6 ms·
Frank founder Charlie Javice arrested, charged with defrauding JPMorgan Chase
- DaveExeter 4y agoThere seems to be a fine line between "clever hack" and "federal indictment".
- ed_elliott_asc 4y agoI think people can get so excited about being a unicorn they either forget or don’t bother to learn what is fraud and what it isn’t. If you make up your user list and say you have x million when you don’t, that’s fraud.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- ceejayoz 4y agoI don't think "lied about having data on 4 million clients, including making up fake client information, in order to entice JPMorgan Chase to buy her company in 2021 for $175 million" falls in an ethical grey area. It's pretty clearly fraud.
- dmix 4y agoIt was an overt fraud, after they started talking to JPM about an acquisition Javice and her Chief Growth Officer paid a NY data science professor $13k to invent a list of customers with real addresses and real sounding high school and college addresses, and then paid for a database of real student email addresses to populate it. This is after their own software engineer refused to do it on ethical grounds. So they went external for help. Then 1yr later when JPM tried to run an email campaign using their database only 30% of the emails delivered made it through (apparently they didn’t have time to use their “real” email DB). Additionally a JPM employee noticed the user list Frank employees sent was capped at the exact 1,048,576 maximum number of rows Excel allows on a spreadsheet which made him suspicious.
- ljlolel 4y agoAllegedly
- dmix 4y agoIn my opinion.
- RC_ITR 4y agoAnd what’s so crazy is that it seems like not that hard of a thing to actually make? Like I’m sure the College Board would sell you a similar list and if you really needed to fluff it, maybe some other shady sources. Classic “only the stupid fraudsters get caught”
- dwohnitmok 4y agoFrank tried this. They purchased lists of student emails from ASL Marketing and Enformion to turn over to JPM. Turns out that the majority of those email addresses were nonfunctional, but even more importantly, even those legitimate email addresses just wouldn't open the emails (because presumably since those users had no previous relationship with Frank or JPM they were just treated as spam). That's what made JPM suspicious. Those emails had an open rate that was > an order of magnitude lower than previous JPM email campaigns.
- RC_ITR 4y agoYeah but this [0] exists and a good fraudster goes “Hey, I’m an up and coming entrepreneur who is about to cash out and I want to give out some scholarships. Can my foundation buy access to your list please?” Then you spend like $1mn tops on the actual best list of high school emails in the country, give out like $5mn in actual scholarships, and get unlimited love and attention from the kids whose life you changed. Plus you stay rich and don’t go to jail. Hell, maybe you even subtly market Frank in the scholarship emails (Hi, I’m the founder of Frank and want to give back to students more directly…) and your user base actually grows! [0]* Student Search Service™ Student Search Service is a free, optional service that helps students start a conversation with colleges and scholarship organizations. If students choose to participate in Student Search Service, they agree to share their name, address, college interest, and Student Data Questionnaire responses with colleges, universities, and nonprofit scholarship and educational programs. This information is used for recruitment, scholarship opportunities, and college planning outreach. College Board does not sell student information; however, qualified colleges, universities, nonprofit scholarship services, and nonprofit educational organizations do pay a license fee to use this information to recruit students and provide opportunities in connection with educational or scholarship programs. These license fees are reinvested in our nonprofit mission. For example, these organizations must sign a strict license agreement that outlines how student information can be used. College Board maintains a direct relationship with, and oversight of, all organizations using this student information and monitors the use of student information by licensed organizations. Students can opt out of Student Search Service at any time. More information about Student Search Service.*
- tootie 4y agoI hope Dimon is being sufficiently humbled by the complete lack of diligence that was done before the acquisition because it apparently took very little time after to discover what they did.
- FlacksonFive 4y agoHe’s doing just fine, he found his therapeutic outlet of torturing employees with RTO policies.
- automatic6131 4y agoWhat? Where's the fine line here? "Oops, I accidentally faked 95% of my userbase for a 9 figure buyout, could have happened to anyone"? This was an attempt to defraud a massive company for hundreds of millions of dollars. The line is in rearview mirror and probably hidden by the curvature of the earth at that point.
- Obscurity4340 4y ago20/20 burn
- steveBK123 4y agoGood. We have entered the part of the cycle where the frauds & charlatans get their repercussions. Very 2008-2009esque in that regard.
- spaceman_2020 4y agoNot a lot of frauds and charlatans got their repercussions in 2008-09. I, for one, would like to see all these “financial influencers” get heavily punished. The amount of scams and rugs and market manipulation they all pulled off in 2020-21 was unreal.
- ceejayoz 4y agoThey're working on it; some high-profile ones last month: https://www.npr.org/2023/03/22/1165477713/lindsay-lohan-jake-paul-sec-crypto https://www.npr.org/2023/03/22/1165477713/lindsay-lohan-jake...
- fghsqwads 4y agoD-list celebs who promote shit on Instagram without pointing out they're being paid. Somehow, I'm supposed to view this as markedly worse than Tom Brady, Larry David, etc. doing the same thing in a commercial.
- ceejayoz 4y agoWhy would you not see them as markedly different? Commercials don't require disclosure because everyone knows they're a commercial. The same is not true for influencers' Instagram posts. Sometimes the scripting is ham-handed enough to be obvious, but hardly always.
- fghsqwads 4y agoThe outcome is the same, people buying something they may not have otherwise. Also, the fact that viewers know something is an ad doesn't change the fact that they view it as a celebrity endorsement.
- ceejayoz 4y ago> Javice, whom Forbes named a rising star in its "30 under 30" issue in 2019... Along with other luminaries like Elizabeth Holmes, Sam Bankman-Fried, Martin Shkreli...
- arcticfox 4y agoI saw a stat the other day that 30 under 30 alums have accounted for something like 2x the amount of fraud $ charges as VC $ raised which I thought was fitting... the list is a magnet for charlatans
- ericmay 4y agoIt makes sense too. I see being on that list as a negative signal. You’re spending time jumping through the right hoops and social circles to get nominated instead of building.
- polygamous_bat 4y agoYou can actually nominate yourself for a lot of those. Naturally, that is very attractive to self-aggrandizing bastards with very little to offer to the world.
- moneywoes 4y agoCosts $30k I believe
- linarism 4y agoWhat actually happens is the VC firms have a relationship with Forbes and push their most favored start-ups on them. A big chunk of people don’t do anything to get on the list, except write their own bios and of course getting funded by said VCs. That being said, yes, there’s quite a lot of vain people in there.
- dsfyu404ed 4y agoThe comparison is apples to oranges though. It's like comparing a CEO's claims of future great success to actual shipped units. To raise funds someone has to actually give up money. When it comes to government prosecution and lawsuits the government and aggrieved parties are more or less free to use motivated reasoning, mental gymnastics and other sorts of faulty logic to make whatever fanciful claims they want so long as there's some shred of a reason for the claim. There's no check being cut, no skin in the game so the numbers aren't ever as grounded in reality as fundraising numbers. These "reality inspired" numbers then gets haggled down to a numbers that are supported by evidence over the course of court proceedings. And then the internet peanut gallery compares the fanciful initial headline to the settlement that is supported by hard evidence and gets their jimmies rustled. That said I'm sure that list is full of shysters and slime balls.
- HopenHeyHi 4y agoThe Forbes 30 Under 30 have collectively raised $5.3B in funding. The Forbes 30 Under 30 have also been arrested for frauds and scams worth over $18.5B. Incredible track record. https://twitter.com/ChrisJBakke/status/1643330142054526977 https://twitter.com/ChrisJBakke/status/1643330142054526977 I'm seriously contemplating just starting an inverse-cramer ETF tracking companies associated with these alumni. Anybody interested? (Not kidding)
- ceejayoz 4y agoThis is a bit misleading; the funding number is for one year's members, the fraud/scam number is over many.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- lotsofpulp 4y agoHow would you track it? These are not publicly listed companies (which is what enables most of these scams anyway).
- HopenHeyHi 4y agoKeep tabs on the 2nd order. I'd imagine the next Theranos/FTX types are in there already acting empowered and speaking out about altruism, cutting deals with some publicly traded companies. "We are running a pilot MVNO in SF distributing P2P WiFi via HOBOS. Hobspots we call 'em. Or hopespots. Still workshopping. They get a free phone with 1GB of data, you get better 5G coverage." => Short T-Mobile. "And coming this winter Ad Coats, because nobody deserves to not look festive during the holidays" => Short Patagonia.
- fundad 4y agoIf I scammed that much money you wouldn’t find me, not even in New Jersey.
- pyrophane 4y agoThe "move fast and break things, fake it 'til you make it" culture around start-ups I think really blurred the line between acceptable behavior and criminal fraud for a lot of people, and some of them stepped on the wrong side of it and got arrested. As the startup scene cools a bit, hopefully there will also be a rethinking of some of its values that will lead to less of this sort of thing.
- duxup 4y agoI don’t think it has anything to do with catch phrases or “culture”. Anyplace that large amounts of money shows up fast just provides opportunity for these things to happen. And in this case lying about how much business you do / customers you have… that one is as old as business…
- _fat_santa 4y agoThis wasn't her bending the rules or going outside the bounds, she straight up faked a majority of their users which was the entire reason JPM invested.
- wonderingyogi 4y agoThis is more common than you think in the startup world. This isn't the first time I have heard such things. Mobile game companies do this too.
- gkanai 4y agoDid Javice think she was not going to get found out? That she could fool JPM? I just don't get this fraud strategy at all.
- htrp 4y agoThe endgame probably was to just get fired... settle out of court for a mutual non-disparagement and then retire to Miami to become a QuantumCrypto angel investor
- JPws_Prntr_Fngr 4y agoTo me, the striking part of the story is the valuation of spam. > Javice lied about having data on 4 million clients, including making up fake client information, in order to entice JPMorgan Chase to buy her company in 2021 for $175 milliion > According to the SEC's complaint, JPMorgan was eager to buy Frank because the company claimed to have contact information — including names, emails and phone numbers — for over 4 million students, a pool of potential new customers the bank wanted to reach. JPM paid ~$42 per student so it could spam them. I don't know what their conversion funnel looks like, but that's surprisingly high to me. College students make lucrative targets, apparently. It's also depressing to think about as an individual in this economy - having our personal info harvested, bundled up, traded, and exploited for hundreds of millions of dollars, all without our consent.
- lotsofpulp 4y agoI am surprised, presumably, that Discover/Navient/etc would not directly sell their borrower’s contact info for much less than $42 per person, and it would be the highest quality real time data.
- JPws_Prntr_Fngr 4y agoGood point, the market rate for contact info must be way below $42. I suspect JPM really wanted the juicier demographic/segmentation data that this little startup app convinced the students to provide. But they're not going to put that in their lawsuit or PR releases: "We thought we were buying 4.2M unsuspecting students' race, sexual orientation, family history, mental health status, blood types, and genetic code, but it was fake! We want a refund."
- function_seven 4y ago> College students make lucrative targets, apparently. I have in my wallet two credit cards that I signed up for back in college. In the 90s. For one of them, I also got a 3 lb. bag of M&Ms. The other one came with a free T-shirt I think? In both cases, them setting up tables on my campus netted multi-decade account holders. I should've bargained harder that day, though. I didn't realize what my CLTV was to them.
- throwaway743 4y agoCurious about her claim of withfrank.org displaying 350,000 students vs the 4 million claim from JP Morgan. Also, curious to know when acquisition talks began and what was said or if instruction was given. There's a Crunchbase timeline showing that the acquisition was agreed upon in Sept 2021. Wayback machine shows that in January 28th 2021 withfrank.org displayed 350,000, but then changed to 4.25 million on February 22nd 2021. Big jump regardless and mindless by whoever instructed that change unless there was another motive. Welp https://web.archive.org/web/20210128204248/https://withfrank.org/ https://web.archive.org/web/20210128204248/https://withfrank... https://web.archive.org/web/20210222193947/https://withfrank.org/ https://web.archive.org/web/20210222193947/https://withfrank...
- fblp 4y agoIt's surprising that there also seems to be a pattern where the people engaging in these crimes can afford to pay $1mil+ bonds (Holmes, Bankman-Fried). I haven't recently seen an article where someone committed massive whitecollar fraud and they couldn't afford this bond because they didn't have incredibly wealthy friends or family.
- tedivm 4y agoA lot of times they don't have to put up any actual money, just collateral. With bay area housing prices being as high as they are they can typically use their houses to cover the bond.
- peteradio 4y agoSo foreign investment in USA property can influence fraud in the tech sector, interesting what this one tangential influence could account for.
- HarryHirsch 4y agoGoes to show that the fraud is systemic - the individual who is being prosecuted is just the face of the operation, family and friends are in on the joke.
- pjdemers 4y agoThey gave the emails where they bought the fraudulent data to Chase. Not only that, they used company email and money to negotiate and buy the data. They need a lesson in how to commit fraud. I assume they will get that lesson in prison.