4 ms·
Only loosely-related, but a little HN-ish... A long time ago, the "trademark enforcement team" of a certain FAANG sent me a legal threats letter, about a domai
by neilv 4y ago
Only loosely-related, but a little HN-ish...
A long time ago, the "trademark enforcement team" of a certain FAANG sent me a legal threats letter, about a domain name I'd registered.
The domain name had been intended for a satirical critique of early social media proto-influencer behavior, and couldn't be mistaken for a brand of the company.
I'd lost interest in writing the site, but, after some back&forth with them, I didn't like that the company I'd always liked was trying to strongarm domain names away from people. I thought this might be culture runaway from the founders' intentions.
So, I initiated a transfer of the domain name to the old university email address of their co-founder, and told them they'd have to ask him for it. And something about this being an opportunity for discussing don't-be-evil.
- traskjd 4y agoOne of the issues in TM law is that if you don't defend it, folks can claim you're not using it. Leads to perverse outcomes at times, especially in orgs big enough to have folks full time employed looking at such matters. [Edit: I'm not saying this is good. Yes, cooler heads should prevail. I'm explaining what can lead it to occurring when it seems nonsensical.]
- jonny_eh 4y agoThere is a limit though. Always consider "how would this look in front of a judge". There should be a cost paid for being overly litigious in this regard.
- unyttigfjelltol 4y agoIt's more like Xerox probably sort of liked that people viewed them as interchangeable with the act of photocopying, but eventually this had textbook consequences for their ability to prevent people from using their name for things they didn't like. I personally would have suggested offering you a license to use the web address, but for whatever reason that ilk of lawyers prefer antisocial methodologies.
- Dylan16807 4y ago> eventually this had textbook consequences for their ability to prevent people from using their name for things they didn't like Like what? I've never heard of such a use.
- unyttigfjelltol 4y agoOk, looks like Xerox pulled their mark back from being merely "generic".[1] [1] https://www.justia.com/intellectual-property/trademarks/strength-of-marks/generic-terms/ https://www.justia.com/intellectual-property/trademarks/stre...
- zinekeller 4y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Generic_trademark https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Generic_trademark Xerox was eventually successful (at least in US), but there are cases like Bayer's Aspirin (surprise!) that were genericized.
- bombcar 4y agoBayer didn’t seem all that concerned with defending Heroin™.
- User23 4y agoThe Aspirin and Heroin trademark revocations were punitive and due to the war, not due to lack of proper defense. That’s why you will see non-Bayer acetylsalicylic acid literally marketed as “Aspirin” but even though the Kleenex trademark is considerably weakened, you still don’t see competitors openly labeling their products with the name.
- maicro 4y ago"Hey, can you xerox me a few copies of this document real quick? Yeah, just use the Canon all-in-one on my desk." Little clunky, but I'm certain it's been said somewhere/somewhen.
- 4y ago
- jasonladuke0311 4y agoGive the history between the assumed parties, I doubt founder would be trying to take that domain name. He lost a lot in court already
- SOLAR_FIELDS 4y agoThere are polite ways to go about enforcing this though. The Jack Daniel’s incident comes to mind: https://mashable.com/archive/jack-daniels-trademark-letter https://mashable.com/archive/jack-daniels-trademark-letter
- vlovich123 4y agoIsn’t the trademark unenforceable in that case because Jack Daniel’s the drink and the book are in totally different markets and trademarks only apply if you’re competing in the same space.
- danielheath 4y agoA judge would likely decide that, sure. After you've engaged $$$ representation and wasted months of your time defending it.
- lelanthran 4y ago> A judge would likely decide that, sure. After you've engaged $$$ representation and wasted months of your time defending it. For stupid things like this, where the stakes are so low[1], I'd be tempted to represent myself[2]. It'll still cost me hours to appear in court, but it will be much less money than if I paid a lawyer and it will cost me a lot less than the other party[3]. TBH, every person of average intelligence should be taught the basics of defending a claim in their jurisdiction: what steps are involved, what paperwork to file at each step, where to file it, what deadlines there are, how to request extensions for deadlines, what constitutes evidence, how to get written testimonies under oath, etc.[4] These things are not hard, and for low-stakes things there's a greater expected value in taking the gamble on self-representation than in hiring an attorney. Much of the time, for low-value claims, you can simply show up and request that the matter be moved to small-claims court[5]. Most courts actually would prefer to move a suit for $1k to a small claims court. [1] Where the product made a total of maybe $1k, the damages are going to be under $100, and that's maybe too high too, because losing this would mean changing the game's name (or even only the font in the title), which is going to be cheaper than even 2 hours of an attorneys time. The only real danger is cost orders against the defendant, but these are a) rare, and b) decided by the court, using the context of what both parties spent. You aren't going to represent yourself and get hit with a cost order for $100k. [2] I'm not a lawyer and I'm not in the US, but I've represented myself multiple times for things that were much less obvious, and defended all successfully. Courts aren't stupid; all you see in the news when courts make stupid decisions are the outliers. You don't see the thousands of sensible decisions a judge made each month. [3] So it'll be an expensive lesson for Monster if they decide to drag it out. I'll lose billable hours for myself. They'll lose money and goodwill. [4] I found, in my district, that the court is very patient with any person defending themselves and would take the time to explain all of the above even in session, and adjourn for the defendant to perform all the steps that were explained. [5] Small claims don't usually handle trademark infringement claims, though, so not in this particular case.
- harry8 4y ago>So, I initiated a transfer of the domain name to the old university email address of their co-founder, and told them they'd have to ask him for it. And something about this being an opportunity for discussing don't-be-evil. And it worked! They clearly did. And dropped "Don't be evil" from having anything to do with the company's present or future. How long between that and them selling ML services to the pentagon for kill-bots? :( (Still a great story and I like your response, more power to you.)
- chrisdirkis 4y agoI hear this claimed a lot. They removed it from their motto, but have retained it in their code of conduct, according to Wikipedia[1], and Alphabet has also adopted a similar motto. Whether you want to argue their actions match this, that's up to you, but factually, they did not drop it "from everything forever". [1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Don%27t_be_evil https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Don%27t_be_evil
- harry8 4y agoAn unenforced code is so useless it is barely worth mentioning except to express total and utter contempt. In your view, how many times has google engaged in evil conduct with this "code of conduct" having had no say before, during or after the decision to be evil was made? Estimate it. "Don't be evil" is long, long gone and it's a shame.
- rolph 4y agoi have a strong hunch, dont be evil is an insider doublespeak. it probably means something very different among the upper alphabet echelon
- javajosh 4y agoIt means something as technophilic 50-year-old Stanford CS students, and the people they hire. These are rational, educated makers who pride themselves on their intellectual achievement. They are drawn to the futuristic, fair, wealthy, egalitarian meritocracy of Star Trek and hope for a post-singularity future. "Don't be evil" has a clear meaning within these (valid) stereotypes of liberal/libertarian California and SV culture. I cannot imagine what happens when you pickle such a view in infinite money for 20 years. It's probably not good.