10 ms·
Iran installs cameras in public places to identify, penalise unveiled women
- seydor 4y agoIt's a pity that this doesnt even make frontpages anymore. Someone should hack those cameras to add fake veils when one is not detected
- NortySpock 4y agoSpray paint might be cheaper
- Disk6824 4y ago[flagged]
- fithisux 4y agoDoes it correlate with the attack by "west" through Israel?
- anthk 4y ago[flagged]
- aerodog 4y agoI don't think HN is the place for your naked racism
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- bigbillheck 4y agoYeah you have to keep it a little more subtle than that here.
- anthk 4y agoWhich race? Arabic culture was spread over with the sword upon Islamic expansion. The same with Christianism in Western Europe. If you think about it, both cultures are totally alien to Europe and Iran. The Christianism itself had to steal lots of Greek philosophy so it could fit in the Roman Empire and the further Middle Ages. With the Enlightenment we got the Graeco-Roman aesthetic and philosphical values back. Is not a matter of race. Since the Roman empire, all of the Western Europe it's pretty mixed with Atlantic and Mediterranean features all over the place. It's a matter of culture. Turkey with Ataturk got it pretty fast. Either evolve, or die as an irrelevant country with backward values.
- realworldperson 4y ago[dead]
- BigCryo 4y ago[flagged]
- sieabahlpark 4y ago[dead]
- d-z-m 4y agoI understand you're being sarcastic, but it isn't hard to realize that the compulsory veiling of women is objectively wrong. The issue is to the coercion of women and girls. Arguments about which culture is good and decent need not factor into it.
- mistercow 4y agoYeah, if you extend your tolerance to tolerance of oppression, you’ve taken a wrong turn.
- mrshadowgoose 4y ago> I understand you're being sarcastic, but it isn't hard to realize that the compulsory veiling of women is objectively wrong. Just to be crystal clear here, I find this behavior as abhorrent as you do. But to claim that any human behavior is "objectively wrong" is asinine. What's "wrong" and "right" just exists in our heads.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- d-z-m 4y agoI used the word "objectively" to close the door to moral relativism. However, I can defend the use of the word more thoroughly. I base my morality on the well-being of conscious creatures. What constitutes well-being is open to debate, but whatever it is, it will be facts about the state of the brain/physiology of conscious creatures in the physical universe. If you admit the physical universe is objective basis for measurement, actions that decrease a creatures well-being can be thought of as objectively wrong.
- boeingUH60 4y ago[Clearview AI nods in approval]
- internetter 4y agoDoes anyone know who was contracted for the facial recognition? Would not surprise me in the least if it was clearview
- boeingUH60 4y agoI doubt it. Clearview is already being targeted by regulators in the US and Canada, and trading with Iran is basically giving those regulators a 50-caliber bullet to knock them down. I’ll guess the software is from a Chinese company..
- paganel 4y agoAt this point anyone who works in the “AI” image recognition space, no matter the company, must be aware that these are some of the consequences of his/her work, there’s no avoiding it.
- RcouF1uZ4gsC 4y agoI bet the software runs on Linux. In fact, I would bet that most of this kind of information gathering/large scale spying is running on computers powered by Linux. So everyone who has ever contributed to Linux must also be aware of the consequences of their work, there’s no avoiding it.
- paganel 4y agoGood way for avoiding responsibility, as good as any other, I guess. But I’m sure that for those directly involved the money is excellent and the feeling of doing something “cool” must be through the roof, uncle Ted and Ellul be damned.
- kyboren 4y agoAnything that makes humans more legible to machines is a threat to human liberty. Biometric surveillance and digital identity initiatives must be resisted or we will inevitably find ourselves hopelessly ensnared by a totalitarian clique. Machines can't be convinced to join the revolution. Build it and they will come.
- Eddy_Viscosity2 4y agoTechnology sure is useful for the autocrats. Very efficient.
- morkalork 4y agoTechnology doesn't mutiny either.
- spywaregorilla 4y agoSee also the ongoing saga of what seems to be the Iranian government (literally, physically) poisoning school girls.
- ybinator604g3 4y agoThey are taking revenge for the protests and unveiling in schools. Their whole terror machine mocked by a bunch of school kids.
- red_trumpet 4y agoDo you have any recent news about this? The last thing I heard was when Khamenei eventually condemned the poisonings[1], which was a month ago? [1] https://www.bbc.com/news/world-middle-east-64862714 https://www.bbc.com/news/world-middle-east-64862714
- ybinator604g3 4y agoSchool girls poisoned in many cities in concert using similar method and government officials claimed it’s nothing but hysteria and the “supreme” leader finally condemns it after a lot of bad press outside of Iran. They install cameras to find one unveiled woman but have trouble to identify who is poisoning school girls nationwide. His condemnation is there to be sold to BBC. Nobody in Iran believes him.
- red_trumpet 4y agoI didn't want to claim I believed him, just that this was the last thing I heard. So it seemed the poisonings actually stopped. But as spywaregorilla pointed out, there are very recent reports of new poisonings: https://www.understandingwar.org/backgrounder/iran-update-april-5-2023 https://www.understandingwar.org/backgrounder/iran-update-ap...
- spywaregorilla 4y agoehhh, it's not super clear but the government response has been so lackluster it seems highly likely that they are responsible for it as a way to suppress protest movements which has a strong momentum among high school girls. The ISW covers it every now and then with their daily Iran conflict updates: https://www.understandingwar.org/backgrounder/iran-update-april-5-2023 https://www.understandingwar.org/backgrounder/iran-update-ap... > Student poisonings have resumed in Iran after approximately three weeks without reported incidents, indicating that the regime has failed to take the necessary security measures to permanently prevent these attacks. CTP recorded ten student poisoning cases on April 5, four cases on April 4, and one case on April 3.[1] The April 3 chemical poisoning attack on Iranian school girls in Naghadeh, West Azerbaijan Province marked the first of such attacks since March 13, as CTP previously reported.[2] The pause in student poisonings between March 13 and April 3 roughly corresponds to the Iranian New Year holiday between March 20 and April 2, suggesting that the recent respite from student poisonings was not due to the regime’s ability to effectively crack down on the perpetrators of these attacks, but because schools were not in session. The resumption of student poisoning attacks also indicates that the network targeting Iranian school girls still exists and retains the ability to operate in Iran. > There are numerous similarities between the most recent student poisonings and the poisonings that occurred between December 2022 and March 2023. Students poisoned in recent days have reported symptoms—such as smelling a strange smell before becoming ill, dizziness, and headaches—which match the symptoms experienced by students poisoned in March.[3] Students from schools where poisoning attacks have occurred in recent days have additionally reported that school principals confiscated their cellphones to prevent the dissemination of news about the attacks.[4] School officials reportedly behaved in a similarly abnormal and unsympathetic manner during the peak of student poisonings in early March, as CTP previously reported.[5] Regime officials have largely disregarded the resumption of student poisoning attacks. Interior Minister Ahmad Vahidi stated on April 5 that he “could not confirm” the poisoning of students in Tabriz, East Azerbaijan Province. Vahidi added that “further investigations should take place,” but did not exhibit any sense of urgency regarding the recent attacks.[6] The regime’s lack of response suggests that it is incapable of preventing such attacks, does not want to acknowledge the existence of a network capable of instilling fear into the Iranian people, and still tolerates the poisoning of Iranian schoolgirls.
- _3u10 4y ago[flagged]
- midasuni 4y agoLiterally a story anbout the state using technology our community develops to anttack women, and of course it’s the “Karen” is blamed. Misogyny in a nutshell.
- nilespotter 4y agoReads like anti-white racism as much as misogyny to me.
- jabradoodle 4y agoThis is not Redit, please try to contribute something to a discussion.
- nashashmi 4y agoI’d argue this is sarcastic irony.
- sdfghswe 4y agoMorality aside, does this surprise anyone? All countries use cameras do enforce their laws, why would Iran be different? The problem here is Iran, cameras have nothing to do with it.
- paulryanrogers 4y agoThis reminds me of the "guns don't kill people" argument. Surveillance cameras have everything to do with consolidating power into fewer and fewer hands. Therefore fewer voices of dissent on the levers of power. Iran is going through a demographic shift. The protests and strikes are evidence of a desire for change. With tools like this even small acts of defiance become higher risk.
- 1101010010 4y ago> This reminds me of the "guns don't kill people" argument. So you're telling me if we banned cameras in Iran, women would no longer be oppressed?
- potsandpans 4y agocheck this out, I'm gonna get on the internet and argue in bad faith
- 1101010010 4y agoBlaming asymmetrically powerful technology before man's own perverted ego is simply misguided.
- kelipso 4y ago"Man's own perverted ego" is a constant across all off human history. Asymmetrically powerful technology is not. What are you even doing if you are only going to look at just the former thing?
- paulryanrogers 4y ago
- itissid 4y agoI've personally known 2 women from Iran who are not fans of the US foreign policy, but become red with anger and visibly shaking when talking about their govt's treatment of women.
- sdfghswe 4y ago> I've personally known 2 women from Iran who are not fans of the US foreign policy, but become red with anger and visibly shaking when talking about their govt's treatment of women. Why "but"? Those are usually the same groups of people.
- achow 4y agoDon't get it; 'but' seems to be very legitimate use. Intuitively, it is more likely that people who are not fan of US policies would be fan of Iranian govt's policies (you know because Iranian govt and US govt don't see eye to eye and all that..).
- sdfghswe 4y ago> but become red with anger and visibly shaking when talking about their govt's treatment of women. Oh sorry I misinterpreted this phrase. I read it as if it said "become red with anger when you criticize their govt's treatment of women". My bad.
- rhamzeh 4y ago"Intuitively, it is more likely that people who are not fan of US policies would be fan of Iranian govt's policies" In what world but an American worldview is that even remotely intuitive? That statement is plain wrong.
- Centigonal 4y agoA lot of Iranians see US foreign policy as aiding or even causing the current Iranian government.
- deleted 4y ago
- victorcreator 4y agoMeanwhile, feminists in the western world fight to wear a hijab, burkha, abaya, etc. and don’t see them as signs of oppression. I wish i understood the logic. Wish we could all stand up against this together.
- bwb 4y agoThe point is the power to choose, not the result A or b.
- letrowekwel 4y ago"Power to choose" in the eyes of law and general society, as advocated by feminists, is not much use if women's family, relatives and other close community strongly disapprove and don't respect that law.
- madeofpalk 4y agoWhat's your objection? That it's moral to be forced by law to wear jeans?
- letrowekwel 4y agoThe law should not force anything. Western feminists should focus on improving women's rights in migrant communities, rather than calling people who point out real problems racist. Then more women actually do have the choice to wear what they want.
- simfree 4y agoOne of our elected feminists, Kshama Sawant did focus on migrant families issues, and passed landmark legislation banning discrimination based on caste. Considering how many Indian Americans convert to a different religion for the sole purpose of escaping the social implications their caste ties them to, this is a good starting point.
- 4y ago
- weatherlite 4y agoWould be swell when these guys have nukes, just what the world needed.
- elbigbad 4y agoEdit to remove non-sequitur.
- DueDilligence 4y ago[dead]
- DueDilligence 4y ago[dead]
- WhereIsTheTruth 4y agoI wish they'd share exactly the reason of these cameras Is it really for spying unveiled women? Or is it for public safety? considering the recent poisoning of young female students [1] + the killing of scientists by the mossad [2] The fact that reuters jumps to conclusions makes me believe there is something fishy going in with Iran and its neighbor Israel Why isn't the press investigating? Maybe that's the question everyone should ask themselves instead of going the easy road, whenever it's too easy, there might be something more complex behind the scenes.. [1] - https://www.bbc.com/news/world-middle-east-64797957 https://www.bbc.com/news/world-middle-east-64797957 [2] - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Assassination_of_Iranian_nuclear_scientists https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Assassination_of_Iranian_nucle...
- refulgentis 4y agoIs this a parody? The press has investigated, thats the Reuters article you're reading.
- WhereIsTheTruth 4y agoParody? if you weren't disrespectful i would have argumented further, instead i'll just wish you a happy easter :)
- quitit 4y agoConsidering that the country protested so fervently over this issue: I don't imagine the cameras are going to survive very long.
- olliej 4y agoWow, giving Texas and co ideas
- EVa5I7bHFq9mnYK 4y agoAnother AI achievement. Frankly, I didn't see any useful application of AI yet, just evil.
- crnkofe 4y agoThis is the true mass surveillance dystopia. When cameras get weaponized to enforce arbitrary dressing rules. Looking at how common cameras have gotten in public places like CCTVs in UK I can't shake the feeling that civilians are just one bad election away from getting hammered by the establishment. I also feel for iranian women. One can't but wonder what life would look like if Iran dumped the derelict religious practices and just went with a more common sense approach to religion and equality.
- olliej 4y agoJust to point out: The "on device" and "private" CSAM detection christian politicians push would trivially be able to be used for this as well. Before anyone says "but CSAM is illegal", in Iran the violating the "hajib law" is definitionally illegal.
- DANmode 4y agoPoll: you are reading this comment on HN. You see "CSAM". Do you know what it means, without looking it up?
- olliej 4y agoThat's a fair point, alas I can't edit my original comment anymore. CSAM is alas a fairly well understood term of art in security and cryptography circles, for those with the good fortune to not know have such familiarity, it means child abuse.
- candiodari 4y agoThe thing people don't understand is that in most oppressive governments, MOST of what the government does is quite acceptable, positive even. The Iranian government definitely also protects women. Even repression is not all bad, or even mostly bad. And like Iranian laws of public decency, CSAM has it's "oh my god think of the children!" central case that is a reprehensible crime. Nobody disagrees with this. Of course, there's a few cracks already: a number of state governments are trying to classify comic book depictions of LGBTQ, even textual ones, as CSAM. You can even vaguely see the argument, the idea being that this encourages children to engage in such acts. The problem is that CSAM laws are perfect for this use case. They're absolutely perfect for repression! After all, we can never have a frank discussion of what CSAM is, based on the actual material, for obvious reasons. We can never have the citizenry openly discuss what material gets added to the list, and what does not get added to the list, so we are 100% dependent on politically not-quite-elected people with agendas deciding what's on the list. Furthermore, one can quickly expose the motives behind CSAM scanning. Is it to help children ... or not? Look at what it's being used for, what these laws effectively do. Obviously it's being used to find children, who are of course in most cases the victim of very minor abuse, or of mistakes, and then placed in the care of CPS. Now you can quickly differentiate motives: 1) if the intention is to help those children, we would make damn sure those children, from that point forward, are treated better than they were at home 2) if the intention is repression, societal control, ... they totally would not care about the treatment of the children found We all know how CPS treats children. It most definitely does not protect children in their care against sexual abuse, for example. Something like half those children does not go to school at all. They have no real future (yes, thankfully there are exceptions). There is a Netflix series "Young and locked up" that is, among others, about what happens to children who protest their treatment by CPS by running away. Go and look. Or look at "Short Term 12" where a victim of child abuse is depicted. The victim, nearly adult tries to get out from "protection", constantly explaining how her life at home (presumably/allegedly WITH abuse) was so much better than her environment in CPS, and eventually returns to "home", where she was abused and destroys and rages. It is left in the middle if she wants revenge for abuse ... or is taking revenge for getting her into CPS. In an interview the director points out that this vagueness about her motives, whether they're against abuse or against CPS, is not an accident. One kid, because he's about to "graduate" from CPS (dumped homeless on the street), tries to commit suicide, because of what he knows his future is. In commentary, it is made very clear that the kid is correct about his future. And of course, there's many stories in the press that this effectively encourages child abuse. After all, CPS in the US is a horrible punishment FOR CHILDREN, worse than jail in some cases. Which of course means it's net effect is to strongly encourage children to simply accept abuse if they've ever seen CPS in action. And, of course, CPS is completely losing the fight against everything they're supposedly fighting, from sexual abuse to suicide, which of course is completely coincidental. Children FEAR state help against sexual abuse much more than they fear the abuse in the US (not that the situation in, say, France, is any different). And frankly, it's hard to argue this fear is anything but justified. So, frankly, you cannot trust government with CSAM scanning, and there's no reason to. It's the perfect instrument of repression, we would not even know if it was used for that, and if you look at the full picture of CSAM scanning, including enforcement, the argument that it's there to protect children is ridiculous.
- avestura 4y agoIt's insane how Islamic Republic wants to speed up its downfall and start another popular uprising with things like this. The walls of Iranian cities are still full of "Woman Life Freedom" and "Death to Khamenei" slogans.