10 ms·
How to Stop Ruminating
- jasfi 4y agoI'd say either talk to someone, as conversation can get your mind off your own self-talk, or go for a walk and pay attention to what's around you.
- phnofive 4y agoThis might well be titled 'Five ways to stop ruminating' (which of course would need to be edited down for submission here): 1: Anticipate rumination-triggering events and acknowledge rumination when it begins 2&3: Use logic and intuition rather than imagination to relate to reality 4&5: Be patient with yourself as you practice not ruminating and expect improvement if you persist I guess that all makes sense, but it's sort of like telling someone how to ride a bicycle by explaining balance and pedaling. Distraction remains a more practical and attractive option in this light.
- nanidin 4y agoI would also recommend reading feeling good or feeling great if you’re stuck in this type of rut.
- vivekd 4y agoI upvoted this post because I the advice he gave about reading up on cognitive distortions and knowing what they are. This helped me alot, just being able to identify that I was thinking very negative things that were purely a mechanism of my imagination and not reflected in reality. Being able to see that there are common patterns of such thoughts and identify them and deal with them is very helpful
- rramadass 4y agoRelated: Cognitive Bias vs. Cognitive Distortion - https://psychology.stackexchange.com/questions/26396/what-is-the-difference-between-cognitive-bias-and-cognitive-distortion https://psychology.stackexchange.com/questions/26396/what-is...
- teleforce 4y agoTo be honest I'm not sure by reading your comment replies to me and other HN users whether you're biased or distorted. Because when you're engaged in any discussions that are not agreeable to you and was asked to produce some relevant proof or references normally you have failed to do that and instead keep relying on some abstract concepts that you considered as "facts". After that you normally resort to attacking the anonymity of the other users that is clearly unrelated and tangential to the subjects being discussed.
- rramadass 4y agoYour comment is totally irrelevant to this thread and moreover you are engaged in ad hominem attacks which you are advised to layoff. Your petulance simply affirms your intellectual bankruptcy given that i have dismissed your comments in other threads which you seem unable to grasp and come to terms with.
- Sakos 4y agoAn important step for me was practicing mindfulness meditation. It's literally training the skill of recognizing your thoughts and being able to step back from them to observe. That distance is important for, say, figuring out what your triggers are or deciding how to handle these thoughts. Honestly, everybody should be practicing mindfulness meditation and cognitive-based therapy. It's a powerful combination. Also, see a therapist. A decent one is worth their weight in gold. Even though I was practicing these things, it was clear it wasn't a perfect fix and adding a third-party perspective was a huge help in learning how to regulate my thoughts and emotions. Some things we simply can't solve completely on our own.
- Timon3 4y agoSame here, mindfulness is a great thing! Initially I had some troubles getting into it, because I always felt I had to wait for the right time to do it. But I've since learned a couple of techniques that can help you notice whether you're ruminating, and to then transition to a more mindful state. It's been a quality of life-improvement for me, maybe it helps somebody else: - wear a small rubber band or something similar on your wrist. If you notice yourself ruminating, give yourself a little flick with it - the very slight pain signal pulls you into the here & now! - designate a time and place to ruminate a bit when you feel the need, but have a timer running, and do something else afterwards. Controlled release in a way! - generally, if you catch yourself ruminating, try to think of something indicating "STOP" or similar. Personally I imagine a big STOP road sign and also "shout" it in my internal voice. It might sound silly, but after actively training for a few weeks you'll have much more freedom in your thoughts!
- ZitchDog 4y agoJust a heads up for anyone reading this, as a mindfulness coach I wouldn’t recommend this technique. The rubber band and “stop” voice are pretty harsh and rather we want to practice inner kindness and letting go.
- ccooffee 4y agoDo you have an alternative recommendation for "strong" reminders? "Counting five breaths" is a tool I got from some mindfulness resource. Focus on the breath as much as you can and count the exhales. When you get to five, begin again from one. Repeat until settled. If I'm fairly out-of-it, it may take me 10 repeats of counting five breaths to center myself. Sometimes it doesn't work at all.
- DoreenMichele 4y agoI will add: Hydrate, have a bite to eat, rest or nap and tend to any known health issues.
- theteapot 4y agoWe're talking about the kind of individual who, for example, got a bad review from a manager years ago and can't let it go. This person thinks about it on the bus, on the toilet, at dinner, when they should sleeping. Hydration is not the issue.
- DoreenMichele 4y agoI'm that person. Health stuff is almost always the issue.
- theteapot 4y agoInteresting. I have the propensity to be that person too even when I'm well hydrated and healthy. I agree with focusing on getting the basics like food, exercise, and sleep right first though. If you can't get that right then you got not hope of sorting anything else out - necessary but not sufficient.
- DoreenMichele 4y agoFor me, it frequently means I'm running a fever. Adequate hydration can help break a fever. It also helps to consciously decide "Yesterday was a bad day. I'm feeling better today. I'm going to let all that nonsense go. The stuff I was thinking yesterday wasn't rational. It's not worth pursuing further."
- adave 4y agoProblem is such stuff does not work if your brain circuitry is impaired for those instructions to just work. Rumination is a tricky thing and we all do it now and then so for those folks its easy to control like you do and its only bad when you are low mentally or physically. For others its really hard to get rid of and is a constant thing they can't just decided to switch off.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- elchief 4y agoI'm a ruminator These have worked for me 1. I have thoughts and I can choose to accept them or not. My thoughts are not my mind 2. Overwhelm myself with positive true thoughts in the same area as negative thoughts so I gorget about the negative ones
- _hao 4y ago> 2. Overwhelm myself with positive true thoughts in the same area as negative thoughts so I gorget about the negative ones I'll use computer analogy for why this is a bad idea (at least it was for me when I did it). That's pushing the problem down the stack and it builds up internal negative pressure. I've done this and it made me even more miserable at the time. You _shouldn't_ mix negative or positive feelings at the same time just like you can't have two distinct things at the same time in the same memory space. In my experience trying to push myself to be positive just made me even more apathetic, depressed and cynical. It just made my internal balance to go to super (-). Having mixed feelings (±) could as well be the definition of deadlock, race condition, halt and catch fire etc. type of thing that happens to us all. It's what leads us to procrastination, dopamine chasing and the effects of those things. The fix for me was to stop pushing myself and try to find the root for some of my fears, insecurities, previous beliefs. It takes internal work and observation, _NOT RATIONAL ANALYSIS_ to try to reach the roots of your issues. We were emotional beings before we were intelligent. The emotional system is a lower-level system than the intelligent/rational system we employ as modern humans. You should observe your emotional state and when you get there, you'll see that your negative thoughts are really not that of a big deal and they're not you and that they don't define you. If your first point is true and you have understood that, then this step should be relatively easy for you. Once that "clicks" you really do feel a certain feeling of lightness and calmness. It means you've let go of those things that were pressuring you inside. It's not happiness (+), but I'd say it's a pleasant neutral (0) where you take things as they are and have the potential to go on about the things you want.
- electrondood 4y agoYour thoughts are your mind. Your mind is nothing more. You are neither. We react to thoughts because we identify with them. It's the secondary emotions that arise from our reactions to thoughts that cause the problems. Observing without reaction causes recurring thoughts to go away on their own.
- baby 4y agoMy personal technique: find a difficult problem/puzzle I can grind on when my mind can’t be put to rest. IMO all the self awareness / meditation advice are moot. What works is to find brain hacks. Ways to either break the loop or move the loop to a different task.
- eastbound 4y ago- I listen to an unpoliticized radio show of 2hrs. It’s irrelevant for life, but funny, it’s not cut by ads (Les Grosses Tètes in France), and it keeps my mind off my annoyances (like, failing at life), - I listen to Youtube videos about plane crashes to get to sleep. Not too good for sleep, but better than ruminating, and it stops at the end of the video (10-20 minutes). I think it smoothes me to hear about people’s death, after a youth being harassed that I can’t let go. Plus aviation shows are always about engineering, it tickles my rational mind, everything is logical, as opposed to humans. - Obviously, get a psychologist, to output your overwhelming thoughts, criticize your reasonings, and make plans for the future. Alternatively, people standing against bullying earlier in my life would have been a good way to prevent me from doing all I’ve done, but I’ve learnt you can only expect so much from humans lol, there is an expected level of violence in society, and the only way to prevent bullying is to be a bully yourself. Or that’s what everyone taught me, don’t be a victim, standup for yourself, it’s ok to do x or y, and blah blah blah, i.e. be as savage as the average of society, which is, a lot. A lot savage. God I wish things were different. Make it change. It’s Easter, let’s hope for a change ;)
- Grothendank 4y ago
- Barrin92 4y agoHow to Stop Ruminating over Ruminating Ruminating on occasion is normal. I knew this was going to be some "executive coach" blog before clicking on it. Unless your rumination interferes with your life to the point where it seems pathological or without any good reason, don't fret it, that's the only advice. Humans aren't machines, we're concerned about things all the time, on some nights we don't sleep well. Especially advice like "paying attention to triggers" seems completely out of place for ordinary people and probably is going to make the average person more neurotic, not less.
- hrkucuk 4y agoIs it just me or did chatgpt write that post? I hope I am delusional and just seeing it everywhere, that it's not true.
- theteapot 4y agoIt's not just you. ChatGPT prompt "Write a short article about How to Stop Ruminating" gives about the same ...: "Ruminating, or repeatedly thinking about a problem or situation, can be mentally exhausting and can lead to negative emotions such as anxiety and depression. However, breaking the cycle of rumination is possible with the right strategies. Here are some tips on how to stop ruminating: Identify triggers: The first step is to identify what triggers your ruminating thoughts. Is it a particular situation, person or stressor? Once you know what triggers your thoughts, you can start to work on avoiding or managing them. Practice mindfulness: Mindfulness is a technique that involves focusing your attention on the present moment without judgment. By practicing mindfulness, you can train your mind to let go of negative thoughts and stay in the present. Engage in physical activity: Engaging in physical activity such as walking, running or yoga can help clear your mind and reduce stress. Exercise releases endorphins, which are natural mood boosters, and can help you feel more positive. Distract yourself: When you find yourself ruminating, distract yourself with an activity that you enjoy. This could be anything from reading a book to watching a movie or spending time with friends. Challenge your thoughts: Challenge negative thoughts by asking yourself if they are really true or if there is another way to look at the situation. This can help you gain perspective and reduce the intensity of your emotions. Seek support: If you find that your ruminating thoughts are persistent and affecting your daily life, it may be helpful to seek support from a mental health professional. They can help you develop coping strategies and work through any underlying issues that may be contributing to your rumination. Breaking the cycle of rumination takes time and effort, but with the right strategies and support, it is possible to overcome this pattern of thinking and move forward with a more positive outlook on life." Does it matter though?
- urthor 4y agoIt's interesting, and also brings the qualifications of the author into question. An expert in the field would have added to ChatGPT.
- quattrofan 4y ago[dead]
- vermooten 4y agonot much use when your ruminating self knows the tricks you're playing on it
- msaltz 4y agoIn the book Getting Things Done the author explains that your brain is basically a really bad reminder system. So if it thinks there’s something you needs to do, it will basically keep reminding you of that thing at all times until you do it. So for each of these things, there’s what the author calls an “open loop”, and the brain keeps telling you about it until the loop is closed. The way out, the author says, is to have a trusted system for storing information outside your brain. In that trusted system, you can write down what needs to be done for each open loop, and that basically closes the loop for your brain and it will stop reminding you of that thing all the time. I still haven’t gone fully into doing it but my director at work swore by it, and the few times I tried it it was almost like magic. Even if you just pull out a todo app or notebook and for each of the things currently looping in your head, write down only the next step you need to take regarding that open loop (and maybe what the desired outcome is - I can’t remember if that’s in the book or not). For me the first time I tried it it was magical - it turned out there were only 4 or 5 things total looping on my mind at the time and after doing this exercise my mind was basically blank - the reminder system stopped telling me there was something I needed to do for these loops. I think for it to be sustainable you probably have to really make sure you follow up on the things you write down so that your brain actually trusts you’ll do the things you wrote down, but at least for me it worked really well as a short term hack on a few occasions. I really need to finish reading the book!
- ryanjshaw 4y agoI've been experimenting with using ChatGPT-4 for this. I tell it to take on a personal assistant persona and it helps me intelligently prioritise & track tasks, plus break them down into smaller steps. You can also have fun with it taking on different styles like your "personal assistant bro" or "Data from Star Trek". It is pretty helpful, but after a while I've seen problems with it getting lost in the back an forth: it forgets tasks, or forgets that they are done. There are definitely issues with large context spaces. After a certain point, I can repeatedly tell it something is done or to remove an item from the list, and it'll apologise but keep the item as "Todo". This is probably one reason why they haven't released the 32k space yet.
- 4y ago
- IAmGraydon 4y agoRumination and meditation are opposite states. If you want to stop rumination, learn and practice meditation.
- intrasight 4y agoIn the morning, I write things down. In the evening, I listen to history podcasts. That got me off Trazidone
- electrondood 4y agoMorning Pages is zero-cost therapy. It's incredibly cathartic.
- hestefisk 4y agoBreathing exercises can help.
- dSebastien 4y agoObserve your thoughts and be rational. Ask yourself whether your thoughts are useful to you: https://www.dsebastien.net/are-my-thoughts-useful/ https://www.dsebastien.net/are-my-thoughts-useful/
- electrondood 4y agoNAC is effective at stopping rumination, easing symptoms of OCD, etc.
- FailMore 4y agoI think more can be said about this. The natural state of the mind is quiet, but it takes a specific type of work to undo the bits that make it unquiet. The bit that make it unquiet nearly always the same, or rather a variation on the same theme: during our infancy we learn at an emotional level that we must or must not be certain ways (e.g. must be pleasant, never confrontational). We then take these strongly formed patterns with us into the world. These patterns shape our behaviours and mean that, at an emotional level, many situations are not calm. That could be something obvious, like a tension in a relationship, or more subtle, that you overly worry relationships are going wrong when in fact they are in an okay state. The more we can undo these musts and must nots, the more we can resolve situations to a level that leaves our minds quiet. I am training to become a psychotherapist and have found that when analysing dreams in a particular structured way can point us to the areas we need to work on to improve the quietness. I wrote a paper on this method: https://psyarxiv.com/k6trz https://psyarxiv.com/k6trz It was discussed on HN here: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19143590 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19143590
- gweinberg 4y agoIt's not at all clear to me that ruminating is a bad thing. When I lie in bed ruminating and unable to sleep, I'm not unable to sleep because I'm ruminating, I'm ruminating because I'm unable to sleep. 100% always. At least sometimes after a long rumination I'm able to figure things out. Maybe sometimes even useful things. Cerattnly things I wouldn't have been able to come up with off the top of my head.
- archduck 4y agoRe: figuring things out, for me, it’s pretty rare that I’m able to resolve anything from _within_ the loop. It's only when I switch to another context and then switch back to it that I'm able to finally stop the looping. I can think of a few reasons why this works: there's evidence of brains doing "background processing" when asleep or occupied with something else, which I find especially fascinating. Sometimes I'm sure it's because there's something that would provide an "exit condition" if I could just see it, but there's some heuristic active in the present state that's causing that line of thinking to be skipped over and/or zapped of enough salience for the brain to consider it worth chewing on. Maybe in order to return to something the brain has to perform some sort of "bootstrapping" in order to "re-render" whatever ideational substance is involved, and somewhere in that bootstrapping process there's an exit condition that is absent from within the loop, I don't know. I would also defend to the death that not all brain-loops are actually "resolvable" in any meaningful way. For example (stretching the meaning of “rumination” here), I have music going on in my head 24/7. Always. Most of the time they're in the form of short-ish loops, so they repeat a lot. This in and of itself isn’t so terrible - it can actually be really nice sometimes to "overhear" what's playing and join in, because I can help drive the musical procession forward, since the part of my thinking self that’s aware and has free will can focus on the music, innovate on what’s playing, lead the music around, change the song, etc. But unfortunately, the musical homunculus squatting in my head who's always awake is also never satisfied with a particular song coming to a close - try as I might to resolve a looping refrain by bringing the song to a close, the goddamn "Achy Breaky Heart" fanatic I never invited into my inner world in the first place just presses play again. Finishing the song does nothing! Here, there is no _resolution_; there is only _substitution_. At this point, if I don't just refuse to give up, I now find myself forced to trawl through my catalog of catchy songs to put on, so that the worst DJ ever, who has no ability to read the room, might hear what _I'm_ playing and decide to join _me_, before I can find any relief. It feels incredibly stupid when the current time is a very wide-awake 4am and it's at that point where you just have to say _fuck this, this isn't working, I'll never drift off to sleep with this asshole (yourself) playing this crap I didn't pick (well, actually, you did) on repeat_, so now you have to try to think of _other_ songs that get stuck in your head so that you can try playing them in your head to yourself until one of them "takes," in order to stop yourself from annoying the shit out of yourself and keeping yourself awake - all because you can't ask yourself to just stop (because you won't listen)! - but also (and this is my point here) because there's nothing that actually _resolves_ a musical "thought" in such a way that makes it "invalid," "irrelevant," "solved," etc. and thereby any less likely to just cue up again. Oftentimes isn't not even a song - it's a jingle. A fucking jingle!!! Similarly, I've had unresolvable brain-loops deriving from weed paranoia, where I _cannot_ reason with the lizard part of my brain in any way whatsoever. The only thing that works is distraction. This is main reason why weed is just not for me - I hate having to will myself to distraction because any sense of presence is too unsettling.
- yuuuuyu 4y ago"Ruminating" is not all bad. The mind works on things and often the best solution to personal or professional problems come to me after I've let my mind work on it. Letting it run freely. Forcefully sulpressing it always seems counterproductive to me.