4 ms·
US public debt projected to reach 181% of economic activity in 30 years
- superkuh 3y agoThis is literally the inevitable conclusion of any economic system based on fractional reserve banking where chartered banks are able to produce new currency from nothing on their balance sheets as debt. There will never be enough money supply (M0) to pay off debt. And unlike more civilized cultures like the ancient Babylonians we don't have periodic jubilees for debt forgiveness for human people.
- karpierz 3y agoGiven that society has relied on fractional reserve banking since the 1600s, what is the alternative banking process you had in mind?
- jesusofnazarath 3y ago[dead]
- creatonez 3y agoYou don't necessarily need to switch off of such a system. But you do need to properly characterize it, rather than having nobel prize winning economists (and crappy news articles like this) get twisted into a pretzel trying to maintain incorrect dogmas about how it works.
- dragontamer 3y agoEhhh... I don't like either of your characterizations. USA started on... very chaotic period. Continental Dollar was a failure in 1780s and the citizenry largely used the Spanish Peso, at least until the next Dollar came out IIRC. Eventually US Banking solidified upon the dual-standard of silver and gold. But... not really? A lot of those banks didn't actually hold that physical silver or gold, it was all virtual notes and paper pretending to be silver or gold. (Is this fractional reserve banking but on the silver standard? Depends on who you ask) In the 1880s (if I got that right), the Silver standard was eradicated and the USA was largely on the gold standard. We were in a pretty turbulent time regardless, until the big-whammy hit in 1930s. While "technically" on the Gold standard, FDR then issued Executive Order 6102 making gold illegal. Simultaneously, from the 1910s in this period, the US banking system was transitioning to the modern Federal Reserve system. I'm not sure exactly when fractional reserve banking hit in the Federal Reserve system, but I remember some important laws passing in the 1930s as well. Its all a moving target and difficult to say "X happened" at a particular point of history. It was all happening at the same time. Different banks, different parts of the country, different states were in a complex web of Silver, Gold, dollars, independent notes, and so forth. I'd personally say by the 1930s, with Gold becoming literally illegal, was when the USA fully transitioned into fractional reserve banking for the masses. Gold remained illegal until Nixon re-legalized it in the 1970s, but also finally removed gold from officially backing our currency (granted: with Gold being illegal, it didn't practically back our currency anymore for decades, so Nixon just made Gold float to the market rate and match reality, as opposed to pretending that we had a gold-backed system). But that's just my opinion on the matter. Others can draw lines in the sand and almost arbitrarily argue any of these points we were "doing fractional reserve banking", or "on the gold standard", or whatever.
- superkuh 3y agoBecause fractional reserve banking is the least worst way and it's very unlikely to change we have to acknowledge this power bias and mitigate it. If chartered consumer bank is creating new M0 money supply as debt through loans or other processes it should not be legally allowed to be involved in stock and other market investments. Deposit and investment banks should not legally be allowed to mix. The immense profits and power to create new currency as debt should not have all it's incentives and value siphoned off into non-productive market manipulations and vehicles. In the USA this is one first step, one we've taken before in recent history, that needs to be taken again to mitigate the centralized (~4k chartered banks in the USA) money supply creation issue of fractional reserve banking.
- ethbr0 3y ago"stock and market investments" vs other uses of money (e.g. loans) is a difficult distinction Presumably this would just look like deposit banks only ever... what? Buying US government debt?
- NoMoreNicksLeft 3y agoI've tried very hard these past few decades to understand what fractional reserve banking is without spiraling into becoming some whackjob conspiracy theorist. Can someone tell me if this is substantially wrong? Through some combination of poorly chosen policies in centuries past, social inertia, and perhaps even a little ignorance even on the part of the experts, we now have a society that has normalized the idea that banks get to authorize people (and companies) to receive resources they don't currently have enough cash to purchase outright. When they authorize this, they pay the seller with imaginary money that they say they have (but don't really have). Thus the seller is (most of the time) made whole. In return for this authorization, the borrowers pay the bank that principal back, along with interest. In some more conservative ways of thinking, interest is the idea that when a lender risks his or her money loaning it to you, they should receive compensation for that risk. But the bank didn't have the money to loan to them either. Whether this means the bank is taking less risk, or more risk, I can't even properly process at this point... but regardless of any hypothetical risk that it might be taking, what the interest really is for is nothing more than the fee for them authorizing that the person/company receive those resources. On that point I'm quite certain, the interest pays that "fee". I do not believe this is a particularly biased take on the matter. I don't believe I've injected much politics into it. I think this system (such as it is) has arisen organically, and without much in the way of design or any group steering it to this. It seems quite insane to me. Beyond the bounds of mere lunacy. Lovecraft never spoke of eldritch abominations so horrifying that they might cause a madness as profound as this. Why are we allowing banks to do this? I get it that society needs someone to do this function. But... 1. Why are banks and their staff the most qualified to undertake the function? 2. How did legislatures and even monarchs ever allow this particular power to slip away from them, without even so much as a debate about why they couldn't be trusted to do it? 3. Even if we need this functionality, how do we know how often it should happen (and for whom), and why would this system both keep it from happening not enough and from happening too much? Especially since banks are incentivized to lend as much as possible in many (maybe even all) circumstances? Isn't this sort of like putting the crackhead in charge of the medicine locker key? 4. Why is no one talking about it in this way? Maybe I'm just fucked in the head, but I've never heard it explained like this, and it makes me wonder if I've got it all wrong. But none of the extant explanations are less crazy-sounding, not that I've ever found.
- sebzim4500 3y ago>we don't have periodic jubilees for debt forgiveness for human people. How would that even work? Why would you ever repay debt if you could just wait for it to be forgiven?
- quickthrower2 3y agoAlso you would need to technically zero out all positive bank accounts, since they are debt owed to people by the bank.
- detourdog 3y agoThis might not be a banking system. This might be part of a social system. A civil society used to have more value than a functioning banking system. There were also ideas that the corner of the ones crop fields couldn't be harvested. These corners should be for people with nothing and the bests of the land.
- quickthrower2 3y agoYes. I think before modern money, cancelling out debts would be simpler (just throw some runes in the sea, or whatever), and they didn't even have mortgages. But now everything is debt and everything is financialized, including the debt itself. I reckon cancelling debt would be great for the rich who are probably leveraged to the hilt to avoid selling anything, to avoid taxes. It would be decent for the middle class who keep their houses debt free. And bad for poor people, who just get this months payday loan wiped out, so they can afford that car repair, and still need to pay rent. House prices would double, due to serviceability increases, so they have less chance of owning!
- BitwiseFool 3y agoAnd on the flip side, why would you ever loan money to someone if you knew you would be forced to forgive some portion of it?
- detourdog 3y agoIt's a really old idea that if you haven't gotten your value back by x period of years give up the value is gone. It could be that it's older cultures that operated this way. The idea is that a loan turns into slavery at some point and that is unacceptable. There is also the aspect that if you could go this long without the loan being repaid you have enough already.
- nine_zeros 3y agoThis. If the only way for more money (credit) to come into existence is debt, then someone will have to keep taking debt. For past debts to be paid off, more debt needs to be created. How exactly is this a stable system? Who the fuck thought this would last?
- DirkH 3y agoI mean, it will last long enough for the generation who started it to get rich off of it? Right?
- detourdog 3y ago30 years is too far out to make sense.
- ur-whale 3y ago> 30 years is too far out to make sense. You're correct. It's very likely to be far worse than that.
- bagels 3y agoIs that really that problematic? Most households have more debt (mortgage) than their yearly economic output.
- rjbwork 3y agoMost households with a mortgage are also not, on a yearly basis, severely outspending their income. The problem is not necessarily the debt - it's the debt plus the deficit.
- onlyrealcuzzo 3y agoIt's probably a problem if you're borrowing money and getting nothing in return and making future generations pay for it. It's subjective if you think our borrowed spending is causing more harm than good.
- tvchurch 3y agoAlways hard to put these number in perspective. Here's the one that worries me: Interest payments on the debt are projected to grow to 6.7 percent of GDP in thirty years (right now they're 1.9 percent and Social Security outlays are 4.9 percent). Deficits are projected to be 10 percent of GDP then, meaning 2/3rds of our borrowing will be done to pay off existing borrowing. That's not good.
- sokoloff 3y agoIt’s not like the latter division is an obviously stable way to analyze the issue. If we just ran a larger deficit, say 27% of GDP, that ratio would be (temporarily) much lower at only 25% of new borrowing. But that wouldn’t be obviously “better”.
- landoftheice 3y ago[dead]
- blindriver 3y agoJapan debt to GDP ratio is already over 220% public debt. The best thing about it is that the Fed holds most of that debt so they kind of monetized it with no major repercussions. Modern Monetary Theory has stated that high public debt loads isn't a problem, and frankly so far it doesn't seem like the markets will ever care. Until it does, and then it will be a disaster but both Japan and the US will never pay off its debts.
- onlyrealcuzzo 3y ago> The best thing about it is that the Fed holds most of that debt so they kind of monetized it with no major repercussions. You mean beside a lost 30 years, one of the lowest rates of family formation, and a high rate of suicide among young people? Sure.
- 40acres 3y agoWhat does that have to do with the debt?
- EA-3167 3y agoThey're talking about the US Fed, aka the US debt, and now you're talking about Japan. Anyway lets be real, the reason why sudden think pieces on the debt are coming out is that it's going to be election season soon, and a Democrat is the incumbent.
- onlyrealcuzzo 3y agoOP was talking about Japan having 220% public debt to GDP - which is what I was responding to.
- BitwiseFool 3y agoRed Team and Blue Team both pearl clutch about the national debt when it is politically expedient for them to do so. Remember all the hullabaloo about the national debt clock back when it needed an extra digit around 2008?
- 3y ago
- stainablesteel 3y agothe only thing i can predict in 30 years is that people will still be breathing, and that just makes me honest
- steelframe 3y ago> the only thing i can predict in 30 years is that people will still be breathing Whoa whoa whoa -- let's not get carried away there, Mr. Optimistic-pants.
- quickthrower2 3y agoAnd the AIs will be multiplying matrices.
- kortex 3y agoI get that countries don't exactly operate like a family budget, but can someone explain what the intended steady state is? There's only really three options: pay it off, keep it at the current debt level (or keep it steady at some percent level), or continuing to let it grow, and it seems like the first two options aren't (credibly) on the table.
- dkjaudyeqooe 3y agoYou missed what the US actually does: it grows its economy until the debt is insignificant. The US has never (in modern times) substantially reduced its debt level in dollar terms.
- quickthrower2 3y agoSo the US is like a Google or Amazon, always growing? And so it can take on more debt.
- kortex 3y agoI get that, but isn't the debt/GDP ratio in general also growing?
- dkjaudyeqooe 3y agoYes, at the moment, but the trick is to grow your economy faster than your debt. The US has managed to do that in the long term.
- BXlnt2EachOther 3y agoyes, it has doubled from 65% of GDP to 130% of GDP in the last 15 years (GFC and pandemic). Click 50Y or Max time scales for more history: https://tradingeconomics.com/united-states/government-debt-to-gdp https://tradingeconomics.com/united-states/government-debt-t... This has been growing faster than CBO projections, though obviously the last few years were unique (hopefully). Found a graph from the 2015 CBO report that is still in a wikipedia article that projected we'd be at about 75% debt/GDP now[1]. Another article from 2020 as pandemic aid spending was going out warned we could hit 106% by this year. IIUC there's not a line that we must not cross, but the level, the rate, and the can-kicking on all this debt spending, and debt in general, worries me (even as someone who leans to the left and supports big government projects). [1] https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:FederalDebt1940to2015.svg https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:FederalDebt1940to201...
- raincom 3y agoAs long foreign countries swap their real assets (oil, grains, metals, manufactured goods, etc) with printed US dollars (nominal assets), they can increase (print) public debt (more dollars). That's why it is important for the US to have USD as the global currency, thereby giving an ability to print whatever money needed. This luxury is not available for most of the countries. That's the crux of modern monetary theory.
- ur-whale 3y ago> This luxury is not available for most of the countries. And it's increasingly likely that it won't be available to the US for much longer. The fact that the US weaponized their currency during the Ukraine / Russia war has not gone unnoticed by most non-western economies. The first couple of chinks in the US armor are: - BRICS countries setting up an alternative payment system to SWIFT - China offering to buy oil directly in yuan and guaranteeing that any excessive yuan balance would be settle in actual gold - a deal that has been accepted by Saudi Arabia. - China negotiating with ASEAN countries to trade goods directly for yuan, with the same excessive balance guaranteed to be paid in gold. - Many countries are starting to diversify they foreign exchange reserve away from the USD, incorporating Yuans, Euros, and - yes - rubles (which can be used to purchase all kinds of useful raw materials from Russia, the largest landmass country on earth)
- TMWNN 3y ago>- Many countries are starting to diversify they foreign exchange reserve away from the USD, incorporating Yuans, Euros, and - yes - rubles (which can be used to purchase all kinds of useful raw materials from Russia, the largest landmass country on earth) At 58.4%, the US dollar's share of global currency reserves is comparable to that in 1995 and 1985. It has declined from its 21st-century high, but so has the Euro. The renminbi has more than doubled ... from 1.1 to 2.7%.<https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Reserve_currency#Global_currency_reserves https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Reserve_currency#Global_curren...>
- ralusek 3y agoIt seems as though national debt has transitioned from something that ever needs to be paid off to instead just being a graph of inflation. The Fed holds the majority of the US Debt, and that will likely increasingly be the case. Governments don't need to tax anymore, they simply generate the money they need by borrowing from the reserve. There is no longer any expectation that this will ever be paid back. The debt is really nothing more than a graph showing the expansion of the money supply, and the interest rate is nothing more than the vector of where the debt is going.
- mensetmanusman 3y agoWe spent like the population would continue to grow. Wups!
- imchillyb 3y agoThe debt will accrue debt, which will require debt to pay. This is, of course, occurring currently we’re just talking about a sliding scale now. A debt for our children’s children’s children to worry over. Nothing to see here. Move along citizen.
- 40acres 3y agoSomeone framed debt to gdp ratio like this: if your debt is 150% of your GDP. It would take a year and a half to pay off your debt if all the national income (gdp) was allocated to payments. No obviously this isn’t a realistic policy - but if we can have “war-time” economies as proven in the past it reasons that we can have an economy solely focused on the repayment of debt (idk, high taxes for a decade?). Am I tripping?
- onlyrealcuzzo 3y agoYou're tripping if you think everyone is going to give all their output for a year to pay for debt without a revolution. Almost half of households have less than $1000 in savings. How are they making it through the whole year without income? How are all the old people who live off social security making it without 5% of GDP set aside to finance their lives?
- jandrese 3y agoMaybe a better comparison is to a post war economy? The US paid off the WW2 debt in about 17 years through ordinary taxation, but US taxes today are much lower than they were after WW2, at least for the very rich.
- detourdog 3y agoIf one looks at the national debt clock I think we each owe just $300k. In these terms it seems quite manageable. My guess is that if it was an actual problem we would solve it. My guess is that it is mostly a talking point.
- oatmeal1 3y agoI'm guessing 300% in 30 years. There's always going to be another crisis that 'demands' short term spending boosts.
- youniverse 3y agoI watched this recent interview with Stanley Druckenmiller (one of the best macro investors with an incredible track record) on more problems we will be facing in a few years. Mainly about how the US is not going to be able to pay for our older generations healthcare unless taxes get hiked to obscene levels. And that these predictions they made years ago are coming to fruition slowly but that their predictions of course could not predict the wild COVID spending that occurred. Future looks interesting to be sure! https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=53wThFFuOqU https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=53wThFFuOqU
- Hermitian909 3y agoI think something shown in the ideological hand here is that the tax hikes are framed as regressive tax hikes. You can make up a significant portion of the gap by adopting the sort of progressive taxes we had pre Reagan. There's also probably substantial savings to be had by moving to a single payer healthcare system which I think we should expect in the coming decades - support creeps up every single year.
- detourdog 3y agoFew people discuss that a large part of the 2008 auto company bailout was simply becuase our retirement and healthcare plans are so inefficient. Essentially the auto companies need relief from the retirement plans to compete with countries with civilized policies. The way congress works against the populous on this issue puts the individuals and the businesses at a disadvantage globally.
- detourdog 3y agoWas there a definition of obscene? Many of the money TV panelists find almost any tax obscene.
- greesil 3y agoBut not the cost to service the debt. Sorta misleading headline.
- mindvirus 3y agoUS debt is such a tough thing to wrap my head around. About half of the debt is to... the US government. And all of it is in US dollars, that the US government can print. So the US could get out of debt tomorrow if they wanted, forgiving the loans it made to itself, and then printing enough to pay off the rest. Which presumably wouldn't impact its ability to lend money to itself. The tough part for me to wrap my head around is why the debt is important at all, given the US is more or less fully in control of it.
- option 3y ago«forgiving the loans it made to itself”. Wouldn’t something like that mean that some ex-gov employees won’t get their pensions?
- mindvirus 3y agoYes, but what makes it so weird is it's one pie. Like, imagine you made up "hacker dollars", which you can make more of whenever you want. They're sticky notes with a number written on them. Then you lent "hacker dollars" to yourself, at a 4% interest. So borrower you creates new "hacker dollars" to pay the lender you interest. If you wanted, you could just say that you forgive the loan you made to yourself, and pay the "hacker dollars" directly. If anything, it seems like a complex accounting system more than anything related to credit card debt or mortgages.
- conductr 3y agoI think this quirk is easier to wrap your head around if you think of the consequences of doing it. Modern economics have baffled me at times, but I’d fully expect our currency to be extremely devalued if they did that. Currency holders would end up paying for it as they couldn’t purchase as much.
- seanmcdirmid 3y agoMany of the loans made to itself are wrapped up in pension funds, SSI, lots of future expenses to cover, etc...so just forgiving the loans wouldn't help much unless you want a bunch of angry old people rioting on the street. Another way of thinking about it is the US deficit is high because savings needs are also high. It isn't just a "we need to spend more money", it is also a "we need to borrow more money" (due to lots of savings demand). The problem is that we aren't using those savings needs productively enough, so we are still going to get hit in the future. China also has a similar problem, but one could argue that they are leveraging savings needs effectively through lots of infrastructure and other capital projects. BUT Japan went that route as well, and it didn't work out too well for them.
- brookst 3y agoI’m old enough to remember when the debt was expected to be paid off in less than 10 years: https://clintonwhitehouse4.archives.gov/textonly/WH/new/html/Fri_Dec_29_151111_2000.html https://clintonwhitehouse4.archives.gov/textonly/WH/new/html... Not that I’m a doomer, just saying it is normal for people to project what will happen if nothing changes, even while we all know things will change.
- anders_p 3y agoRepublicans haven't really cared about paying off the debts since before Regan. (Except for when they're not in power). So it wasn't actually the norm when Clinton tried to make a dent in the foreign debts of the US. Modern economic theory says that there's a big difference between normal household finances and national economics. Countries don't reach retirement age, they get new taxpayers every year. (Either through births or immigration). So there's essentially no limit to how many times they can roll the debts over via issuing new state-backed bonds, except for how the market views the country's future prospects. That's the theory, at least.
- detourdog 3y agoDo you remember after Clinton when the budget was balanced. The Soviet Union had collapsed.
- VWWHFSfQ 3y agoThere's no such thing as "publicly held debt" in USA. USA borrows immense amounts of money from foreign economies (China and others) with no intention whatsoever to ever pay the principal back. Happy to just pay the interest for all of eternity. On and on in perpetuity forever. USA spends a huge portion of the money that it borrows on its military. If those countries ever want to "call" their money back then they will face USA's military if the negotiations deteriorate to that level.
- seanmcdirmid 3y ago> USA borrows immense amounts of money from foreign economies (China and others) with no intention whatsoever to ever pay the principal back. That isn't true. US treasuring notes are in demand because they are incredibly reliable. The US doesn't default on them, so they are safe places to stash billions of dollars that you might not want floating around in your economy (which is why China is such an enthusiastic customer for US Treasuries). > USA spends a huge portion of the money that it borrows on its military. US spending on military is 3.1% of GDP, expected to go to 2.3% by 2033. The US is not borrowing from other economies to fund its military, they don't have to. If that number starts creeping up (like to say 10% of GDP), bad things will happen. But if other countries stop lending us money, we aren't really going to be in trouble at all (we just stop selling treasuries, our military is funded as a part of American production, it isn't using much production from China). In comparison, China spends 2.7% of its GDP on its military, so not far off from the USA, although the PLA is sort of entangled in the private economy, so it isn't so clear.
- jl2718 3y agoThey talk about tax revenues as if that’s a relevant component of bond market cash flows. It’s not. I have an easy solution for bringing it down to any number you want: more government spending, the more wasteful the better. You see, government spending is part of that ‘economic activity’ number. In fact, certain types of especially wasteful spending require purchases that guarantee it will count for double in that number. Of course this creates more debt, so every year you have to create enough money to increase your spending by a huge factor, but it works in the formula used here. This is not a new idea; it was most recently popularized by an Obama economic plan to introduce stimulus on the same premise. And he’s right; spending does bring down the number temporarily. Is it insanity to believe that this represents an economic benefit? Well, you may recognize this response from Rick Santelli: “You can’t buy your way into prosperity. And if the multiplier that all of these Washington economists are selling us is over one, then we never have to worry about the economy again. The government should spend a trillion dollars an hour because we’ll get $1.5 trillion back.” Now as a historical exercise, I would like just one example of a long-term financially-responsible central government that had full control of the issuance of their own legal tender. I’m not suggesting a different system; I’m merely pointing out the possible futility of our expectations.
- freediverx 3y agoReverse the last 30 years of tax cuts for billionaires and corporations and then we can talk about the national debt.