18 ms·
The AT protocol is the most obtuse crock of shit
- throwawaaarrgh 4y agoCame to talk about Hayes modems, ended up finding out we're still reinventing the wheel poorly. I'm going back to IRC...
- barathr 4y agoI'm curious how this will play out for BlueSky with some fundamental human readability vs. decentralization tradeoffs such as the ICN naming tradeoff (http://www.icsi.berkeley.edu/pubs/networking/ICSI_namingincontentoriented11.pdf http://www.icsi.berkeley.edu/pubs/networking/ICSI_naminginco...) and Zooko's triangle. Often folks point to biometric binding for DID's to get around Zooko's triangle, which is problematic from a privacy/trust standpoint. Other systems such as Mastodon avoid running into these problems because of direct and implicit use of DNS for the namespace. (And use of DNS embedding in DIDs ends up undermining the value of flat naming.)
- rektide 4y ago> It turns out using Git, which is almost always used with a centralized 'remote', to do federation, which needs to be weakly consistent, IS A BAD IDEA!!!!! Given that a user owns their feed, I'm not sure why this is a bad idea? I want to take this critiques here seriously but there's not a ton to grasp onto. It definitely didn't feel great that AtProto built from bare ground, reinvented json-schema & OpenAPI for no reason. But ultimately this is one of a number of grievances that feels like doesn't really matter. It's stupid & dumb but in the end it doesn't matter. It's hard to tell which of these points really have hard & real impact. And which are just bias. The general feeling is an unencumbered letting out of biases, which makes it harder to trust.
- barathr 4y agoMy limited understanding of the problem about git as the basis for user data storage is that it then would expose the complexity of git rebasing and the rest via federation. Git is great with a centralized remote (like I believe the original post is getting at) but less so in a federated setting.
- capableweb 4y agoRebasing and similar operations are only a hassle because multiple authors can edit the same files, so you end up with conflicts. In the scenario where every authors can only change their own files, you can avoid those sort of conflicts, as they'll never happen. Remaining is how to solve files referencing other files (in the case of a federated social media, posts that are replies to other posts) which are way easier to solve, as it's not really conflicts but invariants that have to be created.
- codetrotter 4y ago> every authors can only change their own files, you can avoid those sort of conflicts, as they'll never happen A single author can still run into these issues with git if they use multiple devices. Can the same happen in this social media network for a user that uses the same account on their phone, their tablet and their computers?
- capableweb 4y ago> A single author can still run into these issues with git if they use multiple devices. No, using multiple devices are fine, as long as you're not editing the same content in two different ways on them. Meaning changing "A B" to "A C" on one device, and to "A D" on the other. > Can the same happen in this social media network for a user that uses the same account on their phone, their tablet and their computers? When using AT protocol, you'd still be connected to the same PDS, so no conflicts. The conflicts mentioned earlier are about server<>server federation, not server<>client communication.
- groestl 4y agoWell, rebasing is definitely not a must when using Git.
- afiori 4y agoRebasing is how the AT protocol handles deleting posts
- im_dario 4y agoIt doesn’t really use Git, but it has Git semantics. They borrowed some basic concepts (repository, commit, etc).
- linuxdude314 4y agoExactly. Anyone worrying about having to rebase, is over thinking it. This is a protocol level detail hidden behind shiny UX elements. I’ve been using Bluesky for 2 months now; it’s very easy to use.
- dathinab 4y ago> Given that a user owns their feed, I'm not sure why this is a bad idea? that by itself is a bad idea users being able to arbitrary edit tweets in a social network is never a good idea because the moment you say (i.e. tweet) somethingpublic it's not just your thing anymore,
- linuxdude314 4y agoWhat you’re saying is nonsense. Posts are stored in a merkle tree; you can’t just change stuff. Don’t spread misinformation please.
- jug 4y agoWith all that screaming from a user on the main competing network, I really need to hear a response from the Bluesky team to form an opinion here. And understand better why this guy is so upset about this destined-to-fail network to curse and foam about it.
- lapcat 4y ago> With all that screaming from a user on the main competing network Isn't everyone on a "competing" social network before they join Bluesky? I managed to snag an invite (sorry, I don't have any others), so I'm on both at the moment. Though I've found Bluesky to be pretty boring and don't check in much. > And understand better why this guy is so upset about this destined-to-fail network to curse and foam about it. It didn't sound like he wanted to fail: 'And I went into this with an open mind. I was like "I'll just make a simple alternative to the BlueSky server in Elixir".'
- epicsponge 4y agoExactly this, I literally was just trying to implement a simple Elixir server that would scale pretty well. The problem is the protocol is incorrectly spec-ed, is not thought through very well, is incredibly complex and hard to explain, and reinvents the wheel in just about every way it can. This means that in languages like Elixir, which has stuff like an ActivityPub implementation, OpenAPI libraries, and JSON Schema support, you have to write everything from scratch because the user base is smaller than TypeScript / whatever they're writing their implementation in. The protocols they're layering on don't have proper implementations in Elixir, because they're hard to implement right and are annoying to deal with.
- chicargocult 4y ago[flagged]
- SV_BubbleTime 4y agoAny other embedded programmers or older people that remember what an AT protocol really is confused every time they see a story about Bluesky?
- floxy 4y agoI was just about to post that this article isn't about the AT modem commands. https://en.wikibooks.org/wiki/Serial_Programming/Modems_and_AT_Commands#What_are_AT_Commands https://en.wikibooks.org/wiki/Serial_Programming/Modems_and_...?
- ndiddy 4y agoTo be fair, anyone who's worked with cell modems knows that the other AT protocol is also an obtuse crock of shit.
- cbsmith 4y agoYeah, the headline even more "that's not news" when you're talking about modems. ;-)
- JohnFen 4y agoThat was the protocol I thought I was going to read a rant about by the title, and I was all ready to agree wholeheartedly with the author. But it was a different protocol that I have no experience with. It might be a crock of shit, too, but it's hard to tell from that rant. Interestingly, the original modem AT protocol was reasonable. Then as modems became more featureful, the protocol kept getting extended, and extended, and then I stopped using POTS modems and thought I'd never have to deal with it again. Until I built my own cellphone discovered that not only does it live on, but it's been extended even more.
- bombcar 4y agoI’ve always wondered if a cable/DSL modem is an actual AT-style modem somewhere in there, but I’ve been way too scared to ask.
- capableweb 4y ago> I think the fundamental reason why we keep seeing more and more bullshit protocols and projects pop up like this is one fundamental mindset: a refusal to attribute the problems of the modern internet solely to capitalism. I mean, I'm sure they have some points in this ranty thread of toots, but it's hard to take it serious when it ends up blaming it all on capitalism (which, I hear you brother, I'm no fan either) and it's FILLED WITH SHOUTING FOR NO GOOD REASON. Sometimes, when you feel strongly about something, it's useful to write a first draft, and come back to it after cooling down for a day or two, and rewrite it to be more nuanced. The AT Protocol has many flaws, like any protocol, that much is evident. But I don't think this toot-thread gives a accurate view of those flaws. It also doesn't seem to consider that all these different protocols make different tradeoffs, and none of the protocols try to be "one protocol to rule them all". They are simply better at some things, and worse at others. > Also I don't care if I'm spreading FUD or if I'm wrong on some of this stuff. I spent an insane amount of time reading the docs and looking at implementation code, moreso than most other people. > If I'm getting anything wrong, it's the fault of the Bluesky authors This is a really disappointing way of reviewing things, I hope that it doesn't become more popular, because no one actually learns anything from it. It ends up being just a rant, but masqueraded as education.
- camdenlock 4y ago> If I'm getting anything wrong, it's the fault of the Bluesky authors I dunno, this seemed an entirely on-message thing for a “literal communist” to say.
- m348e912 4y ago[flagged]
- b1ue64 4y agoAnd clearly you are too if you're making low-effort "arguments" like this
- afsfa 4y agoBetween that and the bitching about capitalism it is hard to take the rant seriously. If you have a technical argument why the protocol is bad, adding political stuff on top of it makes it less credible.
- m348e912 4y agoBTW this is really a critique at bluesky FOR using the AT protocol and not the AT protocol itself. It's not like Sam has an option to use something else if he wants to interface with Bluesky.
- LeoPanthera 4y agoIt's not that bad. ATZ and ATDT are the main two you have to remember. Wait, is that not what we're talking about? So, it has a confusing name too?
- bombcar 4y agoNO CARRIER
- cbsmith 4y agoHonestly, that's what I thought it was talking about when I read the headline.
- LVB 4y agoWhy the rush? ATDP
- m463 4y ago,,,
- banana_giraffe 4y agoI still have burned into my head the dangers of ATM ATS11=50 And a script to keep doing ATDT##### in a loop till it got through a busy signal, only to find out that short DTMF tones aren't always recognized, and seemingly the tones for "9" and "1" and "1" work when others didn't. Explaining to my parents why there was a cop at the door complaining that the 911 operators were mad at us was fun.
- shanebellone 4y agoI started documenting the GSM command set. It's one of those things that warrants a cheat sheet. Never will I ever retain that crap.
- sleepybrett 4y agoYeah I came here to talk some Hayes
- a2800276 4y ago
- secondcoming 4y agoThis isn’t about AT modem commands then! Pretty interesting rant until he harped on about capitalism, and this > Criticism of Mastodon should be looked at seriously, especially when it's from black people, as this space is overwhelmingly white.
- archgoon 4y ago[dead]
- spacemadness 4y agoI must be blind but I don’t see your quote anywhere.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- tedunangst 4y agoI'm glad somebody looked, because basics like when messages are actually passed around is something I didn't see in the atproto docs either. Alice on server X follows Bob on server Y. When are Bob's posts delivered to X such that Alice may see them? Are they pushed from Y? Are they pulled by X? Polling seems like an absolute disaster in an environment where people have an expectation of semi real-time communication.
- justguessing7 4y agoThe post alleges Bluesky pull based, which would imply it's like RSS but with signatures: > It uses pull-based federation instead of push-based like Mastodon. I was hoping they would employ both: push and pull. Some scenarios I could imagine pull being more efficient, and sometimes push. For instance if I run my own server I don't need to be pushed all content when I sleep. However when I return it could do pulls and then continue pushing. It doesn't look like it's clever like that.
- eropple 4y agoThere are likely scenarios where some level of push-based comms will be necessary, as I understand it. Direct messaging, for example, seems like it'll require pinging a server to pull an asymmetrically encrypted message, or similar.
- afiori 4y agoDMs are not a planned feature of this protocol
- archgoon 4y agoWhen he was ranting about crypto, I had assumed that Bluesky had done another silly Coin or something. Nope, this is just apparently a dislike of public keys and signing messages, which seems like a great idea for a federated protocol.
- jeroenhd 4y agoParts of the BlueSky protocol do use stuff designed for "web3" cryptocurrency stuff (https://www.w3.org/TR/did-core/ https://www.w3.org/TR/did-core/), but there's no cryptocurrency in use for the AT protocol. I'm not sure why they're even using this because the docs state that the current DID stuff is all placeholders until they can find something better.
- steveklabnik 4y ago> I'm not sure why they're even using this because the docs state that the current DID stuff is all placeholders until they can find something better. DID is there to stay, it's that the DID spec has a concept called "verification methods" https://www.w3.org/TR/did-core/#verification-methods https://www.w3.org/TR/did-core/#verification-methods. They are providing a verification method called "DID Placeholder (did:plc)", because none of the existing methods suited their goals. The idea is that if and when a better verification method appears, they can move to that, but that doesn't mean abandoning DIDs altogether.
- NoMoreNicksLeft 4y agoI'm amused. First, that it's the AT protocol... I thought someone was getting pissy about their 45 yr old vintage 1200 baud modem. Second, that people are discovering that Twitter 2.Oh isn't truly federated but just pretends to be. The open source community's spent how many years designing a non-proprietary protocol and putting out reference implementations (and extending it to Facebook-like and Youtube-like and Wordpress-like offerings)... But no, everyone's all just butthurt over Elon Rocketman and will accept whatever garbage anyone puts in front of them.
- Havoc 4y ago> I thought someone was getting pissy about their 45 yr old vintage 1200 baud modem. Meanwhile I was expecting a Linus rant about a kernel merge for it
- NoMoreNicksLeft 4y agoThat would be a glorious rant.
- eropple 4y ago> The open source community's spent how many years designing a non-proprietary protocol and putting out reference implementations (and extending it to Facebook-like and Youtube-like and Wordpress-like offerings)... And it's awkward to write code for and the people who inhabit it range from right-wing reactionaries to, as was so effectively put, the homeowners' association. Turns out that people don't care about "open source" unless it's easy to work with and people especially don't care about "open source" when they want to talk and shitpost with their extended friend group. (Which no, Mastodon doesn't do a good job of! Even setting aside that quote-toots are Good, Actually, Mastodon doesn't let me see replies to a toot unless I go digging so I don't know if I'm just being one of another set of replies that might already have said what I was going to say, so why post at all?) I tend to think that the Bluesky crowd seems like they have their shit together as well as having a small beta explode can allow it (the web app is literally at `staging.bsky.app`, come on) and I think the AT Protocol docs identify real and probably intractable shortcomings in ActivityPub. But it doesn't somehow render ActivityPub moot if you want to use it. Go for it. It's still there.
- 0xTJ 4y agoEven after reading some of that thread, I have no idea what this AT protocol is. Did someone reuse the name for the thing used in modems?
- wmf 4y agoAT Protocol is used by the Bluesky app. And yeah, no one outside HN cares about the Hayes AT commands any more.
- duskwuff 4y ago> no one outside HN cares about the Hayes AT commands any more. You might be surprised. A lot of cellular modems and Bluetooth modules are controlled using a variant of the AT command set.
- anilakar 4y agoWe still have a ton of remote IIoT edge nodes with with Ericsson f3507g modems as the local SMS gateway for the site. Every now and then they hang and require manual reinitialization with minicom and AT commands (unless you want to reboot the whole edge node)
- randunel 4y agoMy 5G modem needed some AT commands (AT^CUSTOMER among others) to be made compatible with the linux kernel. It turns out the exact same Foxconn device is rebranded HP, Dell, Telit and possibly some other by simply running AT^CUSTOMER=1(Dell), 2(Telit), 4(HP). The HP variant wasn't compatible with Linux, but the Dell one was. There's large forums such as wirelessjoint, ispreview and sierra where AT is still extremely relevant.
- jeroenhd 4y agoNo one outside HN cares about AT Protocol either, they just want Twitter 2.0 and have found a promising exclusive club over at BlueSky. I doubt anyone but a small minority of BS users will even know that you can theoretically run your own server and that eventually other servers will join the network.
- lapcat 4y ago> "Additionally, if a Bluesky server goes down, their way of keeping access to your data is by storing all of it on your device!" This seems troubling, if it's accurate. [I've edited the above quote to remove some all-caps and exclamation points.]
- wmf 4y agoNote that Mastodon is even worse. Backup/restore has been generally ignored in social media.
- pfraze 4y agoYou'll store it on your own device, or on another service. I don't understand this criticism; where else do people back up their data?
- jbc1 4y agoPeople might be imagining it as something tightly coupled with the application rather than a data file you can just backup anywhere. Could be worth chucking a "store your profile on your own device, Apple iCloud, Dropbox, Google Drive, or your preferred file storage solution" somewhere.
- lapcat 4y agoTo avoid repeating myself, see this comment: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35885373 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35885373
- gkmcd 4y agoIt's pretty obvious that bluesky is mostly handwaving around decentralization and federation. It will all go in the too hard basket once the service gains critical mass. Another VC-funded bait and switch; nothing to see here.
- hackerfactor1 4y ago+++
- userbinator 4y agoATH0
- pfraze 4y agoOkay well. I work on Bluesky and helped build the AT Protocol. I'm sorry Sam differs with us on this, and I'm glad that Activity Pub is already there for him. However, Sam doesn't understand the ATProto very well and I want to clear it up a bit. Before I do, let me just say: Bluesky and the AT Proto are in beta. The stuff that seems incomplete or poorly documented is incomplete and poorly documented. Everything has moved enormously faster than we expected it to. We have around 65k users on the beta server right now. We _thought_ that this would be a quiet, stealthy beta for us while we finished the technology and the client. We've instead gotten a ton of attention, and while that's wonderful it means that we're getting kind of bowled over. So I apologize for the things that aren't there yet. I haven't really rested in over a month. ATProto doesn't use crypto in the coin sense. It uses cryptography. The underlying premise is actually pretty similar to git. Every user runs a data repository where commits to the repository are signed. The data repositories are synced between nodes to exchange data, and interactions are committed as records to the repositories. The purpose of the data repository is to create a clear assertion of the user's records that can be gossiped and cached across the network. We sign the records so that authenticity can be determined without polling the home server, and we use a repository structure rather than signing individual records so that we can establish whether a record has been deleted (signature revocation). Repositories are pulled through replication streams. We chose not to push events to home servers because you can easily overwhelm a home server with a lot of burst loads when some content goes viral, which in turn makes self hosting too expensive. If a home server wants to crawl & pull records or repositories it can, and there's a very sensible model for doing so based on its users' social graph. However the general goal is to create a global network that aggregates activity (such as likes) across the entire network, and so we use large scale aggregation services to provide that aggregated firehose. Unless somebody solves federated queries with the sufficient performance then any network that's trying to give a global view is going to need similar large indexes. If you don't want a global view that's fine, then you want a different product experience and you can do that with ATProto. You can also use a different global indexer than the one we provide, same as search engines. The schema is a well-defined machine language which translates to static types and runtime validation through code generation. It helps us maintain correctness when coordinating across multiple servers that span orgs, and any protocol that doesn't have one is informally speccing its logic across multiple codebases and non-machine-readable specs. The schema helps the system with extensibility and correctness, and if there was something off the shelf that met all our needs we would've used it. The DID system uses the recovery key to move from one server to another without coordinating with the server (ie because it suddenly disappeared). It supports key rotations and it enables very low friction moves between servers without any loss of past activity or data. That design is why we felt comfortable just defaulting to our hosting service; because we made it easy to switch off after the fact if/when you learn there's a better option. Given that the number one gripe about activitypub's onboarding is server selection, I think we made the right call. We'll keep writing about what we're doing and I hope we change some minds over time. The team has put a lot of thought into the work, and we really don't want to fight with other projects that have a similar mission.
- iptq 4y agoIt seems to me that a lot of the problems discussed in this thread (it's using a new protocol that doesn't work with existing tools, it uses crypto, handles auth in the protocol, server can goes down) are just frustrations that don't have to do with the core innovation that Bluesky promises to deliver, and are instead confusing the AT protocol to be another ActivityPub-related protocol, rather than something completely different. In fact, it misses that having pull-based indexes is part of the idea of separating data publication vs. data curation. Yes, invite codes are kind of a weird thing to shove so deep into the protocol but sometimes these kinds of things are necessary to bootstrap a social network, and become relatively unimportant in the long term. But on the other hand, the AT protocol is not all what it seems either. It's fundamentally not possible to do what they promise unless there is some kind of synchronization point where your most up-to-date identity can be searched. The documentation goes on extensively about the format of DIDs and the fact that there _is_ a resolution scheme, but it fails to mention that this resolution is being done by Bluesky themselves, and is not planned to expand into something that others can control. As a decentralized protocol, you would expect this to be something DNS-based, or if you really wanted something more peer-to-peer, DHT lookup, or at the worst case, a distributed blockchain. Seeing as this is a fundamental protocol-level change, the fact that they're rolling with the current approach makes me believe they will not be changing this in the near future. Bluesky is just converting one problem into another.
- pfraze 4y agoThe DID method has to satisfy a lot of requirements. I did a ton of research on DHT and blockchain approaches and none of them give the right performance, reliability, and cost outcomes while also supporting key rotation. DNS isn't far off but it's a little obtuse to cram it into, so we're starting with did:web and did:plc. We'll add others if they have the right characteristics. The only options that seem reasonable for PLC is for it either to be operated by some trusted multi-stakeholder institution like ICANN or to be a closed-group blockchain. I'm open to either approach but they require the creation of a consortium, which requires buyin from a set of stakeholders that don't exist yet. So until that happens, we run it, and that's why we called it Placeholder. We'll backronym it into something else once we get there (the C most likely being Consortium).
- renahlee 4y agoThere was no reason for that toot to be that aggressive :(
- tazjin 4y agoThe tone of that whole thread in combination with posts like > Imagine if I had to store the 50k+ tweets I've made on Twitter on my device, and upload ALL of them to a new server whenever a community server went down. doesn't make this person seem particularly competent. I'm getting a vague feeling that this is normal discourse on Mastodon though, and that not using social media much shifts your personal overton window for what is acceptable communication until you essentially don't overlap with the very online crowd anymore.
- sundvor 4y agoEverything is upper case and absolutes these days, so many appear to have lost the capacity for nuance; it's turned into a shouting match for our attention.
- doctor_eval 4y agoYea I was like, 50K tweets converted to bytes is like… well it’s one second to upload on my home internet connection. After that, it just felt like rant.
- jeroenhd 4y agoFor what it's worth, when a server does go down and thousands of people start uploading their 50k skeets that all need to be cryptographically verified, other major servers will have quite the scaling challenge. Cryptographic verification is intentionally compute heavy after all. 50k entries isn't a whole lot but as people hosting Mastodon servers have found out, things start slowing down when 1000 people transfer those 50k entries at the same time.
- vidarh 4y agoMastodon does not currently support importing posts from your old account. Just followers/following. It's a nuisance, and there's nothing preventing it per se, since the posts are signed, but that part could be better.
- lbayes 4y agoAlso came here to read about AT modem commands. Still have no idea (and admittedly little interest) what this other nonsense is... Did it have to use the existing name? Did the authors not have access to a search engine?
- camdenlock 4y agoA bit difficult to take anything seriously that this hyperventilating dweeb says: > But I think what's key is to keep an anticapitalist mindset. We can make things easier for users without allowing in what makes social media so fucking awful: capitalism.
- anticristi 4y agoAnyone else read "AT protocol" and thought of old modems?
- numlock86 4y agoYes, me. But old modems? Two months ago I was integrating a 5G modem into a bare metal embedded application. AT is also used for the WiFi and Bluetooth chips/modems we use. AT commands on two- or four-wire RS232. Not everything is Linux and PCI/USB.
- chaorace 4y agoSame boat. A few years back I spent a summer living off LTE internet (before it was cool!) using a Sierra Wireless USB modem bodged into barely working with the help of pirated reference docs. Man am I glad that I gave up on that idea -- the OG AT protocol is, indeed, a totally obtuse crock of shit to the point where, honestly, it barely even qualifies for the moniker of "protocol" at all.
- DoingIsLearning 4y agoSame here, had a client ask for an AT command set to have a brand new nRF52 talking with a Cortex-M3 running some other legacy code.
- lostfocus 4y agoYes. I even started to hear the noises.
- TkTech 4y agoNot even old modems, AT is still used everywhere. Just about every modem I've bought off Sparkfun uses AT.
- yokoprime 4y agoYes. I was very confused for a second.
- coding123 4y agoATA
- resolutebat 4y agoI'm slightly disappointed this isn't about Hayes AT commands. ATDT is pretty straightforward but some of the ATS stuff can get kinda hairy. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hayes_AT_command_set https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hayes_AT_command_set
- peterfirefly 4y agoI wrote code for a PC and an embedded system to use modems -- relatively simple stuff like dial up, hang up, wait for a call, set baud rate. Nothing fancy. We tested about 10 different modems. All of them had their own unique bugs I had to work around. Or maybe one of them didn't have any bugs (that I ran into) -- it's been thirty years.
- viksit 4y agowhat’s this persons background to comment on this btw?
- pimlottc 4y ago… oh this isn’t about modems?
- cat_plus_plus 4y agoOh come on, it's not so bad, just ATDT(number) to connect, ATH to hang up. If you think that's complicated, you should look into UUCP.
- danielrhodes 4y agoSeems like Mastodon/ActivityPub and AT Protocol are solving for opposing problems. Maybe the compromise is a centralized service?
- rvz 4y ago> Maybe the compromise is a centralized service? Yes. Centralization is inevitable and normal users only care if they can use it easily or not and don’t have to choose a instance or set up their own mail server, instance, or whatever. As always with typical techies, the emotions put into this post were already running high given Bluesky itself has gotten someone extremely angry over the tiniest things.
- randunel 4y ago> normal users You (probably) and I have both had a more tech oriented upbringing. Current and future urban generations seem to be more tech oriented, anyway, so perhaps we, who probably form the majority of tech consumers, will become these "normal users" we condescendingly refer to in this forum. With sufficient investment in education or at least awareness, the "normal users" may eventually be privacy and freedom oriented.
- mal-2 4y agoSo far that's been the case, but the spectacular failure of Twitter as a centralized service has definitely taught some people a lesson. It remains to be seen if wariness of centralization will be a major factor for people in the future.
- rsynnott 4y agoI mean, we’ve _just seen_ one major failure mode of a centralised service.
- nottorp 4y agoThe article is about talking to modems right?
- kristo 4y agoIt seems like blue sky is fun right now because it’s exclusive. There doesn’t seem to be anything fundamental to the technology that differentiates the experience from Twitter.
- ujuj 4y agoTo be fair, you can have two products that uses different technologies but have a similar UI/UX, and in a way BlueSky is more similar to Twitter than to Mastodon, UI/UX-wise. And to be honest it's a good thing: many non-tech friends were a bit confused about Mastodon, where you have to understand parts of the technology behind to do basic things (like follow someone from another instance, IIRC). BlueSky is (currently) a bit more friendly UI/UX-wise. I don't know how that will evolve with more instances, though. I also found that discovering people was easier, but YMMV.
- neilalexander 4y ago> There doesn’t seem to be anything fundamental to the technology that differentiates the experience from Twitter It seems like you're conflating the technology with the user experience. Yes, the user experience is similar. No, the technology underpinning it isn't.
- brundolf 4y agoThe technology allows the community to iterate on the experience from twitter. There are already several alternate clients, people have made custom feed algorithms, custom tools and spam-fighting systems, and we're just getting started The twitter experience has been in decline for years, and took a sharp downward turn when ownership changed. But people on twitter just have to live with it, especially now that the (already limited) API has been closed down almost completely, because it's not an open platform like bluesky. If bluesky ever starts to make the official client a bad experience, or starts to make moderation (or non-moderation!) decisions people don't like, users don't have to just live with it. They can go find or create the experience they want without losing anything
- bmacho 4y agoIt says To use the Mastodon web application, please enable JavaScript. Alternatively, try one of the native apps for Mastodon for your platform. Good job, Mastodon. (No, I am not the same guys that complain they don't see javascript games or utilities without javascript. But I think I should be able to see a text on the Internet?)
- jeroenhd 4y agoSadly, like most web application devs these days, most Mastodon frontends require Javascript to function. There are a few smaller projects that don't but there's no nitter.net for Mastodon just yet. The people behind Mastodon don't seem to have any interest in server side rendering at least.
- cmdlineluser 4y agoAdd `/embed` to the end of the URL.
- bmacho 4y agoWow, I did not know about that! Still, it doesn't show the rest of the toots, so content posted on Mastodon is still not readable without javascript. Which is ridiculous, we have medium, twitter, facebook, reddit etc, and they decided to publish somewhere not readable without javascript.
- commoner 4y agoI do agree that the default Mastodon web client should display a static page when the user has JavaScript disabled in their browser. The issue is being tracked here: https://github.com/mastodon/mastodon/issues/19953 https://github.com/mastodon/mastodon/issues/19953
- dathinab 4y agoI'm really surprised every time anyone complains that a web-application (not just a plain web site) doesn't work without JS. I mean it's an application, applications contain code and tracking that code state server side can involve a non small amount of additional cost. Sure they could have a web-side like non-logged in viewer mode and then somehow using hydration magic transition to being a app on demand, but that is a bunch of additional work (i.e. cost) for a very small number of people. But here is a good thing, it's open source so you or any of the view people which care about no-js could try to contribute such a "view only web-site" functionality, or crate an alternative web client which solely uses server side rendering or similar. But in the end that's not worth your time right (at least for me it wouldn't be if I where in your situation)? So why expect anyone who doesn't even get any benefits from it to invest that time?
- WatchDog 4y agoI don’t know anything about XRPC and Lexicon, but claiming that OpenAPI is better than them because it’s more flexible, is not a great argument. OpenAPI is a very complex spec, and most of the tooling around it, only supports some subset of it. Sure it’s complex for a reason, it’s design goals are to be able to document the wide array of ways that HTTP APIs can be built, but if you don’t need that complexity, it absolutely makes sense to use a simpler RPC spec.
- asimpletune 4y agoI don’t know anything about xrpc. Do you know why any of the numerous other rpc specs weren’t chosen? Thrift, cap’n proto, grpc, etc have already been in production for years now.
- Sytten 4y agoClaiming that OpenAPI or JSONSchema can generate good client or server code automatically is a bad joke if the author had bothered to try the current code generators that exist. They might work but the code they produce is really not great nor idiomatic to their language.
- pavlov 4y ago> "Imagine if I had to store the 50k+ tweets I've made on Twitter on my device, and upload ALL of them to a new server whenever a community server went down." This... doesn't seem too bad at all? Let's assume an average of 150 bytes of text per tweet, and an additional 50 bytes of actually important metadata. That's only 10 megabytes for the entire archive of 50,000 items. A single HDR photo from a modern smartphone is larger. IMO this was the original point of Twitter: the extreme limitation on post size (140 characters) made it feasible to build applications that work with large amounts of content. There was a time around 2010 when building a Twitter API client was the standard demo for a new UI framework — the data model was simple enough that a basic client was the next step up from "Hello world" complexity. This was actually a nice vision for a social network! Lots of simple near-realtime data, a jungle of interesting clients to make sense of it. I wish someone was building a Twitter competitor with this kind of minimalist approach.
- mmiyer 4y agoWhat about images in tweets?
- colordrops 4y agoStill likely within the capacity of most modern phones.
- pavlov 4y agoIn this hypothetical minimalist Twitter clone in the 2009 spirit, images are elsewhere. We have a widely used hypertext protocol that lets you reference media objects from anywhere, so let’s use that. Client apps can individually solve the image upload usability question in ways that fit their user base. Yes, there will be broken links. But IMO that’s better than having all your data in one centralized location where it can eventually be taken over by private equity looking to make a buck, or a billionaire who wants to be a media mogul. Edit: Looking back at historical Twitter news, it’s clear that in 2010 their vision was still to have images embedded from other sites. Here’s a relevant TechCrunch article: https://techcrunch.com/2010/09/14/new-twitter-tips/ https://techcrunch.com/2010/09/14/new-twitter-tips/ Note how they added display support for embedded Flickr photo set links. Your pictures could be on the dedicated photo service and you’d still get the nice set browsing UI inside Twitter. They should have stuck with this and built a protocol that lets sites interoperate on things like “here’s a set of photos to be embedded” (so you could use something else than Flickr). But instead they wanted to chase the wannabe-Facebook dream of sucking everything into their servers and using a closed client to sell inline ads.
- nologic01 4y ago> I was like "I'll just make a simple alternative to the BlueSky server in Elixir". But it CAN'T be a simple implementation like ActivityPub can be, because it is extraordinarily complex and requires you to make guarantees about your storage and how your application works. You might suspect that OP has a familiarity bias here but actually there is objective evidence that ActivityPub based implementations are (relatively) simple: there are dozens of implementations of both servers and clients, will all sorts of functionality that is not emulating the "twitter/mastodon" experience. Heck, even a Wordpress plugin in the works. How well all these things will scale etc. is still somewhat of a question mark but this aspect feels important beyond specific details and choices. The simpler, more generic an approach, the more likely it is to find fertile ground and grow as a decentralized architecture. The original decentralized Web was simple and generic and this has been touted as key factor for its explosive adoption. In a sense this was also its ultimate downfall: it did not provide (out of the box) the tools to build the connectivity / social graph experience that was so enormously desirable (and was not provided e.g., by RSS). ActivityPub is somehow making up for that original gap. There might be other ways to do this. But unless there is a bigger agenda (commercialization, financialization), gratuitous complexity driven by not-invented-here or desire for centralized control is more likely to hinder than help.
- brundolf 4y ago> You might suspect that OP has a familiarity bias here but actually there is objective evidence that ActivityPub based implementations are (relatively) simple: there are dozens of implementations of both servers and clients, will all sorts of functionality that is not emulating the "twitter/mastodon" experience. Heck, even a Wordpress plugin in the works. AT Protocol has a very active ecosystem already too (even though Bluesky is still invite-only): https://github.com/bluesky-social/atproto-ecosystem https://github.com/bluesky-social/atproto-ecosystem And this isn't a complete list; there's a very active Discord for people doing bluesky projects which currently has 1.2k+ members
- davidgerard 4y agothere's AP and there's AP - it's a bit underspecified. Mastodon added a lot of stuff to make it much more usable as social media, and other implementations are increasingly converging on the Mastodon API, which isn't super simple, but also lets you talk to the Mastodon API.
- dotancohen 4y agoI seriously thought that this page would discuss the AT modem protocol(s). I remember ending many a late night with ATH...
- topspin 4y ago"Instead you have a 'DID:PLC', which is a kind of 'DID' (invented by, not a surprise, CRYPTO PEOPLE)" Interesting. About two weeks ago at the HIMMS conference (Healthcare Information and Management Systems) in Chicago I ran into this. DID has crypto stink on it and people are actively avoiding it as a result. In this case it was the CTO of an established US consortium involved with CMS standards. This is a shame and it seems irrational to me. Is W3's work on DID doomed? Do they know just how bad the optics of DID are?
- topbanana 4y agoI was surprised that my brand-new LTE modem still uses these commands. It took me back to my BBS days
- jeroenhd 4y agoI've tried to read through the AT Protocol specs but they're very vague and clearly unfinished. Their view on federation isn't exactly what I'm looking for ("a bunch of Twitters that can theoretically interoperate" rather than a decentralized platform) but I suppose only having one or two main servers does solve the "I don't know whether to pick outlook.com or gmail.com" problem that many new Mastodon users seem to face. ActivityPub is no walk in the park either. It's a protocol closer to "the HTTP of social media" than a way to interoperate with other servers. Basic functionality is easy, all you need is a few static JSON files, but if you want to write an application around it you're going to have to dive deep into the docs. What I don't really see is why BlueSky decided to make its own protocol. Like Mastodon is an API that works on top of ActivityPub, BlueSky could've just been a better ActivityPub server as far as I can tell. Most of the big problems ("my toots disappeared after the server shut down") can be resolved without an entirely new protocol. Going back to the drawing board seems like an excellent way to find all the hurdles every other protocol already encountered. The recent "official" s3 account is just one example of that, and I'm sure there will be more. Maybe the value add of the AT protocol will become clearer once it's finished. I'm sure there will be ATProto <-> ActivityPub bridges to make both networks integrate for the people who wish to do so. As far as I can tell, BlueSky is just a new, exclusive Twitter with an API at this moment.
- philipwhiuk 4y ago> As far as I can tell, BlueSky is just a new, exclusive Twitter with an API at this moment Honestly I assumed that was the USP - Twitter sans Musk.
- whywhywhywhy 4y agoSeeing .bsky.social under every username is all I need to see to know the federated aspect of Bluesky will be dumped if it ever reaches success. Normies do not care about this stuff in the slightest and it isn’t worth confusing them to include it and doesn’t benefit the site now it’s gunning for being “new Twitter”
- pelorat 4y agoI don't know, sounds pretty interesting that every user has their own repository and can upload it to a new instance, however how will content moderation even work on a platform like this?
- mal-2 4y agoI'm no expert, but piecing together what I've read, content moderation will not really be a thing. Instead there will be content labeling services which can be provided by third parties. You would subscribe to a labeling feed then use those labels to filter content you didn't want to be visible.
- brundolf 4y agoPretty much yeah. Like the web, filtering happens on the read side, not the write side. This: - Dodges any free-speech issues - Gives individuals more choice and control over what they see - Allows labellers to not worry as much about false-positives because their impact is limited by the above, which means they can use more automation, etc.
- mal-2 4y agoI'm not buying it. - Allows hate speech to hide in plain sight. - Allows plausible deniability that you aren't the nazi bar. - May allow moderation labeling to be used as a form of harassment, by intentionally using labels inaccurately. - Does not actually absolve you of the write-side responsibility to filter illegal content.
- Thev00d00 4y agoThis is great, it reminds of a good fashioned Torvalds rant. Or Guenther Steiner.
- dmytrish 4y agoIt's a nice bit of marketing for Bluesky: in the process of reading the discussion I went from "it's some vague cryptosocial thing" to "well, it does solve things and actually might be worth a look".
- voytec 4y ago> Imagine if I had to store the 50k+ tweets I've made on Twitter on my device, and upload ALL of them to a new server whenever a community server went down. Twitter had what, 160 or 280 char limit per message? 50k*280 is 14MB. What's to imagine here?
- remram 4y agoWith images often in the megabytes range, and videos an order of magnitude higher, this could be anywhere between 5MB and 100GB.
- a13o 4y ago[flagged]
- ansc 4y ago[flagged]
- Waterluvian 4y ago“Twitter outrage” is found anywhere humans are found. I think people just really wanted to believe that it was Twitter-based because then 1) it’s someone else’s fault (Twitter, not human nature), and 2) it can be magically fixed by leaving.
- plaguepilled 4y agoWho is this Sam guy? He yells a lot and while he has identified some interesting points, he also seems very... Alarmist. Is there a reason this post deserves attention beyond its content?
- throwaway2990 4y agoA nobody
- ojr 4y agoFor the normal consumer, Twitter is better than Bluesky/Mastodon, Macs and Windows are better than Linux, ChatGPT and Open AI have better predictions than open source LLMs. Its not even competitive the closed source solutions are so much better than open source ones, in these scenarios.
- citrus1330 4y ago[flagged]
- avsteele 4y agoA critique written in such an unprofessional way should be ignored. It isn't worthy of discussion.
- dingi 4y agoWhy did they need to use AT for whatever thing this is? AT is a well known and decades old protocol for modem communication. smh.
- v0idzer0 4y agoEveryone wants open, decentralized protocols as long as they built them and baked in some inherent advantage for themselves
- natural219 4y agoI've had a good heuristic in my life of simply writing off people that go on lengthy, cuss-filled rants about how bad something is without soberly explaining the technical components, offering alternatives, etc. This author seems no different.
- linuxdude314 4y ago> “The 'account portability' piece is bullshit! The way 'account portability' works is by having two separate keys, one for signing and one as a 'recovery' key. You're supposed to be able to use the 'recovery' key to rewrite history if your account gets hacked or some shit. WE HAVE THE ABILITY TO DO THAT AS SERVER ADMINS!!! MASTODON HAS THIS ALREADY!!“ I’m sorry, but how can you take someone seriously who makes comments this absurd. This reads like jealousy.
- vrglvrglvrgl 4y ago[dead]
- donatj 4y agoI was really hoping for a scathing review of the old AT modem protocol. My understanding is it’s still what’s used by cell phones to communicate with their cellular modems. Back in the early nineties I spent a lot of time learning and using these commands to send files over the phone to friends without an internet connection. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hayes_AT_command_set https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hayes_AT_command_set
- blopp99 4y agosame and i also think AT Modem is a crock of shit
- unboxingelf 4y agocheck out nostr. it’s signed json blobs. that’s it. protocols should be simple and complexity layered on.
- taylodl 4y agoHa! Opened this wondering why someone would still be griping about the old Hayes AT modem command set - some 20 to 30 years later! :)
- chrsw 4y agoTime to dust off my IRC client.
- jasonm23 4y agoReading the headline, I expected a weird rant about Hayes modem commands.
- toomim 4y agoEach release of a new decentralized social protocol spurs the developers of the previous generation to weigh in on the problems of the new one. Here's the last generation of critique, when Diaspora developers discussed the good and bad in ActivityPub, and why they wouldn't support it: - https://overengineer.dev/blog/2018/02/01/activitypub-one-protocol-to-rule-them-all.html https://overengineer.dev/blog/2018/02/01/activitypub-one-pro... - https://overengineer.dev/blog/2019/01/13/activitypub-final-thoughts-one-year-later.html https://overengineer.dev/blog/2019/01/13/activitypub-final-t...
- jcarrano 4y agoI thought it was referring to Hayes AT and I was agreeing 1000%. I guess some names may be cursed.