6 ms·
Anti-cheat software is designed to own your machine, take away your control and monitor you. They are indistinguishable from malware. Valve should be taken to t
by matheusmoreira 4y ago
Anti-cheat software is designed to own your machine, take away your control and monitor you. They are indistinguishable from malware. Valve should be taken to task for not only allowing this malicious software in their platform but also for actively distributing it to users.
Thank you for citing this. I favorited it as yet another example to cite whenever the topic comes up.
Seems to be a trend with japanese companies. Check out the wonderful consequences of allowing these corporations access to your computer:
https://github.com/FuzzySecurity/Capcom-Rootkit https://github.com/FuzzySecurity/Capcom-Rootkit
https://fuzzysecurity.com/tutorials/28.html https://fuzzysecurity.com/tutorials/28.html
- mananaysiempre 4y agoMoney quote: “Essentially, [CAPCOM.SYS] provides ring-0 code execution as a service! Its only function is to take a userland pointer, disable SMEP [thus allowing the kernel to execute from userland-owned pages], execute code at the pointer address and re-enable SMEP.”
- xvinci 4y agoI mean, yeah you are right calling those out, but there is a plethora of vulnerable drivers from e.g. mainboard and GPU manufacturers, very often installed by default on new machines. I would distinguish between an Anti-Cheat actively doing shady stuff (like it seems to be the case here) and companies simply shipping crappy software - because that's too often the case in many areas.
- matheusmoreira 4y agoThat's no excuse. I call those manufacturers out too. The truth is these hardware manufacturers treat software as a cost center, don't invest in it and make shitty software as a result. Honestly they shouldn't even be writing software at all, they should be publishing specs so that better people can write it and mainline it on Linux where it belongs. At least they aren't literally in the business of making malware designed to own people's computers with the express purpose of denying them their computing freedom. That's ultimately what "cheating" is: an exercise in computer freedom. The game is running on my computer, of course I can modify it if I want. Any attempt to prevent me from doing so obviously requires that the computer not obey me anymore. The only thing that separates this crap from malware is some terms of service document nobody reads. I've always been aware that all proprietary software is potential malware but I always gave these developers the benefit of the doubt until the actual vulnerabilities started surfacing. I remember my very first comments on reddit years ago were on a news post about some flight simulator software exfiltrating your browser's saved username and passwords directly to the game company. Let me see if I can dig up that thread. Edit: found it, here it is: https://old.reddit.com/r/flightsim/comments/7yh4zu/deleted_by_user/?limit=500 https://old.reddit.com/r/flightsim/comments/7yh4zu/deleted_b... https://www.pcmag.com/news/flight-sim-labs-fights-piracy-by-installing-malware https://www.pcmag.com/news/flight-sim-labs-fights-piracy-by-... > These idiots sent the passwords over HTTP to a machine running RDP on the public internet!! WTF, this stupidity has to be criminal! Can't make this shit up.
- gabereiser 4y agoYou hit it with "they shouldn't be writing software at all, they should be publishing spec". I've been wanting to roll my own board for a long time (not the hardware, the boot and os side) but haven't outside of a raspi or arduino. I'd LOVE to be able to write my own motherboard code to have a better boot experience (somewhere between Apple Mac's and uSplash Linux) that's fast to user-land. There have been some companies that recently announced this kind of approach (at least with linux) but overall, we need our computer industry to be more open, we need more accountability of shady practices (exfiltrations!) and modern laws to allow people to protect themselves from these corporations that mean to steal our data.
- reactordev 4y agoEspecially since Valve already has anti-cheat malware. The reality is that the only way to combat cheating is to stream it to the client but as we've seen with Stadia, it's just not quite there yet. Instead, they turn your machine into an internet-cafe appliance and prevent you from undoing it. To find cheaters, simply look at stats and behavior. You don't need to lock down a PC. You need to lock down your logs server-side. It's also pretty scary that it's open sourced so more developers can use it. I cringe at having to fight root kits with every game uninstall. I'm a huge fan of games that detect cheaters in subtle ways and direct them to unintended outcomes. Like being stuck in the elevator unable to escape. Or what COD is doing with cheaters, taking away their senses and ability to see people or objectives. Kids will complain it's a bug or what not on the support forums only to expose themselves and get banned.
- matheusmoreira 4y ago> Instead, they turn your machine into an internet-cafe appliance and prevent you from undoing it. Exactly. It disgusts me to my core, the audacity of these corporations. > To find cheaters, simply look at stats and behavior. Partially agree. This is especially relevant in skill-based games but I assume such statistics can be poisoned by cheaters over time, increasing false negatives. There are also game designs where bots are literally indistinguishable from sufficiently addicted players. Think anything with a reward schedule in the game design: MMORPGs with timed spawns, mobile games with timed rate limited gameplay. Especially the latter. In the end, Linus Torvalds is right about security: if the word "trust" isn't involved, it's not security, it's masturbation. We should be playing games with friends who we trust instead of randoms from the internet.
- gabereiser 4y agoAt an individual level, if a player goes from 1.3K/D avg over a sample and then it jumps to 8K/D over the same sample duration later, it’s pretty obvious. Wall hacking and aim bot can be caught with behavior and statistics. Not in real-time but damn near.
- 4y ago
- overthrow 4y agoDoes Windows Defender not flag stuff like that as malware and immediately remove it? Seems like it should. Once upon a time Microsoft wasn't afraid to stand up to corporate-sponsored malware. https://www.zdnet.com/article/microsoft-will-wipe-sonys-rootkit/ https://www.zdnet.com/article/microsoft-will-wipe-sonys-root... I guess that's changed?
- matheusmoreira 4y agoIt's a "legitimate" corporation. The malware has a "legitimate" purpose. The user "technically" agreed to the abuse when they mashed next on the install wizard. I seriously doubt any anti-malware software will block this.
- akiselev 4y agoOnce upon a time Microsoft didn’t put ads in their operating system. Microsoft has jumped the shark. Stop giving it the benefit of the doubt.
- jacquesm 4y agoMicrosoft jumped the shark decades ago.
- ajsnigrutin 4y agoYep, this should be a solution... stop the malware from working, and if the game doesn't work, the users can refund it (since the gameplay time will be 0 hours anyway). Let the developers (well... managers) deal with the refunds then.
- baby 4y agoI think you mean: > software is designed to own your machine, take away your control and monitor you This is not really a problem with anti cheat
- matheusmoreira 4y agoIt absolutely is an inherent problem of anti-cheat software. By definition, that software exists to deny you the freedom to cheat or otherwise modify the game. The only way they can possibly do that is to pwn your machine. Don't generalize that to all software. Free software doesn't do that. GNU was literally founded on the principle of not doing that.
- kube-system 4y agoThat’s not a “problem” with anti-cheat, it’s the entire point. It is a group of people who have chosen to give up their freedom to modify their games in exchange for the ability to play with other people who agree to the same. It is okay for private clubs to have rules for the conduct of their consenting members. FOSS is great for allowing individual freedom of software developers. It doesn’t provide functional solutions for all of the worlds problems, though.
- baby 4y agoThey don’t prevent you to cheat, they monitor to detect cheat. Big difference.
- matheusmoreira 4y agoPlenty of software will kick you from servers or even kill the game process if they detect anything, including false positives like some suspicious string in a completely unrelated chat application. Who cares though? Fine, you can say they monitor you. The point is: to monitor you, they gotta pwn your machine. If they don't you can just defeat their silly "monitoring" software. They own your machine by installing kernel mode malware into your OS. They literally rootkit your computer.
- still_grokking 4y agoNot to mention: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sony_BMG_copy_protection_rootkit_scandal https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sony_BMG_copy_protection_rootk...
- matheusmoreira 4y agoCheck this out too: https://old.reddit.com/r/flightsim/comments/7yh4zu/deleted_by_user/?limit=500 https://old.reddit.com/r/flightsim/comments/7yh4zu/deleted_b... Flight simulator software developer ships malware to users, exfiltrates browser's password store to their servers without even using encryption.
- dylan604 4y agoyou forgot to mention that tiny little Japanese company that was pretty famous for it's rootkit via audio CDs, Sony
- matheusmoreira 4y agoI didn't mention them because while it was a DRM rootkit it had to do with anti-cheating software which is what this particular thread is about. I've indirectly mentioned them in other posts.
- dylan604 4y agoa rootkit is a rootkit. doesn't matter its purpose.
- itsTyrion 4y agoI think we can agree Valorant's anticheat Vanguard is kinda intrusive, having a Ring 0 component (tbf: it works). HOWEVER, it and the user mode component are run on demand. The issue here is sending data all the time and being balls deep in your Windows install even after removing the game
- marcosdumay 4y agoI'm not sure they should refuse to distribute it. But all those things on the comment should be actively disclaimed with high emphasis before you buy the game, and stay available for consultation indefinitely afterwards.