9 ms·
Gravitational-wave detector LIGO is back
- quercusa 3y agoMichelson and Morley smile https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Michelson%E2%80%93Morley_experiment https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Michelson%E2%80%93Morley_exper...
- epberry 3y agoI absolutely love LIGO. YC actually did a great interview with one of the lead physicists on the project where he described some of the technical hardware and software challenges - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1D2j8nTjOZ4 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1D2j8nTjOZ4
- jackmott42 3y agoThat's the guy who when someone told him they got their first detection was incredulous "I don't have time for this" or something to that affect, because he assumed it was a false positive to have gotten something so quickly, but it was real!
- throwawaymaths 3y agoHow do we know it was real and not overinterpreting noise again?
- kmote00 3y agoIt's my understanding that it was correlated by data from the twin facility on the other side of the country.
- throwawaymaths 3y agoThe problem is that we are seeing a lot of correlations. I'd be worried.
- eaq 3y agoOne technique that is straightforward to understand is that folks have done "time-slide" analyses for many years - i.e. offsetting one detector's data in time - to understand what the "baseline" rate of correlations is in data streams where there is no possible physical origin. Naturally, much more statistical analysis has been done to ground the claims of "detection"; beyond detailed academic publications, LIGO and others have been producing layperson-accessible science summaries for years/decades that address these and other questions.
- throwawaymaths 3y ago> have been producing layperson-accessible science summaries for years/decades that address these and other questions. Citation please. Every layperson accessible summary has said "we use advanced statistics and machine learning" and I haven't found a simple high school statistics accessible explanation yet. Unlike say the higgs boson, I think for this experiment a simple statistical treatment is not an unreasonable request. Please show me and correct me. I would love to be able to believe we have detected gravitational waves.
- ssl232 3y agohttps://iopscience.iop.org/article/10.1088/1361-6382/ab685e https://iopscience.iop.org/article/10.1088/1361-6382/ab685e Probably not high school statistics accessible but Bayesian statistics and Gaussian noise and GR isn't.
- throwawaymaths 3y agothank you, that is helpful.
- Gare 3y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/GW170817 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/GW170817
- bsder 3y agoThat event is amazing. I had no idea how much cross correlation they produced (see the "Scientific Importance" sections). I love the fact that measurements got like 10 orders of magnitude or more better--that's just absolutely absurd.
- throwawaymaths 3y agoYou can't take two detectors and just say "they correlate" without presenting the blinded correlation data. If you apply the crazy filters that they do, how many of those signals happen in both detectors by chance? In fact, you can't do a proper statistical analysis without three identical detectors, or at least two pairs of detectors, which we will have once ligo1,2 and Virgo are all online at the same time, and watch how the filtered signals drop in count based on how many detectors you look at. > It is the first GW observation that has been confirmed by non-gravitational means. This is a pretty weak claim. Worryingly, iirc it is the only multi-messenger observation we've made to date, so, again. How many supernovae do we see at any time in any given segment of the sky, and what is the likelihood that it would have happened to be in whatever ~1/20 spatial angle the Gw detectors happen to have resolutions over, and out of the other n candidate neutron-neutron mergers we've "detected" what are the odds that we wouldn't have seen a supernova in the EM by chance in all of the others? If almost every single event came with a mm detection, I'd be convinced, but honestly, IMO it's looking kinda grim right now. We will find out if after we jack up the sensitivity we continue to fail to make multi messenger observations at the same rate as we have so far
- pharrington 3y ago> How many supernovae do we see at any time in any given segment of the sky, and what is the likelihood that it would have happened to be in whatever ~1/20 spatial angle the Gw detectors happen to have resolutions over, and out of the other n candidate neutron-neutron mergers we've "detected" what are the odds that we wouldn't have seen a supernova in the EM by chance in all of the others? The data's all publicly available. You go ahead, do the general relativity, and tell us.
- _Microft 3y agoBeside the mentioned laboratories in the US, Italy and Japan, there is another one in Germany albeit of much smaller size [0]. The length of its arms are only 600m (1/3mi) each but it serves as testbed for technologies [1] that might later be used for other observatories. [0] https://www.geo600.org/ https://www.geo600.org/ , https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/GEO600 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/GEO600 [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/GEO600#Advanced https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/GEO600#Advanced
- borissk 3y agoSince learning about gravitational waves I was always curious if a type III civilization could potentially use them as a weapon.
- cde-v 3y agoAnything can be used as a weapon.
- HansHamster 3y agoFirst thing that comes to mind is a lethal dose of neutrino radiation: https://what-if.xkcd.com/73/ https://what-if.xkcd.com/73/ Now the tricky part is probably to build a neutrino / gravitational wave / whatever source that is intense enough to be useful as a weapon without just evaporating everything in a supernova scale explosion before...
- causality0 3y agoOne of the most interesting yet sadly least rigorous What-Ifs. He relies on simply scaling up a calculation in absorbed dose at the distance of one parsec. Neutrinos do not interact with nuclei the same way gamma rays do, and the effects of a particular amount of neutrino radiation on living tissue is unstudied and unknown. The paper he cites explicitly points this out but he ignored it.
- raverbashing 3y agoOf course it doesn't, I think that was given by the relationship between neutrino count and sieverts But make no mistake, there is such a thing as a fatal amount of neutrinos. It's just that's a supernova mind boggling amount, but it exists. They do interact due to the weak force, which is more than neutrons do (and a lethal dose of those is well known)
- mhh__ 3y agoSee also neutrino HFT
- fjfaase 3y agoFor observatory status see [0]. It also gives the estimated detector range in megaparsecs (Mpc). Initial LIGO's "range" (the radius out to which LIGO could detect at least a binary neutron star (BNS) merger) was 15 Mpc. With the latest improvements is more in the 140 Mpc range. Meaning that it can see more than 9 times as far and that the area of space is increased by a factor of more than 800. This will greatly increase the number of gravitational waves being detected. [0] https://online.ligo.org/ https://online.ligo.org/
- acqq 3y agoDo you know if even longer ranges logged there, like 600, are practically useful or are they too short (in time) for that? https://online.ligo.org/grafana/public-dashboards/1a0efabe65384a7287abfcc1996e4c4d?orgId=1&from=1683599069003&to=1683599318228 https://online.ligo.org/grafana/public-dashboards/1a0efabe65...
- fjfaase 3y agoYes, I have seen those as well. It looks like these spikes always appear at the start when the status goes to 'Observing'. For that reason, they may just be start-up artifact, where you have too less data point to arrive at an accurate estimate, resulting in a far too optimistic value.
- dr_dshiv 3y ago> Meaning that it can see more than 9 times as far Hear 9 times as far?
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- nrdgrrrl 3y agoFeel 9 times as far?
- onionisafruit 3y ago
- galizar 3y agoNice. There's even a citizen scientist initiative for LIGO [0]. I wonder what's the status on LISA though. [0] https://www.zooniverse.org/projects/zooniverse/gravity-spy https://www.zooniverse.org/projects/zooniverse/gravity-spy
- kataklasm 3y agoOne of my professors worked on LISA Pathfinder, the demo satellite used to proof-of-concept LISA technology until the financial shortcomings in the early 2010s were overcome and he recently said that everyone in the project is hard at work getting ready for the program review, after which either a contract is made or the program is reformulated. But no one will put in the gigantic work needed to prepare such a review if it is not almost certain the program will pass the review and become a contract, so things are looking quite good for LISA and its early 2030s launch!
- wefarrell 3y agoI think it would be really neat to have a space based telescope in close proximity to LISA so that when gravitational waves are detected the telescope can point in the direction of the source and capture the light from it.
- cubefox 3y agoI remember reading about LISA as a kid, around 25 years ago. Currently it is planned to launch in 2037. I somewhat doubt it will ever become a reality.
- whoisthis4chan 3y ago> Typical gravitational-wave events change the length of the arms by only a fraction of the width of a proton. Sensing such minute changes requires painstaking isolation from noise coming from the environment and from the lasers themselves. i find it utterly fascinating that we're able to detect such a minuscule deviation
- pfdietz 3y agoLasers beams are bounced back and forth many times, so the deviation builds up. The beams have to be very powerful (100s of kW) to reduce photon counting noise sufficiently.
- wwarner 3y agoKip Thorne explains it pretty clearly in this 2002 lecture https://youtu.be/mGdbI24FvXQ https://youtu.be/mGdbI24FvXQ
- dekhn 3y agointerferometry is indeed amazing. When the ultra-important Michelson-Morley experiment was run some ~100 years ago, they were doing interferometry but in those days there wasn't really good vibration isolation technology. They had to float their whole experiment on a pool of mercury (!) in the sub-sub basement of an idle building, and even then, deliveries nearby (by horse) would cause problems. Nowadays, physics students do the MM experiment in a lab on a benchtop in a day.
- waynecochran 3y agoThe image at the top of the page is not a real image is it? We don't have real photos of black holes yet right? (except the one at https://www.nasa.gov/mission_pages/chandra/news/black-hole-image-makes-history https://www.nasa.gov/mission_pages/chandra/news/black-hole-i...)
- sp332 3y agoThe image is credited to the SXS Project, which does black hole simulation.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- causality0 3y agoThe LIGO song is required background music for this article: https://youtu.be/degD69wnZcY https://youtu.be/degD69wnZcY
- captainkrtek 3y agoBig LIGO nerd here. If interested, you can get public alerts of LIGO detected activity (on mobile and online): https://www.ligo.caltech.edu/page/GWPhoneAlerts https://www.ligo.caltech.edu/page/GWPhoneAlerts https://gracedb.ligo.org/superevents/public/O3/ https://gracedb.ligo.org/superevents/public/O3/
- Simon_O_Rourke 3y agoGood, this is a necessary thing to get back up and running again. Thanks for the update alerts, will subscribe and see what's stirring in the galactic 'hood. Question though - do gravitational waves diminish significantly as a function of distance or intervening mass?
- empyrrhicist 3y agoAt distance it's an inverse square law I believe
- dataflow 3y agoI think their amplitude falls as 1/r, their power falls as 1/r^2. Just a layman but I imagine the amplitude is the relevant part here?
- dmbche 3y agohttps://www.forbes.com/sites/startswithabang/2019/03/02/ask-ethan-why-dont-gravitational-waves-get-weaker-like-the-gravitational-force-does/?sh=27bcf54e2f58 https://www.forbes.com/sites/startswithabang/2019/03/02/ask-... This should answer any questions!
- koheripbal 3y agoThe Android app is so outdated that my Pixel 3a is too new to run it!
- tommywiseausmom 3y ago[flagged]
- seanhunter 3y agoYou seem to have created an account solely for the purpose of making and remaking this same juvenile joke in seperate threads. People like you make the world a little bit worse for everyone else.
- fsh 3y agoThat's what the "flag" button is for.
- shrimp_emoji 3y agoYou misspelled better
- fire 3y agoare gravitational waves like, universal? could we use them as a timing reference, I wonder?
- gus_massa 3y ago[I'm not sure I understood your question. I hope this helps.] The gravitational waves travel also at the speed of light. They will reach first the point of the Earth that is closest to the event first. And then travel and reach the oposite point like 40ms later. The Earth is almost almost almost transparent, so the signal reaches all the Earth, but with a different small delay.
- im3w1l 3y agoThis might be a stupid question but to me it's hard to grasp that they travel at a "speed" when they are themselves distortions of time/space. Does it always make sense to say they move at the speed of light or only for say small amplitude waves where we can do some quasi-special-relativity trick?
- gus_massa 3y agoIt's an interesting question. I must take that General Relativity course some day. Meanwhile, I have to guess ... I guess you are correct and with small amplitudes the apparent speed is equal to the speed of light. For big amplitudes, I'm not sure.
- raattgift 3y agoPp-wave spacetimes (pp = plane-fronted and parallel) can with suitable separations can have arbitrary constant wave amplitudes. Such spacetimes admit a Killing vector field letting us have a sensible way of measuring the propagation speed of the wave. At any point where it is measured, the propagation is lightlike. Parts of a spacetime around an equal-mass circular-orbit binary will be reasonably approximated by a pp-wave spacetime (edge-on, not too close to the sources, and over a duration where their orbit is negligibly contracting).
- rainbowzootsuit 3y agoI was lucky to take a tour of the Livingston, LA facility. It's within about an hour's drive north of New Orleans. Very much worth a visit. https://goo.gl/maps/9fLFCVqjumx1LSkXA https://goo.gl/maps/9fLFCVqjumx1LSkXA As someone who's worked on laboratory ultra-high vacuum systems the ~2m diameter by 4km long arms that are vacuum chambers are quite impressive. A "fun fact" from the tour was that they had a road grading company construct the underlayer for the support of the arms. They asked the company to set the angle of the grading to equal the negative curvature of the earth as the arms have to be straight in space while a surface that's graded "flat" would end up following the curvature of the earth.
- ramraj07 3y agoThe irony of one part of humanity: led mainly by People in the most prosperous country, measuring ever vanishing amounts of interference at the length of a proton to detect exploding stars, and they have to account for among other things the curvature of this planet to the millimetre. Just a few miles away (and likely everywhere) in the same country there are many people growing in number who insist for some reason that the earth is flat. I am genuinely flummoxed why that's still a thing.
- mlindner 3y agoFlat earth conspiracy is not widespread and is not growing. It’s a thing that’s primarily on the internet. On the grand scheme of things there’s bigger things to worry about than what a tiny fraction of people think.
- SergeAx 3y agoHeard an anecdote about LIGO, when they were experimenting with quarz pendulum without a string(s). They statically charged the pendulum and its base, so the pendulum was repulsed from the base, eliminating even slightest possible friction while oscillating. A journalist from science magazine was visiting and decided to take an impressive picture of vacuum-floating piece of quartz. No one had a chance to say a word when journalist popped a flashlight from their camera and pressed the shutter. Flashlight removed the static charge and the pendulum fell to the base.
- peter303 3y agoThe new run has six candidate GW events the first week. Three are high confidence.