9 ms·
iPhone maker Wistron quits, saying Apple didn't let it make a profit
- fomine3 3y agoWistron (Taiwan based) sold plants to Luxshare (PRC based) - so is Apple failing moving from China?
- manuelabeledo 3y agoWhat I read is that Wistron didn’t have a good strategy getting in India, and that cost them Apple’s business.
- mannyv 3y ago"We didn't understand our costs, so we underbid and now are blaming Apple." - Wistron
- kitsunesoba 3y agoIt does seem likely that this is a case of a bit of column A, a bit of column B. Apple very well may have unrealistic demands, but I believe it's also likely that Wistron may not have dealt with the level of QC, precision, and consistency that is expected of Apple products and based their estimates on experiences of working with more typical hardware companies.
- dfox 3y agoWistron is large part of the reason why IBM/Lenovo ThinkPads are regarded as some kind of etalon of quality and repairability. I assume that most of the issue there is misunderstanding of how to run a factory in India and how is that different from both Far East and Europe.
- jalk 3y agoOr perhaps even more damning (as the article also mentions): "We expected to get away with paying our workers lower than the legal minimum"
- s1mon 3y agoYes, that's certainly a valid reaction, and is likely partially true. It's also true that Apple is very well known for very hard negotiation and squeezing their suppliers until there's only a few percent margin. You'd have to be insanely good at controlling all of your costs to make money all the time under that constraint. If yields change or component/material prices fluctuate the wrong way any predicted profit could disappear. Apple also pays suppliers on net 90. With inflation the way it's been, any miscalculation there will sink things. Not all suppliers know how to be banks too. Considering how much cash Apple has, this is really reprehensible. As a supplier to Apple, the gross numbers are so seductive since they are larger than just about anything else, but the net numbers are orders of magnitude less.
- CharlesW 3y ago> It's also true that Apple is very well known for very hard negotiation… No successful company is over-paying suppliers.
- Centigonal 3y agoThere's a difference between over-paying suppliers and being literally the best in the world at squeezing suppliers, which Apple is IMO. You can argue (and I will argue) that Apple's skill at squeezing their suppliers while still maintaining reliable supply chains is a huge part of why they're the biggest company in the world (and also why Tim Cook and not Scott Forstall or Jony Ive succeeded Jobs). That squeezing has real human costs, which Apple is insulated from. They've outsourced the majority of their labor (and related liability) to a global cadre of high-volume, low margin suppliers, while capturing most of the value created by that labor by owning the Apple brand and maintaining tight control of information, resulting in an asymmetric risk/reward profile for Apple inc.
- mistrial9 3y ago"those who do business with Dell, go out of business"
- bdidbdidhdidh 3y agoyou really think apple gives a detailed build instruction on the bid war moment? it probably is a room full of parts and to win you have to commit to the non present parts too. just like fashion production bids btw
- draw_down 3y ago[dead]
- yalogin 3y agoDidn't they also have some issues with payments and working conditions for their factory employees?
- cowsup 3y agoCorrect. Story seems to be, Wistron was screwing over employees to save costs, and used those low-costs to secure a deal with Apple. Then they got caught by the government, and now have to play by the rules. Because of this, they asked Apple for more money, and Apple said no. So now the deal is done. The deal really shouldn’t have happened in the first place, had Wistron played fair from day one.
- elcritch 3y agoPretty sure Apple is partly guilty as well. I really doubt they didn’t know exactly how Wistron was bidding so low.
- karamanolev 3y agoThey might have suspected, but I doubt they formally knew. I would guess it was a type of "don't tell me, I don't want to know, plausible deniability and all".
- actionfromafar 3y agoOnly suckers formally know anything.
- paulryanrogers 3y agoThere be dragons. Better a high trust society with some checks and balances than one ruled by "don't write down anything" sociopaths.
- MichaelZuo 3y ago
- ihsw 3y agoWistron has has a rough history, including underpaying/withholding pay from employees[1]. Good riddance. [1] https://www.businessinsider.com/apple-says-wistron-on-probation-after-riot-indian-iphone-plant-2020-12 https://www.businessinsider.com/apple-says-wistron-on-probat...
- shp0ngle 3y agoWhile Foxconn has... good history?
- dogma1138 3y agoFoxconn offers robust safety net for its employees… (I’ll walk myself out now).
- misterprime 3y agoLiterally literally.
- tomxor 3y agoOnly if they are lucky, retaining limbs is not a contractual obligation for Foxconn.
- squokko 3y agoFlagship customers often do this to vendors. They know that "Apple is our customer" is a big selling point, so they turn the screws tight and make the vendor serve them for no margin.
- smoldesu 3y agoSo... is it possible to make iPhones outside of China or not?
- nradov 3y agoYes, iPhones are also manufactured in Brazil and India. This is largely due to trade barriers in those countries.
- mdasen 3y agoYea, I think it started with trade barriers, but I think Apple likely wants to increase non-China manufacturing to reduce their risk a bit. Tensions with China have been a bit high and when you're Apple's size, it can be good to lessen the risk there. Even if it's unlikely that something would cause a disruption, when you're a nearly $3T company it's probably wise to diversify that risk. Apple's annual revenue is greater than the GDP of many countries like Finland or New Zealand. Ramping up manufacturing in India could be a good hedge against China or the US doing something that might impact their exports from China.
- 5350-uiop-1130 3y agohttps://nypost.com/2020/12/15/riots-at-apple-plant-in-india-cause-7-million-in-damage/ https://nypost.com/2020/12/15/riots-at-apple-plant-in-india-... this is what apple does. they use their clout, then they turn their back and play ignorant whilst placing unrealistic demands on the subcontractors who then place those demand on the labour. from: https://www.macrumors.com/2023/02/14/only-half-of-indian-iphone-casings-meet-standards/ https://www.macrumors.com/2023/02/14/only-half-of-indian-iph... > "Apple engineers told that Chinese iPhone suppliers and government officials have a "whatever it takes" approach to win iPhone orders, work was often completed weeks ahead of schedule at "inexplicable speed". In India, [we] are not running at this pace. "There just isn't a sense of urgency," one Apple engineer remarked." Remember, this is a $3 trillion company, with resources greater than most countries. A company built on tight control of information. If you see lots of positive or misdrecting comments, it's not necessarily a coincidence (imo).
- ly3xqhl8g9 3y agoAt least our current surface finishing technology has advanced so we no longer see the kid sized hand prints [1]. "Apple’s cobalt batteries are built on the backs of child labor in mines, causing severe physical harm to children and violating international standards of human rights." [2] Their PR: "Apple will use 100 percent recycled cobalt in batteries by 2025" [3]. [1] Kid sized hand prints on old victorian roof tiles, https://www.reddit.com/r/interestingasfuck/comments/13oser2/these_kid_sized_hand_prints_were_found_on_these/ https://www.reddit.com/r/interestingasfuck/comments/13oser2/... [2] 2022, Child Labor and the Human Rights Violations Embedded in Producing Technology, https://www.culawreview.org/journal/child-labor-and-the-human-rights-violations-embedded-in-producing-technology https://www.culawreview.org/journal/child-labor-and-the-huma... [3] https://www.apple.com/newsroom/2023/04/apple-will-use-100-percent-recycled-cobalt-in-batteries-by-2025 https://www.apple.com/newsroom/2023/04/apple-will-use-100-pe...
- crooked-v 3y agoYou seem to be assuming that 3 is a lie, but I'm pretty sure someone would notice if Apple wasn't actually changing the sources of their rare earths.
- dirtyid 3y agoNot just Apple manufacturing, seems like they're divesting from India in general after 10 years, also killing their plans to make laptops and EV components. My understanding is they were barely making money throughout their time in India. Wonder if Tata takeover of iphone assembly going to do better? Kind of expected outcome for TWnese companies known to treat their labourers like shit and India gov unable to manage their population from breaking things after being treated like shit. Which has caused problems for more than just Wistron. Yes it's good workers standing up for themselves, but smart thing is to do that after you've proven indispensible, otherwise reinforces India being difficult place to do business in.
- alephnerd 3y agoWinstron's divestment to Tata was honestly a good move. A big reason Foxconn, Winstron, and other Taiwanese/Malaysian/Singaporean assemblers were able to succeed in Mainland China was due to cultural competency within the existing Chinese diaspora (eg. knowing how to communicate to who, how to manage workers, etc). Foxconn, Winstron, and co would just straight up have Taiwanese/Malaysian/Singaporean/Thai Chinese move to Mainland China (in reality mostly Guangdong, Fujian, and Zhejiang due to cultural and familial connections plus the easy commute from Hong Kong or Shanghai) to help manage operations. Taiwanese companies don't have that kind of advantage within South Asia. At that point, it makes sense just to work directly with Indian conglomerates like Tata, who already have in house domain experience manufacturing everything due to India's Chaebol-esque corporate culture, or Japanese+Korean companies that are open to training from scratch. I've seen first hand how South Korean and Japanese companies managed their assembly plants in my dad's village in India (they manfuacture the electronics and computers for Wind Turbines) and it was a night and day difference to a similar attempted Taiwanese operation there. The difference was SK+JP companies would actually try to hire management locally, and if there wasn't anyone qualified, then invest in actually training from scratch, or alternatively, make a partnership with an existing company in India to help manage the local operation. Meanwhile, the attempted Taiwanese operation underbid severely, saw significant timeline overruns, tried to manage everything in-house, and the project was eventually scrapped and given to a private sector South Korean-Indian consortium. There was also a bit of corruption/malfeasance with the Taiwanese operation which pissed people off in the district. All this happened in the 2009-2012 timeframe
- buescher 3y agoIf Wistron was having quality problems, as has been rumored about iPhone production in India [1], this could have been the sort of deal where both sides lost. [1] https://www.theapplepost.com/2023/02/26/apple-disappointed-with-quality-of-iphone-production-in-india-50-of-casing-rejected-for-not-meeting-quality-standards/ https://www.theapplepost.com/2023/02/26/apple-disappointed-w...
- MuffinFlavored 3y agowhat portion of apple assembly for things like macbook/watch/iphone aren't 100% done by machine, and if they aren't 100% done by machine (which they aren't), it sounds extremely not easy to do by hand (especially at scale, for "low wages") what parts can't they automate?
- MichaelZuo 3y agoMost of the final assembly is done by hand. Hence why so many people are needed in the final assembly factories of Foxconn, Wistron, etc.
- buescher 3y agoAutomation doesn't guarantee quality, and it is hard to do at a high quality level, at scale, also.
- eunos 3y agoWistron exit from India https://economictimes.indiatimes.com/tech/technology/wistron-exits-apple-india-biz-after-tripping-over-scale-work-culture/articleshow/100401616.cms https://economictimes.indiatimes.com/tech/technology/wistron...
- cush 3y agoApple is so huge that they treat their manufacturers like a freelance design contracts... "We'll let you build our devices. We can't pay you, but think how amazing it will look to have Apple in your portfolio!"
- avmich 3y agoCapitalism. If manufacturers can't count their beans, who'll do that for them? Of course same applies to actual freelance persons - where the dynamics is substantially different.
- unicornmama 3y agoIt might appears unfair from Apple's side to take advantage of their position. However, hardware manufacturers do not resemble naive and exploited children. Commoditized vendors experience pressure to zero their margins from their largest customers. Every big customer does this (Wallmart, Google, Amazon, etc.) It's textbook business strategy.
- southwesterly 3y ago“Oh, by the way, sign this NDA so you can’t even talk about it.”
- mise_en_place 3y agoInterestingly, it seems first mover advantage backfired on this company. Due to lack of margins and vendor lock in.
- genr8 3y agoa similar situation just happened between Nvidia and EVGA. NVidia makes the chips, And So, holds all the bargaining chips so to speak, and EVGA is just the board partner that has to find some way to make the price work. At some point it becomes impossible and they have to actually walk away in order to not be taken advantage of. We know this much, and I'm going to assume the situation was similar here with Apple and Wistron.
- kitsunesoba 3y agoI think the Nvidia/EVGA situation might be a little different in that it looks like Nvidia is intentionally trying to squeeze out board partners like EVGA in favor of self-branded cards. The closer parallel is probably when Apple killed the Mac clone program by making it extremely difficult for clone makers to compete.
- fomine3 3y agoNvidia still doesn't sell their FE so much outside of US, so I don't think their intension is to selling more FEs.
- thr0waway001 3y agoI guess that's how you get to be a trillion dollar company.
- TradingPlaces 3y agoFoxconn somehow made $137m profit in the past 12m.
- xxs 3y agoYou mean by installing the suicidal protection net, Foxconn barely makes it? Foxconn has 1m3 employees. If they made just 137m in profit - that's just $8 profit per employee a month.
- buescher 3y agoI think those numbers are Taiwan dollars, and "m" is for billions i.e. milliards. So closer to $300 USD per employee per month. For fun, compare to McDonald's.
- AYBABTME 3y ago"just" 8$ per employee/m versus which similar industry's standard?
- draw_down 3y ago[dead]
- carlosjobim 3y ago$8 per employee per month is ridiculously low, no matter the industry standard.
- supernova87a 3y agoApple does help its suppliers to make a profit -- but the amount of profit that sustains a healthy set of vendors for Apple, at quality levels and corporate practice levels that Apple evaluates as "fair". Now, you may criticize that this holds vendors over a barrel and squeezes them to narrow margins, etc. But at least give Apple credit for having a view to the long run and trying to create a pool of vendors that it can rely on in a sustainable way, and not just some surge capacity for the next quarter only to drop them. Apple thinks longer than that. Their procurement function is quite skilled. And it's not like the vendors would magically have some source of business at better terms than Apple that would be good for them in the long run either. You want suppliers to somehow be raking in great margins in excess of what was "fair"? You want an employer who's more clueless and lets you make lots of extra on the top? A successful supplier to Apple knows what it's capable of and what its costs are, signs on to grow with Apple and become successful, and share in the practices that make a company efficient, skilled, productive. They can choose to join this train. Or not. It's voluntary.
- rullelito 3y agoVendor says they can't make profit. Wall-of-texter on HN says they can.. So hard to know who to believe..
- lotsofpulp 3y agoGiven that Apple has delivered tons of devices into people’s hands for well over a decade and continues to do so, I am going to go with the common sense that Apple’s suppliers must be earning a profit, otherwise they would not be doing charity work for Apple.
- madeofpalk 3y ago> Back in 2020, there was a major riot at its Bangalore plant over underpaid wages, with millions of dollars’ worth of damage done. Both the Indian government and Apple investigated, and both found that Wistron was indeed guilty of serious labor law violations, including underpayment of its workers. I’m not sure either are a great source to be honest.
- ShadowBanThis01 3y agoDoes relying on Chinese companies in India really accomplish the goal of independence from China? If there's some kind of political conflict, isn't it likely that China can shut those down using leverage at home?
- huyage 3y agoIsn't wistron literally a taiwanese company?
- ShadowBanThis01 3y agoI don't know, but they're exiting the business anyway. The article also mentions Foxconn and Luxshare, which are Chinese.
- fomine3 3y agoFoxconn is also a Taiwanese company (though its CEO is familiar with PRC)
- ShadowBanThis01 3y agoMore info from Wikipedia: "While headquartered in Taiwan, the company earns the majority of its revenue from assets in mainland China and is one of the largest employers worldwide."
- dahwolf 3y agoYou can hear the western executive think: India has lots of people and poor people specifically, so let's just roll out the China model there. They're going to be in for a shock. India does not have the "submissive communist" mindset where the individual sacrifices everything for the greater good of society, tolerating near-infinite abuse and exploitation. That loyalty model breaks much sooner. And whilst it incidentally breaks in disruptive ways (riots), more often than not it manifests as silent sabotage. There will be instability and if there's anything fatal to manufacturing...
- gnabgib 3y agoThe original news article from [Wistron exits Apple India business after tripping over scale, work culture](https://economictimes.indiatimes.com/tech/technology/wistron-exits-apple-india-biz-after-tripping-over-scale-work-culture/articleshow/100401616.cms https://economictimes.indiatimes.com/tech/technology/wistron...) from The Economic Times (referenced in the article) seems like a better submission.
- pfannkuchen 3y agoI’m surprised Wistron gave comment on Apple allegedly pushing them around, it makes them sound weak (which companies usually avoid doing).