11 ms·
YouTube-DL Hosting Ban Paves the Way to Privatized Censorship
- oefrha 4y agoyoutube-dl is dead. Interesting they’re still fighting over essentially a pointer to a dead GitHub repo. yt-dlp doesn’t have a standalone website so they’ll have to deal with Microsoft directly. Edit: I wasn't aware development has resumed. The latest release is still stuck way back in the past though. Also typoed 'yt-dlp' as 'youtube-dlp' in the original comment; now fixed.
- adminu 4y agoLast activity in the repository shows today for me. Why do you think it is dead?
- thaumasiotes 4y agoA while ago youtube-dl broke and wasn't fixed. yt-dlp fixed the problem. Granted, I haven't kept up on whether original youtube-dl eventually got around to getting its primary functionality to work. The several-month interregnum that definitely occurred seems like a good reason to consider it "dead".
- bharathyes 4y agoNot sure which problem you refer to but it is an active repo that has worked well for the past few months atleast.
- thaumasiotes 4y ago> Not sure which problem you refer to It stopped being able to download videos from youtube. That's not the only functionality, but -- given the name of the software -- I'd say it should have been fixed. All the repo activity in the world won't balance out the inability to do the only thing you advertise that you can do.
- Larrikin 4y agoHave you tried yt-dlp? I remember what made me switch. YouTube downloading didn't break, but became extremely slow when compared to my actual network speeds. YouTube seems to do something to fuck with the speeds every so often. yt-dlp is quick to hop on those issues.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- noirscape 4y agoIt's been fixed but the new maintainer refuses to release a new version until someone manages to help him figure out how to get automated builds running (which seems to have been the problem for the past year and he refuses to just do a manual build so that youtube-dl at least works with YouTube). yt-dlp is a better maintained fork.
- defrost 4y agoThe last official release was 2021.12.17. The I can't believe it's not youtube-dl quasi unofficial fork yt-dlp has a most recent stable release 2023.03.04 (last month). Of the two one is keeping up with the month by month twists and turns of websites altering their video embed methodologies to defeat CLI rippers .. and the other one isn't.
- bharathyes 4y agoboth their release cycles and what they consider as stable might differ and not necessarily mean one is better. yt-dlp still claims to keep track with the parent project. Most would use it for the additional functionalities it provides over youtube-dl.
- sli 4y agoytp-dl is also many, many times faster than the original, in my experience. youtube-dl is almost unusable for mass downloading by comparison.
- defrost 4y agoThere is much much more to the code base than simply youtube ripping, both can (in theory) also rip from (say) ABC Australia's iView, from the Royal Institute Christmas Lecture series, from redtube, etc (hundreds and hundreds of variations of websites). That shim layer between the core ripping engine(s) and the manifold ways of embedding access to a stream is what is being kept current in yt-dlp releases (and -U updates). Original most recent official youtube-dl (December 2021 release) can no longer find its update service.
- thaumasiotes 4y ago> both their release cycles and what they consider as stable might differ and not necessarily mean one is better. You're making it very difficult to take you seriously. Have you actually used youtube-dl?
- anenefan 4y agoyoutube-dl only works for some people around the globe, as youtube is apparently running A/B testing. Yeah there's a sort of fix ... that's been tucked away at github by way of go nowhere link, but there's the given idea it's time to ditch the cheap computer or online server and try and get something else to run instead. I read that sort of sentiment as that yup it's probably dead and maybe time to move onto more expensive toys that programmers really give a fuck, well that year ... or just ignore youtube for the time being. It's sad because what I generally viewed on youtube was of no interest to the music industry.
- probably_wrong 4y agoFor the sake of testing, I just downloaded youtube-dl from Github [1]. I then tried to run the program, but it failed with: /usr/bin/env: ‘python’: No such file or directory Okay, the script can't deal with "python" vs "python3", whatever - I'll change the script's first line and move on. Next attempt: $ youtube-dl https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5pV8WFvSNYE [youtube] 5pV8WFvSNYE: Downloading webpage ERROR: Unable to extract uploader id; please report this issue on https://yt-dl.org/bug. Make sure you are using the latest version; type youtube-dl -U to update. Be sure to call youtube-dl with the --verbose flag and include its complete output. I knew I would get this error because I got it two weeks ago already. And considering that the version number is `2021.12.17` that looks suspiciously close to a dead project, or at least for a project whose very description is "download videos from youtube.com or other video platforms". Edit: I went through the repo and found that this bug has been reported two months ago [2]. I understand that the project is not dead in the sense that they are still looking at bugs, but if a major feature is not working for two months now then I think it's reasonable for people's faith in the project's future to be shaken. [1] https://github.com/ytdl-org/youtube-dl#installation https://github.com/ytdl-org/youtube-dl#installation [2] https://github.com/ytdl-org/youtube-dl/issues/31530 https://github.com/ytdl-org/youtube-dl/issues/31530
- blueflow 4y agoI think if you have python installed but no 'python' executable in PATH, your install is broken.
- pasc1878 4y agoNo the issue is that python on its own meant python2 for a long time and there are still distributions still using python2 I you need python3 the you need to put python3 in the shebang
- noselasd 4y agoThat depends on who "you" are. Linux distros these days tend to ship modern python package with a python3 executable, no python executable. Many distros still support a python2 package, some install that as a python exeutable, some as a python2 executable. iirc. homebrew on OSX installs python as a python3 executable, no python exeutable. Hopefully no-one should support python v2 in 2023 ?
- kgwxd 4y agoI just used it last week, latest dev build, worked better than I ever imagined it was going to.
- PurpleRamen 4y agoyoutube-dl is not dead, it just had a longer pause for reasons. There is (again) active development for some while now, after some reorganization and new focus[1]. [1] https://github.com/ytdl-org/youtube-dl/issues/30568 https://github.com/ytdl-org/youtube-dl/issues/30568
- josteink 4y agoThey've alienated contributors, had toxic feedback to community patches and have in general done everything they can to become irrelevant. These days yt-dlp covers my needs instead, and unlike youtube-dl, they the seem to be accepting patches, making yt-dlp work (and keep working) on more sites and services than youtube-dl does. There's no (technical) reason for anyone to rely on youtube-dl any longer.
- noirscape 4y agoTo be precise, what seems to have gone wrong is that youtube-dl went down the "insane compatibility" road. The new maintainer has put demands in place to support python 2.6 and up, which is fucking bonkers. Nevermind the fact that 2.6 is even deader than 2.7 ever was (which was the version of python2 officially deprecated three years ago). A side effect of this is that the new maintainer also rejects any patches that introduce new dependencies (existing ones being used is fine though), which has killed support since nobody wants to reimplement certain things to work with a python version that is pretty much only used by one guy still running Windows XP (who began to whine on the issue tracker about being ignored even though XP hasn't even been enterprise supported by Microsoft since 2019 but I guess this one guy is a valuable user?) yt-dlp on the other hand follows the "reasonable" road of compatibility, which is "current python3 version + 5 minor versions going back" (which is also the standard used for deprecating things in the python stdlib and security patches). Much better and it seems to have healthier contributors as a result.
- midoridensha 4y ago>They've alienated contributors, had toxic feedback to community patches and have in general done everything they can to become irrelevant. This sounds a lot like what happened to XFree86 when X.org forked it. >There's no (technical) reason for anyone to rely on youtube-dl any longer. Yeah, I gave up on youtube-dl a while ago when I discovered yt-dlp. The latter actually works really, really well, while the former is broken. I'm not sure why anyone still bothers with youtube-dl, but then again there's still a few weirdos who won't give up on XFree86 after all these years, and a few other weirdos who still refuse to abandon OpenOffice.org.
- luto 4y agoyoutube-dl isn't fighting anything here. Their hoster uberspace.de is defendant in this suit for hosting a business card website pointing ytdl-users to github.
- oefrha 4y ago> They're still fighting... They = RIAA.
- yoyohello13 4y agoShhh... don't mention that program. Do you want them to take that one down too?
- luckylion 4y agoImportant to say that Hamburg's district court regularly hands out insane judgements that show that judges understand barely anything about the technology involved and will follow whatever trail the larger business interest will lead them on. Fortunately, they can (and do) get overruled, but it'll take more time and money. We really need some form of process to retire judges that clearly haven't kept up with the times and still think in terms of 'series of tubes'. It can't be the only solution to promote them to a different court and hope they'll do less damage.
- crest 4y agoThey know how keep their court busy by handing out favourable judgments. Fuck "Fliegender Gerichtsstand".
- kristopolous 4y agoEven the "series of tubes" thing can easily explain this. Should the water company be liable if say, some serial killer uses their tubes to drown his victims? Should the electricity provider be liable for powering the computers that ran the servers? These aren't new legal questions or anything - pretty common to come across them in law school. Ianal but I've taken some basic classes and even I've seen them! The rulings, instead, are a consequence of the personal interest and personal ideology of the jurist. We need to collectively create something better then the assumed good faith enlightened monarchies that we call the court systems. The results they produce seem to have chronic problems
- nnx 4y agoAgree on your examples about judging liable a water company or electricity company for helping criminals… And yet that slippery slope has been totally taken for granted in recent decades for banking and finance…
- Retric 4y agoThat argument only stands up until the law is actually changed to make companies specifically liable. Which is what happened in banking and finance.
- waltbosz 4y agoI don't understand, what was Uberspace hosting? Was it just an informational webpage about youtube-dl with no downloadable binaries? The article says the downloads were hosted on GitHub which was linked to by the Uberspace site.
- dindresto 4y agoThey _are_ still hosting https://youtube-dl.org/ https://youtube-dl.org/, which does only link to / redirect to the downloads and repository on Github. While there are download links like https://youtube-dl.org/downloads/latest/youtube-dl.exe https://youtube-dl.org/downloads/latest/youtube-dl.exe on the website, they simply return a 302 redirect to the latest artifact on Github, i.e., https://github.com/ytdl-org/youtube-dl/releases/download/2021.12.17/youtube-dl.exe https://github.com/ytdl-org/youtube-dl/releases/download/202....
- blueflow 4y agoAt Uberspace, you get a shell account with email and webroot. Some sort of console-friendly shared hosting.
- resuresu 4y agoThe internet is dying.
- AstixAndBelix 4y agoAnd using services that need ads to survive by bypassing those ads does not help!
- vorticalbox 4y agothis is why i disbale my adblock on reasources that are using them to stay around.
- grugagag 4y agoHave you tried disabling adblocks on youtube? It’s only not usable but downright malicious
- vorticalbox 4y agoI mostly watch YouTube on my phone and ads are reasonable. Usually 2 short ones at the start then nothing else.
- t-3 4y agoYouTube isn't what's dying, it's the organic, non-monetized, grassroots web that's being killed off. You know, the stuff that's actually interesting and cool and not trying to sell you anything.
- pixl97 4y agoStop talking to each other and start buying things.... https://catvalente.substack.com/p/stop-talking-to-each-other-and-start https://catvalente.substack.com/p/stop-talking-to-each-other...
- pixl97 4y agoAds are the reason the internet is dying....
- kevincox 4y agoThe fact that "technological protection measures" have any bearing on legality is stupid. Implementation details shouldn't affect if something is legal or not. It seems like this is adding an rule that is easier to watch people with because the media conglomerates couldn't sure people for doing other things they didn't like.
- mindslight 4y agoIMO "technological protection measures" should be legally significant in that they should prevent the ability to claim copyright. One should either get a government-granted limited monopoly on reproduction in exchange for it entering the public domain after that period, xor law of the information jungle when you attempt to keep society from using the work for all time - not the intersection of both. Alternatively copyright could just require the original creative work being put in escrow, so that it's available after the limited monopoly period.
- xkcd1963 4y agoYes, youtube makes money by people watching their stuff. They shouldn't discriminate then who (or how) they are watching it.
- nwellnhof 4y ago> We also got ourselves informed about ‘fair use’ under German law. We even appointed a lawyer, at our own cost, who did his own research and also came to the conclusion that what youtube-dl does is perfectly legal and covered by fair use That sounds strange. There's no "fair use" doctrine in German copyright law.
- bjornsing 4y agoArr you sure? We don’t use that exact term in Sweden but there’s similar room for legal use of copyrighted works e.g. in political satire.
- mschuster91 4y agoI'd guess they base the argument on §95a Abs. 3 Nr. 2 UrhG [1]: basically, providing youtube-dl is legal as the part bypassing Youtube's technical protection is just a small part of it, and other than that its primary purpose is to allow an user to exercise their explicit right to make individual private copies of a work of art under §53 UrhG [2]. [1] https://www.gesetze-im-internet.de/urhg/__95a.html https://www.gesetze-im-internet.de/urhg/__95a.html [2] https://www.gesetze-im-internet.de/urhg/__53.html https://www.gesetze-im-internet.de/urhg/__53.html
- summarity 4y agoYes there is (of course nothing is ever exactly the same): https://www.bildung-forschung.digital/digitalezukunft/de/wissen/urheberrecht/urheberrecht-in-der-wissenschaft/gesetzliche-erlaubnis-und-zitatrecht/gesetzliche-erlaubnis-und-zitatrecht.html https://www.bildung-forschung.digital/digitalezukunft/de/wis...
- nwellnhof 4y agoThere are some limitations to copyright protection in German law, but each of them is specific. There's no general exemption like fair use.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- latexr 4y ago> We strongly believe we’re on the right side of history here. Everyone except the music industry knows this I don’t think higher-ups at the RIAA or MPAA are so naïve as to believe they’re doing the right thing in any situation. They just prefer money and power to being decent. Wikipedia gives more weight to Mitch Glazier¹ being a lobbyist than RIAA’s CEO. It comes as no surprise that: > He played a role in drafting the No Electronic Theft Act, the Digital Millennium Copyright Act, and the Copyright Term Extension Act. ¹ https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mitch_Glazier https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mitch_Glazier
- baryphonic 4y ago> I don’t think higher-ups at the RIAA or MPAA are so naïve as to believe they’re doing the right thing in any situation. I learned last week when taking my kids to see the Mario Bros. movie that it's no longer MPAA, but now MPA, the Motion Picture Association. I saw it on the green preview cards before each coming attraction. It's a bit scary: they now see their toxic behavior not only afflicting America, but the entire world.
- Joker_vD 4y agoThat's... been true for decades. The US has this peculiar level of international power where changes in its laws end up directly affecting the rest of the world.
- ghostDancer 4y agoThey even pressure some countries like Spain to change their laws to follow MPA and RIAA desires. I recall around 2010-2011 in Spain politicians made law called "Sinde", surname of the person behind it, at the time it was published in some newspapers that it came to fruition after a meeting/conversations with some USA government members, in some media they even called it "Sinde Biden", yep that one .
- whatgoodisaroad 4y agoI think that's a little harsh on RIAA/MPAA exexs. Their comfortable way of living gets validation from how enthusiastically property laws are enforced. That leaves plenty of room for them to believe they're doing the Right Thing™. Even though, as an article of basic critical thinking, they certainly aren't.
- villgax 4y agoIf YouTube had any issue with people downloading freely available videos they should just put their content behind a paywall instead of masquerading as a video host
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- Linosaurus 4y agoIf YouTube-dl let you bypass the paywall, that would make its main use closer to “obviously illegal”. If it only allows a paying user to make a local copy against the company’s wishes, we would have about the same situation as today. And maybe also a lot of banned YouTube/google accounts when detected.
- anthk 4y agoI can pass local newspapers' paywalls by just renaming the URL into [_] amp [dot] html.
- villgax 4y agoYep DMCA exists for a reason. But YouTube doesn't want to loose out on Ad revenue by paywalling free content like Netflix does with paid content. The content itself apart from Trailers is mostly intended for public viewing regardless of whether YouTube has chosen to monetize it with Ads or whatever
- walterbell 4y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Invidious https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Invidious > Invidious is a free and open-source alternative frontend to YouTube. It is available as a Docker container, or from the GitHub master branch. It is intended to be used as a lightweight and "privacy-respecting" alternative to the official YouTube website. There are multiple online mirrors, some with web download that even works on iOS. https://gonzoknows.com/posts/Yattee/ https://gonzoknows.com/posts/Yattee/ & https://apps.apple.com/us/app/yattee/id1595136629 https://apps.apple.com/us/app/yattee/id1595136629 > Yattee is an advanced video and audio player that can be used to play local and remote files and media links. It is available on the Apple App Store and is marketed as such. However, its core purpose is to function as an ad-free and sponsor-free YouTube app, allowing users to watch and subscribe to any YouTube channel. Due to the strict terms of service of the Apple App Store, Yattee cannot advertise this aspect of its functionality.
- redog 4y agoyewtu.be is an invidious instance with an easy to remember domain name.
- _0ffh 4y agoWow, I occasionally open Youtube in a private browser window, and am invariably disgusted by the hot garbage that it recommends. When I opened your link just now, the video recommendations were incomparably better. Do you know if Invidious does any curation or is it just that their average user is so much more discerning in their consumption?
- seabass-labrax 4y agoNeither the project Invidious nor the software Invidious does any kind of curation - it's just the usual YouTube recommendations, but as if all of the users of each Invidious instance were one person. It's interesting to see how the recommendations differ between instances, reflecting the interests of the average user on that instance. I find that I enjoy YouTube a lot more with that kind of semi-personalised experience, in the same way that Hacker News has a collective but remarkably distinctive feeling compared to other forums/link aggregators.
- narrator 4y agoSci-hub is still up even though corps have been trying to shut that down for years.
- trasz3 4y agoSo why is it hosted in Germany and not, say, China?
- throwaway290 4y agoMaybe because doing so involves financing concentration camps? Just a wild guess
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- trasz3 4y ago[dead]
- littlecranky67 4y agoJust guessing, but the legal situation in Germany is perfectly clear: You are free to download any content from streaming platforms as long as it is not an "obvious illegal source". Youtube being a subcompany of Google/Alphabet clearly does not qualify as "obviously illegal". The catch is, that it is still illegal in Germany to bypass copy-protecting measures. I.e. if you would rip a Netflix stream that uses Widivine/DRM, that would be illegal. I think this is the argument they used in this court case, although I was not aware that youtube videos use browser DRM.
- doodlesdev 4y ago> although I was not aware that youtube videos use browser DRM I'm pretty sure they don't, at least not for all resolutions. I'd never install Widevine into my main Firefox, but I watch YouTube daily though it. Perhaps the copy protections are more security by obscurity (i.e. weird endpoints, weird parameters, arbitrary requirements, etc.) although I have absolutely no idea since I've never read yt-dlp source code.
- rs999gti 4y agoIsn't privatized censorship already here? Cloudflare (disclosure: I am an investor), controls a large portion of the internet with their DDOS and CDN. Followed by Akamai, etc. There are already cases and examples where Cloudflare and other CDNs have kicked sites off of their platform or responded to take down requests. https://w3techs.com/technologies/details/cn-cloudflare https://w3techs.com/technologies/details/cn-cloudflare
- zer00eyz 4y agoBetween ISP's, Proxies, and Payment processors there are lots of extra legal ways to shut down anything you would like to on the web. All it takes is enough money and/or political power. The thing is this isn't new. Traditional publishing had throttles at the publisher, the seller and the library. Freedom of speech is not requirement to broadcast.
- 77pt77 4y ago> Freedom of speech is not requirement to broadcast. The USSR's constitution specified that not only was there freedom of speech but also freedom/right to "broadcast". The state would give anyone access to a printing press to disseminate speech. In practice it was a bit different though.
- kneebonian 4y agoAn American man and a Russian man were arguing about which country was freer. The American said "I am so free I can walk up to the gates of the white house and scream 'down with Reagan, he stinks'". "I have that freedom too" responds the Soviet man, "I could walk over to the Kremlin right now and yell 'Down with Reagan he stinks'"
- A4ET8a8uTh0 4y agoYep. At banks it has slowly gotten particularly bad since lately EU EBA had to issue guidance on how to tackle 'regulatory expectations and[..] unwarranted derisking'. US Treasury did not offer a guideline yet, but one of its higher up recently had a speech that touched on it too. This is what happens when your system is not dumb pipes and can be massaged based on who is currently doing the bossing part. And this is why I roll my eyes at anyone who tells me 'just do it yourself'. Do what at this point? Roll foundational infrastructure that should be dumb pipes? Coffee did not kick in yet, but the game is rigged and whatever ideals existed with the emergence of early internet have been gone for a long time now. We are just seeing some of its more visible effects.
- stevespang 4y ago[dead]
- oszai 4y agoIt's going to be an interesting year. I wonder what the music industry is cooking in regards to generative sound. They'd be the ones to force us all to install a damn rootkit, they need to update their business model beyond the 1900s
- mdp2021 4y agoRegulation of engineering, even in its more experimental sides (as I would depict some current stage expressions of Machine Learning), is an happening attempt.
- CharlesW 4y ago> I wonder what the music industry is cooking in regards to generative sound. No need to wonder: "AI-generated songs on Apple Music and Spotify breach copyright, says music label UMG" https://9to5mac.com/2023/04/12/ai-generated-songs/ https://9to5mac.com/2023/04/12/ai-generated-songs/ To be fair to the creators whose IP powers this generative AI, I think it's worth noting that model makers continue to expect to build their wealth on others' IP with no consequences: https://www.billboard.com/pro/universal-music-asks-spotify-apple-stop-ai-access-songs/ https://www.billboard.com/pro/universal-music-asks-spotify-a...
- mdp2021 4y agoBut this, specifically, seems to be right. > Some of these songs are AI-generated covers of existing songs [...] Chatbots might use entire phrases, sentences, or more, from human authors. Similarly, music bots might replicate both music and lyrics from human artists There is "learning" proper, as having assimilated the important elements of the experience (allowing to use those principles for further creation), and there is "copying".
- thewebcount 4y agoAnd even humans get it wrong: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mark_Ronson#Lawsuit https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mark_Ronson#Lawsuit https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bitter_Sweet_Symphony#Credits_dispute https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bitter_Sweet_Symphony#Credits_...
- qiqiqicharger 4y ago[flagged]
- mdp2021 4y agoWe normally reason using long-term and comprehensive assessments.
- ClarityJones 4y agoI don't know about German law, but this sounds like a situation of mandatory joinder where Github and YouTube should have been indispensable parties. There's no way to determine whether Uberspace's activity was illegal without involving the party who's rights are allegedly being violated or the alleged principal distributing the tool.
- numpad0 4y agoIt's starting to look like German laws and authorities are starting to interfere with the global Internet/WWW, or to more generalize, regional legal differences are starting to become pronounced as Internet usage expands globally. It's not that German laws are particularly "bad"; it's built on different social norms and standards, so some things legal in not-Germany might be not in Germany, AND vice versa. The Internet has to evolve to adapt to this reality.
- mdp2021 4y ago> Internet has to evolve Sometimes it really should be Germany. "Development" is everywhere; "evolution" is pretty much bound to be such; "progress" is where the best slope is. Evolution is sometimes not a progressive development - but it'd better be.
- account42 4y ago> It's not that German laws are particularly "bad"; it's built on different social norms and standards No, when it comes to copyright they're bad - both the laws and the enforcement machine.
- numpad0 4y agoIn wide areas across speeches and informations, actually. But they have their sovereign rights to be respected, I guess, so simply labeling them as punchable backwards thinkers might not be the best solution.
- exabrial 4y agoIf I were a German, this would piss me off more than anything: A lobbyist organization from another country managed to successfully manipulate the court of my home country. Apologies from the USA. We don't support the RIAA.
- ljlolel 4y agoGerman music lobbies and legal issues are even more strict
- Asmod4n 4y agoThe Court in Hamburg is infamous for siding with the media industry for decades sadly. As a suer you can choose which court handles your case for these kind of cases.
- rft 4y agoCame to post this. For an informed opinion on the issue of "Fliegender Gerichtsstand" (essentially, choose where to bring your case) I can recommend Vetter's blog post on the Erdogan/Böhmermann situation [1, German]. LG Hamburg is sadly infamous for this kind of decisions. It can and, based on the research in TFA likely will be, reigned in by higher courts, but this costs money, time and causes a lot of stress on the defendant. I applaud them for standing up to this decision. The law firm (Rasch) in this case is also no stranger to copyright and piracy dealings. If you search for its name you find websites dealing with their "Abmahnungen" (roughly Cease & Desist) [2, German]. [1] https://www.lawblog.de/archives/2016/05/18/das-hamburger-monopol/ https://www.lawblog.de/archives/2016/05/18/das-hamburger-mon... [2] https://www.abmahnung.org/rasch/ https://www.abmahnung.org/rasch/
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- xhkkffbf 4y agoUSA resident who expects to be moderated down: I'm a big believer in intellectual property rules and I hate piracy. These actions don't strike me as "censorship" because my enforcement of IP doesn't stop you from expressing yourself in any way. Oh sure, it stops you from pirating me, but that's not censorship. That's me stopping you from being a plagiarist and a copycat. If anything, tough enforcement encourages people to actually express themselves because they can't just pirate someone else's hard work and pretend they did something of value for society. Quit reading this. Go make your own content and enjoy all of the power that the Internet gave you. Then enjoy the control over your hard work that IP laws give you.
- kkfx 4y agoLadies and gentleman: distributed tools, in that very case for instance but not limited to, ZeroNet, was invented for various reasons. So why ALMOST ALL FLOSS projects do ho have a simple vitrine website + the rest on top of distributed solutions? Oh sure, some like GitHub and co since they are easy but my dear FLOSSers having your data in your hand is valuable and it's a thing you all know. So please try. Try to AVOID GitHub and ANY other code hosting, as well, because it does not matter if is run by some "evil" company or some friendly one, it's not your system. Almost any FLOSS dev have enough iron and bandwidth to share hes/shes bits in a P2P system, do that. If you are unsatisfied by some classic distributed development models (like git patches over a ML) develop something else BUT distributed or being able to run on top of something distributed. If you do so, you not only protect yourself and your users from some evil actors BUT you also brake the leg of all corporate power who try to put anyone in walled garden. FLOSS is the most comprehensive and valuable codebase in the world, if it manage to be independent of top players they are TFU simply by the fact the rest of the world know and understand they are not essential and something better like classic decentralized internet do work better than them. They annoy us with some actions? We can break us entirely killing their most important asset: the band of sheep who thinks we can't live without being on the shoulder of the giants. Aside MANY new tools will rise, paving the way for a came back of classic desktop model.
- octacat 4y agoAlso Vanced stopped working recently.
- doodlesdev 4y agoA nice (better?) alternative: https://github.com/revanced https://github.com/revanced
- littlecranky67 4y agoI wonder when they'll come after jdownlader, the dl tool I use to make youtube videos available offline.
- expertentipp 4y agoJust German bullies being bullies, and their legal bullies are one of the worst. How they ended up being so insolent and impudent?
- LoganDark 4y agoHuh, this submission's ID is 35553337. What a nice number.
- croes 4y agoThis was to be expected, earlier this year a german court decided a DNS is liable a perpetrator for resolving addresses to IPs containing copyrighted material. https://basic-tutorials.com/news/leipzig-regional-court-dns-resolver-operator-as-perpetrator/ https://basic-tutorials.com/news/leipzig-regional-court-dns-... German courts are known for technical bullshit decisions. In the early days of the internet, they decided that you were responsible for what ended up in your inbox. This was before spam filter s were widespread.
- akagusu 4y agoPrivate sector already controls our lives. They tell what we eat, what we talk, how we behave, who can get a job and who can't and it goes beyond. A censored code repository is just one more thing.
- RecycledEle 4y agoI wondered why my Windows command line version stopped working.
- PrefixKitten 4y agowait, wouldn't this ruling technically also make youtube illegal too? they don't own the copyrights to all the videos they are hosting