17 ms·
The hardware is no doubt impressive, as expected, but I just can't see myself in any of the situations they keep showing in VR/AR demos. Does someone really si
by paxys 3y ago
The hardware is no doubt impressive, as expected, but I just can't see myself in any of the situations they keep showing in VR/AR demos.
Does someone really sit on their couch, put on a massive headset, and scroll through their vacation photos? Does someone watch an entire 2+ hour movie with a sweaty headset strapped to them (and plugged into a socket) instead of on a couch with their family/friends? Would I want to be in a group call with generated avatars of people rather than their actual faces? If the kids are having a fun moment would I want to run inside, grab my headset, strap it on and record a video, or just go join them? Would I rather work on this all day instead of a laptop?
And the one thing I could maybe see this being useful for – gaming – was barely even mentioned in their keynote.
If I'm dropping $3,500 and cutting myself off from the outside world (and no, that weird eye display thing doesn't count), a half-assed substitute for consuming the same content as I would on any other screen isn't going to cut it. Show me the actual future, in terms of software/content/communication/immersiveness, then we'll talk.
- capex 3y agoThey're just advertising the tech and the platform. Probably so people could come up with some real use cases and apps for it... otherwise what's the point of introducing it a year earlier.
- wly_cdgr 3y agoAgreed, bur just give this to some cool people, they'll figure it out
- drrotmos 3y ago> Would I rather work on this all day instead of a laptop? That really is the $3,500 question. Can I see myself preferring to work streaming my Mac's screen to a Vision Pro for my IDE, having and things like Slack and e-mail off to the side running on the headset? I don't know, but if I can, this seems worth it to me.
- oezi 3y agoThe key question is if this thing will stay cool enough to be comfortable.
- donbongo 3y agoThis is the same question i'm asking myself too
- ARandumGuy 3y agoAll day is the key component. Most VR headsets recommend taking breaks every half hour, which isn't just a "cover your ass" warning. I know I can't use my personal headset for much longer without feeling woozy after I take it off. By comparison, I'm at my laptop for 7+ hours just for work. I would need to see compelling evidence that the Vision Pro is safe and comfortable to use for that long before I'd even consider replacing my laptop. And if it can't replace the computers or displays I use, then it's just a $3,500 gimmick.
- qintl55 3y agoThey say that the battery on that is ~2 hours (?) So probably not for work yet.
- mostlysimilar 3y agoIt can be plugged in for all-day use.
- asdff 3y agoYou can buy two or three and swap them out. Chicken scratch for a company when engineers cost so much these days anyhow.
- utopcell 3y agoThe problem is not the cost, it's the experience. You _could_ be carrying multiple laptop batteries with you also. It would make the laptop itself lighter and thinner, but it would be a larger hassle overall.
- xp84 3y agoI was disappointed to see that the battery cord, with the magnetic headset-side connector, seemed hardwired at the battery end. Though this is very in character for Apple. You can bet that each "battery with proprietary cord tail" will be at least $199. Look what they charge for an iPhone "battery pack" -- a $2 ring of magnets, a $5 battery, and a bit of plastic = $99. Given the initial cost is so high, it's both frustrating that they will continue to nickel and dime you, and at the same time unlikely that someone dropping that kind of money will even blink at buying an accessory which actually is less than the sales tax on the device itself.
- mgrandl 3y agoI can 100% see myself preferring working on this thing over a Mac, as long as I don’t need a Mac to host my dev environment.
- byteware 3y agoI mean, depending on the work using it as a thin client would make the most sense imo, compiling still takes a toll on the battery life even with m2 magic
- paxys 3y agoA bigger question is – does it support mouse input? Because none of their demos showed it, and without it the headset is basically dead on arrival for any real work.
- anamexis 3y agoI don't think that's self-evident. If the eye tracking is really good, it could obviate the need for a mouse.
- beebeepka 3y agoWhy would it obviate the need for a mouse? I can focus on something and expect my cursor elsewhere. Especially in games
- anamexis 3y agoBecause any time you're doing fine-grained work with your cursor, you're looking at it. I'm not talking about games.
- jnwatson 3y ago5 minutes with an existing eye tracker will show that this is completely infeasible. Your eyes move too much for it to work. Perhaps you could use it to bring windows forward.
- rad_gruchalski 3y ago> That really is the $3,500 question. For me the question rather is: is being able to work from the sofa a couple of hours a day without having to stare at a small screen worth $3.5k? Certainly.
- randyrand 3y agoMaybe I am in the minority, but I have no problem using my laptop on the couch for a few hours. It's quite comfortable.
- rad_gruchalski 3y agoYes, mostly. But sometimes not. Sometimes I wish I could have those 32 inches on the vesa while still sitting on the sofa.
- rabuse 3y agoI'm with you on this. I see these as a wonderful option for being productive just about anywhere, if the experience is actually what was demoed.
- practice9 3y agoAnd for me spending more than 2 hours per day with laptop on the sofa is a recipe for neck pain and migraines. The angle is just not right. If the headset is more ergonomic for this situation, it will find its target audience for sure. The battery is designed for 2 hours sessions, but the device can run indefinitely while on charger
- josephg 3y agoYeah I’m approaching 40, and if I spend more than 30 minutes or so with a laptop on the couch I get crippling shoulder pain at night while I’m in bed. So this sounds like a lovely way to avoid that problem but - even with a headset strapped to your face, what do you think you’ll be using as input devices? I’ll still want a trackpad and keyboard in my hands. (Waving your arms around all day isn’t fun). And if I have to balance a keyboard on my lap anyway, aside from a bigger virtual screen, what’s the point?
- rtkwe 3y agoIt really depends on how the fake screens actually look in use. You need a decent multiple of the number of pixels in the screen you want to emulate on your AR glasses to be able to pull it off well and so far we haven't really gotten it. I do not see myself getting these till they're a third or less the price either unless they're issued to me for work for some reason.
- acomjean 3y agoAnytime its on your face, you could be working. Front and center, your work. anytime, anywhere. depending on how its implemented you can't get away. Hope they include a power button. But 2 hours of battery life is a good amount of work, though it seems short somehow. Nice to know there is a limit on it taking over your time.
- cesarvarela 3y agoI think that price tag is not for end consumers, but early adopters/builders. There is going to be a gold rush of "maybe I can make that flashlight app that makes me a millionaire". Fun times incoming.
- yowzadave 3y ago> maybe I can make that flashlight app I wonder if you could make a literal flashlight/headlamp, either by using the front-facing display as a light, or just leveraging the infrared/lidar sensor to make night-vision goggles
- olyjohn 3y agoGreat. A bunch of VR shit apps just like the regular app store.
- wnolens 3y agoThese days I've moved over to pomodoro technique to be able to get any work done in the face of WFH distractions and general indifference to my work. So strapping on immersive goggles for 30m-1h chunks and taking lots of breaks actually fits my current work model perfectly and might improve my productivity. It all comes down to.. how clear is text?
- ignoramous 3y agoExactly. You know it is worth it when corp pays for the gadgets ;) I mean, how terribly over-priced is the Mac, and yet...
- dathinab 3y agoWhy? Because if well done I get my reasonable high multi monitor like setup everywhere I want, no matter weather I'm sitting or lying or on the train or at home. Fun thing is if you just skim the article it looks as if they copied https://simulavr.com/ https://simulavr.com/ :=) (They didn't this was developed independent of each other and Apple put some tweaks in it which they claim no one else did and gave it a new name and claim they are the first, like always.)
- coolspot 3y ago> Does someone really sit on their couch, put on a massive headset, and scroll through their vacation photos? A male sitting alone in a dimmed room watching photos with a smug on his face. I think they were hinting at something else than “vacation photos”.
- d3nj4l 3y ago[dead]
- prawn 3y agoThey are going to need a setting to disable hand gestures.
- otabdeveloper4 3y agoIt was a special kind of vacation.
- allenu 3y agoI'm in the camp that sees the whole thing as a novelty. I didn't see any use cases that made me go "Ooh, I need this in my life." I already have multiple screens around me. If I'm watching TV and want to look something up, I can open up my laptop or look at my phone. The nice thing about those are I can physically close the laptop or turn off the phone. With a virtual screen, I have to use some UI to do it. I know it doesn't seem like much of a difference, but to me, there's enough lag and lack of real feel of control that I'd prefer a real object than a virtual one. Interacting with app windows in 3D space also doesn't feel any faster than just using a flat window on a flat screen. I'm already super productive using keyboard + mouse and a flat display, so I don't see how using my voice and turning my head to look at things in a virtual space is any better.
- m3kw9 3y agoTo be fair when the iPhone 1 came out nobody really said they need it in their lives vs a Nokia or BB
- allenu 3y agoFor me, it's hard to make direct comparisons with the world of then. Today, everybody has so many devices and are so used to tech all around them every waking moment. An AR headset doesn't feel like a huge leap in additional day-to-day functionality compared with what a smartphone gave us at the time.
- netsharc 3y agoAs this comparison says[1], people got from Wright Brothers to 747 in a very short time and thought we'd be space travellers soon after that, but hey, a 747 was good enough. [1] https://idlewords.com/talks/web_design_first_100_years.htm https://idlewords.com/talks/web_design_first_100_years.htm
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- entrox 3y ago
- jayd16 3y ago> Does someone really sit on their couch, put on a massive headset, and scroll through their vacation photos? Right now they pull open a (what was once massive) laptop and scroll through vacation photos. > If the kids are having a fun moment would I want to run inside, grab my headset, strap it on and record a video, or just go join them Same as running inside to grab the camcorder, no? >Would I rather work on this all day instead of a laptop? If I got multiple monitors from a laptop on any desk then I would find that pretty compelling.
- PascLeRasc 3y agoRecent phones like the 3GS have a camcorder built in and fit in a pocket.
- jayd16 3y agoIndeed, but its not like the scenario described has never happened. If anything, the camcorder dad was a very popular trope.
- bredren 3y ago>Same as running inside to grab the camcorder, no? Presumably new iPhone will record 3d video.
- shusaku 3y ago> Same as running inside to grab the camcorder, no? I agree with this, plenty of us are old enough to remember our parents lugging a huge video camera around at family events. If the videos are compellingly better, this is a use case.
- JumpCrisscross 3y ago> Does someone watch an entire 2+ hour movie with a sweaty headset strapped to them (and plugged into a socket) instead of on a couch with their family/friends? Flights. This might become a must-have for the jet-setting class. That not only makes Apples first-year numbers, it fertilizes the market for developers.
- haberman 3y agoOn flights you want noise cancellation. Maybe you could pair these with noise-cancelling AirPods, but then would you still get the "spatial audio"?
- jtmarmon 3y ago1. Airpod pros have spatial audio 2. Their presentation showed someone using it with airpods on a plane https://twitter.com/techAU/status/1665790510093697024 https://twitter.com/techAU/status/1665790510093697024
- cj 3y agoHow do airpods compare with noise canceling Bose over the ear? (Genuine question, not rhetorical)
- swores 3y agoTwo years ago they were better than the best in-ear noise cancelling earphones Bose had. I've not kept up to date or tried Bose since then so maybe they've got even better (they weren't bad, just not as good as Airpods Pro, IMO).
- yurishimo 3y agoAirPods ate some of the most highly rated wireless earphones at the moment. Compared to full size Bose, I would say they are 90% comparable.
- csharpminor 3y ago
- mithr 3y ago> Does someone really sit on their couch, put on a massive headset, and scroll through their vacation photos? Does someone watch an entire 2+ hour movie with a sweaty headset strapped to them (and plugged into a socket) instead of on a couch with their family/friends? This was exactly my biggest question. In what situation do you sit and watch family photos of a vacation with your kids alone on your couch? In almost all cases, you're doing that with your family, or showing them to someone else. And if you've got a family (as many people in the ads did!) you're also watching movies together with them most of the time. Apple completely sidestepped talking about how other people might be able to share your experience. Even if this is amazing for actual work, and you're working in a physical office (as the guy in the ad did! as Apple requires all employees do a few days a week!), how will you show your coworker what you're working on? They also conspicuously focused on manufacturing, presentations, and conferencing as their office use cases, and not coding, despite repeatedly stating that small text looks very clear. As for the "running inside and grabbing a headset" aspect, it felt like they were implying that people will wear this everywhere they go (which they similarly imply won't feel weird exactly due to the weird eye display thing), so you'll already be wearing the headset. But that feels like a very, very ambitious goal, that right now seems ridiculously unlikely/niche.
- jumpkick 3y agoRegarding looking at family photos alone, this is typically only done in a film, when you, a character, have experienced some terrible tragedy.
- tootie 3y agoAR is so, so, so difficult and so much more than just good resolution. If they are trying to do passthrough camera then the framerate has to be super high while also delivering all that 4k video. The problems with opacity and occlusion of real and superimposed objects is almost impossible to make it truly immersive. I think their trick is likely going to be in the software and in the interaction modes. You can't strap this to your head and ride a bike with heads up display, this will be a seated experience with a controlled environment. And it may do that one job very, very well.
- opportune 3y agoI have not developed a VR/AR game, but I imagine there are several chicken-egg problems making this possible killer app hard to achieve. One is that VR/AR adoption (and usage) is not enough to justify large studios spending huge sums of money developing games that make extensive use of Vr/ar features, at best they’ll take a regular game and port it to VR. Another is that there aren’t very many workers who are experienced at developing VR/AR applications yet, and that the tooling isn’t mature enough (or standardized enough) for this to be easy. But without killer apps there won’t be enough VR/AR users to begin with. Also the hardware is rapidly developing and creating super flashy applications requires high-specced SKUs that are only supported by a small number of devices in the wild. Porting 2D desktop applications with a couple VR/AR gimmicks to VR is something that is well scoped and comparatively easy, it also is mostly re-usable because any “render a 2D UI in 3d” tech is going to work in most or all applications. So in terms of getting features and applications to encourage adoption, it has very high ROI. Also, people probably aren’t just going to strap on a VR headset to look at vacation photos or YouTube videos if the only thing it offers is a super wide field of view and immersive audio. But they will for… other kinds of photos and videos that Apple can’t demo on stage
- t-writescode 3y ago> Does someone watch an entire 2+ hour movie with a sweaty headset strapped to them (and plugged into a socket) instead of on a couch with their family/friends? Some of us don't have local friends we want to sit down and watch a movie with; and some of us don't have local friends at all. I know people who already watch whole movies, etc, in VRChat. This usecase already exists.
- prawn 3y agoWe have multiple TVs in our house. After the kids are asleep, my wife will watch her preferred shows on an iPad in bed (or second screen while working) despite there being a TV in the room. I can see people using the headset like this. Even when the kids are awake, if granted screentime, more often than not they split off and watch/play completely different things. They'll usually only watch the same thing on the same screen if we insist, usually watching a documentary or telling them to watch the same movie together. Otherwise, their different tastes prevail.
- peoplefromibiza 3y ago> I know people who already watch whole movies, etc, in VRChat. This usecase already exists. mmmmm this line of reasoning is a bit worrying to me. I'll use an hyperbole here, apologizes in advance, it's not specifically a counter argument, just a thought, but to me it's like saying "some people are alone, don't have friends, so they use heroin, I can totally see a usecase for manufacturing heroin" Maybe we should try to fix the underlying problem, before trying to exploit it?
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- goosedragons 3y agoAs someone who lives alone in a tiny apartment I have watched a movie on my Quest 2, quite a few. It's better than watching a movie on my PC monitor that pulls double duty as a TV. Would I pay $3500 for that though? Absolutely not. I'm curious how well gaming will work too. They didn't show off any sort of VR controller a la Quest or PS VR2.
- LtdJorge 3y agoBecause their gaming market would be tiny. Gaming on Mac is completely dead, and mobile gaming will take at least a lot of time to adapt to the hardware.
- joemi 3y ago> Gaming on Mac is completely dead "Dead" is an unnecessary exaggeration. I'm a Mac gamer and my Steam library has more Mac games in it than I can possibly play all the way through. No Man's Sky was just released for Mac, and I'm looking forward to playing that too. I just played through Subnautica at the same time as my friend who was playing it on his Switch and he was blown away at how much better and smoother it was on my M1 MacBook. Also Parallels and Crossover open up the ability to play a lot of Windows games on a Mac. I'm still impressed with just how well that works for some games. I'm not a bleeding-edge everything-in-my-life-is-about-gaming gamer, sure, but I still think I'm a gamer. Yes, compared to the Windows gaming market, the Mac gaming market is small, but it's not dead.
- yyyk 3y ago>No Man's Sky 7-years old game. >Subnautica 5-years old game. >Parallels and Crossover Paid emulation, but not as slick of Steam's Proton (which one could get for no extra cost). Linux currently has better gaming support than Mac. Gaming on Mac is not "completely dead", but it's basically getting leftovers. That's ok for many people, but it will negatively affect the fortunes of "Vision Pro".
- krzyk 3y ago
- erTAlEAS 3y agoI agree that it's undoubtedly a very impressive device. I think the next generation of computing devices is going to be centered around the device understanding the environment around you, what you are looking at and doing. E.g. you are shopping, cooking, fixing something at home, running, playing basketball and the device understands what you are doing and gives you info and help about the activity. Democratizing access to a personal universal coaching for everyone, like the Internet did with access to information. This device is kind of like a mac on your head, I think it doesn't differentiate itself enough from what is currently available. That's with the exception for entertainment: gaming and movies where I expect it will provide a much more immersive experience to what you can have at home with a traditional setup, like the other similar device do. I do like the eye display on the front, I think Apple is making a correct bet that these devices can't cut you off from the outside world. In the long run they will be small enough not to cover the face at all. I think it's probably another 5-10 years before the next big thing, but with the Apple silicon advancements and few year of lessons from this device Apple is the best position to dominate that space then.
- zebnyc 3y agoRegarding the photo library, I can speak for my wife. We have a kindergartener and one of my wife's favorite activities is to watch pictures / videos of our kid in bed. She can do this for hours on end to entertain herself. She also likes to watch movies on an iphone instead of a big screen cause she can use it while performing other tasks (cooking, cleaning etc). She has always said no to a larger form factor like a iPad but I think this might be a good use case for her.
- prawn 3y agoMy wife also watches content on phone and iPad. Usually in a room with a TV in it. Doubt she's intentionally watched something on a TV screen for weeks. I mostly watch on a second or third screen while working. Our TVs are used by the kids, and even then they will happily take an iPad instead.
- Pxtl 3y ago> Does someone watch an entire 2+ hour movie with a sweaty headset strapped to them (and plugged into a socket) instead of on a couch with their family/friends? Let's be real, most media content is being consumed on phones these days. In those cases? Yes, a headset is basically just a smartphone for your face. But I agree about the demos in general focusing on stuff you can do already just fine in 2D. There was very little that looked like a useful application of a HUD. No 3D modeling work, no superimposing digital info over relevant real-world objects... just normal computer and smartphone tasks, but wearing a big sweaty heavy expensive face-screen.
- princevegeta89 3y agoCan it be straining the eyes, head, ears, and jaws? Also, what are the negative mental effects of being lost in that world for 2+ hours? Staring at my phone, I still know what's beside me.. I can fall asleep with stuff still playing on my phone... but I can't imagine what sort of an experience it is to fall asleep with the headset still wrapped around your skull...lol
- robbyking 3y ago> Does someone really sit on their couch, put on a massive headset, and scroll through their vacation photos? There was a time that people said the same thing about digital photos -- people swore nothing would ever replace physical photo albums, and thought the idea of having to look at a screen to view your vacation photos was insane. Now just imagine a few generations from now when Apple Vision is the size of a pair of regular eye glasses.
- wpietri 3y agoWhen do you believe that time was? Because that's not how I remember it. I borrowed an Apple QuickTake from friends in the mid '90s, and bought an Olympus 1-megapixel camera not too long after. People definitely complained about the low quality. And some said they didn't want to have to go to a desktop computer to view their photos, which was very plausible given the size and slowness of desktop computers of the time. And they turned out to be basically correct. Digital photography became wildly more popular with the rise of the smartphone and the tablet. Basically computers had to get much more human-friendly, fitting into the existing human world, so that you could use photos as you would with an album, handing them around, pointing at them, etc. Which is part of what makes me skeptical about facehugger VR. Instead of putting technology in their living rooms, it requires people to cut themselves off from their surroundings and pretend to be somewhere else. It's the exact opposite of what made digital photography work for the masses.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- parasubvert 3y agoDigital photography had already won by the time the iPad came out 13 years ago, the DSLR and Point and Shoots were everywhere, and Kodak was on the brink of bankruptcy. Smartphones as awesome cameras didn't really take off until 2010-2011 with the iPhone 4/4s, where it was competing with point and shoots. Facehugger AR is potentially great for bringing remote people into your living room. AppleTV is getting FaceTime, (and Zoom/webex), SharePlay already exists to sync media across remote participants, etc. Also 3d moment captures / replays could be a killer app.
- thefz 3y agoAR/VR is still a solution in search of a problem and will be for a long time. This is one of the most laughable launches and devices I have ever witnessed in my life.
- johnfn 3y ago> Does someone really sit on their couch, put on a massive headset, and scroll through their vacation photos? Does someone watch an entire 2+ hour movie with a sweaty headset strapped to them (and plugged into a socket) instead of on a couch with their family/friends? Not saying that I like it, but a very large swath of people mindlessly scroll instagram for hours a day, or watch movies on their laptop.
- richardw 3y agoUnity as a partner. This thing hasn’t arrived yet. It’ll definitely have games. Personally this is the first AR kit I’ve vaguely wanted. The software, hardware and partner list makes this a game changer. There are more like me.
- ztrww 3y ago> Unity as a partner. Shovelware games drowning in ads and iAPs?
- richardw 3y agoMeaning it's an indication that Apple are interested in games and that more partners will come. This is not the last game-oriented move; anyone with any sense in the market is currently staying up late to think how to leverage this. The people who buy this are the customers you want.
- zitterbewegung 3y agoThis is good for gamers actually not for the obvious one (hand tracking ) but actually the ability to immediately change the isolation. The biggest problem I have with doing stuff in VR is that I multitask in certain games and if you make it so I can switch to something else momentarily then that’s a big win. I agree with you though that why they haven’t been much more aggressive with gaming at wwdc unless at launch or nearer they wanted to announce then but that would be ridiculous since gamers preorder everything and announcing a game would push more gamers to that.
- asdff 3y agoApple hasn't cared about gaming seriously for perhaps decades.
- Aeolun 3y agoI find the gaming experience on the Apple TV really nice.
- DrBenCarson 3y agoWhy there isn’t an Apple TV Ultra with an M2 with extra GPUs to rival the traditional consoles is lost on me honestly. Seems like a massive missed opportunity with relatively low development costs.
- Apocryphon 3y agoWhat are you playing there?
- olyjohn 3y agoSolitaire. Pong. The latest and greatest, bro.
- Apocryphon 3y agoA proud Mac gaming tradition. https://youtu.be/2B-ekl_cEWk https://youtu.be/2B-ekl_cEWk
- Aeolun 3y agoBasically anything on Apple Arcade. “Cricket through the Ages” is hilarious. “Crossy Road Castle” for multiplayer.
- asdff 3y agoIts no PS5/Xbox/Gaming PC
- beezle 3y agoNobody really likes wearing ski goggles, especially for many hours. I can't begin to imagine how annoying it will be to wear something heavier. Hope it has some type of ventilation system! Perhaps a HN opthamologist can chime in - what are the long term effects on vision likely to be from wearing/using a device like this for extended periods of time every day?
- Melatonic 3y agoThats what I am wondering - is this good for us?
- beachy 3y agoI wonder if there will be an answer for this. I've spent the last 35 odd years of my working life peering at screens, from teensy phosphor numbers to decent wide screens. I've had issues with OOS but never with my eyes. I have never heeded any of the warnings about taking a break, refocusing every 20 minutes etc. My eyes are just fine, well as good as most other people my age. My pick is there will be some recommendations with this, but they'll be hand wavey and you won't know if ignoring them will fry your eyes or have no effect whatsoever.
- OJFord 3y ago> (and no, that weird eye display thing doesn't count) That weird eye display thing is the only novel thing here, as far as I can tell? I actually thought that was pretty neat. (Not 3.5k suddenly-I'm-interested-in-VR neat, but still.)
- caconym_ 3y ago> massive > sweaty > strapped > instead of [...] their family/friends > generated avatars > kids [...] grab my headset, strap it on [...] or just go join them? > cutting myself off from the outside world > half-assed substitute for consuming the same content > Show me the actual future It seems like you're trying very hard to convince yourself this will be a bad product that is unpleasant to use and carries unavoidable antisocial externalities. It could very well be all of that and more, but I don't really understand why you would bother with this level of self-assured negativity before there are even any unbiased hands-on impressions out there. Apple is historically very good at execution. > Would I rather work on this all day instead of a laptop? You know, I very well might!
- electrondood 3y agoShoot, I would. I've been dreaming of a headset to replace my monitors for years now.
- sanderjd 3y agoI don't think all those points seem like "trying very hard", they totally seem to me like the base case, and it's up to the product to rise to the occasion and show how this is all wrong.
- brookst 3y ago/ˈpredʒədɪs/ Not that it's morally wrong in this case, I just don't see the upside of deciding what it's like now rather than waiting for data.
- sanderjd 3y agoWe have data: all the marketing materials they released are data. It is perfectly reasonable to look at what they have put out as "these are the use cases we're explicitly highlighting" and find them wanting. Especially because it's not a new class of product. Many of the people bringing criticisms have used past products in this space, and these are their criticisms of those products. This is not some hypothetical thing, VR headsets already exist. This looks like a very solid, probably class leading, iteration on the product, but it's still just an iteration.
- hn_throwaway_99 3y agoI totally agree with everything you've written, but I'd just put forth that I think what Apple did with Apple Watch could be instructive here. Apple Watch was basically originally marketed as a high-end app/notification device (remember the original 10k gold Apple Watch?) Over time they realized the real target market and use case was as a fitness/health tracker, and they doubled down on features and design for that. With these AR/VR headsets, I agree that gaming is the one use case I've actually seen these headsets be great at, but all these companies keep trying to extend it to our daily lives that nobody seems to really want. But I could believe Apple would eventually come around to seeing one or two really good target markets (gaming and watching movies maybe?) and then just really hone in on that. Folks say games will be a tough sell because Apple isn't really known as a gaming platform, but I don't think this is really true if you take iOS games into account. I can easily see game developers wanting to build for this given the hardware capabilities.
- lolinder 3y agoNo one is going to buy a $3500 headset for their puzzle and idle games, so Apple's existing games market is not going to help them sell this device. For Apple to break into the VR games space they'll have to woo both serious gamers and large game studios, both of which seem extremely unlikely given the huge cultural disconnect.
- throw74775 3y agoI worked at a games company that only made casual games and we had individual users who spent more that $3500 per month, admittedly not many, but more than one.
- lolinder 3y agoI'm not saying that casual gamers don't have the cash, I'm saying that casual games almost by definition won't benefit from an immersive experience. People aren't going to go out and spend $3500 to play Candy Crush in the air. Well, not enough to make this device take off.
- 3y ago
- foobarbecue 3y agoI watch tv shows often and movies occasionally on my Quest 2. Often the TV shows aren't in 4K anyway so I'm not losing any resolution. The main reason I do it is the perfect darkness you get with the headset on. Shows like Silo are too dark to watch during the day in my southern california apartment. I know I could get blackout curtains or whatever but the Quest is actually cheaper and easier.
- jillesvangurp 3y agoSure, the announcement is full of cliches and more than a little cringeworthy. But I'm not aware of any device that provides this level of quality and immersion for things like 2D and 3D movies, games, or simply the amount of screen real estate for anything 2D people already use. The genius move with this strategy is that it is mostly about leveling up 2D and existing content and software. With some sprinkling of 3D content. And probably this device is not fast enough for full immersive 3D gaming to begin with. You'd need that new Mac Studio in a backpack mounted on your back with probably a few kilos of battery dangling behind it and some cooling for you and all that hardware. Not going to happen. Some light gaming is probably fine. But it would be a mistake to aim this at gamers. If this works as advertised, this could basically replace most of my devices. Why have a laptop when I can just project whatever in my field of view, grab a wireless keyboard and go to work. Not that different from what magic leap promised to deliver years ago. Only issue with that is of course that they never really delivered that. Apple seems a bit further with their R&D. Probably the first generation will have some significant limitations and a certain level of being just a bit uncomfortable. That head band doesn't look fun without AC, for example. And of course motion sickness might be a thing. Not to mention headaches and other potential side-effects of prolonged exposure to this. And probably showing up in public with this is not a great idea in terms of getting robbed, beaten up, etc. Also, the whole interacting with family is seriously cringe-worthy to look at. This looks to me like a solo experience that has not much capability for sharing it with others. On the other hand, I think they just presented a big money making machine with an amazing walled garden that is pretty much guaranteed to bring countless users if if gets even close to delivering what is on display here. I think 3.5K$ is pretty OK as a price point. I don't have that kind of disposable income necessarily. But lots of people undeniably do. And this does have a certain level of wow that unlocks that kind of budget for those with this kind of money. I bet lots of people are itching to throw money at this thing on the off chance it is much than half as good as this announcement suggests. I'm just hoping that this kicks the competition into gear. This looks like it is a lot nicer to have than some of the other stuff out there. The flip side is of course that it's all locked behind the towering walls of Apple's walled garden. This just screams for a more open answer. Meta looks like it just got its lunch eaten pretty thoroughly. Mark Zuckerberg going on about having meetings in VR just isn't quite going to be good enough. I'd love to see what MS comes up with. They've been working on holo lens for years and been holding off on putting it in the hands of consumers. This might prompt them to kick a few things into gear. A pro-sumer focused version of that maybe with some XBox and Steam action on the side could tempt a few people. And of course all of this stuff is going to be cat nip for the adult entertainment industry. Forget games. I don't think I need to spell that out for this audience. I'm curious to see how Apple is going to contain that.
- codelord 3y agoI think if the hardware is good and even more importantly developer tools are easy to use and better than competition this could be successful. It doesn't really matter what Apple shows in their demo what the use cases are. Does anyone share heart-beats on Apple watch? No. Yet, Apple Watch is a best selling product.
- crazygringo 3y ago> Does someone watch an entire 2+ hour movie with a sweaty headset strapped to them I just want to say, absolutely. Except it's not sweaty. You're not going to do it in a social situation -- it's not replacing a movie the family watches together -- but in your bedroom or home alone absolutely. Just recline on your bed/couch and watch an IMAX-sized screen in the sky above you. Surround sound in your AirPods. I already do it with my Quest 2 and it's glorious. It's hard to imagine how good the experience is until you've tried it. And I'm convinced that within a few years, it's going to become the main way of watching movies together with friends/family/lovers when you're geographically apart -- whether 2,000 miles or 2 miles.
- dahwolf 3y agoI must be old-fashioned or even anti-social, but what exactly is the point of watching a movie together remotely? Does it become some kind of group debate that constantly interrupts the movie?
- crazygringo 3y agoWith comedies you're laughing together and it's awesome. I did that constantly during COVID with friends. Especially great for reality TV shows, you can pause and make jokes about what's going on. It's really fun to pause and chat about what's happening and then resume. Yes it's constantly interrupting the movie but that's the whole point. But because you pause you're not missing dialog or anything. I mean, do you not see a difference in watching something on a couch with friends vs. watching the same thing by yourself?
- dahwolf 3y agoI'll come clean and admit that as it comes to watching movies, I'm anti-social. I do not want to discuss the movie whilst watching it, at all. Lighter content like the news, a talk show, things like that...sure.
- onepointsixC 3y agoDuring Covid & lockdowns, loads of people watched movies together. It's not much different from watching a movie with a friend at your own place. VR gives the activity sense of presence which is hard to describe, but basically it's even more of a social experience.
- drited 3y agoI would totally rather work on this all day instead of being hunched over a laptop. The freedom of posture, and the expansiveness of the desktop real estate blow laptop productivity out of the water in my opinion.
- kaba0 3y agoAnd type on what exactly? On a keyboard in your desk/lap. I don’t see the posture that much more flexible.
- fnordpiglet 3y agoI have a 360 go pro. That does make the headset worth it.
- 30minAdayHN 3y agoI always wanted something like this. I lived in small apartments where I cannot have large screens. I always thought having a good VR / AR headset will unlock a huge screen which I don't have access to otherwise. Of course, it's anyone's speculation and numbers will give us answers in future. I see very similar parallel to headphones imo - why would anyone wear a device instead of listening to amazing speakers. I feel the same for vision.
- rib3ye 3y ago> Does someone really sit on their couch, put on a massive headset, and scroll through their vacation photos? If your photos are: 1. 3D movies 2. viewed in a collaborative setting instead of trying to show your stupid phone to everyone at the table, one at a time yes, you are going to view photos in headset.
- olyjohn 3y agoSo, instead of projecting onto the TV, everybody in the same room is gonna put on a headset?
- LightBug1 3y agoTo be honest, I was looking to hate on this, but they sold it much better than the others... I can see value in it where before it was a gimmick. And come to think of it, isn't this where Apple does best? Taking the components of an idea that others have failed with, and using them to create a new market category. That thing will have to be as light as a feather though... What weirded me out most though, was the feeling that all the presenters had run their demonstrations through chatGPT "in the style of Steve Jobs". Maybe the SMT have rebooted Jobs via an LLM! I enjoyed the memory of him though.
- lolinder 3y agoWhat value do you see here that others haven't already tried selling? I haven't watch the keynote yet, but the landing page looks like all the same concepts Meta's been trying and failing to get people excited about for years now.
- LightBug1 3y agoPossibly it's the confidence that there is "something" behind it. I. E. Apple software... To get all nostalgic again... "And one more thing... the iPhone runs OSX * rapturous applause *". It's that same kind of thing. When I think of Meta, I think Facebook and it's absolutely over. I see Zuck avatar, I see cringe. Same with other manufacturers. Not many have the depth to deliver short and long term. Especially if dropping serious money on it. You have to hand it to Apple, the presentation is cliché, but they know how to sell. I won't be getting one, but I can imagine these selling decently. Not iPhone scale, obviously, but enough to cement the market
- oblio 3y agoHistorically, I think it dates back to Jobs not liking them, Apple doesn't really care about games. It begrudgingly accepts them on the platform as second rate citizens since there's a lot of money involved.
- prawn 3y agoI wonder if they think you either have to be the top dog (PC? PS5?) or you're better off getting the casual gamers (iOS) and not distracting the core business? It's a massive, successful company. I don't think they begrudgingly accept it, or extrapolate from the personal preference of a past boss. The past boss taught them that style and status sells and they've continued with that because it's successful, not just because it was his thing.
- pxc 3y ago> Does someone watch an entire 2+ hour movie with a sweaty headset strapped to them (and plugged into a socket) instead of on a couch with their family/friends? My mom does this because she's legally blind and the best assistive devices she can use for movies are AR goggles that do magnification/zoom. It's the only way she can make out a human face in a film. I've worn them for parts of movies as well just to try them and it's really not so bad. The calculus here will obviously be different for people with normal vision, but I figured this experience with a similar use case was worth noting.
- liendolucas 3y agoI got very similar thoughts... I think the most promising future of this tech are simulations of all kinds: let's virtually open a human body and study it, let's disassemble an engine to see how each part works, let's project how a city should be wise-designed to avoid transport issues, etc. Even most of these things can be also appreciated using regular tech. Why should Apple succeed when most of other companies have not succeeded (Occulus, Hololens, HTC Vive)? Putting aside not so stunning technology, people actually didn't get engaged with the tech so much. I had the opportunity to use a version of the Occulus some years ago and found them pretty impressive, but even though at the time I saw it like a cool gadget only to be enjoyed for a very limited amount of time.
- wslh 3y ago> Why should Apple succeed when most of other companies have not succeeded (Occulus, Hololens, HTC Vive)? Because it is Apple and has shown success (excellent execution) where others don't? How can Apple make chips that astonish incumbents such as Intel without having their own fab? How can they run a real OS in iPhone 1 where Linux existed for long? Surely Apple can fail as other companies do but I they can estimate a market potential with real data.
- tinus_hn 3y agoNo wireless. Less space than a Nomad. Lame.
- mynegation 3y agoAt least one use case I could think of is work on the go. I work from home but I can work from anywhere in my country. But I really do not like working on a small laptop screen, and wish my two 27” displays were with me. If this thing provides at least reasonable substitute- I am game.
- sanderjd 3y ago> Would I rather work on this all day instead of a laptop? Generally right there with you, but this is the one that I think ... maybe? I don't see laptops as an unbeatable experience, and I see work as probably the only thing in my life that might benefit from an "infinite digital canvas".
- z3t4 3y agoWhat about glasses ? https://xreal.com/air/ https://xreal.com/air/ https://global.rokid.com/ https://global.rokid.com/ https://www.lenovo.com/us/en/thinkrealitya3/ https://www.lenovo.com/us/en/thinkrealitya3/ https://www.tcl.com/eu/en/glasses/tcl-nxtwear-air https://www.tcl.com/eu/en/glasses/tcl-nxtwear-air
- quartz 3y ago> Does someone watch an entire 2+ hour movie with a sweaty headset strapped to them (and plugged into a socket) instead of on a couch with their family/friends? I actually tried watching a downloaded Netflix movie on my quest while on a cross country flight once and it was surprisingly not terrible. Also I managed to get away with not ending up on some viral twitter post despite probably looking ridiculous. That said if it wasn’t so bulky I’d probably bring it on more flights but it’s such a pain to lug around I haven’t really done it since.
- goodoldneon 3y agoWe’re still really early in the AR/VR space. Hardware is bulky and expensive but that’ll change over time. Eventually we’ll have lightweight, high-fidelity, reasonably-priced hardware and AR/VR usage will be common
- p1necone 3y agoAgreed. VR/AR headsets are amazing for gaming, and I imagine could be pretty useful for 3d modelling type applications too. But after the novelty wore off for me I couldn't imagine using it over just a regular screen for basically anything else.
- CPLX 3y agoCtrl-F Did anyone say porn yet? Looks like no. So I guess I’ll say it.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- patrickwalton 3y agoI have type 1 narcolepsy and the prospect of being able to work laying horizontal in bed while my muscles are 90% shut off from a sleep attack is worth at least $3k.
- partiallypro 3y agoI thought the hardware was a bit underwhelming considering Apple has an ultra-powerful chip that no one else has with amazing battery life...and they can only squeeze in 2 hours and there is a big cable running down/side of the headset. Maybe it's nicer in person. More impressive to me would be a really well-done pair of actual glasses that are "smart glasses" like the ThinkReality. This to me just doesn't solve any of the major problems with VR/AR (this is not really AR.)
- matthewhartmans 3y agohttps://www.youtube.com/watch?v=s-kdRdzxdZQ https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=s-kdRdzxdZQ It's all going to plan ;)
- Dalewyn 3y ago>but I just can't see myself in any of the situations they keep showing in VR/AR demos. We said the same thing about fingering our way through endless content on a handheld slab of glass we now call smartphones. Innovation doesn't happen without some thinking outside of the box; most of them will be flops, but you'll never succeed if you never even try. >Would I want to be in a group call with generated avatars of people rather than their actual faces? Speaking as a gamer who reminisces the good old days of MMORPGs, I don't care for peoples' mugs. Speaking as a Japanese, the insistence on seeing peoples' mugs everywhere seems distinctly like a western thing that I can't really relate to. Besides, I see them all the time in person (or the rare video call) anyway. >Would I rather work on this all day instead of a laptop? If it turns out the work flows better there, you'll probably say yes. Won't know until we try, though. >And the one thing I could maybe see this being useful for – gaming – was barely even mentioned in their keynote. Apple has given negatives damns to games since time immemorial. iOS being a great mobile gaming platform is an outlier, not the norm.
- dann0 3y agoI don't think this is for 'us' yet - which is why its labelled Pro. I think this is definitely going to be like the Watch - they can see the segment could do with a high quality platform, but they don't know what the killer app will be. This is about getting it into the hands of the developers and people with strong ideas on how it can be used. Also, Apple is rumoured to have been spending lots of energy and money on relationships with high quality game developers lately. I think this shows how seriously they are taking gaming, and area they are really not done well at. Hopefully, they can make this an Apple Watch hardware-wise, and Apple TV content-wise. I excited to see what the clever 3rd parties come up with!
- sam0x17 3y agoAll of this is true, but my biggest complaint is the only really good use case other than games for this sort of tech is immersing yourself in a bunch of terminals in VR, and they even botched that what with it not being a real OS that can run traditional dev environments and only allowing you to embed one mac screen in the whole thing. Like who wants to sit around in a glorified iOS all day and essentially screen cast your one mac screen into there? I should be able to have my vscode window to my left, browser to my right, more terminals to the side and above, etc.. This is going to very quickly become the product that allows CEOs and other megalomaniacs to sit on the couch for three hours watching photo albums of their accomplishments or whatever it is they alluded to. I can see why they went for the $3500 price tag, this is basically an admission that there isn't mass-market appeal for non-gaming VR stuff at the moment, so might as well get $$$ and make it a status symbol for the C suite. The problem is all the people within apple who sanity test this idea, are also those types.. This is not the category disruption they made this out to be.
- nextlevelwizard 3y ago>only really good use case other than games I would actually say that games are NOT a good use case for VR. Some simulation games (mainly racing and flying) are fine for VR, but if you are really into those genres you probably already have better equipment to actually simulate cockpit equipment or at very least wheel and pedals. All other games in VR suck ass. Either they are just 3d movies with some small interactive pits in them or they are tech demos which are stretched to couple hours and called a game or they are just "jump scare the game". My main problem is the movement. Unless you dedicate entire room(s) to VR you have to use D-pad/stick to move - which for me defeats the whole purpose of VR - or you have to use the stupid teleportation which either breaks your game by completely trivializing it or makes movement extremely frustrating. I think we have pretty definitely already showed that gaming isn't the killer VR app. We have had affordable VR headsets on the market for years, but the industry hasn't shifted (because VR is at best a mildly amusing gimmick). We need one of those infinite mats where you can walk and run to become actually usable and drop in price low enough that headset + the mat are together affordable.
- babyshake 3y agoThe audience right now, IMO, is mostly wealthy people who want a new toy. So with that in mind the use-cases they showed make more sense.
- justizin 3y agoOculus already lets you watch Netflix and stuff, visually it’s a pretty decent experience, but like … 42” TVs are $300 or something. you’re not gonna fall asleep on the couch with your headset on, or at least you certainly don’t want to. I think it’s a beautiful and fascinating piece of tech, I doubt I’ll be an early purchaser, but I’d sure like one. It does feel like they are grasping at straws for mainstream use cases.
- albert_e 3y agothe 3D camera should be a separate device. Don't need a head mounted monster for it. I am actually surprised that with prevalance of all the big powerful smartphones with cameras being a flagship feature, we haven't seen 3D cameras (two 2D cameras separated by the inter ocular distance, mounted on the back of a phone) become common yet.
- FpUser 3y ago>"Does someone watch an entire 2+ hour movie..." Avatar is 3+ hours. Would drain a battery which accordingly to specs lasts 2hrs.
- Jemm 3y agoSure, for $500 get a Meta Quest 3 which works just fine. Apple is smoking Steve's ashes with the $3,500 price tag.
- veidr 3y agoI share some of your skepticism, but I do indeed watch movies in my VR headset (while running on my elliptical trainer). I use the Meta Quest Pro right now, so it's not plugged into anything, but I would not be averse to plugging it into some phone-sized battery unit in my pocket or clipped to my belt or something. And I definitely, desperately, do also want to do my software engineering job in VR (with many large displays or floating windows) and not my laptop. But the question is, will those of us who see this future coming and are waiting impatiently for it want to do it with this headset? The Meta Quest Pro is pretty amazing in its own right (and pretty expensive, although not Apple expensive) but it nevertheless just isn't there yet. It reminds me of using Linux for desktop computing in 1999. You can see it will be great one day, but it's definitely not great yet. I feel like Apple could maybe build that if they wanted to... but do they?
- nine_k 3y agoIn the video they show luxurious, spacious interiors. To my mind, the virtual space makes much more sense when your pysical space is cramped (plane, train, car, cubicle) but you need a large display, preferably in 3D. 3D footage and movies, which can be relatively easily downcast to 2D for flat screen consumption, may be another hit. Especially the footage you shoot yourself, pretty exclusive and likely more future-proof. Imagine an upcoming iPhone with a stereo camera (in landscape mode). Also there are obvious traditional applications of AR / VR that become more useful with a retina-class display, such as medical, mechanical / repairs work, and, of course, military. I suspect the medical market can be pretty large, because serious medicine, like heart surgery, won't be strained by the price.
- bandrami 3y agoI think in practice AR is the bigger use, e.g. the Louvre lets you rent one of these (or maybe you've bought one and the Louvre gives you an app for it) and it shows you where to walk to go see the painting of the guy made of vegetables or whatever. Like an audio tour but visual and interactive.
- kaba0 3y agoI imagine one museum actually making it quality, while the rest would just straight up suck. Suckiness in AR/VR I imagine is way worse than a bad UI on your phone.
- olyjohn 3y agoI wonder what it will look like when your wall is 3 feet from your face, but your "monitor" is 10 feet away?
- nine_k 3y agoSimple: you don't see the wall. The mask is not transparent. It shows the real world around through cameras. It can as well show none of it, or imitate a hole in it that leads into an endless perspective.
- parentheses 3y agoI feel this is an overly negative take on what they shipped. It's a platform. The platform seems to solve a lot of the problems of AR/VR (feeling of isolation, control of leaking outside world, better integration with your digital life, truly enhanced media - media that's more mainstream). For those of us who have no use/space for a TV in their home, this is a SMASHING replacement. Imagine if you watch TV nightly but do so alone, this could bring a whole new meaning to "watch parties". For those who don't have a desk and want to be able to stand and work on a kitchen bar, this is a great substitute for an office. I would love to have an office but some times you just can't. The idea that I could use my mac side by side with iOS features that matter to me is huge. I'm slightly disappointed that it's limited to one display, but still pretty nice. I feel like the argument here is the same as the iPhone when it came out - it replaces a lot of low cost items with not 100% coverage but enough to be a compelling buy such that you can rid yourself of those other things. If they make one that can stream 2 screens from my laptop and can be a standalone device for certain useful situations, it's a good buy for me. Ultimately you have to try it to buy it because unlike an iPad, it sits on your face.
- behnamoh 3y ago> but I just can't see myself in any of the situations they keep showing in VR/AR demos. They told Steve Jobs that no one likes to tab on a piece of glass, people want physical buttons. And yet, here we are.
- SamuelAdams 3y agoRead the novel Warcross by Marie Lu. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Warcross?wprov=sfti1 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Warcross?wprov=sfti1 Imagine a world where visual, immersive tech is the default. Look around your home. Realize how much money you have spent on cosmetics. Pictures, photographs, throw pillows, plants, paint, lighting, etc. What if all of that could be replaced at the snap of a command? What if you could hang Christmas lights virtually in less than 10 seconds? What if a poor family who could not afford Christmas lights and decorations could now snap them into place in a second, for free? Sure these goggles are not that mainstream yet. The battery life is too short. They are bulky and sweaty. But the tech will improve. What if wearing immersive goggles was no more difficult than wearing glasses? It might take a few decades but the tech will get there.
- rapiz 3y agoWe're talking about a product and you present a story.
- SamuelAdams 3y agoThe OP I replied to was asking about use cases for an augmented reality product, I listed a few.
- zerbinxx 3y agoSure but.. there’s just the fundamental “not real” element of digital “stuff”. It goes away when the $3500 headset comes off. And I’m not even a pure luddite about this shit, I enjoy getting a new sword in Diablo IV, but the notion that the average guy will buy VR Christmas deco for their AR home (which they don’t own) is hilarious/deluded in a special way
- jkestner 3y agoIs that another scifi novel where you forget it’s set in a dystopia?
- kaba0 3y ago> Realize how much money you have spent on cosmetics. Pictures, photographs, throw pillows, plants, paint, lighting, etc Like a $100 bucks at most? That poor family will surely buy every member a used car’s worth of device. And no, I don’t see it a reality neither in 3-4 generations — it is fundamentally more expensive to produce than a TV/laptop/phone so if its price lowers, so does the rest. It is not a must like a phone is, so why would they not buy a really good TV instead for a tiny fraction of the money?
- baby 3y agoI definitely watched Netflix on the Oculus go which was a crappy screen and a overheating headset, and yet it was amazing. The only thing that prevented me from finishing was the battery. I also joined a cinema experience and there were other people sitting next to me in the room. Man you really have to try it to understand how dope it is
- Sparkyte 3y agoJust buy your whole team the Quest 3.
- jrnichols 3y ago> Does someone really sit on their couch, put on a massive headset, and scroll through their vacation photos? I would, yes. > Does someone watch an entire 2+ hour movie with a sweaty headset strapped to them (and plugged into a socket) instead of on a couch with their family/friends? Yes, absolutely. We have a very small 2 bed, 1 bath place and only 1 TV that's in the central area. If I want to watch a movie while my wife is involved in her studies or work, I'm limited to my iPad or my iPhone. With this, I can lay there and chill. We have no kids, and we don't have friends over for movies. I'm also very susceptible to outside distractions. This would allow me to focus a whole lot more. > And the one thing I could maybe see this being useful for – gaming – was barely even mentioned in their keynote. Perhaps Apple doesn't want it to be brushed off already as another Oculus or gaming toy? > a half-assed substitute for consuming the same content I don't think this is a half assed substitute at all. There's literally nothing else like this. > Show me the actual future, in terms of software/content/communication/immersiveness, then we'll talk. They just showed you. You weren't listening. You focused on gaming. Again, that's probably why they didn't. The anatomy app demo alone would be reason enough for me to buy one. I am frequently in medical related classes and often refer to my anatomy guides on my iPad.
- websap 3y agoI wonder what you'd have to say when someone built the first laptop? It's large, slow, sluggish and not powerful enough as my desktop PC? The device is an engineering marvel and this is the first time that an AR device that's bringing mass appeal. The demo with Disney looked sick, watching the replay of a sporting event in that table top 3-d view would be awesome!
- nextlevelwizard 3y ago>Does someone watch an entire 2+ hour movie with a sweaty headset strapped to them (and plugged into a socket) instead of on a couch I have never watched movies in VR, but in my previous smaller apartment I did watch quite a lot of Youtube with Quest2. I didn't have room for larger solution, phone is way too small and pad is hard to position. With VR headset you could lie in a coffin and still have huge screen. I am also pretty sure I spent longer than 2 hour sessions in VR and sweat wasn't an issue, but I live in Fennoscandia, so I won't just sweat while sitting still. >with their family/friends? It has been a hot minute since I have actually watched a movie with anyone else
- k_bx 3y ago[dead]
- iopq 3y agoThey're not going to show you jerking off to the most immersive porn ever in their ad But that's what majority of people would actually buy VR headsets would do
- graderjs 3y agoI totally want to get this thing! This is awesome! Ha ha ha! :) I don't know if I'd like it, but I certainly want to try it. Looks fucking great! Ha ha ha :)
- ccppurcell 3y agoI wouldn't mind having a huge monitor that I can use anywhere, set up just how I like it. Other than that, you are spot on. Also the camera presents a privacy issue. It has to be always on I suppose.
- heresie-dabord 3y ago> but I just can't see myself in any of the situations they keep showing In other words, what problem is being solved by this product, and will the demand scale sufficiently to turn a profit? Some solutions are enthusiastically -- almost pathologically -- in search of a problem.
- mo_42 3y agoComputers and peripherals have been coming closer to our bodies for decades. Think of the first mobile phones and how strange it was to see people talking on the street. Now, we have headphones with ANC. So, something for eyes might very well be the next step.
- kwanbix 3y agoIt is not 3.500. It is 3.500 plus tax. So closer to 3800. Almost 4000 dollars.
- blantonl 3y agoDon't forget the Apple Branded Case and cleaning cloth, which will easily push the cost to $5,200 /s
- davycro 3y agoI would use this at work in the hospital, especially ultrasound guided procedures.
- mihaaly 3y agoI see myself using it for virtual screens as a work environment. But with real keyboard and mouse. And not for this price. I'll wait. Also for first experiences about comfort, reliability, practicality. I despise desks and chairs with screens, that's why using laptop with internal screen only most of the time - which is not ideal, not at all -, relocating based on my needs and mood. But could use lot more screen space. The watching movie and have a chat with a helmet on while moving around in the hotel room scenarios are just .... well, sorry, couldn't find kinder word for it, just stupid. I feel the sweat of the marketing folks through, trying to find a usecase they feel is pompus enough, worthy for fanfares. It is repelling. Especially for 3500, they are out of their minds! : ) It is in the way, physically and seriously in the way for movies and chat. I am hopeful for the virtual monitor scenario, where the comfort is less demanding than on leasure (even an incentive for taking a break). Of course its exact level is to be discovered, I mean relative the two, office use needs adequate level of comfort too.
- crocowhile 3y agoThey will never mass-sale this unless they unleash porn. We know it, they know it. Nobody is paying $3500 to look at their emails on a visor.
- GuB-42 3y agoMaybe they are showing off this because they want to make a difference. If you show someone playing Beat Saber, you are inviting comparison to $500 headsets. And chances are, the $500 headset plays Beat Saber just as well, maybe even better. Apple doesn't want that, so they are going into a different direction. I don't know how it will turn out, but Apple is usually pretty good at marketing, so I think they know what they are doing.
- shsteimer_1 3y agoI’m continually amazed by how many people translate “this product in its current form isn’t for me” into “this product shouldn’t exist, even as a gen 1”
- lolinder 3y agoThat's not how I read OP at all. Everything they said is in the first person. It's very clear that they're saying they see no purpose for themselves, and people are upvoting because they also see no purpose for themselves. If Apple finds a market, more power to them, but HN commenters was never going to be that market.
- wslh 3y agoThe "I'm dropping at $3,500" should take into consideration that Hololens 2 has a higher price tag [1] but nobody talks about their product, and price ;-) Microsoft seems invisible where Apple doesn't. I also assume with high estimation confidence that Apple has a deep market knowledge to launch this product. [1] https://www.microsoft.com/en-us/hololens/buy https://www.microsoft.com/en-us/hololens/buy
- npteljes 3y agoAs a general late adopter, I see the thing similarly. Flashy tech, no doubt, and I'm sure it would entertain me a bit, especially as I tend to be asocial. However, it seems like a thing that wants a part of the user's life for itself, rather than adding to the life of the user. For this reason, I'm not enthusiastic for it at all.
- barrenko 3y agoNo, but they will.
- f6v 3y ago> Does someone watch an entire 2+ hour movie with a sweaty headset strapped to them (and plugged into a socket) instead of on a couch with their family/friends? I can see myself getting two of these when they’re less expensive and never going to a movie theater again.
- godzillabrennus 3y agoIf I still flew 18 hour every two weeks to visit facilities in Asia from NYC I would want one of these for the flights. Outside of that, I don’t think I could justify $3500 for one. Even if it’s a fun toy.