10 ms·
The Dutch government wants automatic permission to target victims of hackers
- mikece 3y agoSounds like a great way to cause a massive headache for innocent people: hack their computer so the government can then give them a digital proctology exam.
- superq 3y agoIn other words, don't call for help, because then you become the target? It seems like an incredible perversion of justice.
- Muromec 3y agoIt’s more like — if your machine is part of a botnet, cops can legally hack into it too
- wongarsu 3y ago> In the new situation, hacking, targeted interception and data access operations get an automatic extension beyond the actual target of the warrant. If a warrant is requested to intercept the communications of a specific hacking organization, the warrant now also extends to victims of this hacking group. Or, more concretely, if your computer gets hacked by group X and there was a warrant to intercept the traffic of group X, the Dutch services now gain automatic approval to also intercept your communications or hack you. I guess I can see that being useful occasionally, but it also seems ripe for abuse. Just plant a mole in a hacker organisation of your choice, get a warrant against them, and now you can have your mole hack whoever you like, giving you the automatic right to hack them and intercept their communications
- throwbadubadu 3y agoUseful occasionally, without doubt.. but the abuse potential, blown proportionality, and then these legislations always only know one way. Its never about that this wouldn't be useful to the utopian goods vs the criminals. :/
- account-5 3y agoThat example seems a little contrived, when with the legislation used for interception is broad enough to just got after the actual target straight away. Seems a long way for a shortcut, so to speak.
- 411111111111111 3y agoThe fear in this regard is more about overreach and stalking by officers twisting the law for their own agenda. Dunno whenever that's a widespread issue with the Dutch police. As an example: It's doubtful they could get a warrent for their neighbors girlfriend, but now they've got another legal way in. It remains to be seen wherever that's actually going to happen though.
- deafpolygon 3y agoThey are good about transparency, but abuses do happen when they think no one is looking. Unfortunately for us.
- krageon 3y ago> Dunno whenever that's a widespread issue with the Dutch police. Every police force has issue with abuse of power and the Dutch are no different. As always, it is the worst in the margins and so hard to get a picture of how bad it is in an empirical way.
- hcfman 3y agoI don't believe it's wide spread but exactly that is possible with the Dutch government and without any consequences. I lived next door to one of their targets from a drug investigation. The other neighbor was involved and for the next 10 years the other neighbor was allowed to commit all manner of criminal offenses against me and stalk me and the government protected him. They protected him all the way to the courts and then the prosecutor lied in court. I filed criminal charges with the police against him for obstruction of justice. A year later it was dismissed, I filed an appeal to the attorney general and it was dismissed again. The evidence I had against him was overwhelming they simply will not prosecuted a prosecutor in the Netherlands or obstruction of justice. The laws for using civilians in investigations here forbid the use without having a contract upfront, the civilian is not allowed to commit any crimes. However, none of that matters cause there's no effective control and absolutely no consequences. The laws and their guidelines are just bullshit for the public to read and think that it's all under control. The Dutch government were envious of what organized crime could do and now the government is organized crime. And yes, completely innocent, non crime involved citizens can become victims of this.
- pmontra 3y agoHow about asking the hacked person for permission to access their (other?) communications to prosecute the hacker? Too simple? Doesn't scale automatically? But if the latter is the case, it's not something to be used sparingly.
- im3w1l 3y agoI'm guessing they don't want the target to know they are hacked.
- ipaddr 3y agoThat should not be allowed. Police should give discloser.
- JumpCrisscross 3y ago> That should not be allowed. Police should give discloser. This obviously cannot be a boundary condition for policing; it's adversarial. The question is whether this balances public needs against private rights. My gut feeling is the extensions should require court approval or disclosure.
- roblabla 3y agoWe're talking about disclosing to victims here. There should be no adversarial relationship between the police and a hacking victim that I can see.
- lovemenot 3y agoAn organisation might hack some of its allies, who would act as a contact canary. Reporting contact by the police to their friends.
- elisbce 3y agoIt is an adversarial game. The hackers could plant fake victims as monitors for police activities. This is an important reason why the police can't disclose to the victims that they were hacked or how they were hacked. However, I think we could at least make the laws such that the police can disclose certain information upon request post mortem. Absolutely not during investigation.
- Spoom 3y agoOh no, this worm is targeting literally our entire population! I guess we have carte blanche now...
- Aleksdev 3y agoExactly, this is giving serious power to the government over peoples privacy.
- Symmetry 3y agoHow is that easier for law enforcement than just hacking the targets anyways? It's way more steps that can go wrong and way more people who could blab about your operation.
- JohnFen 3y agoSo, if you've been victimized once by a criminal, you can be victimized again by the government? Sounds like a great disincentive to reporting being hacked to authorities.
- krm01 3y agowait. so if you are hacked, then the government has a free pass to hack you as well? Why do all the reasons that come to mind right now fit in the 'bad idea' bucket...?
- jmclnx 3y agono kidding, # 1 reason, people will stop reporting hack.
- t0mas88 3y agoThat's not how it works. It's not "when you report a hack the government can now hack you at will". It is: When an intelligence agency with a legal warrant to monitor another entity that's a severe enough threat to national security sees that entity hack you, they can follow along and monitor communication from the hacked machine and/or hack into it themselves. If enough precautions are taken to limit impact on the victim's privacy and only if their right to privacy is less important than the national security risk the original target poses if not doing so. Source: Read the source doc in Dutch, it's far more nuanced than the English blog post.
- Solvency 3y agoAll you did was use a bunch of words to revise their statement to "when you don't report a hack, the government can hack you at will."
- nottorp 3y agoActually the way t0mas phrased it looks pretty reasonable. And the stuff about reporting makes no sense. Victims of hacks perpetrated by some entity that's worth a national security warrant will most likely not notice they're hacked.
- loufe 3y agoEdit: Title fix suggestion, no longer relevant.
- t0mas88 3y agoContrary to common opinion here I think this is a small thing. The way these things work in the Netherlands, an intelligence agency would currently not intercept any communication from a "stepping stone" hacked by a criminal organisation, because it would be outside the scope of their warrant. That's a stupid limitation to have because it's very common to perform attacks from other hacked machines and not your own. (And for the bad guy's connection to such a server to be encrypted and useless to intercept) What's a bit bigger in this thing is that they would be allowed to actively hack into such a machine themselves instead of just intercepting communications. However that has to be proportional with extra emphasis on the rights of the non-target. That practically means they can only do it in severe cases and not to get information on the non-target. Those suggesting this could be used to "just" hack random citizens are exaggerating. That would not be accepted by the oversight agencies.
- bscphil 3y ago> Those suggesting this could be used to "just" hack random citizens are exaggerating. That would not be accepted by the oversight agencies. In most countries, good governance is considered to be writing laws in such a way that abuse by the government is a violation of the written word of the law, not merely in opposition to its spirit or intent as interpreted by the government's own agencies.
- jfengel 3y agoSuch things are easier said than done. Humans aren't computers. They have far more behaviors, and infinite corner cases. Writing laws that cover all of them is incredibly difficult, and as soon as you do something pops up that you didn't anticipate. It's the reason all of your license agreements and other contracts are so long. Every phrase and sentence is there because something went wrong. It doesn't let them off the hook for the fact that legislatures often do badly. But even with the best of intentions and the best skill things are still never as thorough as a programmer would like them to be, because programming people is way harder.
- pessimizer 3y ago
- MarkusQ 3y agoIt might make more sense if we consider a physical analog: it's already generally the case that the police don't need to get a warrant to enter private property in a hostage situation, or when there's an active shooter, etc. This doesn't mean it's _necessarily_ a good thing in either case, but it's less sensational if you don't frame it as something unprecedented.
- wongarsu 3y agoThose analogs are covered under exigent circumstances. But there is no imminent danger attached to a hacking case. This feels more like "somebody stole my briefcase, which is justification to search my home without a warrant".
- zmgsabst 3y agoPerhaps less contrived: Police observed a drug dealer drop off a package in my bush, then someone else take it later — so they can search my house, just in case. Traditionally, searching your house would require a warrant based on those events… and likely showing more of a nexus, that you were involved.
- lukeschlather 3y agoExcept the briefcase is a computer, and the computer is still in your home, and this is about not needing permission to search the briefcase even though it's still in your possession, because the briefcase has also been stolen and may be actively used in committing crimes despite the fact that you are not committing crimes and it remains in your possession.
- belter 3y ago3 days ago | 65 comments - "NL national security law to grant automatic permission for targeted surveillance" - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36229557 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36229557
- rolph 3y agothis sounds so brilliant. someone gets hacked, doesnt notice the first time until, a second time, sees the attack and goes medieval on the attacker#2[cops] i anticipate clusterfucks ahead. only a minority of people even recognize a hack beyond, having a slow computer, but those few special people will bork it.
- quantum_state 3y agoIf one makes an analogy of this to gunshot victim and shooter scenario, it would show how absurd the government is.
- mrangle 3y agoThe FBI has been doing this for a few years, as far as I remember
- waihtis 3y agoRecall the recent Chinese Volt Typhoon campaign against US infrastructure in which the threat actor used US residential computers as "proxies" to mask their traffic as coming from legitimate, inside the US IP addresses. I imagine the same type of thinking is behind the justification for this.
- spacebacon 3y agoEveryone is a potential honeypot as is. Not clicking anything renders you moderately safe.
- cornflake23 3y ago[flagged]
- deafpolygon 3y agoThis is ridiculous. How are they going to prevent abuse against our own people? THe gov't here is generally pretty good and transparent but there are abuses in every level if they think they can get away with it.
- deafpolygon 3y agoAs a citizen, I am concerned. Loosely interpreted, if your machine was hacked by a 3rd party - regardless of who it was, it is then permitted for the police to hack your device in order to determine the extent of the hack. Very loosely interpreted, it also means they can go after you if your bittorrent traffic was found in the traffic of group "X". Since sometimes, it is not possible to determine which or what traffic is included. The biggest thing is the last "explanatory memorandum" that is attached to the law. While not the law itself, it is in practice how the law will be used: > the permission granted also contains authorization for, during the validity of the warrant, to also enter automated works of the person or organization targeted by the warrant, As explained in the article; > An ‘automated work’ in this specific Dutch law has an extremely broad interpretation and includes such things as phones, computers, servers, websites, databases and mailboxes. This basically means that if you are part of compromised traffic/target, then as interpreted legally, it's open season on anything you have associated to you. I really hope this doesn't become standard practice, because it will just mean widespread abuses similar to how the DMCA is used (but more sinister).
- jstarfish 3y ago> This basically means that if you are part of compromised traffic/target, then as interpreted legally, it's open season on anything you have associated to you. This is the point (also discussed in previous thread). It sucks (for some), but is only logical. I suspect this is all NL finally getting around to dealing with its reputation for being a child-porn hosting haven. The goal of this legislation does allow the cops to "break a window" so they can look at domestic hardware currently only accessible from foreign endpoints. NL cops can't get a search warrant on someone in NL when their supposed IP maps to MIT. MIT says there's no server here, just a Tor exit node. Oh well, nothing we can do! Thus, they're now allowed to hack domestically (force entry), and anybody found interacting with the child porn server they're monitoring necessarily falls under the same scope as the purveyor and rightfully becomes a target themselves. It would make no sense to say you can hack the principal target, but not any subjects subsequently implicated in criminal activity. This stuff is literally impossible to prosecute under the status quo-- the NL cops get tips but don't have cause to act (otherwise it'd just be SWAT-ing), nobody can crack the encrypted traffic, and the clients aren't necessarily resharing outside of this channel. It's a perfect closed system with solid technical and legal OPSEC. But yes, once they punish all of those who have evaded the law this way for the last two decades, they'll come for the torrenters and other petty criminals next. Thank the pedophiles for getting the party shut down.
- lwn 3y agoAn ex secret service regulator has previously warned the House of Representatives (Tweede Kamer) about cheating from the secret service so communication of all Dutch citizens can be tapped[1] [1] (Dutch) https://decorrespondent.nl/13987/de-geheime-diensten-bedonderen-ons-zegt-de-man-die-het-kan-weten/98e8c813-b1e0-05ea-1438-1c1612ed90b8 https://decorrespondent.nl/13987/de-geheime-diensten-bedonde...
- fjfaase 3y agoThis is Bert Hubert [1]. Explaining why he left (in English): 'On my resignation as regulator of the Dutch intelligence and security services' [2]. [1] https://berthub.eu/ https://berthub.eu/ [2] https://berthub.eu/articles/posts/resignation-as-intelligence-regulator/ https://berthub.eu/articles/posts/resignation-as-intelligenc...
- tinus_hn 3y agoThe Netherlands can barely be described as a state of law, considering its absolutely worthless constitution, its apathetic senate and its corrupted judiciary. This is just business as usual, the mainstream media doesn’t even mention this and nobody cares.
- hcfman 3y agoAbsolutely correct. The media part is the sad part, they simply won't print stories about government abuse of power and violation of human rights. If they did, then there would be some possible final accountability, but within the media publishing the Netherlands are absolutely screwed. And for all of you people who are jealous of what the Netherlands has, don't worry. The limburg chapter of the RIEC have managed to convince Germany and Belgium to also start with their own version of democracy beating measures. It's called EURIEC, look it up you lucky people.
- ftxbro 3y ago> "automatic permission" this phrasing sounds wrong somehow
- belter 3y ago"self-facilitated approval"...."self-endorsed clearance"
- DerekBickerton 3y agoIf they spent the money in the right places, i.e helping people or organizations get back on their feet after a breach, that would be more fruitful. This whole 'we're gonna sit in your computer chasing bad guys' is just shenanigans.
- dukeofdoom 3y ago[flagged]
- pimlottc 3y ago“Target” is a bit of a confusing word choice here; “monitor” might be better, or “surveil”, I think.
- mark_mart 3y agoHere we go again, Dutch government won't stop doing stuff to surveillance on the innocent people.
- 0x6461188A 3y agoWhat if the police thinks someone is hacked, starts intercepting and recording their communication, and then later it turns out they were not hacked? In other words, the police could intercept anyone’s communication. Then later if the police is questioned about this, they could say, “Sorry about that. We thought you were hacked. Guess you weren’t.”
- 0x6461188A 3y agoIf the law passes the police will start by intercepting the traffic of all the civil rights organizations that were opposed to the law passing.
- ggm 3y ago[flagged]
- golem14 3y agoA new way for parallel construction ? BTW, is that (p.c.) a thing in the Netherlands ?
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- Aleksdev 3y agoFor some strange reason. I have a funny feeling this will be abused.
- firecall 3y agoIsn't this premise broadly an entire season of South Park? TrollTrace!
- GuB-42 3y agoIt is constitutional? I don't know about Dutch constitution, but there usually is something about privacy, and presumption of innocence, and even if it isn't in the constitution (constitution is mostly about the technicalities of governance), there are things like the Declaration of Human Rights and other treaties that mention it that are above the law.