8 ms·
This is kind of baffling to me. I'm a huge fan of the usefulness of ChatGPT, and I've found ways to use it to improve my productivity in a bunch of areas, but i
by hn_throwaway_99 4y ago
This is kind of baffling to me. I'm a huge fan of the usefulness of ChatGPT, and I've found ways to use it to improve my productivity in a bunch of areas, but if you've "never hired a writer better than ChatGPT", I can only assume you've been hiring really shitty writers. Not necessarily that ChatGPT output is bad, but a lot of the copy has a similar, generic, "college essay" feel to it.
I saw this post on LinkedIn [1] that I think really nails it:
For anyone worried about how generative AI will make creative jobs obsolete, I asked Chat GPT to generate headlines advertising hot cross buns. Here's what it came up with:
"Get Your Hot Cross Buns Here - Fresh and Delicious!"
"Easter Treats Just Got Better with Our Hot Cross Buns"
"Warm Up Your Morning with Our Hot Cross Buns"
"Limited Time Offer: Hot Cross Buns Now Available!"
"Our Hot Cross Buns Will Leave You Wanting More"
"Celebrate Easter with Our Traditional Hot Cross Buns"
"Delight Your Taste Buds with Our Soft and Spicy Hot Cross Buns"
"Bring the Aroma of Freshly Baked Hot Cross Buns into Your Home"
"Satisfy Your Cravings with Our Irresistible Hot Cross Buns"
"Hop into Easter with Our Scrumptious Hot Cross Buns"
Meanwhile a human copywriter just created this real headline for a press ad for Tesco hot cross buns:
"Go Out With All Buns Glazing."
If you want originality, ask a human.
1. https://www.linkedin.com/posts/realtommorton_for-anyone-worried-about-how-generative-ai-activity-7047612819197845504-IKdS/ https://www.linkedin.com/posts/realtommorton_for-anyone-worr...
- benatkin 4y agoEh, that's a specific type of wordplay and not so clever. Just add it to your prompt.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- whitemary 4y ago> a similar, generic, "college essay" feel to it I worked for a large periodical publishing corp throughout my 20s. This + quick turnaround is exactly what the publishing staff (ad sales) fought for, because it was safe. Only the edit staff (writers, etc.) wanted anything else, and those who really wanted it left.
- auggierose 4y agoSure ad sales people want that, and if you let them, they will tank the publication, and then ad sales will be 0. That's the reason you have the edit staff...
- batch12 4y agoIn spirit I agree, but I think you picked a bad example. With just version 3.5 I got these. They aren't cherry-picked, I just massaged the responses with a little back-and-forth (funnier and punnier) Here are the first 5. Bun-believable! These Hot Buns Will Have You Saying 'Oh Doughn't Mind If I Do'" "Hot Buns: The Yeast You Can Do for Your Taste Buds" "Bake Your Day with These Hot Buns: The Roll-ly Grail of Breakfast Treats" "Raisin the Bar: How to Make Hot Cross Buns that are Bun-derfully Delicious" "Don't Be Alarmed, These Hot Buns are Oven-tually Going to Be Your Favorites" A compromise is that your prompt has to be creative.. so a human is still in the loop for now..
- LanceH 4y agoOn the plus side, it probably delivers on time.
- 10xDev 4y agoI think you missed the point. They quoted an advert involving a pun because it was creative, you are just showing results because it includes puns as a response. Most of those are used or subpar.
- batch12 4y agoYeah, it's very possible I missed the point. I think though that most publications will settle for something that's good enough. They don't need (or can't afford) Steinbeck headlines, so they'll go the easiest and cheapest route. I didn't personally find the original headline any better than the generated ones, but maybe I don't have as refined a palate as you do. Thanks for the feedback.
- xereeto 4y agoThese are all very simple low hanging fruit puns. None of these come close to the human example. That said, I'm not an idiot - AI will get there and probably soon.
- jgalt212 4y agounless we encounter a devil's staircase.
- kenjackson 4y agoI asked ChatGPT-4 to do this, but I added "in a creative, original, and witty way". This is what ChatGPT gave me: 1. "Heavenly Buns on the Rise: Our Hot Cross Buns are Simply Divine!" 2. "Bunbelievable! Our Hot Cross Buns Will Make You Hoppy this Easter!" 3. "Hallelu-bun-jah! Feast Your Eyes (and Mouth) on These Scrumptious Hot Cross Buns!" 4. "Cross Your Heart and Hope to Buy: Irresistible Hot Cross Buns Just in Time for Easter!" 5. "Hot Cross Fun: Get Ready to Bun-dle Up with Our Tasty Easter Treats!" 6. "No Bunny Compares: Hop into Easter with Our Delectable Hot Cross Buns!" 7. "Get Egg-cited! Our Hot Cross Buns are Simply Bun-derful!" 8. "Cross Your Buns and Dot Your I's: The Ultimate Easter Treat has Arrived!" 9. "Bun Voyage: Embark on a Flavor Adventure with Our Heavenly Hot Cross Buns!" 10. "Holy Buns-a-roo! It's a Hot Cross Bunanza You Won't Want to Miss!" I thought they were pretty good. And honestly better than what I'd come up with. But also this isn't something I'm good at, or even good at judging. So take my opinion for what its worth given my lack of experience here, but I thought it wasn't too bad. UPDATE: I decided to ask ChatGPT to do it again, but this time to remove references to Easter and instead make it NBA Playoff themed. This is what it gave me: 1. "Bun and Dones: Hot Cross Buns that Make Your Taste Buds Slam Dunk!" 2. "From Downtown! Our Hot Cross Buns are a Three-Pointer in Deliciousness!" 3. "Courtside Cravings: Get Hooked on Our Sky-High Hot Cross Buns!" 4. "Pick and Roll Your Way to Flavor Town with Our Dribble-icious Hot Cross Buns!" 5. "Give Your Appetite a Full Court Press with Our Swish-worthy Hot Cross Buns!" 6. "Treat Yo' Self to a Layup of Yum with Our Un-bun-lievably Tasty Hot Cross Buns!" 7. "Bunbelievable Rebounds: Our Hot Cross Buns Will Keep You Coming Back for More!" 8. "A Slam Bun-kin' Good Time: Taste the Victory with Our Hot Cross Buns!" 9. "Step Up Your Snack Game with our Ballin' Hot Cross Buns!" 10. "Hot Cross Buns: Bringing the Heat to Your NBA Playoff Watch Party!" I liked that I could tweak it toward a direction and get instant feedback.
- tootie 4y agoI describe it's writing style as "8th grade honors student". It's all very correct and perfectly structured but facile and frequently reductive and with obvious errors you'd expect from someone who has only read about the world in books.
- atleastoptimal 4y agoIt's the writing style that is the most congenial to the base average human reader. To a reasonably smart person it gives that artificial vibe but to the network TV watching masses it's perfect writing.
- tootie 4y agoDepending on the need that may be perfectly fine. I wouldn't expect to be published in the New Yorker any time soon, but it can write press releases, marketing copy, technical documentation and probably a load of niches (real estate listings?) which are predominantly written by non-writers right now.
- coffeebeqn 4y agoYou can add a New Yorker writers name or ask it to use the New Yorker style guide in your prompt
- ilc 4y agoSo slightly more sophisticated than the average American?
- fauxpause_ 4y agoSignificantly more sophisticated than average anywhere. People are not good at writing. 8th grade is extremely generous
- atleastoptimal 4y agoIt's naïve to think LLM's won't learn to make trite wordplay based on common idioms in the near future.
- Lerc 4y agoJust tried "Can you generate some options for headlines advertising hot cross buns utilizing wordplay, with a cheeky attitude?" "Bunbelievable! Get Ready for a Crumbelievable Hot Cross Experience!" "Bun in a Million: Your Taste Buds Won't Be Cross with These Hot Cross Buns!" "Hopping Mad for Hot Cross Buns: They're the Toast of the Town!" "Cross Your Heart, Hope to Savor: Hot Cross Buns Worth Sinning For!" "Buns & Roses: It's a Rockin' Hot Cross Bun Party You Can't Resist!" "The Great Bun-der: Hot Cross Buns with an Irresistible Twist!" "Hot Cross Fun: Unleash Your Inner Bunthusiast Today!" "Bun Appetit! Tantalize Your Tastebuds with Our Heavenly Hot Cross Buns!" "Too Hot to Handle: These Hot Cross Buns Are a Batch Made in Heaven!" "Sweet Cross-sations: Get Ready to Indulge in the Ultimate Hot Cross Buns!" And more fun "Now try that again adding a hint of dissatisfaction with the commercialization of Easter while acknowledging that this is itself is a form of that commercialization." "Crossed Wires: Enjoy Our Hot Cross Buns While We Roll Our Eyes at Easter's Over-Commercialization!" "Eggs-cruciating Irony: Hot Cross Buns So Good, They'll Make You Forget the Easter Bunny Cash Grab!" "Bun in the System: We Can't Fight the Hype, but Our Hot Cross Buns Are Worth It!" "Commerciali-sin: Indulge in Our Hot Cross Buns and Forgive Us Our Easter Retail Trespasses!" "Capitalist Crossroads: Relish Our Hot Cross Buns as We (Reluctantly) Join the Easter Bandwagon!" "Hoppin' Hypocrisy: Grab a Taste of Our Hot Cross Buns as We Grumble About Easter's Materialism!" "Bitter Buns: Savor Our Hot Cross Delights While Lamenting the Overhyped Easter Frenzy!" "Eggs-traordinary Irony: Bite into Our Hot Cross Buns and Pardon Our Easter Commercial Participation!" "Rebel with a Bun: Enjoy Our Hot Cross Buns and Share Our Disdain for Easter's Selling Out!" "Crossed Purposes: Hop on the Easter Cash Train with Our Hot Cross Buns, and We'll Share a Collective Eye Roll!" It gives you what you ask for, not what you want.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- krainboltgreene 4y agoNone of these are anywhere near any good as the human delivered one, for so many many reasons. It's a mediocre list even given what you asked for.
- throwaway292939 4y agoThis is likely untrue. I think tone is something ChatGPT excels at. The issue is more likely with your prompting. Sure, with standard prompting you'd get the "college essay" feel. However, I do think long form writing is something ChatGPT isn't really able to do.
- getoffmycase 4y agoThe way ChatGPT writes drives me nuts in some specific ways. So I was messing around with it and asked it to specifically eliminate certain phrases it commonly uses, remove superfluous words, and modify the sentence structures in some specific ways. In the end it was surprisingly easy and fast to get it to produce writing at a significantly higher than 8th grade level.
- sho_hn 4y agoI applaud your creative way of second-level prompt engineering! It used to be the best way to get Linux support was to join a Linux chat room and loudly proclaim Linux can't do something - ten amazing people would jump up to prove you wrong. Turns out this is also how to use ChatGPT. :-)
- dopidopHN 4y agoThis is the way
- throwaway2037 4y agoAgree! See: Cunningham's Law states "the best way to get the right answer on the internet is not to ask a question; it's to post the wrong answer."
- raincole 4y agoThe vast majority of "creative" work is just mediocre, or more specifically, passable. By majority I don't mean > 50%. I mean > 99%. "Go Out With All Buns Glazing" represents < 1% writing amoung all the writing-related jobs. And even that is not entirely impossible with ChatGPT today.
- tetris11 4y agoAlso, employers dont want quality. They want quantity.
- dsq 4y agoExactly. And speed. "Getting there firstest with the mostest".
- croes 4y agoThey want quality but cheap, we'll be fun to watch how they complain to an AI if the results don't satisfy.
- mysterydip 4y agoMost likely they would just run the prompt again with some tweaks. You could ask "generate me 50 slogans for xyz" all day long. Do that with a human and they'd get fed up quickly.
- ChainOfFools 4y agoAs do freelancers. this has been the understanding for as long as freelancing has existed, that 90% of your mediocre pay-the-bills projects just get you by until you land the 10% of work that is interesting, rewarding, and utilizes your talents the fullest. AI is going to destroy that bread and butter (har har) lifeline that freelancers sustain themselves on while they search for opportunities which really leverage their human creative qualities in a way that AI can't mimic. But now they can't either, because they can't afford rent.
- kristopolous 4y agoScroll through the emails you haven't bothered unsubscribing from yet They all sound like that. It's bland uninspired copy - probably with some emojis
- danparsonson 4y agoSide note that I hope someone at OpenAI is scratching their head over the sudden influx of hot cross bun related queries
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- MuffinFlavored 4y ago> I've found ways to use it to improve my productivity in a bunch of areas like what?
- penjelly 4y agofinding answers quickly, writing bash scripts, exploring ideas & planning, writing app boilerplate
- anonzzzies 4y ago> I can only assume you've been hiring really shitty writers Which is what 99% of companies hire because they don’t have budget or think they shouldn’t spend more? Talented writers, designers, programmers, lawyers etc won’t be gone soon, but the 99% of crap out there (most of fiverr, most of upwork etc) will be done soon. And while that seems a good thing in some ways, it is a massive economical and societal issue. The output of chatgpt is ‘good enough’ for most things and for the price (near $0) of it, you can do many iterations yourself without paying a writer.
- camillomiller 4y agoWell they mention in the article she was paying an average of 22$/hr which is definitely not what you pay for a good writer.
- throwaway2037 4y agoCan you please share from your experience what a "good writer" costs per hour?
- camillomiller 4y agoHere in Europe easily up to 60€ per hour or based on assignment. Especially for commercial or corporate work. Way more if the writer has an industry-recognized byline.
- richardw 4y agoEntire product ranges are sold from China with terrible documentation, but still sell. Somehow the people who write those get paid, so I assume there’s a massive range of professional skill levels. I hope Chinese manual writers are currently using ChatGPT for new products. Surely this problem stops now. If not, filling that gap is an opportunity for someone.
- matheusmoreira 4y ago> Not necessarily that ChatGPT output is bad, but a lot of the copy has a similar, generic, "college essay" feel to it. So it's just like the output of these traditional media articles.
- ehnto 4y agoSo much online "content" is just product sales or thinly veiled SEO fodder. If I were a "content writer" and I wasn't servicing high end clients, I would be getting worried right now.
- spaceman_2020 4y agoThe bulk of online content creation is for SEO and content marketing. This doesn't require creativity. It's not going to be a disaster if this content disappears from our culture altogether. Sad for writers though, but every single freelance writer I know does this just to pay the bills and dreams of writing something actually creative.
- mysterydip 4y agoThis sounds like the Kenyan college essay industry conversation the other day. I wonder if the same arguments will apply ("this is good for them because they can do more creative things instead or start businesses to help the local economy", etc)
- throwaway2037 4y agoCaroline O'Donoghue has written about exactly this phenomenom. As a creative writer, you only ever see your "competition's" top work. All the crap that you are forced to do to pay the bills never gets any attention. Her blog is here: https://sentimentalgarbage.substack.com/p/the-pied-piper-is-a-victim-of-the https://sentimentalgarbage.substack.com/p/the-pied-piper-is-...
- jgalt212 4y ago> "never hired a writer better than ChatGPT" Indeed. I stopped reading after this inane quote.
- amelius 4y agoThis is how the future of communication will look: 1. Sender writes a bunch of bullet points and asks ChatGPT to convert it to coherent long form text. 2. Receiver takes the long form text and asks ChatGPT to summarize it into bullet points.
- cultureswitch 4y agoYou might have meant this in jest but considering some of our human to human communication is already like that, I think this is 100% prophetic.
- varispeed 4y agoThis human copywriter pun is extremely bad. I don't think any respectable agency would run with it, simply because it has highly inappropriate sexual connotation that could potentially be offensive to many customers. Ad like this could easily get someone in trouble when used in wrong context (neurodivergent people especially have a problem with this). See also: https://www.kentonline.co.uk/kent/news/boss-suspended-after-glazed-ring-donut-gag-206548/ https://www.kentonline.co.uk/kent/news/boss-suspended-after-...
- mejutoco 4y agoSadly, in general people do not appreciate good writing. Translators, for instance, have little status, and do not get paid very well unless they deal with legal ol live interpreting. Can we name the translators of some books on our shelves? Personally, no. I only remember the three body problem translator is the brother if the author, IIRC.
- hebrox 4y agoI also gave it a shot. I'm Dutch and never heard of hot buns before, so I first tried to generate the prompt: * This is a slogan for hot buns: "Go Out With All Buns Glazing." Can you explain why this is a good slogan? "Go Out With All Buns Glazing" is a good slogan for hot buns for several reasons: * Can you list 10 characteristics of hot buns? * Can you list 10 characteristics of Americans? * As a hot bun company CEO can you write a briefing for a marketing firm to come up with 10 new ideas for a slogan. The slogan should contain at least 1 pun. The briefing should be 1000 words long. Please use this information in the briefing . A good slogan has these characteristics: [copy paste of previous answers] And then in a new session: As the creative director of a marketing firm, you get this briefing. Please generate 10 slogans. ```As the CEO of [Hot Bun Company], I am excited to collaborate with your marketing firm to develop a fresh, creative, and engaging slogan for our brand. Our hot buns have a reputation for being freshly baked, warm, and delicious, and we want our new slogan to effectively convey the unique appeal of our product. In this brief, I will outline the essential elements we would like to see incorporated into our new slogan and provide some background on the characteristics of our hot buns, as well as some general observations about common cultural characteristics often associated with Americans. Our goal is to create a slogan that resonates with our target audience and sets our brand apart. To create an effective slogan, we would like to emphasize the following characteristics: Play on words: Our new slogan should contain at least one pun, making it clever, memorable, and easily relatable to our product. Evokes imagery: We want the slogan to bring to mind the image of warm, freshly baked buns, enticing potential customers to try our product. Energetic tone: The slogan should have an energetic tone that appeals to consumers and makes our brand more memorable. Positive connotations: Incorporate elements that suggest our hot buns are made with great care and enthusiasm, encouraging customers to try them. Short and catchy: Finally, the slogan should be short, memorable, and easy to understand. When creating the new slogan, please consider the following characteristics of our hot buns: Freshly baked Soft and fluffy Warm Glazed or topped Aromatic Versatile Golden brown Moist Comfort food Shareable Additionally, we want to ensure that our slogan resonates with our target audience – Americans. As such, please keep the following general cultural characteristics in mind during the slogan creation process: Individualism Patriotism Optimism Consumerism Diversity Informality Work ethic Philanthropy Entrepreneurship Mobility By incorporating these elements, we believe that we can create a slogan that not only encapsulates the essence of our hot bun brand but also resonates with our target audience. Our objective is to receive 10 new slogan ideas that embody these characteristics while integrating at least one pun. We trust your marketing expertise and creativity to develop a slogan that captures the attention of consumers and highlights the unique appeal of our hot buns. We look forward to reviewing your ideas and working closely with you to finalize a new slogan that will become synonymous with our brand.``` And the results: "Bunbelievable Freshness: Taste the Warmth!" "Hot Buns: America's Baked Bliss" "Rolling in Flavor: Savor the Golden Goodness" "A Bun in Every Oven: Fresh, Warm, United" "Rise to the Occasion: Hot Buns, Hearty Smiles" "Bake My Day: Irresistibly Soft and Shareable" "Bun Voyage: Embark on a Warm, Fluffy Adventure" "Bun Appetit: Taste the All-American Aroma" "Happiness is a Warm Bun: Freshly Baked and Ready to Roll" "The United Buns of America: Let Your Taste Buds Soar" Not award winning, but some are pretty good.
- coffeebeqn 4y agoYou need to give it more context. If you don’t give any style guidance then of course you get the default chatgpt style