14 ms·
This is just bananas to me that a browser would perform "super resolution" at all, much less by default. Couldn't this wreak havoc on doing things like viewing
by crazygringo 3y ago
This is just bananas to me that a browser would perform "super resolution" at all, much less by default.
Couldn't this wreak havoc on doing things like viewing medical images, inserting false detail that isn't there?
As well as on text in images, e.g. inventing a cleanly readable but hallucinated license plate number on a car, or financial figure, where the original is blurry?
Not only does this seem like a terribly dangerous idea, but I'm shocked that a legal review at Microsoft would ever have approved this in the first place.
- Finnucane 3y agoIndeed, this sounds like a bad idea not just for the user but for the image host as well. If I post a picture, I post it the way I want it to be seen. I don't want the browser to arbitrarily reinterpret it.
- lynx23 3y agoWell, that reminds me of autocorrection in web input fields, turned on automatically. Especially great if there is no proper language detection. You type a message into a text field, and Edge corrects every second word because you are typing in your native langauge, how dare you?! This is totally something I'd enable by default, because, you know, what is there except US and UK? Nah, nothing noteworthy... Ah, the joy. Internationalisation, no surprise its written i18n, it reflects the care and fucks given... Or Apple... I t took them 3 major iOS releases to have umlauts pronounced properly with their speech synth. Umlauts?! Who the fuck needs those?!
- leokennis 3y agoReminds me of the issue where Xerox machines would replace some 9’s on your scanned documents with 0’s due to over enthusiastic compression. https://www.dkriesel.com/en/blog/2013/0802_xerox-workcentres_are_switching_written_numbers_when_scanning https://www.dkriesel.com/en/blog/2013/0802_xerox-workcentres...
- xingped 3y agoHoly cow, the implications of that story were terrifying! I can't believe it took 8yrs for someone to notice!
- KennyBlanken 3y agoIt's absolutely astounding that they weren't sued into the ground for that. Contracts, medications, engineering drawings, chemical formulae...
- adhvaryu 3y agoWow, I can't believe they shipped the product knowing this could happen and thought that putting 2 warnings in the software guidebook (who reads that?) would suffice. Maybe they only added that in to avoid getting sued. Also, reading the timeline was great. > March 2015 The German Federal Office for Safety in Information Technology bans JBIG2 from being used for archival purposes. Wonder if any other governments took notice as well.
- Drunk_Engineer 3y agoSending medical images to Microsoft seems like a major HIPAA violation.
- Melting_Harps 3y ago> Sending medical images to Microsoft seems like a major HIPAA violation. Without sounding to condescending: Bro... this entire Industry still relies on using fax or snailmail for records. Using slow, leaky, non-private/seure channels for sensitive information is not as much of a concern to this field than one thinks if you've been in the belly of the beast. Ask anyone who has spent anytime doing IT work at a hospital, or better yet a disgruntled nurse who works the counter after a 12 hour shift. You ever try requesting an MRI in the US? After needing several during COVID and being turned a way and having lots of time on my hands I've actually learned a hack to get it the same week (or in my case the same day recently) now that we're out of the pandemic because I knew who to press for a physical paper trail and get it submitted (via fax) and have it approved by all parties: it cost me a day off of work, and tons of leg work on the phone but it was done and I literately didn't care so long as it was done and prove my method was sound. I got it done after business hours, too! I'm starting to think that the issue with it being so archaic is not because a better solution doesn't exist, but because it's made this way in order for them to justify the long delays in procedures and increase membership duration on their policies and they use things like HIPPA and other acts to justify the lengthy process and obscene amounts of money needed to be able to modify the way things are done, which is why software people just move on and the same mediocrity continues to the detriment of us all.
- voldacar 3y agoWhat specifically did you do to get an MRI quickly? Your personal doctor didn't want to give you one? Or the hospital/MRI place didn't want to give you one?
- f1shy 3y agoWaaaaait! In the US also the FAX is still a thing?! Seriously?! I have heard terrible stories from Germany and Japan, but did not know that also the US…
- donmcronald 3y agoIt’s crazy. I used Edge when it first switched to Chromium because it was a nice, clean Chrome alternative with working sync. Today it’s obvious Microsoft can’t be trusted. This “feature” is insane and it makes me concerned about what Windows might be doing in the background.
- Melting_Harps 3y ago> Today it’s obvious Microsoft can’t be trusted. Today? Where were you when it's 'free' OS' was 'phoning home' or during it's behemoth days in the 90s-2000s when it forced the most pro-business Government (US) to essentially break it up when it was using it's monoploitic practices too far for even them? I have to use Teams and just logically assume all of what was said or talked about exists on some server somewhere for the employer, LEO or intelengence agencies to retrieve; if Snowden has taught us anything is that M$ is the darling child of the Intelligence agencies in the US for a reason. Using M$ outside of a (forced) work environment is literately like asking to be tracked, monitored of your own accord. Nothing they do should be presumed to be secure until proven a length to be otherwise. It's very likely why it's so bloated and runs terribly, they are optimizing no for UX but for it's real business model: spying. Sadly, and with only a slight tinge of despondence: I've given up on preaching about FOSS to the masses, but with stuff like this it's like asking why people sign up for death cults, it alwasy ends in: Humans just being Humans.
- johnnykree 3y agoPlease don’t give up praying about FOSS to the masses. It was a post like this that convinced me to try Linux Arch. I will never look back. I didn’t boot into my Windows drive for more than a month now. I just keep a bare installation for online games that don’t run on Linux. For now.
- intelVISA 3y agoIt's a noble cause, congrats on freedom. If you feel adventurous you can eventually transcend dual boot to a VFIO setup that helps to keep your bare metal protected from Windows entirely.
- mouse_ 3y agoYes, and there is legal precedent. https://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/2021/11/rittenhouse-trial-judge-disallows-ipad-pinch-to-zoom-read-the-bizarre-transcript/ https://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/2021/11/rittenhouse-tria...
- dmvdoug 3y agoIt’s hilarious that the prosecutor’s name there was Binger. MICROSOFT!
- lesuorac 3y ago> e.g. inventing a cleanly readable but hallucinated license plate number on a car, or financial figure, where the original is blurry? You can use enhanced images in trials. In general, Courts rely on expert witnesses so if you can get one that says X method is applicable and used in that field then it's a go. It then becomes the other side's job to find an expert witness to say X actually has these flaws and is untrustable. i.e. the Court is not bothered by confidence intervals; if your profession makes decisions by flipping coins its admissible in court. The Court only cares if somebody is willing to certify it as true. http://www.curtisreevestrial.com/files/1187.pdf http://www.curtisreevestrial.com/files/1187.pdf https://www.jonathanhak.com/2018/02/17/image-clarification-not-a-bar-to-admissibility/ https://www.jonathanhak.com/2018/02/17/image-clarification-n...
- russdill 3y agoSuper resolution algorithms are not image enhancement.
- lesuorac 3y ago> [1]: Super-resolution imaging (SR) is a class of techniques that enhance (increase) the resolution of an imaging system. It looks pretty clear to me that a Super Resolution Algorithm enhances images (aka Image Enhancement). Although I think you missed the point of my post. As long as you can get an expert witness to certify the accurate you can use a technique in court. Somebody else [2] linked the Rittenhouse case as an example as to this being disallowed but that's not what the Rittenhouse case shows. The Prosecution wanted to use pinch-to-zoom; the defense challenged that zooming wouldn't be an accurate representative; the Judge asked the Prosecution if/how they knew that zooming would be an accurate representation; the Prosecution admitted they had no idea how pinch-to-zoom works; the Judge (very reasonable) didn't allow an unknown method to be used in court. The lack of an expert witness to explain how Zooming wouldn't've changed the image was the problem. [1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Super-resolution_imaging https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Super-resolution_imaging [2]: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36297039 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36297039
- gtwomd 3y agoOnly a matter of time until Ryan Gosling shows up in someone's X Ray[0] [0] https://petapixel.com/2020/08/17/gigapixel-ai-accidentally-added-ryan-goslings-face-to-this-photo/ https://petapixel.com/2020/08/17/gigapixel-ai-accidentally-a...
- LeifCarrotson 3y agoOr before the images accompanying a comparison article between a Samsung Scene Optimizer moonshot and $4,800 Sony astrophotography rig become completely incomprehensible: https://www.inverse.com/input/reviews/is-samsung-galaxy-s21-ultra-using-ai-to-fake-detailed-moon-photos-investigation-super-resolution-analysis https://www.inverse.com/input/reviews/is-samsung-galaxy-s21-... https://www.samsungmobilepress.com/feature-stories/how-samsung-galaxy-cameras-combine-super-resolution-technologies-with-ai-technology-to-produce-high-quality-images-of-the-moon/ https://www.samsungmobilepress.com/feature-stories/how-samsu... Don't want to bring too many Reddit memes over, but if the browser enhances the images on both sides of the comparison, and corporate wants you to identify the differences... what can you say but "they're the same picture"?
- KennyBlanken 3y agoJust to be clear, Samsung was caught using basic pattern matching to detect the camera being pointed at the moon, triggering wholescale substitution with the image from the $4.5k camera. A redditor blurred an image of the moon, took a photo of the blurry image on their screen, and got the high-res image. https://www.theverge.com/2023/3/13/23637401/samsung-fake-moon-photos-ai-galaxy-s21-s23-ultra https://www.theverge.com/2023/3/13/23637401/samsung-fake-moo...
- lynx23 3y agoOCR in images is becoming the norm. It was a big relief on social media for blind and visually impaired people. Asking for manually created image descriptions and/or transcribed text was too much to ask from the social web. So ML found one of its first public use cases. Composite image description and OCR. And yes, the quality is bad. But nobody really cared about this, esp. not those offering the feature. Holy heartlessness basically says "it is for free, so be happy that we gave it away. If it fails, that is not our fault."
- Shared404 3y ago> Asking for manually created image descriptions and/or transcribed text was too much to ask from the social web. Mastodon at least has had a better culture about this in my experience. Possibly worth investigating, and it may have degraded over the last mass migrations.
- lynx23 3y agoI should take a look at Mastodon one day. However, all of this talk of having to maintain your own instance and my very bad experience when looking at Google Plus (the most inaccessible social network ever put out by a large corporation) kind of myke me weary I am wasting my time. Besides, I mostly use FB as an event calendar. As long as someone doesn't mirror all the events announced in my area, I will likely not use it on a regular basis.
- f1shy 3y ago>> inventing a cleanly readable but hallucinated license plate number on a car, or financial figure, This has already happened with copiers, which because of a bug in a compression algorithm, would randomly change figures when copying
- AnonCoward42 3y agoI think using some form of super resolution by default is not necessarily a bad idea given other upscaling techniques were deployed before and this is not so different. There are definitely scenarios where you want to avoid this, but these are few and far between. Sending these images to Microsoft by default however is scummy.
- pfffr 3y agoSo anyone in the medical industry using microsift edge is violating HIPAA?
- pfffr 3y agoAlso, it seems like there may be some copyright implications as well? The more I think about this it really seems like Microsoft is opening itself to lots of liability issues with this policy.
- autoexec 3y agoI'm guessing they didn't put much thought into the "enhancement" aspect at all. They just needed some justification to collect lists of every image you view.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- TacticalCoder 3y ago> This is just bananas to me that a browser would perform "super resolution" at all, much less by default. But it's really not the issue here. They invented "super resolution" just as they could have used "ultra denoiser" or "elite acne spot remover" or whatever other bullshit term they think they could use to get away with to "explain" why they're sniffing pictures. The goal is to send the images to Microsoft and nothing else.
- account42 3y agoAll of these other "enhancements" would be just as unreasonable to apply to web images by default even if done entirely locally. Both the exfiltration and the non-standard rendering are issues here.
- jacquesm 3y ago> Couldn't this wreak havoc on doing things like viewing medical images Regardless it would seem to me to be a HIPAA violation.
- raincole 3y agoI rememeber these was a video where a lawyer defended his defendant by line like: "when you zoom in the video, the algorithm makes up things so you can't use it as an evidence, your honor." And he was mocked by the whole internet. Really showing how much an average person knows, isn't it.
- heresie-dabord 3y agoDear user, while you browse sites, we browse your habits: private data worth billions. -- a privacy haiku
- bpiche 3y agoSame people who saw no legal problem with letting Tay/Zo into the wild. Or the Bing chatbot. All product launches that would have sunk any smaller company. They’re so big they believe they can just eat any legal challenge. Probably right too.
- quintussss 3y agoThis reminds me of that one talk at a german hacker conference (CCC) about xerox printers inserting false numbers into scans