13 ms·
Ed Sheeran demonstrates how copyright is destroying musicians
- porkbeer 4y agoWhat is destroying musicians is not copywright, but the oligarchy of distribution and lack of artist representation. For food for thought, look up what Ed makes on Spotify per play, vs what the average person would, and how much of that goes to the labels and distributors.
- andsoitis 4y ago> look up what Ed makes on Spotify per play, vs what the average person would I don't know where to look any of this up. Can you just give us the data?
- jsemrau 4y agoSheeran gets 75,665,830 monthly Spotify listeners based on recent Spotify data. Spotify pays artists about $0.003 per stream, which is $3 for one thousand monthly listeners. Using those numbers, you can estimate that Sheeran earns at least $226,997.49 monthly from Spotify streams alone source: https://www.musicindustryhowto.com/ed-sheeran-net-worth/ https://www.musicindustryhowto.com/ed-sheeran-net-worth/ alt source: https://edm.com/industry/spotify-highest-earning-artists https://edm.com/industry/spotify-highest-earning-artists
- mikequinlan 4y agoThe question was >look up what Ed makes on Spotify per play, vs what the average person would How does Ed Sheeran make per play, and how does that compare to the $0.003 that (I assume) the average person makes?
- nl 4y agoThis calculation is done using that $0.003 number for Ed Sheeran. Spotify spent a long time in negations to get that price, and I'm not aware of any credible claims they pay higher rates to popular artists (outside perhaps limited time launch promotions) I think the more interesting question is how much Sheeran gets vs his record company, but that isn't a Spotify thing.
- OJFord 4y agoI think the point was my $0.003/play for me singing in the shower(^) vs. Sheeran's fraction of that after everyone else's cut. But I don't really know what the point of that is - sure maybe now he could go on his own and take it all, and coast for a while with existing fan base, no marketing or major concerts, etc. - but he presumably (at least at the time he last locked in to x years) thinks that's value for money. ^not actually on Spotify, sorry to disappoint!
- ikt 4y ago> Spotify spent a long time in negations to get that price, and I'm not aware of any credible claims they pay higher rates to popular artists https://artists.spotify.com/en/help/article/royalties https://artists.spotify.com/en/help/article/royalties From there, the rightsholder’s share of net revenue is determined by streamshare. We calculate streamshare by tallying the total number of streams in a given month and determining what proportion of those streams were people listening to music owned or controlled by a particular rightsholder. https://indepentia.com/blog/how-much-does-spotify-pay-per-stream/ https://indepentia.com/blog/how-much-does-spotify-pay-per-st... For example: if Billie Eilish receives 2% of all Spotify streams in a month, she will receive 2% of that month’s available streaming royalties. So the more streams you do, the higher your streamshare, the higher your average pay per steam. Yes it annoys the hell out of me that I support so many underground bands and realise that 60% of my subscription fee is probably going to pop artists.
- mrweasel 4y agoI'm not sure how Ed Sheeran distribute his music, but I think you're making a mistake in the calculations. Ed Sheeran doesn't make $226,997.49 per month from Spotify, that is the amount they pay the record company to stream his music. Artist frequently complain that Spotify isn't paying them enough, but forgetting that the record companies take a very large chuck of the profits, just to act as an increasingly irrelevant middleman.
- bigyikes 4y agoWell, part of what props up the “oligarchy” is copyright law. I think if you want to change the outcomes of the system, we should adjust the laws and incentives underlying the system.
- dcow 4y agoLimit the copyright to the commercial viability of the work. Get rid of all the intermediary performance rights bullshit. Don't allow copyright to be sold or transferred, only the original creator of the work can retain it and seek legal action if damaged.
- pitched 4y agoComparing against playing the song on radio (divided by how many listeners the station has), Spotify doesn’t look too bad.
- scarface74 4y agoThis actually true. Radio stations don’t pay anything to the singer. There is a compulsory fee paid to the song writer and composer.
- SoftTalker 4y agoYes, and almost no radio stations program indie artists, so they make pretty much zero from radio. They make a little from streaming, but mostly make money from live gigs and fan merchandise.
- sacrosancty 4y ago[dead]
- anon291 4y agoThis thinking is incorrect: > But the lawsuits have been where he’s really highlighted the absurdity of modern copyright law. After winning one of the lawsuits a year ago, he put out a heartfelt statement on how ridiculous the whole thing was. A key part: > > There’s only so many notes and very few chords used in pop music. Coincidence is bound to happen if 60,000 songs are being released every day on Spotify—that’s 22 million songs a year—and there’s only 12 notes that are available. Too many technical artisans (and I'm using this term loosely, to include those who craft software, music, or any other physical / virtual good that requires some modicum of skill to produce) believe that the law regarding copyright applies to the sole right to sell a particular arrangement of whatever medium it is they are working in. This is the wrong thinking. While it is true western music has twelve notes and some finite number of common chords, which can only be arranged in finite time in finite ways, this is irrelevant to copyright, because notes, like source code, like paint, like lyrics, etc also has Color, and if you don't understand what Color is (and think it's red, green and blue, and such), then I suggest you read https://ansuz.sooke.bc.ca/entry/23 https://ansuz.sooke.bc.ca/entry/23
- mattnewton 4y agoI'm not sure I understand you, but changing, for example, the timbre of a sequence of notes won't let you get around a copyright claim. The courts have on ocasion broadly interpreted it as the sequence and timing of notes in the US.
- anon291 4y agoWhat matters for copyright is not the notes but how the notes got there. Colour refers to the qualitative differences in provenance, not timbre or anything physical. That's what the article is about. Every thing, from the legal perspective, is imbued with these unseen attributes. It's very confusing for artisans of any kind
- YPPH 4y agoI've only really looked into the case involving “Thinking Out Loud” and Marvin Gaye's song, “Let's Get It On". I'm not music buff, but when you listen to them, they are completely different. There is no similarity at all. Sheeran's claim to the court he was going to quit music stuck me as beside the point - I hope the jury didn't hear that, lest it influence their verdict. The question for them was if there was infringement. There obviously wasn't. This meritless lawsuit was always going to fail. But Sheeran was fortunate to have deep pockets. He can afford to defend meritless lawsuits. The bigger issue is how to deal with large companies suing independent artists, and the consequences they should suffer for instituting meritless lawsuits.
- williamcotton 4y agoNo one is suing indie artists for the $70k they made off of streaming last year!
- j16sdiz 4y agoYou are overestimating how much an indie artists earn of streaming. Sportify, for example, is paying ~$0.003 / steam.
- marssaxman 4y agoPerhaps they meant $70k in aggregate.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- dumbfounder 4y agoThat r you used in sportify belongs in steam.
- williamcotton 4y agoHe was obviously making a very well considered and important contribution to the discussion and not at all dropping a variety of turds, both real and proverbial, whilst sitting on the can.
- nl 4y agoThis article seems like Techdirt is trying to exploit the well-known Ed Sheeran copyright case to push their own agenda. Notably Sheeran didn't say anything against copyright - just that this particular claim shouldn't have come to court. I think most musicians would agree with that, but it's hard to lay that on copyright law exactly - at most it would be a tweak to make it harder to bring action for "sound-alike" songs. Interestingly any change like that would probably make it harder for artists to bring action against AI-written works that sound like theirs.
- renlo 4y agoMy understanding is that "facts" can't be copyrighted. If there's only so many chord progressions that people find pleasing, and music taste is universal and we're born with it, wouldn't that make music more "fact-based"? Everyone will, more or less, agree on what is a pleasing progression.
- karmakaze 4y agoI would check these premises. It was thought that harmony was universal until it was discovered that it wasn't. Then we thought octaves were universal, but apparently there were some tribes that didn't make the association. There's a lot that we're born into, but not necessarily born with. An example of fact exhaustion is canons. They've been done a while, but there's been a lot of music made since when.
- lmpdev 4y agoI hate the idea that a lot of music people end up on in that the canons are the be all and end all of harmony There's infinitely more variety that just Bach's counterpoint people - it was just a (really fantastic) style
- schwartzworld 4y agoFugue > Canon anyway
- lbotos 4y agoI might argue that many people do not agree on what a pleasing progression is. For example, I’m sure my mother would not find machine girl pleasing: https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=fYkShnaf454 https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=fYkShnaf454
- lowq 4y agoI did not expect to find a fellow machine girl enjoyer today! MG is all about the samples and the breakbeats. Definitely not the chords, haha. But I do wonder how that factors in to mixing.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- opportune 4y agoWe honestly need to rethink intellectual property from top to bottom, it’s not just copyright and not just music, it’s so much more and it affects every single kind of IP: Patent trolls, overly broad and vague patents that stifle innovation and prevent competition. Amazon should never have got a patent on 1-Click purchases and hardware shouldn’t be impossible to enter due to entrenched players’ deep patent portfolios. Overextending trademark, look up all the ways Monster Beverages tries to abuse their “Monster” trademark, just as one example. Copyright is used to stifle innovation in the arts as seen here. It keeps works out of the public domain for way too long as well. Not only do these directly cause harm but they create chilling effects due to how they let the legal system be weaponized in their defense. Even if I would win a lawsuit regarding whether I’m allowed to do something, I might still let a big player bully me out of it because of the risk and asymmetric cost of going to court. This generates a huge amount of friction. Without our current IP system you would not have all these abusive middle men in publishing, music, or other media. Not only are they stifling new art, they’re benefitting from IP by using it take a huge cut directly from artists per their contracts. Trade secrets, allowing for reverse engineering but not direct espionage, are IMO the only kind of IP that we should allow as-is. Everything else needs to be thrown out and potentially replaced with something else less abusable - I think Netflix should be allowed to fund a big movie and recoup the costs fairly without it being immediately ripped and given away for free, but they shouldn’t get to bully people making similar content or even content extending the IP.
- AlbertCory 4y agoHow much do you think the lawyers care what HN'ers think? Read this for some honest takes. They don't even care. https://www.reddit.com/r/patentlaw/comments/12x4361/alice_failed_now_what/ https://www.reddit.com/r/patentlaw/comments/12x4361/alice_fa...
- arp242 4y agoWell, that article also wasn't very good. The condescending attitude towards anyone who isn't an engineer is palatable, even to an engineer like me. The discussion on Reddit is mostly constructive in spite of this. The suggestion that HN is somehow representative of "engineers" in general is just not true. While HN includes many people with all sorts of opinions, the average is quite biased, especially on topics like this.
- ouid 4y agoIn the desert there is only a single place to drill for water, but there is enough water if you drill there to serve everyone. The king, in an attempt to find this well, issues a proclamation, that whoever finds this place to drill will own all of the water that comes out of it for the rest of their lives. Most of the desert dwellers recognize that searching for this well wont keep them fed in the meantime, so an enterprising young duke offers a different deal. He says that he will pay people to search for the well, in exchange for the rights to the water if they find it. Many desert dwellers take him up on this deal, its a good job, and it pays well enough to subsidize the searching. When the well is finally found, the king grudgingly hands the duke the rights to the water, and with the wealth that the exorbitant prices he charges for water brings him, the duke eventually owns the whole desert and deposes the king. That's it, thats the whole story. If you thought it was stupid, and that the king should have done things differently, we are in agreement.
- anonymouskimmer 4y agoI think the king should have made the duke point out who actually found the water, and then the king should have stuck to his proclamation and awarded all of the rights to that person. > To promote the Progress of Science and useful Arts, by securing for limited Times to Authors and Inventors the exclusive Right to their respective Writings and Discoveries; It doesn't say a transferable right. and "securing" and "exclusive" seem to argue against transferability. Beats me why the courts and congress decided otherwise.
- sacrosancty 4y ago[dead]
- muth02446 4y agoThese guys enumerated all melodies up to a certain number of notes and copyrighted them: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sJtm0MoOgiU https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sJtm0MoOgiU
- IAmGraydon 4y agoAs a musician for over half my life, this statement is just strange to me: >In the latest case, which just concluded last week, Sheeran said that if he lost he’d probably quit music altogether, as it’s just not worth it. If you are able to "quit music", you aren't a musician. You're someone who figured out how to make sounds people like for money. It's just not something a musician can do.
- nhinck2 4y agoBecause being a musician is somehow special and separate from any other profession?
- peteyPete 4y agoThis isn't about the philosophy behind what being a musician means.. He might not quit playing music as he's a musician, but he might quit the business, performing and putting out music for others to hear, if all that comes out of it is frivolous lawsuits.. Basically piranhas out for blood regardless of the harm they're causing. If I had to spend half my time in court as a software engineer for using a for loop, it wouldn't make much sense for me to keep being one.
- cwkoss 4y agoYour ego might be enormous to think you are more of a musician than Ed Sheeran
- rocketbop 4y agoIt was strange thing to say, even from a business point of view as given his position, he's well placed to make substantial income from live performance and streams regardless of the outcome. I suppose it was hyperbole to illustrate the importance of the case. I'm glad he won the case as it seems so frivolous to me, but I wouldn't object to him quitting music nonetheless.
- juliusdavies 4y agoI see Ed Sheeran's (as well as Katy Perry's) successful copyright defenses as evidence song writers are doing fine. Katy Perry's earlier defeat (for Dark Horse) luckily reversed on appeal last year. Toni Basil also had an interesting copyright victory last year related to 1980's "Mickey" - although her result seems very narrow and technical (related to copyright termination and works-for-hire) and only about the recording, since she never wrote the song in the first place. Whereas Marvin Gaye's heirs' successful litigation against Blurred Lines is very concerning (see: https://www.jonesday.com/en/insights/2018/07/blurred-lines-between-inspiration-and-infringement https://www.jonesday.com/en/insights/2018/07/blurred-lines-b... ), although as has long been the case with copyright litigation in the USA - it really all depends on the jury ! Personally, when I listen to Marvin Gaye's "Got To Give It Up" right next to "Blurred Lines" I really cannot comprehend the jury's result. I guess they both employ a cowbell very prominently? But I wasn't a member of the jury, so it wasn't up to me. I find the Katy Perry result to be at least a little bit of a close call based on my own listening.
- bobsmooth 4y ago>I see Ed Sheeran's (as well as Katy Perry's) successful copyright defenses as evidence song writers are doing fine. Song writers backed by huge companies are doing fine, but what about independent producers?
- juliusdavies 4y agoHonestly, I think if I wrote something significant enough that I got sued for it - that's probably a VERY good sign about my own prospects and future as a musician. Lil Nas X was completely independent when he created Old Town Road with a complete copy & paste of Trent Reznor and Atticus Ross's music. So even in cases of absurdly blatant copyright infringement the artist might still do okay !
- bobsmooth 4y agoI'd prefer if song makers could produce in freedom rather than deal with getting sued or winning the lottery that is getting signed.
- Animats 4y agoSomeone tried copyrighting all the possible pop music melodies. "Most pop melodies run fewer than 12 notes. If you generated every possible melody with just the eight notes of the C scale, that’d be 8^12 melodies, which is 68,719,476,736." So they generated all of them, as MIDI sequences, and stored them on a hard drive.[1][2] Arguably, all those are now public domain. That was back in 2016. If you applied machine learning to pop music, you could probably establish a classifier for melodies that don't sound awful, and get that number down into the millions. Spotify has about 100,000 uploaded tracks. The space of listenable pop music may become fully populated. It would be amusing to have something that classifies songs as "Standard melody #67426564". [1] https://www.theatlantic.com/technology/archive/2020/02/whats-the-point-of-writing-every-possible-melody/607120/ https://www.theatlantic.com/technology/archive/2020/02/whats... [2] https://journals.library.columbia.edu/index.php/lawandarts/announcement/view/297 https://journals.library.columbia.edu/index.php/lawandarts/a...
- bobsmooth 4y ago>Spotify has about 100,000 uploaded tracks. That seems really high and really low at the same time.
- dag11 4y agoI think they meant to write 100,000,000. I was about to say that sounds insanely low, because I have 15k songs "Liked" on Spotify and there's no way I've liked 15% of practically all songs. https://newsroom.spotify.com/company-info/#:~:text=over%20100%20million%20tracks https://newsroom.spotify.com/company-info/#:~:text=over%2010...
- chha 4y agoEven 100.000.000 isnt all songs. There is still loads of music missing, with changes hppening every now and then as labels pulls specific band lineups not covered by their agreements with Spotify. There is nothing by eg The Blues Brothers outside the two movies and their debut album. Nothing by Spocks Beard prior to Neal Morse leaving the band. Other albums are stripped of specific songs because a guest artist wasnt part of the overall deal. There are probably countless other examples as well, and as artists are moving away from physical media completely I fear that entire artist will disappear in the future because they happened to be pulled from streaming services.
- raverbashing 4y agoWell, they lobbied for this crap now they're suffering the consequences of it Sure, some IP protection I'd argue is needed, but they're always on the maximization side of it and they're unhappy it's being used against them? Oh well
- graphe 4y agoWho is they? Ed Sheeran didn't lobby for this.
- danlugo92 4y agoCopyright is greed.
- dang 4y agoMaybe so, but please don't post unsubstantive comments to Hacker News. https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- danlugo92 4y agoIt's succint.
- dang 4y agoYes, but that's not necessarily a good thing when it comes to flamebait. Succinct flamebait often has the most trollish effects, whether that is the intent or not. https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=true&sort=byDate&type=comment&query=troll%20effects%20by:dang https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=true&sor...
- danlugo92 4y agoI wasn't try to flamebait, it is my sincere believe that the whole concept of copyright is greed, just like avoiding regulations, cutting corners in safety etc are examples of greed (all in my humble opinion). Any argument towards my conclusion on copyright would be entirely philosophical but I see your point about trolling is effect not intent but I disagree with it it only stifles discussion and promotes echochamberism (in my humble opinion). Now trolling with intent by all means ban those.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- pbhjpbhj 4y agoGreedy people use it, but the concept at least is not greed in legislative form -- the concept is reasonable recompense for artistic work.
- jimnotgym 4y agoJust to emphasise that 4 chords can make up a lot of songs, here is a giant comedic melody of 4 chord songs. Well worth a listen. https://youtu.be/5pidokakU4I https://youtu.be/5pidokakU4I
- bullen 4y ago“when Alexander (The Great) saw the breadth of his domain he wept, for there were no more worlds to conquer." - Hans Gruber / Hollywood OR When for more worlds the Macedonian cried, He wist not Thetis in her lap did hide Another yet, a world reserved for you To make more great than that he did subdue … —“A Panegyric to My Lord Protector,” lines 73–6
- ciconia 4y ago> There’s only so many notes and very few chords used in pop music. At the risk of sounding like a grumpy old man, I find very sad the fact that pop songs have become nothing more than 4 chords just repeating over and over, with a thin veneer of inconsequential melody over them, serving a never ending stream of banal lyrics. Is this really the best of what award-winning musicians like Sheeran et al can do? I mean, they don't even bother changing the harmony for the chorus, and where has the bridge gone?
- throwaway8689 4y agoAxis of Awesome took those lemons and made lemonade https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5pidokakU4I https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5pidokakU4I
- labrador 4y agoThose chords are sappy
- taylorius 4y agoOh, I'm right there with you man. Modern pop is mostly dreadful. I think music producers have homed in on "the most appealing chord progression possible", and are reluctant to deviate from it, like an arms race. What boggles my mind though, is that some people don't seem to get bored by it. Tbh modern pop isn't even really music any more, it's much more a multimedia thing - with visuals (hot performers, cool videos etc) playing a massive part in its appeal.
- gambiting 4y agoBut.....you yourself called it "most appealing chord progression possible". If it's appealing, why is it surprising that it's POPular? And I don't really see what is there to be bored with - it's just music. You put a POP playlist on Spotify or whatever and it's enjoyable music that you can have on for 8 hours while you work. If you want stuff that deviates from it, there's plenty to choose from - but I don't understand why anyone is surprised that this isn't what most people listen to.
- xg15 4y agoDid someone check if Structured Asset Sales also has investments in AI? I wouldn't even be surprised by now...
- partomniscient 4y agoThis (pre-court case result) video by Adam Neely (also a musician) gives a really good overview of the situation whilst also referencing specific music theory and historical evidence: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tpzLD-SAwW8 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tpzLD-SAwW8
- dghughes 4y agoI like Adam's explanations of such things he explains it well. Rick Beato also a musician and former music professor also has great explanations.
- someweirdperson 4y ago> “They are in a songwriters’ alphabet, our toolkit, and should be there for all of us to use. No one owns them or the way that they are played, in the same way that no one owns the color blue.” Blue might be free, but the same is not true for all colors, at least not all paints [0]. [0] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Anish_Kapoor https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Anish_Kapoor
- SilverBirch 4y agoI find it so disingenuous when people claim "oh well there's only so many notes". Sure, the basic building blocks are the same, but that's like saying every computer chip is the same because they're all made of transistors. It's not about the building blocks, there's an infinite number of ways that you can put them together, and not just by random chance either. Dave Grohl will happily tell you he stole his drum beats from Disco, you would have to be an idiot to claim that Nirvana produced disco music. The complaints about copyright law are to me atleast, not seeing the forest for the trees. It's much more concerning the conflicts of interest between the music labels and spotify - setting up a deal that essentially siphons off their artists's profits to themselves, than copyright law as it is today. If the market were structured such that the labels had a fiduciary responsibility to their signed artists this market would look very different.
- timwaagh 4y agoAs much as he dislikes fighting these cases he is entirely dependent on the money he makes from selling songs and the the way the fact that these have value/are copyrighted allows companies to market him and make him more famous.
- psychphysic 4y agoSo these equity firms are effectively the patent trolls of the music industry
- iainmerrick 4y agoThis is my favourite rejoinder to the idea that "the chorus sounds really similar, it must be plagiarism!", from the KLF's "The Manual" (https://www.tomrobinson.com/resource/klf.txt https://www.tomrobinson.com/resource/klf.txt): We await the day with relish that somebody dares to make a dance record that consists of nothing more than an electronically programmed bass drum beat that continues playing the fours monotonously for eight minutes. Then, when somebody else brings one out using exactly the same bass drum sound and at the same beats per minute (B.P.M.), we will all be able to tell which is the best, which inspires the dance floor to fill the fastest, which has the most sex and the most soul. There is no doubt, one will be better than the other. Admittedly this is from a book that explicitly recommends ripping off other songs as the basis for your own short-lived masterpiece.
- ulizzle 4y agoSheeran writes basic commercial pop music. Maybe if he tried learning some minor chords or scales and tried shifting tempos, he wouldn't get popped with so many copyright claims. "There’s only so many notes and very few chords used in pop music. Coincidence is bound to happen if 60,000 songs are being released every day on Spotify—that’s 22 million songs a year—and there’s only 12 notes that are available." But yeah, let's feel bad for the millionaire mediocre musician.
- batesy 4y agolol this is a bad take
- Jochim 4y agoCopyright cases around music are a great demonstration of many of the problems caused by our approach to intellectual property: * Artists are generally inspired by other artists and societal context. * Most artists make very little, some become fabulously wealthy. * Artists with few resources must be extremely careful not to "infringe" the copyright of a powerful artist. * Powerful artists have access to legal resources that allow them to, intentionally or unintentionally, take from smaller artists without facing similar repercussions. There is a complete failure of the system to acknowledge that people produce similar works independently or that human progress has often been driven by conscious or subconscious inspiration. The current regime would have us paying royalties to the dynasty of the guy that came up with the wheel. I don't think there's any justification that we'd be better off as a society if that were the case.
- showerst 4y agoOn top of that, many cases (including this one) aren't even artists suing other artists. They're estates or companies that bought the rights suing. Oftentimes the creators themselves would be aghast at this!
- heresie-dabord 4y agoWhere there is money, there will be laws and lawsuits. Music is born free and lives by sharing, but the Musical-Industry Complex thrives by other rules.
- onion2k 4y agoOftentimes the creators themselves would be aghast at this! Obviously anyone who has sold the rights to their music gives up that particular claim that though. And (in my opinion) the rights of any musician should die with them, so if they haven't sold the rights to their music while they're alive their music can't fall into the hands of a private equity company.
- Nevermark 4y agoMaking an exception to limit a musicians choice of what to do with their property would just be anti-musician. I.e. musicians should be able to pass on their assets like anyone else. Creating rat’s nests of laws to fix things in ways that are not thoughtfully deep and wide only further separates the rights of the rich, who can afford legal strategists to dodge narrow scope laws, from everyone else. What is needed are judicial judgements that uphold sensible outcomes, and provide relief (and deterrence) against frivolous speculative litigation. The need for an open system of informed human judgement, to settle fuzzy boundaries based on relevant particulars, is one of the primary purposes of a judicial systems. Micromanaging laws introduce massive opportunities for gaming and unintended harm. And create parasitic constituencies that become devoted to maintaining Byzantine situations.
- naasking 4y agoMaybe we should just make copyright non-transferable. As Sheeran says, songwriters know how few notes and chords are possible, it's always non-artists that are bringing these lawsuits.
- avgcorrection 4y ago> There’s only so many notes and very few chords used in pop music. Coincidence is bound to happen if 60,000 songs are being released every day on Spotify—that’s 22 million songs a year—and there’s only 12 notes that are available. But I don’t really run into such coincidences regularly. Maybe the difference is just that the artists that I listen to don’t have millions to be sued for.
- fencepost 4y agoThis is basically the theme of Spider Robinson's Melancholy Elephants from 1982 (http://spiderrobinson.com/melancholyelephants.html http://spiderrobinson.com/melancholyelephants.html full short story). Hugo winner, and if you haven't read it it's both highly relevant and a quick read.
- hospitalJail 4y ago>Powerful artists have access to legal resources that allow them to, intentionally or unintentionally, take from smaller artists without facing similar repercussions. This is legal in general. If I got into a legal battle with Disney or Nintendo it would go like this: >You are probably going to lose >If you do lose, you will be ruined >If you don't lose, you will also be ruined I don't have a solution except to avoid any ambiguity and let the big corporations sort that out among each other.
- Jeff_Brown 4y agoAs someone who prefers songs that use more than 7 notes and four chords, this kind of feels like a solution disguised as a problem. The space Ed Sheeran and most popular music "explores" is small. But that problem is not inherent to making music people like. Even if he were writing in today's environment, Stevie Wonder would never have to worry about an accidental collision.
- isitmadeofglass 4y ago[dead]
- michaelcampbell 4y ago> how copyright is destroying musicians. I honestly think the industry doesn't care, as long as the money flows. Like a lot of creative "jobs", there are 2 types of people who do them; those that can afford to and those that "have to" for whatever personal reasons. The industry will continue to squeeze money out of both of them because the supply is essentially endless.
- MattyRad 4y agoComedy demo of the "four chords": https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5pidokakU4I&pp=ygUPYXhpcyBvZiBhd2Vzb21l https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5pidokakU4I&pp=ygUPYXhpcyBvZ...