7 ms·
> Yes, you can academically wonder whether an orbiting space station is a vehicle and whether it's in the park, but the obvious intent of the sign couldn't be c
by AnthonyMouse 3y ago
> Yes, you can academically wonder whether an orbiting space station is a vehicle and whether it's in the park, but the obvious intent of the sign couldn't be clearer. Cars/trucks/motorcycles aren't allowed, and obviously police and ambulances (and fire trucks) doing their jobs don't have to follow the sign.
Now you're assuming the intent.
The park could contain loose soil on the edge of a cliff, so any vehicle driving there could cause a landslide that topples the vehicle over the cliff and could kill anyone on the beach below. No vehicles in the park.
But the larger point is that people can adopt the "obvious intent" version of the rule when it suits them and the pedantic version of the rule when it suits them. If you're the park ranger and the local police come into the park in their car chasing after some criminals, and the local police are your buddies, you say they haven't violated the rule because the intent isn't to apply to emergency vehicles. If the exact same thing happens but you're having a dispute with the local police, now they're violating the rule and you can come up with something like the park isn't in their jurisdiction.
It's the same rule. It's the same action. The only difference is if you like them or not. And that's the problem.
- raverbashing 3y ago> If you're the park ranger and the local police come into the park in their car chasing after some criminals... If the exact same thing happens but you're having a dispute with the local police It doesn't matter, the rules on police and emergency vehicles usually supersede some local rule about a park. The park is not some absolute ruler of the land, sure it can put rules for general/everyday use but a lot of things are rules at higher levels
- chii 3y ago> supersede some local rule aka, there's some other rule that isn't listed then? Which isn't what is being discussed here.
- hyperhopper 3y agoYes, you're assuming that this is a jurisdiction where police or ambulances have authority over local rules
- FartyMcFarter 3y agoThe game didn't say the park is contained in another land. It's a "hypothetical park". It could even exist in a virtual reality that doesn't have any other rules for all we know.
- usrusr 3y agoYeah, the game is very specific about other rules not applying. It's about "what exactly is and is not in" (in the airliner and space station question) and about "what exactly is and is not vehicle" (all others)
- qnpnp 3y agoYou're assuming another rule here, which not only isn't written but is even explicitly excluded in the very beginning of this experiment.
- raverbashing 3y agoCorrect. But you (and the experimenter) are assuming that rules exist in a vacuum, which in practice it isn't
- jodrellblank 3y agoNo the experimenter doesn't assume that, they say: "please answer the question of whether the rule is violated (not whether the violation should be allowed)." The intent of the experiment is to get your view on whether X is a vehicle or not, and whether Y counts as a place "in the park" or not.
- watwut 3y agoYes, but that is an actual situation in real world.
- anilakar 3y agoBoth "No vehicles" and "in the park" already require you to have external knowledge. What is a vehicle? What constitutes park grounds?
- vidarh 3y agoThat is part of the point of the exercise. You can expand on this rule, but however far you go there will continue to be things that are not clear.
- AnthonyMouse 3y ago> It doesn't matter, the rules on police and emergency vehicles usually supersede some local rule about a park. Nobody said it was a local rule. It could be a federal rule about a federal park. And it could be there for a more important reason than keeping ATVs off the hiking trails.
- mrtksn 3y ago>Now you're assuming the intent. That's true but without assuming intent you end up blindly following rules. Something struck me when first moved to UK from Turkey: Every rule in UK seemed to have an intent and that's why I think Turkey is full of rules which no one follows but in UK the rules are less numerous but followed. In Turkey, Turks like to think that the rules are not followed because the fines are too small or that the government is incompetent and can't enforce the fines. I disagree, I think Turkey is a chaotic society because rules are not built around intent. Did you know that up until (literally)yesterday live music after midnight was banned in Turkey as part of Covid-19 measures? For the first few months until I got my white collar job, I did some part time jobs in London as a waiter etc. and worked at some high end venues and hotels. In these places there are some equipments(like climate control of the wine cellar) which are operated through control panels which are accessible to everyone and they didn't put signs that say "don't touch", instead the signs said "you have no reason to touch this". They were able to keep curious hands away from buttons that shouldn't be pushed by those who don't know what they are doing by simply emphasising the intent. Intent is extremely important, in fact everything is about intent. Every human action is with an intent. Great UX is built by designing around intent.
- hkt 3y agoThis is exactly why criminal law requires two things: the actus reus and the mens rea. Act and intent. So, great point. I guess the only problem on the internet is it is very hard to determine intent, see Poe's law.
- mrtksn 3y agoAgree. IMHO, the problem can be solved with enhanced bandwidth(that is, to use things beyond text, IRL we have mimics and voice tone so emojis are a start) of the communication.
- AnthonyMouse 3y agoThis is why there is a difference between rules and guidelines. Guidelines are suggestions. They're all about intent. "Don't have live music after midnight" isn't a ridiculous guideline for COVID, because it usually implies a gathering. It is a ridiculous rule because rules have to be rigid and well defined, because rules are enforced. Squishy rules aren't rules, they're covert dictatorial powers.
- Etherlord87 3y ago> Now you're assuming the intent. No, it's not assuming, it's interpreting based on prior experience in communication. > The park could contain loose soil on the edge of a cliff. Then the sign would mention that, simple as that. > But the larger point is that people can adopt the "obvious intent" version of the rule when it suits them and the pedantic version of the rule when it suits them. I agree with you here, it happens all the time, is a problem, and perhaps the test is useful to those, who haven't figured this truth so far. Probably not that many in the HN crowd… I'll add that there's a problem with the test: "does it violate the rule" is not very meaningful. It could be understood in two ways: - does it technically, strictly speaking, "violate" the rule, meaning, it does something the sign tells you not to do, - or is the example acting against the intent of the author of the sign. If the test asked "should violator be punished?" I think it would be more meaningful, otherwise it's just synthetic and the controversy is just about semantics, it doesn't incentive a discussion about our worldview and the rules we put in place, it just provokes to argue pedantically about how we phrase a message. Moreover it possibly misleads people to think they disagree on something they really don't.
- AnthonyMouse 3y ago> No, it's not assuming, it's interpreting based on prior experience in communication. It's assuming the intent without sufficient context to know what it actually is. Because very little context was provided. And the context that was provided strongly implied that the rule was important. > Then the sign would mention that, simple as that. We don't even know if there was a sign. None of that was specified.
- Etherlord87 3y ago> And the context that was provided strongly implied that the rule was important. You're assuming that.
- hgsgm 3y agoNo, they were interpreting based on prior experience in communication.
- rprwhite 3y agoThis is a great anecdote for the need of intent. But, you also need context. Without either of those it’s very, very hard to agree on rules. And agreeing on either context or intent, let alone both, in a small community is hard. Doing so across the internet is damn near impossible and that was the point of the article.
- the_mitsuhiko 3y ago> The park could contain loose soil on the edge of a cliff, so any vehicle driving there could cause a landslide that topples the vehicle over the cliff and could kill anyone on the beach below. No vehicles in the park. I live in a city with Trams. Whenever they replace tram rails they remove the surrounding concrete and asphalt. It would be dangerous to drive there. In those cases they explicitly hang a “road closed” sign with an extra sign “including service vehicles”. In the real world signs (especially common ones) try to be reasonable descriptive. Nobody is helped if you argue about the meaning if something goes wrong.
- dudeinjapan 3y agoIf a vehicle entering the park would directly endanger lives--rather than just being a nuisance--the sign would (should) give the extra context to make a stronger discouragement. Otherwise, it is fair game to assume the "intent" of any such sign is to make guidelines to enhance the public's mutual enjoyment/safety at the park, and that such guidelines may be discarded when lives are endangered (police/ambulance). As an alternate example where the rule itself is related to safety, "no campfires" would not be expected to be followed if one became lost and needed to make smoke signals to be rescued.
- wuiheerfoj 3y agoI voted that a police car/ambulance driving into the park _was_ breaking the rules, though breaking the rules may be justifiable in some circumstances. The smoke signal example you gave is similar - if I’m lost, I care more about being found than the punishment for starting a fire. If the ‘no campfires’ rule was punishable by death (and enforced), perhaps I wouldn’t risk a smoke signal
- tsukikage 3y agoThe thing is, you don't generally get to know the context or the intent. You can't have a discussion with the sign, nor can it lecture you. A rule against starting a fire might be because the land owner doesn't like burnt patches on their meadows, or it might be because the vegetation is super dry and if you set fire to it you kill not only yourself but also all the surrounding villages, or something in between. You could argue that the sign should include enough context to convince the reader to follow its instructions, but (a) you end up with signs with tons of writing in tiny font that everyone just ignores because TLDR (and yes, these do actually happen quite frequently in parks around here), and (b) if there is some combination of letters you can put on a sign that works to stop people lighting fires, the meadow guy will put that on his sign because he doesn't want fires and those syllables work. So you've just pushed the problem one level back, but the real question remains the same: do you risk doing the thing you want to, or do you respect the sign?
- 3y ago
- jeffrallen 3y ago> that's the problem No, that's not the problem. That's human nature, and human nature is most definitely not the problem. Humans make the world we live in and we individually get to influence it, but we don't get a veto on how others influence it. To me, the quiz answers depended on common sense, and I was reminded by it that my common sense is not others' common sense, and so what? That's life. We deal, because there's no other choice when we live in society.
- ilyt 3y agoHuman nature is absolutely the problem, just the one that can't be fixed, just worked around.
- hosh 3y agoThis goes right to the discussion in the first couple chapters of _Promise Theory_, laying out the difference between a promise and an obligation. An obligation requires global knowledge, whereas a promise is local in scope, necessarily voluntary.
- heavyset_go 3y ago> The park could contain loose soil on the edge of a cliff, so any vehicle driving there could cause a landslide that topples the vehicle over the cliff and could kill anyone on the beach below. No vehicles in the park. Have you ever looked at the warning signs on water heaters? They make it instantly clear what the dangers are and how bad they can be. A "No vehicles in the park" sign in that situation would be the equivalent of just putting "Caution: Hot" on a water heater. Similarly, parks have signs with people literally drowning and being killed to make it abundantly clear how dangerous they can be.
- gcmrtc 3y ago> The park could contain loose soil on the edge of a cliff, so any vehicle driving there could cause a landslide that topples the vehicle over the cliff and could kill anyone on the beach below. No vehicles in the park. That would be a terrible phrasing then. It should have been phrased something like "Landslide hazard, no weight more than 1ton allowed anywhere in the park." or something in that vein.
- probably_wrong 3y agoThis is core to the Gricean Maxim of Quantity [1], according to which one gives as much information as needed but no more. If the sign says "No vehicles in the park" and nothing else then any reasonable person should assume that the reason for the sign is so obvious that no further clarification is needed. Unrelated, it is also the reason why a hot-dog is not a sandwich, pragmatically speaking. [1] https://www.sas.upenn.edu/~haroldfs/dravling/grice.html https://www.sas.upenn.edu/~haroldfs/dravling/grice.html
- WesolyKubeczek 3y ago> Now you're assuming the intent. Maybe you’re not aware, but rules are all about intent. In a conflict over rules, the judge will be all about the intent. Rules work very well towards revealing the intent of all parties involved. It’s always about intent.
- mannykannot 3y agoWithout assumptions - such as what 'in the park' actually means - most of the cases are simply undecidable. This should not be taken to mean that every rule must be fully, rigorously and unambiguously specified, as this would bring an end to human discourse. Intent is often an appropriate basis for disambiguating rules like this.
- nathan_compton 3y agoIt might be a problem, but it is also an inescapable part of the human condition because, at the end of the day, rules are imaginary and all that really exist are human actions. It is pretty hopeless to complain about rules from this point of view. Assumption of intent is critical to pretty much all social functioning. In this particular case, I think its outrageously reasonable to assume that if some unusual circumstance were to prevail in the park relevant to the definition of vehicle, the sign would explicitly indicate it. And that, without further clarification, the obvious answer is the one intended.
- rossdavidh 3y agoWell, every rule and law in existence, that I can think of, has an assumed intent. That's probably a necessary condition for rules, whether it's a sign in the park or a government regulation or anything else. If people do not have, to some degree at least, a shared intent (e.g. let's have a conversation here about topic X, let's have a park to have fun or relax in, etc.) there is probably no set of rules that can specify sufficiently what can and must not be done. If you did manage to craft such a sufficiently detailed set of rules, it would be too large for people to read and understand.
- yellow_postit 3y agoAnd now I’d say you’ve rediscovered part of the authors intent. Shared intent, across cross border platforms, is awfully hard if not impossible to achieve with anything approaching consistency.
- goodrubyist 3y agoYou should really look into how judges interpret laws (rules, basically). There are two schools I know of: purposivism and textualism (I agree with the latter and it doesn't take into account intentions. That's the basis of how the recent case Van Buren v US was decided, I would recommend reading it: https://www.supremecourt.gov/opinions/20pdf/19-783_k53l.pdf https://www.supremecourt.gov/opinions/20pdf/19-783_k53l.pdf). But in both, you have things like canons of interpretation and background principles and so on. It's always awesome to see how people who have to deal with the problem have thought about it, because they have usually invested a lot of time into it and come up with insights. See also, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Statutory_interpretation https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Statutory_interpretation
- hgsgm 3y agoThe justification for textualism is that it's better to be wrong in a precise way, than to try to be right in a fuzzy way. But both models are wrong. Bit rot is real and applies to laws. It's not possible to keep laws up to date with what they would be if lawmakers had infinite resources to dedicate to lawmaking and maintenance, even ignoring the huge issue of democratic consensus and parliamentary procedure issues. (All models are wrong! Some useful!) The law is a tool which imperfectly models the goals of the lawmakers. For lawyers judges, the beauty of law is that the law has plenty of room to support contradictory interpretations.
- taeric 3y agoYou pretty much have to assume intent, though? To mind, language doesn't exist without intent. You are correct that you may be wrong on the underlying message that is being communicated, but that is basically boiling communication back to the measuring problem. You measure what is easy to measure, you say what is easy to say. (As a fun counter to your example, so it would be ok if I bring a jack hammer and start pounding away? Or a shovel and dig to my hearts content?) The silliness in this is that it boils everything down to a single rule and expects that you can define the words of the rule in a way that makes it obvious that some other meaning may be inferred. That isn't how language works. In no small part because language isn't static. Put in a way that programmers know, decently. Regular expressions can describe context free shapes of symbols. These are usually concise and people feel like they can have a hold on them. Context free grammars, though, are typically not concise and lead to all sorts of interesting theory and problems to keep them going. And, much to the frustration of near everyone, colloquial language does not have a context free grammar, even. To try and take it out of the context is to lose.
- thisisthepoint 3y ago> You pretty much have to assume intent, though? That's the crux of the issue. And the game calls this out at the very beginning. It encourages you not to speculate on if it should apply, just if it does apply. The OPs assertion that this was easy missed the point. > and obviously police and ambulances (and fire trucks) doing their jobs don't have to follow the sign. I don't believe it was obvious, and it wasn't stated goal. These are vehicles. The rule applies to them. The fact that we disagree is the entire point of this game.
- hgsgm 3y ago> Regular expressions can describe context free shapes of symbols. What is "shapes of symbols"? Do you mean "characters"? If you are trying to say that "regular languages" are a proper subset of (less expressive than) "context-free grammar" languages , probably best to leave it at that, and let people look up those well-documented terms if they want to learn more. Making up a new term distracts people who know the normal terms, and is just as confusing for people who don't.
- hammock 3y agoAnd that’s why education, and an educated society, are so important. An educated person can make a much better assessment of intent. For instance, if danger exists to a police car due to loose soil or not. The more important point here for me is not “how should we best design and interact with the rules” (that’s a pretty authoritarian question) but rather “what fundamental human conditions, like education, tend towards more productive interaction with the world, including any rules that exist”
- zamfi 3y agoMinor point perhaps, but there's no question about whether the police are violating the rule when they drive their car into the park: they are. The question is whether it was justifiable and that's not what the original game asks you to evaluate, but it is the much harder question because it is almost always subjective--as you point out. In justifiability you can start asking about intent, weigh the various costs of the action, etc.
- 13of40 3y agoWhere I live, vehicles like police cars have the letters "xmt" on the left side of their license plate. That's because they are exempt from rules like "no vehicles in the park". Per the questionnaire, if the SWAT team drove their tank into the park that would be a vehicle in the park, but they get a pass.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- konschubert 3y agoSelective enforcement of rules transfers power from the legislative to the people in charge.
- dheera 3y agoIn a lot of countries intent is in fact everything. It's common for developed countries to be more governed by written law and have that interpreted as such in court, but in many developing countries it's all about what you are trying to do.
- ouid 3y ago[dead]
- jasonlotito 3y ago> Now you're assuming the intent. The funny thing is, the game itself assumes intent. And even you assume intent. What is a vehicle? "a thing used to express, embody, or fulfill something" is one of the definitions. So, no books allowed. But then, the rule doesn't say vehicles aren't allowed to enter the park. It simple describes the state. That there are "No vehicles in the park." > But the larger point is that people can adopt the "obvious intent" version of the rule when it suits them and the pedantic version of the rule when it suits them. At the very least, the other point is that it's challenging to come up with a rule that can't be misinterpreted even when being pedantic. "No vehicles in the park." No, there are no books current in the park. Just a bunch of cars.
- EdwardDiego 3y ago> The park could contain loose soil on the edge of a cliff, so any vehicle driving there could cause a landslide that topples the vehicle over the cliff and could kill anyone on the beach below. No vehicles in the park. They really need to work on their signage wording.
- majormajor 3y agoFrom computer programming we know that strict rules for complex systems become unmaintainable messes, with countless edge cases that result in things either just not functioning or - worse - allowing people to bypass the rules entirely to, e.g., run malware. So the complaint about rules that involve human discretion strikes me as extremely hollow. We know what trying to write no-discretion rules looks like. We know it almost always still ends up allowing plenty of abuses of the system. To prevent that we need more eyes and more human judgement on things, not less.
- nektro 3y ago> Now you're assuming the intent. Communities are built on intent and learning the culture of the group. Anyone who does not understand this should get into law, not internet moderation.