12 ms·
The end of the accounting search
- antb123 3y agoI love beancount and have used it for a small business and have used wave accounting (made by some friends in Canada). That said Quickbooks is our main system https://beancount.github.io/docs/index.html https://beancount.github.io/docs/index.html
- zdw 4y agoI'm somewhat surprised that GNUCash was picked over Ledger or another of the plaintext systems out there: https://plaintextaccounting.org https://plaintextaccounting.org Maybe this was primarily done based on the users being comfortable with a GUI driven system?
- CameronNemo 4y agoAt the other end, there are a number of accounting systems that are based on plain-text files and an associated set of programs. These systems are much easier to work with [than the non-GnuCash GUI tools evaluated] and are adaptable to most needs. Such a system could have been made to work for LWN, but they tend to lack some useful features. Check writing and report generation, for example, tend not to be well supported. The user interface for many operations is a text editor; this is often seen as an advantage, but it becomes less so as the number of transactions grows. There are advantages to a graphical interface designed for the job at hand.
- seltzered_ 4y ago> Maybe this was primarily done based on the users being comfortable with a GUI driven system? FWIW I started prototyping a plaintext accounting 'app' that combines a popular plaintext accounting system (beancount) with the most used web frontend for it (fava) - it's called beancolage and makes use of eclipse theia (vscode-like experience): https://github.com/seltzered/beancolage https://github.com/seltzered/beancolage My observation is the plaintext accounting ecosystem is wonderful but a bit diffuse to so many specific usecases held by a more technical userbase. My aim for prototyping beancolage was to ask how things could look if there was a more common 'download and try' experience accessible to more people for basic workflows. Also have a talk on the motivations here: https://youtu.be/mxgoFqmSCFc https://youtu.be/mxgoFqmSCFc
- SoftTalker 4y agoI used Ledger to manage the accounting for a small nonprofit. It worked for me, but I was the Treasurer and the only person managing the books. Multiuser would have required git or something similar to handle the updates and possible conflicts. That's all stuff I'm comfortable with as a developer but a complete non-starter for anyone else. These issues would quickly make text-file accounting infeasible for larger organizations. When I moved out of that role, the next Treasurer wanted to use Quickbooks so I had to help import the data. That's another problem with using obscure software -- it's more difficult to hand it off to someone else who only knows the mainstream systems.
- PopAlongKid 4y agoI am strongly considering a switch to GnuCash, but not for the reasons in TFA. >Crashes were frequent; QuickBooks users know to make backups every few minutes to avoid losing work.[...] More recently, Intuit has discontinued support for the desktop version entirely in an effort to force all users to its online, paid-by-the-month service. Both of these statements are not true, based on both my professional and personal use of Quickbooks desktop for over 15 years. QB uses transaction logging[0] so that transactions are not lost, even after for example a power outage. And the desktop versions are still available, but no longer with a perpetual one-time license, but rather $800 annual subscription for the Accountant's version. (This is a doubling in price over just the last few years). So, I will be able to use my 2022 desktop version into the future at no extra cost, however some of the internet-based services (receiving payments, for example) will no longer be supported after 3 years. I have installed and started to migrate to GnuCash because I am not going to pay $800/yr to Intuit, especially when less and less of my use is for professional purposes. [0]https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Transaction_log https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Transaction_log
- jasonjayr 4y agoQB Enterprise uses Sybase internally, which is a sound choice, except they also do some kind of crazy file-locking over a SMB share, which can sometimes go wrong and cause issues. They scramble the login/password (and there are tools to do this computation so you can try to connect to the DB directly, but the schema is convoluted, and clearly decended from their old Dos/Win 3.1 roots), and then connect over the network to Sybase. Network clients crashing can cause issues that are difficult to unwind. It should not be possible to get the database into a state where backups + verification fail if it was enforcing referential integrity, but that seems to be common. The official tools to get yourself out of a pickle from Intuit are guesses at best. There is a cottage industry of people who will (for a great fee depending on how urgent it is), attempt to recover/correct the database for you, because they have experience peeking behind the curtain and building additional tools on the XML API. Good luck if you are using EDI or other electronic document exchange with other customers, and you transmit sales order numbers for a few hundred orders in the morning, and then things go pear shaped and QB refuses to cooperate and open the file in the afternoon. Going back to last night's backup means carefully/manually re-ordering 4 hrs of work to make sure that everything lines up, so you're probably in for a late day. Intuit "officially" supports a linux based server for QBE, but the community seems to thumb it's nose up at it, and offers no support for this configuration. QB, for many years was a very good price for the SMB market. There was a LOT of pricing headroom to the next best accounting package. Someone @ intuit has figured that out over the last 10 years and they are ratcheting up the price till customers fall out -- figuring it's finally worth it to drop QB for another solution. I'm aware of a migration from QB Enterprise to QB Online, that after signing up and paying, Intuit basically aborted the process. "Sorry, we don't support doing multiple tax rates for employees in multiple states in the QB Online version, here's your money back". Maybe they fix that eventually, but that's where it stood last year. QB is a frustrating product, for the inertia it currently has.
- axiomdata316 4y agoI'm a QuickBooks ProAdvisor and have been one for over 20 years and the last few years has convinced me that Intuit is determined to kill the goose that lays the golden eggs by: 1) Forcing all their customers to migrate to the online version of their program. Many of the clients I've spoken to were happy with and preferred the Desktop version. The Desktop version is faster and can do more than the online version. 2) Throwing major updates at the online version that hides or moves functionality. I work with multiple clients and based on the client their version of QuickBooks can be very different from another's. Even the same client that has multiple businesses and has to use multiple subscriptions could have a different look. I don't know what drives this at Intuit but it's confusing for me and I'm supposed to be the expert. 3) Relentlessly raise prices. Intuit has been annually raising their prices in what appears to be an attempt to eventually price everyone out of their product. Some clients have to pay 200.00 a month for the advanced version for one feature they need to have for their business! The attitude from Intuit feels like "So where else are you going to go?" For most of my adult life I've worked as an accountant that works mainly with QuickBooks but I'm worried that I'm going to have to try to find a new way of supporting myself because Intuit appears to be demonstrating by their recent decisions that they don't need to show loyalty to customers or even keep customers. If they can have a few stay on to pay ridiculous subscription fees that's all they need.
- tomrod 4y agoWhy would people not go to Gnucash or Fresh books?
- molsongolden 4y agoThey are just not as good as QuickBooks and not many accountants are familiar with these other packages. The prices keep increasing but the QuickBooks online functionality is the best out there and it is the platform with which most other tools make sure to integrate.
- clashandcarry 4y agoAlso, none of the open source alternatives support simultaneous multiuser access. Users can slowly adapt, but most businesses larger than a sole proprietorship need multiuser capability.
- electroly 4y agoIt's not true that Intuit discontinued support for the desktop version. Where did they get that idea? It's a subscription, yes, but the desktop version is alive and well. I WISH they would kill it so I could force my own users to upgrade to the online edition but no, it hasn't happened yet. We just upgraded to QuickBooks Desktop 2023.
- dboreham 4y agoAs a business owner and software developer I'm extremely reluctant to host mission critical and sensitive data with a provider like intuit. This is why we use desktop QB.
- corbet 4y agoI got the idea from the emails Intuit kept sending me saying that the desktop version was done and I'd have to buy a subscription from now on.
- electroly 4y agoYou do have to buy a subscription, but the desktop version is not done. There is a subscription for the desktop edition and separately one for the online edition. They are still perfectly happy for you to use the desktop edition. https://quickbooks.intuit.com/desktop/ https://quickbooks.intuit.com/desktop/ -- it's the "Work on desktop" options.
- seltzered_ 4y agoFYI, I recently updated scripts and documentation for migrating from QuickBooks to GNUCash : https://github.com/erikmack/qb-escape https://github.com/erikmack/qb-escape Would love if someone tried to package it into a standalone migration tool, so non-technical folks could make use of it!
- cratermoon 4y agoThis is good for GnuCash. It could bring enough visibility and interest to bring in more skilled developers to contribute a little work into adding or polishing some of the features the article mentions are lacking.
- dboreham 4y agoBecause someone is going to pay them?
- cratermoon 4y agoBecause LWN adopted it, raising visibility and interest. I edited my comment to make it sound less like I was saying GnuCash is buggy.
- noisy_boy 4y agoThe main issue towards adoption is the ease of fetching the transactions from various banks. Sure we can write some scripts to process the PDF files etc but it is still very manual compared to, e.g., allowing transaction query via REST api by granting users API keys.
- clircle 4y agoI loved GnuCash until my database was corrupted and i had no idea how to get it back into working order. I stopped tracking my finances closely after that
- ericbarrett 4y agoGnuCash keeps a year of backups (e.g. old saves) by default. It's probably still there.
- Wronnay 4y agoI use beancount for my personal finances and Odoo as well as ERPnext for my company. ERPnext is my favourite while Odoo currently supports the taxation in my country (Germany) a bit better...
- FredPret 4y agoAny tips for getting ERPNext up and running? I just spent a weekend of yak-shaving, and I get to the point where nginx is routing my requests to the “bench start” process, but refuses to serve a page.
- Wronnay 4y agoI currently just use a Cloud offering, but I also have setting it up on my own server on my ToDo list
- FredPret 4y agoMay you have more luck than me! If you figure it out, I'd love to read about it. The official documentation... leaves something to be desired.
- commoner 4y agoFrappe Cloud is by far the easiest way to run an ERPNext instance if you're okay with shared hosting. It's a Frappe framework-based app hosting service from the developers of ERPNext and it supports data file imports from other instances of ERPNext: - Frappe Cloud: https://frappecloud.com https://frappecloud.com In addition to the Frappe Bench setup process, Frappe provides instructions for self-hosting ERPNext with Docker and Kubernetes: - Docker: https://github.com/frappe/frappe_docker https://github.com/frappe/frappe_docker - Kubernetes: https://helm.erpnext.com https://helm.erpnext.com There's also a third-party Docker image from pipech that's easier to setup, but it's not always up to date: - Third-party Docker (pipech): https://hub.docker.com/r/pipech/erpnext-docker-debian https://hub.docker.com/r/pipech/erpnext-docker-debian Bitnami packages ERPNext in single-tier (AWS, Azure, or GCP) and virtual machine (local computer) offerings: - Bitnami: https://bitnami.com/stack/erpnext https://bitnami.com/stack/erpnext To anyone reading this, if you only need software for accounting and not an entire enterprise resource planning (ERP) suite, do yourself a favor and follow the advice in TFA to use GnuCash.
- harperlee 4y ago> Scheme looks like Lisp but isn't really Lisp Well that’s a surprising statement, i’ve heard it touted as more lispy than common lisp.
- jbotz 4y agoScheme is definitely a Lisp. One of its primary innovations over previous dialects of Lisp was lexical scoping, and most later Lisps adopted that, including Common Lisp.
- nerdponx 4y agoA lot of people use the name "Lisp" to mean specifically "Common Lisp".
- ur-whale 4y ago> Scheme looks like Lisp but isn't really Lisp The Lisp world is extremely confusing. I'd wager that at this time, most people in that space can't even agree on what "being a LISP" means.
- mtreis86 4y agoHaven't agreed in half a century, won't agree now, never will.
- harperlee 4y agoJavascript is lisp but clojure ain’t so!
- kazinator 4y agoI've never seen anyone say that MacCarthy's Lisp 1 and 1.5 are not Lisp. Or that MacLisp, or InterlLisp, BBN Lisp and other historic dialects are not Lisp. Or that Emacs Lisp or ANSI Common Lisp aren't. The entire disagreement is about languages that deviate from the core design patterns set out in the ancestral Lisps, some of whose adherents want them to be regarded as Lisp.
- asah 4y ago"Getting our QuickBooks data into GnuCash took a bit of scripting using the capable (if poorly documented) Python bindings." I wonder if LLMs can help with these gaps in documentation and examples?
- reaperducer 4y agoI wonder if LLMs can help with these gaps in documentation and examples? I wonder if LLMs can do someone's taxes. But I'm not going to be the first to try it.
- goostavos 4y agoI was trying to understand what box 2b was on one of my tax forms. Google wasn't helping me because I all I found was unreadable blog spam. So, I tried ChatGPT. "On form blah, what goes in box 2b?" It descended into me arguing with the machine over whether or not 2b even existed. "GPT, I'm literally holding the physical paper in my hand and staring at the box labeled 2b!" "That is incorrect. Form blah has never had a box labeled 2b" So, I'm going to go with: probably wanna hold off on the LLM taxes.
- reaperducer 4y agoIt descended into me arguing with the machine over whether or not 2b even existed. "GPT, I'm literally holding the physical paper in my hand and staring at the box labeled 2b!" "That is incorrect. Form blah has never had a box labeled 2b" So, 2b, or not 2b? That was the question?
- asah 4y agoThis seems weird. Did you try rephrasing the question? Can I see the transcript?
- yyyk 4y ago>It descended into me arguing with the machine over whether or not 2b even existed. Sounds like ChatGPT can already obsolete the tax office.
- onedognight 4y agoGnuCash may not support concurrent users, but it does support concurrent programmers as its XML config files can be checked into git. From my programmer perspective, revision-controlled accounting makes sense. You can fix bugs and change names, merge and split accounts, all with history, comments and easy reversion. And unlike with h?ledger, you have a nice GUI for managing most day to day tasks.
- nerdponx 4y agoDoes the SQLite format support concurrent users? Or would it need better conflict resolution support in the application? Checking the XML data into text-based version control is a really interesting idea. you could probably do something similar with the SQLite data, using a tool like Dolt.
- slondr 4y agoSQLite itself doesn’t support concurrent users.
- abbeyj 4y agoThe FAQ disagrees with you: https://www.sqlite.org/faq.html#q5 https://www.sqlite.org/faq.html#q5
- lostdog 4y ago> But only one process can be making changes to the database at any moment in time
- mappu 4y agoYou can open the same SQLite DB from multiple processes and then issue UPDATEs and INSERTs "simultaneously", and SQLite enforces the single-write rule internally with locking - using shared-memory on the same PC or file-locking on NFS-alikes.
- IG_Semmelweiss 4y agoSerious question - why are people stuck on QB when there are seriouly decent alternatives put there, like xero? My minimum price to go back to QB online would probably be $150k, maybe even more. Here is why: - constant down time - constant errors - clueless offshore support - inflexible reporting - constant UI changes for no reason Switched to Xero, havent looked back. QB Desktop was quite good but working offline is impossible these days for any tech startup.
- Dwolb 4y agoIndustry momentum. If you’re not an accountant, and want someone to take it over for your business, they usually start you on QB.
- coolestguy 4y ago>why are people stuck on QB when there are seriouly decent alternatives put there, like xero? When you're an business owners employee you don't have time or authority to change accounting software because you're overworked & thought of as a cost centre. When you're a business' owner you do whatever your accountant says which is usually a legacy software because a lot of tax preparers & accountants aren't actually in the trenches anymore and don't know about the granular bookkeeping part of accounting and how much better software has gotten in the last decade. When you're an tax preparers employee you don't get to talk to the client. When you're the tax preparer director/owner you don't use software anymore. Source: accounting startup who has doubled revenue 2 years in a row thanks to all of the above
- throwaway4784 3y agoWould you be willing to share which startup you are at?
- mwexler 4y agoNot open source but free with many features, https://www.waveapps.com/ https://www.waveapps.com/ can fit the bill for many small businesses. However, it may not scale the way QB does, and folks you bring on won't have had experience with it's way of doing things. That being said, with QB's changes, chances are that's true of QB folks as well (ha, ha).
- tr33house 4y agoI've used waveapps for my consulting business and it works great
- gavinhoward 4y agoI'm another happy user of GnuCash. I use the SQLite backend for the same reason Jonathan chose GnuCash: scripting. I can script in bash with the `sqlite3` command-line tool. I also use the reports extensively. I personally enter every transaction because I want to know where the money is going and categorize every expense into a budget, but yes, import is important. As soon as I can, I am going to support GnuCash better than just shilling.
- snvzz 4y agoI have been using it for some 15 years now. GNUCash is great.
- greatgib 4y agoGnucash is awesome even if not perfect. The problem to use it in France is that there is regulatory barriers preventing to use it officially. In theory accounting solutions have to comply with rules that are complicated to follow with your own opensource solution!
- nelgaard 4y agoThe same in Denmark from next year. What is missing in GnuCash is mainly some support for e-invoicing in [https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/PEPPOL https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/PEPPOL Peppol] Is anyone working on something like that?
- andrewflnr 4y agoIs it just me or is that an honest-to-goodness commercial open source support business opportunity?
- greatgib 4y agoMaybe there is business for developing the missing features. I would pay for that. But there is also a requirement for certifying that the data of the software can't be altered, and you are not allowed to certify yourself. This is the bad catch 21 situation. Even if it was possible to ensure that data can't be modified on your computer, something like android protected storage, I guess most people would not like that because if you use open source it is to have control over your machine. So the only solution is the "cloud"/hosted solution by a provider, but again, if you use open source in the first place, probably it is because you don't want some external people to have control over your data.
- andrewflnr 4y agoOh, that's weird. I've never heard of anything like that in the US. In theory, a pretty simple scheme of publicly posted cryptographic hashes would prove to anyone you send the data to (presumably tax authorities? Auditors?) that you haven't altered data. Maybe periodically post a running hash of the list of transactions. Even if that works in theory, I'm guessing it's hell to get it actually certified.
- ValentineC 4y agoI'm a huge fan of Manager.io [1], which is free for single-user desktop use. They make money from their cloud plan and from a self-hosted server licence. It's not open source, but I can export practically everything as CSV or TSV, so there's data portability. [1] https://www.manager.io/ https://www.manager.io/
- 2Gkashmiri 4y agolook at https://gitlab.com/gnukhata/gkapp/-/issues https://gitlab.com/gnukhata/gkapp/-/issues this is a AGPL V3.0 licensed accounting software aimed at small businesses and schools and professionals. Its currently being developed for indian market because devs are all based out of india so if anyone wants to implement for their own country, please submit a PR. we need more accounting softwares that are free and open source
- ralphc 4y agoMy CPA wife sets up and recommends Quickbooks Desktop installed on Right Networks, a Windows Remote Desktop shop where Quickbooks and Excel is installed. The convenience of remote work without the awful Quickbooks Online. It handles backups and you do file transfers and local printing. It doesn't stop the Quickbooks subscription pricing but you get to use Quickbooks Desktop.
- freedomben 4y agoAs a linux user and free software advocate, I die inside at your CPA wife's recommendation, but I upvote it for it's pragmatism and applicability to so many people who don't have time or desire to screw around with software. Thank you to her and you for sharing this advice.
- jimnotgym 4y agoThis article has some real problems. Here is one. > Such systems are unwieldy to work with and difficult to get started with. In truth, many of them appear to have been developed as platforms for consulting businesses, though surely nobody would deliberately make their software complex and tricky just to motivate clients to purchase their services. Or perhaps some businesses have complications to deal with that go beyond what a newsletter website needs? Some businesses have inventory, subsidiaries, multiple currencies, have to report sales tax in multiple countries with ever changing requirements (hence the support and updates that this writer doesn't think are required). Some companies have local statutory books that are different than their group books. Really it is a bit like learning 'echo "hello"' and calling oneself a programmer. Then maybe one might ask why are lwn making Linux so complicated...
- Nevermark 4y ago> Or perhaps some businesses have complications to deal with that go beyond what a newsletter website needs? So ... perhaps there should be a version of Quickbooks that serves the simpler needs of smaller customers better? Like: Simple. Desktop. Requires no upgrades as long as its functionality at-time-of-purchase continues to serve well. No forcing of upgrades via dropping of old formats, etc. I also have given up on Quickbooks.
- jimnotgym 4y agoImagine you were relying on Quickbooks, and a major taxation change, like the European VAT OneStopShop came out. How would you deal with that without updates? What about the UKs Making Tax Digital, that would be tricky too. That wasn't the point I was discussing, but there is an answer anyway.
- Nevermark 4y agoCertainly charging for upgrades with useful new and critical functionality is reasonable. But reasonableness would also price even critical functionality relative to how hard it was to actually implement. I.e. don't hold hostage a customers' investments in a software product. Don't force customers to pay a ransom to get a simple-to-implement feature.
- NoboruWataya 4y ago> Getting our QuickBooks data into GnuCash took a bit of scripting using the capable (if poorly documented) Python bindings. Another set of scripts has since been written to import data from the site and from our bank account. GnuCash has a reasonably capable import mechanism for the data formats exported by banks, complete with a Bayesian system to assign transactions to accounts, but a bit of scripting makes the process quicker yet. I assume the person who posted this to HN is not the article's author, but if the author happens to be reading, it would be very helpful to see these scripts. The difficulty of writing custom scripts for GnuCash data is one of its main limitations IMO.
- freedomben 4y agoSome of the scripts are available here: git://git.lwn.net/qb-escape.git But yes I heartily agree, those scripts would be immensely helpful even just as an example/reference for somebody writing their own.
- ThinkBeat 4y agoMore personal finance so only tangentially related but I thought Microsoft Money was as great program years and years ago. I wonder why MS killed it. Every now and again I look around for something similar.
- Noumenon72 4y agoThe Sunset edition of Microsoft Money works on Windows 11. It was perfect for personal finance. Didn't make you learn double-entry bookkeeping like GnuCash.
- ThinkBeat 4y agoMy aunt was an accountant (rip). She had one of those "not calculators" with a built-in printer. Not sure what they are properly called. Her "not calculator" was old, stained with cigarette smoke and coffee and she did not wish for a new one. I got paid a bit a few times to clean it up inside and out. The thing was a tank. (If it still exists, it should still work with a bit of care and attention.) She used some form of financial software running on a terminal. I think it was from an AS/400. She was an expert on both. Whatever key combinations were required to enter data on the terminal had become so ingrained that if you asked her how to do it, she would have to look at what her hands did. (weird). The UX on the terminal was shit if you had to learn it. (Since I got paid to do some data entry, I felt the pain). But if you got used to it, it was damn fast. No lag, no mouse pointing, and it stayed entirely consistent. A bit like VI I guess. As far as I know the system never crashed on her. The server did need care, but it would order it on its own. At some point they brought in Windows PCz and Lotus Symphony, I think. She hated that. She found it all slow, inconsistent and did not like the mouse one bit. The other way around though. When someone new was hired and we were in the age of Microsoft Windows, new people were horrified by the old terminal software. I still sometimes see people at warehouses or stores that use terminal driven software and some of them are just as fast. It is fun to see. The majority though hunt, scratch head, peck, hit whatever undo is, and try again. Should we make easy to use software or software as a tool for those who go through the effort to learn? I dont think any "windows/osx/linux/" screen UI accounting system would be as fast to use.
- MBCook 4y agoAdding machine, perhaps?
- csomar 4y agoCounter-intuitively, making terminal software is harder because you have to think hard about the UX. You have to design how the accountant (or the user) is going to use, you have to make shortcuts, you have to think about the progression, etc... This is not the case for what's happening on GUI-land where the "designers" just randomly put texts, buttons, buttons that look like text, input boxes, tables, etc... It's all there just click a few buttons to get there.
- dang 4y agoRelated ongoing thread: Plain Text Accounting - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36022005 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36022005 - May 2023 (31 comments)
- aetherspawn 4y agoXero isn’t free, but it’s a good alternative to QuickBooks if you need one. It has a neat feature called Hubdoc, which automatically scans, renames, sorts to folders and archives your invoices when you email them to a particular email address. The integration between Hubdoc and Office365 is clunky because for reasons I can’t fathom, they only support Dropbox and Google Drive for archiving, but we have a script that we run on our Synology NAS that copies the invoices from Google Drive to SharePoint (OneDrive). Nothing against GnuCash or open source, we use a lot of FOSS. But we’re in Australia and we switch banks all the time. Those compounding factors would mean that we’d spend a lot of time updating bank roll integration with GnuCash
- lancewiggs 4y agoIt’s transformed businesses and the business of accounting down under. Accountants are focused on helping the companies and tougher questions rather than bookkeeping. Most accounting work is automated and companies have constant control and understanding of their numbers. Not always - but far more often. It’s astonishing how slow the transition to online accounting is in the USA.
- slyrus 4y agoAny HN users out there with experience with Firefly III (https://github.com/firefly-iii/firefly-iii https://github.com/firefly-iii/firefly-iii)? Sounds interesting.
- charles_f 4y agoI really, really enjoy Beancount. I use it for personal finances, and also for the accounting of an association I'm a part of. The combination of a simple text format (that I version), extensible CLI-based querying and reporting tools, and free software makes it absolutely perfect to me.
- rushabh 4y agoWe have been working on a FOSS desktop based alternative to GNU Cash with a modern UI for the past couple of years: Frappe Books - https://frappebooks.com https://frappebooks.com - https://github.com/frappe/books https://github.com/frappe/books Do check it out!
- SV_BubbleTime 4y agoCan it do multiple simultaneous users?
- 18al 4y agoHey, Frappe Books developer here. Not as of now, but it is something that we will be adding in. There has been a lot of requests for multi user support.
- zeusk 4y agoThis looks pretty good! Hope you guys succeed.
- freedomben 4y agoReally neat! This looks like something that could be immensely helpful to me. I have very minor accounting needs but am on the verge of outgrowing the Spreadsheet method. May I ask how you fund development? What is your feeling on the future?
- rushabh 4y agoThanks! We fund the development via our other product - ERPNext. We have one full time engineer working on it. If end up using it, please give us feedback and help spread the word.
- porl 3y agoIs this basically the accounts section of ERPNext? If not, what is the difference? I'm considering ERPNext for a small home business I'm starting up, but accounts are something I've never really delved into much beyond a few attempts at personal budget tracking in the past.
- rwmj 4y agoAnnoying that the UK tax authority (HMRC) has made it impossible for open source projects to access their APIs: https://wiki.gnucash.org/wiki/GB/HMRC#MTD_APIs https://wiki.gnucash.org/wiki/GB/HMRC#MTD_APIs