7 ms·
Miles Davis: A candid conversation (1962)
- johnea 3y agoI fuckin love Miles Davis!
- sambapa 3y agoMiles Davis is the personification of the term "cool"
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- ggm 3y agoIt should be noted, from biographies we learn he wasn't always very nice, or kind. To his friends, to his family, to his fellow musicians. He was a hard taskmaster. People say the same thing about Monk, who was also the personification of "cool" and Mingus who was red hot, but also very cool. All three were angry at times.
- Slow_Hand 3y agoMiles himself would admit to not being very nice to several people. His autobiography includes many passages where he matter-of-factly recounts being cruel to people. Often these passages are him simultaneously voicing regret for his actions, but he doesn't shy away from what he's done. He owns it. This happens several times throughout the years as he recounts events. And while he mostly takes responsibility for his actions, it seems to have been an ongoing behavior that he found himself unable to resolve completely.
- yung_steezy 3y agoI was watching a documentary on BBC about Davis (I think it was _Miles Davis: Birth of the Cool_) and was struck by one of his wives talking about his drug habits. She said that his heroin use wasn't a problem but once he started taking cocaine he began drinking more and became increasingly violent.
- AlbertCory 3y ago> Why I sometimes walk off the stand is because when it's somebody else's turn to solo, I ain't going to just stand up there and be detracting from him. What am I going to stand up there for? I ain't no model, and I don't sing or dance, and I damn sure ain't no Uncle Tom just to be up there grinning. Sometimes I go over by the piano or the drums and listen to what they're doing. But if I don't want to do that, I go in the wings and listen to the whole band until it's the next turn for my horn. I wrote about this exact thing in here last week: https://albertcory50.substack.com/p/the-art-of-leadership-lessons-from https://albertcory50.substack.com/p/the-art-of-leadership-le... But he was Miles. He did it his way. No disrespect at all from me on that. He probably launched as many big stars as Blakey, if not more.
- ddq 3y agoI was enjoying this article but when you got to the importance of character, asking ChatGPT to define it seemed - at least to me - a bit of a cop-out. Would have liked more personal perspective there.
- Tade0 3y agoIncreasingly, when I ask someone for their opinion, they just tell me they've put that question into ChatGPT and this is what it said. Well, okay, but if I wanted to hear that I would have asked ChatGPT directly, no?
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- ghostpepper 3y agoAs a counterpoint, isn't it implied that the person has read what ChatGPT wrote and by forwarding it, agrees that it's a roughly similar phrasing of their feelings on the issue? One would hope so, anyway.
- AlbertCory 3y ago
- macintux 3y agoApropos of nothing, I just walked out of the Leepa-Rattner Museum of Art in St. Petersburg, and Herb Snitzer has a few photos on the wall of jazz greats, including this shot of Miles shortly before his passing. https://herbsnitzer.com/miles_davis3.htm https://herbsnitzer.com/miles_davis3.htm The museum is well worth a visit for anyone in the Tampa, Florida area.
- johnea 3y agoReally a shame it's got that big watermark across it...
- baggy_trough 3y agoA great conversation. Some actual honesty. Would like to see more of that these days.
- pavlov 3y agoThis 1962 interview was published in Playboy Magazine. Somebody simply needs to convince Pornhub that they should spice things up with interviews of jazz musicians.
- JKCalhoun 3y agoAm I the only one that visits PornHub for the articles?
- AlbertCory 3y agoWhy yes. I believe you ARE the only one. PornHub has articles? Why didn't I hear about this? Next thing you'll be telling me: they do reviews of Scotch, cigars, and cool Scandinavian furniture.
- actinium226 3y agoI'm going to use this should I ever let Pornhub into my history and get caught. "I go there for the articles"
- borbulon 3y ago> Have you always been so sensitive about being a Negro? I know this interview is from 1962, but are you fucking kidding me?
- lisasays 3y agoFrom the way Miles responded to the question, he wasn't in the least fazed by it. Why should you be? (BTW the term 'Negro' had an entirely different connotation and sound at that time than it does today, as mentioned elsewhere in this thread. Also, it may help to consider who the interviewer was).
- literalis 3y agoNegro wasn't an offensive word even in the 90s from what I remember. It would have sounded overly formal and a bit outdated but it wasn't a slur. I assume this just comes from Spanish so no more offensive than saying black in English. African-American was still somewhat new and certainly not as a widely used as today. Even in the mid 2000s people used the incredibly offensive term mulatto without a second thought as opposed to mixed race. It would be like if latinx replaces latino completely in 20 years, latino becomes a slur and people in 2040 judging us now as racist for using the word latino. It is ridiculous and ignorance of the reality that language evolves in time. It is also hard to put Miles in perspective. Kind of Blue was the second best selling album of all time at the end of the 1950s after Elvis Christmas album. Rebellious new heroin music as opposed to the high art we view jazz today.
- medler 3y agoThe question definitely seems odd by today’s standards but it’s worth noting that the interviewer is Alex Haley, who was himself Black.
- pessimizer 3y agoI have no idea what people are finding shocking about this sentence, unless it's literally that people now think "negro" is some sort of swear word rather than an anachronistic term for black people (that wasn't at all anachronistic in 1962.) Davis is almost entirely talking about issues that spring from him being black in America, and he's being asked whether he's always been so sensitive about it. Aside from the fact that this is a black man speaking to another black man, the question wouldn't even be inappropriate for a white interviewer. edit: Also, "colored" didn't refer to "people of color," it was just another name for black people. I've noticed that mistake lately from some shockingly ignorant wokesters trying to claim Jim Crow for their own.
- megmogandog 3y agoThere's a lot of great stuff in this interview, but what really floored me was the question, after Miles had talked so much and so eloquently about race in America and his experiences, "Have you always been so sensitive about being a N**?" Like nothing Miles said entered the reporter's skull. It's also interesting to see how much he talks about the importance of representation in the media. Given that's something we've only started to see change much in the last 10 years or so, I wonder how his remarks were received then. Would it have seemed totally out of left field, like 'what is this guy even talking about'?
- gwern 3y ago> Like nothing Miles said entered the reporter's skull. > I know this interview is from 1962, but are you fucking kidding me? Commenters might be interested to know that the interviewer in question was Alex Haley. I don't know why OP's version leaves that out. (Haley did several Playboy interviews, including that with the Klansman; all that I have read thus far have been worth reading.)
- slibhb 3y agoIt's 1962. "Negro" was the polite word, you don't have to asterisk it.
- burnished 3y agoOh, that changes the meaning of the sentence significantly.
- csa 3y agoIt does. Fwiw, Alex Haley was also black, so he was perhaps asking from a shared perspective.
- megmogandog 3y agoI'm aware of the context and took no offense when I read it; I asterisked it for 2023.
- enneff 3y agoIf you found this interesting then check out Davis’ autobiography. It is absolutely fascinating and with a music streaming service you can listen to all the music he talks about as you read. One of my favourite books.
- damontal 3y agoThe story an about him in a cab with Charlie Parker with Parker getting a blowjob from a prostitute while eating fried chicken was a particularly memorable anecdote.
- Uhhrrr 3y agoAnd only one of many. The book obviously never went near a PR person. Highly recommended for anyone with the slightest interest in jazz.
- wyclif 3y agoThe Bird anecdotes are legendary, but I also enjoyed his commentary on Coltrane. Even though Trane has achieved saintly status today, Miles certainly didn't regard him that way (though he did respect his talent).
- Sporktacular 3y agoHe's so sharp and clear on what he wants to say, especially wrt race. Ahead of the general conversation too.
- pessimizer 3y ago> Ahead of the general conversation too. Not ahead of the internal black conversation, which has actually regressed since. Giving an interview like this today would get you smeared as a Russian spy: https://www.thecrimson.com/article/2022/1/24/misinformation-review-retracts-misinformation/ https://www.thecrimson.com/article/2022/1/24/misinformation-... edit: tbh, giving an interview like that back then might have gotten you smeared as a Soviet spy, too.
- coolandsmartrr 3y agoThe Playboy interviewer is Alex Haley, who conducted many notable interviews for Playboy magazine. He had another memorable interview with George Lincoln Rockwell, the leader of the American Nazi Party. Rockwell made sure Haley wasn't Jewish as they were arranging the interview, but was shocked to learn that the interviewer was black. He did seem to have a grudging admiration for Haley, as he continued corresponding with letters opening with "To my V.I.N." (N being the n-word). Haley later went on to author many notable titles, including The Autobiography of Malcolm X (as ghost-writer) and Roots, which turned into a monumental TV series. Part of the show contains a reenactment of the meeting with Alex Haley and George Lincoln Rockwell, each played by James Earl Jones and Marlon Brando: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Z8SxzNdX1MQ https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Z8SxzNdX1MQ
- mynameishere 3y agoCheck out Miles Davis critiquing some poor kid after a performance: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kCTirrJ1Gms&t=1421s https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kCTirrJ1Gms&t=1421s It's not quite as bad as I remember it, but man he could be an ass.
- nickd2001 3y agoI love Miles Davis' music... but that interview really turned me off him. All Miles had to do was show some kindness and empathy. I did wonder actually if simply Miles was autistic, and unaware how he actually need to behave. Miles could have given helpful constructive criticism at the same time as being warm , friendly , encouraging, but seemed unable to do that, or to empathise about what that kid must have gone away and felt.
- camgunz 3y agoYeah I remember when I was younger his sharp style really turned me off too. But almost 30 years later now I just see him as a hard, uncompromising guy. I'm not idolizing like, I'm sure he was many times toxic and abusive, but now that I'm ~40 his style doesn't bother me personally at all. Would I put him in charge of junior software engineers? Nah. Would I play in his band? A thousand times yes, if I could hang (I can't).
- martingoodson 3y agoThis is to misunderstand Miles Davis. The point is that he treated the trumpet player with respect, as if he was taking to a trumpet player, not a child. He was engaging with a group of peers. The evidence for this is that he went on the hire the keyboard player, who was 16 years old, to play in his band a year later.
- nickd2001 3y agoI hear what you're saying. :). People need to hear home truths that's for sure. Its the only way to improve. However, a bit of humour and warmth wouldn't go amiss would it? When I was a kid I played in a wind band. One weekend we had an ultra-sarcastic military guy conduct us. We reacted first with , WTF? This guy is really rude. It soon became apparent though that he had a heart of gold and could make us play really well. He cared about us, and his brusque manner was only skin deep and/or put on / an "act" . It all turned out to be pretty funny. "You do read music, do you?" was a memorable quip. We were like "can't believe he said that", but I think the recipient of that remark rather liked him in the end. It seemed to me Miles appeared not to know the people need that warmth. Which makes me wonder about autism. I must say, Herbie Hancock, who seems like a nice person and full of the warmth that Miles seems to lack, speaks warmly of Miles. So, maybe I should go away and re-read what Herbie had to say about Miles. ;)
- photochemsyn 3y agoMy favorite Miles Davis album dates to seven years after this interview: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bitches_Brew https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bitches_Brew Although, my second favorite Mile Davis album is Sketches of Spain (1959), three years before this interview. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sketches_of_Spain https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sketches_of_Spain Perhaps the music matters more than the interviews do?
- weevil 3y ago> But prejudiced white people can't see any of the other races as just individual people. If a white man robs a bank, it's just a man robbed a bank. But if a Negro or a Puerto Rican does it, it's them awful Negroes or Puerto Ricans. We've come a long way in 60 years. It's Muslims and Mexicans now too. (/s)
- FeepingCreature 3y agoI mean, we've made strides in equality. Nowadays, depending who you ask, it's white people as well! edit: Honestly though, that said, reading this article gives me a ton of respect for Miles Davis. He's really candid while at the same time being very explicit that he's just talking about what he himself has seen, and why he's deciding the way that he does. A lot more people could stand to think like that.
- adyashakti 3y agoi was there. as a young aspiring jazz artist attending conservatory near NYC, i took jazz lessons with Eric Dolphy and others close to Miles. Met him a couple of times at his gigs. i grew up about a mile from the legendary Van Gelder studio where many great jazz albums were recorded. i used to go hang out and pick up the vibes by osmosis. of course you don’t disturb an artist when they’re working. that’s just so obvious to anyone with musical experience. even listening to music at a high level requires unbroken concentration. what kind of idiot would disturb a world-class musician at a gig? yeah, critics. surprisingly the article didn’t mention jazz artists’ spiritual interests. everyone in the scene in those days, including Miles, was reading and discussing original Vedic and Buddhist source literatures. like drugs, it was simply part of being a serious jazz player. spiritual interests and insights drove a lot of the innovation in jazz in the ‘60s. i left the jazz scene to go to india for years of serious study. when i came back, so much had changed. a darkness had come over the scene. many of the best musicians and close friends had passed away before their maturity. it was so sad. i wound up going back to india and becoming a monk. back in the ‘60s we believed that music had the power to change the world. unfortunately the corporate music business didn’t want to change the world, they just wanted profit. the road to hell is paved with gold, friends.
- pier25 3y agoWoah what a story. And then you ended up in tech?
- adyashakti 3y agoi took an entry-level programming job as a way to earn money between trips to india. after documenting a test suite i worked on, my boss noticed i could write well. he gave me a good recommendation and i was able to fund my travel and study by contract tech writing. this was back in the days when software actually had manuals. but no, tech was just a passage to my real vocation: i ‘ended up’ quite intentionally becoming an internationally-known teacher of meditation and enlightenment.
- pier25 3y ago