6 ms·
Both from outside USA seem insane. Broken auto glasses are extremely rare here. Stabbings sometimes, but nearly always not in public but in homes between junkie
by Ekaros 4y ago
Both from outside USA seem insane. Broken auto glasses are extremely rare here. Stabbings sometimes, but nearly always not in public but in homes between junkies drinking ethanol. Not on streets like this case.
- augment001 4y agoBroken auto glass is pretty much the default in SF if you leave anything at all visible in a parked car. Pretty much anyone I’ve ever spoken to has had it happen to them, and it happened to me 3 times. This is because there is simply no law enforcement response. On the other hand stabbings and murder are taken very seriously by law enforcement.
- BurningFrog 4y agoHere in Oakland, the saying is that OPD doesn't come out unless there is a body.
- operatingthetan 4y ago>This is because there is simply no law enforcement response. You're expecting the police to show up in a 60 second window? Do you realize how little time it takes to smash a window and leave?
- throwaway049 4y agoWhat part of their post indicated that expectation?
- operatingthetan 4y agoThey suggested that the break-ins occur because there is no police response. Police response would not stop break-ins in any city. Say I came to your car in the middle of the night and left a strange note on it and then walked away. Do you think there is any way that you could find me with no clues about who I am?
- augment001 4y agoYou’ve completely misunderstood. My comment said nothing about preventing car break-ins. I was pointing out that car break-ins are treated very differently from violent crime. If there is an inference to be drawn, I’d say it is that we should not act as if the two kinds of crime are equivalent.
- lebed2045 4y agoThe most unthought response I see every time. “But what you expect cop gonna do”? There are millions things they could do if given insensitive. Imagine a startup that get paid for every busted criminal? Put a honey pot, install cameras, track license plates. It can be resolved in matters of weeks.
- operatingthetan 4y agoPeople breaking into cars in your area are driving to their thefts? In cities they just walk down the street looking for targets of opportunity. You think that a few honey pots and cameras will slow them down? Imaginative but unrealistic thinking. Someone stole some wood from my yard, and I have them on camera. What am I supposed to do with their image? How do you suggest I find them? Is it worth my billing rate to walk around the neighborhood with their image asking people where they might be for $30 worth of wood? Say we have a database of petty criminals, if I find them do you think they have the assets to pay for the glass and items from an auto break-in? The economic incentives are not aligned for a moonshot on stopping petty property crime.
- projectazorian 4y agoAnd even if your random smash-and-grab thief does get busted, he's just going to be back on the street in a week or two. The US criminal justice system is not set up to handle these sorts of offenders, most of whom probably just require detox and social services.
- floren 4y ago> People breaking into cars in your area are driving to their thefts? In cities they just walk down the street looking for targets of opportunity. I assumed the same but based on reporting I've seen on SF local news, at least some of them are doing it out of cars. Pull up next to a likely target, dude jumps out of the passenger seat and takes a quick look, smash & grab if there's anything good, drive off.
- whimsicalism 4y ago> People breaking into cars in your area are driving to their thefts? In cities they just walk down the street looking for targets of opportunity. I've lived in multiple cities and can say that this is wrong. I find that generally most people imagine these thefts are being done by homeless people on the streets but it's usually actually organized gangs driving in from Oakland. Same thing when I lived in DC, organized criminals driving in from SE DC to rob the rich neighborhoods.
- PicassoCTs 4y agoAll it takes is ninja rocks https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ninja_rocks https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ninja_rocks
- FanaHOVA 4y agoYea crazy. There definitely weren't 261 stabbing homicides in England last year. And my car wasn't broken into every other month in Rome. Nope. Just a USA thing. Everywhere else is a heaven.
- alasdair_ 4y ago55 murders in a population of 850,000 is a hell of a worse rate than 261 in 56 million. It's the difference between 1 in 15,000 and 1 in over 200,000.
- ribosometronome 4y agoIsn't that really a gun problem, though? If you start looking at violent crime in general, the US may actually be lower. It's just way easier for us to murder each other. See places like https://www.politifact.com/factchecks/2013/jun/24/blog-posting/social-media-post-says-uk-has-far-higher-violent-c/ https://www.politifact.com/factchecks/2013/jun/24/blog-posti... which state, with lots of asterisks about why this comparison is difficult and likely not telling the complete story, that: >For England and Wales, we added together three crime categories: "violence against the person, with injury," "most serious sexual crime," and "robbery." This produced a rate of 775 violent crimes per 100,000 people. >For the United States, we used the FBI’s four standard categories for violent crime that Bier cited. We came up with a rate of 383 violent crimes per 100,000 people.
- no-dr-onboard 4y ago> Both from outside USA seem insane. I see this a lot on the internet and comments like this are not as relevant as you might think. Saying place X is better off than place Y is often an incongruent comparison followed by similar fallacies. Y'all, each place is unique and faces a long and considerable history as to how they got there and the type of people that have and currently do live there. I can't even begin to recall the number of times I heard this type of comparison during the Obama administration. America is not similar to Sweden, Finland, Germany, Japan or Canada.
- xiphias2 4y agoCrime and health statistics are mostly depending on economic situation of a country (money per person). US is an outlier in both (especially health spending vs average life expectency)
- trafficante 4y agoJust want to note that US life expectancy is all over the place; much like with nearly every other national comparison statistic, the US average is largely a useless thing to compare to other countries. For example: here in the Pacific Northwest, we’re neck and neck with chart-topping Japan for life expectancy - while most of the Deep South has a life expectancy roughly in-line with the average Iraqi. Yes, America is an Odd Place.
- Supermancho 4y ago> America is not similar to Sweden, Finland, Germany, Japan or Canada. Except for, you know, they are each an organization of humans with access to technology and other cultures. Maybe there's something to be learned.
- profeaturo 4y agoAs long as what you learn complies with the regime idealogy. Europe is a nicer place to live for now, but that’s more in spite of Europeans’ politics than because of it. There’s no significant difference in thought between the typical American liberal progressive and his European counterpart. Now that Europeans have sufficiently Americanized they’ll soon discover that the problems america faces now are in fact universal to all diverse liberal democracies.
- shadowgovt 4y agoIt depends on where you live, but the massive wealth inequality in the US coupled with the ripped social safety net means that not only are people pretty incentivized to steal what they need / want from those who have, but those who have can replace it quite quickly (often with just the inconvenience of some insurance wrangling). So for the vast majority of property crime, the victim ultimately ends up being the insurance premium, and everybody involved kind of knows this, even if they don't say it outright.
- screye 4y agoThe worst affected cities have the widest safety nets. These kinds of crimes are fairly low in towns in Mississippi ravaged by worse poverty and with their own (painkillers) drug problems. The nature of the drugs (fentanyl), the manifestation (homelessness) and the enforcement (or lack there of) are central to the problem faced here. It is not a US problem. It is not a west problem. It is not a city problem. It is an urban-west-coast-city problem.
- briantakita 4y agoI don't know if you've seen any videos of Kensington Ave in Philadelphia, but it's shocking. Chicago & St Louis also have major issues with murder. This is an urban east coast & urban mid-west problem as well.
- screye 4y agoThe worst affected cities have the widest safety nets. These kinds of crimes are fairly low in towns in Mississippi ravaged by worse poverty and with their own (painkillers) drug problems. The nature of the drugs (fentanyl), the manifestation (homelessness) and the enforcement (or lack there of) are central to the problem faced here. It is not a US problem. It is not a west problem. It is not a city problem. It is an urban-US-west-coast-city problem.
- shadowgovt 4y agoIt's primarily driven by wealth inequality, not poverty. Who is someone going to steal from in Mississippi? Their also-poor neighbor who's got nothing worth stealing? The median income is around $25k in that state.
- hcks 4y agoYeah I agree, here outside USA there is no such things. It’s totally an American craziness.
- ericmcer 4y agoIt is just in cities, and specifically in SF/Oakland. Smashing a car window is not really going to be punished in any way in those cities, at most they will take you in and release you within 24 hours. Most likely police will not bother, even if they witness it occurring. When I was younger and walked around at night me and my friends would get mugged fairly regularly (~6X over 4 years) and the police would maybe show up 24 hours later at a random time. One time I even had a clip from a gun the dudes dropped as they were running away (it was empty) and the police never came and took it. I probably still have it around somewhere. I moved to the suburbs recently and it is amazing being able to park and walk around without being afraid of break ins or muggings.
- asveikau 4y agoIt's important to note that violent crime in the United States has been at a low for about 29 years. I don't know how old you are, but for me, "feeling unsafe when you were younger" is a pretty meaningless observation with respect to present reality. Speaking personally, I feel totally safe in San Francisco parks with my children; we've got a lot of peaceful, blissful parks in this city, which in my understanding is substantially safer than it was in the 90s.
- rabuse 4y agoThis is called "coping" with your reality. Doesn't remove the fact that your city is still statistically unsafe.
- asveikau 4y agoSan Francisco isn't anywhere near the top of US cities by violent crime. You've been taken in by a lot of false media narratives. Trump said his bit about "American Carnage in our cities" and set about this revival of the tough on crime rhetoric from the 80s and 90s, a time when violent crime was much higher than today. Your position is not backed by the statistics.
- 4y ago
- briantakita 4y ago[flagged]
- dragonwriter 4y ago> The insanity is primarily contained in Democrat controlled cities. Murder rates are higher in Republican-led states. And we have a dual-sovereignty model (federal/state), cities aren’t sovereign entities, and state governments can and do interfere without limit in their government. > Many people are leaving California due to this insanity. People are leaving California largely because (1) they’ve made out well from the economic success of the state and can live luxuriously elsewhere on their savings, or (2) they haven’t participated in the economic success, and are squeezed out by the effect that success has on in-state prices. (1) is a non-problem, (2) is a real problem, but one that the state is finally taking significant action on (targeting housing, particularly), having generally left it to local governments who have failed to act (before about the last decade, that wasn’t as much an active state policy choice as the fact that the combination of Constitutional supermajority requirements for the state budget plus minority party obstructionism had made the state effectively ungovernable for decades, once that was swept away there were a lot of issues to address.)
- briantakita 4y ago> Murder rates are higher in Republican-led states With the highest murder rates being in the Democrat controlled cities in the otherwise Republican State. Again, most of the country is wide open spaces with mostly friendly people. The period of the Pandemic & lockdown also had a high increase in violence. > People are leaving California largely because (1) they’ve made out well from the economic success of the state and can live luxuriously elsewhere on their savings, or (2) they haven’t participated in the economic success, and are squeezed out by the effect that success has on in-state prices. So if you make money in California, the great weather, social networks, & the business opportunities are not enough to offset the downsides? If you don't make enough money in California, the cost of living is higher than other states. California is a large state. Why is the cost of living, including the rural areas, so high there? How does the Purchasing Parity in California compare to other states?