9 ms·
Thousands of early-career NIH researchers forming union for first time
- nashashmi 3y agoWhat is there possibly for a bunch of employees who have lived with status quo for so many years all of a sudden want to change? It is typically new employees who come in (from elsewhere?) that feel like changing everything around them. And then either they get those changes, or get comfortable with the things that exist, or leave. Edit: Reasons for unions historically have been better working conditions and better wages, but those were for labor unions. Desk jockeys had different motivations for workplace changes, like better treatment of their work efforts, or more meaningful work hours. Better Wages are not it.
- delfinom 3y agoOr you know, instead of crying about change like you are. Existing employees finally cracked. The STM part of STEM has been seriously underpaid and meager living for years. All of that is coming home to roost with inflation and cost of living spiraling out of control.
- FredPret 3y agoUnderpayment would lead to less inflation if anything.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- MaKey 3y ago[citation needed] Inflation might not be driven by wages but by company profits: https://www.theguardian.com/business/2023/feb/24/an-economic-fairytale-australias-inflation-being-driven-by-company-profits-and-not-wages-analysis-finds https://www.theguardian.com/business/2023/feb/24/an-economic...
- nightski 3y agoWhere do you think company profits come from if not from customers?
- avgcorrection 3y agoSome central banks take measures in order to reduce the spending of consumers in order to calm down inflation. Which means less money for customers. So maybe it makes sense?
- FredPret 3y agoYou know your own logic can beat that of others right? Citations are just links to places where other people wrote down their logic and aren't magic fairy dust that'll make an argument true. People geting paid more is inflationary. People producing more output is deflationary. We need lots of both. Company profits come from things being produced and then bought. So when profits are paid out to owners and employees as salaries, dividends, and other mechanisms, it gets filed under "people getting paid". Now my main point is that if S, T and M have been underpaid vs their true output, they should get more.
- gowings97 3y ago"The STM part of STEM has been seriously underpaid and meager living for years." Based on what?
- foooorsyth 3y agoThe E part of STEM is typically the commercial application of STM, so why would that be a surprise? This is the nature of research: most efforts will be pretty useless, and even the useful ones will need significant additional focus, effort, investment, and labor to create a viable commercial product.
- rfrey 3y agoThe assumption that only commercialization efforts are deserving of rewards, and the labour to discover and make viable the things that are being sold are not deserving of rewards, is one that needs reflection.
- kashunstva 3y agoSure, they may have lived with the status quo, but the external environment, dominated by housing costs has in now way been status quo. I imagine that the delta is what is motivating action.
- einpoklum 3y ago> but those were for labor unions. Desk jockeys had different motivations... Desk labor is labor. And us desk jockeys most definitely need to unionize to improve and/or prevent deterioration of our working conditions and wages (and when I say "our wages" I don't mean just the star developers, I mean everyone). Similarly, all laborers, at the desk and at the assembly line, strive for better treatment of our work efforts, the ability to perform meaningful and less alienated work, etc.
- matthewowen 3y agoAre you sure you read the article closely enough? These are early career researchers: grad students and postdocs. These are generally roles someone holds for no more than 6 years, often less. They _are_ all new employees.
- nashashmi 3y agoYes they are all new employees. Funny either I read it wrong or the headline changed. I thought it said NIH employees who had been with the firm for long time.
- DirectorKrennic 3y ago[flagged]
- hirako2000 3y agoMaybe that's the key, lower headcounts but professionals paid private market rates with private market rate benefits, trimming down won't necessarily drop quality.
- Eumenes 3y ago[flagged]
- hirundo 3y ago"All Government employees should realize that the process of collective bargaining, as usually understood, cannot be transplanted into the public service." - Franklin Roosevelt https://www.presidency.ucsb.edu/documents/letter-the-resolution-federation-federal-employees-against-strikes-federal-service https://www.presidency.ucsb.edu/documents/letter-the-resolut...
- Eumenes 3y ago[flagged]
- linuxftw 3y agoTrump was more left-wing than Bill Clinton, it's just that one party has actually turned into extremists while ironically labeling the other side extremists.
- Angostura 3y agoIt's an interesting argument, suggesting that government could simply pay workers 1c per year and that any attempt to address this by the workers by - say - a strike would be "unthinkable and intolerable"
- SketchySeaBeast 3y ago
- SamoyedFurFluff 3y agoI hope something, anything is done to help fix the living circumstances of researchers in the United States. Our best and brightest should be well funded, with little fear of harassment.
- iso1337 3y agoNIH should build more institutes in cheaper areas (eg not NoVa). It’s a win win since it will help revitalize poorer areas of America and save on costs. It will also tilt more senators/congresspeople to vote for NIH funding, similar to military base funding
- Retric 3y agoMilitary personnel move where you tell them, manufacturing jobs can train people up just about anywhere, but research isn’t so simple. It’s a real chicken and egg problem around local talent. Bethesda/Rockville/Baltimore has several different organizations doing medical research which makes the attractive locations for researchers to live. Locate in say Boise Idaho and positions are open for longer and you will need to compromise more in terms of talent. On top of this there’s a huge pool of government contractors which again provides significant advantages.
- rflrob 3y agoI think the biomedical academic job market is tight enough that you could fairly easily attract a strong class of researchers to nearly any second tier city. Maybe not the best of the best of the best (at first), but there’s enough bright people doing 6+ year post docs that you’ll recruit junior faculty in a flash. Credentials: did my PhD and postdoc at R1 institutions, before going to greener pastures in industry.
- robwwilliams 3y agoThere is no best-of-the-best at this stage. Only those who seem hyper bright. Success in biomedical research is much more about other factors—persistence and inquisitiveness being two that are crucial.
- selimthegrim 3y agoThat’s interesting, because Tulane seems to be having a lot of trouble with this.
- michaelt 3y ago
- KRAKRISMOTT 3y agoIt's not going to work. The NIH has no equivalent private sector competitor. For every single researcher, there are 10 other graduates and staff who would be willing to do their job for a fraction of the cost. This is a supply and demand problem, a funding problem. Strip congress and the medical board of their ability to control the number of residency spots and you will see the free market correct itself. Most biology people's first career choice is medicine, not working in research. The only protection they have is the fact that it is hard to get fired from a government job.
- sybercecurity 3y agoFrom the article, they may not be staff. Many research agencies have "fellow" or "associate" positions that aren't full time staff. Similar to a contractor but used for postdoc, graduate students, etc. Sometimes on the path to FTE status, but not always. Could also be non-citizens on a visa for their term. Pay (think stipend, not salary) for these positions are more than what a grad student would get from their university, but not much more. At least from what I've seen (don't know details of NIH). For postdocs/grads/etc without families this can work, but cost of living in the DC area is high.
- einpoklum 3y agoThat's one of the struggles for the union to conduct. Part-time, junior, temporary staff - are staff, and should be recognized as staff, with the full set of rights and benefits befitting their position and their needs as people and as professionals. And the same goes for junior research staff at universities (assistants, fellows, post-docs etc).
- WhatsName 3y agoSounds like the sweet spot for a union. Having bargain power would be a quantum leap for all those workers. As a european, where unions are commonplace and a main driving force behind minimum wages, I find it odd for any worker not to join a union if there is the chance.
- dguest 3y ago
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- MontyCarloHall 3y agoI think academic scientists are criminally underpaid (especially at the NIH), and really hope something can be done to rectify this. However, I don’t think unionization is the way. Ultimately, unions' power comes from the threat of striking. Unions' demands only have teeth because of their ability to completely suspend economic output for an entire company or industry. This is possible because economic output of most unionized industries is collective: a factory worker has no personal stake in the individual widgets that s/he makes, and thus can dispassionately suspend widget production along with everyone else in the union. By contrast, science is extremely individualistic. Each "widget" is a scientific publication, which is directly attributed to a few specific contributors, and crucial for advancing an individual's scientific career. Thus, scientists are extremely passionate about their individual labor. Furthermore, science is often very time-sensitive — there is a huge premium on being the first to publish. Time sensitivity is especially high in the life sciences, since experiments with living things often cannot be easily scheduled around a strike. Passionate, individually invested scientists are therefore much less likely to voluntarily suspend their work than dispassionate laborers in collective industries. This makes striking much less impactful (there will be a lot of scabs in a scientific union strike), thereby negating much of a scientific union's power. (Imagine — you are an NIH postdoc working on a major publication in a hot field that will make or break your candidacy for a tenure-track faculty position. You are aware of several other labs working on the same project. Whoever publishes first gets most of the scientific accolades, and thus career advancement. The NIH union decides to strike. If you join the strike, it will set back your project, increasing the probability that one of the competing groups will scoop you, potentially greatly setting back your career. Are you going to let this happen?)
- data_acquired 3y ago>Although NIH wages aren’t inherently tied to those training grants, if wages increased significantly for NIH fellows, universities might “raise holy hell”, Wiest says, because it could incentivize researchers to apply for NIH positions instead of those at universities. This is a pretty weak point. There's hundreds of research areas and problems not worked on at the NIH that are explored in the hundreds of universities in the US. I don't see anyone switching research areas for better pay --- your skill sets are often tied to a certain class of problems. Sure, yes, there may be such effects in certain research areas. But what fraction of university budgets even go towards post-doctoral fellow stipends (when weighed against every other expenditure in a university budget)?
- kkylin 3y agoNot disagreeing with your larger point, but a nitpick: at these levels (postdocs, research scientists) the relevant university positions will be funded by grants, in fact largely from the NIH. University budgeting doesn't have all that much to do with it. Now, postdoc salaries are set by a combination of university policy + whatever the grant budget says, but grant proposals are also assessed based on how much they ask, and postdoc salaries will be set by whatever NIH actually awards the PI. In the end, for NIH to pay their early career scientists more without creating problems for itself (by competing with groups it funds), it will likely have to increase postdoc pay across the board. This will likely add some upward pressure to postdoc pay across fields, since many universities do look at entry-level NIH postdoc pay as a reference.
- data_acquired 3y agoFair point about how the funding actually works. The UC strike did allow for a good increase to the post-doctoral stipend, and the institutes likely had to move money around in order to make the increases possible. What's also interesting to me in the concerns raised in the article about how budgets (either from grants or universities) will cover pay increases is that this concern never comes up when research consumable costs increase. I had a friend at a major embedded systems supplier for researchers who spoke of the 90% mark-up they charged labs. This gets into a messy issue of course about pricing power and monopoly in scientific supplies, but its telling that as much of a concern is not raised in the public domain about these sorts of cost increases?
- Melatonic 3y agoWe need more labor unions in general - hell yea!
- bourneavent 3y agoSoftware engineers should do this. We got complacent with the high pay but we were never really in control. Recent layoffs would be less likely to happen were it not for unions.
- niemandhier 3y agoInstitutions stand to lose enormous amounts of money if NIH researchers go on strike. The reason: delayed clinical trials. Even more important, in particular this case the individual researcher stand little to loose, since those trials are mostly multi center, multi stakeholders and the individual research drone does not get much credit for its contribution.
- DontchaKnowit 3y agooh great. As if the scientific community wasn't corrupt and perversely incentivized enough.
- Snacktivist 3y agoWe looked into unionizing at our company in the US and hit some big concerns: 1. Managers cannot be part of a union - only individual contributors. There's a lot to unpack here. This can really set up an "us vs them" mindset which when takes hole has things go sideways. It makes switching from IC to manager or manager to IC potentially more complicated (and even contentious). There's are other issues in that managers typically focus on roadmap and where the company is going while many ICs I know want to just focus on getting their work done. 2. Union members are not part of the board. This was something that we felt was unbalanced and relegates unions to not actually having the right level of influence. When we did some research we found that there are better models for unions out there to reference: Japan and Germany. As part of this research we found that unions in the US have been watered down and regulation/legislation has been passed to weaken in. So you get stuff like "right to work" states or what sorts of things you are allowed to strike over. With that said, things absolutely need to shift in a lot of sectors but I'm not sure if unions are the solution that everyone thinks (hopes?) it is.