17 ms·
I don't often like to take a "both sides" approach when assessing specific issues, but this one just seems to highlight the stupidity, or at the very least shor
by hn_throwaway_99 4y ago
I don't often like to take a "both sides" approach when assessing specific issues, but this one just seems to highlight the stupidity, or at the very least shortsightedness, of both sides.
On one hand, for those pushing for a ban, this seems largely performative, a la banning plastic straws. Gas is used for 2 main reasons: for cooking, where it represents a miniscule amount of overall energy use, and for heating, where, if what all the heat pump folks say is true, gas should fall out of favor vs. heat pumps eventually anyway. On the other side, I'm tired of the constant cries of "Muh Freedom!!!" in the face of any regulation that ignores the collective impact of not having any regulations.
Still, even for those who are gravely concerned about global warming, this feels like it will lead to a pyrrhic victory at best by making your average Joe more skeptical of government overreach. It seems like there could have been umpteen different types of government responses (e.g. support for heat pumps) that would have been better received by most folks compared to "we're banning something that a lot of people find useful and convenient".
- topaz0 4y agoA big part of the reason for banning gas is not energy but indoor pollution. There's pretty strong and growing evidence that cooking with gas leads to substantial health risks because of various combustion products that end up in your air (especially if not properly vented).
- endisneigh 4y agoFrom what I’ve read the same indoor pollution exists with induction even if not vented. The confounding variable is that induction generally is present in new construction which will have proper ventilation. TLDR: it’s a function of ventilation
- dustymcp 4y agoCooking itself releases a bunch of stuff that isnt great regardless of stove its entirely on the ventilation.
- chokma 4y agoYeah, searing meat in the pan will raise the PM2.5 levels in my flat by a factor of 30+.
- bluescrn 4y agoWell, before long that choice to eat meat will likely be taken away to 'save the planet', so that one will be solved...
- collegeburner 4y agothis is why all yall need to start grilling :D tho i admit it kinda sucks ass when it's 100 degrees
- throwaway049 4y agoI don't have a view either way, but we can measure pollution from different cooking methods under controlled conditions so we know which is better or worse independent of ventilation. Ventilation depends partly on individual behaviour, eg I open windows in good weather and close them in winter.
- taeric 4y agoMost of the in air particles will be what you are cooking...
- Zak 4y agoOne of the concerns is nitrogen oxides (mostly nitrogen dioxide, as I recall) from high temperature combustion. Car engines attempt to limit combustion temperatures (usually by adding some exhaust gasses to the intake air) to reduce its production. Ventilation prevents it from reaching hazardous levels from a gas stove; induction does not produce it.
- endisneigh 4y agoThe point is most of the harm comes from the cooking, not the gas. Classic over optimizing. Might as well ban Teflon while you’re at it (the eu did this, as it’s harmful)
- Zak 4y agoI'm not sure whether that's true (nitrogen dioxide can be pretty bad), but I am sure that ventilation is the answer either way. I suspect the main motivation for the ban is to be able to shut down the gas lines in the future because their existence results in methane leaking into the atmosphere. Health concerns might help them sell it ("think of the children" tends to be pretty effective, politically).
- amluto 4y agoCooking on induction at moderate temperature does not seem to produce significant particulate pollution. Source: I have a stove, and I have a portable PM2.5 meter. So you can simmer a stock for a couple hours without needing to run the fan (and cook most anything under 300 degrees or so), and with the fan off you don’t lose nice conditioned air from inside.
- hedora 4y agoThere is some evidence that the skyrocketing asthma rates are due to natural gas. They should ban teflon. It leaches estrogen analogues into food, and is an endocrine disrupter. Also, teflon pans last 2-5% as long as cheaper cast iron / stainless steel equivalents (or most more expensive options).
- tomp 4y agoAre you a doctor? This one doctor (whom I probably trust the most of online doctors) disagrees. https://peterattiamd.com/putting-out-the-fire-on-the-gas-stove-debate/ https://peterattiamd.com/putting-out-the-fire-on-the-gas-sto... > For example, the analysis included multiple studies that found an association between gas cooking and respiratory disease in children but variously failed to evaluate parental smoking habits, indoor smoke, pet ownership, or outdoor pollution as other possible factors which might underlie the observed associations. In other words, we must interpret these conclusions with a high degree of caution.
- topaz0 4y agoNo, but I will be by the end of next week.
- gwbas1c 4y agoIndoor pollution from a gas stove has more to do with how the building was built. Older construction leaks a lot more air than newer construction, primarily due to changes in code. More specifically, the air in an older home, from the 1980s, might change over every four hours or so. In a newer home built to modern building codes, it's eight or ten hours.
- CydeWeys 4y agoHours is still an awfully long time to have dangerous chemicals floating around in your air after each time you cook a meal. My apartment has a gas stove, which I was was induction. The gas stove plus the lack of a hood that vents to the outside means the indoor air quality gets pretty messed up. I usually have to open some windows when cooking, which is not great in winter.
- amluto 4y agoYour stove may well cause quite dangerous NOx in rather less than 4 hours: https://pubs.acs.org/doi/suppl/10.1021/acs.est.1c04707/suppl_file/es1c04707_si_001.pdf https://pubs.acs.org/doi/suppl/10.1021/acs.est.1c04707/suppl... See the last page. What you need is a real vent that vents outside. Or a stove that doesn’t emit NOx (and carbon monoxide, etc). Frankly this whole thing is a bit absurd. Everyone ought to know that flue gas from a furnace or water heater is extremely dangerous when it ends up indoors. Why are gas stoves ever considered okay?
- hn_throwaway_99 4y agoThe total effect on health seems rather debatable, and even if so there are better solutions (e.g. minimum ventilation requirements) for that. Total bans on products people use and can enjoy responsibility due to potential health risks is nearly always a bad idea in my opinion. Just look at smoking in the US, for example, which recently hit an all time low. We could have gone the prohibition route (and we can guess how that would turn out), but instead we clamped down on advertising, increased taxes, and helped usher in a societal change where smoking is largely seen as unacceptable behavior by huge swaths of people now.
- 8note 4y agoThis is not a total ban though? They aren't going to force the gas to be removed from current kitchens and heaters any time soon. There is a prohibition on smoking, kids aren't allowed to buy cigarettes
- 7speter 4y agoTheres a comment upthread championing this law because eventually government will ban all the miscreants who use gas powered appliances and heating from using them and using something much more hip and palatable to a subset of voters who can afford expensive house upgrades and electric cars at the snap of a finger.
- hedora 4y agoA top end GE induction range top is $1700. A lower end one is $400. These are both rounding errors vs. a year of energy bills. If you want something even cheaper (for instance, because you hate your tenants, and they are paying the power bill), resistive ones are still available.
- 7speter 4y agoAre you going to be paying for the electrical upgrades to homes that people on fixed incomes will need to get their 100+ year old homes up to code to be able to use one of these induction tops or should they just not live in a house to make you feel good?
- nemo44x 4y agoIt’s all made up and/or overblown by climate doomers. Vented gas is fine and great and removing them will contribute 0 to climate change.
- hedora 4y agoNatural gas is currently under 25% of US greenhouse emissions, but is on track to be over 50%: https://www.ucsusa.org/resources/climate-risks-natural-gas https://www.ucsusa.org/resources/climate-risks-natural-gas Granted, much of that is due to power plants, but residential + commercial is over 10%.
- ajsnigrutin 4y agoThere is also a third problem with this.... what happens when shit hits the fan? If you use gas and your neighbours use electricity, and there's suddenly a power outage, you can help your neighbors and heat/cook their food too,... or in case of a gas system outage, they can help with yours. If you heat with gas, you don't freeze even with a power outage, and can still buy a cheap electric heater with a gas outage... if you heat with electricity, you can atleast try to find someone with gas heat to let you sleep over and not freeze. Banning everything except electricity is just calling for a catastrophy. (yes yes, i know, old heaters will stay, this applies only to new construction, but in 30 years, most old devices will be replaced too) edit: i don't know why the downvotes... probably not many people from texas here... or anywhere else in the world... or maybe people think that NY is somehow immune to such outages
- amrocha 4y agoIf "shit hits the fan" to the point that you don't have electricity for several weeks then it's unreasonable to expect to be able to shelter in your own home imo.
- jprete 4y agoSheltering away from home is extremely expensive, disrupts anything resembling normal life - which a power outage does not - and may not even be possible if a large fraction of the local population all tries to find a hotel outside of the outage area at the same time.
- MereInterest 4y ago> which a power outage does not Things that don't work without electric power: * Refrigeration. For a 6-12 hour power outage, leaving the doors closed is sufficient. For 1-3 days, fridge temperatures may be maintained by buying bags of ice, but not a freezer. * Emergency communication. Landline phones might still function, depending on exactly where the breakage occurred. Cell phones have 24-48 hours of battery power at the most. * Central heating. Even a gas furnace requires electricity for its controller. * Kitchen ranges (conditional). For a gas range, this depends on whether you have a lighter or matches. A power outage disrupts normal life. During a power outage, you cannot cook food, cannot preserve food, and cannot heat your home. Depending on the duration, sheltering away from home may be the less disruptive option.
- lumb63 4y ago+1 regarding cooking gas being a minuscule amount of gas usage overall. And not to mention, gas is still the first choice for most serious cooks, so the small benefit comes at relatively large cost to lifestyle. Regarding heat pumps phasing out gas heat, in NY it isn’t feasible. It gets too cold. In more temperate climates, sure, but in the northern US and further, there will be a need for on-demand heat for a long time to come. The heat pump is being oversold as the answer to everything, but there are use cases it doesn’t account for. The path forward to carbon neutrality is electrification. Electrify new construction, use steam to heat them, etc. Something which addresses heat will dwarf any of the benefits from coming after people’s stovetops, at a fraction of the lifestyle cost. It almost feels like this is something designed to turn heads; a political act focused on banning something quite popular, that everyone knows about, for very marginal benefit. It’s almost certainly not to help with “climate change”; if it were, the legislation would target non-negligible emissions sources.
- jablongo 4y ago> Regarding heat pumps phasing out gas heat, in NY it isn’t feasible. It gets too cold. Not true, heat pumps are widely used as primary heat sources in environments as cold or colder than NY, like in Montreal and other parts of Canada. The take that heat pump tech only works in very moderate temperatures is stale at this point.
- bradlys 4y ago[flagged]
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- amalcon 4y agoUsually that works one of two ways: 1. Ground source heat pump -- which can work pretty much anywhere people live, but costs a lot more and people don't necessarily know about them. 2. Failover to resistive heating when it gets too cold outside. It's fine to do this in Montreal, because electricity is relatively inexpensive there. It's fine to do this in New York City, or even somewhere a little cooler like Boston, because you're doing it for max like 2 days a year even in an outlier year. Not sure if it's fine to do this in Buffalo.
- Cardinal7167 4y ago> feels like it will lead to a pyrrhic victory at best by making your average Joe more skeptical of government overreach This is basically how all climate regulations are perceived at the end of the day, and it’s the primary fuel for my most doompilled opinions for sure.
- tialaramex 4y agoOne reason to specifically forbid new installations is to avoid stranding people when you later legislate provision out of existence altogether. Sooner or later this is going away. If you announce you're not doing new installations, that starts a timer on the existing users. In 2028 everything in use is at least 5 years old. In summer 2035 everything in use is at least 12 years old. Politically that makes it a lot easier to sell an actual prohibition on supply than it will be for places where that's a sudden overnight change from "Sure, you can use gas" to "No, we're ripping that out". My country has begun gradually getting rid of POTS copper wire telephone provision. You can still have it, for a little while at least, but we know it has limited lifespan, if you're an outfit who somehow didn't spot the signs and were shipping devices that expect a physical copper line to work, you've had your notice, in a couple of years stuff like that will drop dead. When it's gone, with it goes a bunch of expenses that most people don't benefit from at all. And yes, also some relatively modest benefits are gone too, but mostly it's a burden, we have better things to spend resources on. But you need to give people a heads up first, and that's what this legislation seems to do.
- wingspar 4y agoAs I understand it, it’s a ban on piping gas lines in new construction, not installing gas equipment in existing buildings. In summer 2035, you won’t have any buildings than less than 12 years old with gas available, But, as I understand it from the article, someone could replace their stove or heating system in a building that has pre-ban gas, no problem at any point in the intervening 12 years. Even the winter of 2035.
- Multicomp 4y agoYeah if anything this will exacerbate the challenge of building new construction because existing buildings will have this valuable utility that new buildings cannot have.
- kibwen 4y agoThe alternatives to gas are so good these days that there's no way I'd pay to connect any new house to gas.
- rhaway84773 4y agoPeople are misrepresenting this. No one is banning gas. You can go ahead and buy a gas stove and use it. What you cannot do is expect buildings to install piping throughout the building, the gas provider to provide infrastructure to supply that building with gas, and get the gas out of a tap. The vast majority of the world in fact does not have gas coming out of a tap because it’s not profitable. The U.S. has it almost entirely because of regulation thst requires it to be provided, which has now baked in expectation among homeowners that it will be there. This expectation leads to buildings paying extra to supply gas at exorbitant costs so their homes don’t feel less luxury than an equivalent competitor.
- prottog 4y ago> The U.S. has it almost entirely because of regulation thst requires it to be provided If this is true, then why is the New York Times calling it a ban? Wouldn't it be more accurate to call it a repeal of whatever legislation that was requiring it? Do you have a source on this regulation?
- jltsiren 4y agoIf the plan is to phase out natural gas heating in a reasonable timeframe, you need to stop new investments in it soon. A ban is a crude tool, but it may be better than telling residents of new buildings that they must start planning to replace their heating systems, because natural gas deliveries will end in 2035 or 2040.
- Aunche 4y ago>Gas is used for 2 main reasons: for cooking, where it represents a miniscule amount of overall energy use Gas cooking makes sense when the infrastructure costs can be amortized with that of heating. One of these costs is the 2-3% of gas that leaks, and this loss will occur even if you heat your home with heat pumps so long as you're connected to the gas grid. If your only use of gas is cooking, it makes much more sense to simply buy cans of propane.
- nonethewiser 4y agoGas cooking makes sense when people want to cook with gas.
- ricardobayes 4y agoIn my area I got a 50k quote to get connected to mains gas even though it's less than 200 meters away. They can pound sand, even the a state-of-the-art heat pump system is a fraction of that.
- cogman10 4y agoThere are more reasons to ban gas in buildings than just global warming. There's the fact that you are actually burning fuel, which released noxious fumes into the home [1]. There's mounting evidence that this sort of exposure has pretty negative health implications [2] Gas is also inherently dangerous, more-so than electricity. There's been more than a few examples of exploded homes/buildings due to gas leaks [3]. All it takes is for someone to accidentally leave a burner on unstarted (or for a kid to do it while playing around the home). But as for cooking, heat pumps won't work there. What you're more likely to see is either homes coming standard with thick enough lines to power everything or stoves with batteries (think about it, a stove is off 90% of the time, so why not slowly charge a battery during that time for the times when you need to cook fast?) [1] https://pubs.acs.org/doi/10.1021/acs.est.1c04707 https://pubs.acs.org/doi/10.1021/acs.est.1c04707 [2] https://www.atsdr.cdc.gov/toxfaqs/tfacts175.pdf https://www.atsdr.cdc.gov/toxfaqs/tfacts175.pdf [3] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ronan_Point https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ronan_Point
- annexrichmond 4y agoWhy can’t people make safety decisions for themselves? Many people will choose electric/induction stoves, or not rent an apartment with a gas stove. But many people do prefer it, and I don’t think it should be up to you or the government whether something is “good” for them or not.
- idontpost 4y ago[dead]
- hdisjdudh 4y agomany people will rent and have no say on what's better for them
- annexrichmond 4y agoI’ve searched for apartments many times in my life, and both options were always plentiful. If it’s important enough to someone they will have a say.
- cool_dude85 4y ago>and for heating, where, if what all the heat pump folks say is true, gas should fall out of favor vs. heat pumps eventually anyway This is exactly what governmental action is meant to put a stop to. We have a case where due to inertia, consumer preferences, market failures w.r.t. externalities, etc. residential gas use would, if left to the market, make up a significant proportion of heating energy. Maybe "eventually anyway" gas would "fall out of favor", but what needs to happen is for it to no longer be in use (along with 1000 other such changes). The market cannot achieve this for us.
- Blikkentrekker 4y agoI don't understand banning these kinds of things in general opposed to simply taxing them considerably. A man should have the freedom to damage the environment so long as he pay for it, and that money can then be used to undo his damage. Of course, it's always quite inconsistent how these things are applied based on cultural reasons. I've been in favor for a long time for higher taxes on paper. The production of paper is apparently 1/5 of deforestation and there really is not much justification for it now with alternatives with less of an environmental footprint, but too many people, even those who supposedly stand for the environment, are too emotionally attached to paper for cultural reasons to see this ever pass.
- tobyjsullivan 4y agoIt's starting to feel like government "solutions" are aggressively targeting freedoms (for lack of a better word) with the fewest, least-organized defenders rather than any consideration for actual impact. For example, here in Canada, we recently banned a wide range of window blinds including the very popular top-down bottom-up style (a personal favourite). Why? To save the kids of course. One Canadian child a year was killed, on average, over 30 years.[0] So it's a performative win and, let's be honest, who's going to defend our right to buy and install blinds? [0] https://science.gc.ca/site/science/en/blogs/science-health/kids-and-cords-dont-mix https://science.gc.ca/site/science/en/blogs/science-health/k...
- jutrewag 4y ago[dead]