10 ms·
"U.S. SEC Chair Gary Gensler told lawmakers on Tuesday that he had "never seen a field that's so non-complying with laws". Crypto firms say they need clarity a
by 1vuio0pswjnm7 4y ago
"U.S. SEC Chair Gary Gensler told lawmakers on Tuesday that he had "never seen a field that's so non-complying with laws".
Crypto firms say they need clarity about regulations, but Gensler has said that crypto markets "suffer from a lack of regulatory compliance, not a lack of regulatory clarity"."
Maybe calling it a "field" is being too generous. Crime is crime.
- koolba 4y agoThat’s rich coming from the guy who couldn’t even answer a basic yes/no question by Congress, “Is ethereum a commodity?”. His congressional testimony was a joke. How that man still has the job of SEC chief is quite the mystery. Being CFO of Hillary Clinton’s 2016 campaign is probably a factor.
- duxup 4y agoIs not giving a yes or no bad? Maybe it isn’t clear?
- hbbio 4y agoIt's really bad. In the press, he says that "actors are not complying" but not being able to answer the most simple question (there are others more complex) is *not* playing in SEC favour. Comply with what? Ethereum is the most used "crypto"-currency and the ecosystem players like Coinbase (a YC company) are right by saying they *can't* comply... they don't know what they are supposed to do despite asking repeatedly for years.
- duxup 4y agoYou didn’t answer my other question.
- latchkey 4y ago"the rules are clear" "great! how would they apply to this simple example?" "lol, no I can't tell you that!"
- thisgoesnowhere 4y agoThat's not how regulation works with the SEC. The rules are broad and are specificly designed to not be strict so that they can be applied to new technologies and businesses. You can say you don't like these rules or how they are applied but that's how they have been applied since their inception. This isn't new.
- latchkey 4y agoSadly, the existing rules are clearly not being applied well to these "new" (10+ year old) technologies. After, whatever decades of "the rules", new technologies have come along that have stumped "the rules". Now, the SEC has to deal with that. Instead of being an adult and having a good conversation, they are just kicking and screaming. What's happening is that SEC is saying that you're breaking "the rules" (ie: Wells Notice to coinbase). So, coinbase says... "ok, cool... what rules am i breaking?" The response is: "lol, no I can't tell you that!" So now Brian is in DC this week talking to regulators trying to get some clarity. He's posting all sorts of pictures of this on Twitter. Let's see what happens.
- growse 4y agoThe response to the wells notice is meant to be an argument as to why you're not in breach of the law. Not a request for more information. If they're not able to argue why they're not breaking the law, then they should hire better lawyers.
- latchkey 4y agoComments like this and your second one below, seem so low brow and childish. Account from 2011 and 1400 karma... keep up the good work there. Of course they can argue it, that's what is happening. They are going to sue the government. Why? Because the SEC refuses to even have a conversation about things. They've been trying, for years, to do so. This isn't some random small company, this is a public company that the SEC should be supporting with better answers than just refusing to even meet. Worse off, along this same thread, Gensler doesn't even have basic answers to questions that he was prepared for.
- ghayes 4y agoYes, it’s very bad, as if you’re a US company, how do you comply if one government agency tells you one thing, and another tells you the opposite. Rule of law fundamentally requires a shared understanding of the law.
- duxup 4y agoDid you ask a government agency? This whole congressional testimony as legal advice for your business makes no sense.
- re-thc 4y ago> Comply with what? Comply by not operating at all probably. Just the SEC can't outright say that.
- dontknowwhyihn 4y agoThe SEC could have prevented Coinbase from becoming a publicly traded company, but they didn’t.
- thisgoesnowhere 4y agoWhat are you suggesting here? Are you saying that because they said coinbase could list that means that crypto is compliant?
- bpodgursky 4y agoDo you really want to live in a country where the government is not willing to tell you whether you are breaking the law?
- duxup 4y agoI don’t think congressional testimony is quite that.
- mikeryan 4y agoThat’s literally one of the main jobs of lawyers because there’s a shit ton of law that’s not clearly defined and based on obscure precedents or never been tried in a court. Heck half of the court system from Appellate to the Supreme court is to figure out what is and isn’t legal. Most government agencies won’t tell you if something is legal or illegal because they don’t know unless there clear case law on the subject, in which case your attorney should know, and they’d spend all day guessing. If Coinbase wants clarity then take it to court and run it up the flagpole.
- growse 4y ago> Do you really want to live in a country where the government is not willing to tell you whether you are breaking the law? Show me a country where the government tells whether or not you're breaking the law without actually prosecuting you.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- ackbar03 4y agoSo is ethereum a commodity? No seriously, I can't answer that either.
- chaxor 4y agoIt's just a currency. That seems rather simple. WTF is a "commodity"?
- scrollaway 4y agohttps://www.investopedia.com/terms/c/commodity.asp https://www.investopedia.com/terms/c/commodity.asp
- pclmulqdq 4y agoThe answer to that question is a little like people arguing in court "it depends on what your definition of 'is' is." It seems like a simple question, but it's heavily loaded with both future implications and past precedents, and it can be very hard to answer questions like that unless you're prepared to back up your answer. He clearly hadn't done enough research to answer one way or the other.
- latchkey 4y ago> He clearly hadn't done enough research to answer one way or the other. He definitely has, or at least he should have. When ETH switched to PoS things changed, but he hasn't officially updated his opinion on it and wasn't willing to go on record about it at this latest hearing. https://coingeek.com/is-eth-a-security-if-it-wasnt-before-it-is-now/ https://coingeek.com/is-eth-a-security-if-it-wasnt-before-it...
- bushbaba 4y agoYou assume he hasn’t done research. Instead it could be his research found there to not be a clear “good” answer and the response was his way out of making a call at such a relatively early industry stage.
- latchkey 4y ago> You assume he hasn’t done research. That's literally the opposite of what I just said.
- pclmulqdq 4y agoIt sounds like we agree that he should have, but he hasn't.
- latchkey 4y agoThe guy taught courses at MIT on bitcoin and previously shilled algorand. He's done research. Although, oddly, he's never done a crypto transaction. He's probably really good at doing standard SEC things, but I'm really starting to question his role in the cryptodigital economy.
- e63f67dd-065b 4y agoThe reason he won't answer the question is because it's complicated. On one hand, yes, Ethereum is obviously a security, it raised money from investors to make a thing, and investors expected to get rich off it. On the other hand, Ethereum is currently regulated as a commodity by the CFTC. If he says Ethereum is a security, then there's a political mess. If he says Ethereum is a commodity, then it breaks down the SEC's case for all the crypto projects out there that's basically stock IPOs but with a thin crypto layer on top. I would not impute his credentials, he was a partner at Goldman Sachs and was chair of CFTC under Obama. He was involved in crafting a great deal of policy after 08 around the new regulations for financial institutions. He's not stupid, he's clearly a better person for the job than most of the people here on HN.
- marcell 4y agoHow can crypto companies be expected to follow the law, if the head of the SEC cannot say if Ethereum is a security or a commodity?
- lacker 4y agoWell, it's easy to follow the law. Just be conservative and treat Ethereum like an unregistered security. Ie, don't offer it for sale to the public. That certainly isn't a good outcome for Coinbase, though, so I can see why the crypto companies wish the SEC had a different suggestion.
- jeremyjh 4y agoLaws the CEO doesn’t like are “unclear”. He doesn’t like any laws because they are intended to thwart grifters like him. So all regulation is unclear.
- lacker 4y agoMy guess is he doesn't want to answer the yes/no question because this question is going to be the subject of a lawsuit, and his lawyers like most lawyers are in favor of not talking publicly about court cases outside the courtroom.
- JumpCrisscross 4y ago> That’s rich coming from the guy who couldn’t even answer a basic yes/no question by Congress, “Is ethereum a commodity?” Commodities aren't Gensler's job. It would be like someone asking him about the tax code. It's fair for him to say "I don't know." What he knows are securities.
- tiahura 4y agoThe Securities and Exchange act of 1934 doesn’t give the SEC authority to regulate bitcoin and thus the SEC doesn’t have authority to it.
- ghayes 4y agoThe Securities Act and the Exchange Act give the SEC broad latitude in regulating securities. The fundamental question is: is Bitcoin a security? The situation now is a bit like if the SEC tomorrow said Harry Potter books were securities, would bookstores suddenly become unlicensed securities exchanges?
- latchkey 4y ago> The fundamental question is: is Bitcoin a security? https://www.coindesk.com/layer2/2022/06/28/secs-gensler-reiterates-bitcoin-alone-is-a-commodity-is-he-right/ https://www.coindesk.com/layer2/2022/06/28/secs-gensler-reit...
- Quindecillion 4y agoIt's not a security. It's not a commodity either. It's money. You may not agree with that and you may not like Bitcoin, but that doesn't change what it is.
- illiarian 4y agoBasically all of crypto passes Howey test for securities: --- start quite --- an instrument qualifies as an "investment contract" for the purposes of the Securities Act: "a contract, transaction or scheme whereby a person invests his money in a common enterprise and is led to expect profits solely from the efforts of the promoter or a third party." --- end quote ---
- Quindecillion 4y agoI agree. All of crypto passes the Howey test for securities. Bitcoin doesn't match that definition though. Who or what entity is the 'promoter' or 'third party' for Bitcoin? There's no registered entity, no (legitimate) foundation, no company, no CEO, no board, no chair. It's just a protocol.
- jrm4 4y agoYeah, he really doth protest too much. Regardless of how you feel about crypto, if you're at all familiar with law you'd understand that we're simply in uncharted territory here; saying that crypto is super dirty and non-compliant is quite literally as inaccurate as saying that it's super clean and fully in-line. The law simply isn't there yet.
- iudqnolq 4y agoThe law isn't there yet if you want crypto to work. But Gensler wants to kill crypto, and for that simply applying the existing rules fairly will do. Crypto doesn't have an inherent right to have the laws rewritten to enable it, it needs to make the case for why that would be good for the public. So far it hasn't.
- csomar 4y agoCrypto as in crypto-currencies is simply two (or multiple) peers exchanging information between them. They do not need a law to permit that, a case for the "good for the public", or anyone authorization for that matter.
- spaceman_2020 4y agoI’ve never seen a field with lower adoption than crypto despite billions in marketing. The actual users on-chain is abysmal and frankly, embarrassing. Current users onchain is in the thousands. Even when the market was raging, the biggest memecoin in the world could only manage about 1M+ wallets - probably about 80-100k real users. NFT trading volume is down to under 6-7k active users. At peak bull market, Tornado Cash, despite its notoriety, had about 125 daily transactions. Arbitrum, an Ethereum scaling solution, gave out literally free money in the form of an airdrop (I got $15k worth). The airdrop went out to about 650k wallets - under 100k real users. If crypto were to disappear tomorrow, it would affect a population no bigger than a small Indian town. An absolute mess. No correlation between adoption and hype/valuation at all.
- SparkyMcUnicorn 4y agoWhat's the source for your data? I agree with you on the overhype, but if roughly 16% of active addresses are real users, then active users within the past 24 hours would be around the population of the largest city in Indiana rather than a small town. Source: DefiLlama
- spaceman_2020 4y agoI said small Indian town, not Indiana town :) Regardless, NFT platform unique daily users down to ~10-12k across platforms: https://dune.com/queries/1622348/2688962?utm_source=mintorskip.beehiiv.com&utm_medium=newsletter&utm_campaign=nfts-are-in-free-fall https://dune.com/queries/1622348/2688962?utm_source=mintorsk... Total unique daily wallets for Tether (USDT) down to about 80k unique wallets. This is just unique addresses - doesn't filter out bots and users with multiple wallets. You can't go more mainstream than this coin. https://etherscan.io/token/0xdac17f958d2ee523a2206206994597c13d831ec7#tokenAnalytics https://etherscan.io/token/0xdac17f958d2ee523a2206206994597c... There are not more than 20-30k active users on chain at any given point.
- jeremyjh 4y agoAren’t most actual users just in exchange accounts ?
- 1vuio0pswjnm7 4y ago1. Genseler cannot say whether ETH is a security or a commodity as such statements could have adverse conssequences for the Commission in currrent/future litigation, e.g., SEC v Ripple Labs. 2. Even if the SEC were to issue guidance that a certain type of crypto operation is exempt from regulation, instead of proceeding on a case-by-case basis, it lacks the resources to carry out the requisite enforcement against all the crypto operations that are not exempt. From what I have read and heard, the likely reason why Genseler will not go after Bitcoin is because he believes the SEC lacks the resources. BTC has too much of a foothold. IMO, Genseler's SEC is taking on the amount of enforcement it believes it can successfully manage, maybe more. Time will tell. IMO, just because some crypto operations manage to evade SEC enforcement does not mean crypto is a legal grey area. It means the SEC has a limited enforcement budget and is pursuing actions that it believes have the best chances of success. There is an extraordinary amount of fraud on the internet. One can argue that lack of enforcement against crypto operations is because "the law has not caught up", but perhaps the more likely explanation is that the authorities have not caught up.
- chrismorgan 4y ago> It means the SEC has a limited enforcement budget and is pursuing actions that it believes have the best chances of success. I’d have expected enforcement to practically print money due to fines. (That one of the deliberate design aspects of fines would be that they would cover all the agency’s investigations, successful and unsuccessful.) Is this not the case?
- 1vuio0pswjnm7 4y ago"Over at the SEC, a spokesperson said the agency can allocate civil penalties to one of three places: the general fund at the U.S. Treasury, the Treasury's Investor Protection Fund (which is used to help fund awards granted to whistleblowers), or another separate fund used to repay harmed investors." According to this, fines are not allocated to the Commission to finance further enforcement activity except that funding awards to whistleblowers might lead to more enforcement actions. Keyword: might https://www.marketplace.org/2022/08/12/where-does-money-collected-from-corporate-fines-go/ https://www.marketplace.org/2022/08/12/where-does-money-coll... "What Does the SEC Do With Money It Collects From Fines? This will depend on the nature of the penalty. If investors or others were harmed financially due to a transgression, the penalties collected will be used to recover those losses and make those investors whole. Until the passage of the Sarbanes-Oxley Act of 2002, all penalties the SEC obtained were paid to the United States Treasury. Section 308 of the Sarbanes-Oxley Act, the so-called "Fair Funds provision," permits the SEC to request that certain penalties be added to any disgorgement fund established as part of an SEC enforcement action to return money to shareholders, investors, whistleblowers, or other victims of the defendant's securities law violations." https://www.investopedia.com/ask/answers/05/secfines.asp https://www.investopedia.com/ask/answers/05/secfines.asp HN commenters seem to pay particular attention to Matt Levine's ramblings. Here he is dispelling the myth: "It is not literally the case that the US Securities and Exchange Commission is a for-profit business whose goal is to maximize its revenue, and whose most important source of revenue is fining financial services companies for their misdeeds. But that is sometimes a tempting way to think about things." https://www.bloomberg.com/opinion/articles/2023-02-02/the-sec-wants-to-see-more-phones https://www.bloomberg.com/opinion/articles/2023-02-02/the-se...