6 ms·
Trendy “raw water” source under bird’s nest sparks diarrheal outbreak
- rmah 4y agoIs it wrong of me to think "evolution in action" here?
- samtho 4y agoThe basic idea behind the Darwin Awards.
- rekabis 4y agoWe should really remove all warning labels, and let evolution pour a little bleach into the shallow end of the gene pool. We’ve bubble-wrapped far too much of humanity, especially in western societies. And while everyone is entitled to their own life (excepting some of the most egregious of murderers), what we are not entitled to is artificial insulation from the consequences of our actions and decisions.
- giraffe_lady 4y ago2008 ass edgelord shit I've been reading this for decades and its never made any more sense. This pseudo-rational malicious superiority complex is such a weird affectation where do you all even learn this stuff is there like a school or. You are just openly and frankly advocating for more preventable harm and death this is not normal behavior.
- michaelmrose 4y agoYou should have learned how and why we treat water several times in the course of science class and if you missed it anyone who hikes around the great outdoors who took the time to look up anything whatsoever would have been apt to find instructions on the danger of "raw water". Furthermore these people aren't folks who wandered by and saw a water feature fit to slake their thirst they deliberately sought it out. They are emphatically so stupid it would actually be a shame if they had kids. Nobody actually walks around pulling off warning labels and hoping people hurt themselves. People in general do as they did here and go to extensive efforts to keep said idiots from harming themselves, then turn around and live in a society that is worse off for having the idiots. This is why people blow of steam by saying spiteful things on the internet. This is emphatically normal.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- ASalazarMX 4y agoNot at all. If some of them adapt to contaminated water, they'll be more hydrated than the ones with bloody diarrhea, and pass their resistance to their descendants.
- morkalork 4y agoGiven that humans haven't adapted 100% to "raw water" after millennia of evolution, the odds aren't really in their favor.
- gobengo 4y agomillenia is not very much time to be applying inductive reasoning about future odds. absence of evidence is not evidence of absence
- morkalork 4y agoWhy don't you go out and drink raw water for a while and report back after.
- fluoridation 4y agoThe question is whether drinking contaminated water has a survival advantage. It could have one if clean water is so scarce to the point that you're more likely to die of thirst before reproductive age than of bacterial infection.
- olodus 4y agoMillenia is however a bloody long time to have daily diarrhea. But I commend them for trying. Good luck.
- ars 4y agoPeople who grow up with untreated water do in fact have resistance to the pathogens in it. See: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Travelers%27_diarrhea https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Travelers%27_diarrhea
- ThrowawayTestr 4y agoAnd I thought drinking raw milk was needlessly dangerous.
- Fatnino 4y agoIt is however, delicious.
- crazygringo 4y agoI respectfully disagree, but to each their own. I love milk. But the first time I had it straight from the cow, it was... not what I expected. I'll take mine filtered, homogenized and cooled down to refrigerator temperature please.
- secondcoming 4y agoAre you used to UHT milk?
- Fatnino 4y agoWhen I was a kid we used to drive out to a farm every Sunday to buy milk. We'd go early because us kids liked watching the cows. Before bottling (in glass bottles that you had to bring back) the milk would drip over some cold rollers so it wasn't cow temperature by the time it got to the milk crate in the car. It spent the rest of the week in our refrigerator and after the first night all the bottles would be cream in the top 1/3 or so of the bottle and out of this world delicious milk in the rest. After that farm closed it took me many years to not equate the taste of "normal" store bought milk to that of water.
- crazygringo 4y agoFunny, I find the milk left after the cream has separated to just be kind of... watery and not flavorful. Because the fat is gone. That's why I said homogenized -- I drink whole milk for both the flavor and the nutrition. Also I'm in the US so I'm talking about store-bought milk you buy refrigerated and with an expiration date 10 days out. It's still quite "fresh". Not UHT milk sold in much of the world that keeps for months unopened at room temperature. Which doesn't have the same flavor at all, although there has been some advancement there depending on the brand. But of course, let me be clear -- at the end of the day there's no arguing with childhood memories. :) What's most valuable is the whole family experience!
- ASalazarMX 4y agoWonder if these people who are afraid of fluoridated water have heard of toothpaste.
- skyyler 4y agoHave you paid attention to the toothpastes commercially available? A shocking number proudly claim to be fluoride free!
- gruez 4y agoI'm not against fluoride in tap water but even I can recognize that there's a big difference between something that's in the water you drink vs something that's in your mouth for 2-3 minutes.
- shaftway 4y agoSublingual drug administration is one of the most rapid uptake forms that exist. The list is basically: - Intravenous - Inhalation (for things easily aerosolized) - Sublingual - Everything else (including intramuscular and subcutaneous) This is often the preferred route for oral medications that aren't too bitter for people, because it avoids stomach acids. So if the thought is that people don't want it in their bloodstream from ingestion, it's probably already there. That doesn't even get into the concentrations. Standard water fluoride rates is on the rate of 1 ppm, whereas toothpaste is typically well over 1000 ppm. The amount of fluoride you swallow as a by-process of brushing your teeth would far outweigh what you drink in a day.
- 4y ago
- anigbrowl 4y agoI don't understand why they turned the water source off. There was a sign saying it wasn't intended for drinking. If people insist on ignoring things and get sick, too bad. If I go hiking I will sometimes drink from a stream or spring. I know there's a risk to this and I accept it. If I'm going to be out in nature for longer I'm more likely to use a filter like a lifestraw or boil water.
- bpfrh 4y agoTreating those people cost money, in the long run probably more than rerouting the stream
- therein 4y agoIf that's what free or socialized healthcare would make people feel entitled to make decisions on, I am not even sure if it is worth it. We don't even have it and the mindset may be leaking into second degree decisions like that. I know you aren't suggesting it that way but your post made me ponder about it. If you socialize healthcare, you are automatically getting someone that says "oh no you don't, not on my dime, I'm gonna have to take care of you if something happens to you, no, no, no", which is practically a parent. It is probably a conversation that should be had. You rarely see it explored from that angle.
- taylodl 4y agoHealthcare costs are already socialized, even here in the United States. We call those costs "healthcare premiums." Why the majority of Americans don't recognize this simple fact is beyond me.
- Gibbon1 4y agoMedicare pays for about 2/3 of the nations healthcare costs. And that's totally a socialized payer system.
- kobalsky 4y agoif it's hard to understand maybe there's a rage bait component at play, maybe the people who got sick aren't new-age health nuts but that were kids playing around that zone.
- ramesh31 4y agoThere are plenty of ways to source "raw water" safely from mountain springs. It's not strictly a bad idea like raw milk or something. But if you're below the treeline, there's a 100% chance you'll be drinking animal shit.
- ackbar03 4y agoIt's not diarrhea it's a detox. Your just getting the bad stuff out of your body that's why it smells so bad.
- init2null 4y agoI can't bring myself to fully believe that you're being sarcastic. It's just too real.
- gonesilent 4y agoI wouldn't call the only water source for these people trendy.
- ineedasername 4y agoIt's not the only source. In fact it was water coming out of a concrete box located on private property. And the trendy part is that it's not isolated to this location or these people: https://www.nytimes.com/2017/12/29/dining/raw-water-unfiltered.html https://www.nytimes.com/2017/12/29/dining/raw-water-unfilter...
- mcguire 4y agoDo you have a source for that claim?
- Havoc 4y agoMy uncle does raw water off roof runoff much to my surprise. His response was never go sick so must be fine. About a year later he ended up in hospital dangerously sick with a mystery something. Pretty sure he went straight back to drinking it though
- therein 4y ago> raw water off roof runoff Isn't that basically puddle water? Would he drink from a muddy water puddle after it rains? What's the logic here.
- chomp 4y agoProbably something analogous to the 5 second rule: if it doesn't touch the ground, it's fine. Water falling from the sky, even if you store it in clean rain barrels, still contains impurities and pollutants that the rain passes through. https://www.cdc.gov/healthywater/drinking/private/rainwater-collection.html https://www.cdc.gov/healthywater/drinking/private/rainwater-...
- jgon 4y agoProbably worse depending on what type of roofing you have. Asphalt shingle debris sitting in water for an extended amount probably isn't putting anything good into it.
- maxerickson 4y agoMost roofing systems are pretty inert. I'd be more concerned about lead or rubber than asphalt (but still not really that concerned).
- Havoc 4y agoDon’t know the type but agreed can’t be particularly safe
- Havoc 4y agoYep. I think it’s insane but he’s a grown adult He’s after reducing eco footprint not health benefits though. Not that it matter for safety
- kortex 4y agoI have an interesting friend, with many interesting antics. They have a property with a clear creek running through it, and wanted to know if it had giardia. Assays are expensive, but metronidazole is cheap, so they drank the water, and determined shortly thereafter, it in fact had giardia.