10 ms·
Minetest: An open source voxel game engine
- gjsman-1000 4y agoMinetest is nowhere near Minecraft… but it’s still fun, and I wish the developers the best (especially as Minecraft gets more and more heavy-handed). I would strongly recommend that anyone playing Minetest get a texture pack, basically any would do, because the stock textures do not leave a good impression.
- comrad 4y agoMinetest is really just a base game and an engine. Look into Mineclone2, a minetest-game. https://content.minetest.net/packages/Wuzzy/mineclone2/ https://content.minetest.net/packages/Wuzzy/mineclone2/
- nathan_compton 4y agoI play Minetest 2 with my kids and we have a great time.
- magicalhippo 4y agoI tried that recently but I found the landscape generation to be really poor. I tried all the various generators, to no avail. It's been a while since I played Minecraft but I can't recall the maps being that poorly constructed. It really distracted me from the game, to the point I stopped after just a few hours. Rest was pretty good tho, so a shame.
- em-bee 4y agoi found a server with a nice community, which is what keeps me playing. but to start my own world i'd wish for better map generators. more realistic mountains, rivers, climates, etc. and maybe some powerful tools would be nice, to efficiently build streets or dig new rivers, grow mountains, ... so you can efficiently create a map by hand, or modify a map to add or remove features. fortunately, new map generators are being worked on, so there is hope for the future.
- opan 4y agoI agree with the first half of what you said, but for people considering MineClone2, be aware that it doesn't have the same mod support as the base game, and so modifying it doesn't always work well. It also adds some of Minecraft's limitations that were otherwise missing in Minetest, such as a more restrictive height limit in both directions. You can normally dig much much deeper and climb much higher in Minetest than Minecraft, and I think this is one of the cooler parts of Minetest. MineClone2 is fun if you know Minecraft and you want something ready to play immediately, but if you have a background of playing modded Minecraft, don't expect to be able to take all the cool Minetest mods and slap them over MineClone2. This means you're playing a clone of vanilla Minecraft. For many this isn't very fun anymore. You'll probably want to start from scratch and build on top of the default minetest_game to enjoy all the cool mods out there, such as df_caverns.
- detaro 4y agoWhen you say "Minetest", are you referring to the default "game" that comes with it? The game engine part is important!
- George83728 4y agoIt would be nice if the default "Minetest Game" were less bare bones, since that is the experience most people new to minetest will probably encounter first. Some decisions in "Minetest Game", like broken blocks going straight into your inventory instead of falling to the ground, seem like they're different for the sake of being different; I have a gut feeling the Minetest devs are consciously staying off Mojang's turf.
- teddyh 4y agos/Mojang/Microsoft/
- uvnq 4y agoAs a fan of older minecraft versions I'm looking forward to messing around with this with friends
- esskay 4y agoOlder java minecraft is still very much alive and well. There's thousands of servers that still use old versions and have hundreds, sometimes thousands of members online at a time.
- gatane 4y agoA minecraft classic client made in C, with its own launcher. https://www.classicube.net/ https://www.classicube.net/
- mvdl 4y agoI like the way the mineyest ecosystem is progressing. I am a huge fan of Minecraft and we turned it into a family thing running our own server. But the take-over by Microsoft feels like a pain and I really dislike that since the move to Microsoft I now have to grant my teen daughters access via a family page.
- teekert 4y agoYeah this is really annoying. My son had friends over, I told them about our MC servers (even with Java/Bedrock cross Play!). Cool! Then I spend the next 30 min calling parents and feeling like talking them into letting their kids watch the pron our family server :| I’m not doing that again.
- bobwaycott 4y agoMinetest was the vehicle through which I first introduced my youngest son to programming around 7-8 years ago (iirc). The way his eyes lit up when he wrote some code to change the game and then played it was just magic. He still—as a freshman CS student wrapping up his first year—fondly remembers those magical feelings today.
- darkteflon 4y agoCame here to ask about just this! May I ask how old he was at the time? I’m considering trying this with our 6 year-old, who is a huge Minecraft fan. Looks to me as though it would probably be beyond him but, on the other hand, I would at least like to try to re-create that “aha!” moment with VS Code on one half of the screen and this on the other.
- bobwaycott 4y agoHe was around 11-12 at the time. He and his brother were huge Minecraft fans (they still play all these years later), and he wanted to learn how to change the game like mods did. I worried Java would be a bit much and might get in the way of him just trying some simple things out, and Lua seemed much simpler and approachable for me to help him with. He was also a big superhero fan, so his first 3 modifications were to give himself superpowers. We added the ability to fly like Superman, run fast like the Flash, and jump huge distances like the Hulk. His favorite moment was when he activated the speedforce() and hulk_jump() together and realized he didn’t even need to fly because the speed-running and massive jump moved him further across the map at a faster rate of speed than his superman() function did. :)
- darkteflon 4y agoWonderful, love it :) Thanks so much - this’ll be our project this weekend. I’ll set everything up so he can just change a couple variables and see the effect immediately. We’ll see where we get to!
- bobwaycott 4y ago
- George83728 4y agoMinetest has a lot of promise, but also has a lot of low-hanging fruit, particularly around the fit and finish of the game. For instance the configuration GUIs for setting up your controls is pretty bad, you still can't reconfigure your mouse keys without editing minetest.conf Still, it gives me hope that if Microsoft ever ruins Minecraft somehow, minetest should prove to be a good foundation for community-run block game.
- fnordpiglet 4y agoThe Minecraft IAP and server spam is getting pretty close.
- rmorey 4y agoThis is the major reason I stay away from bedrock versions, java seems to have way less of this
- bscphil 4y ago> if Microsoft ever ruins Minecraft somehow Honestly I haven't touched Minecraft since Microsoft started enforcing "you have to have a Microsoft account". It's not ruining the game per se, and it's not an overwhelmingly burdensome thing, it has just raised the activation energy of getting back into the game enough that I haven't summoned the will yet.
- mikepurvis 4y agoI bought Minecraft for my son and I've been extremely frustrated by this requirement and that there's seemingly no way to stay signed in— I've had to print out my MS account details and tape them to his computer so he can sign in whenever he needs.
- esskay 4y agoI'd recommend using a launcher, it stops that happening. I use Prism Launcher and after the initial sign in about a year ago I've never been asked to log in again even after going a few months of not playing it.
- jamilton 4y agoA Minetest game I recommend is Nodecore: https://content.minetest.net/packages/Warr1024/nodecore/ https://content.minetest.net/packages/Warr1024/nodecore/ Description: "A surreal dream-world where everything is possible but nothing is easy. Peaceful and Zen. Brutally obstinate. Prepare to unlearn everything you thought you knew about voxel sandbox games." "Brutally obstinate" is right, it's pretty mystifying and I didn't get very far when I played it, but it's definitely interesting. It's like heavily modded Minecraft from another dimension. If you like a game where figuring out how to play is part of the challenge, I think you'd like Nodecore.
- anthk 4y agoSo this is like Minetest blended with The Powder Toy?
- poopsmithe 4y agoI had a Minecraft background and I disliked Nodecore. I would not recommend Nodecore if you want a minecraft-like experience.
- xigoi 4y agoFor a more Minecraft-like – but still unique – experience, I recommend MeseCraft: http://mesecraft.com/ http://mesecraft.com/
- xigency 4y agoThe lineage of voxel miners is quite interesting. MineCraft is obviously trailblazing, but it was preceded by a few others like Infiniminer. I would say I feel bad that early projects like those didn’t make billions from success, but there is a lot to be said about the creative gameplay in MineCraft that change it from being a simple sandbox to a really engaging world.
- bibanez 4y agoThe creator of Infiniminer is the same dev behind Zachtronics, who made Shenzen I/O and exa punks, for example
- xigency 4y agoTIS-100 is also quite fun
- the_lonely_road 4y agoIf you like the genre you should check out Colony Survival! It’s a fun voxel game with a tight gameplay loop based around how high can you make number go up though observation.
- grapesurgeon 4y agoits an interesting project with a lot of promise, but its not something id rather play over minecraft honestly. i hate what microsoft has done with minecraft for sure though.
- beardog 4y agoIt is best to think of Minetest as more of a decentralized open source roblox instead of a minecraft clone as one may initially think since it is more of a game engine than a game.
- opan 4y agoThis is a pretty good way to put it. There are some similarities to Garry's Mod as well. All three are moddable with lua, and Garry's Mod's approach to mods on servers where you connect and automatically download what's needed is more similar to what Minetest does than what modded Minecraft does (where you need to prepare the exact right set of mods ahead of time or you can't connect).
- dang 4y agoRelated: Minetest, an open source infinite-world block sandbox game - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22818192 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22818192 - April 2020 (1 comment) Minetest – Open source voxel game engine - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18282085 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18282085 - Oct 2018 (1 comment) Minetest – A free, open-source voxel game engine and game - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12670310 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12670310 - Oct 2016 (54 comments) also: Minetest for the Web - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33207408 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33207408 - Oct 2022 (41 comments)
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- emmelaich 4y agoIf you like this you may want to also have a look at voxraygames by the irrepressible @Aardappel Video here: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XlNTKN4HSJQ https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XlNTKN4HSJQ
- jesse__ 4y agoThat looks awesome. I'm really looking forward to some high-fidelity voxel engines getting more mature
- kragen 4y agois this going to be proprietary
- Aardappel 4y agoThe actual game itself, yes. Based on this open source project though which provides the language its written in and core engine tech: https://github.com/aardappel/lobster https://github.com/aardappel/lobster
- bullen 4y agoUses lobster programming language apparently.
- Aardappel 4y agoYes, for both gameplay and most of the engine.
- Aardappel 4y agoThanks for the support :) More here: https://twitter.com/voxraygames https://twitter.com/voxraygames
- CaesarA 4y agoReminds me of Ken Silverman's old projects.
- snvzz 4y agoI still remember Mojang's promise to open source Minecraft. Instead, he sold it to Microsoft. /o\
- nsxwolf 4y agoFor $2.5 billion I would absolutely renege on a promise to open source my code. Every time.
- xmzx 4y ago[flagged]
- snvzz 4y agoIf I was already rich (Like Mojang was), I actually wouldn't. YMMV.
- CobrastanJorji 4y agoCounterplan: accept the $2.5 billion. Spend $10 million to fund the development of an equivalent or better open source voxel game engine. Everyone wins.
- leansensei 4y agoHis agreement probably prohibits that.
- CobrastanJorji 4y agoFund it in secret. Name it "Minetest."
- Gigachad 4y agoNotch ended up set for life and distributed out huge sums of cash to all of the employees after the sale who were not rich. At the end of the day its a video game, not firmware for someones heart implant. If it matters to anyone, they can just write their own video game.
- 1val 4y agoPeople should start with building a voxel engine as performant as possible that would allow for player count to scale with hardware to eventually allow for millions of players on the same map. What makes games like minecraft great is the gameplay that naturally emerges from player interaction. This aspect of voxel engines should be actively pushed to the absolute limit. People in the gaming sector tend to apply new tech to improve old overdone gameplay (like making games more hd) instead of enabling previously impossible experiences.
- sanqui 4y agoJohn Lin's voxel engine showed a lot of promise in this department: https://m.youtube.com/@johnlin9665/videos https://m.youtube.com/@johnlin9665/videos
- Gigachad 4y agoDoesn’t seem like many games at all have achieved this. If any. Seems like an extremely difficult problem to try and shard a multi player game on to multiple machines while still being able to interact with everyone.
- hot_gril 4y agoNiantic gave a talk on the Pokémon Go scaling experience, and yeah. That one even has the advantage of not too many people being in one place.
- bullen 4y agoI'm working on it.
- dekhn 4y agoI played for a while, and eventually found a nice collection of mods that were all compatible with each other and made the game really fun. I can't remember all the details, but it made the game a bit more fun. Some were additional items (more complete carpet selection, mobs, biomes), some were functionality enhancements (crafting guide), some were for automation (digilines), travel (elevators). It was pretty fun and whatever "game" (set of rules/textures/etc) I did had some very deep caverns to explore.
- Shared404 4y agoI've always bounced off of Minetest at the "build a game out of modpacks" stage. Anyone have recommendations? Nodecore looks fun, am open to others as well.
- GartzenDeHaes 4y agoMineClone2 is somewhat like an older Java version of MC.
- opan 4y agoYou could try joining a public server (I don't have any recommendations, don't play on them much myself) and seeing what mods they use, or just browse the contentdb for stuff that looks cool. This is definitely an issue that makes the game less approachable to new players. It's hard to get the ideal experience of a bunch of cool mods that work well together if you don't already know which mods are good or have a friend hosting a server for you that put the mods together.
- sundarurfriend 4y agoTake a look at MultiCraft, a fork. I paid (less than a dollar) for the mobile version, but my understanding is that you can compile the repo code and get a runnable version yourself (whether for PC or Android). It's on Github.
- tmtvl 4y agoI haven't tried it yet, but Techage looks interesting. Might be as close to GregTech as we can get in Minetest (GregTest?).
- haolez 4y agoWhen my daughter gets a little older, I'm going to try setting up a similar project on my home lab: https://veloren.net/ https://veloren.net/
- platz 4y agoJust tried it, the visuals aren't bad, but the player control and inventory management seem like an afterthought. The jumping physics feels especially unrealistic.
- kragen 4y agoandroid or desktop? mtg, nodecore, or mineclone (and if so, which mineclone)? which texture pack? etc.
- platz 4y agoIt does let you run it without downloading any "games" btw. If that's not the intended experience they shouldn't make that the shortest path UI experience. but fwiw, I just tried mineclone and at least the jumping physics were better.
- sundarurfriend 4y agoThat's been a long running debate in the community, whether the "MineTestGame" should be included by default anymore. At some point MTG seemed slated to be even discontinued as a project, but instead it got some fixes for outstanding issues and kept intact. In my case, when I was starting out, it was a nice way to incrementally add game features only when I was ready for them, with MTG being the base to start from. So I have a bit of a soft spot for it.
- wg0 4y agoI understand what is a database server and what is a web server but what is a Minecraft server? What does it store? Whole map and state and user accounts? Is there some sort of federation or one has to create an account on every server? Server is also in Java? Requires GPU as well? Open source servers also exist? What is griefing? No idea about any of this never played Minecraft. Edit: Typos and open source
- drones 4y agoFrom my own experience running a server for friends: No federation. For either version of minecraft you have an account you register with microsoft, which among other things provides you with a UUID, allowing users to be identified and authenticated across different servers. The various UUID authentication utilities are not necessary to set up a server, they are just offered for security. Minecraft servers store world data, NPC states, and player inventories. All server data is unique to that server (e.g players cannot take an inventory from one game server and transfer it to another, or access worlds from different servers) There are two versions of Minecraft: Java (written in java, only available on PC) and Bedrock (available on all platforms, and also allow cross play between platforms). PC players generally prefer Java as it was the first version and supports modding. The server side of minecraft Java is also written in java. Not sure what the GPU part is referencing. Minetest in particular is open source, by the fact that the underlying game engine can be modified to create new functionality not available in the base game. In regular Minecraft there is restriction on what exactly a Minecraft server can do and what client-side modifications can be made. Griefing is basically trolling in game: destroying other player's buildings, repeatedly killing them in game, etc. Some server moderators will allow this, some don't. Hope this helps :)
- simion314 4y agoBedrock is only for Windows on PC.
- zimpenfish 4y agoIsn't Bedrock now basically "anything that isn't the Java edition"? Like iOS, consoles, etc.?
- socceroos 4y agoI've got Minetest on my machines. Another good one along these lines is Veloren. It's a Rust voxel game along the lines of minecraft and Dwarf Fortress. https://veloren.net/ https://veloren.net/
- parlortricks 4y agonever heard of this before looks great
- rain1 4y agoIs there a mod that adds PNP/NPN style transistors?
- billfruit 4y agoDoes it support an isometric camera? Or a RTS like zoomable camera?
- mikae1 4y agoI enjoyed https://veloren.net/ https://veloren.net/ more. Open source too.
- SquareWheel 4y agoI'd say Veloren is closer to Cube World, while Minetest is closer to Minecraft. Both are cool projects, though.
- tjoff 4y agoI do not mind the minecraft aesthetic, but it feels a bit weird if all voxels evolved into was that. Most promising showcase (for its time) that I know of was Delta Force from 1998 in which the landscape geometry was vastly more detailed. But then again I haven't been paying attention and might be missing many obvious examples. I'm guessing graphics hardware decided against it but are there more modern showcases? Or any other future of voxels? Delta Force images: https://tagn.wordpress.com/2013/08/07/delta-force-a-memory-of-voxels/ https://tagn.wordpress.com/2013/08/07/delta-force-a-memory-o... Delta Force video: https://youtu.be/Fnj-q3ux-Us?t=287 https://youtu.be/Fnj-q3ux-Us?t=287
- croes 4y agoOutcast was also great
- butz 4y agoCheck out Voxatron (https://www.lexaloffle.com/voxatron.php https://www.lexaloffle.com/voxatron.php), it's like Pico8, but in voxels.
- loupol 4y agoIf I recall properly, Minetest started out as an open-source Minecraft clone hence the aesthetics. Best looking modern voxel games I know of are Teardown[0] and Shadows of Doubt[1]. [0]: https://store.steampowered.com/app/1167630/Teardown/ https://store.steampowered.com/app/1167630/Teardown/ [1]: https://store.steampowered.com/app/986130/Shadows_of_Doubt/ https://store.steampowered.com/app/986130/Shadows_of_Doubt/
- vrglvrglvrgl 4y ago[dead]
- realjhol 4y agoThere is also Terasology - a Minecraft-like voxel game with fancy graphics: https://terasology.org/ https://terasology.org/
- MagicMoonlight 4y agoI would love for this to reach parity with minecraft. They’ve made so much money off of Minecraft but they never really add anything in updates and they keep adding evil data mining stuff. An electricity system and machines like modded mc but in a base game would be so good.
- newswasboring 4y agoIt's completely possible that I'm having a dumb moment, but where can I learn to make games with this engine? I really cannot find a tutorial.
- xigoi 4y agoYou're right, the documentation is all over the place and pretty hard to find. https://rubenwardy.com/minetest_modding_book/en/index.html https://rubenwardy.com/minetest_modding_book/en/index.html https://dev.minetest.net/Main_Page https://dev.minetest.net/Main_Page
- rubenwardy 4y agoTotally not biased, but that first link is a great place to start. Note that the process for making games is the same as for making mods - games are a collection of mod(ule)s. I'll make a note about the docs being hard to find, obviously room to improve here. This page is intended to be the starting page for those interested in modding/game making, it gives an overview and links to other resources: https://dev.minetest.net/Modding_Intro https://dev.minetest.net/Modding_Intro
- newswasboring 4y ago> Note that the process for making games is the same as for making mods - games are a collection of mod(ule)s. I think this is what is confusing. If you call it a game engine, I expect it to make... Games. It's just weird is all.
- nullcaution 4y agoI stopped playing Minecraft years ago, just before endermen were added. I recently had a go at it 6 months ago, and I couldn't get into it. In my mind Minecraft lost its charm of brutal simplicity since MS took over. The spells, the huge diversity of new items its just lost on me. But I like the way these FOSS clones look, maybe I'll give it a shot later. Also, screw MS. I purchased Minecraft 4 times for friends to borrow, I don't want an MS account tied to each one, nor do I have time for that hassel.
- sundarurfriend 4y agoMinetest has the same problem as editors like Vim do - it has only the ingredients for what most people use as the final product, and you have to put them together yourself, with the help of plugins and addons. People will rattle off a list of thirty-odd addons ("this one for monsters, that one a different type of monsters, this one for small animals, this one has small and medium animals, this one adds villagers, this one makes them actually do something, etc."). There's also very sparse info on what addons actually work well with each other, whether the enhanced armor addon will work with this mobs addon, or whether they don't recognize each other, or if the combo will just not let the game start... In the end, since I mostly play on mobile anyway, I went with this paid fork of this called MultiCraft, that's just install-and-play. It's less than a dollar (at least in my currency), and for someone who just wants a sandbox game to play casually, it turned out to be the much easier, less headache-inducing option. (I believe the PC version of MultiCraft is free to play too, you just have to compile it yourself.)
- LittleBox 4y agoThere is another Minecraft-like called Vintage Story, which I like a lot. I love the effort that the Minetest team is making but the game's development doesn't seem to be going anywhere as of right now due to a lack of direction. I feel being a game that is fully open source is not doing any favors. I don't know if it's possible under license but it might be able to pick up some steam if a large, for-profit mod came along.
- ntnsndr 4y agoI'm working on a mod for enabling user self-governance in online games, initially with Minetest: modpol.net
- Rubels1k994 4y agoExpected