10 ms·
Have you been to the library lately?
- damnesian 3y ago>Now they have to deal with mental health episodes, the homelessness crisis, and random violence And people who have jumped on the right-wing bandwagon trying to censor and control libraries have siezed on this, blaming libraries for endangering children. Really shameful behavior. Rather than solve social problems, let's demonize the few places where all people, if they behave themselves, are welcome.
- ochoseis 3y agoI love that I live in a city with a robust library system. I can borrow books online, and check out books from distant branches by having them moved to my local one. The last time I actually went into my local branch to do some focused reading every chair and table was filled with other folks doing the same thing. That is, except for one whole table that a homeless guy had commandeered to lay out his belongings, and was circling and grunting. The guy clearly needed the kind of help you’re not going to find in a library. My city shelters everyone, and has a generous safety net. I don’t know what else to do, but realized the library isn’t the place to go for a library-like atmosphere. Luckily the library cordons off the children’s section on a separate floor where adults aren’t generally permitted.
- seneca 3y ago> And people who have jumped on the right-wing bandwagon trying to censor and control libraries have siezed on this, blaming libraries for endangering children. Really shameful behavior. When shared social resources are turned into political operatives, it's not the fault of the opposition when they are attacked. If you want something to be treated as neutral, it needs to act with neutrality.
- 2301421898 3y ago> If you want something to be treated as neutral, it needs to act with neutrality. What constitutes "neutrality" is constantly changing. In order to remain politically neutral, in recent years, one would need to increasingly censor themselves. For example, in 2019, wearing N95s during wildfire season to avoid inhaling smoke wasn't politically charged. Some people would wear them when outside and others didn't--nobody cared. This month, with wildfire smoke in the air, it has now become political (and decidedly not neutral) to say what was said in 2019--that N95s can help protect you from wildfire smoke.
- wrycoder 3y agoWell, they can. You’ll notice the smoke when you take it off. Now, if you virtuously don one at the first faint hint of smoke, be my guest. But, don’t give me the stink eye, if I don’t.
- PKop 3y agoLibraries have become dangerous harassment centers where drug addicts and people with mental problems congregate and assault normal people wanting to read books... and it's the group the opposes this, says it is absurd and should not be accepted and who want to get these people the hell out of the libraries who should feel shame? No, I propose it is those that enable this problem and degrade our public spaces who should be ashamed.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- karaterobot 3y agoThis isn't new by any means. It was one reason I swerved away from the profession after getting my MLIS degree almost twenty years ago. I like books, I don't want to be a babysitter or a first responder. Of course the other reason, very much related, is that the pay isn't great. I had a graduate degree and didn't make a living wage, and looking at the salary ladder I wasn't going to be making what a first-year developer made for like... 20 years to ever. But I still go to the library almost every weekend.
- Mezzie 3y agoGot mine 8 years ago and same. Granted, I also got MS and then was geographically restricted, but those are the reasons I haven't looked at employment at the local public libraries. It's really depressing that the skills I have that are worth the most are those I learned as a child, but it is what it is.
- samtho 3y agoThe library is one of the last places where you can exist without the expectation of buying something. I’m not some anti-capitalist at all, but I do recognize the role in which public facilities like the library play. Ideally, they provide a space essential for free and open access, within in a local community, free at the point of delivery.
- secstate 3y agoThat's a pretty brilliant observation. On nice days, public parks look similar to the library (and increasingly have the same vagrancy and drug problems, ha!). But public parks don't need staff like a library so it's less obvious who's job it should be to kick everyone out at night.
- Terr_ 3y agoI've seen that observation a lot, the oldest expression of it I can find (with the key phrase "expectation of buying something") is from this union publication in July 2018: > A library is one of the last truly public spaces, where you can go to get out of the elements or meet with people without the expectation of buying something. [0] https://www.afscme.org/blog/camden-county-library-workers-ratify-contract-after-a-year-of-activism https://www.afscme.org/blog/camden-county-library-workers-ra...
- chrisco255 3y agoI go to state and national parks all the time. You don't really see vagrancy problems in the majority of them, but they all have park rangers whose job it is to police that. Many parks, of course, let you camp overnight up to two weeks at a time.
- dolmen 3y agoThis is about city parks.
- chrisco255 3y ago
- orange_joe 3y agoThe societies of North America have totally abandoned the middle class and its ambitions. Instead of staying true to their goals of education, libraries have become daytime homeless shelters driving away their original patrons. So have busses, and trains. Schools have opted out of their obligations to provide the best educations to the public instead tailoring the education to the least capable. Ultimately this will lead to the further hollowing of our civil society as the middle class realizes the bureaucratic core does not have their best interests at heart. But Brutus is an honorable man.
- klyrs 3y ago> libraries have become daytime homeless shelters My library looks nothing like this. You're painting all libraries with a broad brush, generalizing from a very small number of libraries in the downtown core of a handful of cities. But yeah. Our view of homelessness as a personal failure of the homeless person, rather than a societal failure to care for its people, is not working. More punishment and less services only exacerbates the problem.
- zmgsabst 3y agoExcept that it’s cities which prioritize services that have this problem — eg, Seattle.
- klyrs 3y agoIt's also the cities for which housing is most unaffordable.
- WalterBright 3y agoSeattle has a levy on the ballot for a massive increase in property taxes in order to make housing more affordable. I am not making this up.
- RugnirViking 3y ago
- hnal943 3y agoThis is a really clear explanation that libraries have drifted from their original purpose and public funds could be better used elsewhere.
- JohnFen 3y agoIt seems to me that libraries would prefer not to deal with this stuff either. Much like how police are often dealing with things that aren't really police matters, the reason for this state is that we as a society have decided to largely abandon people in dire need. Libraries (and police, and other services) are left to deal with this problem by default, because we as a society don't value finding solutions to the problem enough to bother to do that.
- secstate 3y agoIs it possible that rather than abandoning people in dire need, we're now actually trying hard to help those in need instead of criminalizing bad luck and pretending they don't exist, but that that is exceedingly hard to do well?
- JohnFen 3y agoThere is certainly a greater interest in finding real solutions than there has been for decades, yes, and there are absolutely certain groups that are trying hard. I think the trendlines are heading the right direction here. But, as a society in general, I think we're not actually trying hard yet. We're still largely debating whether or not we should be.
- PKop 3y agoThese people can't be helped. Meanwhile, you are harming functioning healthy people and destroying any public space at great cost to everyone paying the bill. We are all sick of it.
- JohnFen 3y ago> These people can't be helped. It might be interesting to actually try to help these people before writing them off entirely like that.
- jfengel 3y agoThe librarians I know are proud of the way the role of the library has expanded. They don't think of themselves as in charge of books. They think of themselves as in charge of using knowledge to help people. They don't necessarily want to be in charge of providing other needs for the homeless. But their question is: where else are those homeless supposed to go? The library is the most visible public-facing aspect of the government. If they can leverage that to bring services to people, that's a good start. The solution is not to ban the homeless from the libraries. The solution is to bring the rest of homeless services and support to the place where the homeless are.
- Teever 3y agoThe librarians you know support this because they've been tricked by their managers and society into taking on a tremendous amount of dangerous and stressful work for free. It isn't reasonable that we expect librarians to do this kind of work, and I would argue that there are elements of doing so that are outright illegal.
- Mezzie 3y agoAlso the ones who don't support this...leave. It's one reason why I won't work in public libraries as someone with an MLIS.
- prawn 3y ago"Master of Library and Information Science", for anyone else who didn't know.
- zdragnar 3y agoThis field draws on a lot of the same people who are drawn to social work. They know they're not going to make big money doing it, but they're going to get into it anyway because taking on the profession is a virtuous thing to do. There's a degree of willing self sacrifice, especially since (like other similar fields, such as museum curation) it practically takes someone dying for a position to open up. Given all of this, these librarians aren't being tricked by anyone. It's just one more moral, virtuous thing to do for the community, despite not having the training or support to handle anything but the easy cases.
- at_a_remove 3y agoI worked in a library, though not as a librarian, for a long time. And I had worked in one as a high school student. I no longer support libraries as they stand. Most of their current issues are self-inflicted. I will now lay out why. The Internet came along, and Google of course. (You remember when Google seemed to have the correct answer to everything, in the past) And then the scanning of books, and the librarians panicked. They had an identity crisis: What good is a library in the age of Google? This contagious panic spread and the usual questions came about. "What will we be, then?" And they immediately started trying to be everything to everyone. In a university setting, that means that various small groups will immediately come looking. Maybe the library can help us! And so the library begins to do things outside of its original scope, further and further. We begin housing various student groups, despite not having enough space for books. Checking the logs of the prayer room and the breastfeeding room was a little bitter, but we still need that ... but we have too many books. Named faculty carrels, we keep those, but we have too many books. Bathrooms we have, but that one woman just likes to empty her bladder in the elevator. Librarians, in their helpfulness but lack of identity, have become janitors and people who help you fill out your tax forms and security guards who have to keep an eye out for that guy who likes to jerk off on Level A, in the back. I received a survey from my library a couple of years ago. Multiple choice: "Are our libraries A) doing enough to help LGBTQ people? B) not doing enough?" Note the lack of the third option, maybe you're focusing on them too much because WHERE ARE THE BOOKS? My local "civilian" library doesn't seem to have anything to lend that isn't recent any longer. It's Redbox for books. The shelves are fewer, the shelves are shorter, the shelves have been shoved back for "community spaces." The local loan system is garbage, the statewide system is getting thinner and thinner, and inter-library loan beyond that, well, it used to be great, but they're shoveling out books (and I'm not talking about that thirty-ninth copy of Twilight which was once in hot demand but isn't any longer) that were once in most branches I visited. Many academic libraries are playing a game of Hearts. There's only two ways to win Hearts. The first involves getting rid of your Hearts before the other players do, paring down books. The other involves trying to collect all the hearts, which makes you the hub of an interlibrary loan system that externalizes the cost of having and housing books, which is not insignificant. Before she retired, a librarian passed on to me a shocking paper describing the cost per year of the average book just to exist on a shelf. Most people don't think about that. No, I don't think a middle ground is what is called for. Get back to books, by which I mean, the acquisition and organization of information such that the depth of it can be accessed by those in need of it, perhaps more so than they really understand, not just the first thing that Google (or ChatGPT) vomits out.
- n8cpdx 3y agoSee also: https://www.theverge.com/2023/6/14/23760787/san-francisco-public-library-wifi-homeless-castro-district-8 https://www.theverge.com/2023/6/14/23760787/san-francisco-pu...
- Animats 3y ago> "In the late 1970s, “homelessness” as we know it today didn’t really exist; the issue only emerged as a serious social problem in the 1980s." This is worth remembering.
- david2ndaccount 3y agoVagrancy used to be a crime.
- AlanSE 3y agoI honestly, genuinely, fail to understand the meaning of that. It can't possibly be true that homeless people didn't exist before the 1980s. What does this actually mean?
- loeg 3y agoPossibly a reference to deinstitutionalization in the 1970s.
- PKop 3y agoCrimes and harassment were punished, not put up with and subsidized.
- treis 3y agoThe mentally ill were confined to institutions. The more functioning homeless put enough scratch together to get a place at a flophouse. I think it's also policing. There was a time that a bum who got caught in the wrong place got the crap kicked out of them by the cops. Obviously problematic for so many reasons but violence does have its way of modifying behavior. Also drugs. Just way easier to get and more powerful than before. Back then it was mostly alcohol. While that takes a terrible toll on one's body most alcoholics are functional to a reasonable extent. Not so much for crack or heroin or meth addicts.
- Animats 3y agoFirst, there were more big housing projects [1], and more welfare. Those created their own problems - third generation welfare moms, gangs, etc. Second, more crazies were institutionalized. Santa Clara County used to have "The Great Asylum for the Insane.", opened in 1885. This was a huge complex of buildings in a rural setting. The place was later renamed to Agnews State Mental Hospital, later Agnews Developmental Center.[2] Beginning in 1972 this was gradually shut down. The last patient was kicked out in 1998. The remaining buildings are now owned by Oracle, and you can go look at some of them if you want. Third, vagrancy used to be be illegal. Cops arrested people for it, and they were sorted out into "too lazy to work", "unable to work", or "crazy". This peaked during the Great Depression, when the Works Progress Administration was created to give unemployed people jobs.[3] At peak, the Federal government employed 3 million people, mostly doing construction work. There was some really nice construction. Rincon Annex, the old post office in San Francisco, is one of the finer local examples. As the demand for unskilled labor declined, finding some place to send the "too lazy to work" people became difficult. Fourth, drugs. There are too many burned-out people who aren't coming back. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Robert_Taylor_Homes https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Robert_Taylor_Homes [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Agnews_Developmental_Center https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Agnews_Developmental_Center [3] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Works_Progress_Administration https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Works_Progress_Administration
- secstate 3y agoNot to be a totally wet blanket, but I often hear a lot of "it didn't used to be like this" or "the purpose of libraries" thrown out in discussions like this. Carnegie's vast wealth single-handedly forced the idea of libraries that weren't just for rich university students, privileged religious orders or the mind-bendingly affluent. He loved books and wanted to share them, which is very noble. But he also had no room for slackers. To quote wikipedia, quoting, Carnegie: > Carnegie believed in giving to the "industrious and ambitious; not those who need everything done for them, but those who, being most anxious and able to help themselves, deserve and will be benefited by help from others." This vision of the public library as public welfare's physical manifestation is a modern invention that is not anchored in history. That doesn't mean it shouldn't be. My partner was a librarian for a long time and loved helping those in need. But let's make sure we're accurately remembering the past, not designing a convenient past to justify the budgets to do the work we see we need done in the present.
- chkaloon 3y agoNot sure libraries wanted that role foisted on them. Sounds like they became the default because they were open access, and society gave up on things like mental institutions (yes, there were abuses, but imo we went too far and threw the baby out with the bath water) and aren't dealing with the issues effectively. Libraries are dealing with them because they are all there is.
- lapcat 3y ago> This vision of the public library as public welfare's physical manifestation is a modern invention that is not anchored in history. It didn't need to be. It wasn't like they were turning away the homeless with library door security guards back then. It simply wasn't a problem. From the article: "In every public place, the evidence of a social welfare system that has been chipped away at for decades is on display." The library has become a last resort, by default. The solution is "doing things that are much more difficult: building more social housing, hiring more social workers, investing in mental health workers, schools, community centres, and everything else needed to address problems before they reach the library’s doors"
- ThalesX 3y agoI go to the National Library of my backwards little country; some 2 - 3 times per week, when I know I won't have a lot of meetings and I want to focus on work. I go there, in the silence, find a nice place to sit down, plug my laptop, connect to the wifi and start up the IDE. I don't need to buy anything, I don't need to talk to anyone, it's chill in the summer and just a bit too chilly in the winter. It costs me $5 / year (parking space included...) and if I'm lucky I get a seat with an amazing view. Going to and from there on foot is also a bit of exercise. Before discovering this hidden marvel, which is actually a huge building, I never liked the loudness of working in a cafe until one day when it hit me, why not try the library. Haven't looked back since.
- PKop 3y ago[flagged]
- JohnFen 3y ago> Why do we glorify the vagrants and mentally ill that do this? Nobody is glorifying anyone.
- ineedasername 3y ago> Why do we glorify the vagrants and mentally ill that do this? How has this been glorified? Separately, Yes— people that exhibit this behavior should be dealt with using laws against that behavior, but as a society we can’t just foot the bill for all of that and say “problem solved”. We need to understand the extremely complex interwoven factors that gave rise to that behavior to address the root cause instead of just playing whack-a-mole with the symptoms.
- lapcat 3y ago> These people should be thrown in jail, not allowed to roam the streets harassing everyone. Do you know how much jails cost? More than homeless shelters, indeed more than homes, more than libraries, more than schools. Locking people up is the worst, least efficient solution to our problems.
- simonsarris 3y agoActually, for stopping librarians being sexually assaulted jail works really well. It is the most efficient solution out of the ones you've proffered as less expensive, because those do not solve the problem at hand.
- lapcat 3y ago> Actually, for stopping librarians being sexually assaulted jail works really well. Does it? Are you proposing a lifetime sentence for all homeless people, with no possibility of parole? Otherwise, people get out of jail eventually, and then what? Moreover, rising housing prices produce more and more homeless, so there's a supply issue. The least expensive solution would likely be to just give homes to the homeless. And guess what, it's actually significantly easier to get a job if you have a home, because a home gives you a home address (try putting "none" on a job application), a shower, a closet to put work clothes, a decent night's sleep, etc. As a society, however, we've decided that we're not interested in the least expensive solution, because we don't want to eliminate homelessness, we want to punish homelessness. Giving homes to the homeless would not allow us to be judgmental against the homeless, and that seems to be a very high priority for a lot of people.
- richjdsmith 3y agoMy local small-town library has become a pseudo homeless shelter. It’s exactly as this article describes. Often I’ll go in and there will be a local homeless person muttering in the corner. That has certainly dissuaded me from going regularly.
- oh_sigh 3y agoSame here - well, small city library (Boulder, CO). Late last year we even had to shut down our library for multiple weeks, because methamphetamine was detected during testing, because people were smoking it in the library. https://www.nytimes.com/2023/01/04/us/boulder-colorado-meth-library.html https://www.nytimes.com/2023/01/04/us/boulder-colorado-meth-...
- dhuk_2018 3y agoDon't worry, we're opening another pseudo day shelter in NoBo!
- Mezzie 3y agoIt's also the main reason I have no interest in working in public libraries at the moment. I studied to help manage information, not babysit or be a social worker.
- squeaky-clean 3y agoI couldn't even tell you the quality of my local library because they are only open from 10am-5pm and aren't open on Sundays. Those hours are fine for students, but how is anyone with a job supposed to be able to visit?
- kccqzy 3y agoSame here. I end up only going to the library to pick up books I requested to borrow online and to return books. It's rare if I actually stay in the library to read.
- wolpoli 3y agoI am not sure the reason for these articles talking evolving the library and providing homeless services and supports. There are already resource centers with services and supports that homeless need, which may duplicate what libraries already offer, eg. computers. They are staffed with people from their community as well.
- bombcar 3y agoThe libraries are taken advantage of because they don’t enforce the same standards that homeless service centers do, often because of unfamiliarity. Sadly, they eventually learn what to do.
- ghuntley 3y agoI work from libraries all the time. Love them.
- jemmyw 3y agoI visit the library quite often. My kids love going. If I'm waiting for something, like my car being serviced so I can't get home, then the library is the best place for doing some quiet work.
- charlie0 3y agoSoon we'll need to have a police officer stationed at libraries, just like at some schools.
- ranger207 3y agoLast time I went to the library I had to go through a metal detector. Then they had only one floor of books out of 5. Going to try another branch but I wasn't particularly happy
- robotburrito 3y agoI often see the police at my local library here in SF. They now have a large security guard there full time. More often than not the library is reasonably calm, but I would say once a week we have someone screaming and freaking out. Overall though, I love the library and go a few days a week when I need to get out of my apartment to get some work done. If libraries did not exist already, I couldn't even imagine them being funded now a days. A free place!? Where people can read books for free!?!?!?
- kotaKat 3y agoNo, because my local library is only open during the week. It's closed on the weekends, and during the week it's 9:30 to 5 PM, with the exception of 11:30 to 7 PM on Wednesdays. My library literally doesn't have funding and the city nor its taxpayers care enough to help.
- activiation 3y agoYes, for a passport application
- etempleton 3y agoWe really do not have a solution to mental health issues and homelessness in the US. We determined asylums were cruel and inhumane, but our alternative is nothing.
- afpx 3y agoIt's a tough battle. If you only consider the wealthiest countries, homelessness strongly correlates with nominal GDP. But, reducing GDP would probably create more homelessness.
- throwaway173738 3y agoThe whole deinstitutionalization thing was supposed to come with community mental health centers funded by the government. But when Reagan took office after Carter this was one of the first things on the chopping block. This left us in the situation we have today of lots of really ill people ending up in jail or on the streets. But I’m sure someone saved some taxes somewhere.