8 ms·
Radioactive spill near Richland WA worse than expected
- f6v 3y agoTerrible, just so sad. Now go make an HBO show with naked guys in the mines about it.
- burdobarde 3y ago[flagged]
- defrost 3y agoNot a highway accident spill, this is an update on yet another Hanford site spillage: The spill of highly radioactive waste beneath a building on the Hanford nuclear reservation north of Richland and near the Columbia River is both deeper and broader than anticipated. In a statement Thursday, the Department of Energy said the contamination in the soil at the Hanford 324 Building 1,000 feet from the Columbia River and a mile north of Richland is “much larger” than previously identified. Now the Department of Energy is rethinking the cleanup plan for the spill discovered 13 years ago, with work crews making preparations for the excavation of the radioactive material over the past six years. The spill of cesium and strontium in the soil beneath the 324 Building is so radioactively hot that it would be lethal to a worker on direct contact within two minutes, DOE has said previously.
- placesalt 3y agoI'm absolutely sure they've thought of this, but I do wonder why they don't just divert the rivers around it and mine the entire place like an open-pit mine. Cart the square km or two of material off to some processing location and be done with it. It'd likely cost less than what's been spent already. Again, I'm sure this has been thought of and rejected for a good reason. Still, doing it piecemeal doesn't seem to be working.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- nvy 3y agoOpen-pit mining produces dust, and in this case that dust would be heavily contaminated, and could then end up being blown away to contaminate some new site, making the problem worse.
- lostlogin 3y agoAdditionally radiation combined with rain and snow in an open mine would add a new twist to a known problem when mining.
- defrost 3y ago> and mine the entire place like an open-pit mine. That bit specifically evokes memories of choking clouds of dust having to be sprayed down to reduce the worst of it but still creating plumes of air borne particles spreading and settling over surrounding areas. Now with the addition of post WWII nuclear weapons refining by products.
- pugworthy 3y ago[flagged]
- brazzledazzle 3y agoYou double commented. Just a heads up.
- pugworthy 3y agoI don’t think you quite appreciate how big the Columbia River is there, or what the terrain is like.
- locusofself 3y agoYep, absolutely massive river running through basalt rock. Vantage WA might as well be the Grand Canyon.
- lolinder 3y agoTo clarify, it's not a new spill, it's the same spill from 13 years ago, it's just that they have learned it was worse than previously thought. (Your quotation mentions this but your summary says "yet another", which makes it sound like this is new)
- cipheredStones 3y agoFurthermore, it's a spill discovered 13 years ago which happened in the 80s.
- joshstrange 3y agoFor those of us that still inexplicably use 2000 as a pin in time which we compare dates to: The 80s were not 20 years ago, they were 40 years ago (34-43). 13 years ago was 2010. I read that and went "Ok, so it wasn't known about for the first ~7 years, not great, not terrible" but no, it was ~30 years.
- defrost 3y agoApologies, by "yet another" I meant "just another" of the plethora of Hanford issues that still persist .. you're correct that there a very few new issues coming to light, I recall decades of stories of known issues being updated to reveal they're a bit a worse than earlier stated .. which is a by product of sending teams in to poke about and fix things I guess.
- seanmcdirmid 3y agoMy dad worked here in the late 1970s on the commercial reactor on-site (still operational, we lived in West Richland). This led to a lifelong career for him in the nuclear industry, but he died at 70 of bile duct cancer. There was a class action settlement from the DOE that we somehow auto-qualified for after his death since the cancer might have been related to his work there (but after Hanford he worked at plants in many different places, supposedly they had better standards).
- cco 3y agoNot an uncommon story in South Eastern Washington I'm afraid. Sorry for your loss.
- seanmcdirmid 3y agoThat fits my dad as he was born and raised in Walla Walla. I’m not sure how common it is though, I left the region after first grade.
- vel0city 3y agoSo, what happened here? What kind of spill happened? There's such little public info easily available about this it seems, but maybe I'm just bad at searching late at night.
- zamfi 3y agoLeak in a stainless steel floor let radioactive stuff into the ground under the site.
- vel0city 3y agoBut like why was there all this radioactive stuff all over the floor all these years? That's my real question. What actually happened in this room? Why was there all this stuff going down a sump?
- zamfi 3y agoSeems like they were doing some work in there, and some stuff spilled. They probably cleaned it up, and then discovered a crack some of the spilled stuff leaked through?
- defrost 3y ago> the 324 Building operated from 1966 to 1996 and supported research on highly radioactive materials. There are many possible research activities that take under fume hoods in chemistry labs and hot cells in radiation labs. At Hanford scientists were interested in both charting the radioactive decay breakdowns and half lives of elements ( a huge tree of branches and possibilities ) and in weapons development - studying the properties of various clumps of matter wrt how well they absorbed particles, emmitted particles, focused particles, etc. When (for example) milling a disc of material, there will be waste, when using beakers, they will be flushed and washed out .. all this leads to material going down a drain and into a holding sump. Ideally the sumps are cleaned out, even when hazardous, but eventually many sumps will crack and leak material. Several Hanford sumps leaked - as did multitudes of Hanford waste barrels. People were pretty much learning and developing procedures on the flay in these early days of atomic fever.
- hindsightbias 3y agoHanford, the gift that keeps giving… I knew NukeE’s in the 80’s whose best offers were Hanford. They’re probably still there. If you want a forever job, study Nuclear Engineering.
- seanmcdirmid 3y agoMy dad’s contract with Westinghouse at Hanford ended in 1980 or 1981 (definitely he was not there in 1982). He got contracts in New Jersey, Louisiana, Michigan, but was unemployed for a year when the entire nuclear industry imploded in 1985-86 because they stopped building new nuclear power plants. He eventually got an FTE job in Mississippi of all places, and the pay was much lower than we were used to (also our family declared chapter 7 bankruptcy because of the unemployment leading to a house that got foreclosed). Don’t go into nuclear engineering if you want a good job in a nice location (they never build nuke plants in nice places!). The only places providing nuclear engineers are the navy and overseas (universities got rid of the NE programs in the 90s), it isn’t considered a nice job, and the pay is just so so (unless you are contracting, but then your job isn’t stable). Also kids if you do good on your ASVAB, and a Navy recruiter wants you to sign up to be a nuke, just say no unless you really really want to do it.
- lostlogin 3y ago> they never build nuke plants in nice places! I think you have it around the wrong way. The plant is what makes the place undesirable. Isolated and uninhabited is quite appealing.
- seanmcdirmid 3y agoTell me how Grand Gulf nuclear power station makes Port Gibson MS a nice place to live (my dad took a 1.5 hour commute to live in Vicksburg instead)? Honestly, the nicest place we ever lived was the Tri cities when my dad worked at Hanford.
- lostlogin 3y ago
- arcastroe 3y agoLooks like this risks contaminating the Columbia River which passes through Portland, Oregon. Does Seattle need to be worried? Asking for a friend
- seanmcdirmid 3y agoThe Columbia passes north of Portland, and no water from the Columbia should flow down to it (since everything is draining out through the Columbia into the pacific), while Seattle is far enough away that it isn’t an issue. Vancouver WA is the only biggish (but not very big) city down stream from the tri-cities (plus lots of really pretty towns on the gorge). The spill is 1000 feet away from the river so there isn’t any immediate danger yet. They’ll just dig it out probably?
- hinkley 3y agoExcept of course that everyone in Seattle east salmon and the Columbia is once again a salmon river is it not? Cesium replaces potassium readily, which is part of why the Bikini atoll is still so dangerous. So there’s that.
- rcme 3y agoIsn’t salmon usually caught in the ocean near the river’s mouth? The closer salmon get to spawning, the worse they taste. And it’s hard to get a large ship up the river. This seems like it would be more of an issue for trout fisherman, especially because trout are full time residents of the river.
- seanmcdirmid 3y agoSalmon aren’t allowed to be caught in the river barring treaty exceptions (so tribes can do it), also grizzly bears will eat salmon going up to spawn, but they aren’t a problem on the Columbia.
- hinkley 3y ago
- scythe 3y ago>Radioactivity in the contaminated soil has been measured at 8,900 rad per hour. Ah, Gell-Mann amnesia, how I forget thee. The rad is a unit of radiation exposure, or "dose"; it measures how much radiation impacted a target (such as you). The appropriate way to characterize radiation in soil would be curies (properly terabecquerels, but we still use curies because of course we do) per kilogram. This is a material property, while the radiation "dose" is a function of distance (and angular position -- a "geometry" factor). However, it does correctly correspond to the stated risk to personnel. 8900 rad per hour would indeed deliver a lethal dose of radiation within a few minutes.
- dkbrk 3y agoThis isn't that egregious. I mean, yes, you're technically correct, but it's easy to mentally translate "radioactivity in the contaminated soil..." to "the radioactivity in the contaminated soil is such that it would deliver 8,900 rad/hour to a worker standing in its vicinity" (or something along those lines). It's entirely understandable that the reporters didn't go through whatever awkward and pedantic phrasing they technically should have. And while Ci is technically the right measurement for "amount of radioactivity", that's not a measurement that's useful for general consumption. Giving the expected dose and dimensions of the contaminated soil is vastly more effective at communicating the severity of the contamination.
- ekianjo 3y ago> it's entirely understandable that the reporters It's entirely possible that the reporters dont know shit about radioactivity too
- locusofself 3y agoI have a joke t-shirt that says Hanford on it, with cartoon family that has a two-headed dog, and the skeletons glow in the dark.
- jansan 3y agoWhere does that meme with mutations from radioactivity come from? Was it propaganda from the anti nuclear power lobby or has something like this actually been observed after the expossure to radiation?
- blueprint 3y agoradioactivity causes mutations in germ cell dna which causes more obviously mutated offspring, but just the same, enough radioactivity would change enough of your cells' dna to see something. it's just that it would probably be cancer and burns.
- ofalkaed 3y agoIt goes back to at least the 50s, Japan had a thing for giant mutant monsters resulting from the bombs, Godzilla and all that fun stuff. I have never encountered anyone using mutants as a talking point for an anti-nuclear agenda.
- nottorp 3y agoAnd then it devolved into Hollywood genetics. You know, when something rewrites your genetic code and as a result you grow an extra head in a 30 second scene.
- jansan 3y agoThere was quite a popular Austrian band who had some political songs, and one was about a man living near a nuclear power plant. Due do an accident at the power plant their son had six ears, mushrooms on the head, glowed in the dark, etc. That is the only example that I can come up with right now, but I have heard risk of mutations mentioned as a result of nuclear energy over and over again. Here is the song (German): https://www.verunsicherung.de/diskografie/songs/burli.html https://www.verunsicherung.de/diskografie/songs/burli.html
- PeterStuer 3y ago"the building currently is in a safe and stable configuration" Just like they said all previous times. First took them decades to 'discover' there had been 'accidents'. Then they 'just let it sit' for another 7 years, before being forced to do 'something' because the building was planned to be demolished. Then they try to jungle-rig together some contraptions that might scoop out the spill without too much cost Then it takes them another 5 years to accidentaly stumble upon the spill not being so contained as they 'hoped'. But hey, trust them. This time they promise its all safe and stable. Once again. This is the same comedy capers fly by night operations we see time and time again in each human endeavour. Yet somehow, the nuclear lobby wants us to believe they are exempt from human failty, despite being disproven time and time again. Nuclear power might be great, but humankind just can't handle the responsabilities.
- 7e 3y agoThis spill occurred 40 years ago. Humans are capable of improvement over time. Look at airline safety, for example.
- bmitc 3y ago> Look at airline safety, for example. Like the Boeing 737 Max?
- qup 3y agoNo, like the aggregate
- CTDOCodebases 3y agoIt may sound heartless but we can make new people. We can’t make an uninhabitable environment habitable.
- KSPAtlas 3y agoWell technically, space is an uninhabitable environment and people can temporarily live there fine
- explaininjs 3y agoThis is the site I always point to when the pro-nuc crowd likes to tout how safe nuclear energy is. Sure this is weapons, but I’d be a whole lot more confident in our ability to handle nuclear waste if we didn’t have a ~100 year old active ongoing nuclear disaster that we can’t manage to fix and we don’t even know the full extent of. Once we demonstrate ability to clean this mess up, maybe then we might be able to trust ourselves with future nuclear projects.
- junofan 3y agoWhat does a spill of cesium and strontium at a research site have to do with nuclear power generation?
- nikanj 3y ago[flagged]
- perihelions 3y agoThe research that caused the spill was in support of nuclear power generation—for testing vitrification of spent nuclear fuel for geologic burial. From OP: - "In the 1980s one of the building’s six hot cells was being used to prepare concentrated radioactive cesium and strontium from Hanford plutonium-production waste for Germany to use for testing of a repository for radioactive waste." (And speaking generally, it's a type of work that's representative of closed nuclear fuel cycles: a type of work that'd you want to see a lot *more of*, if you want seriously to expand the nuclear fission economy. I'm no flavor of anti-nuclear; but let's not reflexively dismiss interesting discussions of technological risk—let's not fall into that polarization trap).
- junofan 3y agoI mean, it’s research. Expect fuckups.
- nebalee 3y agoI think the poster is very clear that their objection is about how nuclear waste is handled, not where it came from.
- perihelions 3y agoThis is, astonishingly, more cesium than Fukushima released. This must have been the entire inventory of multiple nuclear reactors accumulated over years. - "In October 1986, a spill of a highly radioactive waste stream containing cesium (137Cs) and strontium (90Sr) occurred in the B-Cell of the 324 Building in the 300 Area of the Hanford Site. The spill is estimated to have contained approximately 1.3 million curies of radioactivity. An unknown fraction of this spill was lost to the subsurface through a leak in the sump in the floor of B-Cell." https://www.pnnl.gov/main/publications/external/technical_reports/PNNL-21214.pdf https://www.pnnl.gov/main/publications/external/technical_re... ("Numerical Modeling of 90Sr and 137Cs Transport from a Spill in the B-Cell of the 324 Building, Hanford Site 300 Area")
- HPsquared 3y agoI'm amazed there can be such a large spill, at a highly monitored site no less, that goes mostly unnoticed.
- merpnderp 3y agoNuclear weapons sites had a lot more leeway from regulation and oversight than nuclear power sites.
- lazide 3y agoIt probably was - nuclear weapon fuel production and processing was mostly done at Hanford, and the things they’ve done to do it quickly and ‘easily’ have been pretty horrifying. Being able to classify everything has helped.
- jokowueu 3y agoWait is this the same spill they discovered about 13 years ago which happened in the 80's ? The head line made it look like something new happen and got scared for a second
- fluxem 3y agoWhere are all the people that say nuclear energy is cheap, totally safe and fool proof except for one time having an unsafe design or another time building it on a shore for water access or building it in the future war zone or …?
- kevingadd 3y agoI suspect most nuclear energy advocates are not necessarily advocates of manufacturing nuclear weapons, which AFAIK is the source of this spill. See https://www.hanford.gov/page.cfm/AboutHanfordCleanup https://www.hanford.gov/page.cfm/AboutHanfordCleanup
- fsh 3y agoFrom the article: In the 1980s one of the building’s six hot cells was being used to prepare concentrated radioactive cesium and strontium from Hanford plutonium-production waste for Germany to use for testing of a repository for radioactive waste. Hanford was used for weapons manufacturing, but the research project was on nuclear energy (Germany never had a nuclear weapons program).
- lockhouse 3y ago> (Germany never had a nuclear weapons program) Technically they did, but I know what you meant (not since World War 2)... https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/German_nuclear_weapons_program https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/German_nuclear_weapons_program
- karaterobot 3y agoThis isn't good, but it's an old spill, and not even one we just learned about. And, it doesn't change the fact that nuclear energy is without doubt incredibly safe, nor the likelihood that our world would be better off today if we weren't so irrationally scared by it, or so unforgiveably willing to overlook the millions of deaths from fossil fuel pollution every year.
- Georgelemental 3y ago
- andrew_eu 3y agoNot so long ago I read an excellent book, Plutopia [0], which went into detail about the development and management of Hanford. Alongside that story, it tells a parallel narrative about Ozersk -- a similarly polluted nuclear town in Russia. The book does an impressive job at building an intuition to the dangers of radioactive waste for non-technical readers. At the same time, it is not terribly uplifting to realize that environmental destruction was/is treated as an afterthought. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Plutopia https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Plutopia
- DebtDeflation 3y ago>The bottom of the cell is about 42 feet above groundwater. >PNNL confirmed the findings of the Hanford contractors that the spill was both broader and deeper than thought when the plan to excavate it from within the hot cell was developed. Not a comforting thought. I hope they are actually monitoring groundwater radiation levels.
- KSPAtlas 3y agoThis is also another reason why nuclear waste reprocessing should be more common, theoretically there should be less distance to transport
- fsh 3y agoThe accident happened during processing, not during transport.
- Garvi 3y agoInteresting how fake stories about Chinese balloons can linger in US media for weeks, fuelling racist ideologies, while actually vital stories like this are almost completely censored out of the public eye. There's the us-vs-them mentality, then there's the repeatedly shooting oneself in the foot and blaming others mentality.
- 88j88 3y agoI must have missed the fake stories. I just saw the ones about a school bus sized metal structure hovering over the US sent by China, endangering people below it.
- Garvi 3y agoYes, I have just searched through CNNs archives. Apparently CNN has never accused China of using balloons to spy on the US. Apparently we were always at war with Eurasia.
- merpnderp 3y agoIt’s not racist to assume giant ballon structures sent over your secure sites by a country with 500 nuclear weapons pointed at you and a whole military complex devoted to war with you, might be spying. It’s pretty crazy to just assume they aren’t.
- Garvi 3y agoI would argue that quite the opposite is the case. I'm sorry we disagree on such a basic level. My argument: weather balloons exist and have for decades; US authorities knew right away there was no spying equipment,because they had access to the craft, and mislead the public; US authorities lied about the weather balloon flying directly above an important US military base; the pentagon just admitted there was no spying equipment; we are also now ignoring the 5 other incidents of accusations of spying-by-balloon and shooting down of objects that followed. I just reread your comment. You believe China has a "whole military complex devoted to war with the US". I would be very interested in where you got these ideas?
- adius 3y agoThis is the headline for everybody who’s wondering why Germany is so anti nuclear …
- panick21_ 3y ago... I'm still wondering.