os-2-updated-for-the-...
- pbhjpbhj 3y agoMy own personal and private opinion is that I wish the legislation would opensource things that are not being actively sold where the owner is a corporation. You still have registration in USA, so if you register then you have to deposit, if you register with corporate ownership then you pay a yearly renewal, if you stop paying the deposit goes to public domain. Simples.
- grogenaut 3y agoAnd how much does that deposit need to be?
- pshirshov 3y agoI guess the best way woul dbe to regulate that. If you want to sell any software (including firmware) you have to deposit the sources and encryption keys into some state-owned repository. If you decided to stop maintaining the code it would be released into public domain after some reasonable grace period (e.g. 5 years). That would solve many issues including excess e-waste.
- flohofwoe 3y agoThe reason is often that those codebases are usually a giant hairball of closed source 3rd party dependencies which would be a nightmare to put under a common open source license, no matter if the companies behind those products still exist or not.
- Heinrich_zHM 3y agoOften Open-Sourcing is not an option, as they license closed source code for it. Windows for example couldn't be made open source because of licensed, closed source code blocks.
- boppo1 3y agoRIP UT2k4
- dclowd9901 3y agoI wonder if this reaches into the territory of “abandoning your copyright” though.
- rychco 3y agoAgree. I would even be happy if the game was stripped of all licensed code/assets/tools/etc. And honestly, I don't even care if it can successfully compile/run. Just having the code alone would be tremendously useful for the purpose of study.
- hinell 3y agoI think they won't as certain parts might have migrated to new engines without being changed much. Like geometry engine etc.
- rkagerer 3y agoMaybe start a non-profit whose sole mission is to buy up this old IP and release it.
- jjrh 3y agoFrom a pure archiving point of view it would be great. It's a shame how many pieces of software are already totally lost forever.