7 ms·
For context Johnson and Johnson's total revenue for 2022 was $94.94 billion [1], and this settlement is to be paid out over 25 years. So the total cost to them
by somenameforme 4y ago
For context Johnson and Johnson's total revenue for 2022 was $94.94 billion [1], and this settlement is to be paid out over 25 years. So the total cost to them is about 1.3 days of revenue per year at their current revenue levels. Factor in inflation and growth, and it'll end up being a few hours of revenue per year.
More hard hitting justice for corporate malfeasance.
[1] - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Johnson_&_Johnson https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Johnson_&_Johnson
- lumb63 4y agoIt’s sad to me that situations where companies cause negative outcomes for people are paid for by fees and are labeled “the cost of doing business”. I saw a post here the other day that said that, rather than releasing products and later the burden be on others to prove they are unsafe, the burden should be on companies to ensure their products are safe prior to releasing them to the public. Money does not solve issues; you can compensate people for the cost of their cancer treatments, etc., but I’m sure they’d probably rather never have had cancer to begin with. The wrong can’t be retroactively undone.
- changoplatanero 4y ago> the burden should be on companies to ensure their products are safe prior to releasing them to the public I don't know if this policy would make the world a better place. There are so many life saving or life improving technologies that would be delayed because of the burden of proving them to be "safe"
- simmerup 4y ago> the burden should be on companies to ensure their products are safe prior to releasing them to the public I suspect big companies would love to stifle the competition from small competitors who can’t afford to sink money into this type of analysis
- candiddevmike 4y agoSounds good to me, stifle away. Move fast and break things doesn't fit in with consumer safety.
- azemetre 4y agoReally, is this the argument you want to actually make? That we shouldn't regulate things that people put on/into their body because we might hurt the "little guy?" Mind you I've been hearing about this mythical "little guy" that massive multinational corporations love to trot out when it comes to increasing regulations or taxes against them but over the course of my lifetime all I've seen is a massive increase in power and consolidation from these companies. It's so odd realizing you live in a dystopian cyberpunk future without the pretty trinkets to go along with it.
- samstave 4y ago>>"dystopian cyberpunk future" This is the future all of us kids from the 1970s and 1980s BUILT on the premise of "wouldnt it be cool if...." -- We (and I am personally guilty, as are many HNers, of facilitating the "wouldnt it be cool if Cyberpunk tropes were reality?" I helped build spying (marketing) infra, sentiment measures etc... But the "little guy" that bigPharma preys upon is the 'patient' J&J needs corporate capital punishment, because this isnt the first time or only incident of them causing negative outcomes for profit (recall their tainted vaccines?)
- renewiltord 4y agoWhy aren't there consumer products unions that certify products as safe ? That way, the people who care can get the certified product, and the rest can accept risk. It won't work for something like cigarettes where the risk is external but if the risk is to you, then you can manage it this way.
- lotsofpulp 4y agoThere are, such as Underwriters Laboratories. But the human body is such a complex machine that it’s infeasible to do the experiments necessary to provide the kinds of guarantees that one would desire. Many effects have multiple causes and can show up decades later.
- renewiltord 4y agoAh, so we should label the products with the appropriate certification and if it is missing, consumers should choose their position on the risk-reward curve.
- lotsofpulp 4y agoI cannot tell if you are being sarcastic, or just describing how life works.
- anfilt 4y agoThing is people have been using talcum powder for many many centuries. It's just ground up rock... The thing is when you gather something from nature there will be naturally contamination. The claim is about asbestos being in the talc powder which is also a rock... The thing is asbestos can occur naturally in and dirt all around the world. There are some places even in the US where dust storms are more dangerous just because this fact. Here's just a short memo about naturally occurring asbestos. https://ncceh.ca/sites/default/files/Naturally_occurring_asbestos_outdoor_setting-Feb_2018.pdf https://ncceh.ca/sites/default/files/Naturally_occurring_asb... I am not saying J&J should get off scotch free if they knew some sources of talc they were using had high levels of asbestos. However, I am gonna say it's not surprising that there may be some contamination. Moreover that's just one form of natural occurring contamination. There other minerals that naturally occur that also are unwanted contaminates such as heavy metals and so forth. What matters is are the contaminants reasonable low for a naturally sourced product since it's not possible to have zero contamination.
- somenameforme 4y agoI think the simpler solution is to start holding the people in charge of the companies accountable for the actions they greenlight and continue to approve. Johnson and Johnson knew their product had asbestos in it. It seems absurd they're not facing criminal charges. If I, as an individual, sold an asbestos tainted powder to people that resulted in deaths and cancer then there's a very good chance that I'd be spending the rest of my life in prison, even if I didn't knowingly do so. But if I do it as a massive global corporation, on a far wider scale, and with full knowledge of what I'm doing, my penalty is... nothing? I mean literally they're not even facing criminal charges, this was a civil suit. It just makes absolutely no sense whatsoever, and the stupidity of it all is enough to make one angry.
- lumb63 4y agoI don’t disagree with you; I think personal liability is in order in some situations, too (see: 2008 subprime mortgage crisis). However, again, these actions attempt to equalize after the fact. I suppose they also disincentivize beforehand. But why stop at disincentivizing the behavior, which requires relying on people to be rational actors, and instead not allow the behavior at all? We have organizations like the FDA, etc., to ensure that the food and drugs we put in our bodies are safe. The reality is the gamut of technologies, products, and environments that impact our health are far more broad than “food and drug”; why not regulate them the same way?
- ramblenode 4y ago> rather than releasing products and later the burden be on others to prove they are unsafe, the burden should be on companies to ensure their products are safe prior to releasing them to the public. I personally agree with the precautionary principle and think there should be stricter requirements for certain classes of new products, but the best solution is probably some type of compromise based on level of newness and possible danger. The core problem is the "unknown unknown". There's no upper limit to how much testing you should do to ensure a product is safe because the space of possible dangers is nearly infinite. So any policy will be a balancing act of false positives and false negatives and what levels of each are tolerable. I think this is the proper question and it is not an easy one to answer.
- missedthecue 4y agoUsing revenue doesn't make sense here, because the level of "hurt" would vary wildly if they had 90% margins or 0.9% margins. In their case, $9 billion wipes out about three years of profit.
- marricks 4y ago“Three years of profit” over 25 years, not accounting for inflation. Perhaps the first comment was too harsh but let’s not be overly generous.
- JumpCrisscross 4y ago> “Three years of profit” over 25 years, not accounting for inflation It looks like an $8.9bn settlement after $7.4bn in litigation expenses [1]. I would guess that is a substantial portion of J&J's total profits from talc-based products, inflation adjusted. Were that product an independent company, this would have bankrupted it. That's decent deterrence. [1] https://njbiz.com/jj-offers-8-9b-to-settle-claims-talc-products-caused-cancer/ https://njbiz.com/jj-offers-8-9b-to-settle-claims-talc-produ...
- goldfeld 4y agoIf they spent such an inordinate amount trying to escape, that is not part of deterrence, it is a gamble that big boys can take and they took and it didn't go as well. That gamble, or at least a good part of 7 billion, is their own fault and doing and not an external punishment, and importantly, doesn't absolve the final punishment, not even morally. Even more crucial, that money went to the dirtiest type of rich law firms (it is kind of an offence on its own!) and not to settling the damages at all.
- JumpCrisscross 4y ago> spent such an inordinate amount trying to escape, that is not part of deterrence, it is a gamble that big boys can take You’re claiming a tougher penalty would be fought less vigorously?
- eternalban 4y agoCurious as to what laws shield the executives of these companies from facing criminal charges. Any lawyers in the house? Where is the line legally drawn?
- HWR_14 4y agoRevenue, as opposed to profit, seems like a particularly poor metric. But better still is going to be market cap. Their cap is ~$400 billion. So this might be a little over 2.25% of the value of a giant corporation. Maybe halve that because of the time value of money. It seems extremely doubtful the talcum powder business never accounted for more than 1% of the value of the company, so this is probably a pretty big fine.
- goldfeld 4y agoDoes it matter the portion of the smaller company? The parent company is responsible for its actions, and that is enough. A giant corporation that does outright damage (and is caught out) should get a sentence as to be repressed in the behavior so executives think twice next time, that is what matters. 2% of value or possibly less is hardly a threatening indictment. Why should not a company be brought to its knees? You know, the same as citizens are? There are jobs and families? So are there on the side of damaged parties, generally. And it has competitors who can do the company's part just as well as they can.
- HWR_14 4y agoIf you're talking about compensatory damages, the size of the talc business doesn't matter. J&J has to make people whole. If you're talking about punitive damages, the size matters. Making sure that the action is non-profitable is important. But at the same time, you can only expect so much oversight of small parts of a company. 2% of the net worth of a Fortune 50 company is not a small fine. > Why should not a company be brought to its knees? You know, the same as citizens are? I'd flip this question around. Why should citizens be brought to their knees? But often, they are not. Certainly not with civil actions.
- Supermancho 4y ago> 2% of the net worth of a Fortune 50 company is not a small fine. That's your opinion and worth as much as any other. Second, it isn't even 2% amortized, which compounds the lack of impact. The people who died over this are dead and aren't getting paid, so these kind of small payouts are minimal incidental damage.
- tomcam 4y agoYou cynic. Because look how many people were sent to prison and did hard time… oh. Wait a minute…
- goldfeld 4y agoIn Who Can Be Happy and Free in Russia?, a dissenting peasant has to be lashed out by the barin's command, who thinks he is still landed gentry but in reality is being fooled by the compassionate and loyal to the bone downtrodden peasants, who rather own their lands now but keep playing a farce. The community leader calls the dissenting peasant to a room within earshot of the barin, gives him as much vodka as his morals need as to ask him to yell loudly while the leader makes beating noises and says nasty things to him. The peasant commits suicide soon after in the story.
- chiefalchemist 4y agoWhat needs to change is the nature of the punishment. As long as it's monetary and only monetary, the punishment is negligible. Put one or two executives in jail and things will look different. Rob a bank, you go to jail. Rob people of their lives and you keep your well paid job and your company get slapped on the wrist. Ultimately, the fines are paid by consumers. But jail time? That's a payment made by the guilty.
- morpheuskafka 4y agoWouldn’t it make more sense to compare it to the revenue from talc sales specifically, or maybe that business unit, and not the whole conglomerate?
- paulpauper 4y agoWhich is why the stock price is up on this news and positive over the past 5 years despite this lawsuit. it's a rounding error
- themitigating 4y agoCome on, revenue is not profit.