12 ms·
Heavy electric trucks cheaper than diesel goods trucks
- trabant00 3y agoI could talk about how charging during a delivery is a no go. I could talk about the initial price. Or about battery life. Or infrastructure. As I know people in the transport business I'm just gonna shut up and wait for them to switch for economic reasons. Until then it's just words.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- londons_explore 3y agoRoad wear is one thing that won't be a blocker... Road wear is paid for by the taxpayers, and therefore has nil cost to any business deciding which type of trick to buy.
- ajsnigrutin 3y agoBut there are weight limits on trucks (atleast in most countries), which means less load taken in one trip.
- toomuchtodo 3y agoA combination of economics and policy will force this. California has outlawed new diesel truck sales after 2036, and other states aren’t far behind (you can drag the stragglers along). Diesel truck pm2.5 emissions are harmful. Carbon emissions are harmful. Adapt or die. PepsiCo and Frito-Lay are already running Tesla Semis in production. The learning curve is bending up. To get better at this, we’ll have to first suck at it, in the aggregate. https://www.cnbc.com/amp/2023/04/28/california-bans-the-sale-of-new-diesel-trucks-by-2036.html https://www.cnbc.com/amp/2023/04/28/california-bans-the-sale... https://ww2.arb.ca.gov/sites/default/files/barcu/regact/2022/acf22/acf15db.pdf https://ww2.arb.ca.gov/sites/default/files/barcu/regact/2022... https://electrek.co/2023/04/12/tesla-delivers-fleet-tesla-semi-electric-trucks-pepsico/ https://electrek.co/2023/04/12/tesla-delivers-fleet-tesla-se...
- throwaway97345 3y ago[flagged]
- toomuchtodo 3y ago[flagged]
- ben_w 3y agoYou don't lose freedom by switching fuel. Emphatically so when you didn't get a say in the old fuel either, and even more emphatically when the new one is cheaper overall than the old.
- aww_dang 3y ago>California has outlawed new diesel truck sales after 2036, and other states aren’t far behind (you can drag the stragglers along). When the new fuel is cheaper and suitable for consumer's needs, there will be no need to "drag" them along or prohibit choices. I believe this is what the comment was referencing.
- gautamdivgi 3y ago
- bushbaba 3y agoIf you include the true cost of remediating the diesel’s pollution then the electric truck comes our way ahead.
- aww_dang 3y agoWho determines the 'true' cost? How much is that exactly? Are there any other figures or dissent in regards to the premise?
- bertil 3y agoThere are two things you can look at: 1. The consequences of global warming You could ask people how much they’d pay to keep chocolate or coffee, bananas, pineapples, or mangoes. Most of Florida’s coastline, about half of California. There are things that specialists disagree about, but all have no doubt that all those crops will not be cultivated (outside) if we stay the course. Florida and California are now seeing insurance companies bailing out, so we are moving from scientific certainty to economic reality. Naturally, there’s more: most people think that Cajou nuts, açai berries, passion fruits, agave, prickly pears, should be on this list (because of temperature) but if we start looking at that, then people think pollinator collapse or opportunist infection are going to be there first… So I tried to make a conservative list. Typically the answer to the question “What would you pay to keep those (chocolate, coffee, etc.)?” is that whatever cost to save those things is worth it. You can try to find numbers, but the US famously started wars to end democracies in several countries to grow just bananas (that gave us “Banana Republic”), so we are closer to amounts where it’s less money measured in many billions and more state-sponsored violence. All that long rant to say: whatever is the cost of not destroying those, that is the “true” cost. 2. The cost of CO2 extraction and storage With current rock-bottom electricity prices in Iceland, ClimateWorks research facility can extract CO2 for a bit more than $3,000 per ton (depending on accounting for research costs; that number is just OpEx IIRC). To convert that to the cost of transporting goods, you can apply a ratio of 50 grams of CO2 per tonne-kilometer [1]. A 40-ton truck will have to pay $600 to compensate for every 100 km. That sounds like a lot, even without considering the cost of storage. ClimateWorks hope to lower the price by an order of magnitude [0], which specialists think is unlikely. In truth, much cheaper electricity makes electric trucks that much more appealing. You will never save any money by burning fuel and then spending energy trying to re-capture that CO2 at low concentrations. It’s engineering nonsense. A better idea would be to have trucks carry a balloon with their emissions and that’s obviously a clownish idea. All that, again, before we even have a scalable solution for storage. A cousin works on that project for Statoil. Sure it might work (with the right salt cave) but it’s nowhere ready to scale to handle emissions from trucks all over the world. So we will never be even close to making ICE trucks a sound idea if we consider the environmental impact. [0] https://www.unesco.org/en/articles/carbon-capture-and-storage-plant-becomes-operational-iceland https://www.unesco.org/en/articles/carbon-capture-and-storag... [1] https://www.transportenvironment.org/wp-content/uploads/2021/10/202108_truck_CO2_report_final.pdf https://www.transportenvironment.org/wp-content/uploads/2021...
- hedora 3y agoThe study took those things into account (fixed route deliveries, maintenance cost models and computerized scheduling address all your concerns and have been common place for decades). Anyway, I saw an electric ford van on a delivery run yesterday.
- mywittyname 3y agoPeople with a financial stake in the outcome have decided to invest a lot of money into electric semis despite knowing about all of these limitations (and many more) ahead of time. So they must have some plan for overcoming these hurdles. Perhaps these limitations aren't as rigid as people swear they are, or maybe shipping modalities change in order to play to the strengths of EVs. For example, there's nothing stopping shipping from becoming a relay-based, rather than point-to-point. Or maybe it becomes financially feasible to have drivers swap trucks. Yeah, that kills the "owner operator" long-haul trucker, but that model is pretty untenable anyway. Even industry experts can call an idea patently absurd, then have it become dominant over the next 20-30 years. Cable television is a good example of this, it's crazy to attach physical cables to every house in the USA in order to deliver TV, which can be sent over-the-air at a fraction of the cost. But we did just that. The benefits out-weighed the (tremendous) costs.
- johnchristopher 3y ago> So they must have some plan for overcoming these hurdles. Or maybe their plans is to get the first mover advantage and see what pans out ? Or get the whole market à la Uber by spending a lot of VC money and then figure out how to recoup ? See farming tech.
- mywittyname 3y agoUber had several long-term plans for making money. Surge pricing, predictive analytics, combined trips, tiered service, etc. Uber makes a gross profit of over $12 billion on a revenue of nearly $32 billion. They lose money on paper because they keep reinvesting profits and further investments back into the business. They've almost doubled revenue YoY. So even the most ludicrous SV startup you can think of pulled this off.
- johnchristopher 3y agoThanks, I bought into the uber for free because of vc money meme.
- theshrike79 3y agoWhy is charging during a delivery a no go? Charging during loading would be the most reasonable solution, the truck will be stationary for 30-60 minutes or more anyway. The battery life issue is mostly offset by lower operating costs: electricity is a lot cheaper than diesel / 100km and electric motors are pretty much maintenance free
- m0llusk 3y agoIt seems like battery swapping could potentially make battery charging a side issue.
- spaceguillotine 3y agoTitanfall 2 showed us the way!
- gregman1 3y agoUnfortunately this ground breaking technology exists only in China.
- pornel 3y agoIt's already being done by retrofitting diesel trucks. It's interesting they can change gears without having a clutch. https://fullycharged.show/episodes/this-giant-electric-semi-can-swap-out-its-batteries/ https://fullycharged.show/episodes/this-giant-electric-semi-...
- fallat 3y agoYeah... battery swapping seems like the next big thing for e-vecs. Imagine we shared batteries and all batteries must have some sort of reporting mechanism to report its life and charge holding and it must always be at 80% before being repurposed / fixed? Could be interesting...
- hedora 3y agoConsumer car batteries charge 20->80% in under a half hour these days, and are warranted for a minimum of 8 years. 30 minutes seems slow until you realize that you hardly ever need to charge the car away from home. I do not miss going to the gas station! I’d guess the mechanisms needed to swap the battery would be more maintenance than they are worth. I guess for delivery vans, which drive during peak solar production, doubling the number of batteries so you can charge during the day might make sense.
- FpUser 3y ago
- olivermarks 3y agoFantasy theories that ignore many of the core transportation facts, which include very volatile costs of fuel (diesel is nosebleed higher than gasoline in California this year, a disaster for businesses and tradesmen) Effective, efficient, fast refueling networks Complexity of fleet equipment, speed to repair Tires - an 18 wheeler gets through a lot of tires in its lifetime in service. EVs are very heavy unloaded Fleet trucking is a brutal business where every penny counts and owner/operators are whipsawed by fuel prices, demand waxing a waining and endless politicla meddling. Once we have nuclear, a credible supply grid and have overcome the battery capacity and fire issues EV will be viable to businesses. Until then it is the unrealistic slow motion disaster being forced through in California. https://www.freightwaves.com/ https://www.freightwaves.com/ is a good site to track developments
- justinator 3y ago>Once we have nuclear, a credible supply grid and have overcome the battery capacity and fire issues I'm not wrong right? That's all this generation's Moon Shot in scope.
- olivermarks 3y agoIt should be, but sadly the fantasy of windmills and solar panels continues. https://www.npr.org/2022/09/27/1124448463/germany-coal-energy-crisis https://www.npr.org/2022/09/27/1124448463/germany-coal-energ...
- justinator 3y agoWell, Germany is a pretty special case given the Ukraine war totally screwed them energy-wise.
- sdenton4 3y agoSeems to me that fuel price volatility is a point in favor of electric, as grid electricity prices are less volatile cyclic price swings (day/night) can be planned for, and grid energy is fed by an array of sources, which reduces volatility compared to being dependent on a single energy source. Fuel with subsidies and unmet externalities is already a slow-motion disaster...
- keltex 3y agoHere's the actual paper that this article refers to: https://www.mdpi.com/1996-1073/16/6/2793 https://www.mdpi.com/1996-1073/16/6/2793
- justinator 3y agosneaks into the room TRAINS! sulks back out of the room
- newyankee 3y agoWith better last mile connectivity, trains should be the only option. But guess loading and unloading is the weak link along with last mile lack of options.
- Maxion 3y agoThe problem with trains is that the infrastructure is very expensive, and also wildly unprofitable, and very slow to build.
- oblio 3y agoHow does that work, though? Aren't highways crazy expensive? In what world can 2 metal tracks plus some small foundations be cheaper than 20m width of concrete, asphalt and much bigger foundations? The economics of rail versus roads don't make any sense to me. The only way they do, I imagine, is if roads are crazily subsidized.
- Rhapso 3y agoNot just subsidized, but build and managed by the government!
- 3pt14159 3y agoI studied civil engineering, with a focus on structural, but a heavy geotechnical element and some pavement design and rail desing. Highways are cheaper and easier because they're usually less investment and planning at once. They have their own downsides, don't get me wrong, but no. Rail is long term, lots of property seizure, usually a single track across a vast distance, etc. Rail makes sense for a lot of places, but for a country as large as America, it's hard to see the benefits as fast as highways and we need logistics to switch to electric quickly. That said, to make highways more efficient more places should take a page off of the 407 in Ontario, Canada. The fluctuating pricing keeps the roads in high usage most of the time and it stops tragedy of the commons issues with sinks (the cities that highways dump their vehicles to) and keeps highway economic pricing honest against things like rail and sea.
- sologoub 3y agoSweden is doing a lot of good functional experiments and practical research leaning on much of existing tech. Like this experiment with electrified roads to help address EV truck range limits: https://www.carscoops.com/2023/05/sweden-will-open-the-worlds-first-permanently-electrified-road-though-they-havent-decided-which-tech-itll-use/amp/ https://www.carscoops.com/2023/05/sweden-will-open-the-world... The E16 experiment looked really promising and would rely on all existing tech (contactors on power lines, like the old trolley buses of old) and hybrid power plant for last mile: https://www.iea.org/policies/7162-electric-highway-demonstration-project-e16 https://www.iea.org/policies/7162-electric-highway-demonstra... Can’t find any reported results of this, but seems small in scale (100km). The concept solves the range problem. Imagine for example in California to have these along the 5? Now you can move things from Los Angeles to Seattle without needing to recharge. Add to it some driver assists and you have a much safer and more efficient transportation system which is as clean as the electric grid. Then you can provide financial incentives to travel in off peak demand times, etc.
- seanmcdirmid 3y agoThere are still active trolley bus routes that use overhead lines (Seattle, San Francisco, Lausanne, even Beijing has a trolly bus route). But we can’t even electrify our rail routes. I doubt we would electrify I5. Although, trucks aren’t trains where diesel turbine electricity generation makes sense.
- sologoub 3y agoI5 passes relatively close to a lot of generation and the land around it in the south is pretty decent for more solar. Haven’t traveled into WA, but I suspect other sources would be better there. In US, I suspect rail crosses large swaths that might be harder to electrify, but the sub 1% electrification is really disappointing compared to say EU: https://alternative-fuels-observatory.ec.europa.eu/transport-mode/rail https://alternative-fuels-observatory.ec.europa.eu/transport...
- seanmcdirmid 3y ago
- fwungy 3y agoSo basically, if you build perfectly optimal sized battery trucks and run them on a perfectly optimized schedule and route system they're perfectly optimized and attain very high levels of efficiency. That's vacuously true for just about everything.
- fnordpiglet 3y agoThey had two selections of batteries and a specific real world route. That doesn’t sound like cherry picking, that sounds like basically how things work for most trucking. Long haul trucking is more visible but most trucking is moving goods along a short to medium length established route. Most EV have at least two battery configurations as options.