18 ms·
Intelligent people take longer to solve hard problems: study
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- devnull255 3y agoIf I try giving this as an explanation for churn on any issue I'm investigating, they'll probably take longer paying me ...
- entropicgravity 3y agoAh, that's my problem with the 2nd Law of Thermodynamics.
- kstrauser 3y agoProblem: I need to typeset a book. Normal person: typesets the book Knuth: takes a decade to solve book typesetting once and for all I wonder if the intelligent people tend to solve more general problem classes and then apply that to the specific problem at hand.
- danq_ 3y agoThere are two measures of intelligence: Correctness and Speed. Correctness is the primary measure, and if two parties are correct then speed differentiates their level of intelligence. This is the only measure that has been quantified and scientifically correlated with many other attributes of human existence like success and happiness. This measure is is called IQ. If both people get an answer correct, then literally, by definition, the stupider person will be the person who takes longer to arrive at the correct answer. Remember: IQ tests are timed. This study is sort of a play on the very definition of what it means to be stupid. Again, IQ tests are timed for a reason. The real title of this is should be: Stupid people take less time to arrive at a wrong answer then smart people take to arrive at the correct answer. This is sort of a useless study, because yeah, I can answer the hardest questions in the entire universe with the wrong answer almost instantaneously. Of course wrong answers will be faster. The fact that most of you aren't noticing this says something about your intelligence. Maybe you guys are just taking too long to notice this, so in that case according to this study you're all smarter than a dumb dumb like me.
- foota 3y agogreen user to shadow banned speedrun?
- danq_ 3y ago[dead]
- Noumenon72 3y agoIt's not clear to me from Google that IQ tests are timed. Some sections of some tests are. I don't think any test is like "For question 4, you get 10 points for answering within 2 seconds, 5 points within 4 seconds, and 0 after." A time limit on the test could just be to keep you from accidentally measuring conscientiousness in people who are willing to spend 10 hours to get everything right. That said I'm pretty sure reaction time and "clock speed" are part of intelligence, just correlated well enough that you don't need a reflex test added onto the paper test.
- danq_ 3y agoParts of it are timed. I know because my brother is a trained administrator of giving these tests. Even without the concept of an IQ test the fact that if you were given two people who both answered 50 questions correctly, one person took a full day to complete the questions while another person answered them in all in 2 minutes. Clearly our conceptual intuition of intelligence says the Faster person by literal definition of "intelligence" is more intelligent. Like what is the experiment in this article measuring here? If it's comparing people who got the exact same test scores then the experimenter can't identify differing levels of intelligence because everyone got everything right. How can they say the faster person is stupider then the slower person if the scores are the same? The only way to truly compare is to find people who got the answers wrong, but in this case your measuring the speed of arrival at a wrong answer which is in itself a pointless measurement. Obviously wrong answers are faster to come up with and obviously a person with more wrong answers is going to be faster and stupider then the person with right answers.
- harry8 3y agoStupid people don't understand risk and do dangerously rushed jobs: study The headline writing is known to be idiotic here (including mine) and everywhere. Article content is no better. I can get nothing else from this.
- Uptrenda 3y agoEveryone here just like: t-this is why I procrastinate, can't meet deadlines, or finish anything... I-I'm a very profound thinker ;___;
- smeej 3y agoThe conclusion in the title doesn't at all follow from the study in the article. Intelligent people know they have what it takes to get the answer right, so they spend the time to do it. Less intelligent people are familiar with their limits and their odds of getting the right answer, so they do some of the reasoning, quit, and guess from there. That's why the intelligent people aren't just slower, but more accurate. They're actually solving the problems. The others are reaching the end of their ability much more quickly and guessing.
- softbt 3y agoGonna start telling people I’m actually intelligent when they say I’m slow from now on
- hyperliner 3y ago[dead]
- robertakarobin 3y agoOoh, that's a much better explanation for my zillion half-finished projects. I'm not an undisciplined perfectionist, I'm just too intelligent. :)
- carabiner 3y agoDamn straight.
- robertakarobin 3y agoIn the words of Calvin and Hobbes, "You know how Einstein got bad grades as a kid? Well, MINE are even WORSE!""
- acchow 3y agoMaybe subclinical ADHD?
- robertakarobin 3y agoWhy not both?
- hateful 3y agoI know I am Twice Exceptional[1] in that regard. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Twice_exceptional https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Twice_exceptional
- Madmallard 3y agoIt's very likely just not enough incentive to go through the difficult and lengthy unfun parts. That's most people. It's not abnormal.
- PartiallyTyped 3y agoDupe: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36172461 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36172461
- lapcat 3y agoAlso https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36160582 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36160582 and https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36211454 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36211454
- pazimzadeh 3y agoOn the other hand, "more intelligent" people's brains work less hard during reasoning. https://www.nature.com/articles/s41467-018-04268-8 https://www.nature.com/articles/s41467-018-04268-8
- Solvency 3y agoSomething tells me trying to bluntly define "more" and "less intelligent" and then compare the two groups with blanket studies like this is utterly ridiculous.
- Frameshift 3y agoThe "less likely to jump to conclusions" is the important part. This doesn't necessarily mean they are slower at processing information.
- no_butterscotch 3y agoYup. I also wonder if they could see another part of the brain to see if intelligent people are more concerned of judgement from other intelligent people, or perhaps even from everyone in general for some intelligent people that intelligence is their identity.
- elcritch 3y ago> The findings challenge the assumption that higher intelligence is the result of a faster brain. They suggest that faster is not necessarily better, and that under certain circumstances there is a tradeoff between speed and accuracy which results in better decisions. Talk about conflating different aspects of something to arrive at faulty logic. There clearly is a relationship between higher intelligence and a faster brain, to some degree. However faster thinking enables more sophisticated searching of complex problem spaces.
- s1artibartfast 3y ago>There clearly is a relationship between higher intelligence and a faster brain, to some degree. However faster thinking enables more sophisticated searching of complex problem spaces. I don't think that's clear at all. The confusion is around different definitions of speed and different definitions of the task. You have the speed to process data points or variables, and the speed to come to a result. You also have the number of variables used to calculate a result and the number of variables needed to come to a result. It is reasonable to believe that some brains can process the same data faster than others. It is also reasonable to believe that some brains consider more variables than others. However, more variables is not always better. You can process faster, and include more variables, but still perform worse overall if you are using too many unecessary variables. In terms of computing, an example would be multiplying 2x2. A slower computer can give you a result faster if it is representing 2 as a 2-bit number than a faster computer representing it as a 64-bit number
- david38 3y agoI think of it as a computer with moderately fast registers but horribly slow main memory. In this case, more registers would clearly show a win. BUT a more organized person would eventually win as the number of variables grow. Hence why systems and habits beat out raw intelligence on general life success, but why an intelligent person lives a simple life on easy mode and why those at the (uninherited) top are often scary smart AND hard core driven and organized.
- 3y ago
- nerdo 3y agoPeople who don't attempt the answer just guess, which takes less time than solving. News at 11.
- biomcgary 3y agoAlthough your response is a bit clever, I think you capture the actual dynamic, which the paper (https://www.nature.com/articles/s41467-023-38626-y https://www.nature.com/articles/s41467-023-38626-y) tries to obscure by avoiding the comparisons (time taken for each correctly answered question vs incorrect) needed to make it obvious.
- alach11 3y agoOn a multiple choice test, does it really matter if they filter to only correct answers? Guessing will still result in fast answers, and be correct 25% of the time.
- alexfromapex 3y agoIntelligence is related to increased perception throughput abilities, i.e. neural volume and density, so more intelligent people are processing more information which takes slightly longer (probably logarithmic). It all ties back to the same sort of results in neural networks. Not sure why I got downvoted...seems studies support my conclusion.
- jawns 3y agoA while back, I created an online experiment, based on a 2020 study, that identifies dogmatic thinking. https://shaungallagher.pressbin.com/blog/dogmatism.html https://shaungallagher.pressbin.com/blog/dogmatism.html Without giving too much away, this tracks with the 2023 study's results, in that people with higher intelligence scores are less likely to trust their System 1 gut reaction and more likely to involve their System 2 deliberate, logical processes.
- KennyBlanken 3y agoA 2% difference in scores between the most and least dogmatic users means your test complete hogwash. Your refusal to provide any data beyond averages is very telling. My guess is that there's a very wide distribution of scores, little trend, and very little correlation.
- mcint 3y agoThis link would better serve you and the community as a top-level post. I guess you did share it 2 years ago, though it looks like commenting is now closed. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26620690 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26620690 Share it again! The iron is hot! I find the initial paragraphs of analysis rather insistent, one might say dogmatic, in their praise of non-dogmatism. Some later paragraphs express my immediate response: perhaps this dogmatism varies based on your relationship to your current information environment. I'll suggest that consideration of these numbers might be better supported by tables to show participant and average numbers, and invite comparisons.
- mcint 3y agoAnd if you share it again, link from (a reply to) your comment.
- wincy 3y agoSo, I'm a little frustrated with this because it doesn't tell me how many times I opted for the easier version, just the average, because it seemed like a low cost to pay, I did it almost every time, (which it states is the rational thing to do) but then I also scored as very dogmatic, and got almost exactly average on the test. The conclusions it drew about this were that I was not open to new information, which is totally off. I DID ask for new information almost every single time, far and above what the average participant requests. The important thing isn't the performance on the test but how often the person requested new information, but then this metric is completely discarded in the final assessment! I'm not sure what exactly this is meant to measure. It feels like it's just smugly calling me dumb for thinking I know better than the average person (which, if I didn't, why would I believe what I believe?) I only believe things I already have a high degree of confidence in, and it would take good evidence to sway me from those opinions. If this is close minded, being "open minded" seems like a good way for your brain to just fall out of your head.
- jollyllama 3y agoIs this innately biological, or have intelligent people just been trained not to jump to conclusions/trust their gut, while this training was not as successful in other population segments?
- poomer 3y agoThese shape matching questions are the problems asked in the study: https://www.researchgate.net/profile/Jordan-Barbone-2/publication/332778825/figure/fig8/AS:753575709921281@1556677858251/Penn-Matrix-Analysis-Test-PMAT-example.ppm https://www.researchgate.net/profile/Jordan-Barbone-2/public... I would bet that quite a few people just guess when they find this type of question too difficult.
- alach11 3y ago> I would bet that quite a few people just guess when they find this type of question too difficult. Psych research is such garbage. Of course people are going to start guessing if the problems are boring and they can't solve them. They tried to account for this by comparing timings of only correct answers. But on a multiple choice test, even random guessing will be correct (and fast!) sometimes.
- chankstein38 3y agoHonestly this makes the most sense to me. I guessed first before thinking it through and if I were doing the test and it were timed I might've just guessed.
- booleandilemma 3y agoCan we also rephrase this as: if you want to be more intelligent, slow down and take the time to think through a problem?
- ChainOfFools 3y agoI strongly suspect this effect is correlated with a weakness in short-term or working memory. Independent of general intelligence is the necessity for those with a weak short-term or working memory to compensate by relying on long-term, in depth understanding in order to JIT the necessary short-term structures into being on the spot, (often repeatedly as these images decay rapidly) in order to solve a problem. Whereas those with a short-term memory advantage can simply rely on memorized sets of arbitrary relationships to address the problem. In other words if you have a weak short-term or working memory you have to, by necessity, deeply think through everything - whether simple or complex. This may allow spotting the rare inconsistency or opportunity others may not, but as it comes at a performance and time penalty which, under circumstances commonly encountered in one's educational career (timed examinations) it more typically results in filtering such people out of fields where excursive, highly lateral modes of thinking would be beneficial. To survive this filter one must either acquire (or be gifted with) the talent of exceptionally swift traversal of a large and heterogeneous general knowledge graph, as one cannot rely on a handful of tightly knit but relatively isolated silos of memorized specialization.
- coldblues 3y agoA lot of replies here talk about short term memory, needing to truly understand information on a deep level and have the "why?" question answered, using software to externalize information and a lot more that I can't really mention right now on a phone in the middle of the night browsing HN and coming across this gem. A lot of this stuff seems highly related to ADHD. I exhibit them, and have done quite some amateur research myself on these behaviors and others seem to relate as well. P.S: I am also an i3wm user btw ;)
- growingkittens 3y agoI have a childhood brain injury that affects my working memory and sequencing ability, among other things. I think in pictures with a verbal commentary, although words disappear soon after I think them. My brain stores information everywhere it can fit: in emotions, music, patterns, movement, etc. Interpreting reality is fraught with error. You describe the effect very well. I am working on a personal knowledge system to compensate. What are your ideas on this subject? Popular PKS systems expect the user to adapt to "the system," rather than adapting to the user's particular set of needs. I consider each user to be a unique combination of common components.
- pcurve 3y agoI don't claim to be intelligent, but I do dread doing group brainstorming sessions using Post-it notes because it takes me time to think about the problem. I'm usually the the guy in the group with the fewest notes. I've rarely see anything useful come out of these sessions, even though I've participated in hundreds of these with different people, companies, and settings.
- jamesdelaneyie 3y agoYour goal during the ideation phase of those workshops should be to output as many post its as possible in the given time. Output the bad ideas quickly and you'll move along to better ideas much faster when you're not humming and hawing over one post it. You have to be ok with looking slightly crazy however and not mind being linked to your poor ideas.
- lanstin 3y agoYeah, I'll have no answer the first day of mulling over a complex problem, but often I'll have an excellent answer the next day. It's worked well for my own work, but sometimes people are surprised that the slow seeming person, me, has useful ideas.
- wizeman 3y ago> needed more time to solve challenging tasks but made fewer errors [1] As someone else said, I can solve problems very quickly if the solutions don't have to be correct... But more seriously, it seems like different people might have different thresholds for when they consider a problem solved? If you decide to go back and review the problem and solution (even just mentally) to make sure you didn't make mistakes, of course that would take longer and give you more correct answers than the person who doesn't do that? [1] https://www.bihealth.org/en/notices/intelligent-brains-take-longer-to-solve-difficult-problems https://www.bihealth.org/en/notices/intelligent-brains-take-...
- dimal 3y agoThis must be why I can’t do well in any coding interviews. I’m just too damn smart.
- pschuegr 3y agoYep. Going to mention that next time. "I'm too smart to solve this quickly, can I get back to you next week?"
- adverbly 3y agoRelated: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vKA4w2O61Xo https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vKA4w2O61Xo TL;DW: I have a rule and you need to figure it out. The rule relates to a sequence of three numbers. You can propose a sequence and I’ll tell you yes/no if it meets the rule. I’ll give you the first sequence to get you started: sequence: 2,4,8 passes: Yes
- paulpauper 3y agoI think people are overreading into this, assuming the results even mean much anyway. people who score higher on timed tests which corelate well with IQ, such as the Wonderlic or the SATs, are smarter.
- ChainOfFools 3y agoThere's a confounding factor here, which is that people who score poorly could do so either because they could not solve the problem at all, or because they took too long to solve it (due to having to create mental tooling on the spot that others could buy off the shelf through memorization) and had reached only a partial result. In timed standardized exams where work is not shown or graded, both results are equally assigned zero points. As AI, even the ersatz AI available currently, becomes more sophisticated and widespread the value of a human who can mimic the capabilities of a machine will diminish rapidly. Creative and explorative thinkers will, provided they are not merely skilled at the derivative "craft" of performative creativity but are truly creating value without precedent, will accordingly become increasingly sought after.
- beepbooptheory 3y agoI always find it so strange and a little creepy to treat "intelligent" as a category like "brown haired" or "diabetic." You take a test and receive a score (an "intelligence score" apparently) and if you are past X points you are intelligent. Now you are among the set of intelligent people in the world. I know this is an agreed upon reality (especially among us nerdy types), but it always rubbed me the wrong way. Even bracketing off all the very real issues around measurement tools here, it always felt in general like neurotic pursuit to quantify the qualitative, or even an egoistic pursuit to claim superiority out of thin air. And I read articles like these, and I can't help but feel slightly validated despite their presuppositions: maybe there isnt a spectrum of intelligences, but just heterogenous minds. We have come up with these tests, but they just show how well a person is at that test that we happen to call "an intelligence test." But you start digging deeply with the numbers... and of course you going to get counter intuitive results! You have investigated categories that are themselves sustained out of thinnest of scientific consensus and dubious ideological origins, delegating your measurement to fraught tools laden with cultural specificity. It just feels crazy to me, it feels like never leaving grade school. But maybe they'll find "intelligence" one day, and then I'll have to eat my shoe while waiting in line to be recycled because I didn't pass muster as an intelligent human.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- foxbyte 3y agoThis complements the idea that problem-solving is the essence of intelligence. It's not always about speed, but the quality of decisions made, especially in complex situations
- feiszli 3y agoOh wow I must be a genius...
- giovannibonetti 3y agoRelated: Thinking, Fast and Slow, by Daniel Kahneman. According to Wikipedia [1]: "The book's main thesis is a differentiation between two modes of thought: "System 1" is fast, instinctive and emotional; "System 2" is slower, more deliberative, and more logical." Intelligent people might rely more on System 2 than ordinary people, which pushes latency up. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Thinking,_Fast_and_Slow https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Thinking,_Fast_and_Slow
- thorncorona 3y agoA large portion of the effects and studies mentioned in that book have been retracted or refuted, just fyi.
- giovannibonetti 3y agoWow, good to know!
- jbotz 3y agoA "large portion" is an exaggeration, and I don't know that any have been "refuted". Some of the studies around "priming" (Chapter 4 of the book) have been called into question for failure of being replicated, and Kahnemann himself has since said that the published studies on priming may not be replicable. Since the publication of the book we've had a "replication crisis" in the relevant literature, so the book may not be on as solid ground as Kahnemann believed when he wrote it, but it's still a very good book with important insights.
- dorianmariefr 3y agoSo we have to be the smartest because it's been 3 months we are investigating an issue :D
- hax0ron3 3y agoThe title of the article should be "People with higher intelligence scores take longer to solve complex problems". Let's say that I define being very intelligent as being able to rapidly solve hard problems. I think this is a reasonable definition of the word "intelligent". Indeed, I think that it is in many ways a more meaningful definition of "intelligence" than defining it as scoring well on intelligence tests. Well, then the article title becomes self-contradictory.
- commandlinefan 3y agoYeah, the title (and the article) doesn't say "than what". If intelligent people take longer to solve complex problems than stupid people, then stupid people are smart and smart people are stupid. But the article doesn't really explain that either.
- ldehaan 3y ago[dead]
- fxtentacle 3y agoExtremely misleading title, in my opinion. Let me quote the actual research at https://www.nature.com/articles/s41467-023-38626-y https://www.nature.com/articles/s41467-023-38626-y : "subjects with higher PMAT24_A_CR (fluid intelligence) made fewer mistakes, but were slower" Yes, intelligent people took longer to solve hard problems. But they made fewer mistakes. Getting things right on the 1st try might be much faster than needing a 2nd attempt, even if the 1st try takes 20% longer.
- NotYourLawyer 3y agoSocial science is ridiculous. What a non-result.
- mordae 3y agoActually, solving problem quick and dirty, putting the solution to a test and iterating will probably result in better outcomes than simply thinking super hard and making less attempts for a whole bunch of tasks. It sure helps to be able to iterate quickly in software development for one. It has reminded me of an exchange from Shirobako (best anime ever, 100/100, watch it even if you prefer other forms); older animator is telling their younger colleague to learn to draw faster, because while they can work on the quality for the rest of their life, but they won't be able to draw fast when they are older. Drawing faster means more iterations, means more experience gained overall.
- thorncorona 3y agoIf what you're doing is getting a math problem correct than I would imagine doing it once correctly is the fastest approach...
- proc0 3y agoSlow is smooth, smooth is fast. Forgot where that's from but I think it's a Navy or Marine saying.
- jandrewrogers 3y ago
- boredumb 3y agoIn my experience when you're younger you can make a decision quickly without thinking through a lot of the edge cases and it works most of the time so it's much faster and just as good. Most of the time.
- robbywashere_ 3y agoShame that whiteboard problem took you 1hr (and 5 minutes) to solve. NEXT!
- sobriquet9 3y agoPeople with higher intelligence scores, not intelligent people.