10 ms·
> The included charging dock is also a speaker. I've gotta say, charging docks are a killer feature for me and I don't understand why Apple doesn't do the same
by crazygringo 4y ago
> The included charging dock is also a speaker.
I've gotta say, charging docks are a killer feature for me and I don't understand why Apple doesn't do the same.
There used to be the Logitech Base [1] that I still use with the previous-gen (9th) iPad, but the smart connector in the newest iPad (10th gen) is no longer compatible with it, as the angle of the edge changed.
It's been years since I plugged in my phone or AirPods -- I only wirelessly charge. The idea that we should still be plugging in tablets with Lightning or USB-C is bizarre to me. A charging dock is the way to go, and it's so unexpected to me that Google realizes this while Apple doesn't. It's actually the only reason I haven't upgraded my iPad.
[1] https://www.logitech.com/en-us/products/ipad-accessories/base-ipad-pro-stand.939-001454.html https://www.logitech.com/en-us/products/ipad-accessories/bas...
- ablyveiled 4y agoWireless charging kills batteries faster -- that's why I personally avoid it.
- itsyaboi 4y agoHow so?
- rubatuga 4y agoMostly the extra heat degrades the battery chemistry
- itsyaboi 4y agoPerhaps this is an issue with a particular charger? I've yet to notice my phone get warm when charging wirelessly.
- stevenhuang 4y agoThe best wireless chargers I'm aware of are the magsafe ones which align the coils using magnets, improving efficiency and reducing heat.
- pazimzadeh 4y agoCan you expand on this because I've noticed that my iPhone 13 mini's battery life has been quickly getting worse, and I use the magsafe charging a lot.
- radicaldreamer 4y agoIt's the heat generated with wireless charging which kills the battery, not the charging speed
- Gigachad 4y agoOpen the battery page in the settings and look at what % it has left. At 80% Apple suggests replacing it.
- bryanlarsen 4y agoWireless is usually a lot slower than plugging it in, so i suspect it'd be better on batteries rather than worse. But the best way to save your batteries is to not charge to 100%.
- LeifCarrotson 4y agoI wish there were standard software in Android and iOS to limit charge percentage and battery temperature during charging. It's ludicrous to me that the default behavior is plugging in your phone to a 30W ludicrously fast charger when you go to bed in the evening, where it then climbs to 100% charge and holds there while you sleep. I should be able to tell it I'd like it to reach 85% charge as of the time my alarm goes off in the morning, timing that in a way that minimizes battery heating. My laptop, likewise, should be able to sit at 85% when on the docking station, potentially even syncing with my calendar to know when I have to leave and might need more battery or a more rapid charge before a meeting.
- TexanFeller 4y ago> It's ludicrous to me that the default behavior is plugging in your phone to a 30W ludicrously fast charger when you go to bed in the evening, where it then climbs to 100% charge and holds there while you sleep. Apple already does something similar. It's not configurable beyond on/off but optimized battery charging on MBP, iPhone, and iWatch learns when you're normally awake and holds charging at ~80% overnight until a bit before your normal wakeup time. On MBP it holds at 80% most of the time during the day too if it learns you're rarely running on battery.
- deprecative 4y agoOn Android this is called Adaptive Charging and has been on my Pixels for several years at this point.
- richev 4y ago> ludicrously fast charger when you go to bed in the evening This is why I never charge overnight. Just pop the phone on to charge while I'm having a shower in the morning, or in the evening while I'm having dinner. Those time windows seem enough to keep my phone (Pixel 5) sufficiently charged. > My laptop, likewise, should be able to sit at 85% when on the docking station Samsung laptops have/had this exact feature, which they called Battery Life Plus[1] [1] https://web.archive.org/web/20140101070825/https://www.samsung.com/us/article/tips--tricks-extending-notebook-battery-life/ https://web.archive.org/web/20140101070825/https://www.samsu...
- RandomThrow321 4y agoDo you have a source? I thought this has been thoroughly debunked.
- stevenhuang 4y ago> thoroughly debunked. I wish people would stop using this phrase. Especially when they couldn't be more wrong. Heat degrades batteries, wireless charging generally comes with more heat from the lower efficiency. But at the end of the day it most likely won't matter as people get new phones every few years anyways.
- shawabawa3 4y agoThere are so many more factors than heat though For one, I thought charging slower was better, so could the increased heat be offset by that? Also, it's more heat per joule transferred, but over a longer period of time, is that not better than sudden heat from fast charging?
- stevenhuang 4y agoHeat is the primary factor, and even with fast charging the inefficiencies of wireless charging will mean the latter will dump more heat into your phone. The constant current phase of fast charging does not generate much heat in comparison at given wattage as it's able to charge up your phone much more quickly at higher efficiency until it switches to trickle charging at ~80%.
- illiac786 4y agoBut fast charging makes batteries very hot too. Btw, you basically just asked people to know when they are wrong. Seems very optimistic...
- stevenhuang 4y agoWhere did I say fast charging doesn't make batteries hot? I've built LiPo packs from scratch and rebalanced cells manually, I know something about LiPo degradation.
- hammyhavoc 4y agoPage 1 of Google seems to suggest the contrary. Source?
- atherton33 4y agoThe dock seems to be magsafe style contacts not wireless
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- MBCook 4y agoThis isn’t wireless, it’s basically pogo pins. It’s magnetically aligned/held, but that’s all.
- RandomThrow321 4y agoI'm not going to get a Pixel Tablet, but I really do like the idea of a charging dock speaker.
- koinedad 4y agoI like the dock idea as well
- wccrawford 4y agoCouldn't you just get a Nest Mini and 3d Print a cover for it with a charging connector built-in? I know the existing tablets on the market don't lend themselves to being docked, but my point is what if you want a speaker and a tablet and a dock, and the speaker should work when the tablet isn't docked, it's actually just 2 devices jammed together.
- mindvirus 4y agoThe charging dock is cool, but feels like a missed opportunity to have it be a regular Google Home speaker when the tablet is undocked.
- ehsankia 4y ago> undocked You mean docked? And is it not? I thought it basically acts like a Nest Hub Max [0] when docked? [0] https://store.google.com/ca/product/google_nest_hub_max https://store.google.com/ca/product/google_nest_hub_max
- MH15 4y agoI believe they did mean "undocked" so if the tablet is in the other room the dock could operate as a Google Home independently.
- ehsankia 4y agoOh I see, so just the dock being a speaker by itself. Interesting. Yeah not sure if it has any real processing in it, or if it's purely driven by the tablet itself when connected.
- outofpaper 4y agoIt's a missed opertunity to add a teeny bit of compute to it. This dock is essentially the same as what Lenovo released a couple years back only that was also a bluetooth speaker.
- numpad0 4y agoIt’s just my impression, but, to me we humans seem to instinctively avoid retuning a tool to where it have been found, likely to avoid allowing adversaries inspect it. We however tend to build a routine, and leaving objects to a key tray is okay so long the actions to pick up and returning mentally differs. What I’m saying is, I personally like the idea of cradles, but I seem to be a minority. Cables seem to be a more generally preferred solution.
- madeofpalk 4y agoApple has been rumoured to develop a HomePod/iPad dock thing for a while. I hope it happens (but not like this terrible mockup) https://www.macrumors.com/2022/10/15/apple-ipad-dock-smart-home-display/ https://www.macrumors.com/2022/10/15/apple-ipad-dock-smart-h...
- vineyardmike 4y agoWhen I recently worked at <big consumer tech> we did “market research” and we basically came to the conclusion that apple is probably waiting to see reactions to pixel tablet dock to decide if it should be an iPad first or HomePod first.
- Freedom2 4y agoWhat's interesting is that even when Apple follows a design or trend, their fans can often claim that Apple innovates it at the same time. For example, Android has had wireless charging and USB-C ages before Apple, but when Apple started to use them, their fans said something along the lines of 'Apple refined and innovated on the prototype concept, and are first to deliver a working, solid product', despite the Android ones working... fine? I wonder if we'll see the same with these docks.
- seanmcdirmid 4y agoApple still isn’t using USB-C for phone charging. How good are the MagSafe equivalents in android land?
- chefandy 4y agoI'm not currently in the apple ecosystem at all, but am a long-time apple product user and have been on a first-name basis with hundreds of iPhone users since they came out. 100% of the awful statements and stances towards the android ecosystem or any of its constituents I've seen attributed to "apple fans" have come from people mad at apple and apple users. Zero percent– really— have I heard from actual Apple users. One of the big selling points of iPhones is that if you have a phone released within 3 or 4 years, you don't have to think about the capabilities of your phone. At all. I'm not saying they're objectively better, it's just geared towards users who want their phone to get out of the way and do it's thing, and that's fine. If there's a trove of apple users somewhere that have strong opinions about Android phones, I've never encountered them. I'll never understand why some people get so wrapped around the axle about phones.
- pphysch 4y agoIt's quite fascinating. Apple ships their tablet with a stylus, while Google ships theirs with a charger-speaker-dock. Apple is saying "this is for the creatives" while Google is saying "this is a home console".
- plexicle 4y ago"Apple ships their tablet with a stylus" Huh?
- pphysch 4y agoYikes, I was under the impression that it was included in the $449. Nope, gotta drop another $100. My point stands: Apple has pen as primary accessory, Google has dock.
- NikolaNovak 4y agoI mean, Galaxy Note has a pen but iPhone does not. Does that mean Samsung is for creatives but Apple is not? :-> Don't get me wrong, I enjoyed your theory, the thinking and rationale :). But given the pen is a whopping 100$ for Apple, not sure if it's as simple as that.
- vineyardmike 4y agoApple made or tried to make the operating system useful enough to use productively with a stylus and keyboard. Google has not yet. Remember the original iPad was very much NOT a keyboard/stylus device. Google is a few years behind, but fwiw their device supports Bluetooth keyboards and styluses they just don’t make a first party one.
- adolph 4y agoApple used to know how to do this: The Apple Macintosh PowerBook Duo Dock turns a PowerBook Duo into a full-featured desktop Macintosh including a 1.44 MB floppy disk drive, a complete set of desktop ports, and NuBus slots as well as the options of a secondary 230 MB hard drive and a 68882 FPU to improve performance. The Duo Dock is compatible with all of the grayscale PowerBook Duos (210, 230, 250, 280), but can also support the color Duos (270c, 280c, 2300c/100) with a replacement lid. https://everymac.com/systems/apple/powerbook_duo/specs/mac_powerbook_duodock.html https://everymac.com/systems/apple/powerbook_duo/specs/mac_p...
- cheq 4y agocharging docks are cool, but they're a little inconvenient for traveling and portable needs
- sokac 4y agoIt can be charged via usb-c. > Can the Pixel Tablet charge with a regular USB-C® cord? > Yes, in addition to charging your Pixel Tablet with the Charging Speaker Dock, you will also be able to charge your Pixel Tablet with a USB-C® cord.1
- LegitShady 4y agoI keep my ipad pro 2018 12.9" in a logitech slim folio that gives me the same standing position and all I need to do is plug in a usb-c to the ipad. The audio on the ipad pro is great, no need for another speaker in a dock. And along with a mouse it makes it an almost functional microsoft office experience, and folds down for drawing in procreate. The case just looks nicer. the keyboard case is more functional for me. https://www.logitech.com/en-ca/products/ipad-keyboards/slim-folio-ipad-keyboard-case.html https://www.logitech.com/en-ca/products/ipad-keyboards/slim-...
- rendaw 4y agoAre charging docks not a way to avoid EU regulations around standardizing/unbundling charging cables?
- blackoil 4y agoCharging Dock is one option you can charge using USB-C also.
- shawabawa3 4y agoYou have to include USB-C charging but that doesn't mean you can't use other charging methods (like the new Macbooks that have magsafe and USB-C)
- usernew 4y agohere's the thing with wireless charing - and this may not apply to your use case. when you're plugged in, you're running on the cable. my laptop for example, which I set to charge to 80% and stop, is pretty much always plugged in unless I'm carrying it between rooms. my phone - an android phone - has always been plugged in to charge. the battery acts as a surge protector. now what happens when you wireless charge. your device is running on your battery, 24/7, charging and discharging while you sleep. Here I am with a phone that's over 10 years old, flashed with the latest android, that I use for email and sites like this or youtube about 3 hours per day, and infrequent navigation. maybe an hour of call time, about 5 hours of screen time per day. over a decade later, my battery lasts several days w/o a charge. my wife is probably more like you and I get her a new iphone every 3 years. she wireless charges - always. her battery life after 3 years of this, is absolute crap, because mine is discharging 5 hours/day, and hers is discharging 24 hours per day. what is bizarre is when people think plugging a cable into a reversible port is some kind of a task or inconvenience compared to placing it aligned on a round circle. please share your thought about the insurmountable inconvenience of having to press the pump on the soap dispenser instead, or having to turn the knob on a door.
- modzu 4y agowires are a mess.
- wittekm 4y agoI do wonder if something like the MagSafe (laptop) adaptor would strike a happy medium. Also - I don't know if Apple's 15w Qi is strong enough for a tablet.
- predakanga 4y agoYou make a good point - there are loads of third-party magnetic charging cables out there, but I never saw the point when I have a wireless charger. I might have to give the cables a try next time I replace my battery, see how it affects longevity.
- kalleboo 4y ago
- makeitdouble 4y agoApple isn't good at charging. There's a lot of aspect they excel, graphic design, ergonomics, material etc. Charging has never been their forte. I present as evidence: - the original humongous 31 pin ipod cable - the harpooned mouse - the wireless charging mat they never could deliver - the first Apple pencil (and its usb-c charging cable...) - their previous gen desktop keyboards charging over lightning Their only great charging idea was probably magsafe for laptops.
- nobrains 4y agoAnd (from greats), iphone magsafe wireless magnetic charging.
- alpaca128 4y ago- the iPhone battery case with the battery bump on the back
- qup 4y agoIf I recall this was like eighty bucks and guaranteed to break your charging port within ten days.
- bryanrasmussen 4y ago>Apple isn't good at charging. They're pretty good at changing how you charge every few years and charging you for that change though.
- SiempreViernes 4y agoI'd reword that as: Can't agree: Cupertino constantly changes charging copling and consequently can charge for that change.
- bryanrasmussen 4y agoI think mine was more nicely balanced, but I suppose the increase in alliteration may be worth it.
- pmontra 4y agoWhat's great with charging docks? I charge with several chargers hanging from sockets all around the house. If I had only a charging dock I would have either to carry it were I need to charge my tablet while I'm using it or move myself to the dock.
- simonh 4y agoI agree the dock as the only way to charge seems daft, but I suppose they expect everyone to have a USB-C charging cable for their phone already, and use that on the go. Most Android phone owners will, and I suppose this is aimed at them.
- prmoustache 4y agoBoth aren't mutually exclusive. "Charging via Charging Speaker Dock (included) or USB-C® charger (sold separately)"
- crazygringo 4y agoBecause I only charge at night since a single charge gets me through the day. And it's just so much easier to set a tablet down to charge than to grab the cord when it fell down the back of the desk/table/whatever, and then find exactly where the tiny charging port in the middle of a long edge is. Or just to lift up rather than carefully unplugging first, and leaving a messy cable behind that's easy to knock off of its surface (or build a system to carefully clip it somewhere). And a dock isn't taking away the port. It's just a nice option.
- mkraft 4y agoSomeone needs to figure out medium range charging and sell a unit to every home, coffee shop, airport, airplane, etc. Let us never be powerless or tethered or docked again!
- HlessClaudesman 4y agoSome smartass engineer should have sold Tim Cook on the docks by rebranding them as dongles. Then Apple would have put out ten different coloured dongle-docks for each new device. Related: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-XSC_UG5_kU https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-XSC_UG5_kU
- 7speter 4y agoDidnt the first ipods come with charging docs?
- hackernewds 4y agoI would like to use my tablet while it is charging. This seems like a very basic requisite?
- AdmiralAsshat 4y agoThe HP Touchpad had an awesome wireless charging stand all the way back in 2011.[0] What I especially liked about it is that WebOS (before I blew it away and loaded Android onto the tablet) could switch to a slideshow mode when it was left on the stand, and so your Touchpad could serve as a digital picture frame while not in use. [0] https://www.phonearena.com/news/HP-TouchPad-Touchstone-Charging-Dock-demonstration_id20014 https://www.phonearena.com/news/HP-TouchPad-Touchstone-Charg...
- 5555624 4y agoOr you could set it up to show the clock when not in use, which was what I did. (I still like to be able to glance at a clock.) I have yet to install Android on it; so, maybe I'll do that this weekend.