52 ms·
New study: 70% of type 2 diabetes cases linked to food choices
- remote_phone 4y agoWhen I first came to Silicon Valley, the free soda really hurt me. I gained 30 lbs because I was drinking over 6 cokes a day. I didn’t realize the damage it would do and now I have type 2 diabetes.
- metadat 4y agoWhat about consumption of processed sugar? (e.g. ice cream, candy, cookies, brownies, and all the foods from the grocery stores in the United States with sugar discreetly sprinkled in). Personally, I know if I consume too much of the above for several days, weeks, or months prior to a blood test, my A1C will be fucked up and bad. I am quite athletic, trim, and thin.
- fowtowmowcow 4y ago"Of the 11 dietary factors considered, three had an outsized contribution to the rising global incidence of type 2 diabetes: Insufficient intake of whole grains, excesses of refined rice and wheat, and the overconsumption of processed meat. Factors such as drinking too much fruit juice and not eating enough non-starchy vegetables, nuts, or seeds, had less of an impact on new cases of the disease. “Our study suggests poor carbohydrate quality is a leading driver of diet-attributable type 2 diabetes globally, and with important variation by nation and over time,” says senior author Dariush Mozaffarian, Jean Mayer Professor of Nutrition and dean for policy at the Friedman School. “These new findings reveal critical areas for national and global focus to improve nutrition and reduce devastating burdens of diabetes.” Type 2 diabetes is characterized by the resistance of the body’s cells to insulin. Of the 184 countries included in the Nature Medicine study, all saw an increase in type 2 diabetes cases between 1990 and 2018, representing a growing burden on individuals, families, and healthcare systems. The research team based their model on information from the Global Dietary Database, along with population demographics from multiple sources, global type 2 diabetes incidence estimates, and data on how food choices impact people living with obesity and type 2 diabetes from multiple published papers. The analysis revealed that poor diet is causing a larger proportion of total type 2 diabetes incidence in men versus women, in younger versus older adults, and in urban versus rural residents at the global level. Regionally, Central and Eastern Europe and Central Asia —particularly in Poland and Russia, where diets tend to be rich in red meat, processed meat, and potatoes —had the greatest number of type 2 diabetes cases linked to diet. Incidence was also high in Latin America and the Caribbean, especially in Colombia and Mexico, which was credited to high consumption of sugary drinks, processed meat, and low intake of whole grains."
- 19h 4y agoCorrelation does not equal causation. Diets high in red meat and fat have been the norm for most of human history, yet diabetes has only become an epidemic in recent decades. The real culprits are the processed foods and sedentary lifestyles of modern life, not traditional diets.
- rcme 4y agoBut they specifically called out processed meats, not just red meat.
- morsch 4y agoRed meat consumption in the US may be down compared to the 70s, but I'm pretty sure it's up compared to the human average 100, 500, 1000, 5000, 10000 and 50000 years ago. Overall meat consumption (per capita per year) in the US has increased continuously and quite significantly from around 90kg in 1960 to around 120kg in 2000 and stable since then. https://www.theguardian.com/environment/datablog/2009/sep/02/meat-consumption-per-capita-climate-change https://www.theguardian.com/environment/datablog/2009/sep/02...
- riceart 4y agoDiscreetly? It’s on the nutrition label. I don’t think candies and ice cream today are particularly less healthy than they were 50 years ago - and there are clearly more options today. It’s easier to eat healthy today than it ever was - this is not why people are getting fat. This is an unwinnable conflict between population medicine and policy and individual choice.
- maxerickson 4y agoCandy has probably gotten larger and easier to eat. Like compare a peppermint to stuff like peppermint M&Ms.
- riceart 4y agoNo - in general shrinkflation is a thing - and it tends that things peaked 20 to 30 years ago. Many junk food items are larger than when they hit the shelves but substantially smaller than their peak sizes.
- cronix 4y agoAn example since the pandemic, a "pint" of Hagen Dazs ice cream is no longer a pint (16oz). They are now 14oz. Same with most other brands that come in that size container. Halloween candy also got pretty microscopic. The "bite size" snickers, etc, are like 1/4 the size they used to be.
- CincinnatiMan 4y agoHaagen Dazs has been 14 oz for several years now, possibly even more than a decade.
- bookofjoe 4y ago>Beginning in late January 2009, 16-ounce cartons shrunk to 14 ounces, and two months later the larger 32-ounce pots lost 4 ounces. The price for either carton, however, stayed the same. https://www.cnbc.com/2014/04/09/shrinkflation-the-consumer-goods-that-have-down-sized.html https://www.cnbc.com/2014/04/09/shrinkflation-the-consumer-g... Impressive memory!
- mumblemumble 4y agoI would guess that processed grains and starches (i.e., stuff made of flour - even flour made from "whole grains", Veggie Straws, stuff like that) is still a bigger problem for most people. My understanding is that they get digested so quickly and efficiently that, from a nutritional perspective, they're equivalent to sugar.
- adgjlsfhk1 4y agoimo, the biggest contributor is soda. soda is roughly half as many grams of sugar as ice cream, but eating half a soda bottle of ice cream would make most people puke
- rcme 4y agoA can of coke has 39g of sugar. A 14oz Haagen Dazs vanilla bean ice cream contains 32g per serving and 84g in the entire 14oz container. A 2L bottle of Coke contains 220g of sugar. So half a bottle is less than 1.5 ice creams.
- adhesive_wombat 4y ago39g/355ml[1] is almost exactly half (54%) of 84g/414ml. So Coke is indeed half the volumetric sugar content of ice cream. However, I think I probably could fairly handily eat half a Coke-can's worth of ice cream! Half a 2L-bottle's worth of ice cream (1L) would not end well, whereas 2L of Coke is a lot but definitely possible. [1] Had never realised US cans were slightly larger than what we have (330ml).
- boomboomsubban 4y agoThis seems to be saying fast food hamburgers are a much bigger cause of type 2 diabetes than the soda. Not what I assumed, though does reflect those I know with type 2 diabetes now that I think about it. The journal article breaks it down semi geographically, and call Western Europe and North America "high income countries." Probably a better term than "Western countries," but looks out of place between "Central/Eastern Europe and Central Asia" and "Latin America and the Caribbean."
- markus_zhang 4y agoI remember back then I heard a theory (didn't validate) that either sugar or fat is fine but consuming both at the same time is bad.
- ambrose2 4y agoAnd several weeks ago there was an article here on HN about some research showing that ice cream wasn’t unhealthy (for something, I forget, heart disease?). Seems safer to just eat less processed foods.
- bombcar 4y agoEven something like "ice cream" can be a very basic milk/cream/salt or something with sugar or something whose list of ingredients would make a petroleum engineer blush and run.
- dangwhy 4y agoi remember some bro saying that its because that combo never occurs in nature outside of milk.
- bobthepanda 4y agoThe problem with 'high income countries' is that, well, East Asia exists. TBH, they should probably break down East Asia into China, the rest of East Asia, and SEA. That's a huge lump of very wildly varying peoples.
- jmartrican 4y agoReally confused as to how processed meats lead to an insulin resistance disease. Also, I thought refined carbs have similar glucose index as their non-refined counter parts, so how would adding more insulin inducing foods be beneficial? And how come the grand daddy of insulin spikes, sugar, isn't a factor?
- btilly 4y agoThe non-refined versions may release as much glucose, but they don't do it all at once. Also the fiber that they contain is good for you. Processed meats contain a LOT of salt. Salt doesn't cause diabetes, but it does cause water retention and high blood pressure, so is bad for people with diabetes. As for sugar, they are on the list of foods they examined. What they found is that we're eating more French fries, so that turns out to be a bigger factor in practice.
- thih9 4y ago> Processed meats contain a LOT of salt. Salt doesn't cause diabetes, but it does cause water retention and high blood pressure, so is bad for people with diabetes. Why is salt / bad influence for people with diabetes relevant in this context? Weren’t we interested in meat in relation to the rising global incidence of diabetes? Cottage cheese, shrimp, canned tuna and more also are high in sodium.
- SoftTalker 4y agoProcessed meats often also contain a lot of sugar. Breakfast sausage, bacon, etc. frequently have added sugar.
- epistasis 4y agoEven beef jerky has ridiculous amounts of sugar, it's hard to find a brand that doesn't have more sugar calories than protein calories. I tend to cook nearly all my own food anyway, but it would be nice to be able to pay somebody to make ready to eat foods that didn't include ridiculously needless additions.
- bitL 4y agoWould a pure chocolate (99% or 100%, no sugar at all) help avoid T2 due to increasing levels of adiponectin?
- noloblo 4y agoAdiponectin is a hormone and an adipokine protein that affects several metabolic processes and is mainly known for its insulin-sensitizing and anti-inflammatory effects. Your adipose tissue (body fat) is mainly responsible for producing adiponectin, though other tissues in your body produce it as well.
- abtinf 4y agoSerious question: what is the evidence that type 2 diabetes is caused by diet? I’ve seen this assertion made universally, but never any explanation of its scientific root.
- Operyl 4y agoIt's not universal, my mother is pre-diabetic, has a good diet, and isn't overweight.
- dangwhy 4y ago> isn't overweight i am not overweight but i am fat, if that makes sense. Lacking muscle makes you prone to low insulin sensitivity and t2d.
- Operyl 4y agoI guess it’s worth qualifying that my mother is not fat either, she’s a normal skinny human being with regular muscle density in this regard.
- dangwhy 4y agoyea unfortunately all these diseases have a lot do with cellular dysfunction from ageing. I ate mcdonalds and soda for 4 yrs in college everday but never had any diabetes.
- username989 4y agohttps://youtu.be/epgRw-vIRSA https://youtu.be/epgRw-vIRSA
- steve_adams_86 4y agoApart from this study, the disease isn’t linked to diets directly, but the result of diets if that makes sense. Obesity is a major factor. Being sedentary is another. Once you become pre diabetic it seems diet becomes a larger factor for more obvious reasons, but the path to get there in the first place doesn’t seem to require a specific diet. You could become obese eating anything and still wind up having very high risk for developing type 2 diabetes. I think this is a source of confusion because people develop it even though they became overweight on relatively healthy food. Or, at the very least, what they consider to be healthy food. As for this study it seems to indicate to me that certain foods are much easier to get obese with, so they’re linked to the disease. When you consider carbohydrate quality, a major difference between high and low quality sources is that the higher quality ones are harder to eat more of. That by default is a great protection from obesity. Foods which are harder to eat are almost always better for us if we struggle with portioning. Take raw carrots for example. You would struggle to become obese by eating raw carrots. On the other hand, you can casually drink like 4 carrots worth of calories in a few minutes via soda. And not feel full at all.
- candiddevmike 4y agoI've been suffering from hypoglycemia for a good part of my life, and recently the episodes have started to become a bit more frequent (a bad hypoglycemia episode is like an incredibly horrifying panic attack). Trying to figure out WTF is going on with me has been daunting, everyone tells me to eat more sugar or more complex carbs which just seems to repeat the cycle. No one wants to test me, or knows what to test me for, and right now I'm fighting to get a CGM so I can tie things with a food diary. Everything seems to revolve around food, but it's hard to figure out what's "bad food". Curious if anyone has had something similar.
- thedebuglife 4y agoI don’t know if this helps at all but there’s some ways to get a GCM from the private industry without needing a prescription, such as Nutrisense. I paid about $150 a month for it though.
- candiddevmike 4y agoTo me, that's a lot of money for a piece of plastic. I get that it's a medical device and needed lots of testing etc, but Nutrisense seems like too much "value add" to justify what they charge for it. Hopefully I can get a prescription and get this all covered by insurance.
- dangwhy 4y agoeven presciption is expensive. You can buy it on amazon in india but thats still like 80$/month.
- tsol 4y agoCGM's are fairly recent technology and they're all very expensive right now
- candiddevmike 4y agoAccording to Wikipedia, first CGM was approved in 1999. That may be recent for medical devices I guess, but it still seems like they're charging a lot for 20+ year old tech...
- SamoyedFurFluff 4y agoDoes that mean subbing out my rice for brown rice or subbing out my white sourdough for whole grain sourdough reduced risk?? Or if I still eat way too much whole wheat pasta it’ll still contribute to t2d down the line?
- Pxtl 4y agoI mean I'm 41 and mostly ate whole wheat and brown rice when I cooked and still got T2D, but on the other hand I have an incredible weakness for breakfast cereal -- not the sugary ones, just carb-loading on cheerios.
- dangwhy 4y agoyea i think its hard to pin down t2d to couple of foods like authors did. I've used cgm for months and i've noticed many things influence . > stress > body composition ( muscle is more sensitive to glucose/insulin). > meal and time of day > activity post meal ( chilling vs walking ect) > sleep
- snvzz 4y ago>breakfast When waking up, body goes overdrive into making glucose on its own. Eating breakfast at all seems to me like a bad idea. You want to keep the fast going for as long as possible, not break it.
- notshift 4y ago[flagged]
- ghotli 4y agoSeems like a submission like this should just link to it directly, rather than it being buried at the bottom. https://www.nature.com/articles/s41591-023-02278-8 https://www.nature.com/articles/s41591-023-02278-8
- mjevans 4y agoUnless there's an easy solution most of us are just going to die from this. I can't battle the market that wants to feed me supersized everything because that's where they can hide the cost of wages and offer an illusion of value. It needs to be tasty (enough), it needs to be cheap (at least enough to compete with the crap food that's already an option), and it needs to be an option everywhere. Clearly, regulation is required to force the market to offer healthy options for consumers.
- koolba 4y agoIt’s pretty easy to stop eating processed crap. Heck, it’s easy to stop eating entirely for most of the day. Skip breakfast and lunch. Have a single meal a day and use the time you saved from skipping the other meals to prepare something nutritious and delicious. It’s so easy that people have been doing it for thousands of years. Except now it’s even easier because you don’t have to stalk a gazelle or wake up at dawn to weed a garden.
- bombcar 4y agoThe skip is key in my experience - if you try to “eat something small” your body goes into “devour the entire McDonald’s” mode and it takes much more willpower.
- bni 4y agoDon't skip. Eat at least 3 meals a day with a good balance of Carbs, Protein and Fat. For a snack, have some whey protein. Then you will have the energy to lift weights 3 times a week, and do cardio (or just long walks) days inbetween.
- robopsychology 4y agoYes you can - stick to whole foods and cook reasonable portions. Mediterranean dishes are easy and healthy to cook. The rest of the world can do it, so can America!
- SamoyedFurFluff 4y ago
- jeffbee 4y agoWho else has trouble interpreting these guidelines? What's 300g of fruit in practical terms? I ate a huge honeycrisp apple for breakfast. It probably weighed 400 or 500g. Is that a whole day of fruit? Or, does it not really count because of the water content? I also ate half a dozen dried apricots. Am I supposed to mentally rehydrate them to arrive at the serving size? And what about this use of the term "optimal"? The way they are using it is to mean "there is no risk associated with exposure beyond the optimal intake exposure level" which to me suggests a word like "sufficient" instead. Can you just eat as much fruit as you like? I'm old and my eating habits aren't going to change but my children are both really interested in these topics and concerned about developing bad eating habits, even though I think I have given them healthy ones.
- senectus1 4y ago>I ate a huge honeycrisp apple for breakfast. It probably weighed 400 or 500g that is huge... a half kilo apple?!?!
- jghn 4y agoAnd one bred to have extra sugar to boot
- jeffbee 4y agoYeah they are pretty sweet, why I didn't eat anything else at breakfast. I am fairly sure that an all-apple diet would kill a person.
- Izikiel43 4y agoYeah, you can get cosmic crisp apples of around 400g
- NDizzle 4y agoI had one in my fridge most of last week waiting for the right time to strike. It was a serious apple and required a plan.
- prirun 4y agoMy personal, unsubstantiated opinion is that the food most people eat is now full of substances and chemicals that weren't there 50 years ago. A huge example is high fructose corn syrup. Almost everything is sweetened with that instead of cane sugar. Food manufacturers IMO only care about making food cheap, making us crave it, and making it last a long time on the shelf. They aren't concerned about making sure it is healthy, as long as it doesn't immediately kill us. Another example is artificial sweeteners. Studies have shown that sucralose (Splenda) reduces insulin resistance something like 17%. Is anyone making sure that everyone knows that? Hell no.
- cyounkins 4y agoHigh fructose corn syrup is a very poor example. It is composed of fructose and glucose, both very familiar molecules to our bodies.
- AbsoluteCabbage 4y ago[flagged]
- iambateman 4y agoSource? I googled and couldn’t find anything.
- hammock 4y agoHow could mercury have gotten into HFCS? Huge chlorine (chlor-alkali) plants using mercury cells produce “mercury-grade” caustic soda, hydro- chloric acid and other chemicals which are, in turn, used to produce thousands of other products, in- cluding food ingredients such as citric acid, sodium benzoate and HFCS.2 The mercury in these plants can contaminate their chemical products, as well as the broader environment. In HFCS production, caustic soda and hydrochloric acid are used to separate corn starch from the corn kernel, as well as to adjust the pH of the process. The HFCS industry, according to Vulcan Chemical Company, former operator of one of these plants, is a primary user of “mercury-grade” caustic soda and hydrochloric acid.2 The Environmental Health commentary provides data substantiating that mercury contaminating commercial HFCS is a problem. In the fall of 2008, we looked for total mercury in 55 brand-name food and beverage products where HFCS was the leading or second highest ingredient. An independent laboratory found total mercury, above the limit of detection, in about one in three products, including: dairy beverages, soft drinks, salad dressings, barbecue sauces, flavored syrups and jams. In other words, we found total mercury across the range of foods and beverages in which HFCS is routinely used.
- AbsoluteCabbage 4y agoYou mean eating a diet of pure sugar and vegetable oil might have consequences? :surprised pikachu:
- throw7 4y agoWake me up when it's causation not correlation.
- TechGoat 4y agoI've read a lot about avoiding whole grains lately as many of them contain lectins, a protein that disrupts the intestinal lining which causes leaky gut/inflammation. This inflammation can be disruptive for chronic diseases such as Diabetes. Curious what the ideal balance of grains would be.
- andreygrehov 4y agoTLDR from ChatGPT: A study by the Friedman School of Nutrition Science and Policy at Tufts University found a correlation between poor diet and 14 million cases of type 2 diabetes worldwide in 2018. Insufficient intake of whole grains, excess refined rice and wheat, and overconsumption of processed meat were identified as significant dietary factors. The research revealed that poor diet has a larger impact on men, younger adults, and urban residents. Central and Eastern Europe, Central Asia, Latin America, and the Caribbean saw the highest number of cases linked to diet. The study suggests that addressing dietary issues can help tackle the global type 2 diabetes epidemic.
- peteradio 4y agoI don't see one comment criticizing the study, below is the study design and below this section is much more information about how they generate the quotable number. It looks like at its core there are separate data sources which de-link the person with T2D to their specific diet features (I might be way off base here so please correct if I'm wrong). Instead they are doing quite some complicated fitting to deduce these numbers. I'm not an expert in this field, and even the field I am this type of statistical work would too much for me to easily understand, but I will say this: there is a lot of lost information and to me its difficult to know whether I should base dietary decisions on this. Anyway I do not need to be told processed meat is bad for me, it destroys my gut every time I eat it and still I go back for more. ---snip--- Study design A comparative risk assessment model55 estimated the numbers, proportions and uncertainty of global T2D cases attributable to suboptimal intake of key dietary factors (Extended Data Fig. 1). Comparative risk assessment does not use ecologic correlations to estimate risk but incorporates independently derived inputs and parameters on demographics, risk factors, their etiologic effects and disease incidence to model attributable burdens55. For this investigation, we leveraged input data and corresponding uncertainty in 184 countries on (1) population dietary intake distributions based on individual-level survey data from the GDD (http://www.globaldietarydatabase.org/)56; http://www.globaldietarydatabase.org/)56; (2) population overweight (BMI ≥ 25 kg m−2) and underweight (BMI < 18.5 kg m−2) distributions from the NCD-RisC57; (3) total T2D-incidence distributions from the Global Burden of Disease study58,59; (4) linear, BMI-stratified effects of dietary factors on weight gain or loss60; age-adjusted direct etiologic effects of these factors on T2D, adjusted for BMI, and of weight gain on T2D from previous meta-analyses and pooled analyses of prospective cohorts23,61,62; (5) optimal dietary intake levels from previous analyses12; and (6) population demographic data from the United Nations Population Division63,64 and the Baro and Lee 2013 dataset on educational attainment65 (Supplementary Table 6). https://www.nature.com/articles/s41591-023-02278-8 https://www.nature.com/articles/s41591-023-02278-8 ---snip---
- grumpy_coder 4y agoThe linked 'scientific' paper is just embarrassing. From the study design "A comparative risk assessment model estimated the numbers, proportions and uncertainty of global T2D cases attributable to suboptimal intake of key dietary factors." That's it, that's the whole paper, reporting what the risk assessment model estimated.
- andreareina 4y agoThe study in question: https://www.nature.com/articles/s41591-023-02278-8 https://www.nature.com/articles/s41591-023-02278-8
- tpoacher 4y agoSo, type 2 diabetes impacts your ability to eat certain foods?