7 ms·
Industry docs reveal makers of 'forever chemicals' covered up health dangers
- chiefalchemist 3y agoCover up aside. As I understand it, currently the way these chemicals are regulated is: manufacture and use first, worry about safety issues later. More or less the opposite of how medical chemicals (i.e., drugs) are overseen. As a result, a buffet of chemicals have been put in use and we know very little about their solo effects or what happens when they interact with other chemicals in the wild. These companies not disclosing their awareness is criminal. But that doesn't explain why the government refuses to update regulations to be proactive in preventing such substances from being "use first, ask questions later."
- throwaway290 3y agoProbably the idea is to trust that people are inherently good and not malicious jerks willing to endanger everything around for personal gain. I think maybe it's the way to go indeed but then when it does go wrong the punishment should be proportionate to that trust.
- Ekaros 3y agoFunny thing is that we have been proven wrong with that for centuries now... Maybe the powers just don't want to learn.
- throwaway290 3y agoSo you think it's better to live under a regime where anything not explicitly sanctioned is forbidden?
- indigochill 3y agoEven under that assumption, the interaction of chemistry and biology is tricky (even drugs that have a well-established track record of being safe still have negative side effects for some people). Even moreso when you just let the chemical loose into the world rather than administering it in a controlled scenario like prescription pharmaceuticals.
- scns 3y agoMedication is tested on men only. So consequences for (pregnant) women will surface when prescribed to them.
- chiefalchemist 3y agoGood people make perfectly good mistakes. We have safety requirements for medical chemical (i.e., drugs). Why can't we do the same for industrials chemicals when we all know those chemicals end up in the environment, in our bodies, etc.? It's silly (read: insulting) to hear, "...incidents of Cancer X, Cancer Y and behavior Z are increasing and we have no idea why that might be..." Good people want to know. Not so good people turn a blind eye and feign ignorance. History is littered with good people, with good intentions, creating things with not-so-good consequences.
- throwaway290 3y agoThe topic is people with clearly bad intentions intentionally covering up or obstructing research...
- lotsofpulp 3y ago> But that doesn't explain why the government refuses to update regulations to be proactive in preventing such substances from being "use first, ask questions later." Because people, by and large, like the convenience of these substances. It is not a politically popular position to go around banning things that people find increases their quality of life, even if just in the short term. See fossil fuels and carbon emissions. It would be trivial to slap a 10,000% tax on them to limit its use and bring down carbon emissions, but it would come at the cost of people not being able to do things they want to do.
- ceejayoz 3y ago> manufacture and use first, worry about safety issues later And at that point, use something similar that probably has the same safety issues. Like the switch from BPA to BPS and BPF.
- kasperni 3y agoI recently stopped using Oral-B Glide dental floss because of this study [1] that showed elevated levels of PFASs in blood of users of that type of dental floss. [1] https://www.hsph.harvard.edu/news/hsph-in-the-news/dental-floss-harmful-chemicals/ https://www.hsph.harvard.edu/news/hsph-in-the-news/dental-fl...
- mathieuh 3y agoThanks for the link, going to toss mine too What did you switch to? I have one of those waterpiks but I don't feel like it does a very good job
- monetus 3y agoI got this on a discount and it has been great. I use a waterpik too, but honestly I feel like it is best at blasting the oils from your teeth before you brush. https://www.burstoralcare.com/product/floss?color=black https://www.burstoralcare.com/product/floss?color=black
- theNJR 3y agoWhy do you think that is any better?
- oblio 3y agoThe cynic in me says: because it's not a visible corporate target unlike Oral-B so nobody bothered to test it, but it's likely to have the same problems unless they explicitly say they don't and had an independent party validate the claim and possibly an auditor confirming.
- ricardobeat 3y agoIt seems to be made of polyester, charcoal and wax, explicitly no PFAs, so what would be the reason to assume "it's likely to have the same problems" if the problem is the PFOA coating?
- cryptonym 3y agoPeople involved in covering up health dangers should be personally responsible for their criminal actions and prosecuted the hard way.
- agentgumshoe 3y agoI really don't get that. I would think it's simple enough for the CEO to face criminal charges, unless they can clearly show which other individual(s) are responsible, or very clearly demonstrate there was some special and exceptional circumstances that necessitated the exception. Instead we call companies people and let them wash things away with money. No one faces guilt, maybe a CEO 'steps down' to spend more time with family until the anti-competitive clause finished and they pop up somewhere else.
- danaris 3y agoAs someone on a sibling thread noted, if you limit the personal liability to the CEO, then that creates a strong incentive to make the CEO position into "highly-paid fall guy" while the other people responsible—quite probably even the people primarily responsible—laugh all the way to the bank. At a minimum, liability must be possible for the entire C-suite and the board. Depending on the nature and degree of the atrocities being committed, I can see a pretty strong argument for liability for anyone involved in any way who's being paid more than, say, national median salary + 50%—that is, anyone for whom "I was just following orders" doesn't have with it the background of "and if I disobeyed, I would risk destitution for myself and my family." The horrible effects of some of these decisions, and the number of people who have to suffer them, mean I have no compunction about comparing acts like these to war crimes, and we don't allow "I was just following orders" as a defense to those, either.
- agentgumshoe 3y agoI was thinking that if the CEO needs to show who is responsible, they would make sure their auditing and retention/archiving practices are in good order and tested and accountability would improve all-round. But yeah, there's always complexities that make things difficult... Still, you're paid tens or hundreds of millions, it should come with some risk.
- clcaev 3y agoIf we are not going to regulate these in a manner similar to pharma, then we need robust liability framework that would pierce the corporate veil for executives and large equity owners, as well as requiring extensive lability insurance.
- agentgumshoe 3y agoShocked, shocked I tell you! Well, not that shocked. We really do learn these lessons the slow way. Now watch the media really hold them to account...hmm. Surely this is the last industry to be doing this stuff, surely.
- iinnPP 3y ago"The $16.45 million settlement was the largest civil penalty obtained under U.S. environmental statutes at the time. But it was still just a small fraction of DuPont's $1 billion annual revenues from PFOA and C8 in 2005." Spotted the problem. The fix is simple, fine them 110% of the ill-gotten gross profits(from start to finish) attributed to all products impacted even slightly. Then provide an instant settlement to all children born with health defects who's biological parents purchased any of the products. No lawyer cuts. The amount is $10,000,000 each and permanently funded healthcare. Should the company go bankrupt, each person in position to become a whistleblower who chose not to, can work the rest of their lives paying "child support" equal to their earnings minus whatever social security gives. The same thing for the regulators who failed.
- greenpresident 3y agoMost theories of optimal fining are based on social costs S, discovery cost C, and discovery chance P. If, for example, you would like to maximize total welfare, you would fine S/P+C. A rational actor would only engage in the behavior of their expected gain was larger than the expected cost to society. The firms profit should be irrelevant in my opinion. But make these firms believe that they will have to cover the true costs of their behavior!
- plagiarist 3y agoYeah, I mean, as long as we're idealizing, let's have them pay the actual costs that were externalized to society instead of merely wiping out profits from misdeeds.
- horsawlarway 3y ago> A rational actor would only engage in the behavior of their expected gain was larger than the expected cost to society. This is - bluntly put - a shite fucking idea. I am not trying to "maximize total welfare" where one way to accomplish that is to allow a bad actor to get ridiculously wealthy at the expense of everyone else (even if the total paid by everyone else is less than the bad actor makes). We have a term for this: Privatized profits and socialized losses. We're witnessing that this mindset is completely dysfunctional. It allows bad actors to accumulate immense wealth through behaviors that are net negatives for all other participants - further, those bad actors can then use that wealth to avoid or offset the share of their social costs that should be paid (ex: lobbying politicians, paying off regulators, bribing judges, etc) ---- There is a reason most people don't accept a deal where both parties gain, but one gains at a heavy advantage over the other: We know that allowing this behavior is bad for long term social stability, and we have all sorts of ideas about "Fair" that we apply to stop it: https://www.sciencedirect.com/topics/neuroscience/ultimatum-game https://www.sciencedirect.com/topics/neuroscience/ultimatum-... > The firms profit should be irrelevant in my opinion. But make these firms believe that they will have to cover the true costs of their behavior! The profit is the ONLY FUCKING THING that is relevant. The firms don't care about "true costs" (which, as an aside are often impossible to reasonably calculate). All the firms cares about is "Does bad behavior A lead to more net money, or less net money?" As long as the answer is "More net money" The firm is going to engage in bad behavior. The answer ALWAYS needs to be: Fine the bad behavior until it is not profitable. Full fucking stop.
- drowsspa 3y agoLeaded gas all over again, huh... Profits always speak louder
- scns 3y agoSadly yes, since with profit in the billions you can buy a few politicians, who look like beggars in comparison to big corp execs. /jaded
- theNJR 3y agoWhat an infuriating article. What is everyone’s pot and pan of choice these days? I just realized we are still using the nonstick gifted by my in laws. They need to go into the garbage.
- Semaphor 3y agoI use a ceramic coated cast-iron pan most of the time, and a normal non-stick for when I really need non-stick (eggs, some fish).
- natdempk 3y agoFor fish and eggs it’s worth looking into carbon steel as well. You can get basically a non-stick surface without PFAS and it’s lighter than cast iron.
- Semaphor 3y agoIt would be worth it, if I regularly used it. But for that one time a month and less, I’ll stay with the non-stick. Even scrambled eggs work in the ceramic, it’s only fried eggs, and super-flaky fish that aren’t that great in it.
- culopatin 3y agoI only use cast iron or stainless. I don’t get the need for non stick. Maybe it’s because I don’t cook eggs every morning.
- lepton 3y agoI cook eggs every morning with a pat of butter in a well-seasoned cast iron pan. Works great.
- culopatin 3y agoThen there we have it then. I use cast iron for anything that requires heat, frying and browning, and for anything like boiling, tomato sauces or stews I use the stainless as to not strip the fats from the cast iron. Keeps it simple.
- jmyeet 3y agoWe need to be more like China [1]: > China executed a dairy farmer and a milk salesman today for their role in a tainted infant formula scandal in which at least six children died and 300,000 were made ill, state media said. Or jailing 50 steel executives for faking emissions data [2]. Fines are the cost of doing business. Jail is the only thing those responsible fear. Take the example of Purdue and the Sackler family. This company and family is largely responsible for the opioid epidemic by knowingly lying about Oxycontin. They amde billions from it. Despite a total worth of $11 billion a court recently granted them immunity from civil lawsuits for $6 billion of that [3]. So despite killing hundreds of thousands of people, they get to keep $5 billion of that. Be more like China. But since US corporations own the government that will absolutely never happen. We routinely use civil asset forfeiture in this country, primarily against poor people (eg parents' house seized after son's drug bust [4]). Personally I think it's a ridiculous perversion of justice that civil asset forfeiture isn't unconstitutional but here we are. Every single asset of the Sacklers should be viewed as the proceeds of an intentional crime that killed many people and has had a huge cost of society. It should be seized. All of it. [1]: https://www.theguardian.com/world/2009/nov/24/china-executes-milk-scandal-pair https://www.theguardian.com/world/2009/nov/24/china-executes... [2]: https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2022-01-28/china-jails-almost-50-steel-executives-for-faking-emissions-data#xj4y7vzkg https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2022-01-28/china-jai... [3]: https://www.cnn.com/2023/05/30/business/sackler-purdue-opioid-liability/index.html https://www.cnn.com/2023/05/30/business/sackler-purdue-opioi... [4]: https://www.cnn.com/2014/09/03/us/philadelphia-drug-bust-house-seizure/index.html https://www.cnn.com/2014/09/03/us/philadelphia-drug-bust-hou...
- f6v 3y agoThey key question is whether death penalty or life sentence acts as an effective deterrent. We all heard that Chinese execute for big corruption. Does this mean China has eradicated corruption? I have my doubts (and believe me, I don’t ever jump on CCP hate train).
- remote_phone 3y agoI think it would. Why would someone falsify data for a company if they know they might get executed. It wouldn’t be for their own gain.
- Mistletoe 3y agohttps://www.atsdr.cdc.gov/pfas/health-effects/us-population.html https://www.atsdr.cdc.gov/pfas/health-effects/us-population.... I found this website useful and I found this encouraging. >Since 2002, production and use of PFOS and PFOA in the United States have declined. As the use of some PFAS has declined, some blood PFAS levels have gone down as well. >From 1999-2000 to 2017-2018, blood PFOS levels declined by more than 85%. >From 1999-2000 to 2017-2018, blood PFOA levels declined by more than 70%. Of course they may have just switched to other PFAs but it is something. I also found this recommendation useful- >Below 2 nanograms per milliliter: If blood concentration levels fall below 2 nanograms per milliliter, people “are not expected to have adverse health effects,” the committee said. When looking at the charts remember that 2 ng/mL is the same at 2 ug/L, the units used in the graphs.
- hcurtiss 3y agoKnowing something is "toxic" is not the same as knowing we should not use it, or that it's particularly dangerous. Tylenol is very toxic to ingest. So is gasoline. Yet we use both every day. Caffeine is pretty toxic as well. Not only do you need to know a product's toxicity, but also the expected dose, and exposure over time. PFAS may very well be dangerous -- I haven't looked at it closely -- but the reporting has all been a mess. Even the linked article here doesn't tell us much. In the first bullet, the quote of a quote with excerpts out of context is telling. The second bullet about toxicity when ingested -- again, that's true of lots of products. At what dose, over what period of time? The third bullet about birth defects -- that happens. The question is whether they had reason to believe it was related to exposure to C-8. As a modern society, it would be extremely expensive to have a zero tolerance position for toxics. Many every-day products that produce a great deal of value in our lives are toxic. The question is one of whether the toxicity is material or likely to affect people, and whether the risks outweigh the benefits. None of this reporting grapples with those issues.
- _justinfunk 3y agoThe point is that industry knew that there were dangers associated with the use of PFAS, not that it was toxic but still used safely. 3M's website lists their uses of PFAS, including cookware. We probably would be upset if they coated paper plates with Tylenol and hid the effect that could have on people. https://pfas.3m.com/pfas_uses https://pfas.3m.com/pfas_uses
- tremon 3y agoNobody's arguing for a zero-tolerance policy, that feels like a strawman. Most of the toxic products we use have very strict usage guides and/or regulations attached. There's two issues, and you're glossing over both: 1) purposefully hiding the negative effects of your products 2) the lack of meaningful accountability for those doing 1 Not only do you need to know a product's toxicity, but also the expected dose, and exposure over time Exactly. And it seems that people knew about those, yet chose to hide these things from the public. The question is whether they had reason to believe it was related to exposure to C-8 No, the question is whether they had a moral obligation to research that and publicize it, given what else they knew and didn't tell. If they had shared the rest of their knowledge, maybe they could be absolved from this particular point if nobody else in society thought it worthwhile to look into. But given that they didn't, this obligation falls only on them.
- JoshTko 3y agoIt should be obvious by now that we should ban all chemicals that don't have extensive, long term 3rd party safety testing/history.