17 ms·
Pixar was never a masterpiece factory
- c_crank 3y agoI'm glad someone else has the sense to see Inside Out for what it was. But the article just seems to reaffirm the idea that Pixar isn't what it used to be, just pushing the date to when they stopped making a lot of good movies further back.
- fundad 3y agoprops for not jamming the word wokeness into this.
- Cthulhu_ 3y agoBut why did you feel like you had to? Now you've drawn the attention to it and I'm replying and aaaaaaa.
- fundad 3y agoAnd now I'm replying to you but only to show solidarity
- adultSwim 3y agoHopefully Freddie is becoming less obsessed with "wokeness" and "cancel culture". It's still subtext in this critique of Pixar.
- warning26 3y agoWith the exception of the "Inside Out" hot take, most of the movies OP calls out as bad were commonly viewed as such. This feels like one guy's random opinions about Pixar movies with no overarching point besides "there were some bad ones in the past" which seems uncontroversial.
- WA 3y ago> This feels like one guy's random opinions about Welcome to substack
- Cthulhu_ 3y agoWelcome to any blog really, except that Substack, and before that Medium, somehow gained a reputation of being more worthwhile reads than someone's random wordpress blog.
- noirscape 3y agoIt's about presentation. A random WordPress blog (or blogspot or whatever other blogging engine you prefer) has a very specific visual style that denotes "I'm not a professional, I'm just me with an opinion". Medium and Substack visually mimic newspaper columns and give the same kind of cachet to their authors, even when it's not necessarily deserved.
- freejazz 3y agoI mean it could be the opinion of someone thats been writing and working in film criticism... but no, he's a "marxist" that has a book about how the problem with schools is that they ignore race/IQ "science"
- fractallyte 3y agoNot a mention of Pixar's shorts, which I frequently like more than the movies! And they are masterpieces that established Pixar at the beginning of CG animation. https://www.pixar.com/theatrical-shorts https://www.pixar.com/theatrical-shorts
- tgv 3y agoThe one with Jackalope (sp?) must be one of the most touching shorts I've seen, without resorting to sentimentality or (cheap) effects. It's on YouTube, of course: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KOLG-BAvjz0 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KOLG-BAvjz0
- rjh29 3y agoDisney Animation Studios rarely get a mention next to Pixar, but their 3D films are equally as good. Bolt, Tangled, Wreck-it Ralph, Big Hero 6, Zootopia...
- curtgrimes 3y agoNot to mention a little movie named Frozen.
- auxym 3y agoI recently read Culture Code, about organizational culture, and it talks about Pixar quite a bit. It is mentioned that after some failures, Disney purchased Pixar then had Pixar execs, including Ed Catmull, come to Disney to instill a culture similar to the one at Pixar. The story is told as a success, with the films you cite as examples of that.
- atonse 3y agoBefore the never ending sequels on the Pixar side, they actually have settled into a complementary relationship. Pixar does the more adventurous stuff, crazier ideas, totally different kinds of plots and stories/worlds/characters, with a focus on storytelling rather than songs etc. Whereas Disney Animation (with recent titles like Tangled, and the Frozen movies) is the 3d version of what Disney's Animation Studios always did best, take classic stories, and turn them into quasi-musicals with a modern twist, but do it in a really talented way. In my 20s, I used to get mad about the idea that Disney just stole story ideas and made it their own, but this was too reductionist. There is immense talent involved in actually taking an old story, modernizing it, adding all the original music, creating that original new world, building scenes, dialog, all that stuff. And I appreciate it and give Disney a lot more credit nowadays. Whether it's Beauty and the Beast or the Lion King, or modern hits like Frozen and Tangled, they really add a lot in their interpretations of these stories, and make it their own.
- chx 3y agoZootopia had one song IMO and it was amazing.
- busterarm 3y agoThe fact that the most words that the author can spend on Coco are "it's pretty" says it all for me. With the later rant about Pixar deliberately setting up their beats to make their audience cry, Coco _MUST_ be part of the conversation there and it's conspicuously missing. Coco is a wonderful film and probably the chief offender of the forced crying thing the author hates. Personally, I can't even think about the damn film without welling up and that's one of the movie's strengths. "Remember Me" is a wonderful, catchy earworm of a song that just refuses to leave my thoughts years later. And it's a fucking musical. I. HATE. MUSICALS. But Coco works for me by perfectly contextualizing the songs with the plot of the film. It's not musical numbers for the sake of it. So yes, for a studio that has put out a masterpiece like that, its lesser efforts should be heavily criticized.
- justinclift 3y ago> I. HATE. MUSICALS. Have you seen Sing, and/or Sing 2?
- dumpsterdiver 3y agoI avoided those movies initially because I thought they would be excruciatingly "singy". As it turned out, both movies were watchable imo, but I would never watch them again. Maybe that has something to do with my general disdain for full-fledged musicals, and how the movie was marketed as that. Even though the movies weren't actually full-fledged musicals, the marketing grossed me out enough that I think I have some sort of PTSD about watching them again.
- codetrotter 3y agoAnother couple of musicals that I think most people will like even if they generally don’t like musicals: - Grease (1978) https://m.imdb.com/title/tt0077631/ https://m.imdb.com/title/tt0077631/ - Hair (1979) https://m.imdb.com/title/tt0079261/ https://m.imdb.com/title/tt0079261/
- Scarblac 3y ago- The Blues Brothers (1980) https://www.imdb.com/title/tt0080455/ https://www.imdb.com/title/tt0080455/
- pavlov 3y agoI admire the overall craftmanship of Pixar movies, but I don't like their over-polished high-concept approach to storytelling. The characters and story notes are like carefully weighted abstract puzzle pieces that stand perfectly in relation to each other and provide opportunities for beautifully rendered CGI set pieces, but the overall mosaic leaves no lasting impression on me. Many of their movies seem to contain an embedded short film that stands out from the surrounding balancing exercise, as if the directors themselves had needed an escape hatch from the grinding process that produces these movies.
- mentos 3y agoSo you’re saying they’re not flying they’re just falling with style?
- ZeroGravitas 3y agoHe seems really angry at some weird idea he has about Pixar fans looking down on stuff that's also simultaneously half their output and that he looks down on. I'm assuming there's some kind of culture war thing happening in the background I'm not aware of which gives this some kind of warped logic but without that context it's just weird.
- cinntaile 3y agoHe seems to be taking jabs at "liberals" in quite a few of his other posts, so this doesn't sound too far fetched.
- projektfu 3y agoFor reference, he seems to be firing from the far left at centrist liberals and identity politics afficionados.
- lelanthran 3y ago> For reference, he seems to be firing from the far left at centrist liberals and identity politics afficionados. I don't know what this is supposed to mean. Aren't the identity politics afficionados the far left themselves? No centrist liberals preaches identity politics, almost by definition alone.
- c_crank 3y agoIt depends on if you think Marx or Eliezer Risco has a monopoly on being the furthest left.
- projektfu 3y agoGlancing through his work, he suggests that identity politics is anti-collective because it's focused on the individual and not the group. I can't speak more to that, I just was interested in what the underlying politics were from the above comment, because derision towards "liberals" is usually a right wing position, but obviously there are many leftists who have beef with some definition of liberals. They can all agree to hate the Atlantic and the NYT perhaps.
- noirscape 3y agoI think one reason why Pixars "decline" is more harshly felt is because the Pixar "style" is the only type of flagship animated feature Disney puts out nowadays. It's not that Pixar has always been good, like any company there's been ups and downs, but because Disney themselves have also gone all in on 3D animated films[0] (and none of those really come close to what Pixar puts out; even the recent flop of Elemental is still a better movie than most 3D Disney movies of the past decade), all those movies get compared to each other in a much more direct manner. Back in the early 2000s, it was pretty straightforward; Disney did the 2D animation, Pixar the 3D animation. It means that when Pixar or Disney puts out a stinker, its easily covered by the other. A sort of trade if you will. Disney has kinda now ended up in a bit of a slump for the past decade (likely directly the fault of the Live Action Remakes they keep doing - it feels really uncreative), so the highs and lows of Pixar are that much more apparent. They'll be doing fine. Elemental sucked, but it doesn't seem like it's a pattern for Pixars movie creation process. Not in the way that Shrek's poop humor ended up dominating DreamWorks for over a decade or how Despicable Mes "marketability" ended up ruining Illumination. [0]: The last blockbuster 2D animated movie was the Princess and the Frog and according to Disney it didn't make enough money to continue making them.
- genmon 3y agoI wouldn't agree that Disney is in a slump at all -- and it's possibly their lack of slump that makes it easier to level shots at Pixar. Frozen (2013) just gets in your decade window. Then there's Moana (2016) and Encanto (2021). All three have been hits with great songs, values and storytelling.
- noirscape 3y agoThe release cycle is still a lot more staggered since Disney just interspices it with a lot more filler content (those Live Action Remakes) that the Pixar releases are somewhat meant to fall back on. For every Frozen, there's a Tangled that doesn't make the cut in quality and that stands out when they don't have the same consistent release cycle of movies for the animated canon since it's broken up by the mostly mediocre Live Action ones.
- rcme 3y agoThe author's criticism of Up is weird to me. I watched Up when it was released. Can't say I remember it too much. But, I don't think it's fair to criticize a movie by saying that a movie is bad if you remove the best scene. One of my favorite books is The Blind Assassin by Margaret Atwood. 99% of the book is the musings and activities of an old lady, which are not interesting to say the least. It's not until the last page that the whole story is tied together. If you removed the last page, it wouldn't be a great book.
- soneca 3y agoI don’t think it’s the same thing. The initial scene is a masterpiece but if you remove it, it would still be possible to understand the movie. And the tone and message of the first scene is very different from the rest. I compare (negatively) to “Saving Private Ryan” which also has a masterpiece of a first scene, that also can be removed without much loss to the main plot. The difference is that on SPR the first scene set the tone and message of the movie perfectly. And if you remove it, the rest of the movie is pretty great too. You can’t say those two things about “Up”.
- gwd 3y ago> I compare (negatively) to “Saving Private Ryan” I think the word you want here is "contrast"; i.e., "Contrast this to Saving Private Ryan, which..."
- soneca 3y agoIt might be. Thanks for pointing out
- aidenn0 3y agoPretty sure the usage of compare is correct here. Compare can point out but similarities and differences.
- gwd 3y agoYou're right that in plain English, "compare" is a perfectly adequate word in this context. However, the person I replied to wasn't quite satisfied with it: they felt the need to add "(negatively)". I was trying to give them a more idiomatic word / phrasing that would add the extra rhetorical emphasis they were looking for.
- msla 3y agoThe Golden Age of Film is 12. That is, the Golden Age is whenever the person writing the piece was 12 years old. Arguments will be marshaled to support.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- zuminator 3y agoAlthough it has had loads of critically acclaimed hits, I don't think Pixar was ever considered as much of a "masterpiece" factory as it was a hit factory. It's only ever a small percentage of people who go to the cinema to see masterpieces. People go to be entertained, and Pixar has been very good at that for a very long time. It also benefitted from riding a steady wave of in-house CG improvements all the way from the Luxo shorts to the point where the verisimilitude has to be dialed down so as to fit the expectations of the Disney/Pixar look. Like the first Star Wars films, there was a gee-whiz tech factor to their early movies that compensated for some banal or hackneyed beats in their storytelling. And they can't rely on that any longer. If anything, they've ceded the eye candy aspect to the Avatar series and the eye-popping Spider-Man cartoons. I think to the extent that Pixar is in trouble, it's because they need to figure out a way to break out of their self-imposed box without losing their core identity as a studio.
- freetime2 3y agoI consider several Pixar movies to be “masterpieces”. The production quality is so high, the cast and voice acting are so good, and the story is able to appeal to adults and young children alike. High art they are not, but I don’t think that “masterpiece” should be reserved only for high art. The credits in Pixar movies are filled with people who masters at their craft. In terms of animation, I personally hold Studio Ghibli in higher regard. But they are targeting a different audience with more adult themes. And I wouldn’t hesitate to apply “masterpiece factory” to either studio. Compare either studio to DreamWorks and the difference in quality is noticeable in just about every aspect of the production.
- lloeki 3y ago> Studio Ghibli ... are targeting a different audience with more adult themes Definitely for the "adult" theme part, although I'd word it differently. While the likes of Mononoke Hime and Grave of the Fireflies should probably be handle with care (resp. violence and very heavy context) most are perfectly watchable by children (of course being mindful of what may shock or otherwise create psychological harm). I'd argue that many of these "adult" themes are perfectly graspable by children and it's our own prejudice that we project, and that these films present them in an accessible way for children, enabling deep parent-child discussions that would help understand and structure a child and prepare them for their life to come. I'd rather have my children watch Ghibli stuff than Disney.
- costanzaDynasty 3y ago[flagged]
- threeseed 3y agoMovies like Wall-E, Finding Nemo have strong ESG themes and were acclaimed successes. You seem more obsessed with finding any excuse to be anti-ESG rather than having a specific issue with recent Pixar films which have issues unrelated to specific themes.
- costanzaDynasty 3y agoThe average CEO last 5years. You've listed a 15 and 20 year old movie. You don't see a difference in the quality of the storytelling in Pixar movies? You don't see Disney movies checking boxes rather than telling stories? Simply saying ESG makes you obsessed, ...telling. People are talked down to all day at their corporate fake work job. They want a break from the HR speak in their entertainment. Its really not hard to figure out. Personally, watch what every you want. But every criticism of Disney the last 5 years is meet with ism's. Disney has been making bad movies for 5 years. Bad stories, bad special effects, their treatment of talent and bad leadership.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- logicprog 3y agoI think the problem is not that putting """woke""" messages in movies ruins them, I don't think that's remotely the case, nor that people who care about the stuff people term """woke""" inherently can't write good stories, I think it's that when the people making movies don't have any good ideas, any vision, anything they feel confident the movie can stand on its own merit with, they slap such messages on the front and hope that'll make it above criticism and/or meaningful in some way.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- freetime2 3y agoI was surprised to see Cars listed as one of the ones that people generally hate. I’m a little biased because my son absolutely adored that movie, and I have fond memories of him taking his Lightning McQueen toy around with him everywhere. But over many repeated watchings both my wife and I agreed it was a quality production. It has a good cast with Owen Wilson, Bonnie Hunt, Paul Newman, and even Larry the Cable Guy puts in a pretty decent performance. The minor characters are charming, too (including George Carlin and Cheech Marin). The story is fairly timeless and reminiscent of Doc Hollywood. I don’t know how they manage to make it work so well with anthropomorphic cars, but somehow they do. The main character has a good arc, and there’s a good amount of nostalgia. I don’t think I ever cried, but I definitely felt something - which is more than I can say for the Cars sequels. Would I go and watch it now without kids? No. But Pixar put out a movie that entertained kids and adults alike. Earned $462 million at the box office. Made an absolute killing in merchandise sales (and I thought the toys were pretty high quality, especially the die cast Tomica cars here in Japan). I have a lot of respect for what they were able to do with Cars. Not so much for the sequels, though. They also call Monsters University a mediocre sequel, but I tend to prefer it over Monsters Inc. Pretty much for the same reasons as Cars - good cast, timeless story reminiscent of Revenge of the Nerds, and my kids loved it.
- agumonkey 3y agoNever watched Monsters Univ. but Monsters Inc. left me somehow speechless. There's a subtle yet relentless crescendo in that screenplay that robbed my brain until the last second.
- coldpie 3y agoGive it a watch! I think University is very slightly more enjoyable to watch, possibly because the universe is already established from the first movie so it can move a little faster. But yeah, both are absolutely stellar films.
- epiccoleman 3y agoI'm astonished by this opinion, I think Monsters Inc. is a wildly better movie. University is fine but frankly nothing special - although the plot points involving Mike realizing he's just not scary, and the ultimate resolution where he realizes he makes an awesome director/manager for Sulley, is a pretty good moral.
- goertzen 3y agoHow did this make it to the first page on HN?
- threeseed 3y agoI'm confused as well. This is just a random person's rant about Pixar movies. Meanwhile on the second page of HN there are far more interesting articles about tech.
- hajile 3y agoThe subject of Pixar seems to be the actual interest and the article seems to be a vehicle to start that conversation. Not so unusual for HN.
- Wiskyt 3y agoyes i was consfused as well as i read more and more of that endless rant. but it turns out for me the subject itself was interesting food for thought. not the article
- throwaway_ab 3y agoSure, they have not been a masterpiece factory for almost two decades now. However they were certainly a masterpiece factory at one point, that point being the first decade of the studio's life. During that time they were certainly a masterpiece factory. From 1995 with their first film Toy Story, to 2004 with the release of The Incredibles, that resulted in consistently great films for 9 years. Their record held for 11 years until Cars was released in 2006. I believe no other studio has had similar performance. I remember around early 2000's news of Hollywood studios in panic because investors started asking other studios why it was considered business as usual, a given, that for every successful film a studio released there would be flops too. So like VC investing, the pay off for the eventual success had to be enough to offset those films that flopped and lost money. But then came Pixar and suddenly a studio proved you didn't have to have flops, every film they made in their first decade was a resounding success. They blew the conventional logic of Hollywood economics out of the window. This article sort of paints a picture of how outstanding their success was at the time: https://www.theguardian.com/film/2004/nov/12/3 https://www.theguardian.com/film/2004/nov/12/3 So I guess I disagree with the title, Pixar was most certainly a masterpiece factory in its first decade. Reading deBoer's article I can't say I agree or disagree about the recent state of Pixar, I grew up with Pixar films and their first decade coincided with my childhood and early teenage years, so when I think to myself "yeah Pixar's recent work doesn't touch that early magic" I can't really tell is that my bias coming through? Maybe I am overthinking this a bit.
- mdhen 3y agoI mean studio ghibli has to be in that conversation too.
- PurpleRamen 3y agoDo they? They are from Japan, not Hollywood. Very different business culture. And while they are successful and beloved, compared to Pixar they only made small money. They only have one movie who made comparable money to a Pixar movies, which was Spirited Away in 2002/2003, and it "only" made as much as Toy Story in 1995, and a bit more than "A Bug's Life" in 1998. So even if investors in Hollywood knew about Ghibli around that time, they probably didn't consider it as a relevant investment.
- Brendinooo 3y agoUp is the dividing line; I believe any concept after that would have been developed post-merger with Disney. It’s about as simple as that. I’m not a Disney hater to the extent of some, but any weak film before Up and any strong film after are the exceptions.
- bigbacaloa 3y agoHaters gonna hate
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- cerol 3y agoI'll just come out and say it. I absolutely loved Toy Story 4. I watched TS1 and 2 as a kid, and I remeber loving it and rewatching dozens of time. Then TS3 came out, with Andy going to college, around the same time I was going to college. Toy Story 4 was an absolutely stunning movie, both in terms of photography, and underlying message. In my opinion, it is about growing up, finding out who you are, and letting go. They ended the franchise in the best way possible.
- seizethegdgap 3y agoI genuinely hate to break it to you, but Toy Story 5 has been officially announced by Disney. https://www.latimes.com/entertainment-arts/movies/story/2023-02-09/to-infinity-and-toy-story-5-tim-allen-confirms-return-as-buzz-lightyear https://www.latimes.com/entertainment-arts/movies/story/2023...
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- Affric 3y agoI think there’s a bit to this and also a bit where he gets it wrong. What’s right: 1. A Bug’s life was underwhelming after Toy Story. I grew to like it more after having entered the workforce. 2. Luca is understated. 3. Kids love Cars way more than adults. 4. Coco is a real diamond in a whole lot of (relative) rough. 5. The second half of Wall-E is quite good. 6. People aren’t unkind enough regarding Toy Story 4. Not amount of unkindness will be enough enough. There’s lots more wrong but I want to zero in on one thing, Up. De Boer says that without the first 10 minutes the movie is awful… but that’s the point of the movie. It’s about a miserable grieving man… the scene sets up the rest of the movie. Of course the movie sucks without it. It tells the story on the basis that you have just watched that scene.
- escapedmoose 3y agoImo it’s not just that Up sucks without the first 10 min, it’s that the last 90% of the movie is aimless, emotionless, and feels unnecessary. Like the first 10 min should have been a pre-film short that they drew out because it was too depressing to just end like that.
- Affric 3y agoCarl is old and he builds new memories and shared his life with a child and a dog. Carl hates his companions. The child he must suffer is simple and naive. The dog is plainly an idiot. But Russell is trying to improve himself and Dug is pure of heart. The adventure and how these two creatures display virtue and improve his life in spite of being unable to compare to his late wife nor the more sophisticated and accomplished Muntz reveals to him that life is still worth living and that connections are still to be made. I think it makes sense.
- escapedmoose 3y agoIt makes sense and I intellectually understand the premise, but emotionally it fell flat for me. This could be due to a number of reasons, e.g. the writing, the animation, the voice acting, my headspace at the time of watching… I had to pause the movie to stop bawling after that first 10 minutes, so it’s possible that the bar for emotional connection was simply set too high after that.
- mcphage 3y agoSo many thinkpieces have come out about Pixar and... I disagree with all of them. Pixar has put out a lot of masterpieces. They've put out a lot of movies that, while not masterpieces, are still really great. They've put out a few mediocre movies, and they've put out one or two real stinkers (Cars 2, The Good Dinosaur). They can put out some mediocre movies, or some merely very good movies, without having lost their way. Look at their release schedule! 2 movies a year some years! You can't release movies that quickly and have every one be a masterpiece. And that's okay.
- mherkender 3y agoI respect what the author is getting at -- Pixar movies sometimes favor adult expectations instead of being kids movies and get stuck somewhere between. I can agree to an extent, I felt Soul was really guilty of this. But the author is a victim of the same mistake. If kids like the movie it's a kids movie. I think Soul is barely for kids at all but if kids like it, it's a kids movie. Letting an adult decide what a kids movie truly is is just ignoring kids in a different way. They also seem to think producing a handful of some of the most influential movies of all time makes Pixar not a masterpiece factory, as if their weak efforts somehow make their better efforts less valuable. And finally I won't hear Coco disrespected like that, Inside Out is overrated sure, but Coco is the same caliber of film as Ratatouille.
- artichokeheart 3y agoThere have only been a few Pixar movies I haven’t liked Cars 2, The Good Dinosaur and Finding Dory and not all of the others have had drawn an emotional response from me. That said anything that draws you in and makes you feel something is by definition good art. Art is completely subjective. This blog post is just another “I don’t like other people having fun” post
- RGBCube 3y agoWhat's with all the Cars 2 hate?
- kevinthew 3y agoNot sure when long form shitposting became acceptable but no one wants to read this tripe
- lelanthran 3y ago> Wall-E is famously bifurcated, with the first half being a nearly dialogue-free tone poem and the latter half a (now PROBLEMATIC) story about saving humanity. What's problematic about the second half of WALL-E?
- goodgrieving 3y ago[flagged]
- strgcmc 3y agoNot saying I agree or even that the author is referring to these specific ideas, but there's plenty to anger people with: https://www.avclub.com/your-guide-to-the-wall-e-controversy-1798214449 https://www.avclub.com/your-guide-to-the-wall-e-controversy-...
- Wiskyt 3y agogod damn what a BS article (imo) none of the points make real sense
- lelanthran 3y ago> god damn what a BS article (imo) none of the points make real sense Maybe that's because none of the complaints it is reporting makes real sense? The article, as I see it, is merely reporting on the controversy. They aren't making their own points, they are repeating the points made by others. That's what news is supposed to be: report what is happening, not what you think.
- kjs3 3y agoYeah...that was kinda the point.
- ravenstine 3y agoI guess if Pixar was never a masterpiece factory then no studio was? It's certainly not like Disney hasn't had a history of duds from pretty much the beginning. I haven't been a fan of Pixar for the last couple decades, but their first 6 films (the ones most people think of when they hear the name "Pixar") were pretty excellent. By the time The Incredibles came out, there was no reason to not believe a Pixar movie was guaranteed to be worth seeing.
- hinkley 3y agoGhibli has switched to more slice of life story lines and while my kids still love them, they lack the sense of wonder that made me “force” them to watch Totoro, then the were up for Castle in the Sky and friends, and later Spirited Away, Nausicaä and Mononoke. They liked Up on Poppy Hill and Marnie Was Here more than I did. We aren’t watching Grave until they’re 21. Which is probably more for by sake than theirs at this point. I watched it 10 years ago and once is really enough.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- tptacek 3y agode Boer claims that the trailer for Brave belies the fact that it was stuck in development hell, so much that includes content not in the movie --- but everything in that trailer is in the movie, so much so that the "mountain" Merida is seen climbing was critiqued for being Yosemite geology rather than Scottish. I'm baffled by the claim that Ratatouille is intentionally hard to love. I think it's a telling statement. de Boer's schtick is, of course, contrarianism for its own sake (it's why so much of his writing ends up here, despite the fact that his writing beat almost never overlaps HN). It's as if he assumes that anything he likes must be an outsider pick. In the world I inhabit, Ratatouille is universally beloved, with a higher gross box office than the allegedly crowd-pleasing Cars movies or any of the Toy Story films. The whole paragraph really comes across as a parody of the Rick and Morty copypasta, but I don't think that was deliberate.
- stainablesteel 3y agothis is a natural birth and death cycle pixar was formed by hard working, interested and enthusiastic people. they understood people, kids, and the art of storytelling which gained them a fanbase as the fanbase idolizes them, many people look to join their ranks. too many want it, so only the most fanatic ones have the dedication to get in. at this point, the fanatics are what causes the downfall. they are the kid in the chocolate factory who grew up eating the candy and refuse to stop. in fact they made it into the factory for the sake of eating more. there was no inspiration on the fanatics part to inspire anyone else, or to raise the spirits of children as was done to them. the art they produced was for themselves, not for others. that's the gist
- weinzierl 3y agoThey didn't have to be a masterpiece factory, being a welcome change from the uniform Disney pulp was enough. Sadly the fresh wind didn't last long and we are back at the choice mostly between Japan and France for higher quality animated movie productions. Maybe some of the Netflix stuff or what is made in Russia could count, but that's it. Everything else is assembly line produced mass product.
- waffletower 3y agoThe a posteriori "I told you so" title, "Pixar was never a masterpiece factory", is a clickbait sham. Many Pixar sequels outdo most first-run offerings from their wannabe competitors. They have also made a great film or two this decade. I loved Bug's Life. In retrospect, it is easy to demonize the film as arguably its best performance was made by Kevin Spacey. Cars was challenging to get into, particularly given the considerable Heartland cultural nods. As my first born loved it, I saw it repeatedly and eventually I could clearly see its greatness that others could see first viewing. It did decidedly well at the box office. A much much better title of this article would be, "I don't understand why everyone else loved Pixar so much".
- puppymaster 3y agoITT: Apparently we all have different opinions about animated movies and that's okay
- Justsignedup 3y agoI think what Pixar was originally was a tech company with groundbreaking tech enabling them to make 3d movies in ways nobody else could. But writers and directors aren't perfect. And it is important to note that there will be flops. The main "problem" is that the tech is so commoditized now, that pretty much every studio has excellent 3d animation tech and basically can do everything Pixar can do. So now it comes down to artists, writers, and the director to make the substance, and basically Pixar is just another company now... no longer are they groundbreaking. IMO this is fine. It just sneaks up on you, subtly, and then before you know it Pixar is just another company making animated movies of reasonably decent quality. Edit: To be honest, I think all of Pixar's movies (except maybe Cars) were above average in terms of quality.
- ml-anon 3y agoYou’d be hard pressed to find a more despicable founding leadership team in all of tech/entertainment and that’s really saying something: Jobs, serial sexual assaulter Lassiter and unrepentant wage fixer Catmull who was also instrumental in covering for Lassiter for decades.
- joker_minmax 3y agoMost people in this thread blaming Disney are massively overlooking Ratatouille which came out after Disney took over Pixar. The main woman in the film is allowed to have a big nose instead of a button nose, and she also doesn't have the stupidly large "Pixar mom" hips that have become prevalent in animated films from a lot of production companies. I would love to see more female characters like Colette in animated film. And that's just aesthetic things about character design. Ratatouille is one of the most re-watchable films they made. The perspective of seeing the world from a rat's POV is inventive, the score is pleasant, the concept is fun, and the message is soulful.
- QuantumGood 3y agoWatching the making of one of the Frozen films, and the making of a Pixar film early in their history, Frozen's process struck me as similar to Pixar's approach to collaboration, but on acid. I immediately felt Disney and Pixar were at the end of their run—there was no one in the process saying "this process is broken".
- boppo1 3y ago"Things were actually never good" headlines are such tiresome gaslighting.
- bbstats 3y agoYes it absolutely was.