7 ms·
Supreme Court Rules Companies Can Sue Striking Workers for 'Sabotage'
- nullc 3y agoIn this case, workers intentionally waited until they'd filled up all the trucks with concrete to go on strike, so that the concrete would harden in and destroy the trucks. The company was able to clear the trucks to save them, at the cost of all the concrete. Wonder how the author here would feel about surgeons going on strike scheduled intentionally after beginning open heart surgery on a loved one?
- rcme 3y agoAre cement trucks equivalent to loved ones? I would love to know how I could replace a loved one if they perish.
- pavlov 3y agoIn the Supreme Court’s equation, cement trucks are more important than loved ones because losing cement has an economic impact but some old retiree undergoing heart surgery was just a non-productive liability anyway.
- JimtheCoder 3y agoWell, a a healthy retiree, maybe. But, if you're providing healthcare to an old person to the tune of $50,000+ multiple times in a few short years, you could call them a GDP booster, no?
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- Avshalom 3y agoallegedly intentional Regardless as https://www.eater.com/23575014/supreme-court-union-case-glacier-northwest-teamsters-starbucks-workers-united-explained https://www.eater.com/23575014/supreme-court-union-case-glac... point's out: in a lot of jobs prep is a required part of the job, so either you get fired for not doing your job or you get sued for losses from the strike.
- awildfivreld 3y agoI know there is a rather large culture difference, but here in Norway the unions announce the start time of the strike some time before the actual walkout, instead of "you're striking right now". If the employees here (and in the OP) did the same, they could start the strike by the end of one workday, so that no food/cement would be wasted as it it was never prepared. Is this not possible in the US? Or is this a case of increasing one-uppance as the relationship between companies and employees is _that bad_?
- waldothedog 3y agoThe scenario you describe in paragraph 2 is not out of the ordinary, but the tension you describe in paragraph 3 is certainly not out of the ordinary either
- rayiner 3y ago> Is this not possible in the US? Or is this a case of increasing one-uppance as the relationship between companies and employees is _that bad_? The latter. America is a low trust, high conflict society. You can argue about “who shot first” but labor relations in America has often escalated to violence by both sides.
- rayiner 3y agoYes, it’s allegedly intentional. That’s all it takes to initiate a lawsuit. The Supreme Court’s ruling was only that the lawsuit could proceed, not that the employer won. They still have to prove the allegations.
- ZoomerCretin 3y agoIf the company never stopped filling trucks, the workers could never go on strike. The company was well aware they were not willing to meet their workers demands. They shouldn't get to filibuster a strike.
- marcosdumay 3y ago> If the company never stopped filling trucks, the workers could never go on strike. The same workers filling the trucks are the ones going on a strike. They can strike before starting filling exactly as well as after it. Honestly, a ruling that doing sabotage during a strike consists on sabotage is completely mundane and expected. I don't think it would even appear on this site if the title was honest.
- paddw 3y agoI think the case of medical workers would be considered a bit differently, and deservedly so. Despite that, I think the Supreme Court's ruling on this case was essentially correct for this specific situation, although I think it's worrying to think about how this precedent set could be abused for different cases in the future.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- awhitty 3y agoWonder how the author here would feel about surgeons going on strike scheduled intentionally after beginning open heart surgery on a loved one? This is a silly comparison. Concrete trucks don’t have beating hearts - they’re just property owned by the business. It’s important to recognize life as distinct. Physicians take the Hippocratic Oath, and they otherwise generally care about the well-being of their patients. Also, it is illegal to strike at a health care facility without first giving 10-days notice (to plan how to continue care). I’ve talked to residents organizing at Mass General Brigham, and (though they aren’t planning a strike) my vague understanding is that the logistics of striking in health care are targeted more at paperwork rather than holding up care (e.g. provide the care but don’t sign the notes so billing can’t commence). I recommend reading more about how organizing in health care works - it’s complex, very topical these days, and I think it’ll show you that folks tend to care for one another. Too easy for Silicon Valley edge-case thinkers to reach for ad absurdum armchair arguments like “what if a doctor let their patient die on the operating table because they want more money” - that’s not where their heads are at at all. It’s also incredibly important that quality of life improves for health care workers. Med students are 3x more likely to die by suicide than the general population.
- kcplate 3y agoWhile it may not be an apples to apples comparison and certainly exaggerates the impact (a human life vs property), it describes the mechanism of the intentional destruction of property in this case pretty well. Even the NLRB states that a strike may be considered unlawful if it deprives company owners of their property. Timing the strike to intentionally destroy company trucks seems to go far beyond the act of the organized withholding of human labor. https://www.nlrb.gov/strikes https://www.nlrb.gov/strikes
- awhitty 3y agoNo, it certainly does not describe the mechanism. One is inconveniencing a business and one is murder. Please don’t get confused on this.
- 3y ago
- justin66 3y agoConcrete, human lives. They are practically the same thing!
- mundo 3y agoWhat a terrible analogy. This strike didn't hurt anyone, it cost the employer money, which is exactly what they're supposed to do! A strike that doesn't cost money isn't a strike, and a union that can't strike is a social club.
- shukantpal 3y agoThe idea that strikes are intended to cost the company does not lend itself that workers can do anything that damages the company. Are workers allowed to blow up the trucks using TNT (as long as no one gets hurt)? Can they steal all the gasoline in the trucks and sell it on the secondary market? No. Strikes are intended to lose the company money in a very specific way - by a lack of labor. They are not intended to lose the company money by intentional destruction of property (nor should they be intended to do that)
- mundo 3y agoYou sound like you're arguing with me, but all of the rules you described seem to suggest that what the strikers did in this case was legal. They didn't blow up anything or steal anything, they quit working at an inconvenient time. Also, I think you're imagining a set of gentlemanly Marquis of Queensbury rules around strikes that don't exist. This isn't an elaborate ritual like the filibuster; labor dispute precedents are written in blood.
- shukantpal 3y agoIf you intentionally fill up a truck with material that destroys it and then leave it, that is property destruction. That is equivalent to blowing something up (the concrete expands and blows up the truck) in that it is property damage. Another example to help you understand: If I came into my office in the morning with a highly flammable liquid and put them where the sun shines in the afternoon, and then intentionally left for "striking" - the ensuing office fire would be property damage on my part.
- Ekaros 3y agoThere is difference of losing money because employer can't sell something for duration or some sort of expected stoppage happens. And pure waste of material and possibly equipment. Imagine if software developers took a service down for maintenance and then just decided to strike at that moment. Or maybe unloaded some servers from truck and then left them outside in rain.
- belter 3y agoGLACIER NORTHWEST, INC., DBA CALPORTLAND v. INTERNATIONAL BROTHERHOOD OF TEAMSTERS LOCAL UNION NO. 174 - https://www.supremecourt.gov/opinions/22pdf/21-1449_d9eh.pdf https://www.supremecourt.gov/opinions/22pdf/21-1449_d9eh.pdf
- sitkack 3y agoLame ruling, I'd love to see the full court transcripts. The onus should have been on management to properly account for a work stoppage, esp if they are negotiating that day and they continue to load the trucks. The actual financial risk of equipment loss was extremely low. Cement truck operators have contingencies for traffic, backups at work sites, work site closure, etc. The cement load is good for 90 minutes (meaning within spec) and go can longer but will be worthless. You throw down a tarp, drop the load, when it hardens you can break it up and remove it. This just opens up another avenue to prevent workers from striking.
- supernova87a 3y agoFull court transcripts have been available for years, if not more than a decade at Oyez.org, and at numerous university and public interest websites. Lame ruling in what way? In that it's unreasonable for a concrete company to sue the union for intentionally waiting until the concrete was mixed, loaded onto trucks, and only then striking, to obviously cause maximal damages to the company? Maybe you should read the transcript if you're actually curious.
- sitkack 3y agoSuch a rude response on every level. All you have done is regurgitate other comments, "intentionally waiting" has not been shown. "Maybe you should" (unconstructive phrasing) If you were going to educate rather than attack, provide links to the transcripts of this case. You are not arguing in good faith.
- 2OEH8eoCRo0 3y agoGood ruling. Everyone should be able to sue for anything, whether you'll actually win is another matter.
- hotpotamus 3y agoFrom personal experience I can say that this attitude is a good full-employment plan for software patent attorneys.
- rayiner 3y agoThe Vice write up isn’t very good and omits a key point: https://www.jdsupra.com/legalnews/supreme-court-allows-company-to-sue-a-2261987/ https://www.jdsupra.com/legalnews/supreme-court-allows-compa... > The Court took time to point out that workers do not forfeit the NLRA’s protections simply by commencing a work stoppage when the loss of perishable products is foreseeable. The Court emphasized that in this case the workers reported to work, prompting the loading of the concrete, and only after the concrete had been loaded into the trucks, did they commence the work stoppage. In so doing the workers not only destroyed the concrete but put the trucks at risk.
- no_wizard 3y agoThe ever important thing here is what will constitute sabotage going forward. I imagine a follow up lawsuit will be that general striking is sabotage, in some way. For instance because routine maintenance is not performed equipment becomes damaged by proxy, sort of stuff. It opens up a possible slippery slope going forward on this.
- ok_dad 3y agoSoftware engineers no longer able to quit jobs they hate or they get sued for destroying company value. Cher this all you want, first they came for the trade unionists…
- erik_seaberg 3y agoI get to say I’m not coming in tomorrow. I do not get to start a risky data migration and then abandon it; that’s unprofessional.
- ok_dad 3y agoWhat if you strike and the company sues you because the system has a bug and there was no one there to fix it? When is it acceptable for a software engineer working on software running 24/7 to strike? Let me know, because a ruling like this could be interpreted in many ways.
- erik_seaberg 3y agoI wouldn't deploy a risky change immediately before a strike, for the same reason I wouldn't do that and go on a road trip. If it's been in prod a day or two and we didn't see a need to roll it back, it's just part of the system now, and the replacement workers can deal with it.
- draw_down 3y ago[dead]
- 3y ago
- batch12 3y agoSo tired of rage bait 'news'. The author of this article surely has no 'agenda'. The article stands up a strawman (scarecrow?) of 'profits' as the sole driver and makes no effort to even consider that the actions were intentional and intended to cause damage.
- CharlesW 3y ago> The article stands up a strawman (scarecrow?) of 'profits' as the sole driver… The word profit/profits doesn't even appear in the article. Can you point out a sentence or two with an "agenda" (opinion) that isn't part of a quote?
- batch12 3y agoThe "quotes" have been chosen to back the author's opinion obviously. Additional evidence is the liberal use of finger quotes around words like sabotage and emergency maneuvers to lower the weight of those statements. The best evidence is the whole headline: "Supreme Court Rules Companies Can Sue Striking Workers for 'Sabotage' and 'Destruction,' Misses Entire Point of Striking" Edit: This one stands out. Is it a paraphrase or a quote? If it's a quote maybe they hit their tick limit and couldn't afford any more marks? Union leaders agree that strikes are supposed to be disruptive. But the precedent this case sets is that when a union goes on strike, it has to ensure that it won’t lose the company any money, said Seth Goldstein, a lawyer at Julien, Mirer, Singla & Goldstein, who has supported organizers in union disputes at Trader Joe’s and Amazon.
- CharlesW 3y ago> The "quotes" have been chosen to back the author's opinion obviously. Or, to provide some balance to the actual anti-union ruling. The quoted words are from the ruling. "Misses Entire Point of Striking" is a statement of fact, because striking can't work if that act doesn't negatively impact the business.
- batch12 3y ago
- crazygringo 3y agoI'm extremely pro-union, but this decision makes sense to me. If you're a developer going on strike, you don't get to turn off the production database before you leave the building. Now obviously there's always going to be a gray area between sabotage/destruction and not showing up for regular work duties. Continuing the developer analogy, if you know the production database is going to run out of disk space in 4 days, that's not your problem. But halting work mid-shift with concrete that will dry out and could damage the trucks is extremely irresponsible and totally unnecessary in the context of labor negotiation. I can't see any legitimate reason why it's necessary to leave your job mid-shift in a labor dispute if that will result in damage. The union should either have called for the strike to begin before the shift or allowed workers to finish their shift. There's no reason for property damage to be part of labor negotiations.
- CharlesW 3y ago> …if you know the production database is going to run out of disk space in 4 days, that's not your problem. […] I can't see any legitimate reason why it's necessary to leave your job mid-shift in a labor dispute if that will result in damage. So, your rule is that it's okay for blue collar workers to strike as long as they don't leave during their shift, and for white-collar workers to shift if it doesn't impact the business the same day? > There's no reason for property damage to be part of labor negotiations. Striking hurts the company by definition. Whether the result is that concrete dries out, or fish go bad, or production servers are killed, or television production is halted doesn't matter.
- gruez 3y ago>Striking hurts the company by definition. Whether the result is that concrete dries out, or fish go bad, or production servers are killed, or television production is halted doesn't matter. Right, but there's an obvious difference between hurting the company through lost production, and hurting the company through lost production and deliberately engineering scenarios where work stoppages would cost maximum damage.
- 3y ago
- jmclnx 3y ago[flagged]
- bdowling 3y agoIn the same paragraph, "Teamsters president Sean O’Brian said that the ruling will not impact the Teamsters’ striking efforts." So, how much does this really affect anything?
- xracy 3y agoBecause there are more unions than just the teamsters? Yeah, this is pretty cut and dry for teamsters, but what about... anyone else?
- jmclnx 3y agoYes I saw that too, I wonder how this will play out with the ruling. This quote is very concerning: >That sets a precedent that if a union strikes, it has to ensure the company won't lose any money. The whole point of a strike is to force profits of a company to go down so they will be able to be serious at the table.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- leereeves 3y ago> This when people in the US needs to be as brave as the people in France. What exactly are you proposing? Blocking traffic? Setting fires? Riots? Perhaps the American people can rely on our government to protect us (from you).
- pieresqi 3y ago> Blocking traffic? Setting fires? Riots? Yes. All corporation bootlickers screaming muh damaged bussines can eat my ass . Protests/strikes don't start out of nowhere or just because people want to destroy stuff.
- timmaxw 3y agoA few quotes from the Supreme Court documents (https://www.supremecourt.gov/opinions/22pdf/21-1449_d9eh.pdf https://www.supremecourt.gov/opinions/22pdf/21-1449_d9eh.pdf): > The National Labor Relations Board [NLRB] has long taken the position—which the parties accept—that the NLRA [National Labor Relations Act] does not shield strikers who fail to take “reasonable precautions” to protect their employer’s property from foreseeable, aggravated, and imminent danger due to the sudden cessation of work. > the Union argues that “workers do not forfeit the Act’s protections simply by commencing a work stoppage at a time when the loss of perishable products is foreseeable.” If the mere risk of spoilage is enough to render a strike illegal, the Union insists, then workers who deal with perishable goods will have no meaningful right to strike. > But given the lifespan of wet concrete, Glacier could not batch it until a truck was ready to take it. So by reporting for duty and pretending as if they would deliver the concrete, the drivers prompted the creation of the perishable product. Then, they waited to walk off the job until the concrete was mixed and poured in the trucks. In so doing, they not only destroyed the concrete but also put Glacier’s trucks in harm’s way. This case therefore involves much more than “a work stoppage at a time when the loss of perishable products is foreseeable.” > the NLRA does not impose a legal requirement that workers give specific notice of a strike’s timing [but] the Union’s choice to call a strike after its drivers had loaded a large amount of wet concrete into Glacier’s delivery trucks strongly suggests that it failed to take reasonable precautions to avoid foreseeable, aggravated, and imminent harm to Glacier’s property So I think the Supreme Court is quite reasonable in saying that the Union could be liable for the destroyed concrete in this case. (I don't have an opinion on the jurisdictional question of whether this should be decided by the NLRB vs. a state court.)
- Ekaros 3y agoSeems like they did something unreasonable. They could have just told previous day that hey we are going to strike tomorrow from the morning or at this time. Sort things out so you maybe don't do stuff when we are out.
- bdowling 3y agoThe decision here is that the plaintiff corporation should have been able to sue in state court (i.e., that the state court erred in dismissing the case). The result is that the plaintiff can begin its case in state court, not that the plaintiff will win. As I understand it, the NLRB is a forum totally biased in favor of labor, so the important question was whether the plaintiff could bring a case in state court.
- specialist 3y agoIt's unsurprising the Thomas Court ignored precedent, ignored the explicit legal protections covering strikes. Also entirely expected that the Thomas Court rejected our Constition's separation of powers and continues to subsume Executive authority over administration. Two aspects are surprising, however. Justice Jackson's textualist sole dissent, asserting the Court should honor and adjudicate the law as written and render a legal decision. In other words, 8 justices, including 2 nominally liberals, are content to continue ruling based on their "vibes" alone. This radical ruling wasn't snuck thru justice Alito's emergency shadow docket.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- krapp 3y ago> In other words, 8 justices, including 2 nominally liberals, are content to continue ruling based on their "vibes" alone. Yeah, that's what "textualism" and "originalism" actually amount to, ones own prejudice reflected by the imaginary ghosts of the founding fathers.
- xracy 3y agoBunch of people tying this to specific case, and saying how it's a good thing... Just for consideration. If the NLRB recognized this is an issue for negotiation, it doesn't seem good to me to say "corporations, that already have a ton of the power in these negotiations can sue outside of the NLRB." The problem I see is why wouldn't anti-union companies just sue for loss of business now? The goal posts have moved, and it doesn't seem like it would take much effort to get them to where you can sue people for sabotage just for striking in the first place. Everyone who is saying this is a good thing is pointing to how the NLRB agrees wit h this. So why is it necessary if the governing body that oversees these disputes agrees with the principle of this for negotiations? It seems like we just lost more worker protections here, and that people are gonna be SLAPP-sued to oblivion anytime they strike...