19 ms·
Patterns of mean-level change in personality traits across life course (2006)
- fragebogen 3y agonumber of samples = 92 hard for me believe that you would infer anything statistically meaningful on population scale from that small of a sample, or am i missing something? is it common to work with so small sample sizes in psychology?
- cubefox 3y agoIt's a meta-analysis, so they analyzed 92 studies.
- spangry 3y agoYep, the article confirms: "Ninety-two studies satisfied the inclusion criteria. Because many of these studies reported data from several samples, the number of samples, 113, was greater than the total number of studies. The total number of participants for the 113 samples was 50,120. A total of 1,682 estimates of change were compiled."
- fragebogen 3y agothanks! that wasn't clear to me.
- adhesive_wombat 3y ago"Our study was inconclusive: one third of patients were cured, one third died and the other guy got away".
- just_a_monkfish 3y ago[dead]
- moi2388 3y agoYes it is. There are quite some studies where the sample size is 20 or 30 people per group, and sometimes even 15-20 in total. Combina that with the fact that they often use psychology students as experiment group and the fact that most research doesn’t go further than assume a normal distribution, and you might start to understand why more than 2/3rds of all psychology research cannot be reproduced.
- em500 3y agoI think what you're missing is that sample sizes for statistical significance do not depend on the population size. The big caveat is that the sample is random and representative, which you can't really verify beyond doubt. But if a sample is random and representative, you could estimate population statistics of millions (or even infinite) with a sample of just 30 or so. As sibling posts mentioned, a much bigger issue than sample size is representativeness: college psychology study samples tend to be drawn disproportionately from college students. They might not generalize well to the general population even if you increase the sample size ten fold or a hundred fold.
- p-e-w 3y ago> But if a sample is random and representative, you could estimate population statistics of millions (or even infinite) with a sample of just 30 or so. While that statement is technically correct, it is useless in practice. In order to determine whether a sample is representative (of the trait you are trying to measure), you need to know what the true mean value of the trait is – but if you knew that, you wouldn't need to conduct the experiment in the first place. That's why it is important to have a large sample size, because under some very general assumptions, the distortions caused by outliers become smaller the more samples you look at. In the limit (that is, when the sample size equals the population size) those distortions disappear entirely, and the sample mean becomes the true population mean.
- mjburgess 3y agoTo add to this, the assumptions behind any use of statistics here are wild when applied to pyschology. 1. We assume that people have stable measurable independent properties f1(x1.., t), f2(x1.., t), ... 2. We assume these are modelled by a linear model, f1(t) = ax + b, etc. 3. We assume the parameters (a, b) of this model causally determine `f1` st. each corresponds to an independent cause of `f1` 4. We assume that we have some reliable measurement process, say m, which measures each property producing samples of that a,b: m(f1) = random samples of a,b 5. Then we assume that these samples are representative of the true values, ie., that mean(a samples) = a + random_error The problem with the field is that (1 - 4) are false -- arguing about 5 is a little like arguing what time a broken clock should be set to.
- p-e-w 3y ago> is it common to work with so small sample sizes in psychology? Yes. Even much smaller sample sizes are common. I've seen "results" published in supposedly reputable journals with sample sizes as small as 9. Not 9 other studies that were meta-analyzed, mind you. 9 individual people. This is just one of several reasons why most of psychology is junk science, if not outright fraudulent. Statistical methods is usually a required course for students in such disciplines, so I do not buy the "they don't know better" excuse. Not that you need to know statistics in order to understand that you can't conclude anything from a sample size of 9.
- hackernewds 3y agoPsychology isn't accepted as a hard science, perhaps an applied science. Since there really isn't a precise follow to the scientific method, hypothesis - inference - conclusion.
- FrustratedMonky 3y agoSo Astronomy is not a hard science? Because there is only observation, no testing of hypothesis?
- naillo 3y agoThey can test it in the limited sense of simulation. Not ideal but it's more than even psychologists can do
- FrustratedMonky 3y agoThat is so completely false that I fear you are responding purely by a bias against psychology and have not read anything about it. Of course you can form a hypothesis, and test it on real live humans, gather data and check results.
- willcipriano 3y agoI don't think a lot of people know this. The evidence required for a physiological intervention is lower than a surgical or pharmaceutical intervention. The AMA used to lump psychology with things like chiropractic, acupuncture and homeopathy until they were sued by chiropractors under antitrust law in 1987.
- lamename 3y agoIt's a meta-analysis, which means they evaluated 92 papers in the literature.
- williamcotton 3y agoThere are many reasons that qualitative research is better than quantitative research. Understanding context and nuance, exploratory studies, complex phenomena, and social dynamics and interactions are more often better served by having fewer subjects.
- stevenhuang 3y agoNever only look at sample size. Something can be statistically meaningful with a small sample size if the effect size is large for instance.
- fzeindl 3y agoWhile this is a meta analysis in general I suspect it is not easy to get and retain study participants for decade-long studies.
- jschveibinz 3y agoYou think that’s small? Try reading a paper in education and learning. Some of the seminal papers have less than 30 subjects. And these papers have driven teaching policies for decades.
- deofoo 3y agoThe impact of culture is another critical data-point. For example, in some cultures, elders are viewed as being kind, wise and important while in others, grumpy and useless.
- 627467 3y agoI'm always curious as to how global these findings can be, the titles certainly don't narrow it down making it sound universal findings. Yet, could it be that these findings are universal and yet culture teaches us to ignore these changes?
- banach 3y agoMaybe there is a causal relationship there. Being viewed as useless might make you grumpy, being viewed as wise might make you kind.
- __MatrixMan__ 3y agoI strongly suspect that there is, I've seen this effect in play so many times at smaller timescales, and you'd expect to be even stronger at longer ones
- Silverback_VII 3y agoIn primitive cultures, reaching old age could be seen as an achievement, given the difficulty of surviving without a healthcare system. In most modern societies, however, aging isn't as challenging and elderly individuals are often "locked away" in retirement homes. In other words, they essentially disappear, living a life of a ghost. Moreover, what kind of wisdom would you expect from someone who spent their years merely waiting for the day of their retirement?
- neffy 3y agoPerhaps the wisdom of advising that is not a good idea. And also that young whippersnappers who think that that is what the majority of old people spend their time doing may not be paying much attention to the world. Reaching old age is still an achievement, especially for young male motorcycle riders, and experience of society and its history always comes for free. The "locking away" stage is something old people generally try to actively avoid, and mostly generally for those with actual dementia in any case.
- taylorius 3y agoDoes the paper have anything to say as to how individuals may become more consarned as they age?
- willcipriano 3y agoInteresting bit: "In contrast, people increase on measures of social vitality (a 2nd facet of extraversion) and openness in adolescence but then decrease in both of these domains in old age." > social vitality: living or preferring to live in a community rather than alone. Seems like you grow out of wanting to live in a community. I wonder if a aging population will cause cities to decline in population more rapidly than the raw numbers indicate it would.
- chpatrick 3y agoBoth of those sound like the classic grouchiness that comes with age.
- willcipriano 3y agoHonest question: how do we know they are grouchy and instead we aren't just annoying. I have a kid but kids can get on my nerves, when I'm 90 I could imagine 40 year olds annoying me in a similar way.
- hallway_monitor 3y agoGrouchiness may be correlated with age but not all older people are grouchy. Maybe it's actually caused by feeling useless and unloved.
- rootusrootus 3y agoMy elderly mom can switch pretty quickly from easygoing and fun to grouchy when I inadvertently treat her like she's not quite capable of managing her own life. She'll be the first to admit that it's starting to become true, but it's a fine line. I think old people become more grouchy the more young people treat them like they're old and useless, or stupid.
- lonelyasacloud 3y agoWatching friends and loved ones die while an individual's body falls apart isn't something many people find particularly easy.
- graddrisrp 3y agoThis is a bloody brilliant and comprehensive meta-analysis that sheds some light on the patterns of personality change across the life course. It is remarkable how much variation and plasticity there is in human personality, and how different traits show different trajectories of change. I wonder what are the underlying mechanisms and influences that drive these changes, and what are the implications for well-being and social relationships.
- jschveibinz 3y agoI don’t understand the animosity to your comment except that perhaps the crowd does not agree with the power you have attributed to the analysis. In general, though, I would agree that the analysis does identify an interesting set of threads to consider when thinking about how we change as we age. Have a great day.
- chrisweekly 3y agoSee also "Personality Isn't Permanent" by Ben Hardy.
- FrustratedMonky 3y agoI am a little surprised how much anti-Psychology sentiment there is on HN. I know it is typically viewed as a 'liberal' field, and perhaps has a harder time quantifying measurements. It is more difficult to measure a human trait, than to measure a temperature. I'm wondering what the options are? We can't just dismiss Psychology, cancel an entire field because it has difficulties. Why can't we study humans, what study of humans would take the place of Psychology? I'd say all those pointing to the successes of 'hard' sciences, have it easier. Isn't iterative improvement what all science is about?
- Xcelerate 3y ago> I am a little surprised how much anti-Psychology sentiment there is on HN. I know it is typically viewed as a 'liberal' field It has nothing to do with “liberal” or “conservative” fields of studies and everything to do with reproducibility and predictivity. If psychology could make predictions to the 13th decimal place like we are able to do for the gyromagnetic ratio of the electron (and confirm via experiment), there would be no complaints. There is also a tendency for the outcomes of psychology studies to be “oversold” in a sense. To be fair, this is more often due to the media sensationalizing the results or reading something into them that isn’t there, but you don’t see this as often in physics (well, maybe a bit with quantum mechanics and black holes).
- FrustratedMonky 3y agoI'd say a large part of the bias here is because the media over-hypes the results, which isn't necessarily the fault of the field. All fields are driven to hype results to get more research dollars. There does seem to be a bit more backlash when Psychology is over-hyped then when others do it. But we do need to study humans, and they are hard to quantify. It is very misleading to compare measuring electrons to measuring 'how do I feel'. It is difficult to measure. That doesn't mean not to. It seems like here the sentiment is strongly to go ahead and toss the baby out with the bath water.
- plewd 3y ago
- omginternets 3y agoIs there a full link to the paper somewhere?
- eranation 3y agohttps://www.researchgate.net/profile/Brent-Roberts-2/publication/7337585_Patterns_of_Mean-Level_Change_in_Personality_Traits_Across_the_Life_Course_A_Meta-Analysis_of_Longitudinal_Studies/links/00b7d53c23b35d61aa000000/Patterns-of-Mean-Level-Change-in-Personality-Traits-Across-the-Life-Course-A-Meta-Analysis-of-Longitudinal-Studies.pdf https://www.researchgate.net/profile/Brent-Roberts-2/publica...
- culi 3y agohttps://sci-hub.se/https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/16435954/ https://sci-hub.se/https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/16435954/ (page 15 for the pretty graphs)
- robinduckett 3y agoSomeone should add (2006) to this
- blueyes 3y ago> Agreeableness changed only in old age. Nir Barzilai, a researcher of aging, tells a great story about a very nice 100 year old man. When Nir comments on how nice the man is to his 80yo son, the son says: "well, he was a real jerk when he was my age." https://peterattiamd.com/nirbarzilai2/ https://peterattiamd.com/nirbarzilai2/
- steveBK123 3y agoIt's interesting they found minimal gender differentiation. As I've aged and observed myself and my cohort through teens/20s/30s/40s some into 50s.. the effect of men mellowing out is quite strong. Women do not have nearly as strong of an effect, nor necessarily in the same direction. This shouldn't be too shocking due to the effects of reduce testosterone over time in men, and starting from such a higher level of aggressiveness.
- rrrrrrrrrrrryan 3y agoJust curious - are these men that mellow out fathers?
- steveBK123 3y agoNot all, no
- deathlight 3y agoPeople do be living, a consequence far removed from most individual’s lives these days. I even had to look up how to spell individual; that's how foreign of a word it is in present times.
- mojifwisi 3y agoLink to the full paper: https://web.archive.org/web/20151010141416id_/http://www.researchgate.net:80/profile/Brent_Roberts/publication/7337585_Patterns_of_mean-level_change_in_personality_traits_across_the_life_course_a_meta-analysis_of_longitudinal_studies/links/00b7d53c23b35d61aa000000.pdf https://web.archive.org/web/20151010141416id_/http://www.res...