8 ms·
If You Double-Park and You’re Rich, Should You Pay a Higher Fine?
- user3939382 4y agoI’ll just add that there are two guilty parties in double parking: the person who does it, and the municipality which failed to provide adequate parking infrastructure to the town.
- xorfish 4y agoThat is how you get to the current state of car dependence in the US. Parking costs a lot. It should not be subsidized.
- adamlett 4y agoWe should encourage less driving for many reasons, which is why municipalities should have fewer, not more parking spaces. If there aren’t enough available parking spaces, that’s a failure of pricing. Increase the price of parking to a level where there is always an acceptable number of available parking spots.
- generic92034 4y ago> Increase the price of parking to a level where there is always an acceptable number of available parking spots. That would be favoring rich people, though.
- zmgsabst 4y agoAll methods of decreasing driving are unduly burdensome on the poor. That’s why I object to these policies: They’re middle class and up people advocating that other people bear the burden for what they want done — often times, burdening the more productive members of society who perform critical jobs. If you actually thought it was important, you’d take unilateral action… instead of making “tragedy of the commons” excuses and demanding authoritarian impositions on lower classes. That kind of entitlement by the bourgeoise is how we ended up with the worst governments in human history — and I’m sad to see us repeating it.
- xorfish 4y agoCar dependence imposes a huge cost on the poor. With good public transportation and bicycle infrastructure, poor people wouldn't need a car. Reducing car dependence is a good thing for the poor.
- adamlett 4y agoIf only other countries existed that had implemented these policies, then we would have some evidence to indicate whether you were right or wrong.
- marcinzm 4y agoThe cost for unlimited public transportation in NYC is $127/month (not counting the 50% discount if you're extra poor). I dare you to prove that owning a car (depreciation, interest, gas, insurance, registration, taxes, tolls, maintenance, inspections, etc.) actually costs less than that per month.
- adamlett 4y agoPossibly, but let’s not lose sight of the goal, which is to get people to drive less. There is no solution to this problem that allows everyone to keep driving the same amount as they always have! It may seem unfair that a small number of sufficiently wealthy people do not have to change their behavior, but enjoying privileges that are not available to most people is what it means to be wealthy. And in the meantime, the rest of us can console ourselves by remembering that if only rich people drive because only they can afford it, at least they are bearing the full cost of it, and hopefully the money they pay will go to something all of us benefit from.
- CalRobert 4y agoSo?
- marcinzm 4y agoYou're free to use many of the available paid parking options which charge at the appropriate market rate for land in the areas.
- user3939382 4y agoFound the guy that’s never been to Hoboken.
- ethanbond 4y agoIt’s not the public’s job to provide storage for private citizens’ items
- CalRobert 4y agoThis is why I park my helicopter wherever I please as well, because of course, it's the municipality's responsibility to provide storage for my private vehicle.
- theshrike79 4y agoYes. Fines should be a percentage of income. That's how we have it in Finland and it works. Fines are supposed to hurt you financially, not be a cost of doing business that hurts poorer people disproportionally.
- Ekaros 4y agoNot parking fines, they are fixed amount by municipality. Parking fines, is bit more complicated. Maybe the tax rate of the car or some current price... Then again rich could get cheap car and just use that.
- masklinn 4y ago> Not parking fines, they are fixed amount by municipality. Why not parking fines? They can be set in day fines as well.
- Ekaros 4y agoI think average people would thing that they would be too high for the crime. Minimum day fine for someone without income is 6€. Now parking fine is I think depending locations is 20-80€. So you tell that this incomeless person parked the car. And we have set it at 5 day fines so 30€ at low end. On other hand day fine for median earner is around 35 €. Which would mean 180€ parkin fine. Most would think that to be excessive.
- masklinn 4y ago> Most would think that to be excessive. But is it? Alternatively, provide two values and select whichever is higher e.g. "30€ or 1 day", this method is common with corporate crimes (e.g. "1 million or 1.5% global revenue", that sort of things). Even if you're on the low end of incomes a day in jail would hurt a lot for a parking fine.
- jrvarela56 4y agoHow can you calculate someone’s income in a way that makes this feasible? Wealthy people 1) dont have most stuff to their name directly, 2) have capital gains which make income ‘spike-y’, 3) make money on many jurisdictions, many which may not be visible to the country fining the person Just curious how this works in practice
- vegancap 4y agoOn the fence on this one, because it seems unfair to punish someone more just because they're doing well, for essentially the same crime. But... there was a drug dealer in our block of flats once who had so much cash he'd park his BMW outside the door on double-yellows, and he'd just pay the £50 fine several times a week, just to save him a 3 minute walk to the car park... so, perhaps a system of increasingly punishing repeat offenders maybe?
- bearmode 4y agoBut why is it more fair to punish someone more because they're poor? Matching the fine to income/wealth is the best way to ensure the impact to the recipient of the fine is similar, regardless of personal wealth. A poor repeat offender may be bankrupted after just a handful of fines. A rich repeat offdner may be able to continue doing it hundreds of times afterwards without much issue.
- VulgarExigency 4y ago“The law, in its majestic equality, forbids rich and poor alike to sleep under bridges, to beg in the streets, and to steal their bread.”
- fwlr 4y agoIf you dispense the same punishment to two individuals and one is less able to withstand that punishment, are you punishing that person more? I’m not sure that the answer is a simple “yes”. For one, this would mean if you gave someone a 50% discount on their parking fine because they were poor, but it turned out they actually only had 25% of the assets of the rich person, you are still unfairly punishing the poor person more than the rich person. It can’t be correct that an observer has to know the financial status of every citizen to judge whether their government is being fair or not.
- sacrosancty 4y ago[dead]
- SpaceL10n 4y ago
- Aeolun 4y agoYes. Or rather, you should pay an amount that makes you likely to stop doing whatever it is regardless of wealth/income.
- self_awareness 4y agoAnd who is going to decide what is the proper amount?
- sacrosancty 4y ago[dead]
- Aeolun 4y agoThe same people that decide the amount now? Why would that change.
- captainbland 4y agoI think so. A person who already lives paycheque to paycheque can be put into a really bad position by a fine but that same fine isn't even the tiniest deterrent to somebody well off.
- mattlutze 4y agoYes. Simple penalties create classes of crime; wealthy folks just ignore the penalty on double parking some poor schmuck because who cares about a $100 fine when you're making $1M? These regulations are written to discourage unfair acts or behavior that exploites the social contract. It tells folks that the municipality thinks it's right for less-wealthy people to be burdened with providing comforts for more-wealthy people. Means-tested fines actually get to the point of it: dissuade all people from doing something dangerous, indefensibly rude, et cetera, and not just poor folks. For some additional discussion: https://www.theatlantic.com/business/archive/2015/03/finland-home-of-the-103000-speeding-ticket/387484/ https://www.theatlantic.com/business/archive/2015/03/finland...
- qazpot 4y agoShould rich people get less jail time because they lose more money because of time spent in jail (per day income is higher) than a poor person. Should a person with more children get less jail time because more children will be left without a parent as compared to a childless person.
- frereubu 4y agoI can't tell if you're being sarcastic or if these are genuine questions. I suspect the former, in which case you need to unpack your arguments a bit more.
- heywhatupboys 4y agoparking is a monetary fine, and thus directly related to the earnings of an individual.
- Arnt 4y agoA fine example of whataboutism. FWIW, both the country where I was born and the one where I live have chosen a simple approximation: Fines are set at "x typical daily earnings" and the court will estimate the equivalent in legal tender, jail time is set in days.
- 4y ago
- admissionsguy 4y agoNo. The rich would have already contributed disproportionately towards the maintenance of the infrastructure.
- Nemrod67 4y agoIn most western countries these days the tax level effectively decreases with wealth, so no... they might not have contributed "disproportionately" already
- admissionsguy 4y agoThey would have contributed disproportionately in absolute numbers, which are the actual numbers that get stuff built. It is of little help to anyone to pay a 50% tax if you don't earn or have much to begin with.
- fwlr 4y agoImagine a government with eleven citizens, ten of which earn a thousand dollars a year and pay 50% income tax on each dollar, while the eleventh earns one million dollars a year and pays just 10% income tax on each dollar. If the government then spends every tax dollar on building a road, that road has been ~95% paid for by one citizen and ~5% paid for by the other ten. It’s quite possible in principle for the wealthiest people to pay a lower tax rate than poorer people, yet still contribute disproportionately to public funds. (In fact something like this dynamic is indeed happening in most Western countries, the top 1% usually account for more than one third of total tax dollars paid.)
- alanfranz 4y agoSuch one citizen still earns like 1000 other citizens. Fairness is hard to establish in an highly skewed distribution. Nevertheless, I genuinely think that modern governments need to shift taxation from earnings to wealth (especially regarding natural monopolies)
- ofalkaed 4y agoUS is far to lax when it comes to cars/driving, just take the car and or licence of repeat offenders, make them earn it back. My neighbor was recently complaining to me about how it was unfair that his unpaid parking tickets amounted to more than the value of his car.
- steffandroid 4y agoNot just a higher fine, wealthy offenders should also have their driving licenses revoked and their vehicles seized.
- decross 4y agoAnd young people should get longer sentences? The younger, the longer?
- FactualActuals 4y agoIt doesn't help that the size of SUVs and Pickup trucks have grown over the past 20 years. They take up more width and the length of truck beds are shrinking in place of more cabin space. I would love to find a truck that has a similar profile to a Chevy S10/GMC Sonoma but manufacturers are pushing bigger and bigger trucks to the market.
- RcouF1uZ4gsC 4y agoAnother option for New York is that if you have too many civil violations you get banned from Broadway, Maddison Square Garden, and the Opera for the year. This would have minimal impact on the poor, but would probably motivate the rich to avoid these civil fines.
- self_awareness 4y agoNo. For rich people it's trivial to hide their income: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/One-dollar_salary https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/One-dollar_salary -- it would only make things worse for the middle class, which is the worst class of all: too rich to get any help from the government, too poor to hire lawyers. So, you guys try to hit the rich guy, but you hit the middle class guy instead, who pays all the taxes. Good job!
- bearmode 4y agoSorry mate but no, the worst class of all are those facing homelessness every month and forgoing meals because they simply can't afford food.
- self_awareness 4y agoI don't agree and your answer kind of proves my point. They themselves don't have any responsibility, and they're not contributing anything to the society, yet they're the class that everyone defends and everyone pays for. Also if you're a registered homeless person they you're eligible for free food. Nobody thinks about the middle class, only IRS. (I'm ready for downvotes)
- bearmode 4y agoSo you'd take the constant threat of bankruptcy, homelessness, and starvation over being middle class, then?
- xtiansimon 4y agoHow about an “ascending” scale?
- sohkamyung 4y agoSingapore includes a demerit points system for some driving offences. Under this system, a driver "who accumulates 24 or more demerit points within 24 months will be suspended for a period of 12 weeks." [1] So while richer people may not be hurt as much by the fines, they are more at risk of being suspended from driving if they repeat the offending behaviour within a certain time period. [1] https://www.motorist.sg/article/534/traffic-offences-in-singapore-demerit-points-composition-fines-2023-update https://www.motorist.sg/article/534/traffic-offences-in-sing...
- vivegi 4y agoThat is a can of worms. What is the operational definition of Rich? - Networth? - Income? - Net Taxable Income? Instead, it can be an escalating penalty that is based on repeat offences; increasing fines for repeat offences, culiminating in something like losing driving privileges, impounding of the vehicle, permanent loss of driving privileges etc.,
- adamlett 4y agoIt doesn’t seem that difficult to me. It’s obviously net worth.
- xboxnolifes 4y agoMax(X% net worth, Y% Income, Z% taxable income) Fixed.
- 0xbadc0de5 4y agoWhat part of "equal under the law" did they sleep through in grade school? I understand that thinking is hard and it's much easier to just adopt the opinions presented by someone who gets paid by advertising products to you. But please try to think this one through. Arbitrary punishment based on class or wealth or any other factor not related to the crime is a hallmark of a banana republic, not a civilised society. Parking fines are a Trojan Horse - once such a scheme is adopted, it will be applied throughout the legal system.
- archagon 4y agoThen the well-off will just do whatever the fuck they want for a small “service charge”.
- 0xbadc0de5 4y agoNo, they won't. That is not rational thinking. You could probably afford one parking ticket per year, so do you go out and deliberately double park once a year? Quick sanity check - Any time you see/hear "rich people will do X" or "rich people should do X", just replace "rich people" with "I" to see if it makes sense. Just because someone has more than you does not make them any better or worse of a person than you. Same goes for the contrary, just because someone has less than you...
- archagon 4y agoThey already do. And the wealthier you are, the more likely you are to have sociopathic, psychopathic, and narcissistic traits: * https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/how-wealth-reduces-compassion/ https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/how-wealth-reduce... * https://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/2016/09/13/1-in-5-ceos-are-psychopaths-australian-study-finds/ https://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/2016/09/13/1-in-5-ceos-are-... (Sure, call these pop sci if you want, but I'm not going to seek out primary sources for the sake of an internet comment.) > just replace "rich people" with "I" to see if it makes sense Would I become more of an asshole if I had orders of magnitude more money than the average person? It certainly wouldn't surprise me. At the very least, my ego would get quite inflated.
- PrimeMcFly 4y agoIf fines are not proportional than they only punish the poor.
- jacknews 4y agoJust make fines be time, not money. A parking fine is 2 hours washing dishes serving meals to homeless people, or cleaning the shelter toilets, etc.
- throwawa14223 4y agoNo. A fine should represent the negative externality to society. Flexibility indicates that society is interested in cash not the prevention of the externality.