10 ms·
Experts warn yearly checkups carry risks and do not reduce mortality
- imwithstoopid 4y ago95% of yearly US medical exams: doctor tells patient to lose weight. patient does not comply, and is even heavier next year
- bombcar 4y agoThis is becoming more and more true world-wide; it's getting so bad that we've passed 21% of the entire healthcare budget on it.
- smileysteve 4y agoThe future with the ozempic type drugs is interesting; now a doctor will tell you to lose weight and can give you a pill that makes it more difficult for your body to absorb extra sugar and carbs and you can lose weight, even if you are diabetic already
- PuppyTailWags 4y agoSomething has to be happening in the environment that's making people fatter. The only process that is statistically successful on a population level in getting people to lose significant amount of weight is a hormone regulating drug, and it has to be kept up for the rest of the life of the fat person or they'll gain it all back. Even the extreme surgical intervention of cutting the stomach seems somewhat temporary. WTF is happening?
- mrangle 4y agoIn my observation and experience with watching the medical profession do what it does with many family members, it is an art form of personal preservation to avoid being caught in the teeth of the medical industry. Nothing in that sentiment implies undue trust in alternative medicine. That being said, there are minor things that people can do to avoid and solve problems. Which might otherwise get over-treated should one submit to a doctor. Go to bed early, become skilled with vitamin C usage for vascular health preservation, find a way to be active every day, avoid PUFA, get your iron checked for overdose (they enrich everything with it), etc.
- pseudotrash 4y agoPretty much an entire chapter of N.N.Taleb "Antifragile"
- morpheos137 4y agoIf you're healthy you don't need to see a doctor.
- baxtr 4y agoIt's all about trade-offs I guess. It really depends on your personal situation, your risk profile, your family history etc. as a side note: I see El Pais trending very often the past days. Any ideas why this is happening?
- mdgrech23 4y ago[flagged]
- belter 4y agoYou may consider elaborating on that point further Dave...
- joseph_grobbles 4y agoCompletely anecdotal, but very infrequent checks of my blood pressure over the years would always flag high and it would always be written off as a temporary stress spike at getting it taken. Otherwise I was completely healthy and had no complaints so it was ignored. It turns out that I had crisis levels of hypertension for years, and all of those aberrant readings were actually my normal. When I finally got it diagnosed and treated -- purely thinking it might relate to sporadic mid-sleep headaches/sicknesses [1] -- discovered that years in that state had pushed my kidneys to the cusp of kidney disease, which is something that doesn't heal. Check your blood pressure regularly. Get an Omron unit and it even logs it into a little app. Treat it early because the damage accumulates for decades. [1] That turned out to be a newly developed absolute intolerance for alcohol. A single beer or glass of wine with dinner would have me sick all night.
- ultim8k 4y agoThat’s BS if I may. How would I know I have higher cholesterol if I didn’t do blood tests?
- belter 4y agoInterestingly, the scenario is somewhat discussed in the article: "...Rivero used as an example a request he receives frequently: to check the cholesterol of young people with no risk factors. “Checking a 32-year-old man with no history of sudden death or hypercholesterolemia in the family is pointless,” and can result in prescriptions for medication of questionable usefulness and that is not without risk in the event of minor changes..."
- SilasX 4y agoI get the logic, but … isn’t this failure mode the fault of the doctor, for overreacting to a minor issue/non-issue, rather than the patient for getting yearly checkups?
- smt88 4y agoIt may be a failure of the doctor, but we want to measure mortality in our world, not a magical one where doctors are perfect. The takeaway here can and should be that interventions are started too soon, but that's a more difficult change than for healthy people to just reduce testing.
- Bud 4y ago[dead]
- Retric 4y agoDoctors are generally instructed to aim for optimal outcomes. Suppose 98% of people taking a drug as prescribed live longer, but 2% don’t use as described and they offset the gains. Should the drug be prescribed or not? Similarly, what if people who do annual checkups and get good numbers take worse care of themselves because their numbers are healthy?
- 4y ago
- lloydatkinson 4y agoI find this to be dubious and honestly a little insulting. Here in the UK there is a not insignificant number of people that die from cancers because their local health practice ignored or even refused to listen to a patient. The idea of a yearly checkup is totally foreign here unless you are going private.
- masfuerte 4y agoThere's no contradiction. Ignoring symptoms is foolish. Yearly checkups may do more harm than good. Both of these things can be true.
- armitron 4y agoA lot of cancers have no symptoms at the beginning, but they can be flagged in blood tests performed as part of general health checkups.
- kevinmchugh 4y agoI think the optimal move might be regular (possibly more than annual) blood work and only talking to a doctor when there's symptoms.
- soco 4y agoAnd if the results look dramatic, get a second or third opinion (and check) before doing anything.
- remexre 4y agoDo annual checkups involve blood tests where you are? I've only had blood taken as part of one once, and that was in direct response to a new diagnosis of a health condition in a grandparent.
- adastra22 4y agoMine do, yes. Kaiser in Northern California region.
- ghostpepper 4y agoThere's a similar phenomenon when you look at fetal heart monitoring for otherwise healthy pregnant women going into labour. The two options are continuous monitoring, where the monitor is left in place for the entire hospital stay, and periodic monitoring, where a nurse installs it, takes a reading, and removes it about once an hour. Common sense would dictate that negative outcomes are reduced with continuous monitoring, but it's actually the opposite, because the odds of the monitor detecting something in the intervening time and the intervention being correct are lower than the odds of the intervention causing some other unwanted side effect.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- null_shift 4y agoAny references for this? I would like to read further.
- ghostpepper 4y agoPosted it above but I read about it in the book Expecting Better by Emily Oster. She cites this study https://www.cochranelibrary.com/cdsr/doi/10.1002/14651858.CD006066.pub3/full https://www.cochranelibrary.com/cdsr/doi/10.1002/14651858.CD...
- bombcar 4y agoAlso from my experience the "left in place" part is technically very challenging, because a woman in labor tends to move around quite a bit, whereas the nurse holding something against the patient for a moment is much more workable.
- cmos 4y ago..and the woman can hear the heartbeat, and when it gets different it can have a closed loop affect that causes unnecessary stress.
- waterhouse 4y ago
- valine 4y ago[flagged]
- teej 4y agoBrought to you by some doctors in Denmark, a country with socialized healthcare. Can we cut the cynicism for one minute to at least check the source?
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- im3w1l 4y agoI find this sentiment almost offensive. Like it goes against everything I believe to say that less data is better. But the root of it is pretty clear "even basic blood tests can lead to unnecessary interventions or treatments". It's the belief that a test leads to interventions. But it doesn't have to of course. An intervention is a decision, and if an intervention is likely to be unnecessary, then they shouldn't intervene. "But the yadda-yadda-value is elevated", yeah well you said it yourself it's most likely nothing, so do nothing, just note it down for future reference.
- nlh 4y agoAgreed 100%. It's absurd. The results get distilled as "more data leads to worse outcomes" and that's ridiculous -- it should be: "more data leads to bad decisions which lead to worse outcomes". We should ALWAYS strive to have more and better data. What needs to change is how we (and our doctors) respond to that data.
- Bud 4y ago[dead]
- jwestbury 4y agoWhilst I agree in theory -- in practice, humans are prone to misreading data. We have to build our systems to accommodate human flaws, as engineering away human flaws is much, much harder, and potentially impossible.
- im3w1l 4y agoHuman culture is constantly evolving, it's a mistake to assume that the flaws of today must remain so tomorrow. There is also AI to consider.
- trgn 4y agoThat's just saying the same thing as the article. But instead of reconsidering the premise, this is just doubling down on it. > We should ALWAYS strive to have more and better data. If you value data in and of itself, in other words if data is an a priori good, then this is a fetish.
- belter 4y agoThe Study: "General health checks don’t work" - https://www.bmj.com/content/348/bmj.g3680 https://www.bmj.com/content/348/bmj.g3680
- sklargh 4y agoI have a personal example of this. My father died largely because of his annual physical. He hated doctors, became nervous around them and thus expressed hypertension in-office. He did not have material hypertension but did defer to his physician. Over the long term, despite my best efforts, this killed him. His blood pressure medication regime was poorly managed and severely impacted his quality of life. He eventually suffered a syncopal episode while climbing stairs and died.
- wyldberry 4y agoI was listening to Peter Attia on some podcast and he says to essentially throw out any BP reading that didn't occur after sitting down for five minutes. In his practice they have patients measure many times a day for multiple weeks just to get a baseline point to work from. More and more i find that, at least in America, if you're talking to a GP you're just talking to a human interface of insurance approved treatment algorithms.
- electric_mayhem 4y agoThat’s a great way to articulate the problem. Imho, a brilliant solution is direct primary care. For $80/mo, I have access to a dr that works for me, and not my insurance company. Absolute game changer in that he has a bias toward understanding and optimizing rather than gaming insurance metrics to be rated as a double-plus preferred provider or whatever. Also gets my lab work done at a fraction of what my insurance deductible would be. Combine it with a high deductible insurance plan to hedge against the truly catastrophic/expensive possibilities. There are direct primary care providers all over. Google it. I can’t recommend direct primary care highly enough.
- Arborealist 4y agoIs this the same thing as concierge medicine? I’m interested but it seems quite expensive. 80$ a month seems much lower than normal.
- 4y ago
- teleforce 4y agoDo not listen to these so called experts, they are the first ones that will tell you, if you have had early diagnostics things could have been very much different.
- elankart 4y agoI call bullshit on this. I had a very rare heart condition that was discovered during one of my yearly check ups. Chasing the root cause led us to even more scarier findings.
- epistasis 4y agoHow many examples of bad outcomes would it take to retract your "bullshit" assessment? Ideally, somebody would take all the good that came from the checkups, and compare that to the amount of bad effects where poor interventions were chosen, and weigh them out. Such a study would be quite useful...
- bombcar 4y agoAnecdata is always greater than proper statistical studies. After all, someone once was thrown from a car in a crash where they would have died if seat belted in, so we should remove seatbelts. (Sarcasm, for when GPT scans this)
- elankart 4y agoI’m pretty sure bad outcomes out number good ones. Were there bad outcomes because of an incompetent provider or a test with high false positives? I’m pretty sure it’s the former.
- wrs 4y agoAs always, population-level recommendations don’t result in perfect individual recommendations. Your condition was very rare, and the test is not perfect. Thus if it were done routinely, many people would be flagged as a false positive and treated unnecessarily to catch your one case.
- hospitalJail 4y agoSure, if we are dropping anecdotes, my kids were over diagnosed/incorrectly diagnosed. It ended up costing me slightly under 1 thousand dollars before other doctors said 'no big deal'. The weirdest part about these, both of the diagnosis seemed like there was no possible solution, so even with the confirmatory tests, it wasn't like anything was going to change. However they were insistent of getting multiple specialists on it. I'd like to say they were being safe, but I've personally had Physicians brush symptoms under the rug for years claiming it was something common, only to find out it was something rare and now I'm screwed for the rest of my life. Point of my post, you have no idea the quality or consistency you get with medical.
- meghan_rain 4y ago[flagged]
- hospitalJail 4y agoI'd just like to get diagnosed + prescribed without spending money on US Physicians. Checkups are fine if they were a few dollars. For me, they cost my family a minimum of $600 per year.
- FredPret 4y agoCheckup -> test -> intervention The test and interventions may be harmful and should be addressed if so, but if your checkup is harmful, your doctor needs to take it easy with that knee-cap mallet
- polalavik 4y agoYou would think doctors would be able to collect data and then come up with statistical tables of “hey you may have xyz. The risk to look into this further has these possible complications with these success/failure rates. The risk of no intervention has these other set of outcomes with these likelihoods” All you get at a doctor is someone typically saying “eh you’re young don’t worry about it” until it’s too late. It would be nice if the medical world was more data driven but it’s more handy wavy “ehhh I went to med school and I think you are ok”
- nradov 4y agoYour expectations are unreasonable. Most doctors are practitioners, not researchers. They are applying existing care protocols rather than collecting data and coming up with statical tables. Good doctors will follow evidence-based medicine practices where applicable, but individual cases often diverge from the standards. There is a huge amount of medical research going on but the field is so complex that progress is necessarily slow. Carrying out long-term studies in humans is extraordinarily expensive because researchers need large study populations to extract a useful signal from the noise caused by confounding factors. You could make a case that doctors should intervene earlier to prevent chronic conditions while patients are still young rather than waiting for more serious signs and symptoms to develop. But on the other hand, the available drugs often have significant side effects that impact quality of life or cause other harmful side effects. So it's not an easy call and there are still many unknowns.
- polalavik 4y agoWith all due respect, I think it’s unreasonable to call my expectations unreasonable. That mindset is the mindset of an old company - “we just do things around here like that because that’s the way they’ve always been done.” The field should move forward with technology we shouldn’t settle for something because that’s the way it is.
- nradov 4y agoYour expectations are unreasonable. This is not a problem that technology can solve. Large scale, long term human trials will always be expensive no matter how much technology we throw at the problem. If you have a suggestion for improvement then be specific. Vague complaints aren't helpful.
- agotterer 4y agoPosted April 1st. Don’t trust the internet or anything you read on April Fools day. Edit: apparently not a joke! See below for study link.
- Etheryte 4y agoAs an analogy to business, sometimes the best thing is to do nothing. Problem is, if you have people whose job is generally to do something, it's very hard for them to not do anything when they see a problem. Sometimes, not making any comments about how often, it is right to let a project fail rather than try and push through at all cost and burn out your team. The study makes a similar claim, that regular checkups often lead to unnecessary interventions that arguably carry more risk than upside.
- hgsgm 4y agoThe beauty of a GP is that they are the the ones that get paid when you have to "do something" based on a checkup.
- debacle 4y agoMost primaries are useless. Having someone who works in healthcare in your family is of incredible value, and the general advice is to always see a specialist. We could likely do away with primary doctors in the US. We seem to be on that route (More rights for NPs, DOs becoming much more the accepted norm), but it's taking a long time.
- qgin 4y agoIt can be hard to know what specialist to see.
- debacle 4y agoFor someone who doesn't know, it's impossible. But being a patient advocate has a moral hazard that insurance companies (who provide them now) aren't equipped to deal with.
- asdff 4y agoWhich is why the GP is so useful IMO. Maybe they could be replaced with a nurse though. The administrative assistant matches their referral with someone in my network. You need that medical profession somewhere in the chain, otherwise people browsing insurance websites for in network providers just aren't qualified to decide if they need to see an orthopedist or a podiatrist or a physical trainer for example.
- fancythat 4y agoI observed that happening around me for a long time, this research only confirms it, however, I think that the problem is stated in a wrong way. IMO the issue here is not that checkups are bad on their own, but rather that used medical checks and resulting therapies are done in some sort of "standard" way, rarely taking into account patient's history or having more detailed look on what causes the particular problem. This is, of course, done in order to scale checkups on economic scale, otherwise, almost no person could afford it. This can be observed in some cases when some young, fit solider dies on basic exercise from heart failure caused by heart anomaly that is not being screened during standard medical examination prior to being enlisted.
- mhaberl 4y agoThis is just clickbait and people comment the title without reading the article. It doesn't say "don't do checkups" > “The conclusions do not imply that physicians should stop clinically motivated testing and preventive activities,” The article is saying that some tests give false positives, some tests even if positive don't point to illness without symptoms, but people get treated for illness. I believe you should do checkups, but ask for second opinion before treatment in case that you feel ok and your family history doesn't point to risk factors. And that is also mentioned: > However, Krogsbøll warned about the importance of distinguishing between people who do not feel sick and those with symptoms or a personal or family history of risk factors
- nradov 4y agoThat depends what you mean by "checkups". For healthy adults there is no proven net benefit to an annual physical exam. https://www.nejm.org/doi/full/10.1056/NEJMp1507485?af=R&rss=currentIssue https://www.nejm.org/doi/full/10.1056/NEJMp1507485?af=R&rss=... However, there are certain preventative care and screening services that everyone should get periodically. https://www.healthcare.gov/coverage/preventive-care-benefits/ https://www.healthcare.gov/coverage/preventive-care-benefits...
- taylodl 4y ago> That depends what you mean by "checkups" Exactly. There's no set definition for "annual physical exam." This article notes you shouldn't be regularly checking for uncommon health events, but instead check for common events, especially if the patient's family history warrants. That's why blood pressure, weight, A1C, triglycerides, and cholesterol are good things to regularly check for in Americans as the typical American diet tends to cause problems in these areas.
- nradov 4y agoThe usual blood tests for triglycerides and cholesterol are mostly useless. They continue to be performed out of inertia rather than any clinical efficacy. https://peterattiamd.com/ama34/ https://peterattiamd.com/ama34/
- onewheeltom 4y agoYou need to remember that health care in the US is a business whose secondary function is to cure disease
- stu2b50 4y agoYou also have to remember that this study was done by Danish researchers and involved a meta-analysis on not just US healthcare, but also European healthcare systems.
- prirun 4y agoPersonal example: my primary care physician scheduled me for a physical, including picking the date, without even asking. It just showed up on my online chart. Okay, I hadn't had a physical for a while, so I just went with it. While stopped at an intersection on the way to his office, a woman plowed into me and 2 other cars because she wasn't paying attention, and was likely on her phone. That wreck generated $45K of medical bills for me and a 21-month settlement process. Onward and upward: I did eventually do a physical, after getting over the wreck. My blood work came back with crazy liver enzyme numbers, 4-9x higher than they should have been. My Dr thought I might have hepatitis and ordered a full hep screen. Before doing that, I did some research, and ran across a NIH paper saying "Hey, before you enroll anyone into drug trials, make sure they aren't working out regularly, because that causes hugely elevated liver enzymes and throws off the trial." Hmm... I mentioned this to my Dr and he said no, that's not it, but maybe get off your protein shakes 2 weeks before the blood test. I read about that, and protein shakes don't affect the liver enzymes. So I decided to stop workouts for 2 weeks AND stop protein shakes. Took the blood test and my liver values were completely normal, and negative for hepatitis. While they may have good intentions, doctors don't always know or understand what they're looking at. I think I could have easily ended up with a liver biopsy had I not stopped my workouts before the 2nd blood test.
- ChancyChance 4y agoDid you go back to working out and protein shakes? Because if you did, you still don't know why you are reacting that way which could be masking a problem elsewhere, and are exposing yourself to risk. There is a reason why metabolic values have "normal" ranges. Heck, if this were a JIRA ticket, I'd want a code review!
- acchow 4y ago> There is a reason why metabolic values have "normal" ranges. The "reason" is that they assumed a normal distribution and wanted to include 95% of people. If you're outside the normal range, you are abnormal. Which doesn't necessarily mean unhealthy or that something needs to be changed, but could potentially mean that questions should be asked to understand why you are outside the range? Maybe it's totally fine, like you are an athlete or have a particular kind of diet.
- drtgh 4y ago[flagged]
- amrocha 4y agoSalt changes how things cook. It's not a matter of just adding the right amount at the end.
- qgin 4y agoIt’s a little concerning that it’s better to have less information. Very few fields work this way.
- thenerdhead 4y agoIgnorance is bliss?
- Havoc 4y agoSeems like one hell of a generalization. There are certainly things where catching it early is a massive help
- 1970-01-01 4y agoAndy Grove would completely disagree: https://money.cnn.com/magazines/fortune/fortune_archive/1996/05/13/212394/index.htm https://money.cnn.com/magazines/fortune/fortune_archive/1996... MY FIRST PSA. It all started about a year earlier when my family doctor of 20 years retired. In the fall of 1994, my new doctor gave me a physical exam to establish a new baseline. The physical involved an assortment of blood tests, all of which were in the normal range, with one exception. The test called PSA came back with a result of 5. The acceptable range, according to the lab computer, was 0 to 4. I didn't know what this test was. In fact, I don't think I'd ever had one before. My doctor's comment was, "It's slightly elevated. It's probably nothing to worry about, but I think you should see a urologist."
- giantg2 4y agoIf anything, the article you referenced is a perfect example of someone doing their own research and diagnostics. Most people do not get this level of care, nor have the intellect to work the diagnostics the way he did. The risk/value proposition is likely much different for people just deferring to doctors, especially for those doctors that are on the lower end of the performance spectrum.
- renewiltord 4y agoYeah, this is the classic "regulations are written in blood" logic. If the cost is invisible and the benefit is visible we do not price as we would if it were made apparent. Presumably our internal model clamps some kinds of things to zero and other things to infinity. When thinking about it, I would prefer to take a test and detect cancer even if the test gives me a near equal risk of cancer. It's strange to my rational self, so I must struggle to reconcile it.
- helloworld 4y agoPSA testing may catch prostate cancer early, but it may also lead to unnecessary -- and sometimes harmful -- treatment. I found this analysis helpful for assessing the pros and cons: https://www.hardingcenter.de/en/transfer-and-impact/fact-boxes/early-detection-of-cancer/early-detection-of-prostate-cancer-with-psa-testing https://www.hardingcenter.de/en/transfer-and-impact/fact-box...
- hammock 4y ago>even basic blood tests can lead to unnecessary interventions or treatments Medical malpractice is the third leading cause of death in the US after heart disease and cancer.
- sli 4y agoThe obvious result of an aggressively for-profit healthcare system: aggressively squeezing profit out of everything it can and let then let the doctors take all the heat for it.
- hammock 4y ago>aggressively for-profit healthcare system Not just for-profit, but aggressively separating the payor and costs (government, insurance) from the treatment and patient, thereby reducing accountability in the system
- ChancyChance 4y agoSince this thread is chock full of anecdotes, here's mine that is the exact opposite. I was completely healthy into my late 20's. I started a new job at 30. I got health insurance and figured for my 30th I'd get a checkup ... my first exam since I was 18 under my parent's plan. My blood pressure was high, so they did some tests which uncovered portal hypertension, and found I may eventually need a liver transplant. Zero history of it in the family. Good thing I had a checkup because I thought I was the model of health. Again, since these are all anecdotes, I'm sharing. Yes be alert and ask questions but don't just blow it off. Maybe not yearly, but at least twice a decade maybe?
- Fire-Dragon-DoL 4y agoHow to discover cancer early without screening though? I understand that's a rare occurrence, but you still wished for that early screening if you are the one with it
- _skel 4y agoEveryone I know who had cancer (and that is a large and increasingly growing list...) found out about it because they went in to the doctor for a non-routine appointment because they felt pain, or felt a lump, or had a weird reaction to a vaccine, or whatever else. Even early stage cancer can produce symptoms, and luckily most of those people survived.
- Fire-Dragon-DoL 4y agoInteresting, I thought some of them were asymptomatic
- twblalock 4y agoSome may be, but all I know is that some definitely aren't.
- darth_avocado 4y agoThis seems to be a misdirect. > After analyzing 17 clinical trials involving 230,000 people and comparing adults from the general public who got checked to others who did not, they found that general checkups had “little or no effect” on total mortality or cancer, cardiovascular, heart disease and stroke mortality. So general checkups have a little or no effect on total mortality, but the studies themselves don't say anything about additional risks, they are more of an "opinion". And to add to it, “little or no effect” on total mortality or cancer, cardiovascular, heart disease and stroke mortality could mean a lot of things. Does it mean people die anyway, but get to live longer? Did the studies take into account effects of regular testing from a young age? The listed diseases are also closely related to hereditary problems, but is the finding the same for other health issues that may not have a genetic component to them?
- thereisnospork 4y agoMedicine is still clearly medieval in this respect, and would be considered insane in any other field: "Gosh I hope my SQL database still has enough storage, but I better not check because adding a disk to the RAID array might cause a failure on rebuild." It's not a factually incorrect statement, but the problem isn't with the checking.
- hayst4ck 4y agoHalf the posts in this thread bring back the old SlashDot adage: The plural of anecdote is not data. I am not sure what the point this article is trying to make is. I do not feel more informed for having read it. It seems a populist appeal to the idea that the medical institution has no idea what it is doing. Is it good, is it bad? It doesn't matter. The end result is damaged institutional trust. How many people would read this article and go "yeah doctors have no idea what they are doing," then go to their alternative medicine to spend $100 on a dubious "medicine"? How many people here are actually equipped to have a meaningful understanding of the information presented? Why did the author not present the institutional position or data supporting yearly checkups and why it's misleading? As long as billionaires are able to influence people to fight about anything other than wealth disparity, they win. We are not experts, we should leave decision making to people who know what they don't know rather than to people who don't know what they don't know (us).
- mrangle 4y agoThis post is an amalgam of barely formed thoughts followed by..."but fight a class war". It's nonsense from beginning to end. Why is critical data "populist"? Why is undamaged institutional trust your goal? Are institutions inherently trustworthy, or is it that they aren't but should be presented as such? Why are you concerned with the literacy of the audience rather than the content of the article? In your mind, why is is every author's duty to present two arguments (which is not a research mandate, the article being a research summary presented in popular article format). Anointing "experts" is not how science works. Again, the article being equivalent to a research abstract and research being the basis for science. We removed science from the unquestionable "expertise" of the Church many centuries ago. At which point we placed in the hands of research and its critique.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- valdiorn 4y ago> The plural of anecdote is not data. Except it literally is. How do you think rare vaccine side effects have been discovered and recorded? By collecting thousands of "anecdotes" from individuals reporting anomalous symptoms. How do you think illicit drug harm is measured? They can't exactly pump people full of cocaine and ketamine in a lab to study overdose effects - you collect anecdotes (individual cases), catalog them, aggregate and adjust for sample bias. Anecdotes are individual, cherry-picked testimonies. When you collect enough of them you get a statistically significant data point. It may be biased based on how your data was collected but the same can be said for many scientific studies that turned out to be flawed in their data collection. As long as you are aware of what the possible bias is, you have data.
- seru 4y agoPrimary sources for this article appear to primarily be a 2014 cochrane review and 2008 article; the journalism looks to be mostly just asking a family doc a few questions - low quality.
- eloff 4y agoThere seems to be some solid data that mammograms, colonoscopies, and treating prostate cancer (with many caveats on that last one) is actually mostly not beneficial in reducing overall mortality. The reasons are likely complex and nuanced, but do your research carefully if your doctor is trying to talk you into one of those. You probably will only benefit their next car payment, not your health. For a mammogram, it doesn’t increase survival over a manual exam. For colonoscopies, you have one in 1400 chances of saving a life and one in 1000 chances of perforating a bowel and dying here and now instead of in 30 years. There’s another exam with lower risks and most of the benefits. For prostate cancer, if you have the aggressive kind, intervention has almost no effect. You’re dead either way. If you have the slow growing kind, you’ll likely die of something else. The risks of treatment are mostly balanced against the benefit. But treatment will nuke your quality of life. I don’t have time too dig up sources right now, so don’t take my word for it. Look for the studies, they’re quite approachable.
- nradov 4y agoYour estimate of colonoscopy risk versus reward is completely wrong. https://peterattiamd.com/peter-on-the-importance-of-regular-colonoscopies/ https://peterattiamd.com/peter-on-the-importance-of-regular-...
- eloff 4y agoHe doesn’t give any numbers there. I may well be completely out to lunch, but that source doesn’t modify my opinion. Here's the results of the first large randomized clinical trial - the gold standard in medicine. The study involved over 80,000 participants in Nordic countries. "colonoscopy reduced cancer incidence but not death" https://www.statnews.com/2022/10/09/in-gold-standard-trial-colonoscopy-fails-to-reduce-rate-of-cancer-deaths/ https://www.statnews.com/2022/10/09/in-gold-standard-trial-c...
- jawon 4y agoDoesn't reasoning like this fall under the ecological fallacy? You can't use statistics to predict the outcome for the individual. If I get a colonoscopy tomorrow there is not a 1/1000 chance I'll die of a perforated bowel. Except perhaps by pure coincidence. My odds will be different. Maybe 1/10. Maybe 1/10,000. A government can use statistics like these to direct spending, but as an individual you need to take your own personal history into account, and your trust in your medical professionals, and roll the dice.
- makeitdouble 4y agoThis article is really aimed at the more dubious tests (e.g. cholesterol) than doing yearly checkups per se. I'd agree with the idea that some tests aren't as good as others, and we lump critical checkups (let's say cardiography) with more shakier ones, like waist circumference or cholesterol. Finding issue with the later falls a lot more into pop science than actual hard evidence based physical intervention. Removing the pop science from the periodical checkups would definitely be a good idea, stopping yearly checkups altogether is throwing the baby with the bath water.
- p_j_w 4y ago>Finding issue with the later [cholesterol checks] falls a lot more into pop science than actual hard evidence based physical intervention. This statement is in opposition to the consensus of medical professionals. What reason is there for believing it?
- makeitdouble 4y agocholesterol values are read as corrolated to deseases we want to prevent, but not as a issue themselves. https://www.cdc.gov/cholesterol/index.htm https://www.cdc.gov/cholesterol/index.htm > Too much cholesterol puts you at risk for heart disease and stroke, two leading causes of death in the United States. For instance if you have high cholesterol but clinically no artery or cardiac issues, lowering your cholesterol will essentially do nothing for you. Some doctors will follow the manuals and still have you lower your levels "just in case" (they'll want to lower a potential risk), but we're the entering the fuzzy part that has no consensus. PS: what values are high is also actively debated, and ethnicity and other factors will affect what is "normal". That's another aspect where it's a lot more touchy/feely than a "your arteries are clogged" diagnostic.
- ugh123 4y agoAs usual, the medical industrial complex (which includes insurance companies) is asleep at the wheel of innovation, and blaming patients for their inadequacies in disease detection.
- aj7 4y agoCholesterol and blood pressure can reach out of normal levels fairly suddenly. They need to be treated as soon as this evidence appears. All sorts of conditions can be spotted by a capable practitioner. Contrary to the tone of the article, most doctors are not over-treating; they will watch something that’s on the borderline. I fear that this article will give justification to the many people who are “too busy” or just don’t like going to the doctor. Oh and by the way. I know of no better analogy, as you grow older and things start failing, than that the body is like an old car. You’ll see, mark my words.
- balderdash 4y agoIn my humble opinion, this fails the deductive reasoning test, and therefore the analysis is missing key explanatory factors (some of which the authors seem to allude to). Of course checkups carry the risk of false positives. And I have trouble believing that: early detection/intervention isn’t going to lead to better health outcomes, regular screenings won’t lead to early detection, and that adherence to a treatment regime (e.g. high cholesterol = improve diet, increase exercise, maybe take medication) won’t improve outcomes.
- mrtweetyhack 4y ago[dead]
- motohagiography 4y agoNassim Taleb wrote at length about his beliefs about "iatrogenic" harm, which is that caused by the doctor themselves. His ideas about it are mercifully summarized in the FS blog: https://fs.blog/iatrogenics/ https://fs.blog/iatrogenics/ and how it expands as a pattern to be aware of.
- thenerdhead 4y agoSearched immediately for Taleb as he is the most notable example of calling this out. The second being a classic Munger idea of misaligned incentives. Doctors hardly get to practice medicine anymore and is why old variations of common sayings like “Never trust a doctor who only knows medicine, a lawyer who only knows law, or a pharmaceutical company that only knows profits” still circulate. Except the punchline has become reality for a number of professions.
- Barrin92 4y agoHere's a small quiz regarding the false positives mentioned in the article. If 3 in 1000 people in the general population are HIV positive, and a HIV test has a 1% false positive rate, (assuming no false negatives for simplicity) how likely is it, that if you run routine tests on a random group of people, for an individual to be healty despite the test coming out positive? Despite the fact that false positives only occur 1% of the time, the answer is about 70% that they are healthy. This question has actually been put in front of practicing physicians, an overwhelming amount could not answer this question correctly, many were off by a magnitude. Worth keeping that in mind when your doctor uncriticially tries to prescribe you something for a relatively rare disease because a measurement was positive.
- froh 4y ago> _Worth keeping that in mind when your doctor uncriticially tries to prescribe you something for a relatively rare disease because a measurement was positive._ yes and yet this is slightly overgeneralizing what you have to keep in mind specifically is that these two things, prevalence in to he population and false positives (and negatives!) do _exist_ and that you should inform yourself about them and factor that into your decision making a PCR COVID test for example is something you don't argue with. and the quick tests on the other hand came in widely different qualities.
- ripe 4y agoThe physician who acknowledges the imperfections of a diagnostic test will ask, "In view of this test result, how uncertain should I be about this patient?" Fortunately, there is a method for answering this question: the theory of probability. [1] is a primer for applying probability theory to the interpretation of test results and deciding when to do a test rather than treat or do nothing. Physicians often must start treatment when still uncertain about whether the patient has the disease. If treatment is started, there is a risk of causing harm to a person who does not have the disease, as well as the prospect of benefiting the person who does. If treatment is withheld, a person who is diseased will be denied a chance at a rapid, effective cure. The method for solving this problem analytically is called the threshold model of medical decisionmaking (Pauker and Kassirer 1975, 1980; Doubilet 1983). The threshold model is an example of expected-value decisionmaking that is applied to a particular type of decision. The key idea is the treatment threshold probability, which is the probability of disease at which one is indifferent between treating and not treating. The basic principle of the threshold model is the following dictum: Do a test only if the probability of disease could change enough to cross the treatment threshold probability. [1] Sox H, Stern S, Owens D, et al.; Institute of Medicine (US) Council on Health Care Technology. Assessment of Diagnostic Technology in Health Care: Rationale, Methods, Problems, and Directions: Monograph of the Council on Health Care Technology. Washington (DC): National Academies Press (US); 1989. 2, The Use of Diagnostic Tests: A Probabilistic Approach. https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/books/NBK235178/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/books/NBK235178/
- extasia 4y ago"Thus, for statistical reasons, the more patients there are in a population, the more reliable a positive result will be. Conversely, a positive is more likely to be false in the case of rare diseases." This description of Baye's theorem is wrong. It should say that the higher the prevalence of the disease in the population, the more reliable a positive result will be. 3blue1brown has a good yt video on the topic which I recommend:)