14 ms·
Running a movie theater is more expensive than you can possibly imagine
- prepend 4y agoTheaters are in a bad spot and I think they are doomed as an industry unless as boutique specialty theaters like LA’s New Beverly [0] as I don’t think the experience is worth the cost. My favorite local theater was $6 for a Sunday morning showing ($11 for regular). It was probably 50 years old and I think everything in it was maybe as recent as the 80s or 90s. The staff were super friendly and seemed to love movies. While only 3-6 for a 10 theater cinema they would bake their own cookies and brownies and dress up in homemade costumes. A mix of teenagers and 50+ people. They recently “upgraded” and now tickets are $10.50 ($21 for a regular ticket). The upgrade means the theaters now have fake leather power recliners that are actually less comfortable. I go see fewer movies now. And I can’t help but wonder “what bank loaned them this money, they’re never getting it back.” I don’t think movie tickets for $20 can compete with concerts ($20-infinity), major league sports ($15-200), plays, and other activities. To take my family to the movies is now $200 after tickets and popcorn and I can go to a major league soccer game for the same amount that includes parking, tickets, hot dogs, and beer. As long as I don’t want to see a specific game. I used to see 3-5 movies a month, now I see 3-5 per year. I’m happy having a similar experience at home via streaming (worse picture, no community, but much more convenient). I feel for the theater owners and employees as I’m sure it’s expensive. But it’s expensive to run a blacksmith and it’s expensive to telephone switchboard. It’s not that those things don’t produce value, they do. It’s that their value comes nowhere near their cost when compared to substitutes. [0] https://thenewbev.com/ https://thenewbev.com/
- bko 4y agoI think you're a little off on the alternative ticket pricing. I just checked New York red bulls and two tickets all in start at $74. Not including parking and getting there. Similarly when I looked at concert tickets they are never $15. Movies are also located in metro areas so easier to get to, are more flexible with times and showing and overall a more comfortable experience especially with a family. I think $20 per person for an afternoon is still competitive as a leisure activity. https://www.ticketmaster.com/event/00005E389E6B454C?brand=nyredbulls&wt.mc_id=MLS_TEAM_NYRB_SINGLE_GAME_TICKETS_PAGE_GAME6&CAMEFROM=CFC_NYREDBULLS_WEB_SINGLES_23GM06&_ga=2.249593605.283251250.1683720955-2126193457.1683720955#offer-card https://www.ticketmaster.com/event/00005E389E6B454C?brand=ny...
- cjrp 4y agoBut maybe theatres are actually competing with Disney+/Netflix at what.. $11-15/month?
- local_crmdgeon 4y agoI see this take a lot and disagree. I don't go to a theater in lieu of Netflix, I go on dates, with friends etc. It's more competitive with bars.
- cjrp 4y agoI thought I saw somewhere that bars were having a similar problem, with Gen Z choosing to drink/socialise at home rather than go to bars, restaurants, etc.
- bacchusracine 4y ago>with Gen Z choosing to drink/socialise at home Not just Gen Z. Why should I go to a bar and pay almost double a bottle what it costs me for a decent beer when I and a friend can pick up a twelve pack for what it would cost us to have two beers apiece elsewhere? Why should I pay outrageous prices for a steak when between the two of us we can smoke a brisket and have enough to share with others or leftovers for another meal? And doing so I know I can get excellent service from someone happy to be there? People forget that these are hospitality industries. They're all about service. You should be able to go there and feel happy you came. Instead most of these places make you feel like a bother and then despite a decent tip on the table you still get hit up for more money at the register. I try to be polite, friendly and tip well. I expect decent service when I go out and increasingly do not get it. So why should I go out when for a bit more effort I and my friends can do it ourselves and share for either less or the same cost, but a better experience?
- conductr 4y agoInflation which is a new concept for myself in my mid-40s is playing a large part. We're not fully mentally adjusted to inflation and "value" these services less. Or perhaps we still mentally "value" them in 2019 dollars. Meanwhile, service workers have to live in the present and care about 2023 dollars. I know I still get a little sticker shock just seeing menu prices now, I can't say honestly that I'm tipping the same because of it. It's what I have control over. Or, I can just avoid the place altogether which is what many people choose to do. I haven't fully done that yet, I've scaled back a little but mostly just natural consequence of having young children (we eat in more now). Obviously, it doesn't help that tipping culture is absolute hell these days. I feel like I'm being gouged everywhere I go. For every single interaction. And, it's done in a way that's before the service where I feel like it's mandatory or my service will suffer if I don't go along with it. It's awful and I'm choosing more an more to boycott the tip line almost everywhere (seated meal being an exception).
- JKCalhoun 4y agoTheaters as we knew them do appear to be dead. I don't think I've gone to see a movie since Covid and when I drive past theaters I don't see a lot of cars in the parking lots. I don't think there's been anything showing though that I've wanted to see in a long time. Hollywood gets the blame for that. Cost to see a movie is also a big issue. It feels like the small theaters though are making a come back. I see plenty of "art house" theaters in Kansas City ... even a drive-in or two are appearing. These surely don't require the high-end playback equipment and tend to, IMHO, show better and more varied content.
- HeyLaughingBoy 4y agoMy kid said he wanted to see the Mario Bros movie the day before it stopped playing here. We were the only ones in the theater! How do they stay in business??? I will say that it was nice that they brought the food to our seats so we didn't have to wait around.
- slavik81 4y agoThe Mario Bros movie is nominally the 24th highest grossing film of all time. Your experience may not have been representative.
- toast0 4y agoIt's also been out for a month, and they went to it on the last day it was playing (at their particular theater), which is usually going to be a wednesday or thursday. Cinema attendance is pretty low mid week. At my local cinema, I have a 75% chance of a private showing if I go to a wednesday showing in the first week; but a larger nearby chain has more screens and larger attendence. I try to go to the local one if I go, because I would like it to stay in business, but they don't carry all the movies. And I just put in a home theater, so it's nice to use that when I can.
- HeyLaughingBoy 4y agoOh, I fully expected attendance to be low at 4:30PM on a Wednesday. What I didn't expect was to be the only two people watching it.
- beezlebroxxxxxx 4y ago> I don’t think movie tickets for $20 can compete with concerts ($20-infinity), major league sports ($15-200), plays, and other activities. Compared to those other things, sure. But if you consider that a lot of people go out to eat once a week and regularly spend far more than $20, then that $20 price tag is not so crazy. Part of the problem has been that a lot of movies released lately barely feel worth paying that much to see. The movies are just mediocre. When I see a good movie, though, I don't even think about how much it cost me to see it. (Also, seeing a major league sports game for $15 is incredible. In my market, even at $20 movies are usually way cheaper than tickets to a sports game.)
- prepend 4y ago> But if you consider that a lot of people go out to eat once a week and regularly spend far more than $20, then that $20 price tag is not so crazy. It’s not that $20 is a crazy amount of money. It’s that it is crazy for what you get. I think restaurants would be in a tough spot too if you could get unlimited McDonalds spit out from a box in your kitchen for $18/month. People would still eat out, but much less given the substitutes. My MLB team regularly does $15 nosebleed tickets. My MLS team does $25 nosebleed tickets a few times a seasons and the food is much cheaper. But it’s also super easy to pay $100/ticket. With movies, everyone pays the same price. I don’t think movies are worse as I went to the movies pretty consistently over the past 30 years and there were ups and downs. The price of movie tickets has kept up with inflation for the most part, just doubling in the past 25 years [0] so I think it’s just that the price of digital goods has dropped so much (mp3 in 2000 was $1, still $1 today) because the price of bits gets cheaper. And this is bad for physical goods with clear substitutes. Interestingly, movie theaters should have benefits from digitalization as digital projectors are much cheaper as film costs a lot to produce and distribute and projectionists used to be the highest paid employee. [0] https://247wallst.com/media/2021/03/29/this-is-the-price-of-a-movie-ticket-in-the-past-25-years/ https://247wallst.com/media/2021/03/29/this-is-the-price-of-...
- bandrami 4y ago> With movies, everyone pays the same price. It doesn't have to be that way; in a lot of Asia your ticket is for a specific seat and is priced based on that (both the view and the amenities e.g. the more expensive ones have a full table and table service for the food).
- ip26 4y ago$200 to go to the theater when tickets are $10? Just how many people are in your family?
- chii 4y agothe popcorn is probably 50% of it, for a family of 10.
- pc86 4y agoNot the GP but tickets are $10 for matinees. They can easily be $18-22 for primetime shows. So if you're a family of 4 you're paying $80-90 for the tickets, everyone gets drinks, popcorn, maybe a snack or two. It's easy to see it push $45-50 per person pretty quickly with kids.
- Fargren 4y agoI know there are lots of people who do it, but I can't wrap my head about why any normal person pays for drinks and food at the cinema. It might not be the biggest ripoff I can think of, but it's probably the most blatant one. The markups are huge, for items everyone knows the cost of.
- jsbg 4y ago> I know there are lots of people who do it, but I can't wrap my head about why any normal person pays for drinks and food at the cinema. What's the alternative?
- Fargren 4y agoWatch a movie without food or drinks is what I did most of my life. Same with almost everyone I know, I don't feel like this is a weird choice to make. Where I live now it's illegal for cinemas to stop you from bringing food in, so I occasionally might bring my own snack, but that might be like one out ten times. Mostly just watch the movie and eat before or after. (Spain if you want to know)
- Zababa 4y ago> I don’t think movie tickets for $20 can compete with concerts ($20-infinity), major league sports ($15-200), plays, and other activities. They don't always have to compete. I rarely go see concerts, and I never go see sports, plays, or anything else really. But I go see movies from time to time. In that case there is no competition, at least not in similar activities.
- JohnFen 4y agoI agree. I love live theater the most, and see it frequently. I don't see movies that often. But if all live theater ceased to exist, I doubt that I'd see movies more often. The two things are very, very different and can't substitute for each other.
- jollyllama 4y agoI like hearing about your pre-"upgrade" local theater. We had one like that around here even eight years ago that did second-run screenings in addition to loads of foreign films or rescreenings of films from decades ago. Great experience, super cheap. Unfortunately there was basically a hostile takeover of it by a guy who bought into the big seat vision.
- WorldMaker 4y agoA common alternative to the "upgraded" is the sad "closed". My city lost its well-loved second run theater of several decades somewhat recently. At least in our case we're somewhat lucky that the owners of that continue to invest in our only non-chain first run theater, and while it has some of the "big seat" upgrades it still tries to do some of the foreign films and indies and big "midnight" rescreenings of classics. (And is still cheaper than the big box, big chain options.)
- bachmeier 4y agoThese days TVs with large screens are everywhere. When 32" was considered a big TV, theaters delivered a different experience. I've stopped going to theaters because the cost/benefit analysis doesn't work out. I've got a long list of entertainment subscriptions that need to be paid each month, and honestly because today's movies aren't even worth a $5 ticket price. It feels as though they're too focused on technology and not enough on having a good story.
- ccozan 4y agoMy own experience as well. After buying a 65" OLED LG , adding a good 5.1 System, and having Netflix, Disney+, Prime streaming in 4K , Dolby Vision, etc , I honestly do not need a cinema. I would gladly wait for the streaming variant to appear. COVID certainly accelerated this transition.
- nemo44x 4y agoIndeed, but for certain movies, at a good cinema, it's still worth it IMO. Top Gun: Maverick is a movie I've seen at home and in the theatre. The theatre experience was superior I felt. That movie is probably suited to the experience but I really enjoyed the open atmosphere and distance from the huge screen and the room that audio had to work with. But yeah, for most things a sweet system (which is very attainable for most people today) is often fine.
- conductr 4y ago> I used to see 3-5 movies a month, now I see 3-5 per year Same. Except it has nothing to do with theaters and everything to do with Hollywood and what's being released. The question becomes if Hollywood went back to the "old model", the model that saw less franchises and more comedy/drama/etc releases. Would it put butts in seats at the theater? Or has the latest generation/tv-tech obsoleted or diluted the experience thus shrinking the market going forward? (eg. like ecommerce did to shopping malls) Hard to know, but I do miss good unique movies.
- ihateyouall123 4y agoCompletely wrong.
- quibono 4y agoWhich part of the comment is completely wrong? Unless you mean all of the points raised.
- tomjen3 4y agoI can't justify paying more than a month of streaming for a specific movie that I have to share with people and where I can't put in a pee break. Cinema just do not make sense unless you are a total fan of a given franchise. I wanted to see the new Top Gun, but I just waited until I could buy it digitally. I can't wait until it becomes illegal to prioritize theaters - even if I have to pay the same for the ticket, the popcorn is a lot cheaper. That might make me watch more movies, but then again who knows.
- MagicMoonlight 4y agoWith concerts and live events, having people there is part of the experience. And it’s happening live. With movies you’re just watching TV in the dark. Except the room is full of chavs and you have to pay £20 to watch an hour of unskippable ads.
- vuln 4y agoIn my area 3 movie tickets a large popcorn and a large drink will run you ~100$.
- CoastalCoder 4y agoMind saying where that is? I live in New England, and I think that would cost about $50-60 at our local theater.
- ubermonkey 4y agoWe went to see GUARIDANS 3 last night. Tickets for the upgraded theater screening were $41 for 2 people. One small popcorn, a bottle of water, and one box of candy were another $25. I can see hitting a hundo reasonably easily here (Houston).
- TheFattestNinja 4y agoThere is a very good question about price perception there. What should be the "right" price for a cinema experience? If you start from first principles and you compute it as "2.5 hours of entertainment in a climate controlled and comfortable environment with refreshments", it doesn't feel unreasonable to put it at 30$ (per person): that's in line with how much other comparable activities will set you back (escape rooms, paintball, whatever). If you go from "the price has increased too much since I used to go there as a child/teen" then you are going to say that's way too much. Some (most?) movies do feel better in a cinema than at home (at least to me). And this is without considering 3d, immersive sound/vibration or anything, just "vanilla" cinema. "Everything, everywhere, all at once" doesn't have the same ooomph on my tv. I don't see them dying but they are endangered and niche. Bit like theatre.
- George83728 4y ago> If you start from first principles and you compute it as "2.5 hours of entertainment in a climate controlled and comfortable environment with refreshments", it doesn't feel unreasonable to put it at 30$ (per person): that's in line with how much other comparable activities will set you back (escape rooms, paintball, whatever). When I was a kid, my family didn't have AC so on hot summer days my mother would take us to a bookstore. Free AC and entertainment for hours, plus a few dollars for lunch (not in the bookstore, but nearby) and a few dollars more for the books we'd inevitably buy at the end of the day. These days, bookstores are mostly gone but public libraries have AC now so it's gotten even cheaper.
- ballenf 4y agoI don't know if there's enough people out there like me, but I'd love a smaller theater with traditional seats and decent sound if it was at a reasonable price. After searching out the best and biggest screens and audio, I've slowly realized that stuff doesn't affect my enjoyment that much. What does affect my enjoyment is the bill for bringing a small family making me limit the affair to once or twice a year. There are a handful of these discount theaters around and they seem to be popular, but for me require a much longer drive. Seems like an intractable problem. Because if they followed my advice, maybe they'd lose the crowd of people who have expensive setups at home. I'm not so sure they get much revenue from that crowd anyway, however. Presumably they know their customers better than I do.
- fauxpause_ 4y agoThere are not enough people like you. Like 5% of movie theater seats get sold. The only way to be profitable is to be able to sell out the popular films.
- ljf 4y agoI have to really work to get my kids to want to go to the cinema - they aren't (yet) wow'd by a movie being out 'sooner' than we can see it on netflix or similar, and the experience for them is just better at home. I love a great cinema trip, but we barely go once as year, as our at home set up scratches the itch. --- I have a purely 'ok' set up at home - more involved than some peoples, but nothing fancy: In my living room I have a 120" diagonal screen (£30 from amazon) that we manually pull down the 12 to 24 times a year we use it. I have a schools short throw hd projector that was £70 delivered from ebay and then a set of £15 (2nd hand) pc speakers that are a sub and 2 speakers - all running off a 1st gen chromecast. In my shed I have a marginally better set up of a mechanised screen (£70), then a more recent chromecast running to an hdmi splitter with optical audio out, which goes into a year 2007 5.1 sony amp (£30), with another schools projector (£130) - this set up came to about £250 all in. If you have the room to keep the bits, I highly recommend a similar cheap set up - you can obviously spend loads more, but our cheapo living room set up does us proud and the audio is more than good enough for kids films. Means we enjoy loads of films as a family.
- dbspin 4y agoI wonder what the economics are of the boutique theatres in places like Portland and Berlin. Berlin seems to have several dozen independent cinemas - all radically different (although many are part of the York Kino group). These go all the way from tiny neighbourhood (kiez) cinemas that are a few couches arranged around a 10 foot screen, to enormous screens in iconic buildings. There are also Summer Kinos, giant semi-permanent outdoor screens that show films in woodland and urban settings within the city. It's an incredible part of Berlin life. Oh and they all serve wine, beer and radler, plus usually a variety of branded sweets. Ticket prices are usually under 10 euro too. There are of course lots of multi-plex type cinemas in Berlin too, and they're just as trashy as those in the rest of Europe and the US. But they seem comparatively less popular.
- bombcar 4y agoIf the theater owns the building they can survive bot very little. If they rent, they will get squeezed quite hard.
- Scoundreller 4y agoDepends. I can imagine the zoning in some parts of Europe being “this property is zoned as a theatre and can only be used as such” and that will drive down rent.
- bombcar 4y agoYeah, and "vintage" theaters can get away with a lot less "bells and whistles" like digital projection and other things the article is talking about.
- dbspin 4y agoAbsolutely, they're positively the opposite of the experience described in the article. Much more chill, casual destination. I enjoy a good 3D, seat shaking multiplex experience perhaps once a year. But the casual drop into to sit on a couch with a beer and some fancy candy Berlin cinema experience is something I indulged in weekly when I lived there.
- Maxburn 4y agoThe very last times I went to a theater were to the "premium" theaters with big reclining seats but not even that was enough to get me back. I haven't been to a theater in probably fifteen years and I have no desire to. It's really about the inconvenience of making a trip somewhere at a specific time. Then you have to deal with all the other people, bathroom lines, blocking your view or just talking over the whole thing. For middle class it's not really a lot of money for a decent player, stereo, and TV especially when you realize they last over a decade easy. My speakers and stereo are probably 12 years old (but still THX, TrueHD, DTSHD-MA), and I have one of the last plasma TV's made so about 9 years old. Sure it's "only" 1080p. I think with apple goggles or whatever they have coming the equipment expense is about to go way down clearing this expense for the masses. Then there's just the convenience of seeing what you want when you want. Need to pee or make a snack, just pause it. Falling asleep, just stop it and finish it tomorrow.
- 404mm 4y agoLast time I went to a theatre, I bought tickets for specific seats. When my wife and I arrived, we discovered elderly couple occupying our seats and leaving us with worse options. I tried to explain to them that we paid for those and they just “played dumb”. It also became obvious that the man was down with some cold. We ended up leaving before the movie started.
- Maxburn 4y agoHope you got a refund, and if they did it's interesting they would refund rather than fix the seating issue.
- 404mm 4y agoYah, I was really pissed. I got a refund and yes, it was their preference too. Tbh, at that point it was my preference as well. Had they moved the elderly couple we would be still sitting next to someone clearly sick. No 2hr movie is worth spending a week with cold (ymmv lol)
- CPLX 4y agoSurprised they don’t mention the new model of reserved seating and table service with a full menu and bar options. That’s pretty much become the standard here in NYC and it’s reasonably popular.
- ubermonkey 4y agoIn Houston, table service and full menus are available at the iPic theaters, but the screen and sound are not as nice as the "regular" theater.
- FearNotDaniel 4y ago> Today, those fees have expired and the original digital projectors are out of date or failing outright, servers are crashing, and each service call demands a highly paid IT technician — presuming you can find one at all. So, all those promises from 20 years ago about how it will be so much cheaper to run a cinema on digital tech, no more duplicating and distributing physical film prints, no more calling out expensive maintenance staff to repair projectors with all those fiddly moving parts... plus ca change, as Jean-Luc Godard might have said. I guess in part this is connected to a broader symptom all HNers will recognize, that we live in a society that generally thinks software is free or cheap to produce, and computer-based thingies, once installed, never need any maintenance or upgrading...
- Finnucane 4y agoCheaper for the studio, not for the theater. The studio cut their film distribution costs and outsourced the rest.
- rob74 4y agoOne fact that still remains (and the article suspiciously doesn't mention) is that there's still less manual work involved with digital projection: no loading/unloading/changing film reels, which means reduced personnel costs.
- OJFord 4y agoA bit less, but you'd be surprised how much is similar. The films are delivered on physical drives, loaded and unloaded, sent back. There's keying in timings with lights & curtains & music etc., there's checking it actually worked (because yes you're right, there isn't a projectionist sitting there the entire time). If all goes to plan it definitely is less, I suppose it's roughly the same work for 1 showing, but almost nothing for the rest. But not nothing, and obviously it does go wrong sometimes.
- steveBK123 4y agoDigital photography kind of was like this. The operational costs (film, development) were eliminated but the capital cost (cameras) were 5x higher and needed updating more often. A serious amateur could shoot the same film body for a decade, or even a life, with maybe some regular maintenance (fairly repairable right up through cameras made in 80s and even 90s). Maybe they had a manual focus body, then an autofocus body, and.. that was about it. The camera you were using was probably re-sellable at a decent price because the production life of any given model could run up to a decade. With digital, the leaps & bounds being made in tech caused camera purchases to be much more frequent. Say every 2 years in 2000s, every 3-4 years in 2010s, and every 4-5 years in 2020s, as the rate of change did eventually slow. Regardless, the camera body also became practically disposable, basically a write-off if damaged, and resale value plummeted due to the rate of advancement. As it worked out, if you were a heavy shooter, maybe the operational cost going to $0 actually netted you out on the equipment spend. Most light hobbyists and general vacations/weddings/birthdays sharpshooter ended up spending far more in the digital era. This lasted right up until iPhones became good enough, even indoors poorly lit, that most normies don't own a single camera (5~10 years back). Camera makers have adjusted to this new world by moving up-market, with less frequent releases, but at higher and higher price points. They understand that their main market now is hobbyists, and the decision to spend $$ vs 0 to enter the hobby is a bigger decision than spending $3k or $1.5k on a body.
- cocacola1 4y agoRegal has a subscription, so I pay around $24 a month and get to see as many movies as I want. Considering their regular ticket price is like $15-$19 online, it pretty much pays for itself in a couple of trips. Certainly makes buying concessions easier on the wallet.
- PaywallBuster 4y agoSeen the same in Netherlands
- treis 4y agoAm I the only one that found this stuff surprisingly cheap? Seems like practically nothing compared to the real estate and building costs.
- icodestuff 4y agoIf you're in San Francisco or New York, maybe. If you're in the rust belt, that's going to be a much higher proportion of your costs.
- treis 4y agoRetail square footage is not cheap wherever you go. Even rust belt is getting a few bucks a sq foot and average is more like 15-20. So a couple thousand square foot theater is around $10k a month and probably more like 20-40k. I don't know, maybe theaters get a super good deal as anchor tenants. But doesn't seem to add up that $1,000 a month on a projector rental is a driver of price increases.
- Finnucane 4y agoI think the basis of the complaint is that it can be an ongoing maintenance expense. And it's more expensive than the pre-digital way of doing things, atr least for the theaters. But yeah, compared to your other overhead costs, it can't be the main driver of ticket prices.
- MrBuddyCasino 4y ago> People go to theaters for presentation they can't get at home, but that's no guarantee of the best picture and sound. I'm not sure the premise is entirely correct. I think the main attraction is watching a movie together with other people, because it adds to the emotional experience. I think this premise is the same mistake phone makers did when all they advertised was technical specs like RAM and GHz and cores, when that is a very reductionist view of the actual experience of using a phone, which apparently only Apple understood. This seems to work well for Open Air cinemas, where picture and sound might just be ok but not great, but you are in nature with other people and its just totally different from some multiplex chain. At least where I live they are regularly sold out. Now they just have to release movies that are worth watching, which apparently they lost the capability for since around 2017.
- kjs3 4y agoI never got the 'experience' aspect of going to the movie. Sitting in the dark with a pack of strangers you don't really interact with. Some non-zero percentage of whom are rude/entitled further downgrading the experience. And eating bad snacks. With a product on the screen that fails to impress more often than not. I have friends who absolutely adore the movie theatre and consider it a transformative experience. But it just does not resonate with me; does not generate an 'emotion' other than annoyance.
- nanna 4y agoIf you're ever in London go to the Prince Charles Cinema to discover the experience of cinema at its absolute best.
- PaywallBuster 4y agoDo we need all that premium/proprietary equipment? Laser projectors: $40,000-$150,000+ Dolby Sound: $75,000-$100,000
- davidferguson 4y agoSometimes it's forced upon cinema owners. There's only one company making non-laser cinema projectors these days, and so laser is really the only tech in town when it comes to replacing an ageing or broken projector.
- 999900000999 4y agoThe quality of big budget movies has also dropped to the point I'd rather just wait for streaming. Aside from an indee movie ( Mad God I think ) , I haven't seen a single movie in a theater since Rise of Skywalker. Yes Disney it was that bad. I honestly think theaters are obsolete, I'd personally rather stay home and watch Netflix.
- pxtail 4y agoI find almost all newly released movies uninteresting - maybe it's old age or maybe modern big budget movies are "over-calculated" - it seems like producers want to tick all possible boxes, sell to as broad audience as possible and of course play it safe to the maximum - do not try something new which isn't sequel, prequel or other similar form of "guaranteed audience" insurance. It results in watchable but totally uninteresting and mediocre outcome.
- Levitz 4y ago> I honestly think theaters are obsolete, I'd personally rather stay home and watch Netflix. I frankly think this point isn't considered seriously enough. When you go to a sports event you see the sports instead of a screen. When you go to a play, you see the play instead of a screen. When you go the cinema, you see a screen. A bigger screen with a great sound system etc etc, sure, but a screen nonetheless. Does it make sense to move 200 people to a big room with a big screen when each one of them have a small room with a small screen? If for some bizarre reason cinemas were invented just now, would they find any market at all? It does sound like a bit of an absurd proposition to me.
- hnburnsy 4y agoMovie theaters do have a labor costs advantage... >Currently, lower-level movie theater employees lack mandated overtime in 28 states. Theater chains nabbed their Fair Labor Standards Act amendment in 1967 to exempt “any employee employed by an establishment which is a motion picture theater” from both minimum wage and overtime. The rationale for the exemption at the time was that theaters could not afford the labor costs because of low profit margins, poor box office and rising costs. While the minimum-wage exemption was removed in 1974, the overtime exemption has remained, to the puzzlement of labor experts.
- zokier 4y agoI like going to movies, but it is sad that my local multiplex has some really outdated equipment. I don't need some crazy imax stuff, but going to movie theater and seeing clear pixelization on screen does bother me. From my point of view we jumped to digital prematurely, should have skipped the 2K projection tech.
- yboris 4y agoThese costs seem absurd! > Media block: $7,000-$40,000 "helps convert the digital cinema package provided by a studio into data that can be projected with picture and sound" So, a laptop that can take a file in one format and convert it to another format? Why even have a different format for a projector? > Digital library server: $12,000-$27,000 "These provide storage to hold multiple movies" So, a movie on a hard drive right next to the projector is too complicated? To me, it sounds like both of these can be replaced with a $2,000 laptop. Is the whole thing just so that the file is DRM-ed to hard that nothing else except expensive equipment can play it?
- whywhywhywhy 4y ago>To me, it sounds like both of these can be replaced with a $2,000 laptop. Presumably the cost comes from the fact it has to be a secure toolchain from studio to projection. If it was just a random laptop then the full res copy could be syphoned off by a rogue employee. Not defending the prices, just saying the studios have a strangle hold on that industry so you can't just solve problems in a simple cheap way.
- timthelion 4y agoStrangling your customers doesn't seem like good business.
- gjsman-1000 4y agoIt’s good business considering that a DCP leak of a movie the first day in the theater could be catastrophic. Heck, a leak of any DCP is bad for the movie studio. DCPs are the highest quality available version of a film the public will ever see. They are better than 4K Blu-Ray in every respect; fantastic news if you are a pirate who wants to re-compress it into some cheap discs for Malaysia. It’s also fantastic news if you are a shady local movie theater wanting to skip royalty payments - what studio executive is going to notice? (Also, before anyone says “just go after the pirates then,” many pirates are from countries like Russia who don’t give a darn. If a pirate is hosting your movie on Russian bulletproof hosting with a Russian domain, you are basically SOL as a movie studio. All you can do is ask for DNS blocking in countries where that's legal; and hope that you can identify the pirates and wait until they make the mistake of stepping on a US Ally's soil if they ever do.)
- ilamont 4y agoFormer 35mm projectionist here. This statement is flat-out wrong: A 35mm film projector was a machine with a handful of parts. If one broke, theaters could be back up within a matter of hours. Are you kidding me? A 35mm projector has hundreds of precision engineered moving parts. If one of them breaks, you're not swapping it out with a replacement from Radio Shack. You might not even trust the pimply teenager running the projector (me) to touch any of the interior parts or gears. You're going to the pros: Authorized service techs, or a specialized AV supplier who may have it in stock, but is definitely not open on the weekend when these things tend to break. And, the supplier may have have to order the replacement part from Japan or Europe. If you're part of a chain that uses standard equipment (not a given, considering consolidation) you might be able to borrow parts or spares from your pal running the show at the multiplex across town. Worst case: Because most theaters operate two sister machines for each film (a reel can only hold ~75 minutes of film max, so you have to switch over to the second machine halfway) you can technically swap reels on a single machine with a 5 minute intermission. The 35mm projectors were professional-grade machines designed to last for years. Our theater used 25-year-old Italian projectors made by Cinemacannica which is still around today (https://www.cinemeccanica.eu/cinema-products/ https://www.cinemeccanica.eu/cinema-products/), and looks like it has moved into digital exhibition. Some of the old 35mm machines are still around, usually at indie theaters. I spotted one a few years ago in Somerville Mass as described here: https://leanmedia.org/memories-movie-theater-film-projectionist/ https://leanmedia.org/memories-movie-theater-film-projection...
- MichaelZuo 4y agoYeah it sounds like the writer of the article is spreading hogwash.
- incahoots 4y agoAmazing insight, thanks for sharing. I had a micron of an idea how it worked, but of course when you look into a specific process, it's clear it's never as simple as it appears
- ilamont 4y agoThanks. Besides the reels, just about the only part I could swap out was the light bulb, and even that had a process around it - for instance, I had to wear lint-free gloves because if I touched the bare bulb with my fingers, the oil from my skin could cause the bulb to explode when 1000+ watts start coursing through it. Fire safety was a real concern. I had to be tested and licensed by the state, and most of the questions were about what to do if there was a fire. Part of the projection machinery included venting to get all of that hot air away from the projectors and out of the room (not unlike a server room).
- sarojmoh1 4y agoWell..there goes my dream of owning one. Haha, jk, would be awesome to setup a small community theater though
- fundad 4y ago[flagged]
- callamdelaney 4y agoWe need more movies like Interstellar & Dune and less Guardians of The Galaxy 36, people might be more willing to go to the cinema then. I can get free tickets and still don't go more than once or twice a year.
- justinator 4y agoWhat I actually got from the article is that if simply running a movie theater is wildly expensive just to achieve the status quo, so the only way to get enough butts into seats is to really show lowest common denominator movies that will actually turn a profit. The only way to even release the films you'd like to see is to have your tent pole films. And not all movies need the advanced tech to tell a good story. It's been 25 years since Life Is Beautiful came out (my opinion: a masterpiece). I guess theaters can show the movie now if they get a digital transfer of it, but none of the extremely costly upgrades in the theaters will do anything to make the experience of watching that movie really any better. But I want to watch the next Life is Beautiful. I feel like Life is Beautiful is art, and I'm asking to see an art exhibition at an amusement park. I have to think I'm the one with the misaligned expectations.
- thomastjeffery 4y agoThat's an absurd conclusion. One film will only get a person to sit in your theater one time. If you're very lucky, they will watch the same film two or three times. After the first few days, how is it any surprise your seats are left empty? Instead of maximizing for audience diversity, theaters need to rebalance content diversity. Get the same butts back into the same seats by showing something else. The largest theater in my state has 20 screens showing 19 films. The last time I saw a film there, the theater was empty, because of course it was! Everyone who wanted to see it either already had, was in the next room over, or was planning to see it at one of the other 5 showings that day; or the next... I bet they could have filled every seat on a Tuesday afternoon if they had just shown something else. It's not like every person in town has seen every movie ever. It's obvious this whole situation is self-inflicted. The studios that own 100 years of content don't want to compete with their own new releases.
- 23B1 4y agoJust wanted to weigh in on this thread and let people know that without theatrical releases helping support big tentpole movies that we all love... those sorts of films won't get made. That's the CURRENT paradigm and I'm not saying it's efficient, but there was a reason people have recently been saying 'Tom Cruise saved Hollywood' with the success of Maverick. Roughly 50% of all theatrical releases LOSE money. A large chunk breaks even, and about 27% have margins that could be considered a decent ROI. If you're a tech person, I am begging you to make an investment in theatrical filmmaking. Lower the cost of this equipment, or find ways to encourage filmgoing, or for the love of god build a film-producing engine that can make this bonkers-slow and bonkers-unprofitable business move out of the red.
- JackFr 4y agoHard to believe the studios keep making them. Oh wait, I forgot that movie studios routinely lie about revenues and margins. They are the OG's at hiding profits and engage in accounting shenanigans that make real estate tax lawyers blush.
- decremental 4y agoHollywood is just about the last industry on earth people should be trying to save. I have no sympathy for the low turnout to high budget propaganda films.
- marcellus23 4y ago> big tentpole movies that we all love Like what? Hollywood has been going downhill for years now — there are a few good movies a year, but it's nothing compared to what it used to be like. Just endless bland corporate written-by-committee superhero movies, prequels, sequels, reboots... maybe it's just time for the format to die.
- isametry 4y agoBREAKING: Aging Person Complains About Current Media, Is Convinced Older Media Was Better
- noodlesUK 4y agoWhat I often find so interesting is that the projection and sound systems for a high-end home theatre are so much vastly cheaper than what they are describing, and deliver a surprisingly similar experience. You can buy the best 4k laser home theatre projector that Sony offers for around 20k USD. You don't need an optical block, and you can hook it up to an Apple TV or blu ray player and get high bitrate 4k signal. You can build a very respectable quality 9.2.1 surround system for less than 5k USD. The maintenance costs are negligible with this HT stuff. The trick is getting access to cinema releases, which is essentially impossible for a home user. I'm surprised none of the theatre chains have subdivided their spaces into smaller, more intimate rooms which seat around 8 people and use consumer level kit. Obviously you can build a very nice home theatre for less than that (optoma makes great budget projectors).
- toast0 4y agoMost home theater spaces are much smaller than even a small cinema theater. You need more light to fill a bigger screen and that adds cost. Engineering for a much higher duty cycle adds costs too. Audio wise, you end up needing a lot more speakers and a more complex system to drive them. Some of the high-end cinemas put subwoofers under every butt; that's an option in a home theater too, but it's pretty excessive.
- joshmarinacci 4y agoIt feels like three things are going on here: higher labor costs, the end of cheap financing, and a lack of good films. Not a good business to be in, I’m afraid.
- kozikow 4y agoTVs got larger and more capable, so it's not as much of an improvement to go to the cinema. And cinema ticket prices got way too high for the offered improvement. Snacks got worse and way more expensive, comparing to what you can get at home.
- AlbertCory 4y agomovie exhibition is a lousy business. We showed them for free at Google: https://albertcory50.substack.com/p/culture-at-google-part-one-the-movies https://albertcory50.substack.com/p/culture-at-google-part-o... Granted it was after work and people had shuttles to catch, but attendance probably averaged 20. And we didn't show Hollywood shit movies, which would draw more, maybe. One thing that could save theaters is social interaction: people stayed after the movie and talked about it. For Animal Kingdom I think the discussion went on for a half hour. But these were all people with some connection to each other, not random strangers. And you could bring your dinner in there and eat while you watched. I also, for a while, belonged to a movie club that showed brand new movies in the theater on Sunday morning and usually had the director or other people from the movie for Q&A after. Those drew hundreds of people. But traditional movie theaters? A relic.
- albatross13 4y agoI will say, after not going to a movie theater for awhile and then subsequently seeing D&D in theaters twice...going to a movie theater is actually really nice. There's something to be said about going to a movie theater and being able to watch a movie distraction-free. No phones, no tablets, etc. It was nice.
- davemp 4y agoI've noticed a trend with these types of articles. The story is something like "Running X Business is Expensive", but when I look into it I usually see a couple themes. - The business is not owner operated - Key competencies have been outsourced - Real estate is a cost center (or equity building is just conveniently ignored) These pieces really just read like medium sophistication bean counters whining that their rent seeking play isn't working out so well. --- If you're not owner operated and you're outsourcing stuff like media servers, I don't really know what to say. For example Regal has 7,262 screens and theaters supposedly blow $20-70k per screen on media equipment??? That's $150-500Mil that could have easily funded an R&D effort to capture some massive savings (barring some sort of vendor lock in that I'm unaware of). If you want a cut of business's revenue and all you offer is basically branding and alternative financing, I'm not sure why anyone should feel bad for you.
- fundad 4y agoPeople have dreams of being their own boss but aren't cut out for the feast or famine. In the richest country in the world, business is competitive.
- jtwaleson 4y agoI’ve commented this before on Cinema threads on HN, but why don’t more cinemas show older releases? There’s 100+ years of film classics, I’m convinced there’s a market for this. I would love to take my kids to see Star Wars A New Hope. Much more than most of crap that came out this year. (There’s crap every year but the good stuff sticks, so there’s survivor bias)
- brightball 4y agoCompletely agree. The difference is that with new releases the theaters don’t have to do any marketing of their own.
- hammock 4y ago>I’m convinced there’s a market for this The market is very small, compared to new releases. It's not hard for an existing theater to test this The ones that work have some unique spin, e.g. the Wurlitzer organist plays an overture, or it's a singalong, or a cult classic for meetups like RHPS, etc
- jasmer 4y agoBecause it's niche and getting people into the theatre is dependent on the marketing budget behind the films themselves, and in particular, the celebrities. There's too much noise in the world for people to realize that 'Blade Runner' is playing at some random theatre. What could work are co-markted events, for example, playing 'Blade Runner' leading up to a new release, and, if it's promoted broadly. Or 'film festival' type things - I'm also certain there's a market for Venice/Cannes/Oscars content even in the theatre chains but it'd require marketing coordination. Finally - price. It's too expensive relative to the 'almost big screen' we have at home, and the shift to 'Big CGI Only' for theatres is real. This is a whole other problem.
- TylerE 4y agoI could see it working if it was marketed more like a recurring event where the focus wasn't on the particular film. I'd totally be into a series where it was like... every Tuesday at 8 we're going to show some classic pre-1990 film. We won't tell you in advance what it is, but it'll be good. (Maybe use the AFI lists, or a minimum of an 8.0 IMDB rating or something).
- blueridge 4y agoJust a shout out to Alamo Drafthouse. We have two theaters in our area and they're excellent. Great image and sound, comfortable chairs, always clean, never have to worry about loud people due to their moviegoer policies. Before they were built, we almost never went to the movies. Now, we go all the time.
- pier25 4y ago10 years ago I used to go to the movies a couple of times a month but these days I just hate it. People seem to talk a lot more than before. Teenagers that care about anything but watching a movie. People playing on smartphones at max brightness. I've even seen people answering their phone mid movie. Kids running around bored to death since their stupid parents thought it was a good idea to bring them to an adult movie. Image quality just cannot compared to an OLED HDR with Dolby Vision. Sound is usually way too loud and honestly my Atmos home theater setup sounds better than most theaters. After multiple shitty experiences I've just had enough. I prefer to wait a couple of months and just watch the movie at home either in Bluray or from iTunes/HBO/Disney. Theaters could provide a good experience but they just don't care. They only care about selling tickets and food.
- arp242 4y ago> People seem to talk a lot more than before. Teenagers that care about anything but watching a movie. People playing on smartphones at max brightness. I've even seen people answering their phone mid movie. Kids running around bored to death since their stupid parents thought it was a good idea to bring them to an adult movie. This is also my perception, and a big reason why I stopped going to movie theatres (and concerts), but to be honest I don't know if it was really any better 20 years ago or if I'm just an old grumpy curmudgeon. I guess you need a time machine to do any proper research on this. I do know that "talking during theatre or movie screening" should absolutely be listed in the DSM under personality disorders.
- MagicMoonlight 4y ago“We’re choosing to use 20 year old equipment and spend 50k a year maintaining it rather than just buying something that works” And 20k for a media server? They’re getting memed