7 ms·
Lenovo profits sink 75% as PC demand continues nosedive
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- 0zemp2c 3y agoWintel is dying Microsoft doesn't care, they moved on to Azure and AI Intel kinda cares, but they are moving on to being a fab provider Dell, Lenovo, Acer...they're screwed...they have no other play but Wintel
- hn_throwaway_99 3y agoThat really has nothing to do with what this article is about.
- TheRealDunkirk 3y agoIt may or may not. I've often wondered how much sliding demand for PC's is due to an increase in sales of Apple products. Unfortunately, the entire decades long infatuation with these sales figures relies on Gartner, which I believe was bought off in the early 90's by Microsoft. The critical piece of information that would make these figures useful is what percentage are corporate purchases, and that's the part that's never been reported in all the 30 years I've been watching. Every time I bring it up here, my question is ignored, and I can't figure out why no one else is curious about this.
- Dudester230518 3y agoMy WinAMD is doing just fine. No linux trash for me, thanks.
- rejectfinite 3y agoBased.
- huijzer 3y agoYou are heavily downvoted, but I think you’re right. The Windows + Intel combo appears to be in serious trouble for the PC and laptop markets. The main problem I see is the slowing of Moore’s law and Dennard’s scaling. It used to be that you didn’t have to innovate on a laptop. You only needed to get the state-of-the-art chip on board to beat the competition. This is less so nowadays as can be seen from the Apple laptops which have improved on all layers on the stack. The newest Intel or AMD laptop doesn’t necessarily beat a 2 years old Apple laptop performance and usability wise. Regarding Windows, Microsoft does care according to the build conference from yesterday: they announced plugins inside Windows and other cool new features. However, according to Nadella, Google makes more money on a typical Windows laptop than Microsoft does. I think this partially explains why Windows seems to have stalled innovation wise.
- AzzieElbab 3y agoPC demand had always been a mystery to me. Ok, fine, I have to compile a lot of code and sometimes run k8 on my 4-year-old Linux laptop, but who else needs a powerful PC besides gamers(who mainly use consoles anyway) and graphics designers? ML is cloud-based these days, right?
- taylodl 3y agoHave you seen modern CAD software? That's pretty compute intensive. That's just one of many tools in the engineering space that is compute intensive. Remember, there are a lot of engineers! Movie making and editing is still pretty compute intensive, as is animation. Thanks to YouTube, a lot of people have video editing work streams and they're looking for ways to get their work done faster and make their content stand out so that viewers will click those 'Like' and 'Subscribe' buttons so that they make more money. Music making is getting more and more compute intensive, especially nowadays as all the what once were physical processors in the signal chain are all being virtualized. Add in amp simulators, cab simulators, AI drummers, and of course nobody wants any latency, and you need some modern processing muscle to make it all work. Apple makes the Mac Studio for a reason - and it's not for gamers! As far as developers are concerned, no, you don't need much horsepower to "compile a lot of code", but you may need a lot of horsepower to run that code if it's in one of the aforementioned software categories.
- dehrmann 3y agoIntel also plays in the datacenter space.
- dehrmann 3y agoI halfway want a macbook for my next laptop for this reason, but I find the plastic thinkpad chassis more comfortable, and the data recovery story for macs with a bad cpu/ram is bad.
- karaterobot 3y ago> Shipments peaked at 350 million for 2021, and PC makers believed that the total addressable market would remain at those heady heights A global pandemic and forced sheltering in place causes millions of people to buy new PCs for work from home. Lenovo, seeing this, draws the conclusion that all of those people will continue buying new PCs every year, forever? They deserve whatever happens to their business if they're that dumb.
- catboybotnet 3y agoi imagine they expect yearly purchases like apple and iphones, for some reason. it shouldn't be the norm to throw out Perfectly Working Hardware(tm) like an old pair of shoes, but it's the only thing that generates revenue when you aren't in the business of support contracts for decade old hardware. that or they saw growth for one year, and thought that it's a permanent increase. either way, The Board is unhappy when Line go Down.
- bdcravens 3y agoPerhaps they assumed from WFH was going to become the new norm, which would likely result in some continued demand (though certainly less than pandemic levels)
- polygamous_bat 3y agoHere's the problem: executives are incentivized to (a) make the stock price go up, and (b) make them go up real fast. This means that if the options are (a) admitting the truth that this was a temporary surge, and thus having a moderate but sustainable increase in the stock price, or (b) pretend this is the "new normal", peloton purchases are gonna grow 40% every quarter, and so the stock should skyrocket _right now_, guess which one they picked. It's not a bug, it's a feature of stock-value-maximizing capitalism as opposed to true-value-maximization.
- amelius 3y agoIt'll only be a matter of time before some manager figures out planned obsolescence.
- atemerev 3y ago"What if you discovered that your whole personality depended on low interest rates"
- afavour 3y agoCOVID hits, purchasing patterns change dramatically. COVID recedes, purchasing patterns move back towards pre-pandemic norms. We see this trend over and over and it’s baffling that the execs never saw it coming. Though in Lenovo’s specific case I am curious if there has been a semi permanent shift from office desktop PCs to laptops, now that hybrid and WFH are a lot more common.
- 5350-uiop-1130 3y agogrowth, companies are like junkies that need a bigger dose each time to get the same kick. i guess the issue is that investment always flows towards the highest return. but then you sooner or later end up in a casino world.
- paulrouget 3y agoI'd love to see a Thinkpad with the old thinkpad keyboard, a good ARM CPU (like M1, not like X13S (Snapdragon 8cx Gen 3)), a 4:3 display without all the usual Lenovo bloatware. One can always dream…
- goodpoint 3y agoThe ship has sailed and Framework seems to be the new thinkpad.
- goodpoint 3y agoSilent downvotes, suuure.
- rubenfiszel 3y agox1 carbon with an m1 cpu, I wouldn't care how much it would cost.
- moffkalast 3y agoI'm sure someone would build you one for a few hundred grand if you really don't care about the cost.
- WorldPeas 3y agoThis would probably be achievable once framework releases an ARM motherboard. At that point, it's looking more like they'd release an ARM board than a trackpoint keyboard. I can dream...
- catboybotnet 3y agohell, i'd take a modern x86 cpu with the ol' keyboard and a 4:3 display. the perfect pc...
- dehrmann 3y ago> a good ARM CPU Is Raptor Lake not close enough to the M1?
- hn_throwaway_99 3y ago2 points: 1. Journalists love to headline percentage profit declines, because it's a bigger number, but large companies often have big swings in profitability. Revenue changes are much more important, and the article states the revenue was down 24%. 2. I'm still baffled that this can be remotely surprising to anyone. All these "pandemic surge" companies (think Home Depot, Lowes, Peleton, and here Lenovo with laptops) had to have known this was just temporary. I mean, they sell durable goods, and obviously the pandemic pulled a ton of demand forward (as well as added demand). Nearly every kid in the country needed a laptop for remote school during the pandemic. How on earth did anyone think that demand could continue?
- version_five 3y agoRe: 2, it's just that nobody involved has any incentive to act like good times won't continue indefinitely. That's the natural consequence of pricing companies as the present value of their future earnings.
- thx-2718 3y agoThat's why you pick stocks on what you think is run well/built to make money within the time frame you want your money there. Because then there's presumably a better chance that they will deliver on those earnings.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- bastardoperator 3y agoExecutives don't care. Of course they knew. They'll do anything for money even if it means destroying lives. They need that bonus and they need it now.
- happymellon 3y agoI don't see anywhere in that fine article that stated that Lenovo implied that sales were going to continue to go up, or that their actions were going to "destroy lives". Where did you come up with this?
- temp51723 3y ago=( typing this from my ~12 year old lenovo x201.
- zinclozenge 3y agoI bought a Lenovo mini-pc for $570 and it took a month before I canceled it and bought a mac mini M1 for $599, with much better hardware.
- ipaddr 3y agoSwitching from pc to mac is more than a hardware upgrade. If this is your first mac you are in for a different experience.
- zinclozenge 3y agoTrue. In my case I was going to put Linux on it and use it for a home automation server.
- realo 3y agoInteresting... Why not buy something like this instead? Granted the M1 mac will be a gazillion times faster and whether or not you actually need that speed for a home automation server is for you to decide, of course. https://www.onlogic.com/cl210g-10/ https://www.onlogic.com/cl210g-10/
- r00fus 3y agoGiven Asahi Linux - there's no situation in which you can compare a dual-celeron to an M1 chip and come out desiring the Celeron unless it's like half the price (tl;dr - it's only $150 cheaper so no).
- arbuge 3y agoI think using an m1 computer as a home automation server is the proverbial sledgehammer to crack a nut. Even an old latop/desktop from ebay for <$100 would work perfectly well.
- mastax 3y agoIt's interesting looking at all the new PC products which were obviously designed ~2 years ago and are not really suited to the current market conditions. E.g. the new AMD CPUs are too expensive, the new AMD + Nvidia GPUs are too expensive, etc. Of course pricing isn't set until just before release but the broad strokes of die size and memory bus width were set long ago. AMD + Nvidia seem to be trying to cling to ~60% gross margin but I don't think they'll succeed.
- RSHEPP 3y agoMy 8 year Acer is on it's last legs. I need to a new laptop. But the fear that I will be laid off for the second time in a year tells me I need to hold off until... who knows when.
- marcodiego 3y agoPC demand has been falling way before COVID. I guess it has been so since at least 2013. I even remember some people assigning it to windows 8. Actually, the real reason are changes in usage patterns. Most people today don't have to buy a computer. They can do everything they need with mobile phones, smartv's, smart devices and whatever other device is more adequate. The explosive rise in popularity of the late 90's and early 2000's was just because a full blown computer was the most convenient device to access the internet. Now that people have options, there are less people buying the device they don't actually need. What we are seeing, indeed, is that things are going back to what is normal. Most people really don't need a computer.
- hn_throwaway_99 3y agoThe data from the article basically proves every one of your points wrong. > They can do everything they need with mobile phones, smartv's, smart devices and whatever other device is more adequate. Yeah, sure, I see everyone working from home on their smartphones. All those college kids are writing their term papers on smart TV's, gotcha.
- marcodiego 3y ago> Yeah, sure, I see everyone working from home on their smartphones. I don't see "everyone working from home". > All those college kids are writing their term papers on smart TV's, gotcha. Colleges can provide this demand and not everyone is a "college kid". With regard to the other points, you can check how pc shipments have been in decline since 2011[1] and how android and ios have been growing during the same period[2] [1] https://www.statista.com/statistics/264467/global-pc-shipments-since-1st-quarter-2009/ https://www.statista.com/statistics/264467/global-pc-shipmen... [2] https://gs.statcounter.com/os-market-share#monthly-200901-202304 https://gs.statcounter.com/os-market-share#monthly-200901-20...
- hn_throwaway_99 3y agoYou've misunderstood my post. I'm not arguing everyone is a working from home or a college student writing term papers. I provided those satirical examples to show that phones are largely an entirely new market, they're by and large not replacing PCs. Every PC market expert I've ever heard on the subject has a very simple explanation for declining PC sales: the market was growing for decades, and then simply saturated, and now it's pretty much just a replacement market. The entire fact there was a huge spike in PC sales during the pandemic pretty much disproves your argument. People still need and want PCs and laptops, they simply pretty much all already have them. My bet is that nearly everyone on this site who used a PC 2 decades ago is still using a PC for things like work and writing, it's just now they're also using a phone.
- jamesgill 3y agoFor computers, I actively use: * A nine-year-old desktop Mac Mini (2014) * An eight-year-old MacBook Pro (2015) * A five-year-old ThinkPad T480 (2018) And a nine-year-old home server sitting in the basement (Optiplex 9020). I rarely need new computers.
- grogenaut 3y agoLol you have bought 4 in the last 9 years or one every 2.25 years. About as often as I get a new phone. Way more often then I buy a washer, dryer, game console, TV, fridge, car, furniture, etc.
- seydor 3y agoYou will need one for AI
- romeoblade 3y agoOptiplex 9020's make surprisingly good home servers. I have three, a 2 node proxmox cluster and 1 running as a NAS. The cluster is running 15 VM's including a 5 node docker swarm. I downsized from older HP G1 series in a rack when I moved across country in 2019 and couldn't be happier. Runs everything I need and they were cheap to max out.
- windex 3y agoLenovo's laptops have begun soldering things to the board making them less desirable.
- elric 3y agoI'm surprised their sales haven't dropped even more. I had an incredibly hard time buying a new Thinkpad earlier this year. Their website is actively user-hostile. It's so incredibly slow that using it makes me yearn for the speeds of a 52k dialup modem. Their model lineup continues to become more and more baffling, and the utter shittiness of their website makes it a nightmare to navigate the lineup. Once I did find an acceptable machine, I couldn't fucking pay for it ... for years I've been paying Lenovo by bank transfer, never had any issues with it. But all of a sudden, they've removed the option. And the machine was too expensive for my credit card. Customer support told me to get bent (or to increase my CC limit, one or the other). Which I eventually managed to do, and which works when ordering one machine, but there have been instances where I've ordered ten at a time ... Once it did arrive, I couldn't help but notice that the latest iteration of keyboards has gotten worse again, the touchpad frequently stops working for several seconds, and the trackpoint starts to drift on occasion. Sigh. Maybe I'm just a grumpy old man.
- g8oz 3y agoI'll echo your complaints. A recently purchased monitor started going dim and they refused to replace it because it could "possibly have been from physical mishandling" in their words. Just getting to that decision was an ordeal in itself with multiple contact avenues just simply not working.
- dopeboy 3y agoI will continue to purchase from them, but their buying experience is just horrid. Take a page from Apple and consolidate your offerings + offer less customization.
- elric 3y agoI'd argue that fewer base models with more customization options would be preferable.
- robotburrito 3y agoI agree, their shopping experience was insanely terrible. Tons of models with slight differences in model numbers that all seem like 99% the same laptop. Finally find one that suits my needs and it's more expensive than a new MacBook Pro anyway so why bother. Additionally, the chance your new $2000+ laptop will be $500 a few months later lightly used on Ebay is really high. So I just wait. My current personal laptop is a nice Thinkpad with an i7 I picked up for $300 on craigslist. Sure the screen feels like it's from the 90s, but it mostly stays plugged into a monitor.
- la64710 3y agoThe first question a headline like this comes to mind is : What are those PCs (including laptops) being replaced with? Obviously a PC/laptop can only be replaced with another one. So the aggregate demand generated by replacement needs cannot change drastically over the years. I assume this part of the demand will stay somewhat stable with slight ups and downs. Then the other part of the demand is the demand for new laptops. Which also cannot change a whole lot unless there is a drastic increase in population. So the remaining part of the demand that happened due to remote work/class requirement - that may contribute to the decrease as demand for that wane as folks go offline again. But that itself cannot contribute to 75% profit sink. A headline like this does nothing but spread misinformation and I wish there was a way to legally ban them. At least HN moderators can do their part by not boosting these time of meaningless article by using a little part of their cerebrum cortex.
- liotier 3y ago> What are those PCs (including laptops) being replaced with? Tablets
- r00fus 3y ago> What are those PCs (including laptops) being replaced with? It's the equipment version of a "staycation" - you keep your older kit and save your money. Windows11 requirements are quite low (1Ghz/4GB RAM/64GB Storage). macOS has ever increasing requirements but there are workarounds to keep some older but not decrepit machines operable [1]. And there's always Linux for the rest. Also just like cars - I'm sure the used market is thriving. [1] https://github.com/dortania/OpenCore-Legacy-Patcher https://github.com/dortania/OpenCore-Legacy-Patcher
- uguuo_o 3y agoAfter their superfish debacle [0], I just have not been able to give them my money regardless of how great some of their machines are. Maybe someday. [0] https://www.tomshardware.com/news/lenovo-settlement-superfish-scandal-progress,38657.html https://www.tomshardware.com/news/lenovo-settlement-superfis...
- jscipione 3y agoI remember January 2000 very clearly. After the Y2K panic ended (with a whimper) sales dropped, stocks crashed, and we spiraled into a recession with layoffs and consolidation to follow. It seems we are entering a similar pattern now with the Pandemic panic over, sales drying up, stocks tanking, layoffs and a recession.
- spokeonawheel 3y agocuz its all so dang expensive