5 ms·
5G Rollout Disappointments
- pangolinja 4y agoAh, millimetre wave, best known for allowing unqualified TSA staff to see through your clothes at airports. Of course broad-area surface-penetrating surveillance is not what this technology is being rolled out for at all.
- mjevans 4y agoSkimmed, it seems like exactly what the reader might have suspected. * More users on the 5G sites dragging that greenfield under-used speed mark down to the more typical value. * Much of the hype 'best' with extremely high HZ spectrum that has short distance and low penetration E.G. Mostly giant sports stadiums. * Suburbs and rural areas not a good match for the distance (frequency use) or capital investment required.
- hedora 4y agoRural coverage is the only problem I had with 4G, even living in the city, etc. These days, the land line phone company has abandoned our area, and the cell companies carpet bomb us for unlimited 5G home internet service that doesn’t exist near us (despite the fact that we get a 5G connection at home). So, it is starlink for us. Count me as unimpressed with 5G. I wish they’d focus on better geographic coverage and more reliable coverage instead.
- mschild 4y agoI live in a large European city and am very often out and about and use my phone to navigate and consume content. I simply don't see the need for 5G. 4G was a major stepup in speed and given the rise of smartphones and platforms like YouTube, the speed increase made sense. There was an actual use for it. The speed increase for 5G seems to not really be needed though? At least for a majority of people 4G seems to do exactly what it needs to do.
- tommiegannert 4y ago(Outside Zürich) I see 5G as motivated by carriers, being able to pack more customers into the same cell. And I would never pay extra for it. My carrier once called and wondered if the 5G is working, and how I experience it. I'm guessing that was a PR stunt, since otherwise I wouldn't have noticed the awesome things they do for me in the background... But I might be too negative on this point. Maybe they actually wanted to know if their technology was working, by calling me and asking...
- blensor 4y agoTangentially, if you are from outside Switzerland make sure to know your roaming charges very very well. Swiss carriers have gigantic roaming charges. Every time. I fly through Zurich (from Austria) I blow through my roaming limit 60 seconds after landing because I forgot to disable data. 1MB/16€ Yes that is Megabyte not Gigabyte
- mrighele 4y agoAFAIK It’s your operator that decides the roaming charges, based on your contract (they may be different based on the country though). So you may want to check with them
- blensor 4y agoYes, it's definitely something that you (I) need to solve with the own carrier. I do still feel that there is something iffy about that, because Switzerland and Austria being direct neighbors it seems strange that they don't have at least a somewhat reasonable roaming agreement by default.
- muro 4y agoSimilar if you are from Switzerland and cross any border. If you are in Switzerland semi-regularly, either get a plan that has cheap roaming in and out of EU, or two SIMs.
- 27fingies 4y agoIs LTE and 5G performance degradation due to the wireless technology or is it somewhere upstream of that? Like what good is throwing more radio capacity at a stadium if it’s the backhaul, peering, or some other appliance in the middle that is getting overwhelmed? This seems unsurprising.
- mixdup 4y agoI think it's a combination of all of the above. Plus, 5G is still new so there's still way fewer towers and less spectrum dedicated vs. LTE One other thing is that 5G as it stands now is a bit of a hybrid, still relying on LTE networks and control planes to do management functions. Some networks are working on, and have partially built out, 5G-native control planes but it's not done, it's new, and that also means those functions are still working out the bugs
- Klathmon 4y agoI've just found that any time my phone says it's on 5G, it barely works at all. I've actually gone in and set the preferred network to LTE and every now and then I try setting it back, and almost every time I set it back within the day. Doing some speed tests back and forth, LTE tends to have significantly less latency, higher bandwidth, and just works while every single web page load on 5G feels like a gamble.
- yummypaint 4y agoI think phones lying about their connection strength is a much broader problem. My phone isn't even 5G capable, but it will show me 4/5 bars or even 100% strength with full LTE when it is provably unable to transfer data. Carriers know that lying to people's faces makes them less likely to complain about poor service, just like how they lie to our faces about their service maps. There really needs to be some kind of legally codified standard for how phones report signal strength.
- JW_00000 4y agoIsn't that a case of the phone manufacturer lying, and not the carrier?
- noisem4ker 4y agoSee previous discussion here: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18737008 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18737008
- buggeryorkshire 4y agoWhen I worked on femtocells many years ago it was Apple who did their own thing with the signal strength bars, it was a source of massive frustration. They were also the ones least receptive to reports of radio layer issues. Though coming back to the original discussion a lot of issues with 5g are backhaul problems which aren't indicated by the signal bar.
- 4y ago
- throwaway4good 4y agoBack when it was 4G western suppliers were under really strong competition from Chinese suppliers (ZTE and Huawei). Now these suppliers are banned/effectively banned in most Western countries. And we are left what seems to be just Ericsson and surprisingly things have gotten a lot more expensive, only slowly built-out, and not really that good. Having said that, I just went through Copenhagen airport and the 5G network there is really good: Very low latency, very fast initial connect, and very fast download speeds. So 5G can deliver the end-user experience it promised.
- f6v 4y agoBut look, now it’s only Americans who can eavesdrop. Better than those damn commies!
- indeyets 4y agoYou mean Swedes? ;)
- zaptrem 4y agoThis but unironically. Now the spies ultimately have to answer to my vote.
- throwaway4good 4y agoBut not mine …
- SSLy 4y ago>just Ericsson Uh, Nokia? Samsung? Whatever Amazon and the startups are cooking?
- throwaway4good 4y agoIn Denmark I think it is all Ericsson. Never heard of Samsung or Amazon (???) around here.
- nizmow 4y agoAnecdata: in Sydney, Australia, 5G on Telstra is incredibly fast (I get more than 1 gigabit at my apartment, but more typical / busier cells seem to be between 300-500Mb), and my experience using it mostly just for web browsing is it’s streets ahead of 4G.
- 0xy 4y agoI get 250 on 4G, so it seems like it's far from streets ahead. 4G can do 10x 4K streams at once, while 5G can do 15-20? A solution in search of a usecase. Not to mention 5G is significantly more unstable and patchy. Good luck with latency with a single wall between you and the tower.
- ksec 4y agoI am thinking should I flag this. And thinking how low can ieee get? ieee publishing 20+ years ago were not great, but they wont bad. Right now this piece has no engineering insight into it, zero understanding of how MNOs across the planet earth work, no idea of 5G upgrade cycle both backend and front end, and zero mention of Pandemic / COVID delaying upgrading work. So what is the point of this article? Or are they now simply another marketing / PR company to downplay the 5G and hype 6G next? Are we still at the stage people think Real 5G = mmWave? Which is what I believe 99.99999% of the internet comments were suggesting and at least 90% of HN believes in 2022.
- Mistletoe 4y agoWhy would you flag this? That’s not what flagging is for and is one of the asbolute worst features of HN. It amounts to censorship based on user preferences. It’s a real article from IEEE, just because you don’t like it or agree with it doesn’t mean you flag it. > What does [flagged] mean? >Users flagged the post as breaking the guidelines or otherwise not belonging on HN.
- jnsaff2 4y agoIf you think that flagging amounts to censorship then I guess you don't believe that there are bad faith actors who exploit vulnerabilities in human cognition? I don't think this ieee article is nowhere near flagging territory but there are plenty genocide and fossil fuel shills around here.
- Mistletoe 4y agoI think that's what the flag button should be for, things encouraging harm to other people or out and out lies or going to malware sites, but the IEEE article is none of that, it's a well-reasoned article with sourced facts.
- silisili 4y agoI'm not going to argue with you, but it would be really helpful to me or us if you could be more informative and perhaps less insulting to the crowd. After all, most mobile tech is done in the dark and few are truly versed in all of it. I for one didn't think 5g == mmWave, but I specifically chose TMobile because their initial 5g rollout plan made way more sense for me, as it wasn't mmWave, where others seemed to be focusing there.
- temptemptemp111 4y ago[dead]
- Superfrag 4y agoIn India, 5G has been a godsend (Mumbai & Hyderabad). I'm sure it's because the number of people on 5G is drastically lower than the number of people on 4G/LTE. Let's see what the experience is like when everyone gradually starts using the 5G network, but for now the difference between 4G and 5G is massive. Even in remote areas (various parts of western Maharashtra), whenever 5G is available, it's a noticeably better experience than 4G.
- drclau 4y ago> I'm sure it's because the number of people on 5G is drastically lower than the number of people on 4G/LTE. 5G has increased capacity over 4G, so even if all 4G users would switch to 5G, you will still have better service.
- AHOHA 4y ago5G is an umbrella for different types and technologies, and I believe that’s the confusion part of what the artice mentioned and the reader views. 5G has three main categories (technically two but separating the 2nd one to further explain it), 5G NSA (non stand alone), where the 5G RAN uses an existing 4G LTE core, 5G SA (stand alone), as the name implies, is stand alone from previous generations and has its own architecture and core, new radio, etc., and the third one -which is still a SA by the way- is the mmwave, what the article is referring. This article has a thorough explanation (1) In most nowadays 5G implementation is the first one, where you get a slight enhanced LTE, as it’s easier to implement, SA, which provide extra features is still not widely used -although it’s changing, and then you have the least adopted one is the mmwave due to its new bands (unlike the sub-6GHz) that require new radio/towers/etc. on a higher frequencies (also higher noise), and also new UE (or user equipment/device), which so far only very limited devices support that. In Canada, we did some cell surveys utilizing robots/drones to map the areas at different altitudes to find the deadzones and coverage, and you can say in most of the results, NSA can have the coverage as the LTE, mmwave in some cases we had not just to maintain a clear line of sight to get any signal, but also we have to be relatively close. So mmwave adoption might still in its early stages, it’s also why so operators went with C-band instead. (1) https://dgtlinfra.com/5g-standalone-sa/#:~:text=What%20is%20the%20Difference%20Between,new%205G%20packet%20core%20network https://dgtlinfra.com/5g-standalone-sa/#:~:text=What%20is%20....
- SSLy 4y ago5G mmWave is best used in dense - ie. not so often in North America - urban areas. I's going to work great in busy metro stations, shopping streets/malls, concerts. Not in suburbia.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- afavour 4y agoI’m in NYC and use mmWave for my home internet and it’s genuinely game changing: ~1Gbps internet with no wires at all. Given the monopolies internet providers have in NYC it’s liberating. But my nearest antenna is a block away with pretty good sight lines. If I move my radio even 6ft in the wrong direction my speeds go through the floor. I think the 5G hype was excessive for a technology that only works in very specific circumstances and it’s led to some disappointment.
- the_mitsuhiko 4y agoThe almost hilarious situation in Austria is that people usually have (truly) unlimited or high volume contracts. You can pull terra-bytes if data a month, even with tethering. As a result the main way in which contracts differ are speeds. The fastest 5G contract these days is 500Mbit. Most people are fine with paying for the much cheaper 100Mbit contracts. So even if 5G has speed benefits, usually I wont notice.
- arnaudsm 4y agoI have to mention the elephant in the room : many carriers push customers to replace their home wired connection with 4G/5G modems. These short term gains ruin the game for everyone. Wireless bandwidth is precious.
- ohazi 4y agoSure, but is anyone (who has an actual choice) actually choosing to do this? From what I can tell, carriers seem to run a lot of really stupid ads and keep the marketing money faucet flowing for a long time before they finally give up.
- arnaudsm 4y agoA dozen of my millennial friends do not have a wired internet connection. Gen Z even more, especially students.
- izacus 4y agoYes, many people are deciding to use mobile-only connections, suffer through the usual performance degradation when everyone decides to Netflix at once... and also actively "Who needs this?" complain against building out wired infrastructure which would fix this issues en masse.
- fuzzfactor 4y agoWhen Sprint first built out its digital cellphone network, their slogan was "you can hear a pin drop". It was basically true, this was more clarity and intelligibility than the full-quality land line POTS. After a year or two their airwaves got crowded and it became apparent they were compressing the audio enough to be noticeably way worse than the POTS was. Cell carriers seem to have kept performance at that low level ever since. Plus lots of times it seems like it's no longer full-duplex, after a pause more like voice-activated from either end before it starts transmitting to the other party.
- smileysteve 4y agoHD Voice has been rolled out across multiple carriers for a couple of years in the US.
- solarkraft 4y agoIt's crazy to me how much telephony still sucks. We can stream 4K video but not some audio in reasonable quality?
- giantrobot 4y agoIf the audio of a phone call was pre-recorded on a good microphone it could sound awesome even over low bandwidth "voice" connections. Audio for voice calling is optimized almost entirely for latency. This means super short buffers and relatively simple encoding. Streaming video/audio has a distinct advantage of not having the same latency sensitivity. It's not a two way conversation so if the stream is a second or two behind the wall clock as long as it's in sync you're never going to know unless you're watching a stream of an event you can see live, then you'll see the encode and transfer delay. Besides latency, the microphone/audio input pipeline on a phone is in one of the shittiest recording environments it could be in. It's right next to the users mouth, sometimes far too close, so it needs automatic gain control to keep from being overdriven. It also needs to filter out the audio coming from the speaker lest it generates feedback. The microphone itself also needs to be very small and is attacked to the body of the phone so it's difficult to isolate from body sounds like the user's hand rubbing over the body. The fact a cell phone can even transmit reasonable sounding voice is a minor miracle involving many thousands of engineer-hours. The extra processing power and bandwidth available today to handle wideband voice helps a little with quality but it's still very latency sensitive and still suffers vs less latency sensitive codecs or one-way streaming.
- lucumo 4y agoI just figured I'd do some measurements of the different speeds. Location: in the center of a modern well isolated family home, with HR++ glass. So not ideal for optimal reception, but I didn't care to get up from the kitchen table. Tested with speedtest.net in the browser with Android Chrome. Network is T-Mobile NL. 5G: 69.52 Mbps down, 37 ms ping 4G: 56.79 Mbps down, 34 ms ping 3G: 4.01 Mbps down, 56 ms ping I'm not sure if T-Mobile is still keeping their 3G network at optimal performance. All their competitors have phased out 3G. They'll probably follow soon (though only 2G phase out is announced). Anyway, 4G → 5G is an improvement, but not orders of magnitude. That might be a bit much to expect though. I also measured my wifi/fiber connection. Got to 162.86 Mbps and 17 ms ping. Still much better than the mobile networks. (And lower than I expected, so probably time to debug a bit.)
- SSLy 4y agoFor a comparision, 80's apartment complex on a city outskirts 5G: Rx 233 mbps, Tx 90 mbps, ping 18 ms 4G (LTE): Rx 185 mbps, Tx 63 mbps, ping 19 ms It's hard for me to tell where is the 5G tower, but the LTE one is on the condo block across the street. EDIT: I think they're co-located. I guess it just depends on what is the infrastructure around you and how close is it.
- usr1106 4y ago> I'm not sure if T-Mobile is still keeping their 3G network at optimal performance. All their competitors have phased out 3G. They'll probably follow soon (though only 2G phase out is announced). Are you saying in the NL 2G networks will be closed before 3G networks? In Germany 3G networks are already closed, in Finland closing has been announced. But 2G networks are promised to run still for years.
- lucumo 4y agoIt looks like T-Mobile is the only one to phase out 2G before 3G. The other two networks (KPN, Vodafone) have already phased out 3G, but will keep 2G until 2025. T-Mobile announced 2G phase out will finish in June this year, but hasn't announced 3G phase out yet.
- MisterBastahrd 4y agoI'm about half a mile from a 5G tower and have been using a T-Mobile hotspot for about a month because the only telco that has run internet on my side of the street (in a town that literally has fiber 300 feet away) is AT&T, and then they only have DSL. This is in a Dallas suburb. AT&T? Nearly 90 bucks for 50Mbps down, 12 up. T-Mobile? 50 bucks 140 down, 50 up during peak times.
- anecdotal1 4y agoCancel your T-Mobile and buy a Calyx (also using T-Mobile) and you'll be paying ~$45/mo (after hotspot device cost) and have no data cap or throttling (it's real, grandfathered contract from Clearwire) I can do 800mbit+ on mine, symmetrical.
- xchip 4y agoIn Belgium 4G speed was capped, nibody notices it, the speed was enough, but still deployed 5G as if it was going to be a game changer.
- joshspankit 4y agoI just now asked a non-technical friend (who knows nothing about 5G besides it’s supposed to be better): “5G towers are faster but they have less range. What problems would you expect when rolling it out across the nation?” They identified all of the major ones in the article. Just like many in tech did when 5G was announced. And yet somehow we’re still here.
- kriro 4y agoI think 5G is more of an enterprise technology than consumer tech. For me latency and "campus networks" (or simply the ability to apply for a license to operate your own 5G network in a fixed location) are the two most interesting things about 5G. Those are clearly valuable if you think about a production line of connected devices in some fixed geographic location (factory etc.). Pure download speeds etc. don't matter that much to me, 4G was already plenty. The rollout is a bit curious though. In Germany providers are incentivised to connect people no cover area (iirc they have to connect at least x% of the population). Sort of makes sense but also cuts off potentially very interesting use cases (for example rural areas where 5G could be used for agricultural machinery).
- blurbleblurble 4y ago5G is preliminary sensing infrastructure. Don't take my word for it, go read and watch all the IEEE and 5G/6G industry literature that spells this out in great detail. "Integrated sensing and communication" is the search term to get you started.
- s3p 4y agoThis article is a disappointment, not 5G. Cellular speeds have been increasing at an increasing rate over the last few years. Things have been getting much better for consumers. The article cites the lack of mmWave as the reason 5G is getting "slower" but then kills its own argument by explaining how mmWave has almost zero range. What is this article even trying to accomplish?
- JohnFen 4y agoThe real problem with 5G, in my opinion, was the usual problem with tech -- the hype. All of the exaggerated and unrealistic tales about the possibilities were heard as promises by most people, and those are promises that 5G cannot meet in the real world. The reality is that 5G was hugely desired by the telecoms because it eases their problem with the amount of load the cell system has to carry. And deploying it is very expensive, so they wanted public money to help. Which means they wanted to get people excited about it, thus the hype machine was put into overdrive.
- johnea 4y agoHmmm, maybe because the whole thing was marketing bullshit from the benginning?